Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / The Scam of School Vouchers (with Nick Fish of American Atheists)
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Fusian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews talking here with Nick
- 0:57Fish. He's the president of America Canathia's full disclosure. I serve on the
- 1:02board of directors, so it's not like he's a stranger, Like we know
- 1:04each other. Hey, Nick, how are you doing? Man? Good
- 1:07stuff? Are you? We are sitting here at the Secular Student Alliance National
- 1:11Conference twenty twenty four and we've both given our presentations and kind of have that
- 1:17post speech like, whew, I didn't see him. I can relax out
- 1:22during years, yeah, fortune, I hope nobody walked out now. So
- 1:26I wanted to talk to you about the vouchers. It was the focus of
- 1:30what you were talking about. I'm in Oklahoma and the big brew haha going
- 1:34on there is about this private Catholic charter school that Oklahoma wants to use taxpayer
- 1:42money for total violation of church and state. And I knew it was a
- 1:49problem. I didn't know it was that big a problem. So I guess
- 1:52we'll start with Oklahoma. Maybe you know more about it at this measure than
- 1:56I do, because you got all the lawyers and stuff on it. But
- 1:57what the hell, what's going on? Well, so these are two sort
- 2:00of separate but related problems. There are charter schools which are given a special
- 2:06permission to run, and they're usually outside the standard structure of public schools,
- 2:09but they are in essence sort of public schools. Now, what Oklahoma is
- 2:15innovating on, if we can call it, that is, for the first
- 2:19time, creating a completely religious charter school, a charter school that is run
- 2:23by, that is managed by, and that has the rules of the Catholic
- 2:29Church. That is as clear a violation of the Establishment clause as possible.
- 2:32This is a school that would not have to follow any rules related to curriculum,
- 2:37to discrimination, to providing special heed, to any of these are the
- 2:42requirements that every public school has to do. That's sort of the bottom line
- 2:46of what a lot of charter schools, how they have quote unquote better results,
- 2:51is they don't have to serve everyone. They don't have to protect everyone's
- 2:53rights in the same way, even though they're quasi public. Now with charter
- 2:58schools, they're usually a separate nonprofit organization. But in this case, that
- 3:02nonprofit organization is the Catholic Church. And so you know, even the state
- 3:07attorney general, who is a Republican, has filed a lawsuit challenging this.
- 3:10Taxpayers who filed lawsuits challenging this. Clergy in Oklahoma have filed lawsuits challenging this.
- 3:15I think everybody in the state of Oklahoma basically is suing over this at
- 3:19this point, which they should be. That people should be outraged. I
- 3:23don't think. I don't think evangelical Christians are particularly interested in funding with taxpayer
- 3:28with their tax dollars, Catholic schools, and they shouldn't. They shouldn't be,
- 3:31and no one should be in that position of using taxpayer money to fund
- 3:37the indoctrination of children into a religion that isn't yours. Frankly, no one
- 3:39should be funding the indoctrination of children into any religion with tax payer money,
- 3:45even if it was your own. But that's what they're trying to do here.
- 3:47And this is entirely a result of the state superintendent who is just hell
- 3:52bent on doing anything he can to erode, break down, demolish not just
- 3:58church state separation, but our public school system as a whole. And that's
- 4:01how all these things are related. That all of these measures, whether it
- 4:04is charter schools, Catholic charter school or whether it's vouchers taking tax payer money
- 4:10out of the public school giving it to people to then pay tuition at private
- 4:14religious schools, and that's what vouchers usually are. It's about dismantling public education.
- 4:19And if you follow the through line from this, this is all the
- 4:21way back to the earliest days of the civil rights era, you can trace
- 4:27through line that it's about demolishing public schools because public schools are the greatest tool
- 4:31of social mobility, of equality, of generating opportunity for people to get themselves
- 4:38out of poverty, to mingle and mix and get to know people in their
- 4:42communities who are different from them, bringing together people from different faiths, from
- 4:46different races, from different economic status, and building a democracy, making sure
- 4:50that people are educated. And Christian nationalists have no interest in seeing that.
- 4:57In fact, they want the opposite of that. They want a certain group
- 5:00of people in power, and public schools threaten that. And that's why they've
- 5:03gone from the earliest days of creating segregation academies to finding out that that didn't
- 5:09message test especially well. People were slightly horrified when you just set out loud,
- 5:13oh yeah, we don't want black people to get educated, we don't
- 5:15want our children mixing with black people, and they that's what they said to
- 5:18changing their tone a little bit, to changing the message to say, oh,
- 5:21we just want competition, We just want open markets, a market opportunity
- 5:28for schools. The problem with that messaging, and the problem if you think
- 5:30about it for more than five seconds, is then you're saying that children are
- 5:33the commodity, that there are winners and losers in marketplaces, and what you're
- 5:38saying, if you are creating a market of public schools or primary schools,
- 5:43that some children are going to lose. And I don't think that we should
- 5:46be starting from that position in schooling, that we should be in a position
- 5:48where every student should have the opportunity to succeed. That anybody, regardless of
- 5:53their need, whether it's that they need special attention because they have a learning
- 5:57disability, or because they are doing great and they need to they want an
- 6:00accelerated program. I think we should be funding all of that. We should
- 6:03be making sure that teachers have the resources they need to give everyone the type
- 6:06of education that they need and that would enable them to succeed. And that's
- 6:10what public education is supposed to do. And it's truly one of the greatest
- 6:14innovations in the history of the world, and it happened in America. And
- 6:17so when they talk about American exceptionalism, I wish they would talk about how
- 6:21exceptional our education system is and not some idea that we were ordained by God.
- 6:26God didn't do this. We did this because we looked and said,
- 6:29you know, what we really need here is to educate people. I think
- 6:30it's interesting to watch the people who say we're the greatest country on the face
- 6:35of the planet, and then you're like, okay, great by what metric?
- 6:40And then we're like, okay, crime rate, no, teen pregnancy,
- 6:44no education, no, who's most warlike healthcare system. You know,
- 6:47we're one of those very much an emotional it's kind of an identity, you
- 6:51know, And we see a lot of thinking shut down the one Nation under
- 6:57God crowd. You try to educate them about the founders, about the Constitution.
- 7:00I mean, I see people waiving the Constitution to defend this idea that
- 7:05we need to have the Ten Commandments on Capitol grounds. Have you read the
- 7:10Constitution? I mean that's the question, right, have you read? Have
- 7:14you read the Ten Commandments? The answer is no. It's been interesting though
- 7:17to watch Oklahoma A. G. Drummond and Superintendent of Public Instruction Ryan Walters
- 7:23go head ahead on Twitter like they're just going after each other with the lawsuits
- 7:28and everything else, and the course with Walters, it's a holy war everybody's
- 7:31then he's going after the woke have come to take they want to strip away
- 7:35from your children. And I think it's been interesting to watch how they've weaponized
- 7:40this holy war narrative against people like us who just say it's not fair,
- 7:46it's weird. Well, I think you know, it's ironic because they're so
- 7:49hell bent on claiming a level of persecution and what you just said there is
- 7:56really interesting that he's spinning this narrative that the woke or the theists, the
- 8:00godless atheists, the godless commis or whatever are trying to take something away from
- 8:05children, and it's exactly the reverse, right. It's every accusation here is
- 8:11a confession on the part of your state superintendent, because the only person trying
- 8:16to take anything away from any kid is him. He's trying to take away
- 8:20millions of dollars from education funding to funnel it into the Catholic church. Period.
- 8:24That's what's happening. He's trying to take away millions of dollars, giving
- 8:28it to families that can already afford to pay tuition at private schools to give
- 8:35them a tax break. And then guess who's picking up the bill when those
- 8:37programs spiral out of control because there's no top level that they max out at
- 8:43for the amount of money that goes to vouchers, it's every day working class
- 8:46tax payers whose property taxes go up because we're funneling this money now into private
- 8:50schools that, again, people were already paying. It's not new people going
- 8:54into those private schools with these vouchers, it's people that were already there and
- 8:58paying the tuition. Rich families that were able to pay that tuition. That's
- 9:03who's taking anything away from kids. It's him. It's him and his ilk.
- 9:05Now let me jump in here. As I understand it, the vouchers
- 9:09go and are supposedly going to benefit people who want school choice hashtag choice to
- 9:16send their kids, but it doesn't remotely cover the full cost of a tuition.
- 9:20What it does is then they continue to send their kids to public school.
- 9:26So the voucher made essentially no difference to those who are of moderate or
- 9:30modest or no income, right, But the middle to upper class they essentially
- 9:35get a break, they get a discount on the private school their kids were
- 9:41attending. Anyway, am I reading that right? That's exactly correct. So
- 9:43if you're a lot of these vouchers, so I believe it's in Arizona,
- 9:48the vouchers were captain about seven thousand dollars, and you know, please fat
- 9:50check my number. I think that's about right. But the tuition was you
- 9:54know, twice that three times that per year. So it doesn't give a
- 9:58genuine choice of someone who all ready who doesn't have the income to send their
- 10:01kid to a fourteen thousand dollars school either, so they just stay in public
- 10:05school. So it's the people that already could afford to spend twenty grand on
- 10:07tuition. They're just getting a tax break. Basically, they're getting money back
- 10:11in their pocket. And who's paying for it. It's working class people paying
- 10:15their property taxes. And by the way, it's the school system paying the
- 10:18choice because that money gets taken out of their budget. So now those school
- 10:22districts which are already starved for resources, you're taking money away from them,
- 10:28but not reducing the number of students they have to serve. They still have
- 10:31to serve the same number of students. It's just that the person that wasn't
- 10:33even attending their school in the first place. It's a math trick to take
- 10:37away the money that would have gone to them, but they're not attending your
- 10:39school. So now you have schools that are starved for resources. They don't
- 10:43have up to date textbooks, they don't have enough equipment in their labs,
- 10:46they don't have instruments for their kids that want to play in music class,
- 10:50they don't have enough teachers, all of these things, and you're taking millions
- 10:52of dollars out of their budget and funneling it into private often usually typically religious
- 10:58schools. So I'm in Oklahoma, or actually how many states? I think
- 11:03it was? Almost all states? Is that right? So? Forty nine
- 11:07states have some type of school privatization scheme. The only state that doesn't is
- 11:11North Dakota. Which one's the worst? Do you think? Right now?
- 11:15I think the least accountable one is the law that was passed in Arizona.
- 11:18By most metrics, the Arizona program is outrageous. And the ironic thing is
- 11:24that voters have literally never, literally never approved at a statewide level a voucher
- 11:30scheme. Every time it has been on the ballot, every time it's been
- 11:31up for a vote, it has lost. Vouchers have lost the American people.
- 11:37Voters in every state support public schools and they want their schools to take
- 11:39care of kids. They want kids to be able to go to school.
- 11:43They don't want to have to pay tuition. They think that, hey,
- 11:46I'm paying my taxes. I want to make sure my kid can get a
- 11:48good education. Period. It's that simple. This is not something where atheists
- 11:52and agnostics and humanists and teachers are out of step with Americans. In fact,
- 11:56we are in lackstep with the overwhelming majority of Americans is extremists on the
- 12:01Christian nationalist side of things like your state superintendent, who are dramatically out of
- 12:05step with everyday Americans. And so we need to reinforce that we need to
- 12:09proudly be on the side of protecting public education. And the last thing I'll
- 12:13mention on that is when we surveyed thirty four thousand atheists, humanists, and
- 12:18non religious people a few years ago at American Atheists, we asked people what
- 12:22issues, Which of these issues do you think the atheists and secular movement should
- 12:26be engaging on. Do you want to know with the number one issue of
- 12:28all respondents that they said we should be engaging on more than ninety percent protecting
- 12:35public schools number one issue. If you want to know where keeping crosses off
- 12:39of public land, and you know, I think it's a problem, but
- 12:41you want to know if what number, what percentage of people thought that should
- 12:45be our top priority? Almost no one. And so if we're talking about
- 12:50our prioritization focusing on issues like this where the overwhelming majority of Americans agree with
- 12:56us, where it cuts across partisan lines, where every time we can put
- 13:01it to voters, public schools win, and adding and including church state separation
- 13:07to the broader sort of tapestry of civil rights work, civil liberties work,
- 13:11showing that we're serious about protecting that this is a great issue for us to
- 13:15do that, for us to be good partners, for us to get engaged,
- 13:18and for us to give our community an opportunity to get involved and to
- 13:22build power. This is the time to do it. This is an issue
- 13:24where we are winning, and we can win, and we have to continue
- 13:28winning because the other side is so well organized and has billions and billions and
- 13:31billions of dollars behind them. The Betsy Devaces of the world, the David
- 13:37Kochs of the world, the Christopher Rufos of the world, all of these
- 13:39people, they have a well oiled machine pushing back. But it's entirely fraudulent.
- 13:46It's astroturfed. It's not real. All they have is money. More
- 13:52of my conversation with Nick Fish. Next, I want to talk about that
- 13:54word astroturfing. What is it, what's it mean? What are the implications
- 14:00we'll find out next? Bonus broadcast this week on a critical issue. As
- 14:09we're talking about the school voucher program. My guest, Nick Fish, president
- 14:15of American Atheist, has been talking about a tactic called astro turfing. Now
- 14:22explain that term you did yesterday, but for my audience, what is astroturfing?
- 14:26Yeah, so everybody knows what the grassroots are, right, the grassroots
- 14:31support popular support coming from the bottom up. If you were a football fan
- 14:35at all, you know that what they found is that having real grass kind
- 14:39of got tore up, so they replaced it with really bad looking green carpet.
- 14:43That was AstroTurf. It was fake, fake grass. It was expensive,
- 14:46it didn't work really well, but it didn't get torn up, and
- 14:48it was a lot easier to maintain than grass. And that metaphor works really
- 14:54well because true, genuine grassroots work is tough because you're talking with and working
- 14:58with people that have day jobs, that have families that you know, it's
- 15:03this is the third or fourth or fifth thing that they're working on each day.
- 15:05So it takes a long time and it's really hard to do genuine,
- 15:09strong grassroots organizing, but it has the advantage of being real. Astroturfing is
- 15:15the idea of the practice of investing a ton of money into a few extremists
- 15:20or a few, you know, just a few people to give the appearance
- 15:24of popular support, to give the appearance of grassroots support. And that's what
- 15:28the David Cokes and the Betsy Devases do with this type of work, and
- 15:33the Moms for Liberty. You know, we look at book bands and we
- 15:37saw this coverage about how there was a backlash of popular backlash against all these
- 15:39books and what was true. What actually was the case is that I think
- 15:43it was five or six people who were responsible for fifty percent of all book
- 15:46bands nationwide because they were just a bunch of busybodies who had nothing better to
- 15:52do with their time than sit back and take a bunch of money from the
- 15:54Cokes and from Betsy Devas and her ilk to call and whine about the fact
- 15:58that there was a book they didn't like in a public school somewhere. They
- 16:00don't genuinely enjoy any level of true support. These are extremists who just have
- 16:06a bunch of money which allows them to spin up very quickly, and it
- 16:08takes a little bit longer for grass to grow, and so we have to
- 16:12be cognizant of that. We have to always be organizing, We have to
- 16:15always be preparing to build genuine grassroots support. Otherwise this astroturfing campaign can quickly
- 16:22dominate the conversation and then we have to undo a bunch of damage. And
- 16:25that's exactly what we've seen with this Moms for Liberty, you know, school
- 16:29privatization work is they get out over their skis, they expand too fast,
- 16:33They grab a bunch of stuff and really show their extremist colors, and then
- 16:37the real Americans, real people look at that and go, hey, wait
- 16:41a second, this is terrible and I don't like this. But that takes
- 16:42a little bit of time, and in the meantime, kids pay the price.
- 16:47And that's just what we're dealing with right now. As I'm talking to
- 16:48Nick, we're sitting here in a conference room next to the main room,
- 16:52so people are apparently applauding through the walls at the words that you were saying.
- 16:56Just a couple more minutes, if you got a Nick Fish, president
- 16:59of a American atheist. I saw my own governor, Kevin Stitt midterm election,
- 17:04gets elected. First thing he does is take the podium and dedicate every
- 17:07square inch of the state of Oklahoma to Jesus. And I thought to myself,
- 17:14what about all the Native America. I mean, we have tons of
- 17:15Native American land, right, What about all the Native Americans who don't hold
- 17:21to a Christian faith tradition? What about Oklahoma tax paying Muslims and Hindus and
- 17:25seeks. What message did he just send to them? Essentially, you're either
- 17:32renting or you're trespassing on Jesus's land. And I'm struck by him, by
- 17:38Walters, by all of these other people. And I look at and you
- 17:42tell me this may just be a subjective personal opinion. Is one of the
- 17:45problems with our resistance that we're crap at organizing because the Kochs and you know,
- 17:52all of the is it the Family count, what's it? Family Research
- 17:57Council of the Land FRC and all these major lobbyist groups and political action committees
- 18:03and religious Excuse me, they're a church. That's why they're not subjected to
- 18:07any audits or any filing of paperwork. They're a church, now, how
- 18:08they are? They have been at this for fifty freaking years, and we're
- 18:15I feel like it's hard to get us focused. Is that a Have you
- 18:18perceived a challenge with all of us independent minders? Yeah? I mean So
- 18:23this is one of the things that we that everybody in any movement deals with.
- 18:26And it goes back to what I was just talking about about genuine grassroots
- 18:30support. So if you have money, and these guys do, they have
- 18:34billions of dollars that are aimed at deregulating, destroying, demolishing, and discrediting
- 18:41the social safety net because they don't want to pay taxes. And that's a
- 18:44lot of what it goes back to. And so they've weaponized racism and they've
- 18:48weaponized Christian nationalism to get to that end. That's the sort of David Coke
- 18:52idea, because like David Coke is an atheist, he's not religious. Explained
- 18:56to a few I've got. The Koch Brothers are these menu facturing magnates that
- 19:00have funded basically every billionaires quasi libertarian right wing cause for decades in the United
- 19:07States. Yeah, they're billionaires. One of them has died, but they're
- 19:11very old. And one of them died and the other one is still around
- 19:12and funding all this stuff. And so you know, you can parachute someone
- 19:17in, you can hire somebody to go into some state and spend all of
- 19:21their time organizing people, and it pays dividends we're dealing with, and you
- 19:25know, to give a good example here, folks have maybe heard of Project
- 19:27twenty twenty five, which is this basically a manual, thousand page manual from
- 19:33a bunch of right wing think tanks about how to implement a Christian theocracy in
- 19:37America, how to convert the federal government into a an agency basically just staffed
- 19:44top to bottom with sick offense and extremists aligned with a future Trump administration.
- 19:48But the policy goals in there include making it harder to get a divorce,
- 19:52making it illegal to access contraception, making it illegal to use IVF in vitual
- 19:57fertilization, just criminalization of LGBTQ people, pushing LGBTQ people out of public schools,
- 20:03out of any job. Really, it's a manual for extremism. The
- 20:07budget just to produce that report from the Heritage Foundation was twenty five million dollars.
- 20:11Do you want to know what the combined budget of the Freedom from Religion
- 20:15Foundation, American Atheist, the American Humanist Association, Secular Coalition for America,
- 20:19Americans United, and the Center for Inquiry is less than twenty five million dollars,
- 20:26all of those organizations together have less of a budget than the Heritage Foundation
- 20:30put into it this one report, and so that gives you an idea of
- 20:34the scope of the problem. Heritage Foundation is one hundred to two hundred million
- 20:38dollar a year organization. Alliance Defending Freedom, which is the most absurdly named
- 20:42group out there, a Christian nationalist law firm that generates lawsuits out of nothing
- 20:48to sue and the courts go along with it. Often. They have a
- 20:52budget in almost of one hundred million dollars, you know, and this is
- 20:55just two groups that we're talking about, and they're ten times bigger than we
- 20:57are, than all of us combined. But what they don't have on their
- 21:02side is popular support. They know that they have to lie, steal,
- 21:04and cheat to get their goals accomplished. They know that they have to make
- 21:08it impossible for people to vote. They know that they have to purge people
- 21:11from the voter roles. They know that they have to solidify anti democratic mechanisms
- 21:18in order for their side to win, because anytime their actual policy agenda gets
- 21:22up for a vote, it loses because people look at it and go,
- 21:26wow, this is extreme. And I even I a Christian couldn't support this,
- 21:30and so we need to expose. We need to highlight exactly how extreme
- 21:33these people are. But again remind ourselves that we always need to be organizing,
- 21:37We need to always build capacity. We can't just do this every other
- 21:41year. We can't just do this every four years when there's a presidential election
- 21:44coming up. We need to create genuine sources of community for people so they
- 21:48know where to go when something pisses them off and they want to get involved.
- 21:52Where do I turn? Oh, I know exactly where I can go.
- 21:55But we also need to normalize our communities participation in politics. Think we
- 22:00have this idea as atheists often that if we just make the best argument in
- 22:04court, we're going to win. They won't have any choice. I think
- 22:07people often think of the legal system as Harry Potter that if you just say
- 22:11the magic words a spell, you know a patronis is going to run out
- 22:15of your mouth and smack sam Alito in the face and he'll say, I
- 22:18have no choice. Now, that's not how that works. That's too bad,
- 22:21because I pay to see it. I pay to see it. It's
- 22:23an upside down flag that hits him in the face. But that's not how
- 22:27it works, and so we have to be involved in politics. We have
- 22:30to be involved in electoral work, and people think of that as some dirty
- 22:34word. It's not. We have reality on our side, but we also
- 22:38have the majority, overwhelming majority of our fellow Americans on our side on so
- 22:42many issues. But we have to be willing to engage and we have to
- 22:47be willing to get out there stand shoulder to shoulder with people we agree with
- 22:51on the issues, which means that it might be people we disagree with on
- 22:53other things. It might be people that we strongly disagree with on the religion
- 22:57question, on the question of whether or not public schools are good actually,
- 23:03or whether or not they want a theocracy, We're going to agree with them.
- 23:07We find common ground with them. You know, some of the most
- 23:08effective messengers on these issues are groups like Christians against Christian Nationalism, the Baptist
- 23:14Joint Committee, who's here this weekend. You know, our faith allies who
- 23:17agree with us, who care about church state separation because they've seen what happens
- 23:21when government picks sides, when picks winners and losers in religion. They're the
- 23:25people who can really help us in this fight because it represents the majority of
- 23:29Americans. It represents the majority of people that we need to win those fights.
- 23:33And so we have to be organizing constantly. We have to be joining
- 23:36things. And I know that's often a scary thing for people who you know,
- 23:40and I don't want to be little that. It's a scary thing for
- 23:41people who are leaving a religion where that was supposed to have their back,
- 23:45where they had a sense of community, and then they got pushed out because
- 23:49their value their beliefs change, but their values didn't. You know, the
- 23:52word that they use to describe themselves went from progressive Christian to atheists, or
- 23:56went from conservative Christian to oh, actually I'm an atheists, right, And
- 24:00they laughed, and then suddenly they found themselves with no support system and they're
- 24:04they're worried about being vulnerable again to that, And I get it. It's
- 24:08hard, but it's what we need if we want to create a better world,
- 24:12we have to be willing to put ourselves out there. We have to
- 24:15be willing to be vulnerable a little bit and go out there and be a
- 24:18part of a community again. All right, And before we lose the room,
- 24:22at the end of your presentation, you gave some resources. No one
- 24:26was linked to American Atheists, But I mean, where in the world would
- 24:27you send people if they're like, I want to help, no idea,
- 24:32Yeah, how to help? What would you send them? First thing I
- 24:33would say is go to Atheist dot org, slash sign up, just get
- 24:37on our email list. We send out at least one email a week about
- 24:40something that's going on in policy that we hope is relevant, we believe is
- 24:44relevant to people. And then we link from there to some other groups.
- 24:47But I think you know some other resources, some other organizations. I would
- 24:49certainly suggest our groups like PEN America or the National Coalition for Public Education if
- 24:55you're concerned about schools, they're you know, right front and center in this
- 24:57fight in Oklahoma and fight against vouchers. Great starting place. And then you
- 25:02know our allies and partners that Americans United are doing great work on this.
- 25:06That's Americans United for Separational Church and STATA. Their website is AU dot org.
- 25:10So atheist dot org, au dot org. You'll find good resources.
- 25:12I'll throw those links in the description box for easy clickage. Got a click?
- 25:17All right? Nick Fish, President American Atheists and a good friend.
- 25:19I appreciate your work. Thanks for thanks for helping to lead the charge out
- 25:23there on the front lines. Honestly, I don't know how you're so good
- 25:26natured about it. I wake up every morning and want to just put my
- 25:29head through sheet rock sometimes. But what are we going to do? Quit
- 25:32right right now? I mean, that's that's it is. You know,
- 25:34I've seen the power of making change. And once you get once you get
- 25:41to that, once you're able to see what happens when you can get something
- 25:45done that improves people's lives, that protects people's rights that really matter to somebody,
- 25:48especially people that no one else is advocating for. Once you do that,
- 25:52it's it's intoxicating and he's like, yeah, we did a good thing
- 25:55today. And that I think drives a lot of it is we can do
- 25:59this. We have the power to do this. We just have to organize.
- 26:00We have to get organized and do it. And yeah, not lose
- 26:04hope may not be the right word, but they do not lose, Yeah,
- 26:07lose that sense of purpose, I think is the best way to put
- 26:10it. Good stuff, Nick Fish, Thanks again. Thanks. Follow The
- 26:12Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos.
- 26:18Products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist
- 26:22pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log
- 26:27onto our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com.