Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets: Episode 185 of The Investor's Podcast
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to TIP. Hey everyone, welcome to this
- 0:03Wednesday's release of the Bitcoin Fundamentals podcast.
- 0:06On today's show we have the insightful Andy Edstrom and
- 0:09Jesse Myers joining us. We explore the recent
- 0:12realization by major political parties that being anti crypto
- 0:16is now an election losing proposition.
- 0:19We'll dive into the implications of this shift, discussing how it
- 0:22impacts the Bitcoin landscape and what it means for the
- 0:25future. We also get into this very
- 0:27interesting AI discussion with the NVIDIA results that just
- 0:31recently came out and how it's at the intersection of Bitcoin
- 0:35mining and AI training. All right, so with all of that
- 0:39said, let's jump right to the interview with Mr. Andy Edstrom
- 0:42and Mr. Jesse Myers. Celebrating 10 years, you are
- 0:50listening to Bitcoin Fundamentals by the Investors
- 0:52Podcast Network now for your host Preston Pish.
- 1:06Hey everyone, welcome to the show.
- 1:07I've got Jesse and Andy here. Thrilled to have you guys to
- 1:11have a fun conversation today. Welcome.
- 1:13It's always great to see you Preston.
- 1:15Really love our conversations, happy to be here.
- 1:17Always. Super excited about it.
- 1:20You know, it's it's funny when there's two guests and I do the
- 1:22intro, you can always see the awkward pause between the guests
- 1:26like do I go 1st and say welcome back, welcome to you as well.
- 1:31Anyway, let's go ahead and start this thing off.
- 1:34Big news. Big news here.
- 1:37Jesse, you had a baby, your wife had a baby yesterday.
- 1:41Congrats. Thank you.
- 1:43What can you tell us? Yeah, it's, it's funny to be on
- 1:47a podcast today. Literally less than 24 hours
- 1:51since. She's going to kill.
- 1:52You first child was born, but, you know, have the opportunity
- 1:57to talk about Bitcoin with with Preston in the end.
- 2:00Yeah, I can. I can spare an hour, that's for
- 2:01sure. Yeah.
- 2:03So first born was born yesterday.
- 2:05It was 41 hours of Labor. So long a long haul big boy. 9
- 2:12lbs two ounces. Wow.
- 2:14Yeah, that is big, yeah. Yeah, and I was, I was, it
- 2:17doesn't mean anything, but I was particularly proud that he had a
- 2:22very large head, 14 and 1/4 inch head, so felt good.
- 2:28Wow. Well, good.
- 2:29For you guys, brain baby, brain baby.
- 2:31That's right. Let's see, brain baby.
- 2:33Well, Congrats to you guys. Very, very exciting.
- 2:38I just want, I just want to say, Preston, when you reached out
- 2:40about doing the episode, I knew that, that the baby was coming,
- 2:44but then Jesse told me, oh, wife's going into labor.
- 2:48But that was two days ago. And I'm like, oh, no problem.
- 2:51The baby will be out. He'll 24 hours to recover.
- 2:54Yeah. And then 40, almost two full
- 2:57days of Labor. So.
- 2:58You know my goodness. Jesse's a trooper.
- 3:00He doesn't. Look, his wife is the trooper.
- 3:03That's right, that's right. I mean I have already cracked
- 3:07jokes about how I did most of the work but I didn't do.
- 3:10Tell you she's in a backhand yet?
- 3:12Oh my. OK, All right, let's go ahead
- 3:14and get down the business here guys.
- 3:17What are your overall thoughts as we look to just how Bitcoin
- 3:21has performed, the general markets have performed since the
- 3:24start of 2024? Anything that you guys find
- 3:27noteworthy or surprising that maybe you weren't expecting or
- 3:31maybe that you were at the start of the year till here we are at
- 3:35the end of May? Yeah, you go first, Jesse, I.
- 3:38Definitely have some thoughts there.
- 3:40I think even though we're not talking about it a ton lately, I
- 3:43think 2024 is for Bitcoin is all about the ETFs still.
- 3:49And the pattern of what has happened with the ETFs is very
- 3:53interesting and very promising in my opinion about going
- 3:58forward because you know, we we had the ETFs roll out the Wall
- 4:03Street expectations about the net inflows for the first year
- 4:06were modest. Way different than what we saw.
- 4:10And they've already been blown out of the water, so there's
- 4:12already a ton more demand than everyone expected.
- 4:17What is it about? 5X more than what some of the,
- 4:21you know, the the mainstream analysts were saying, are we
- 4:255-10 X? What is it would you say?
- 4:27I think it is something like 5X. Around.
- 4:29My head, I feel like it was like a $3 billion mark and we're at
- 4:32like 12 or 15, something like that.
- 4:35That could be totally wrong, but anyway, so, so they roll out in
- 4:39January. The first month is really
- 4:41defined by GBTC outflows. And so net inflows to to the
- 4:49ETFs overall are kind of 0. But then February and March very
- 4:55net positive, the GBTC outflows subsided.
- 4:57People who wanted to get out of GBTC took the opportunity in the
- 5:01first month. But then the flows we saw in
- 5:03the, in the next couple months were all inflows, people piling
- 5:07into BlackRock and and Ark and Fidelity in particular.
- 5:12And the reflexivity is what I found very interesting and I
- 5:17think it's very promising going forward.
- 5:19As the, the price of Bitcoin started to to run up because of
- 5:23all these inflows, we on quite a few days we were seeing $500
- 5:27million of net inflows into the Bitcoin ETFs, which amounted to
- 5:32the prices. We were at like 9000 Bitcoin a
- 5:35day being absorbed. And at that time we were mining
- 5:39900 Bitcoin a day. Since the halving that's dropped
- 5:42to 450. So we were seeing on some of
- 5:44those days 10X inflows into into Bitcoin ETFs versus the amount
- 5:50of supply being created. And as the price started to run,
- 5:53that's when we got those really big days.
- 5:55So you know, price starts to go up.
- 5:57The psychology with Bitcoin has always been that when the price
- 6:00runs, people want to buy it more.
- 6:02And so we saw that with the ETFs and we had you know quite a we,
- 6:07we pulled forward a lot of post market posts having bull market
- 6:12rally because of the supply demand imbalance in February and
- 6:16March in particular. And then with the Genesis Gemini
- 6:20bankruptcy proceedings in March, April, we started to see a lot
- 6:24more GBTC outflows again, which sort of, you know, negated the
- 6:30inflows we were seeing from organic demand in the ETFs.
- 6:34And we kind of went sideways. We've been going sideways for
- 6:36the last couple months. And I think that's in large part
- 6:39spurred by the the Genesis Gemini bankruptcy proceedings
- 6:43causing the GBTC selling that made the supply demand imbalance
- 6:48from ETFs go away. But looking forward, we we're
- 6:52not going to see that kind of GBTC activity again.
- 6:55And so I think we're probably just a a bit of a rally away
- 6:58from kick starting that flywheel and that reflexivity to the
- 7:01upside again, which is very promising for the next 12
- 7:04months. Andy.
- 7:06Well, well said. So I'll throw in the latest ETF
- 7:10news here, which is that surprise of all surprises, it
- 7:16looked like the Ethereum ETF was not going to be approved, it
- 7:21looked like. Anything.
- 7:23Yeah, exactly. Yeah.
- 7:25Excuse me, Never say never. It was probably, you know,
- 7:29unfortunately inevitable, but there but but, but people didn't
- 7:33think it was going to happen soon.
- 7:34And then we had this wild about face in the political landscape.
- 7:41And maybe I won't dig into the weeds on that just yet, other
- 7:46than to say I feel like Gandalf in Lord of the Rings in the Two
- 7:53Towers, and he's standing in front of Theon, King Theon and
- 7:57the evil wizard Saruman, right, has possessed King Theon and
- 8:03like drawing blood from a stone, Gandalf exercises the evil
- 8:09wizard. And I feel like that's what just
- 8:11happened with Elizabeth Warren and the Democratic Party and,
- 8:16and, and crypto policy. But what I'll, but the other
- 8:19thing I'll say about the Etherium ETF looking forward is
- 8:23I'd been thinking about scenario analysis and I'd been thinking
- 8:26about, OK, we had the wave of adoption of the ETFs that Jesse
- 8:31just described. And now we're in this cooling
- 8:33off period and we've been waiting for wealth managers,
- 8:37financial advisors to do their due diligence and start hitting
- 8:41the buy button more frequently in the coming months.
- 8:44And then I was thinking, Oh my, OK, now we got this Ethereum
- 8:48ETF. Is this going to confuse them
- 8:49right now? I got two.
- 8:51Now I can get two things I can press the buy button on for my
- 8:54clients. But as it turns out, and correct
- 8:58me with if I'm wrong, it appears that what got approved don't got
- 9:03yield, don't got staking. And I think that's actually a
- 9:08really good fact, relatively speaking, for Bitcoin price
- 9:12performance this year, for the Bitcoin ETF, because I don't
- 9:15think that a an Ethereum ETF product that does not deliver
- 9:21yield to the client or to the investor is nearly as compelling
- 9:26as one with yield. And yeah, it's just kind of a,
- 9:29it feels like a much worse substitute for Bitcoin.
- 9:35It already would have been a bad substitute, but it's even worse
- 9:37not to. Mention it for anybody that
- 9:39would be investing in that. I think that the next question
- 9:42that the person would have is how many of these tokens exist.
- 9:46Oh, you can't tell me what do you mean that there?
- 9:49You know, we can't figure out what what that is or what it'll
- 9:52ever be. I think that that's going to
- 9:55raise a lot of questions for people.
- 9:58Now you've got the whole narrative of all its smart
- 10:01contracting and you know, most investors aren't going to dig
- 10:04for more than three seconds in their research and they might
- 10:08just buy into that and say, oh, well, it's newer.
- 10:11And so then I'm going to buy that because it's smart
- 10:13contracting and and that'll be the end of it.
- 10:15And so I guess when I'm looking at it, it almost just seems like
- 10:18we're just replaying everything from the previous cycles at a
- 10:23higher fractal with more people and more institutions than we
- 10:27did on the last cycle, and it's just all just replicating itself
- 10:31all over again. Is that a fair?
- 10:33Is that a fair as it ever was? Yes.
- 10:37And, and, and playing that forward, Preston, I think what
- 10:40people are probably not anticipating yet, but will
- 10:44probably happen is that big names like Wall Street names,
- 10:48some of them will blow up as they engage with Bitcoin or
- 10:53Ethereum the wrong way. Like if if you take on leverage,
- 10:58for example, and you know, we'll see what, what happens in the,
- 11:02in the next cycle. But the same hubris, the same
- 11:04lack of understanding of finite scarcity is, is coming into this
- 11:10cycle, same as it was last cycle and the cycle before last time
- 11:14it was FTX. We'll see who blows up this
- 11:17cycle, maybe in the future, you know, maybe this cycle, maybe
- 11:20it's next cycle, but I think, you know, we'll start to see
- 11:23trad 5 giants who engage with Bitcoin the wrong way and take
- 11:26on too big of a risk without realizing it go out of business.
- 11:31Where do they draw the line for applications of ETFs of, you
- 11:36name it, coin? I mean, yeah, like, where do we,
- 11:38where do we go from here? That is what concerns me about
- 11:42Ethereum ETF, because if you're going to green light an Ethereum
- 11:45ETF, there's no reason you can't green light a Solana ETF.
- 11:50And then to your point pressing like where do you draw the line?
- 11:52Is it, is it that you can only do an ETF for the top ten
- 11:57cryptocurrencies? No, that that would be
- 11:59completely arbitrary. So what?
- 12:01I'm going to push back. I'm going to push back a little
- 12:04bit though. I mean not having yield matters
- 12:07a lot. I mean no analogy is perfect,
- 12:10but like imagine this version of Ethereum ETF.
- 12:14Ethereum, the kind that doesn't pay the yield.
- 12:17Imagine it's like buying AUS treasury.
- 12:20It's like buying an ETF that has U.S.
- 12:22Treasury securities, except for the US Treasury securities don't
- 12:26pay the coupon. That's a great point.
- 12:29I mean, because that's that's baked into the debasement, like
- 12:32because they have to continually debase it, that the debasement
- 12:36is paid to the validators. And if you can't participate in
- 12:40that part of it, well then it yeah, I see exactly what you're
- 12:42saying. It's even worse than the Fiat
- 12:44rails because of now you're going to have, because of the
- 12:48the really small market cap, there's going to be a lot of
- 12:50people that get duped into it as just more money enters this
- 12:53quote UN quote space in the short term.
- 12:56But in the long term, that's exactly right.
- 12:58It's worse than a treasury, which is a very interesting
- 13:00point. Now, as you guys just look to
- 13:03the, the speed. Well, how about you, the, the
- 13:05question proposed Andy on like, where do they draw the line?
- 13:08And, and I think the, the second question I got for you is what
- 13:11in the world changed in Washington?
- 13:13And what appears to be the snap of a finger where everybody was
- 13:17like, Oh my God, we need to approve this.
- 13:19I I have a theory, but I want to hear your theory.
- 13:21I have AI have a theory too. So the short answer is a bunch
- 13:25of politicians on both sides of the aisle found a way to remove
- 13:31their craniums from their rectums.
- 13:34And what I mean is, let's call crypto.
- 13:38You know, I have to talk about crypto, not just Bitcoin, but
- 13:43the majority of politicians had either been ignoring it or
- 13:47fighting it for so long. And then it appears that Biden
- 13:54was going to well, there was this proposal to reverse Saab
- 13:59121. Saab 1/21 was this dumb rule
- 14:02that basically kept banks out of Bitcoin and crypto.
- 14:04That's the short version. And then the House decided to
- 14:07pass an action to reverse that. And the president, forgive me if
- 14:13I get the order wrong, by the way, the, the order of events
- 14:16said he was going to veto it. Biden said he was going to veto
- 14:18it, but the Senate passed it anyway.
- 14:21And then also candidate for re election, Donald Trump talked
- 14:27positively about crypto assets. I think it was literally the
- 14:32same day maybe that it passed in the House, either House or
- 14:35Senate. And then you saw poll movements.
- 14:40So it appeared that Trump was gaining significantly on Biden.
- 14:46And it seems to be that the administration realized that
- 14:50anti crypto is bad politics. And so we had the largest sea
- 14:56change in the attitude of politicians to crypto assets and
- 15:01Bitcoin, frankly, that we've seen, I think, in the entire
- 15:05history of the space in the last 15 years.
- 15:08So basically it was politics and it was electioneering.
- 15:12And Trump figured out that this is something you want to be on
- 15:15the right side of, not the wrong side.
- 15:17And then Dems figured out in short order that that was also
- 15:22the way they wanted to go and that they had an opportunity to
- 15:25lose the election based on alienating young people who are
- 15:29into Bitcoin and crypto, and they tried to avoid that
- 15:34outcome. Perfect summary.
- 15:36Yeah. I mean, it comes down to we're a
- 15:39large enough cohort now maybe it's 1% of voters.
- 15:44Like that's their number one issue maybe.
- 15:47And you, you know, in the election that we're coming up
- 15:50to, Democrats can't afford to alienate 1% of their, their
- 15:56young voter base that happened to also be into crypto.
- 15:59That's how you lose an election. And it seems like, seems like
- 16:03some pollsters and political consultants got the the message
- 16:09out to the Democratic Party at the top level.
- 16:11And overnight, everybody changed their tune.
- 16:16I'm curious if you guys have read the prospectus or the these
- 16:19initial filings as to the validators and collecting the
- 16:24what do we call it when they're plugging it into the validators?
- 16:28They're getting the yield off of the yield.
- 16:30The yield are like if I'm BlackRock and I'm doing this on
- 16:34behalf of all these these people that are buying the ETF, can I
- 16:37still plug this into a validator, collect the yield and
- 16:40just not pay it out and be within compliance of the ETF
- 16:43filing? This is an interesting question.
- 16:45I have not read the prospectus. I think it's the legal question
- 16:48is the interesting one though, because the notion which is sort
- 16:52of a novel legal concept, I mean it comes from the from the
- 16:56Hinman speech. I don't know, 2018.
- 16:59I want to say Bill Hinman was then senior at the SECI think
- 17:04head of corporate finance enforcement.
- 17:07And I think he presented this notion that, you know, the
- 17:11whiskey barrel that you make the whiskey in is not that's a
- 17:14security or you can sell it as a security.
- 17:16But once you've made the whiskey, then it's the
- 17:19commodity. OK.
- 17:20So that's sort of the notion with the with Ethereum.
- 17:23And another notion with Ethereum is, is, yeah, if there's someone
- 17:28paying you a yield from your activity, is that there for a
- 17:32security? I don't know the answer though
- 17:34as to whether the validator can withhold that yield and
- 17:41therefore it's like a commodity from the perspective of the ETF
- 17:45holder, the investor, because there's no yield, but the issuer
- 17:49gets to gets to scalp that. I mean, that would that would be
- 17:52a pretty interesting, a pretty interesting outcome.
- 17:55I had to admit, that's not the scenario that I had thought
- 18:00about in advance, but that'd be. I mean, if you're if you're Wall
- 18:02Street, wouldn't you be campaigning for that with the
- 18:05SEC? Is that, Oh yeah, we're not
- 18:07going to pay this out as year old, but you know, we can
- 18:10basically keep it. So this is my opinion on like
- 18:14what the the SWIFT tide change was.
- 18:17First of all, I think the fees that they collected on the
- 18:20Bitcoin ETF were astronomical, like way higher than they ever
- 18:24expected. And they're just looking at this
- 18:25space very generically and saying, hey, let's roll out
- 18:28another one of these things and make a whole bunch more fees.
- 18:31And all we have to do is just go bang a couple of these
- 18:34politicians over the head to get this approved and then we're
- 18:36golden. And I think that's what they
- 18:38did. The other thing that I think
- 18:40it's, it's just become politically popular.
- 18:42I think for our for anybody, it's just politically popular
- 18:45regardless of what party you are to support this.
- 18:48So like, why battle it? Here's another one, the dollar
- 18:52stable coin. I think they're finally starting
- 18:54to figure out that the only buyer of all this treasury
- 18:58issuance is going to be dollar stable coins.
- 19:00And if they know that Ethereum, Tron or whatever is the, the
- 19:05turnkey way in which you can get these private institutions to
- 19:09basically become buyers of all these treasuries, while they
- 19:12need to somehow support this and embrace it because it's the only
- 19:15way out, especially when they're looking.
- 19:18I mean, they can, they can clearly do the math at this
- 19:20point. And they're looking at like what
- 19:22they're going to have to print in the coming 5 to 10 years.
- 19:24And I'm sorry, the only buyer for this, the only buyer for
- 19:28this becomes short duration issuance of a stable coin into
- 19:32the entity that would buy this up all this garbage.
- 19:35So I think they're looking at it from that perspective.
- 19:38I, I'm sure you guys saw the Paul Ryan clip that went out,
- 19:41which I just like had to take a step back and watch it.
- 19:46I was like, Oh my God, they finally like figured out like
- 19:48where this is all going. And so I think that's another
- 19:51piece of why they're maybe embracing this.
- 19:54And then I guess the last one, this would be this would be
- 19:58assume that they have a really deep understanding of everything
- 20:01that's happening. And I'm not so sure that they're
- 20:03there. But if they don't approve any
- 20:06other ETF and where I think this is going in the coming year to
- 20:09two years with the amount of printing that's like on deck, I
- 20:13think they almost need something else, some other, you know,
- 20:16Sailor calls it the ETF like an API to plug into the traditional
- 20:21rails to plug into the the new Bitcoin ecosystem.
- 20:24If they don't have something else there to almost act as a
- 20:28distraction or an additional API to plug into, you're just going
- 20:33to see an ungodly amount of flows go into Bitcoin and it's
- 20:37just going to maybe rip the face off of of the entire traditional
- 20:41Fiat system. So maybe the approval is, and I
- 20:45think that this is more tinfoil hat, but I'm, I'm still throwing
- 20:48it out there as an idea. Maybe the approval of this and
- 20:51anything else is to slow that bleed out of traditional finance
- 20:56directly into right into the veins of Bitcoin.
- 21:00Those are, you know, a couple of my theories as to why they they
- 21:04just had this sudden realization like, Oh my God, we got to get
- 21:06something else approved. Hey, Preston, I agree with you
- 21:09completely on all fronts. And I'll throw one more in
- 21:12there, which is just taking the perspective of the banks.
- 21:16You mentioned stable coins, like, yes, somebody's got to
- 21:19Hoover up all this Treasury debt.
- 21:21Yeah. Who's going to buy that?
- 21:23Right. Well, we they talked about the
- 21:26supplementary leverage ratio, right, and allowing the banks to
- 21:30Hoover up more of the stuff with no capital charge.
- 21:33Which they don't want to do. Which they don't want to do,
- 21:35Andy. Exactly, exactly.
- 21:37So imagine you're a bank CEO and you're looking at your
- 21:40congressman. You're like, guys, you're
- 21:42delivering all this business to Coinbase.
- 21:45You know, SOB 21 prevents me from making my rake.
- 21:50Oh, and you want me to take down all this worthless treasury
- 21:53debt? You're out of your mind.
- 21:55You got to let me play this crypto game again.
- 21:57This is from the perspective of the bank CEO, so I think that's
- 22:01another angle. And and they're also like, when
- 22:04we look back, what was it a month ago, how they all want to
- 22:06become custodians and they're working that into the politics
- 22:09as well. Tells goes perfectly aligned
- 22:12with what you just said, which is we want to play in this
- 22:14space. And Elizabeth Warren, just shut
- 22:17your mouth and like support this or else we're going to start
- 22:20pulling all your funding. And it's so funny to me how like
- 22:23she acts like she's against the big bankers, but she's, they
- 22:26literally have their arm, you know, like she's a Dang puppet
- 22:29man. So she's just going to, you
- 22:31know, it's funny, when we were out in in California, I had made
- 22:35the comment that I think within the year, people like her, we're
- 22:38going to actually flip and become pro crypto or whatever by
- 22:44the end of the, you know, within a year's time frame.
- 22:46And sure enough, what did it take like six months?
- 22:48And here we are. They're all.
- 22:49Flipping, yeah, nailed it. Because it's just incentives,
- 22:53right? Like it's not hard to like see
- 22:56that that's what's coming next when you just understand where
- 22:59the incentives are going. But did you guys see the news?
- 23:02I think it just rolled out today with Kenya and Mara, the mining
- 23:07relationship. Did you guys?
- 23:08No, you guys didn't see that Hulk.
- 23:11Yeah, I've seen. Much news the last few days.
- 23:13Yeah, I guess that's true, Jesse.
- 23:15Evidently, there's a private public partnership with respect
- 23:18to mining that's happening in the country of Kenya.
- 23:21I think that we're going to see a lot more of this.
- 23:23I'm curious if you guys would agree a lot more of this from a
- 23:27miner's perspective, Because like one of the core pillars for
- 23:30them is they have to have some type of stability or
- 23:34understanding as to, hey, if we're going to spend all this
- 23:36money on infrastructure to get this cheap energy that's locked
- 23:40up inside of your country. Like we have to have some type
- 23:42of assurance that you're not going to the, the political
- 23:45winds are going to shift in six months from now and we're going
- 23:47to have to spend a ton of money like moving all these rigs
- 23:51somewhere else. So I find this really
- 23:53interesting. I think this is one of the, I
- 23:55don't know if it's the 1st, but one of the very early public
- 23:58partner relationships that we're finding between minors.
- 24:02And I would suspect that this should pick up.
- 24:04I'm curious, any of your thoughts on that?
- 24:06So I have mixed feelings and thoughts on this.
- 24:09So one perspective I completely agree with you, countries need
- 24:14expertise to help them deploy mining capacity and also they
- 24:20need, as you say, you know, flexibility and for it makes
- 24:23tremendous sense from the corporate perspective, from Mars
- 24:26perspective, they have a whole fleet of ASICS and the more
- 24:31jurisdictions they can operate in and move between it, you
- 24:33know, and, and widen their revenue base is great for them.
- 24:37I wonder a little bit though, from the perspective of this
- 24:40foreign sovereign from the foreign government because
- 24:43really like, yes, they want coins and so the miner can help
- 24:49them acquire coins, but also what they really want is a way
- 24:54to surely and safely transact outside the dollar system.
- 24:59So the strategic element there I think is really important for
- 25:02sovereigns. And I don't know that you get
- 25:05that by hiring AUS domiciled mining company, right, to do
- 25:10your deployment because the long arm of the US government and the
- 25:16whole jurisdictional apparatus, I think still owns you even if
- 25:23those facilities are offshore. So I think it's sort of a mixed
- 25:27bag. It sort of surprises me a little
- 25:29bit that US domiciled miners would have a big role in those
- 25:34foreign domiciled deployments of mining capacity.
- 25:39But we'll see what happens. Yeah, good point, Jesse.
- 25:44Yeah, I think this is just kind of an interesting evolution.
- 25:47I haven't seen the press release on that, so I don't know the
- 25:51details, but it's been very interesting to watch from afar
- 25:56what has been going on with Bitcoin mining in Africa.
- 25:59I'm thinking in particular of Gridless Compute, a very
- 26:02interesting company that's been doing some super exciting work
- 26:06in Africa, going in and putting in micro hydropower
- 26:09installations to small hydropower, generating the
- 26:13electricity, generating installations and then mining
- 26:16Bitcoin because the incentives are there basically like there's
- 26:20untapped hydropower there. You just need a, A use case, You
- 26:24need the economics to be there in order to go and put the, the
- 26:29CapEx into building that insulation to generate the
- 26:32electricity, because you need a buyer for that electricity and
- 26:35you need, you need it to be local because electricity is
- 26:38hard to transport. And Bitcoin solves that problem,
- 26:41becomes the buyer of last resort.
- 26:42That makes the economics make sense to put that hydro, micro
- 26:46hydropower insulation in and boom, you're installing
- 26:51electricity production in remote regions of Africa that have
- 26:54never had energy production because it makes economic sense.
- 26:58The incentives are there. And so it makes sense that, you
- 27:02know, the sovereign level players are recognizing, you
- 27:06know what, I could be incorporating that myself.
- 27:09I could be using this playbook. We have untapped resources.
- 27:12We just need expertise and rolling that out at a nation
- 27:16state level. It's just the the next evolution
- 27:18of you know, as we know with Bitcoin, the incentives are
- 27:22there at every single level of the individual corporate nation
- 27:25state level. And it's all about tapping
- 27:29electricity production and turning that into economics and
- 27:33incentive. So long as the incentives are
- 27:35there, somebody's going to entrepreneurial
- 27:38entrepreneurially do that and that can be a nation state as
- 27:41well. So I think that's this sort of
- 27:44public private partnership is probably a sign of many more to
- 27:48come, in particular in regions and countries where they have
- 27:51untapped energy production resources.
- 27:54For a lot of these countries, I think they need to have some
- 27:57type of policy in place in order to attract foreign investment.
- 28:04Because I think right now, from a venture standpoint or any type
- 28:07of investor that's from the US or Europe or wherever that's
- 28:10looking to take advantage of these opportunities that are all
- 28:13over the world. And you know, this one in Kenya,
- 28:15for example, or any other country for investors, they're
- 28:19very suspect or very worried about the return on their
- 28:24capital and not getting rug pulled by the local government
- 28:27through laws and regulations that don't necessarily protect
- 28:31their interests. So if somebody's listening to
- 28:33this from any one of these countries, that would be the
- 28:35thing that I would really try to press upon them is in order to
- 28:38attract foreign investment into your country, there has to be
- 28:42some type of legal structure that puts those investors at
- 28:45ease. And I think that you can turn on
- 28:47the floodgates on a lot of this infrastructure, especially if
- 28:49you got energy prices below $0.04 per kilowatt and you have
- 28:53excess abundant energy there because maybe the World Bank in
- 28:56the IMF went in there and build a bunch of stuff and then never
- 28:59fully, you know, utilize that energy.
- 29:02I think there's just huge, massive opportunities all over
- 29:06for this kind of stuff. There's going to be a big
- 29:08opportunity here for mining consultants.
- 29:12I'm talking about like traditional metals mining, like
- 29:17oil and gas drilling. US businesses and European
- 29:22companies, some of the biggest companies in the world have been
- 29:25the have been in the business of figuring out how to safely
- 29:30profit on the extraction of resources in foreign countries,
- 29:35developing countries for, you know, as long as there's been
- 29:38history at least since colonial period and, and including, you
- 29:43know, the more more recent century in decades.
- 29:46And so, yeah, it's a tricky, you know, it's a tricky business.
- 29:50There are different ways of doing business and opening doors
- 29:55for big Western foreign companies in African and Asian
- 30:00countries. And yeah, it's a an unusual art.
- 30:04It's partly a dark art, but those who have been doing it
- 30:07successfully to extract normal traditional commodities that are
- 30:13developing countries probably will have a big opportunity to
- 30:17do it here again with Bitcoin mining.
- 30:19Yeah, here's one that's off topic, but I just have to ask
- 30:22you guys. NVIDIA, your thoughts?
- 30:28Holy moly, I mean. It's insane.
- 30:31It's totally insane what they're doing and like the growth is
- 30:35just absurd. I here's the thing.
- 30:37That's that I, that has me so confused.
- 30:40So I saw Stan Druckenmiller had sold his NVIDIA position what, a
- 30:45week ago, a week and a half ago or something like that.
- 30:48And when I saw that, I was like, oh boy, this next earnings is
- 30:51going to be just destructive. Like if I if I if I had a
- 30:56position which I I don't unfortunately, but if I had to.
- 31:00Pay his own admission, Stan Druckenmiller talks about in
- 31:04interviews. He talks about historically he
- 31:07has made most of his money on the bear side.
- 31:10He has made most of his money trading over decades by buying
- 31:15bonds, often buying duration at just the right time when things
- 31:19fall apart. So you know, I'm not going to
- 31:22tell you that he's a bad stock trader and it sounds like he
- 31:26missed this one and he may be kicking himself.
- 31:30But on the other hand, he himself would admit that he's
- 31:33made most of his money. Yeah, trading FX, trading bonds,
- 31:38trading rates, especially with stuff going sideways.
- 31:41Yeah. I will say another thing though
- 31:43that really interests me with respect to NVIDIA is this other
- 31:47dynamic that's now playing out in the mining spaces.
- 31:50Besides sovereigns getting involved now there's so much
- 31:52more competition for Rackspace, right, Yes.
- 31:55So if you have. This is really big.
- 31:58So yeah, lay this out for us, Andy.
- 31:59This is really big. And I think this is somewhat new
- 32:02for people that maybe haven't heard this before.
- 32:04So really lay this out for everybody.
- 32:06Yeah, yeah. So, so historically the Bitcoin
- 32:09mining business was you need a site, you need an energy source,
- 32:14you need the physical ASICS and you need Internet, you know, in
- 32:20interconnect basically. And when I say the site, I mean
- 32:24actually you have to build the structure, you need cooling, you
- 32:27need all the things that keep the machines cool and running
- 32:31all the time. Well, that's also true of
- 32:35regular way data Centers for the most part, although regular way
- 32:39data centers have a higher requirement in terms of being
- 32:44close to where the data that they crunch is going to be used.
- 32:49So that's the amazing thing, of course, about Bitcoin mining.
- 32:51You can put them, put it anywhere on Earth.
- 32:53You got an Internet connection. You can put a Bitcoin mine that
- 32:57doesn't work quite as well. You know, if you're serving up
- 33:00Netflix videos, right? You can't be serving up Netflix
- 33:03videos from, you know, from small Bard or in New Zealand to
- 33:10the United States, right? Rural Kenya, good example.
- 33:12OK. And for people that are are not
- 33:16understanding that it's just because of the speed at which
- 33:18you're basically pulling that file and sending it.
- 33:21So like let's say we found a really great spot from an energy
- 33:24standpoint that's like $0.02 per kilowatt, but it's down in
- 33:28Antarctica or whatever and you want to then start housing and
- 33:32storing data and servicing that data in that same location.
- 33:36It's not very opportunistic for call it Google or you name it
- 33:41data center or some AI farm that's, you know, servicing
- 33:45inquiries and then returning the data packets to that person from
- 33:49call it Chicago or wherever. So that distance poses an issue
- 33:53for data requests and servicing the data.
- 33:56Exactly right. OK.
- 33:58And now to. Spell that out a little bit more
- 34:00that specifically the 10 minute block time that makes that makes
- 34:04it fine because you know you're not.
- 34:06You don't have to meet like 100 millisecond requirement or
- 34:09something like that for latency. You can.
- 34:11You can be 10 minutes and it's OK.
- 34:13Yeah, on the Bitcoin side, yeah. On the Bitcoin side, so now
- 34:17enter machine learning and AI and specifically LLMS and
- 34:21foundation models. So now there's huge incremental
- 34:25demand for good data site capacity.
- 34:29So there's a competition between Bitcoin miners and guys running
- 34:35machine learning models for similar sites.
- 34:39But then it's further complicated by the following to
- 34:41train models to do training. Actually, you kind of can do
- 34:46that remotely. And I'm no expert on the
- 34:50requirements here, but like you could have a data center and I
- 34:54don't know, the desert of Morocco where you're where
- 34:58you're doing, you're training these models.
- 35:00But then when you're doing inference, you're actually
- 35:02serving customers like, you know, your ChatGPT and you're
- 35:07asking it a question for to answer the question.
- 35:09Now you have to reduce that latency like we just talked
- 35:12about. And so as the large language
- 35:16models develop and as more of the overall work is inference
- 35:24and as the as that data center capacity has to move toward the
- 35:28user, you get a shift in the mix of how these data centers are
- 35:32built and constructed and how the equipment is moving through
- 35:36them. So it's all very complicated.
- 35:38I don't pretend to know how it's going to play out, but clearly
- 35:42there's sort of a a competitive dynamic here.
- 35:45But there may be a complementarity aspect as well.
- 35:49You know, if you can build a data site where, oh, you've got
- 35:52some curtail, you got to keep the machine learning algos
- 35:56running all the time, but maybe you have some, you know, swing
- 35:59curtailment capacity on the Bitcoin mining side.
- 36:02So I'm sorry as a long winded answer, but those are some of
- 36:05the issues that I see. So to give just a little bit
- 36:08more context on what Andy was describing.
- 36:10So when you're training the, the data or you're, you're training
- 36:13the AI model, you're pulling all of the data that you're
- 36:16ingesting into it to train it. And that's all fixed data like
- 36:20you're, there's no time requirement where you are.
- 36:24You have to pull this piece of data in within 3 seconds and
- 36:27service it back to the original person that was, that was
- 36:30requesting the, the return on the, on the initial send of the
- 36:34data. And so when we're looking at AI,
- 36:37you could literally store all of the, the files and all of the
- 36:40indexes of, of the information that you're pulling when you're
- 36:43training it. And so you can do that remotely.
- 36:46You could do that from very far distances from where you have
- 36:49major population sources. After you train the model, then
- 36:54it's a single file. And for, for example, I just
- 36:57pulled this up GPT 3. I asked what it was for four,
- 37:01but it wouldn't provide me the information.
- 37:03But just to kind of give people one idea, GPT three had 175
- 37:08billion parameters and the file size, the output file size was
- 37:12350 gigabytes. OK, think about how insane this
- 37:17is that you could ask any question to GPT 3.
- 37:21Now, it's not as good as four, but you could ask GPT 3 any
- 37:25question and get a pretty Dang good response in the file size.
- 37:31Let's say you have a one terabyte laptop, you know,
- 37:34sitting on. It's only taking up a third of
- 37:36the memory on that entire laptop to answer any question.
- 37:41It's insane so like the the it's mind boggling.
- 37:46So how how much bigger is 4? I don't know, but I would be
- 37:49surprised and I'm no AI expert, but I would be really surprised
- 37:53if it was larger than half of a Terra in size for GPT 4.
- 37:58OK, so the sizes that we're talking about here.
- 38:00So you now you can take that file and let's say you stick
- 38:03that file. Obviously they have to keep all
- 38:05this stuff encrypted. They don't want the the file to
- 38:07get out. But let's just say that they
- 38:08stick that in Chicago after they developed it remotely off site,
- 38:12which is what Andy's describing of why there's going to be like
- 38:15this relationship between training models and Bitcoin in
- 38:21remote locations is because you can do it in remote locations
- 38:24without having to worry about servicing the, the data packet
- 38:27responses. But then you can take that file,
- 38:30let's say it's a 500 gigabyte file and you could put it in,
- 38:33you could put it in Chicago, you could put it in LA or whatever,
- 38:36which is close to where the population hubs are.
- 38:38And they're getting pinged and it's just, it's spitting out the
- 38:41answers to all these things. It's totally nuts.
- 38:44The, the relationship, the what's the word?
- 38:47I'm looking for the symbiosis between Bitcoin mining and and
- 38:52AI training is somewhat miraculous and mind blowing if
- 38:57you ask me. Yeah, the data center managers,
- 39:00people in the data center management business, are going
- 39:04to be pretty busy for the next few years.
- 39:07It also reminds me of, I remember when the news came out,
- 39:10it's like a decade ago that Google had first implemented AI
- 39:15systems to optimize energy usage in their own data sites, right?
- 39:20In their own data centers, they cut energy usage by like 30% by
- 39:24implementing their own machine learning algorithms.
- 39:27So it's going to be the algos that are doing the optimization
- 39:31work, right to shift capacity around the world between these
- 39:36different, you know, load bearing facilities.
- 39:40It's going to be wild to see. My understanding.
- 39:43Go ahead, Jesse. Preston, you, you struck me with
- 39:47that comment about the miraculous link between the AI
- 39:51processing and Bitcoin mining. But I think it, I guess it, it
- 39:54makes sense in the, in the context of, you know, we're
- 39:56living through the digitization of everything.
- 39:59And with the Internet today, it has historically been like how
- 40:03we call and retrieve information.
- 40:06But as we progress through digitization of everything that
- 40:10is now including security of money and also processing and
- 40:15thinking, you know, and, and stuff that's not call and
- 40:19response. And so I guess it, it fits in
- 40:22with that sort of mental model of, of the Internet is just the
- 40:26the tip of the spear of digitization of all functions
- 40:29and and some of those later functions are not call and
- 40:33response. And so it goes together.
- 40:35Which gets us just back to the first principle.
- 40:37I mean, it's Andreas Antonopoulos or it's like
- 40:40Internet of money. It's like, yes, Bitcoin is
- 40:42special and and amazing. Oh, but also it's just the
- 40:46inner, you know, the digitization of everything.
- 40:49And it's just kind of joining the rest of the pack.
- 40:51For some reason, people think of Bitcoin as this strange animal.
- 40:57They just can't get their heads around it.
- 40:59And Oh, yeah, no, it's just, you know, it's just the Internet
- 41:03implementation of money. Yeah, it's so weird to me also
- 41:08that when you think about like these now all of this NVIDIA and
- 41:13AI training happening in concert in the same location as call it
- 41:17a Bitcoin miner, You literally have both poles happening.
- 41:22You have deep pattern, the synthesis synthesizing patterns
- 41:27into a 350 gigabyte or 500 gigabyte file that can answer
- 41:32any question, right. And then on the other side of
- 41:36the pole, you have Bitcoin mining, which is absurd amounts
- 41:40of entropy that is just guessing at, you know, a solution and
- 41:45just they're literally opposite sides of the pole and they're
- 41:48happening inside this thing that you that you're flowing
- 41:51tremendous absurd amounts of energy through to perform these
- 41:54two actions. What?
- 41:56What the hell is that? Yeah, it's it.
- 41:59It's that security needs entropy and so that you design that
- 42:03system around not allowing for thoughts or synthesis.
- 42:08But then you know, on the flip side that thought or pattern
- 42:11recognition or you know, processing requires the the lack
- 42:17of entropy. We were going to talk about
- 42:20NVIDIA. I guess we kind of did a very
- 42:22passive we we all just went right back to Bitcoin.
- 42:25But yeah, I know some some crazy, crazy, just.
- 42:29What a time to to be alive is what it comes back to and like
- 42:33the the most incredible time to be alive.
- 42:36I, I think that I feel like everyone, even Bitcoiners, fails
- 42:41to recognize that like the Internet revolution isn't over,
- 42:44you know, like it, it feels like the Internet is done.
- 42:46It feels like, oh wow, likethe.com era and and then you
- 42:50know what Google and Apple have done over the last couple of
- 42:53decades that that'll never happen again.
- 42:54But that was just the call and response information.
- 42:57And now we're entering into we're, you know, we're, we're
- 43:00still in the early stages of that happening to money and then
- 43:03thought with AI. It's crazy.
- 43:06You could argue the whole Google, like the last 20 years
- 43:09was really kind of the initial organization of all the thoughts
- 43:12and patterns and and data so that it could then be ingested
- 43:16into these AI models. For further consolidation, the
- 43:20library that is then going to be used for all of the work.
- 43:23Yeah, by the way, I literally have this sitting on my desk.
- 43:27This book, A Brief History of Intelligence.
- 43:30I cannot recommend. This book is So Good by Max
- 43:34Bennett. Really, really good.
- 43:36All right, let's. If you haven't read this one.
- 43:39That's good too, yeah. Super intelligent.
- 43:41It's a little dark. For me it was a little dark.
- 43:43Yeah, yeah, this is. Extremely dark.
- 43:46That was the book that I read it in 2016.
- 43:49That was the the book that put me into my first bout of
- 43:53depression that I've experienced related to AI.
- 43:58Elon, Elon was a very big fan of that book, the Super
- 44:01intelligence book, and I think that might have jaded his like
- 44:04why he's so deeply. Not that that I don't think.
- 44:08I'm not trying to suggest that we shouldn't be concerned or or
- 44:12that it can't go in a dark direction.
- 44:14But yeah, this one here just does real fast for because this
- 44:17book just came out. It's basically this history on
- 44:21the evolution of like how the human brain evolved and then
- 44:25looking, looking at other animals and how their brains
- 44:28have evolved in the pattern that was constructed in order to get
- 44:32to the neocortex with like this deep basically modeling
- 44:36capacity. And then how they're using
- 44:38their, their understanding of the biological brain in order to
- 44:42do all the AI stuff that they're doing right now.
- 44:45It's it is amazing. I love that Holding up the
- 44:49Physiology of Behavior, which is, yeah, the best textbook for
- 44:52my neuroscience degree. Love learning about it.
- 44:54Jesse, I totally forgot about this.
- 44:56Yeah, this is right up your alley, man.
- 44:58Yeah, that's my whole, my whole, that whole shelf is all
- 45:02neuroscience. Yeah, we forget about that part
- 45:04too, About, about the, the brain is the lens through which we see
- 45:08the world. And yeah, it's the to date, it's
- 45:10the, it's, it's matter making sense of the world, the
- 45:15universe, which is beautiful and crazy to to think about.
- 45:18It's the only matter that strives to make sense of the
- 45:21world of the universe. And part of the reason or the
- 45:25reason, you know, we can even scratch the surface of
- 45:28understanding is because we've evolved those big brains and
- 45:31Congrats on your kids big brain, Jesse.
- 45:35And of course, the downside, by the way, is that's how you end
- 45:37up with with 41 hours of Labor. A big brain is not an easy
- 45:43delivery make. Random anecdote.
- 45:47Daddy was a neuroscientist, so unfortunately it's gonna be 41
- 45:50hours for you, sweetie. Sorry honey, we're basically
- 45:55Kangaroos or marsupials in that sense.
- 45:58We're not supposed to be born when we're born.
- 46:00Think about any other mammal, like like any deer or wildebeest
- 46:04or anything like that. They come out functioning, able
- 46:07to walk and run within hours. But for a, a human baby, it
- 46:11takes 18 months. And the reason is because we
- 46:15can't stay in the womb any longer.
- 46:16Our brains get too big, our heads get too big, we have to
- 46:20come out and then we're useless for 12 to 18 months.
- 46:23And we're basically like a kangaroo, you know, go in the
- 46:26pouch and be carried around and then you can function so.
- 46:30Just wrapping it all together. So I've seen wildebeest being
- 46:33born on the Serengeti, you know, and stand up within minutes.
- 46:39And so I highly recommend people take a trip.
- 46:41You could see two things. You could see this miracle of
- 46:45nature I'm we're describing in action and also you could go see
- 46:48the mining deployment that Marathon is doing so.
- 46:52Nice combo there. Two birds with one stone bring
- 46:55you back to Bitcoin, baby. So I'm going to take it back to
- 46:58the to the brain and AI here. OK, So Jesse, I'm curious after,
- 47:02you know, I'm not complete, I'm almost done with this book.
- 47:05There's a couple different cortices and things like that
- 47:07that have just kind of blown my mind as I'm reading this.
- 47:10As somebody who's studied this deeply, what is, you know, what
- 47:14is a region in the brain or something that you had studied
- 47:17that just kind of blew your mind And it just continues to stay
- 47:19with you that that is like for me when I'm reading this book,
- 47:23like the relationship with information or modeling coming
- 47:27out of the neocortex into the basal ganglia over to the
- 47:30thalamus and then back up again was just fascinating to me.
- 47:34So go ahead. I'm I'm curious what what you
- 47:36would say. Oh boy.
- 47:37It's, it's impossible because that's that's we, we know so
- 47:41little about the brain ultimately.
- 47:43Like we, we know about the brain because of when things go wrong.
- 47:48So we we literally learn about the brain because of brain
- 47:51damage to patients. And then you figure out, OK, so
- 47:54this region of the brain is ablated And and then they one of
- 48:00the best authors, in my opinion, in the kind of in the
- 48:04neuroscience space is Oliver Sacks.
- 48:06He was, yeah. He he would write beautiful
- 48:09stories about his patients. And, you know, this most famous
- 48:12book is the the man who mistook his wife for a hat because
- 48:15that's a literal problem that one guy faced when a certain
- 48:19region of his brain had brain damage.
- 48:22He mistook his wife for being a hat.
- 48:25How does that happen? What what has to go wrong?
- 48:28And and it also reveals how weird the inner functions of the
- 48:33brain are. But to your, to your question, I
- 48:35mean, everything you learn about in, in neuroscience, it's like,
- 48:38wow, that's a weird system for how that connects to that and
- 48:41how you process. Like, like visual spatial
- 48:44processing is this very strange matrix of areas of, you know,
- 48:48the surface of that portion of the brain.
- 48:51And each one does a different thing and processes the, the
- 48:56patterns and macro and micro and colors and puts it all together.
- 49:00And it's like, you know, you have a little bit of damage in
- 49:01one area. That's what you know, you're,
- 49:04you're you don't see. There's a a thing called a left,
- 49:08right blindness where you can, you can look at a plate with
- 49:12food on the left side and on the right side and you can literally
- 49:15not see the left side of the plate.
- 49:18You can think that the left side of the plate is empty just
- 49:21because a certain little spot is busted.
- 49:24That's the story of every region of the brain.
- 49:26And and yeah, awesome. OK, let's talk about on ramp.
- 49:31So for people that aren't familiar with On Ramp, explain
- 49:34what that is and then tell us what you guys are passionately
- 49:37working on. Yeah, On Ramp is a company that
- 49:41I Co founded about two years ago with Michael Tanguma from
- 49:46previously from Unchained Capital and it is a multi sig,
- 49:50multi institution custody company.
- 49:53And so, so that takes the idea of multi sig, which is
- 49:57inherently a self custody sort of idea of you.
- 50:01You split your Bitcoin custody between three hardware devices
- 50:07and those 3 keys control the vault that holds your your
- 50:12funds. And you need two of three of
- 50:14those keys to sign in order to move funds.
- 50:18But ultimately you are in control of two or three of those
- 50:23keys. So it's a self custody thing
- 50:25that you've set up and you maintain and and securities on
- 50:28you. Multi institution custody is
- 50:31taking that idea and saying, let's have institutions hold
- 50:35those keys on behalf of the end user.
- 50:39And the important part here is that each key is held by a
- 50:42different institution. So no, no single institution has
- 50:47a quorum of the keys necessary to control the funds in the
- 50:50vault. Instead it's the end user who
- 50:53the the vault is in their name that has a legal relationship
- 50:57with each of those key holding institutions.
- 50:59And those key holding institutions can only sign at
- 51:03the direction of that end user. So it's a way to have multi sig
- 51:08without having to set up and maintain your own keys while
- 51:13still maintaining control of your keys because you know the
- 51:18the not your keys, not your coins mantra is is is right.
- 51:21But really what that's trying to get at is not your control, not
- 51:25your coins. And multi institution custody
- 51:28manages to have a system where you don't have to be become a
- 51:32pro or proficient even at setting up and maintaining your
- 51:35own keys, but you can maintain control through the the system
- 51:40of re relying on three different institutions holding keys on
- 51:44your behalf. In on ramps case it's the the
- 51:47three key holding institutions are on ramp Bitco and coin
- 51:50cover, which you know Bitco and coin cover have been fantastic
- 51:54partners for us, some of the best, my opinion, the best
- 51:58companies in the industry for key management and the
- 52:02infrastructure from Bitco has been fantastic.
- 52:05And so that's where we've been working on building and scaling
- 52:08up. And it's been a great ride that
- 52:10Andy's been a part of. And it's been great to have Andy
- 52:13along for for that ride as we onboard more and more Bitcoin
- 52:17and help people solve the problems that they have with
- 52:21having to figure out what's the right custody solution for me.
- 52:24And a lot of people have the tension of, you know, I don't
- 52:27trust myself enough or I don't want to have vulnerability to a
- 52:31wrench attack by having unilateral control of my funds
- 52:35at home or you know, within driving distance.
- 52:38And this solves for that. It also solves for the
- 52:42inheritance problem that many people face when, you know,
- 52:45storing their funds. How do you ensure that in the,
- 52:49you know, in the event you get hit by a bus that your
- 52:52beneficiaries can access your funds?
- 52:56You know, if you set up a treasure map with hardware
- 52:58wallets that may not, that may not be accessible, but with a
- 53:03legal relationship with multi institution custody, it's a
- 53:07pretty seamless transition from you to your beneficiaries.
- 53:11I want to share a chart. Oh, sorry.
- 53:13Go ahead, Andy. What?
- 53:14Well, no. No, that's, that's well said.
- 53:16I was just going to say a couple things.
- 53:17First of all, yeah, the wrench tech, you know, issue is big.
- 53:21By the way, remember when you could buy a wrench for $5?
- 53:24Remember when it really was a $5 wrench?
- 53:26What are you up to now? Like 8-9.
- 53:28Yeah, I got to believe more like 20.
- 53:30So that's one thing. And then, yeah, just, you know,
- 53:32in terms of my role at at on Ramp, you know, it's been my
- 53:35mission for a while. I did it for Swan, you know,
- 53:38doing it for helping out with On Ramp as well to just try and
- 53:42divert some small percentage of buying power for Bitcoin, you
- 53:48know, away from the Roche motel paper Bitcoin structures like
- 53:53the ETFs and into actual coins. And if it's going to be into
- 53:56actual coins, you know, that means that those coins can be
- 54:00withdrawn to self custody in the future.
- 54:04You know, I suspect that U.S. citizens, but not exclusively
- 54:09U.S. citizens, people bitcoiners that have a significant stack.
- 54:14You know, a lot of them have their roll your own ninja self
- 54:18custody set up, but they're a little bit worried that not all
- 54:24those coins are going to make it to their wives and kids if
- 54:27something happens to them. And so kind of makes sense to
- 54:31have part of the stack in multi institution custody and I think
- 54:34it makes sense for managed wealth as well.
- 54:36And then of course, as part of that effort, we, you know, we've
- 54:40been, we've been having some fun, me and Jesse running the
- 54:43scarce assets podcast. We had an amazing launch of that
- 54:48show because of course, episode one was you, Preston, and it was
- 54:53a lot of fun. We had Jeff Booth and we had
- 54:57Lynn Alden and Pierre and Morgan Richard and Alex Gladstein and,
- 55:02you know, VJ and Breedlove and, and a bunch and it's just been a
- 55:07blast. So I just want to thank you for
- 55:09helping us launch my podcast as strongly as we possible possibly
- 55:15could. There's no one else I would
- 55:16rather have started it with than you.
- 55:18And it was a lot of. Fun.
- 55:21We had a fun conversation, I remember.
- 55:23We did. I've got one more question for
- 55:25you. So Saylor was up on stage, I
- 55:28don't know where this was at, but he was presenting a slide
- 55:32that Jesse had created. I love this slide because I
- 55:36think it, it really allows a person to zoom way out and see
- 55:42the really, really, really big picture.
- 55:44And I am sharing this slide right now that Jesse created.
- 55:49And for the listener, if you're, if you're not, you know, on, on
- 55:53YouTube watching this and you're just listening to it, it lays
- 55:56out all the buying power in the entire world, whether it's
- 55:59equities, real estate, bonds, that just the, the currency
- 56:03itself, art, gold, collectibles, you name it.
- 56:06And it shows that the total value of all of this stuff is
- 56:11900 trillion U.S. dollars today. And you know, at a 10%, what is
- 56:17called a 10% growth rate of M2, which I think it's even more
- 56:20than global M2 is a faster pace than 10%.
- 56:23But well, let's just say it's 10% next year.
- 56:26This should be quadrillion. Yeah, a quadrillion.
- 56:31So walk us through how a person what, what when we're looking at
- 56:36this, Jesse, obviously you think Bitcoin's going to continue to
- 56:40grow past the one trillion. But what is contracting or what
- 56:44is shrinking in size on all these different asset classes as
- 56:48we're looking at this chart? Yeah, that's awesome.
- 56:52Thank you, Preston. Yeah, Sailor has been using this
- 56:55this chart because what what it helps tee up for him is as he,
- 57:00as he phrases it, that all assets are in a constant
- 57:05continuous competition. And that is to say that some of
- 57:09these asset buckets are growing and some of them are shrinking
- 57:12based on how investors are allocating their capital any
- 57:16day, month, year, decade. When I see this, this lens, when
- 57:22when I put together these numbers and assembled it all and
- 57:24put it on the page and you see Bitcoin as $1 trillion asset
- 57:29class, that's 0.1%, one, one thousandth of the total asset
- 57:36landscape. And gold is 12, arguably 16
- 57:39trillion. So you know, that's kind of your
- 57:41closest competitor. It's a 12 to 16X from, you know,
- 57:46where we are with Bitcoin, and that's small potatoes in the
- 57:49grand scheme. When you look at all of these
- 57:51asset classes, to me, the thing that really sticks out is bonds.
- 57:57We were talking earlier about what it means to be holding
- 58:00bonds now and into the future. I think that because of the
- 58:06amount of sovereign debt levels 35 trillion in the US and and
- 58:12our deficits in the US now normalizing $2 trillion annual
- 58:18deficits, we haven't balanced the budget in 22 years.
- 58:21We're going to keep adding to those deficits and that means
- 58:25we're going to keep adding to our national debt and we're
- 58:28printing to do all that. So we're adding more bonds and
- 58:35what that amounts to is that the, the nominal yield on a
- 58:38bond, I don't think we'll outpace inflation over the
- 58:41coming decades, 10/20 plus years.
- 58:46It's it's already not. And so holding bonds today in my
- 58:50opinion is a is a net negative proposition.
- 58:56You are, you are losing purchasing power by holding
- 59:00bonds and receiving that nominal yield of of 4%, which sure might
- 59:04be above the stated CPI numbers, but I think is actually below
- 59:10the true inflation rate. So if you're holding bonds and
- 59:15everybody is right, like if you go look in your vanguard account
- 59:18and see what percent of of your, your four O 1K is tucked away
- 59:23and and you know, safe, quote UN quote safe low risk bonds, it's
- 59:30going to be a significant portion 2040 sixty 80%.
- 59:33And that's losing in real purchasing power every year, in
- 59:37my opinion. So, and that contrast with
- 59:40Bitcoin, which in my view, the secret sauce of Bitcoin is it's
- 59:44increasing scarcity. The, the function that's built
- 59:47into it every four years that the amount of Bitcoin being
- 59:50created gets cut in half, you know, every day, every month,
- 59:54every year. And you know, we just dropped
- 59:57from 1.8% annual supply growth to .9%, which.
- 1:00:04Means that we're now lower than gold because gold is 1.5 to 2%
- 1:00:07annual supply growth every year. So on this page, you know,
- 1:00:11Bitcoin just became a better store of value asset, a more
- 1:00:14attractive store of value asset, and has reason to get better
- 1:00:17into the future versus gold. The fact that it's still not as
- 1:00:21large as gold is a lagging function of the world's
- 1:00:25recognition that Bitcoin is a better store of value asset, a
- 1:00:28better savings technology ultimately than gold because
- 1:00:32people don't recognize it. It has increasing scarcity built
- 1:00:35into it. It will grow and the the price
- 1:00:38will appreciate every four years because of that increasing
- 1:00:41scarcity function. And that's Bitcoin versus gold.
- 1:00:45But then there's bonds and bonds are already a negative real
- 1:00:50return in my opinion. So those are the three buckets
- 1:00:54that stand out to me. Andy, you actually summarize
- 1:00:56this on the show in a in a nice way when you were talking about
- 1:01:01how you're viewing it for your clients of those three asset
- 1:01:04categories. You want to tee that up.
- 1:01:06Yeah, yeah, absolutely. So I just first, I want to say I
- 1:01:09love this analysis, Jesse. You know, I did my own version
- 1:01:13of this analysis in 2019 when I was writing Why Buy Bitcoin?
- 1:01:17And of course, you improved on it, Jesse, by putting it into
- 1:01:21beautiful graphical format. So I love this.
- 1:01:24I love this version of it. And yeah, one of the ways, first
- 1:01:28of all, one of the ways I pitch it to clients, I can't remember
- 1:01:31where I got this, got this, but basically Bitcoin is the new
- 1:01:34gold and gold is the new bonds, right?
- 1:01:37So it's like the bonds, as Jesse so eloquently pointed out, are
- 1:01:42going to lose you money in terms of real purchasing power over
- 1:01:45over the long run. And so gold is better than that.
- 1:01:48And gold is taking share. By the way, the way I
- 1:01:50implemented that as a practitioner for my clients was
- 1:01:54first back in 2016 in the then 30 year history or almost 30
- 1:02:00year history of my firm, my wealth management firm, we had
- 1:02:04never owned what I call hard money assets, right?
- 1:02:07We'd never owned gold for clients ever, right?
- 1:02:09It was a pet rock that didn't generate cash flows.
- 1:02:12But we started to figure out what was going on with the
- 1:02:16bigger picture macro. And so we bought gold for the
- 1:02:18first time. And then of course, Bitcoin
- 1:02:21raised its hand, so to speak. It had shown up earlier, of
- 1:02:24course, but but I found it when I found it some years ago.
- 1:02:28And so that for my clients has been taking share out of gold.
- 1:02:33So it's a little bit the, you know, the the Pac-Man eating the
- 1:02:36Pac-Man eating the Pac-Man where the ultimate eater of
- 1:02:41everything, of course, is Bitcoin, but the intermediate
- 1:02:44eater of bonds is gold. I, I think that perhaps the, the
- 1:02:49simplification of where this chart I think is heading is
- 1:02:53Bitcoin is a better asset than gold and gold is a better asset
- 1:02:57than bonds. And right now the current
- 1:03:00valuation of those 3 buckets is, reflects the opposite.
- 1:03:04And I think that economic reality and, and the demise of
- 1:03:09our Fiat structure because of the debt levels that we've taken
- 1:03:13on will osmotically, organically 'cause people to realize that
- 1:03:19they're better off putting their capital in Bitcoin rather than
- 1:03:23leaving it in bonds to continue generating a negative real
- 1:03:27return. And I think the end state of
- 1:03:30this, if we were only looking at those 3 buckets, is that Bitcoin
- 1:03:35flips bonds in the general role and size of those categories,
- 1:03:42those buckets here in the global asset landscape.
- 1:03:45Which is to say that, you know, in my Bitcoin's full potential
- 1:03:49evaluation piece where this chart comes from, I landed at
- 1:03:53what I think is probably conservative end state of
- 1:03:58Bitcoin siphoning off capital from all of these buckets, most
- 1:04:02of all from bonds and eventually growing to become 200 trillion
- 1:04:09of the 900 trillion in in global asset value, which would mean
- 1:04:14$10 million per Bitcoin in today's dollars.
- 1:04:18And I think that's where we're heading.
- 1:04:20The only thing I'd add to there besides that, as if that wasn't
- 1:04:24enough of a mic drop, is, Oh yeah, don't forget the largest
- 1:04:29box on that graphic, which is real estate.
- 1:04:32And yeah, I was giving a chat to the local office of Berkshire
- 1:04:36Hathaway Realty about a month ago, and that conversation to
- 1:04:42your average realtor would have been outlandish and or offensive
- 1:04:47until very recently. Yeah.
- 1:04:49They just laughed you out of the room.
- 1:04:50Exactly. Well, this time was not the
- 1:04:53case. It was well attended, people
- 1:04:56were listening very carefully. They're asking really good
- 1:04:59questions and I think there is more than ever a realization
- 1:05:04that taking the Bitcoin, taking a bite out of that giant piece
- 1:05:08of the pie real estate is, is also likely to happen.
- 1:05:12Because the cap rate on all that real estate changes and I mean
- 1:05:15it's so drastically mispriced right now because of fixed
- 1:05:18income. It it being a premium above the
- 1:05:21fixed income quote UN quote risk free rate.
- 1:05:24So, you know, whatever that multiple turns out to be as that
- 1:05:28as the the cap rate changes on all real estate.
- 1:05:31I mean, Andy, what do you think? Are we talking a multiple of
- 1:05:34three? Is it going to, is it going to
- 1:05:37be cut into a third of where it's capped today because of
- 1:05:41those discount rates and what hurdle rate you're going to need
- 1:05:43by just holding Bitcoin and, and, and because equities are
- 1:05:47going to because the equities get repriced, right?
- 1:05:49And so then of course, the cap rate on on real estate gets
- 1:05:52repriced. So what?
- 1:05:53What is it? Yeah, exactly.
- 1:05:55I I think, you know, order of magnitude, I think of 50% ish
- 1:06:01and it easily could be because your conservative could be more
- 1:06:04than that. Yeah, and.
- 1:06:09And this gets back to Preston's whole thing here, which is, you
- 1:06:12know, from a, from a value investor point of view, nothing
- 1:06:16makes sense out there. And the thing that I think will
- 1:06:21restore sanity is Bitcoin being such a better asset to hold that
- 1:06:28it sucks capital away from all of these insane premium asset
- 1:06:34categories. And I think there's there's
- 1:06:37there's a natural equilibrium again.
- 1:06:39Sorry, I think there's a reason what what we're trying to say
- 1:06:42here is there's a reason that Preston launched the Bitcoin
- 1:06:45Fundamentals podcast, not the gold Fundamentals podcast or the
- 1:06:50Fixed income bonds Treasuries Fundamentals podcast.
- 1:06:54Correct. So, so all of that is basically
- 1:06:58saying that you're 10 million is a conservative number, what
- 1:07:01that's really saying? That's right.
- 1:07:04I mean, in that article I put together a table and and I
- 1:07:08didn't know that that Andy had done had done this exact
- 1:07:10exercise the years before me. So cops to Andy.
- 1:07:14You did it better. It's OK.
- 1:07:15You did it better well. What does Is Sailor saying 200
- 1:07:18trillion or is he saying 300 trillion?
- 1:07:20Sailor hasn't said what he you know, he hasn't put a flag in
- 1:07:26the ground on on a number like that, but he has.
- 1:07:29I actually. Like very kind about my analysis
- 1:07:32and put it forward as you know, very interesting thought
- 1:07:36provoking bit of analysis that I, you know, reading between the
- 1:07:39lines he tends to agree with so. I mean when I'm looking at the
- 1:07:42buckets, it's like and something that I did went while you were
- 1:07:45talking there Jesse, is I converted all of those numbers
- 1:07:49from a percentage as to like how much Bitcoin that would be.
- 1:07:52So the Bitcoin which was one trillion of the 900 trillion
- 1:07:56total pot, there would only be 23,000 Bitcoin of the 21 million
- 1:08:02percentage wise. The bond, the bond size which
- 1:08:07was what was it 300 trillion would be 7 million of the 21
- 1:08:12million Bitcoin. Assuming all the Bitcoin are
- 1:08:14still there and haven't been lost, we're just assuming all 21
- 1:08:17millionaire there, that would be 7 million of the 21 million
- 1:08:20Bitcoin would all be representing the value of the
- 1:08:23bond market, the real estate market, it would be 7.7 million
- 1:08:27Bitcoin and then stocks would be 2.7 million Bitcoin.
- 1:08:32Yeah, so. That's that's an awesome.
- 1:08:35Those numbers are very thought provoking.
- 1:08:37I do think that this this was one of the reasons I I wrote
- 1:08:40that piece of ultimately, I don't think we end up in a world
- 1:08:45where there's 21 million Bitcoin worth of value.
- 1:08:50I think we end up, weird as it is, in a world where there's 50
- 1:08:54million Bitcoin worth of value, or maybe it's 30 million Bitcoin
- 1:08:59worth of value. Because of cap rates and
- 1:09:01because. Of and that's because there's
- 1:09:04there's always going to be value in other assets.
- 1:09:06Yeah. And and if you price it in your
- 1:09:08unit of account of Bitcoin, you're, you're saying I've,
- 1:09:11well, I've, I've got one Bitcoin worth of real estate, but that's
- 1:09:15not included in the 21 million of Bitcoin because you own the
- 1:09:19real estate, you don't own the Bitcoin at that moment in time.
- 1:09:22Because the illiquidity of the equity and what the market is
- 1:09:26trading it out as a multiple of earnings is why you're seeing in
- 1:09:30excess of 21 million, correct? Yeah, yeah.
- 1:09:33And. Yeah, I think that's.
- 1:09:34Perhaps a different way of thinking about it is one of the
- 1:09:38things that I disagree with in in Bitcoin.
- 1:09:41In the Bitcoin landscape meme lands landscape really is
- 1:09:45Infinity divided by 21 million. I think that's directionally
- 1:09:49correct, but wrong. I think it's a it's a very
- 1:09:53helpful meme for thinking about Bitcoin as you know, all
- 1:09:57important, but I think that Bitcoin doesn't become
- 1:10:00everything. You're still going to value a
- 1:10:03Monet painting. You're still going to value 1000
- 1:10:07acre ranch. Turns out you can't.
- 1:10:09You can't live in your Bitcoin. Yeah, right, It turns out.
- 1:10:14Yeah. Some people would like to.
- 1:10:16Many would like to so, for there is a difference between forever
- 1:10:20Laura and Infinity divided by 21 million.
- 1:10:24Well, let's just take NVIDIA like if you were going, let's
- 1:10:26say the whole world has been bitcoinized, right?
- 1:10:28And we're that's the only unit that anybody wants to accept or
- 1:10:32wants the deal in. And you're looking at, well,
- 1:10:34NVIDIA just banged out this many, this many Bitcoin on an
- 1:10:37annualized basis. And I'm going to pay 10 times
- 1:10:41that those earnings in order to own this equity.
- 1:10:44So if you're paying 10 times the the number of Bitcoin units that
- 1:10:48are flowing through it from an income statement standpoint, top
- 1:10:52line revenue standpoint or, or bottom, I guess they would be
- 1:10:55have to be measured off of the top line to to start getting the
- 1:10:58multiples above 21 million. That's how it happens, correct?
- 1:11:02Yeah, and there's and there's. Yeah.
- 1:11:04And there's, you know, there's the other reality here.
- 1:11:07Another way to frame it is there is money in the system and what
- 1:11:11percent of the total value is the money and money plus the
- 1:11:14credit, right. So the the pyramiding of the
- 1:11:17credit in the banking system on top of the base money.
- 1:11:20So yes, the world is full of productive assets that are worth
- 1:11:24something. They should be worth more than
- 1:11:28the monetary asset that doesn't generate cash flows when that
- 1:11:33monetary acid, you know, reaches its valuation potential, which
- 1:11:37is happening before our very eyes over a period of years and
- 1:11:41years and years. And some days I wake up and
- 1:11:43think it's I can't believe how how quickly it's happening.
- 1:11:46And other days I can't believe how slowly because it's so
- 1:11:49obvious what's going on. Yeah, exactly.
- 1:11:53But that's that's another way to frame this, you know, total
- 1:11:57potential of oh, it's the unit of account, but there are other
- 1:12:01valuable and productive assets. And yes, someday Preston will
- 1:12:06put in a bid on NVIDIA stock or whatever other stock that
- 1:12:10generates cash flows, but the valuation may not be at, you
- 1:12:14know, whatever 50 * 2 year forward earnings.
- 1:12:18Oh, you. Are I'm already buying equity
- 1:12:19MicroStrategy or at least I, I haven't like added to the
- 1:12:23position, but like I do have an equity, but I would buy the I,
- 1:12:26I, I was smart, I would have bought the Dylan Leclair thing
- 1:12:29at the the Japanese equity that he's doing the same micro
- 1:12:33strategy move on. Yeah, Metaplanet.
- 1:12:35I, if I was smart, I would have done it right during the
- 1:12:37announcement, but now I'm like, you know, I, I'd have to go in
- 1:12:41there and look at the treasury and market price right now.
- 1:12:43But there's another one that is just like, hey, that, that is
- 1:12:46something that actually might make sense.
- 1:12:47Now. My, my position size with
- 1:12:50MicroStrategy is taking on a much larger percent than I would
- 1:12:54like in my overall portfolio just because of the 61O2 risks
- 1:12:57that I, you know, I, I waited at, but I am, I'm if a, if a
- 1:13:02company is demonstrating that they are making money, they have
- 1:13:06a Bitcoin balance sheet initiative and it's actually
- 1:13:11priced and I think they have some type of competitive mode to
- 1:13:13continue to make money. I'll buy it today.
- 1:13:16I'll buy it today if the numbers makes sense.
- 1:13:19It's just. Math.
- 1:13:21It means there's. It means there's now a a
- 1:13:24strategy that meets your criteria as a Bitcoin value
- 1:13:28investor to generate Bitcoin in excess of.
- 1:13:32Moreover, the investable universe of companies that meet
- 1:13:36your criteria, Preston can only grow.
- 1:13:40It can only go up. There are more.
- 1:13:42There's only going to be more and more names, more and more
- 1:13:45tickers, more and more companies that are meeting Preston Pish's
- 1:13:49value investor. Bitcoin value investor.
- 1:13:52I'm a Bitcoin boy. There's some value investors
- 1:13:55that their stomachs are turning here and you say that.
- 1:14:00That's that's the winning formula.
- 1:14:02Is it? Hurry up and figure out that you
- 1:14:04have to be a Bitcoin value investor in order to outperform
- 1:14:07Bitcoin. Otherwise, just hold Bitcoin.
- 1:14:10Amen, Amen. We're trying to do it on the VC
- 1:14:12side too. I mean, it's I, I don't know
- 1:14:14where else you could outperform it, to be quite honest with you,
- 1:14:17unless you are getting it at a discount to the treasury and
- 1:14:21you're making money as a publicly large publicly traded
- 1:14:24company or you're stepping into an industry that is ripe for
- 1:14:27disruption and you can get it in early stage and you think it
- 1:14:30can, you know, 100 X from from the purchase.
- 1:14:33If you have the luxury of stepping in and buying it at
- 1:14:35that price, I don't know how else you can outperform it, but
- 1:14:38so I'm trying to be in both the spaces in addition to obviously
- 1:14:41holding Bitcoin, but. Risk adjusted a thing, yeah, a
- 1:14:45thing probably each of us said years ago was on a risk adjusted
- 1:14:49basis I haven't found a better investment opportunity than
- 1:14:52Bitcoin. And on a risk adjusted basis, I
- 1:14:57still haven't found a better investment opportunity than
- 1:15:00Bitcoin. Wonder what the risk adjusted
- 1:15:02would have been on NVIDIA over the last decade because I know I
- 1:15:05think somebody just posted a chart today that the last 10
- 1:15:08years NVIDIA has outperformed Bitcoin.
- 1:15:11Yes, it has. Oh, it definitely has.
- 1:15:13It is the one asset that has outperformed Bitcoin.
- 1:15:17I I found this earlier this year.
- 1:15:20It's like the one thing basically that's that's
- 1:15:22outstripped Bitcoin's performance.
- 1:15:24There's no way but the. Inverse, the inverse of that.
- 1:15:27Remember, dear listeners, it's now a what, 2 1/2 or $3 trillion
- 1:15:33market cap company? And the tree does not grow to
- 1:15:37the sky if you're a company, but if you're a monetary protocol it
- 1:15:42does. The tree can grow much farther
- 1:15:44into the sky to. The sky.
- 1:15:46Yeah, much higher. Not forever, but much.
- 1:15:49Higher to Infinity. That's a great point, Andy.
- 1:15:52I love that. Yeah, no.
- 1:15:53If I had to, if I had to bet NVIDIA versus Bitcoin in the
- 1:15:56next 5-10 years, Bitcoin's gonna obliterate it.
- 1:16:00How does it right? What company can 5X from a multi
- 1:16:04trillion dollar valuation Much much harder.
- 1:16:06Not impossible, but very difficult.
- 1:16:08Very tethered to physical reality and good luck with those
- 1:16:11supply chains. Good luck with long lead items.
- 1:16:13Good luck with all the sub components and the, the proper
- 1:16:17coordination and the timing and the, the lack of or the
- 1:16:20potential competition and the, Yep, the governance of, you
- 1:16:24know, this country trying to take over your, you know, your
- 1:16:27chip manufacturing or whatever. Good luck competing against
- 1:16:31Bitcoin, guys. This was a blast.
- 1:16:33This was. Go ahead, Jesse.
- 1:16:34What are we going to say? I was just going to say Bitcoin
- 1:16:36is a whole lot more certain because you can just go look at
- 1:16:39the supply function and know that it's going to keep
- 1:16:42appreciating the value without you having to risk anything.
- 1:16:45Yeah, if you accept that it is a sound system to begin with.
- 1:16:50Yep, All right, Jesse started off.
- 1:16:53Tell people where they can find you and anything else that you
- 1:16:55want to highlight. Yeah, you can find me on Twitter
- 1:16:59at Cresis under Score BTC. You can also come check out on
- 1:17:04ramp at on rampbitcoin.com. And yeah to check out our
- 1:17:08episode with Preston on the Scarce Assets podcast.
- 1:17:12You can find that on on YouTube or any podcast app that you use.
- 1:17:16That's right. Scarce Assets is in the on Ramp
- 1:17:18feed along with the other great content that we're producing.
- 1:17:23And yeah, Ed Stroman, Andrew is my Twitter handle.
- 1:17:28We will have that in the show notes.
- 1:17:30Jesse, Congrats. Congrats to your wife.
- 1:17:33Thank you. Massive news.
- 1:17:34So exciting. So excited for you guys.
- 1:17:37And guys, thanks for making time today.
- 1:17:39Thank you so much, Preston. Thank you for listening to TIP.
- 1:17:43Make sure to follow Bitcoin Fundamentals on your favorite
- 1:17:47podcast app and never miss out on episodes.
- 1:17:50To access our show notes, transcripts, or courses, go to
- 1:17:54theinvestorspodcast.com. This show is for entertainment
- 1:17:58purposes only. Before making any decision,
- 1:18:00consult or professional. This show is copyrighted by the
- 1:18:03Investors Podcast Network. Written permission must be
- 1:18:06granted before syndication or rebroadcasting.