Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Recovering Attorney’s Fees in Tax Proceedings and State Board of Equalization Update
Transcript
- 0:03Greetings, everyone. My name is Howard Gould,
- 0:08and I am co -chair of the real estate section
- 0:10for the Beverly Hills Bar Association. We want
- 0:14to welcome everybody to our program today. Happy
- 0:17that you're able to join us. Before we get started,
- 0:21I want to give you an idea of what some of our
- 0:24upcoming programs are going to be. Our March
- 0:2819th program is going to be our annual California
- 0:32Association of Realtors update on their new forms
- 0:36or the changes in forms. Jana Garner from CAR
- 0:42is going to join us again this year and she's
- 0:44always extremely well versed about what's happening
- 0:47with the CAR forms that everybody uses. April
- 0:5116th, we're going to do a program on 1031 exchanges.
- 0:54Howard Fisher, former president of the SPAR Association,
- 0:58is going to give that presentation on 1031 exchanges.
- 1:02On April is our review of the prior year's cases
- 1:06with Larry Jacobson. We're going to do a new
- 1:10program we've never done on May 21st, which is
- 1:13about landlord insurance coverage for habitability
- 1:17claims in landlord tenant disputes. A big issue
- 1:20for landlords because so often habitability matters
- 1:25are raised when they have a dispute with a tenant.
- 1:28And again, another former president of this bar,
- 1:30Steve Raucher, who is an area practices insurance,
- 1:35is going to give this program about habitability
- 1:38insurance for landlords. On June 25th, Brian
- 1:43Mashian, who lectures for American industrial
- 1:46realtors about their forms and who lectured for
- 1:48us the last two years on the lease form and the
- 1:51real estate purchase agreement, is going to do
- 1:54a different program this year, something you
- 1:55probably haven't heard before. He's going to
- 1:58talk about how you effectively represent the
- 2:00small tenant in negotiating a commercial lease
- 2:03and what the dynamics are and how they're different
- 2:07when you've got a large tenant going into a commercial
- 2:10space as opposed to a smaller tenant in a multi
- 2:13-tenant space. And we'll have some good, I think,
- 2:17tips about things that he uses when he's representing
- 2:20the smaller tenants. If you have questions today,
- 2:25please put them in the Q &A, not the chat. We
- 2:28don't use the chat for questions, and we'll be
- 2:30monitoring the Q &A as we go along. The chat
- 2:34does have a link to the program materials and
- 2:37some other information about the Beverly Hills
- 2:39Bar Association that you're welcome to take a
- 2:41look at. The Beverly Hills Bar is very prompt
- 2:45about getting out their MCLE certificates, so
- 2:48you'll have that not long after this program
- 2:51airs. and if there's other people you know who
- 2:53are members of the Beverly Hills Bar they can
- 2:55access this program later if they choose to in
- 2:58the bar's library. I'm very, very happy to have
- 3:03Chris O 'Neill joining us again, and this year
- 3:05he's brought his colleague Ruben Sislin with
- 3:09him. Chris has spoken with us a number of times
- 3:14before. His practice focuses on ad valorem property
- 3:17tax and assessment counseling and litigation,
- 3:21including appeal hearings and trials. For over
- 3:2430 years, Chris has represented a variety of
- 3:27California taxpayers in equalization proceedings
- 3:29before county assessment appeal boards, the State
- 3:33Board of Equalization in Superior Court, the
- 3:36California Court of Appeals, and Chris has litigated
- 3:39property tax issues before the California Supreme
- 3:42Court. To give you some idea of the breadth of
- 3:45his practice, he provide services for owners
- 3:49of oil and gas fields, oil refineries, pipelines,
- 3:53shopping centers and anchor department stores,
- 3:55power plants, airport concessions, jet aircraft
- 3:59port terminals, aerospace manufacturing facilities,
- 4:03hotels, entertainment venues and theme parks,
- 4:06golf courses. billboards, hospitals, and manufacturing
- 4:10and food processing facilities among others.
- 4:13So he is a very broad clientele across many industries
- 4:17and some very complicated types of properties.
- 4:20He's also testified before the Los Angeles County
- 4:23Superior Court as an expert witness on property
- 4:25tax matters. Chris graduated from Claremont McKenna
- 4:30College and got his JD at UCLA. Rubin also focuses
- 4:34his practice on California state and local tax
- 4:37controversies. He does that at the audit administrative
- 4:40and judicial levels. He has broad experience
- 4:43representing Fortune 500 and middle market companies.
- 4:46closely held businesses, startups, families,
- 4:49and individuals in a wide range of state and
- 4:51local taxes. That includes corporate, franchise
- 4:55income taxes, personal income, sales and use,
- 4:59property and gross receipts, and other local
- 5:01taxes. So Rubin is doing a lot of things besides
- 5:04just the property taxes. And Ruben got both a
- 5:07BA and an MA in economics at USC and his JD from
- 5:11Loyola Law School with concentrations in corporate
- 5:14law and tax law. So thank you both for joining
- 5:17us. And Chris, tell us about how to collect our
- 5:20attorney's fees and property tax controversies.
- 5:23Happy to do so. And while we're waiting for the
- 5:26PowerPoint to come up on the screen, let's just
- 5:29chat about that for a moment. Many people, you
- 5:33know, they think, oh, my taxes are too high.
- 5:36I've got to fight them somehow. And what they
- 5:42often think is that, man, not only do I have
- 5:45to pay the tax, but I'm going to have to pay
- 5:47my attorney to fight this tax. And a lot of people
- 5:52don't realize that it's not so. And in fact,
- 5:57we'll see, and we can turn ahead to page three
- 6:00in the PowerPoint if you want. We'll see that
- 6:04attorney's fees can be recovered in all types
- 6:08of state and local tax proceedings. Today we're
- 6:11going to spend a good part of our time talking
- 6:15about the property tax arena, but fees can be
- 6:19recovered in city and municipal business tax
- 6:22controversies, in transfer tax controversies,
- 6:25and that's becoming a bigger and bigger issue
- 6:27with the changes in the transfer taxes in San
- 6:32Francisco and Los Angeles and the very high transfer
- 6:35taxes that are now being collected on transactions
- 6:38in those locations and other Northern California
- 6:43locales and even in state franchise tax matters.
- 6:47And people also don't realize sometimes they're
- 6:50small amounts and sometimes they're very large
- 6:52amounts. So we're going to talk a little bit
- 6:53more about what types of recoveries, what amounts
- 6:57of recoveries we've seen in the past. On the
- 7:02transfer tax, what sort of properties are you
- 7:04talking about being transferred? You know, transfer
- 7:08tax is both commercial and residential properties.
- 7:14So now when we're talking about commercial properties
- 7:17and they're very, very large or high value properties,
- 7:20then we're talking about very large amounts of
- 7:22transfer tax. And that's why this is becoming
- 7:25an issue in places like San Francisco and Los
- 7:27Angeles, where the percentage of total price
- 7:30or value, actually percentage of value that's
- 7:33being collected for transfer tax is 5 % and above
- 7:36in those locales. So I want to return to the
- 7:40next slide. You know, why do we have a fee, I
- 7:47would say call it a fee awards or attorney's
- 7:49fees to taxpayers in tax proceedings? Well, first
- 7:54of all, we need to remember that only the taxpayers
- 7:56are entitled to the fees under these statutes
- 7:59that we're going to talk about in a little bit.
- 8:01So they're unilateral provisions. They're not
- 8:05bilateral like you find say in contracts where
- 8:08the prevailing party or the offending party is
- 8:11entitled to recover fees against the other. The
- 8:16idea is the legislature in enacting the statutes
- 8:19we're gonna talk about a little bit here, wanted
- 8:22taxpayers to feel free not only to challenge
- 8:26improper assessments. The question you start
- 8:30off with is, is it worth fighting this assessment?
- 8:34But to be able to say, maybe it's more worth
- 8:37fighting if I could recover my fees, particularly
- 8:40if this assessment seems out of place, improper,
- 8:45wrong, illegal, unconstitutional. The other thing
- 8:49that it does is, because taxpayers are out there
- 8:52and more able and willing to challenge their
- 8:56assessments, with the possibility of getting
- 8:59fees, it ensures that taxing authorities and
- 9:02not just county assessors, but all types of state
- 9:05and local taxing authorities consistently interpret
- 9:08and apply the tax laws to all taxpayers. So let's
- 9:13talk about what attorney's fees are recoverable.
- 9:16Let's go to the next slide here. In these proceedings,
- 9:21and I'm going to be using property tax as an
- 9:24example here, but fees are obviously recoverable
- 9:27if you have to appeal from an administrative
- 9:30tax proceeding. They're recoverable in the trial
- 9:33court for the cost of going to court to recover
- 9:38those fees. Now oftentimes in property tax, there's
- 9:42a further appeal to the California Court of Appeal.
- 9:45Fees are recoverable there as well. Fees are
- 9:50also recoverable if the trial court or the court
- 9:53of appeal remands the matter back to the administrative
- 9:56panel, in this case an assessment appeals board,
- 9:59for further proceeding. You can get your fees
- 10:01on that remanded hearing. You can even get fees
- 10:04for bringing your motion for attorney's fees.
- 10:07We've got one of those right now where we're
- 10:09requesting not only fees in the trial court,
- 10:12but fees for the cost of bringing the motion.
- 10:16By the way, I should point out that in italics,
- 10:20after some of these, you'll see the names like
- 10:22Canandaigua Chinese Theater. These are actual
- 10:25cases published or unpublished, but available
- 10:28on Westlaw. And at the end of the PowerPoint,
- 10:33there'll be a list of the cases that we're talking
- 10:35about here. So you can actually go and read the
- 10:37cases and see what they stand for. The last one
- 10:40here, I've had some people say, well, can I get
- 10:43my fees for my initial proceeding before the
- 10:46administrative panel? And unfortunately, No,
- 10:49you can't, because until that panel has decided
- 10:52the matter, it's unclear whether the jurisdiction
- 10:56has acted improperly. But otherwise, all other
- 11:00fees are potentially recoverable in these proceedings.
- 11:06Next one I'm going to just get to real quickly
- 11:09on the next page. It's this idea of should fees
- 11:13be allocated? For the most part, the answer is
- 11:17no. And that's because in most proceedings there's
- 11:20one cause of action. property tax. It's a complaint
- 11:23for refund of property taxes paid. And it's very
- 11:26hard to split the cause of action. You'll find
- 11:29in other types of proceedings that maybe the
- 11:33party prevailed on two out of four causes of
- 11:35action. And then there's an argument that, well,
- 11:38maybe half of the fees should not be awarded.
- 11:41But for the most part in property tax proceedings,
- 11:44and I believe in most tax proceedings, the entire
- 11:48amount of fees incurred is fair game. and should
- 11:51be claimed. There shouldn't be any splitting
- 11:54of causes of action, splitting based on how many
- 11:57legal theories or theories were put in there.
- 12:00In fact, the Villa San Clemente case is saying
- 12:03where things are really intertwined, it's just
- 12:06impractical. we're not going to do it. The Court
- 12:09of Appeals said we're not going to do that here.
- 12:11And it didn't. And although a certain amount
- 12:13of fees were discounted for other reasons, there
- 12:16was no fee splitting based on the number of theories
- 12:19that the taxpayer raised in the Superior Court
- 12:23proceeding. Now we're going to take a look at
- 12:28what kind of fees have been recovered. I'm going
- 12:30to ask Ruben to take over on the next slide here.
- 12:35Right. Thank you, Chris. Good afternoon, everyone.
- 12:38Thank you for joining us. So you may be wondering
- 12:41how much in fees can actually be recovered. Is
- 12:44it even worth the effort to pursue fees? And
- 12:48it certainly can be, depending on the case. But
- 12:51it's not always worthwhile. And the amounts of
- 12:56fees that may be covered can vary quite a bit,
- 12:59depending on the particular case, the attorney
- 13:01fee statute under which recovery is sought. We're
- 13:04going to discuss these various statutes soon,
- 13:07but here we just want to give you an idea of
- 13:09the fees that have been recovered in prior cases.
- 13:13And I'll let you know, and Chris will talk about
- 13:15this a little bit more in a moment, but the fees
- 13:19you see on the slide here, they're not meant
- 13:22to be an exhaustive list by any means. They're
- 13:24just a selection to give you all an idea of what's
- 13:27been recovered. And the fees are granted at the
- 13:33trial court level and oftentimes are not appealed.
- 13:38So the published cases you would look at, you're
- 13:41not always going to see all the cases where fees
- 13:44have been recovered in tax cases. And it may
- 13:48be helpful to go actually look at the trial court
- 13:50decisions to see what sort of fees have been
- 13:52recovered there, maybe not appealed. And that's
- 13:55certainly helpful. But in my experience, oftentimes
- 13:59what happens is a taxpayer will get a fee award,
- 14:03and then the parties will start negotiating and
- 14:06trying to settle the case. So there ends up being
- 14:09some sort of fee recovery, but it may not be
- 14:11for the full amount that was actually awarded
- 14:13by the trial court. And we never really get to
- 14:18see what happened there unless we were actually
- 14:20involved in the case. Chris, I know you had some
- 14:24comments about the cases we have up here. Few
- 14:27other comments one is the last one on this list
- 14:30the five million dollars that was actually a
- 14:32private attorney general action Brought by a
- 14:35taxpayer in San Francisco related to a hotel
- 14:38tax The other cases are property tax cases, but
- 14:43I wanted to focus on the Madonna one the fourth
- 14:47one down That's an older case. It was it was
- 14:50decided under section eight eight hundred back
- 14:54when the maximum fee under section 800 of the
- 14:56government code was $1 ,500. Now that's now increased
- 15:00to $7 ,500 per claim. But I have seen trial courts
- 15:06in property tax proceedings be very creative.
- 15:09in the number of $7 ,500 awards that they can
- 15:13make. For example, if there's a property and
- 15:16it really consists of eight parcels, I've seen
- 15:19a trial court award $7 ,500 per parcel. So $7
- 15:25,500 times eight. I've also seen where there
- 15:29may be a party brought appeals for four different
- 15:31tax years. And the courts will use, a trial court,
- 15:35these are trial courts, will give four awards
- 15:38of $7 ,500 each. $7 ,500 times eight or times
- 15:43four is a pretty significant amount of money.
- 15:47And so that gives you a further idea of how...
- 15:50you could be creative in seeking fees in these
- 15:55proceedings. And like I said, half of the reported
- 15:59cases do not show the amount of fees that were
- 16:02actually recovered. So there's at least twice
- 16:05as many of these that we know are front -end
- 16:07reported cases. Probably there are dozens and
- 16:10dozens of others, either in trial court proceedings
- 16:14that never get reported or other appellate court
- 16:17proceedings that got resolved or settled. If
- 16:21we turn to the next page, I'm going to let Ruben
- 16:24talk about what are the vehicles, what are the
- 16:26statutes for recovering attorney's fees? There
- 16:30are several statutes that allow for recovery
- 16:32of attorney's fees and tax cases. The primary
- 16:36ones you'll see listed are listed on this page,
- 16:39and we'll discuss each of these. In a bit more
- 16:42detail on the next few slides, but just to give
- 16:44you a quick summary of what we have here is you
- 16:47have government code section 800 and this essentially
- 16:51allows for a limited fee recovery as we just
- 16:55discussed where the government's action is arbitrary
- 16:58and capricious. Next, it's revenue and taxation
- 17:02code section 1611 .5 and 1611 .6 and those two.
- 17:09Go together and it applies in property tax cases
- 17:12where the county assessment appeals boards Findings
- 17:16of fact are either absent or legally deficient
- 17:21The other one is sections 5152 and 538 of the
- 17:27Revenue and Taxation Code. And this also applies
- 17:31in property tax cases where the assessor fails
- 17:34to take proper action where it believes a law
- 17:37is unconstitutional or invalid. And lastly on
- 17:41this list, you have a Code of Civil Procedure,
- 17:44Section 1021 .5. And this is the widely used
- 17:47private attorney general action. attorney fee
- 17:51provision, and it's used in a variety of contexts,
- 17:54including in the tax cases. There are a couple
- 17:58of more statutes that you don't see on the screen
- 18:00here, and we won't be discussing them in detail
- 18:03today, but I do want to make note of them. Revenue
- 18:07and Taxation Code Section 19 -717. And this essentially
- 18:14grants the court an income tax refund actions,
- 18:18discretion to award taxpayers their reasonable
- 18:22litigation costs if they prevail in the position
- 18:25of the state of California. In those cases, it
- 18:28would be the franchise tax board and the proceeding
- 18:32was not substantially justified. There's a similar
- 18:36statute, Revenue Taxation Code Section 7156,
- 18:41which basically allows the same type of fee recovery
- 18:44in sales and use tax cases as well. Well, let's
- 18:50turn to the first one on the list here, which
- 18:55is on page 10, Government Code Section 800. Oh,
- 18:59I'm sorry. I jumped. Ruben, I'm sorry. I jumped
- 19:05ahead. No, that's okay. This is a quick slide.
- 19:10Just the review standard for attorney's fees.
- 19:14So the determination is made at the trial court
- 19:18level. The trial judge has discretion to allow
- 19:21fees to determine the reasonableness of the fees,
- 19:25the amount of the fees. That decision will stand
- 19:29unless there's an abuse of discretion. However,
- 19:32where in cases where you have an issue of interpretation
- 19:35of the statute that allows for an award of the
- 19:38fees, then you would have de novo review and
- 19:41in those cases. And that second one is important
- 19:45because. We're going to spend most of the rest
- 19:48of the time here talking about the statutes involved
- 19:51and the specific language, the specific wording
- 19:54in those statutes. If we turn to the next page,
- 19:58we'll start with Government Code Section 800,
- 20:00which says, in any civil action to appeal or
- 20:03review the award, finding, or other determination
- 20:05of any administrative proceeding or any other
- 20:09provision of state law, If it's shown that the
- 20:12award or determination was the result of arbitrary
- 20:15or capricious action or conduct by the public
- 20:19entity or officer, and if the complainant prevails
- 20:23in that civil action, they're entitled to an
- 20:25award of $7 ,500 computed at $100 per hour. Obviously,
- 20:31this is a little bit dated. Remember, this used
- 20:34to be $1 ,500 back in the 70s when the Madonna
- 20:38case came out. People have said it needs to be
- 20:42increased to 15 ,000 today or even 25 ,000. So
- 20:46far, the legislature hasn't done that. But the
- 20:50key elements are set forth there. And if you
- 20:53turn the page, I've actually pulled them out
- 20:55and made a list of them. Any civil action, appeal
- 20:59of any administrative proceeding under any provision
- 21:03of state law. Obviously, this is intended not
- 21:05just to apply to tax, but to any type of administrative
- 21:10proceeding, but it is regularly applied to tax.
- 21:14In fact, we file a lot of lawsuits in Superior
- 21:18Court challenging tax assessments by taxing tribunals,
- 21:23by administrative boards, and we always assert.
- 21:28If we don't assert anything else, we always allege
- 21:31section 800 and that fees have been incurred
- 21:34to bring the action and a recovery is requested
- 21:38under government code section 800. Now the key
- 21:41in section 800 is obviously the fourth bullet
- 21:44point there. Arbitrary or capricious action or
- 21:48conduct, clearly a factual question for the judge,
- 21:53and it's going to go to looking at what was the
- 21:57tax, What was the basis for assessing the tax?
- 22:00If there was factual basis for assessing the
- 22:03tax, did the tribunal, did they go outside of
- 22:08what the evidence would provide for? Did the
- 22:12officer go outside of the government officer
- 22:16or official, go outside of what the law provides
- 22:19for? And an important element of that is the
- 22:23last bullet, well, did the taxpayer prevail in
- 22:27the civil action? Believe it or not, sometimes
- 22:29people, sometimes in these cases on appeal, a
- 22:34taxpayer, they say, well, you didn't get a refund,
- 22:37therefore, you didn't prevail. Remember, oftentimes,
- 22:41in a tax proceeding, you have to be remanded
- 22:44back to the administrative panel. The tax tribunal
- 22:49for further proceedings and an award of the tax.
- 22:54So we'll see, we're gonna go over some of the
- 22:56case law here, but partial refunds and even remands
- 23:00are sufficient for recovery of fees under section
- 23:03800. Now, section 800, you will say, well, that's
- 23:08not a lot of money. we're going to see in a little
- 23:10bit that the legislature has raised that or actually
- 23:15taken the cap off of Section 800 in some situations,
- 23:22including property tax. But let's turn to now
- 23:25some applications of Section 800. Remember I
- 23:28said, appeal a decision of an administrative
- 23:31or tax proceeding, and that is considered a civil
- 23:35action. So clearly, The courts have said that
- 23:38a property tax assessment proceeding, an appeal
- 23:42from that to the trial court is a civil action.
- 23:46What is arbitrary and capricious? Well, again,
- 23:49the Court of Appeal has told us that whenever
- 23:52the trial court says, you know what? This decision
- 23:55by the assessment appeals board is deficient
- 23:59and we are remanding it back to the board for
- 24:03further proceedings so we can get some good findings
- 24:05out of the board. That per se is an arbitrary
- 24:09and capricious determination entitling the litigant,
- 24:15the taxpayer, to fees. Who is the prevailing
- 24:18party? Well, the matter in the Canadega case
- 24:23was remanded back to the board. And the taxing
- 24:28authority, the county in that case said, well,
- 24:30wait a second, it was remanded back. There was
- 24:33no property tax refund. And the court of appeals
- 24:36said, no, look, in many cases, tax proceeding
- 24:40appeals are for the purpose of getting a remand
- 24:44with instructions. back to the administrative
- 24:48panel, the tax tribunal, and that is the relief
- 24:51sought that entitles the taxpayer to attorney's
- 24:56fees. Now, interesting case that, and this comes
- 25:00up from time to time, arbitrary and capricious
- 25:03conduct can also be shown where in the Madonna
- 25:07case, the board found a value, the assessment
- 25:09appeals board found a value that was outside
- 25:12of the range of any values that either the assessor
- 25:15or the taxpayer had put into the record. The
- 25:18board said, look, how can the board determine
- 25:22a higher value than either side for the property
- 25:26than either side thought was the correct value?
- 25:29And in that case, it was very clear that the
- 25:31board said, look, this decision is not supported.
- 25:34by a fair or substantial reason, attorney's fees
- 25:38are merited. There's another case, a much higher
- 25:41value case called Next Century versus County
- 25:44of Los Angeles where that same issue arose. I'm
- 25:49going to turn it over to Reuben to talk about
- 25:51R &T code 1611 .5 and 1611 .6. 16 11 .5 and 0
- 26:02.6 these sort of go hand in hand at least when
- 26:05it comes to attorney's fees and at least in my
- 26:08view, this is the primary fee recovery provision
- 26:11for property taxes. Not because it has wide application.
- 26:16It can, but more so because you can recover a
- 26:22substantial amount of fees or that's justified.
- 26:25There's no limitation like we have under. government
- 26:29code section 800, which is only $7 ,500, although
- 26:33those numbers can be higher as Chris explained.
- 26:37And I'll let you read the text here of the statute,
- 26:41but section 1611 .5 essentially sets forth the
- 26:45standard for findings of fact and property tax
- 26:49cases. And just briefly to give you some background.
- 26:53Property tax disputes between taxpayers and county
- 26:56assessors are generally heard by the county assessment
- 26:59appeals board. You can think of that hearing
- 27:01before the assessment appeals board as the trial
- 27:05in the property tax case. And as section 1611
- 27:09.5 provides, The county assessment appeals board
- 27:12must make findings of fact if a party requests
- 27:15it and this could be done by the taxpayer or
- 27:18the assessor and the party requesting it must
- 27:21also pay the fee or deposit required for the
- 27:24findings to be made. The key language in 16 11
- 27:27.5 is that the findings of fact shall fairly
- 27:31disclose the board's determination of all material
- 27:34points raised by the parties and we'll take a
- 27:38look at what that means for. Just a minute, if
- 27:41we could go to the next slide, please. So now
- 27:46turning to 1611 .6, this is the actual attorney
- 27:50fee provision. And in essence, this provides
- 27:53that if the assessment appeals board fails to
- 27:56comply with the standard for findings that we
- 27:59just looked at under section 1611 .5, then an
- 28:03attorney's fees against the county may be recovered.
- 28:06for the services necessary to obtain proper findings
- 28:09that comply with 1611 .5. We could turn to the
- 28:16next slide, please. So we'll dive a little bit
- 28:23more into detail here on how 1611 .5 and 0 .6
- 28:28work. So 1611 .6 provides two circumstances under
- 28:33which fees may be recovered. First, you can recover
- 28:37fees where the County Assessment Appeals Board
- 28:40fails to make the requested findings. This would
- 28:44apply, for example, where the taxpayer requested
- 28:46findings, paid the fee, but the board just didn't
- 28:50issue the findings. Where we are seeing this
- 28:54come up more recently is where the board does
- 28:57not make timely findings. So in some counties,
- 29:01the board will issue a written decision after
- 29:04the hearing is held and then this will trigger
- 29:07a deadline for the board to issue its findings
- 29:09and that's 45 days. That written decision also
- 29:13triggers a taxpayer statute of limitations to
- 29:15appeal the board's decision to the Superior Court.
- 29:19We have situations where the board not only will
- 29:24miss their 45 -day deadline to issue the findings
- 29:26but will also not issue the findings before the
- 29:31expiration of the taxpayers' deadline to file
- 29:34a court action to appeal the decision. And as
- 29:38a result, the taxpayer is forced to file a court
- 29:41action having not seen the board's findings of
- 29:45fact at all. This usually does force the board
- 29:48to issue the findings of fact, albeit late, after
- 29:53the taxpayer has filed the court action. The
- 29:55issue this raises is whether the findings, because
- 29:58issued late and only after the taxpayer filed
- 30:02the court action, would be considered deficient
- 30:05or not having met the standards under section
- 30:081611 .5. This is still a developing issue. There
- 30:12are several pending cases that deal with this.
- 30:15And so we'll have to wait and see how the course
- 30:17decided. But that's something we're seeing now.
- 30:21I said there were two ways to recover fees under
- 30:241611 .6, so that was the first. The second one
- 30:28is the fees may be recovered where the board
- 30:31does in fact issue the findings of fact and there's
- 30:35no issue with the timeliness of the findings,
- 30:38but the findings are so deficient that the court
- 30:41remands the case back. to the assessment appeals
- 30:44board to make new findings that reasonably comply
- 30:47with the requirements of section 1611 .5. In
- 30:52other words, the findings fail to fairly disclose
- 30:55the board's determination of all material points.
- 30:58And as a result, the court remands the matter
- 31:00back to the board to make new findings. And let
- 31:04me just jump in here real quickly. You might
- 31:07be asking, well, how could a board issue findings
- 31:11that were deficient? You would think they would
- 31:14know what's required to go in those findings.
- 31:17But in fact, some counties have such very large
- 31:22backlogs of cases and so many cases. are requesting
- 31:26findings that sometimes the boards are issuing
- 31:30findings without the input or advice of counsel
- 31:33perhaps, without careful review and editing of
- 31:38the findings. We even have cases pending where
- 31:42the findings simply are unintelligible. The sentences,
- 31:46there are very important sentences, key sentences
- 31:50in a set of findings and and you can't understand
- 31:53what the sentence means. It has two potential
- 31:56meanings because a word or two or a punctuation,
- 32:00a word or two is missing, or punctuation is in
- 32:03the wrong place. And so actually this is happening
- 32:06more and more frequently and even in the major
- 32:10metropolitan counties. We're finding in those
- 32:13counties where county council writes the findings,
- 32:16and that's not true in all counties, findings
- 32:19tend to be pretty good. but in those counties
- 32:22where the assessment appeals board members are
- 32:24left to write the findings themselves and they
- 32:27don't have the benefit of county council perhaps
- 32:30or an attorney reviewing the findings sometimes
- 32:33they come out a little bit garbled and that's
- 32:35where you get these deficient findings issues
- 32:39also where maybe a board member they write the
- 32:42findings they outline them and write them and
- 32:44they overlook an issue a very important issue
- 32:47perhaps so that's how this is coming to the And
- 32:50it's coming to the fore a lot, I would say, over
- 32:52the past 10 or 12 years now. So to add to what
- 33:03Chris was saying, looking at slide 16 here, so
- 33:06what does it mean for the findings to be deficient,
- 33:09right, to allow you to recover fees here? The
- 33:13cases that I've looked at the issue have said
- 33:17It's not necessary for the findings to cover
- 33:20every evidentiary matter, but the board should
- 33:24address specifically its reasoning for accepting
- 33:27or rejecting each issue raised by the parties.
- 33:32The board's written findings of facts should
- 33:34include all legally relevant subconclusions supportive
- 33:37of its ultimate decision. The findings must enable
- 33:41the reviewing court to trace and examine the
- 33:45agency's mode of analysis. The findings must
- 33:49also tell the parties in the reviewing courts
- 33:51why the board rejects evidence other than conclusory
- 33:57terms. The findings must also set forth findings
- 34:02to bridge the analytical gap between the raw
- 34:05evidence and the ultimate decision or order of
- 34:08the board. The standard for findings is intended
- 34:13to facilitate orderly analysis and minimize the
- 34:18likelihood that the agency, the assessment appeals
- 34:22board here, is just going to leap randomly from
- 34:26evidence to conclusions without providing its
- 34:29analysis. The issue that often comes up in these
- 34:35cases is How far beyond the written findings
- 34:40of fact may you look to determine if the findings
- 34:43comply with the standard, the standard being
- 34:461611 .5? For example, are the findings sufficient
- 34:51if they don't themselves explain why the board
- 34:55decided a certain way, but the findings reference
- 34:59an adopted document in the record that provides
- 35:03that explanation? Perhaps. What if, however,
- 35:08the findings don't provide any explanation? But
- 35:12if you were to go through the record, you may
- 35:15be able to piece together a few things that could
- 35:19provide that explanation. Is that sufficient?
- 35:23Arguably not, because the cases do say the court
- 35:27should not have to go through the record to make
- 35:29sense of the findings. So this is the types of
- 35:33disputes we're seeing now in this context. One
- 35:38and other important point is that even if the
- 35:42findings are deficient and fail to meet the standard
- 35:46under section 1611 .5, that doesn't always necessarily
- 35:51entitle the taxpayer to fees. We saw this in
- 35:55the Chinese Cedars case, which explained that
- 35:58the attorney's fees are permitted where the court
- 36:01finds that the findings are deficient and remands
- 36:05the case back to the board with directions for
- 36:08the board to make findings that comply with the
- 36:10law, section 1611 .5. So you may have circumstances.
- 36:18where the findings are deficient, but the court
- 36:21may just remand it back to the board to make
- 36:25a certain change in its decision or the valuation
- 36:30that it has used and make that decision. But
- 36:33the board does not actually end up having to
- 36:36make new findings, and that would not be qualified
- 36:39for fees. I should just add here that those of
- 36:44you who do much administrative law practice and
- 36:47then take those administrative cases up into
- 36:50the courts, you might recognize some of this
- 36:53language that's in Chinese theater, Paramount,
- 36:56and SSL Landlord because They tend to follow
- 36:59the well -known Supreme Court case, the Topanga
- 37:02case. I guess Topanga versus either city or county
- 37:05of Los Angeles. The standards there have been
- 37:08brought into the property tax realm, modified
- 37:13a bit to fit the realm, but pretty much we're
- 37:16following what Topanga, the Supreme Court, has
- 37:18told us in that case. Let's move on. Let's talk
- 37:22about the next ground for seeking fees. This
- 37:27is also related to property taxes on page 17
- 37:30of the PowerPoint We could advance there we go
- 37:36This is again a two -parter. It's section 5152
- 37:40coupled with section 538 of the Reven tax code
- 37:45and here If you have an action to recover taxes
- 37:50and there's a finding that the taxes are void
- 37:53or partially void And the assessor, knowing that,
- 38:00nevertheless made the assessment, instead of
- 38:02following the procedure in 538, there's an entitlement
- 38:06to attorney's fees. Now, we need to know, well,
- 38:09what does 538 say? So let's take a look at the
- 38:12next page, page 18 here. Section 538 of the R
- 38:17&T Code says, if the assessor believes believes
- 38:20is the key word here, that a provision of the
- 38:24Constitution or a regulation or a statute is
- 38:27unconstitutional or invalid and either assesses
- 38:32or adopts an interpretation of that that causes
- 38:37an improper assessment instead of having brought
- 38:41a declaratory relief action, then there's an
- 38:44entitlement to fees. In other words, the assessor
- 38:48can't employ the law that he thinks is illegal
- 38:52if, in fact, he didn't first seek a deck relief
- 38:57in the courts for determination of the legality
- 39:01of that statute or that regulation, or I would
- 39:04assert that court decision. The page 19 has the
- 39:12key elements of these two statutes when read
- 39:14together. The assessor should have followed.
- 39:18The assessment is void. Of course, we're talking
- 39:21about any statute, regulation, or constitutional
- 39:24provision, and bring in action for declaratory
- 39:28relief. But the key element in this 5152 -538
- 39:34approach is the assessor believes. Such a broad
- 39:42standard, and as you can imagine, it's engendered
- 39:45a lot of litigation to try to determine what
- 39:48does assessors believe mean, or assessor believes
- 39:52mean. The next page summarizes some of the next
- 39:56couple of pages, the jurisprudence on this. In
- 40:00the SSL landlord case, they said, well, we have
- 40:04to look at the assessors subjective state of
- 40:09mind as shown by his statements on the record
- 40:12or objective facts. And we're going to distinguish
- 40:16between when the assessor believes the law is
- 40:19invalid and when he simply misinterprets it or
- 40:22misapplies it. Now we're beginning to get kind
- 40:25of toward a fine line. The Phillips case maybe
- 40:28was more helpful to us. He says the assessor
- 40:32believes means the mental state of the assessor,
- 40:36and this gets quoted again and again, cognitive
- 40:39decision on the part of the assessor that the
- 40:41law is invalid on its face or as applied and
- 40:45that misreading or misunderstanding the law is
- 40:47not enough to support an award of fees. Now,
- 40:51there's some more case I'm going to get to those
- 40:53in a minute. The question really comes down to,
- 40:57and I often say, we need to look at the testimony
- 41:01of the assessor and in our In our proceeding
- 41:06before the administrative board, before the tax
- 41:09tribunal, we need to ask these questions if we
- 41:12think the assessor doesn't believe that a rule
- 41:14is correct, doesn't believe that a statute is
- 41:17correct or some provision of law is not correct.
- 41:21And to directly ask the assessor, do you believe
- 41:24that this property tax rule is unconstitutional?
- 41:28Do you believe that this statutory provision
- 41:31is in conflict with other statutory provisions?
- 41:35Do you believe this statute is unconstitutional?
- 41:39Do you believe that this rule is in conflict
- 41:41with other law? Do you believe that the assessor's
- 41:45office should not follow this rule? And I bring
- 41:50that up because if we turn to the next page,
- 41:53in the Prudential case, this is what happened.
- 41:56The assessor actually testified, I believe property
- 42:00tax rule four is invalid. Now, I'm sure that
- 42:05his attorney was sitting there or the assessor's
- 42:08representative cringed at the moment that that
- 42:12appraiser said that during the hearing. But that's
- 42:16the standard that we've kind of been held to
- 42:19is, is there an affirmative statement by the
- 42:23assessor on the record? And that's why we ask
- 42:25during these hearings, when we see a legal provision
- 42:28is that issue, do you believe that this is incorrect?
- 42:32The most interesting case is probably Ocean Avenue,
- 42:36where the assessor's office, the assessor's witnesses
- 42:39didn't testify that it was unconstitutional or
- 42:43illegal. They simply kept saying that the property
- 42:46tax rule on which the taxpayer relied was just
- 42:50too good to be true. The assessor's attorney
- 42:53said, it's too good to be true. It can't possibly
- 42:56be right. And the assessor's witnesses says,
- 42:58yes, it's just too good to be true. They can't
- 43:01possibly get that kind of result. And of course,
- 43:04it went up to the Court of Appeal and the Court
- 43:06of Appeal said, look, we can read between the
- 43:08lines. When the assessor said, it's too good
- 43:10to be true, he meant that statute is illegal,
- 43:14that statute conflicts with the Constitution
- 43:16and other statutes. There is a limit to this,
- 43:24and it's unfortunate it came in the land partner's
- 43:26case. This limitation doesn't apply because the
- 43:30assessor does not apply a well -settled rule
- 43:34or a well -settled law that's unambiguous. And
- 43:39that's too bad because we are now at the point
- 43:42in some of our jurisprudence in the tax proceedings
- 43:46in the property tax world where The assessors
- 43:49will not blatantly say that the statute is unconstitutional
- 43:53or illegal or a regulation is violative of a
- 43:57statute. They'll simply say, we're not going
- 44:00to follow that. And I believe that no one has
- 44:04yet done this, but we really need a precedent
- 44:07where the assessor says that and a court says,
- 44:11when you say, I'm not going to follow that, what
- 44:14you mean is you think it's illegal or unconstitutional.
- 44:17We haven't reached that point yet, but that would
- 44:19really be helpful in where we are right now in
- 44:23our property tax jurisprudence. I'm going to
- 44:28turn it now over to Ruben to talk about the private
- 44:31attorney general action way of approaching recovery
- 44:35of attorney's fees. So let's look at Code of
- 44:40Civil. Procedure section 1021 .5 and as Chris
- 44:46noted, this is commonly referred to as a private
- 44:48attorney general fee award. And the basic objective
- 44:52here behind this doctrine is to encourage suits
- 44:56to enforce important public policies by providing
- 45:00substantial attorney fees to successful litigants.
- 45:03The doctrine recognizes that without some mechanism,
- 45:08authorizing a fee award, such private actions
- 45:11would often be unfeasible. In terms of the standard
- 45:16here, the requirements to get fees, the court
- 45:20has power to award attorney's fees to a successful
- 45:23party against one or more opposing parties and
- 45:27actions resulting in enforcement of an important
- 45:30right affecting the public interest. There has
- 45:34to be a significant benefit that is conferred
- 45:40on the general public or a large number of persons.
- 45:45So for example, the Green Farms case we'll see
- 45:49on the next slide, there the plaintiff compelled
- 45:52the city of Los Angeles to follow its own municipal
- 45:55code instead of an internal document. in terms
- 45:59of classifying taxpayers for purposes of its
- 46:02business tax. And this affected a large number
- 46:05of taxpayers within the city. And the benefit
- 46:12to the public in general does not have to be
- 46:15the primary benefit that's sought. by the litigant
- 46:18in the case, and the fact that the litigant has
- 46:22other motivations of private interest, that too
- 46:26is not dispositive. The standard is whether the
- 46:29action resulted in the enforcement of an important
- 46:32right affecting the public interest. Next, there's
- 46:39the necessity and financial burden of private
- 46:43enforcement. are such as to make a fee award
- 46:47appropriate. So in terms of the financial burden
- 46:51piece, this essentially looks at whether the
- 46:54cost of pursuing the case outweighs the litigants
- 46:58personal stake in the case. In other words, does
- 47:03pursuing the case place a burden on the plaintiff?
- 47:08And lastly, the interests of justice require
- 47:12that such fees be paid by the opposing parties
- 47:15rather than out of the recovery obtained in the
- 47:18litigation. And again, this is sort of tied in
- 47:23with the financial burden piece as well. There's
- 47:26a lot of interplay here in terms of making this
- 47:29final determination. you have a situation where
- 47:36the cost to actually litigate a case is far more
- 47:39than what could be recovered. And in those cases,
- 47:45justice is served by recovering the fees from
- 47:48the opposing party. So we could move on to the
- 47:53next slide here. And we've got a listing of several
- 47:57cases here where BAGA fees or fees under section
- 48:021021 .5 have been recovered. This is just a very
- 48:08short listing. There are several other cases
- 48:10out there, and it's just to give you an idea
- 48:13of how broad its application is. Fees can be
- 48:19sought in various different types of tax cases.
- 48:23So with the examples here, you've got Green Farms.
- 48:27That was a Los Angeles business tax case. The
- 48:31Northwest Energetic case that involved LLC fees
- 48:36administered by the Franchise Tax Board. The
- 48:40Pacific Mutual Life Insurance Company case that
- 48:44dealt with the insurance premiums tax. And then
- 48:48the Kahanan Inc. case, that one, you know, this
- 48:53involved penalties for late filing of a hotel
- 48:57tax in San Francisco. So, you know, it has very
- 49:06broad application and there are several other
- 49:08cases and probably more than the ones I've reviewed
- 49:12that aren't listed on here. Okay, so that wraps
- 49:19up our portion of the program dealing with recovering
- 49:22attorney's fees. Ruben and I do practice quite
- 49:27a bit in front of the State Board of Equalization.
- 49:30And we wanted to give a quick update on some
- 49:34things that are happening there, which impact
- 49:38especially the property tax world. As many people
- 49:41know, oh, four or five years ago, the state board
- 49:45was stripped of its authority to handle matters
- 49:49involving sales tax. and its oversight of the
- 49:56franchise tax and those were specifically assigned
- 50:00to franchise tax board. But the state board does
- 50:03remain by constitution in charge of the property
- 50:08tax in California and has oversight in that area.
- 50:12There are two projects currently ongoing before
- 50:15the state board relating to that oversight authority.
- 50:19The first project which they're having actually
- 50:22a meeting today in Sacramento to discuss is improving
- 50:25the local assessment appeals board process or
- 50:28proceedings. There are really, I guess, three
- 50:34primary parts to that that are going on right
- 50:36now. One is the dealing with assessment appeals
- 50:39board recruitment and training. Board members
- 50:46are usually lay people. There is a problem in
- 50:50some counties of getting enough people to serve
- 50:52on the boards. There are now boards in several,
- 50:57not several, at least a couple counties in Northern
- 50:59California that cannot get enough people to serve
- 51:02on the board, and they're trying to figure out
- 51:04what to do about that. And that has to do with,
- 51:08well, can you change the training or the standards
- 51:10requirements? They're even looking about, could
- 51:13they, looking into the possibility of having
- 51:16board members in one county ride circuit in other
- 51:19counties that don't have boards or don't have
- 51:22an adequate number of board members. And there's
- 51:25another proposal on the table, which Ruben is
- 51:27going to talk about in a minute, which might
- 51:29also deal with this or solve this problem. The
- 51:32second item they're dealing with right now in
- 51:34Sacramento is in this area is the application
- 51:37form itself. There is some move amongst the county
- 51:41clerks to handle property tax matters to simplify
- 51:45or modify the assessment appeal application considerably.
- 51:49I think that would cause some issues, but that
- 51:52is currently on the table and being debated by
- 51:54before the state board of equalization even today.
- 51:58And the third is probably related to the first
- 52:01issue. And that is dealing with excessive postponements
- 52:05and continuance requests in these assessment
- 52:07appeals proceedings. which is why the backlogs
- 52:10in some of the counties, the backlogs of appeals
- 52:13to be heard are very, very large. In LA County,
- 52:17just a few years ago, there were over 40 ,000
- 52:19appeals pending. I understand that that's now
- 52:22down well below 20 ,000. But part of the problem
- 52:26is the scheduling issues they're having. And
- 52:29then discovery that goes on in these proceedings,
- 52:32which is also causing a lot of delays. The state
- 52:37board's project here is to gather information
- 52:40from assessors, county clerks, and industry or
- 52:46taxpayer organizations, and then they're hoping
- 52:48to come up with either guidance in the form of
- 52:51letters to assessors, or they may even modify
- 52:54some of their property tax rules to deal with
- 52:57these issues. They're considering No, any kind
- 53:02of option that's available to the board to provide
- 53:06guidance to assessors and to the taxpayer public.
- 53:10The other project that's going on right now was
- 53:13initiated by Malia Cohen, our state controller,
- 53:17and the board agreed to go forward with an intangibles
- 53:20project. The purpose of that is to going to be,
- 53:24as I understand it, to summarize the current
- 53:29state of the law as relating to intangibles in
- 53:33the property tax context, provide guidance on
- 53:37what are intangibles, and then to provide guidance
- 53:40on how do you value intangibles. And I've been
- 53:42in the intangibles area for 30 years now. There's
- 53:47a lot of case law. There's statutes out there.
- 53:50There's some state board guidance. I think the
- 53:53idea is to bring it all into one place and allow
- 53:56for guidance that's going to benefit assessors
- 53:59and taxpayers in the long run and make it easy
- 54:03to get your hands around this topic. And I'm
- 54:06going to turn it over to Ruben to talk about
- 54:08the last thing that's going on, which I think
- 54:09is in some ways related. Yeah, so this is assembly
- 54:15bill 2172. This was introduced only, I think,
- 54:19about a week ago, and it goes to Chris's point
- 54:25about the boards, the equalization boards being
- 54:30overwhelmed, not having enough board members
- 54:34trying to work through the backlog and. Before
- 54:40we just essentially, they're looking to do one
- 54:44person property tax appeals boards. I think it's
- 54:50important to look at the existing law for a moment.
- 54:54What we have now is that the county board of
- 54:58supervisors are authorized to create assessment
- 55:01appeals boards that have three members. And there
- 55:07are certain minimum qualifications for these
- 55:10members, and that includes that they have to
- 55:13have a minimum of five years of experience in
- 55:17California in one of several areas, and that
- 55:20could be a CPA, a licensed real estate broker,
- 55:24an attorney, or a property appraiser. So with
- 55:29this proposal under AB 2172, It essentially allows
- 55:35to have single member appeals boards where an
- 55:40assessment appeals commissioner would hear the
- 55:43property tax appeals. In order to actually allow
- 55:49for this to occur, the individual counties would
- 55:54have to adopt an ordinance to allow the single
- 55:57member boards. And the ordinance may provide
- 56:03that all appeals be heard by an assessment appeals
- 56:07commissioner, so a single member board. So it
- 56:12is possible that counties can do away with the
- 56:16three -member assessment appeals board, at least
- 56:19under the current language of what's been proposed.
- 56:23Although the bill does also state that the proposal
- 56:27is meant to supplement and not replace the authority
- 56:30of counties to appoint the traditional three
- 56:33-member boards that we're used to. So theoretically,
- 56:38you can have both the single -member and the
- 56:40three -member boards within the county, and I
- 56:43think it would depend on what each county decides
- 56:45to do. With these single member boards, the commissioners
- 56:50must also meet certain minimum qualifications,
- 56:52and these are similar to what we have for the
- 56:55three member boards, except we don't have that
- 56:58minimum five -year requirement here. And the
- 57:04stated reason for the proposal is that it will
- 57:07increase the timeliness, consistency and legal
- 57:10rigor. of property tax appeals determinations
- 57:14while preserving due process and public accountability.
- 57:18I should also note that it's got a limited operative
- 57:22period. It's currently proposed to be effective
- 57:26as of January 1 of 2027 and would sunset on January
- 57:321 of 2034. So it has limited application. But
- 57:37as I'm sure we've all seen with other laws, the
- 57:42legislature does often extend these things. So
- 57:47the bill was just introduced recently. We have
- 57:52yet to see how it's going to work through the
- 57:54process, what sorts of changes. We'll see if
- 57:56it'll even survive. So it's still too early to
- 57:59tell. I'll stop here. I know we're getting toward
- 58:05the end of the session here, so I'll turn it
- 58:10back over to Howard now. Howard, you're muted.
- 58:21Thank you. Thank you, Chris. Thank you, Ruben.
- 58:23It's always wonderful to have people who are
- 58:26so well versed in the subject matter to present
- 58:28to us and have so much experience in doing these
- 58:31things over the years and even up to date as
- 58:33to what's going on at the State Board of Equalization
- 58:36and appreciate all of your wisdom, because obviously,
- 58:40in some of these cases, the attorney's fees are
- 58:42really a major issue in terms of what's happening.
- 58:46And thank you again for joining us this year.
- 58:48And thank you to everyone who attended and for
- 58:51all of those who tuned in to listen to this at
- 58:53a later time. Thank you. And thank you to the
- 58:55Beverly Hills Bar for all the administrative
- 58:58help. Bye -bye. Thank you. Thank you.