Latest / Bloomberg Law / Presidential Immunity in Question, Public Officials and Social Media, Legal Hot Tubs
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law.
- 0:03Speaker 2: What does a prosecutor have to prove in order to
- 0:06Speaker 2: get a rico conviction? Tell us why the Solicitor General
- 0:10Speaker 2: is sometimes referred to as the tenth Justice.
- 0:12Speaker 1: Interviews with prominent attorneys in Bloomberg Legal Experts.
- 0:15Speaker 2: That's Jennifer k for Bloomberg Law. Joining me is former
- 0:18Speaker 2: federal prosecutor Robert miss.
- 0:20Speaker 1: And analysis of important legal issues, cases and headlines.
- 0:23Speaker 2: It's the toughest hurdle for prosecutors proving Trump's intent. Alito
- 0:27Speaker 2: took on Congress, saying Congress has no power to regulate
- 0:30Speaker 2: the Supreme Court.
- 0:31Speaker 1: Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:38Speaker 2: Welcome to a special best of edition of the Bloomberg
- 0:40Speaker 2: Law Show. Ahead in this hour, Donald Trump looks for
- 0:44Speaker 2: a get out of jail free card. The Supreme Court
- 0:47Speaker 2: grapples with whether public officials can block citizens on social
- 0:51Speaker 2: media and what exactly is a legal hot tub.
- 0:57Speaker 3: That's what makes these cases hard is that there are
- 0:59Speaker 3: First Commendment interests all over the place.
- 1:01Speaker 2: And not only are their First Amendment interests all over
- 1:04Speaker 2: the place, as Justice Elena Kagan put it, but the
- 1:08Speaker 2: justices questions seemed to be all over the place, as
- 1:11Speaker 2: well as they considered whether public officials can block citizens
- 1:16Speaker 2: on social media. The two cases involved school board members
- 1:20Speaker 2: in San Diego and a city manager in Michigan who
- 1:23Speaker 2: blocked followers on social media, of course, evoking discussion of
- 1:27Speaker 2: former President Donald Trump's efforts to block people from his
- 1:31Speaker 2: Twitter account.
- 1:32Speaker 3: I mean, I don't think a citizen would be able
- 1:34Speaker 3: to really understand the Trump presidency, if you will, without
- 1:39Speaker 3: any access to all the things that the president said
- 1:43Speaker 3: on that account. It was an important part of how
- 1:46Speaker 3: he wielded his authority. And to cut a citizen off
- 1:51Speaker 3: from that is to cut a citizen off from part
- 1:54Speaker 3: of the way that government works.
- 1:56Speaker 2: The central question is whether the social media activity constitute
- 2:00Speaker 2: state action, making it subject to the First Amendment, and
- 2:04Speaker 2: the federal appellate courts in the cases came to opposite conclusions.
- 2:09Speaker 2: The Justice has presented a host of social media scenarios
- 2:13Speaker 2: to the lawyers. Here are Justices Sonya Sotomayor and Brett Kavanaugh.
- 2:18Speaker 4: So let's assume a mayor says, I'm setting up a
- 2:22Speaker 4: hotline for emergencies on my Facebook or Twitter, and if
- 2:30Speaker 4: you have an emergency, call that hotline, and I will
- 2:34Speaker 4: use the power of my office to set in motion
- 2:39Speaker 4: government response for your emergency. Seems to me that that's
- 2:45Speaker 4: government faction, isn't it.
- 2:47Speaker 5: But suppose the city manager on the personal site says
- 2:52Speaker 5: we have new recycling rules. You have to use a
- 2:54Speaker 5: blue bin, has to be at the curb. We'll be
- 2:57Speaker 5: picked up on Wednesdays. If you have any questions, contacts me.
- 3:01Speaker 5: That's only on the personal site, not on the official site.
- 3:05Speaker 5: Such state action.
- 3:06Speaker 2: Joining me is Professor Eric Golman, co director of the
- 3:09Speaker 2: High Tech Law Institute at Santa Clara University Law School.
- 3:14Speaker 2: Eric explained the main issue in these cases.
- 3:17Speaker 6: The core issue is what should happen when government officials
- 3:22Speaker 6: maintain social media accounts. Can they treat it as if
- 3:26Speaker 6: they're ordinary citizens or are they governed by the rules
- 3:30Speaker 6: that apply to government generally?
- 3:32Speaker 2: And are the issues in the two cases before the
- 3:35Speaker 2: court basically the same?
- 3:37Speaker 6: They're basically the same. There are little details about exactly
- 3:40Speaker 6: how the particular government officials were using their social medi
- 3:44Speaker 6: accounts that might matter to the final conclusion, but the
- 3:48Speaker 6: core questions the court's asking and the legal test it's
- 3:51Speaker 6: likely to adopt are probably going to be the same.
- 3:54Speaker 2: So let's talk about the concerns of some of the justices,
- 3:58Speaker 2: and Justice Elena Kagan said there are First Amendment interests
- 4:01Speaker 2: all over the place.
- 4:03Speaker 6: I thought that was a really great line, honestly, just
- 4:05Speaker 6: as Kaigan has just such a great way of turning phrases.
- 4:08Speaker 6: And she's absolutely right there First Amendment considerations on all sides.
- 4:13Speaker 6: It's not like there's an easy path forward that balances
- 4:17Speaker 6: all the respective interests. On the one hand, people who
- 4:19Speaker 6: work for the government should be free to engage their
- 4:22Speaker 6: communities and express themselves publicly as private citizens. That's the
- 4:27Speaker 6: constitutionally protected right. They don't give up that right by
- 4:30Speaker 6: going to work for the government. On the other hand,
- 4:32Speaker 6: when the government controls online discourse spaces where people are
- 4:38Speaker 6: talking to each other, there's a really real and significant
- 4:43Speaker 6: risk of censorship. And so the concern is that if
- 4:47Speaker 6: the government officials can act like private individuals, they can
- 4:51Speaker 6: functionally censor conversations. Now, if they're acting as a private individual,
- 4:55Speaker 6: they're allowed to do that, but after the government they're not.
- 4:58Speaker 6: And so either we're going to circumscribe the free speech
- 5:02Speaker 6: rights of government employees, or we're going to allow government
- 5:05Speaker 6: employees to circumspend the free speech rights of the people
- 5:09Speaker 6: who want to engage with them. Somebody is going to
- 5:11Speaker 6: lose something here.
- 5:13Speaker 2: Yeah, so Trump came up naturally, and just as Elena
- 5:16Speaker 2: Kagan said, Trump was conducting a lot of government on
- 5:19Speaker 2: his Twitter account. It's an important part of how he
- 5:22Speaker 2: wielded his authority. And to cut a citizen off from
- 5:24Speaker 2: that is to cut a citizen off from part of
- 5:27Speaker 2: the way the government works. And in these local cases,
- 5:31Speaker 2: it's just as important for constituents to hear what their
- 5:35Speaker 2: school board members are saying, or their town managers and
- 5:39Speaker 2: the like.
- 5:40Speaker 6: It's not just to be able to hear what the
- 5:42Speaker 6: government officials are saying, but also to be able to
- 5:45Speaker 6: talk back to them, and even more importantly, in certain circumstances,
- 5:49Speaker 6: be able to talk to each other as constituents or
- 5:52Speaker 6: as citizens that are responding to the posting of a
- 5:56Speaker 6: government official. And so when a government official exercised some
- 6:00Speaker 6: of the tools that provide them via social media to
- 6:03Speaker 6: control conversations, what they're really doing is distorting the conversation
- 6:07Speaker 6: that citizens might want to have with each other.
- 6:10Speaker 2: So I don't know why. To me, it seems like,
- 6:13Speaker 2: you know, if you're posting public information on a website,
- 6:17Speaker 2: on a Facebook page that that should be open to
- 6:21Speaker 2: the public and the public able to comment, and if
- 6:24Speaker 2: you want not to do that, then have a private
- 6:27Speaker 2: page as well.
- 6:28Speaker 6: So certainly those ideas came out. In fact, there are
- 6:31Speaker 6: three different categories of pages that a government official might have.
- 6:35Speaker 6: They may have an official government page. They may have
- 6:39Speaker 6: a campaign page, which is not part of their official
- 6:42Speaker 6: government duties but still is an important place for them
- 6:45Speaker 6: to evangelize the work they're doing. And they may have
- 6:48Speaker 6: a personal page that has nothing to do with their
- 6:51Speaker 6: role in government. And figuring out which account is in
- 6:55Speaker 6: which category is something that is baffling to us as
- 6:58Speaker 6: citizens when we see our government officials online. And it's
- 7:02Speaker 6: also vaccine to the government officials because so often they
- 7:05Speaker 6: want to take their victory labs, they want to evangelize
- 7:08Speaker 6: their work, to tout their successes, and we aren't sure
- 7:11Speaker 6: are they telling them as official government policy, as a
- 7:14Speaker 6: campaign promise, or just because they're touting their own work
- 7:18Speaker 6: as a private individual. And the court didn't know how
- 7:21Speaker 6: to approach that issue. They understood the trade offs, but
- 7:25Speaker 6: there was no clear way to move forward that was
- 7:27Speaker 6: going to satisfy everybody.
- 7:29Speaker 2: So I want to get your reaction to what just
- 7:31Speaker 2: as Amy Cony Barrett said.
- 7:33Speaker 7: I think it's very difficult when you have an official
- 7:37Speaker 7: who can, in some sense define his own authority. So
- 7:39Speaker 7: I think for a governor or President Trump, it's a
- 7:43Speaker 7: harder call than someone like a police officer who's a subordinator.
- 7:46Speaker 7: I could you know, my lucker could just start posting
- 7:50Speaker 7: things and say this is the official business of the
- 7:52Speaker 7: Barrett Chambers right, and that wouldn't be okay. But if
- 7:56Speaker 7: you know that wouldn't be okay.
- 8:02Speaker 2: That come and got a laugh, of course, But what
- 8:04Speaker 2: do you think about the content of what she's saying.
- 8:08Speaker 6: I mean, the example she gave was kind of weird
- 8:12Speaker 6: because a clerk wouldn't be likely to be able to
- 8:14Speaker 6: set up and speak on behalf of their judge that
- 8:17Speaker 6: employed them. So that was a weird example. But the
- 8:20Speaker 6: broader principle is one hundred percent correct that the court
- 8:24Speaker 6: is trying to figure out how do they simultaneously govern
- 8:27Speaker 6: the top of the political hierarchy, like a president or
- 8:32Speaker 6: a governor or even a mayor, someone who's at the
- 8:35Speaker 6: top of the organizational Peermid and all the people who
- 8:38Speaker 6: are rank and fly all government employees, some of whom
- 8:41Speaker 6: might also be able to speak on behalf of the government,
- 8:43Speaker 6: others of whom have no real legitimacy to do so.
- 8:47Speaker 6: And the Supreme Court is struggling figure out how can
- 8:49Speaker 6: we come up with one rule that covers all of
- 8:51Speaker 6: those different types of job, responsibilities and status in the hierarchy.
- 8:56Speaker 6: And it's possible that they cannot come up with a
- 8:58Speaker 6: single rule that will govern It may need multiple rules
- 9:01Speaker 6: that will have to be iterated over time.
- 9:02Speaker 2: So you think that there's no clear legal test that
- 9:05Speaker 2: they could come out with.
- 9:06Speaker 6: Honestly, no, there is no clear legal test. And I
- 9:09Speaker 6: think we can be a little bit more emphatic that
- 9:12Speaker 6: the different considerations include things like what's the employee's job,
- 9:17Speaker 6: and what tools are available in social media to be
- 9:21Speaker 6: able to control conversations and which of those tools was wielded,
- 9:24Speaker 6: and how did the person describe or characterize their account
- 9:28Speaker 6: and how much of the account was used with official
- 9:32Speaker 6: related postings versus personal postings, like we need a multi
- 9:36Speaker 6: dimensional matrix to try to figure out where to place
- 9:39Speaker 6: all the different nodes in those questions. And that's why,
- 9:43Speaker 6: even with two cases in front of the Supreme Court
- 9:45Speaker 6: that they can use to compare and contrast. They still
- 9:47Speaker 6: don't have enough cases to cover the full range of
- 9:50Speaker 6: facts that are going to be implicated by their ruling.
- 9:53Speaker 2: Coming up, we'll discuss whether there was any consensus on
- 9:56Speaker 2: the Court. I'm Jim Grosso. When you're listening to Bloomberg, This.
- 10:07Speaker 1: Is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 10:12Speaker 2: You're listening to a special best of edition of the
- 10:15Speaker 2: Bloomberg Law Show. Joining me is Professor Eric Goldman of
- 10:19Speaker 2: Santa Clara University Law School about Supreme Court oral arguments
- 10:23Speaker 2: over whether public officials can be sued for restricting access
- 10:28Speaker 2: to their social media feeds. It's the first of several
- 10:31Speaker 2: social media classes this term. The first case involves two
- 10:35Speaker 2: San Diego Area school board members who set up Facebook
- 10:39Speaker 2: and Twitter pages during their twenty fourteen campaigns, then continued
- 10:44Speaker 2: using the sites to talk about school issues after winning
- 10:47Speaker 2: election and taking their seats. They set up their pages
- 10:50Speaker 2: so that their posts were open to comment by members
- 10:53Speaker 2: of the public. Two of their constituents left frequent comments
- 10:57Speaker 2: criticizing the board, and the school board members eventually blocked them.
- 11:02Speaker 2: The second case involves a city manager in Michigan who
- 11:06Speaker 2: used his Facebook page to post both family and professional information.
- 11:11Speaker 2: His posts in twenty twenty about the COVID nineteen pandemic
- 11:15Speaker 2: drew a series of critical comments from a follower, who
- 11:18Speaker 2: he then blocked. Federal appeals courts reached opposite decisions in
- 11:23Speaker 2: the cases, and now it's up to the Supreme Court.
- 11:26Speaker 2: So how about the idea that was floated by Justice
- 11:29Speaker 2: Katanji Brown Jackson of a clear disclaimer indicating that government
- 11:34Speaker 2: officials were posting on social media in their personal capacity
- 11:38Speaker 2: or I guess vice versa, in their government capacity.
- 11:41Speaker 6: Certainly, no doubt that legends would help, at least us
- 11:44Speaker 6: as constituents know what to expect. But the disclaimers could
- 11:49Speaker 6: just be another form of a manipulation by the government official.
- 11:53Speaker 6: They could say I'm not speaking officially, but then speaking
- 11:55Speaker 6: ways that actually are fully official, or vice versa. They
- 11:58Speaker 6: could say, this official government account, but let me highlight
- 12:01Speaker 6: some of my personal attributes and treat them as if
- 12:04Speaker 6: they're a part of the government responsibility. And so the
- 12:08Speaker 6: disclaimer doesn't really solve the problems that I think we have.
- 12:13Speaker 6: But no doubt that if somebody portrays their account as
- 12:18Speaker 6: an official government account without trying to walk it back
- 12:22Speaker 6: or qualify that. I think the rules should be that
- 12:26Speaker 6: we should hold them to that approach. But if they
- 12:29Speaker 6: don't officially represent as part of their government account, it
- 12:32Speaker 6: still might be part of their government function, and so
- 12:35Speaker 6: the disclaimer is not going to be complete.
- 12:37Speaker 2: The Buiden administration was backing the government officials' positions. They
- 12:42Speaker 2: characterized the Facebook and Twitter feeds as private property. That
- 12:47Speaker 2: seemed to me to be a not a great concept here.
- 12:51Speaker 6: It's a really awkward conversation because we know that the
- 12:55Speaker 6: social media services have their own rules, they have their
- 12:59Speaker 6: own technological options that differ amongst themselves, and they have
- 13:06Speaker 6: the ability to intervene with respective particulars and content irrespective
- 13:11Speaker 6: of whether or not the Constitution would permit the government
- 13:13Speaker 6: official take that action. So they're like the elephant in
- 13:16Speaker 6: the room. Everyone knows that the social media services are
- 13:19Speaker 6: an integal player in this conversation, but they're not the
- 13:22Speaker 6: plaintiff or the defendant, and as a result, they're not
- 13:26Speaker 6: actually represented in this litigation, and as a result, the
- 13:30Speaker 6: Supreme Court is likely to treat them as this opaque
- 13:34Speaker 6: third party player who is immaterial or inconsequential to the rules.
- 13:39Speaker 6: That's actually a good outcome. I really don't want the
- 13:41Speaker 6: Supreme Court talking about social media as a private entity
- 13:46Speaker 6: or not. I don't want them making hard lines when
- 13:48Speaker 6: that's not the question the government has to answer. But
- 13:51Speaker 6: it's impossible to ignore the shadow of the cast over
- 13:54Speaker 6: everything that takes place on their services.
- 13:57Speaker 2: The federal appeals courts reached opposite conclusions in the lower
- 14:01Speaker 2: court cases.
- 14:03Speaker 6: That's correct. The Ninth Circuit held that the government officials
- 14:06Speaker 6: in that case, school board members were acting in their
- 14:10Speaker 6: function as government officials when they blocked some constituents from
- 14:14Speaker 6: accessant and social media acount. In the sixth Circuit, it
- 14:18Speaker 6: was a government employee who had also blocked individuals. The
- 14:22Speaker 6: court had held in that case that he was acting
- 14:24Speaker 6: as a private individual that was his private account.
- 14:27Speaker 2: So there were three hours, I believe, of oral arguments.
- 14:31Speaker 2: Did you see some justices, some blocks of justices sort
- 14:36Speaker 2: of coming to some conclusions or did you see any patterns?
- 14:42Speaker 6: The short answer is no, Really, the oral arguments were
- 14:46Speaker 6: quite opaque about where the judges are likely to end up,
- 14:48Speaker 6: which is unusual. But one would have hoped that we
- 14:51Speaker 6: would have been able to get a clearer line from
- 14:53Speaker 6: the oral arguments, having said that, there are two things
- 14:55Speaker 6: that stood out to me. First is that some justices
- 14:58Speaker 6: seem to be gravit attaining to of the test that
- 15:00Speaker 6: was advocated by the Department of Justice and was endorsed
- 15:05Speaker 6: by the lawyers for the government employees about looking at
- 15:09Speaker 6: the duties of the government official and their authority to
- 15:12Speaker 6: speak on behalf of the government. And so Justice gore Such,
- 15:14Speaker 6: for example, at one point said it sounds like we
- 15:17Speaker 6: got consensus that's the right test. I don't know if
- 15:20Speaker 6: there was consensus, but it wouldn't surprise me if the
- 15:23Speaker 6: test looked something like that. At the end of the
- 15:26Speaker 6: oral arguments, Justice Kagan once again had a really powerful
- 15:29Speaker 6: turn of the phrase. She came and basically blasted the
- 15:33Speaker 6: government lawyers, saying that the government lawyers proposed test was
- 15:37Speaker 6: really out of sync with the importance of social media
- 15:41Speaker 6: to the government function and would limit the ability of
- 15:45Speaker 6: us as constituents or to be able to defend our
- 15:47Speaker 6: own interests when the government keeps embracing social media. So
- 15:51Speaker 6: I saw kind of two opposite approaches there, Justice Gorsuch saying,
- 15:55Speaker 6: you know, sounds good to me. Let's go with the
- 15:57Speaker 6: test that you proposed, and Justice Keag is saying that
- 15:59Speaker 6: test is actual really harmful to the future.
- 16:02Speaker 2: Was there a split on ideological lines or did this
- 16:05Speaker 2: cross ideological lines?
- 16:07Speaker 6: I couldn't put together a pattern that represented any kind
- 16:10Speaker 6: of ideological partisan fit. But having said that, I would
- 16:14Speaker 6: say that it seemed like some of the quote more
- 16:17Speaker 6: conservative justices were more inclined to support the government employees'
- 16:21Speaker 6: freedom to do what they want, whereas some of the
- 16:24Speaker 6: quote more liberal justices were more skeptical about how that
- 16:27Speaker 6: could lead to censorship.
- 16:28Speaker 2: So at times when we've had these oral arguments at
- 16:32Speaker 2: the Supreme Court involving, you know, the Internet, texting, social media,
- 16:37Speaker 2: the justices have seemed to be a step behind, maybe
- 16:41Speaker 2: more than one step. Did it seem like they fully
- 16:44Speaker 2: grasped what was going on in these cases?
- 16:47Speaker 6: They really didn't. This was yet another example of how
- 16:50Speaker 6: the Internet baffles Supreme Court justices. And just to be clear,
- 16:54Speaker 6: we don't know how many Supreme Court justices spend time
- 16:57Speaker 6: on social media, but it's not like they do it publicly,
- 17:01Speaker 6: So they're just not familiar with social media the same
- 17:05Speaker 6: degree that most of us, as everyday users are, So
- 17:08Speaker 6: it's not surprising that it's a little bit baffling to
- 17:10Speaker 6: them that they're not immersed in that as part of
- 17:12Speaker 6: their daily functions. But there was a really awkward line
- 17:15Speaker 6: that came from Chief Justice Roberts where he talked about
- 17:18Speaker 6: social media and described it as the gathering of protons,
- 17:22Speaker 6: And it was such a reductionist approach that social media
- 17:26Speaker 6: is just about the movement of electronic pulses on the Internet.
- 17:29Speaker 6: That's all it is. And it's kind of like saying
- 17:31Speaker 6: that Supreme Court of opinions are just inc on a
- 17:35Speaker 6: piece of paper. It's a reductionist conclusion that isn't inherently wrong,
- 17:40Speaker 6: but it completely misunderstands the scope and the stakes at
- 17:43Speaker 6: issue in this case.
- 17:45Speaker 2: And this is the first of several social media clashes
- 17:50Speaker 2: that coming up this term involving the First Amendment and
- 17:53Speaker 2: how it applies to social media companies.
- 17:55Speaker 6: So just to be clear, there's going to be a
- 17:58Speaker 6: steady stream of Internet law cases is going to the
- 18:00Speaker 6: Supreme Court and likely to be decided by the Supreme
- 18:04Speaker 6: Court over the next few years. We've had just this
- 18:07Speaker 6: upswell of legislation trying to regulate the Internet, and many
- 18:11Speaker 6: of those laws are going to end up before the
- 18:13Speaker 6: Supreme Court. So we're just kind of at the beginning
- 18:16Speaker 6: of this multi year cycle where the Supreme Court is
- 18:19Speaker 6: going to be regularly deciding the future of the Internet.
- 18:22Speaker 6: One of the other cases they've set it or there's
- 18:25Speaker 6: two companion cases involved the Texas and Florida social media
- 18:28Speaker 6: censorship laws. These are laws that were enacted to basically
- 18:32Speaker 6: take government control over the functional operations of social media.
- 18:38Speaker 6: Sounds like the kind of thing that we would think
- 18:39Speaker 6: would be clearly censorship, and yet the Florida court said
- 18:43Speaker 6: that some of it was struck down, some of it
- 18:45Speaker 6: was okay. The Texas tele Court said it all sounds
- 18:49Speaker 6: good to me. And so the future of the Internet
- 18:51Speaker 6: is very much a stake in that set of cases
- 18:53Speaker 6: as well, because if the Supreme Court says that the
- 18:56Speaker 6: government can dictate how social media runs its operations, they
- 19:00Speaker 6: are going to be dictating what editorial decisions those services
- 19:04Speaker 6: can make.
- 19:04Speaker 2: A lot more oral arguments on social media to come.
- 19:08Speaker 2: Thanks so much, Eric. That's Eric Goldman, a professor at
- 19:12Speaker 2: Santa Clara University School of Law and co director of
- 19:15Speaker 2: the High Tech Law Institute. Coming up next, Donald Trump
- 19:19Speaker 2: looks for a get out of jail free card I'm
- 19:22Speaker 2: Jim Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 19:31Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 19:36Speaker 2: You're listening to a special best of edition of the
- 19:39Speaker 2: Bloomberg Law Show.
- 19:41Speaker 4: And did you see today that deranged Jack Smith?
- 19:45Speaker 5: He's the prosecutor.
- 19:46Speaker 3: He's a deranged person. Wants to take away my rights
- 19:50Speaker 3: under the First Amendment, wants to take away my right
- 19:52Speaker 3: of speaking freely and openly.
- 19:56Speaker 2: Donald Trump never seems to miss an opportunity to ridicule
- 19:59Speaker 2: Jack Smith, the Special Council who's bringing charges against the
- 20:03Speaker 2: former president in two cases into jurisdictions. The trial date
- 20:08Speaker 2: in DC on charges of trying to overturn the twenty
- 20:11Speaker 2: twenty election is just a few months away, but Trump
- 20:15Speaker 2: is looking for a pass by arguing he has absolute
- 20:18Speaker 2: presidential immunity, and his attorneys have asked federal Judge Tanya
- 20:22Speaker 2: Chutkin to toss out the indictment. Joining me is former
- 20:26Speaker 2: federal prosecutor Jessica Romp, a professor at Cardozo Law School.
- 20:30Speaker 2: Jessica tell us about Trump's claim of presidential immunity.
- 20:35Speaker 8: So their argument is that Trump enjoys absolute presidential immunity
- 20:41Speaker 8: from prosecution because he claims that the indictment brought by
- 20:46Speaker 8: the Social Council related to January sixth is based on
- 20:49Speaker 8: what they contend are his official acts while president. I
- 20:53Speaker 8: would submit this is the most significant motion that Trump
- 20:56Speaker 8: has filed to date in all of the cases that
- 20:58Speaker 8: are pending against him, and that the court's decisions on
- 21:01Speaker 8: this motion could establish new law regarding whether a president
- 21:05Speaker 8: is beyond the reach of the criminal law for acts
- 21:07Speaker 8: taken while president, even after he leaves the office.
- 21:11Speaker 2: What do you make of his attorney's arguments? They make
- 21:14Speaker 2: several levels of argument. Are they convincing well?
- 21:18Speaker 8: The motion is well written, and unlike some arguments we've
- 21:21Speaker 8: seen from Trump's counsel in some of the cases brought
- 21:23Speaker 8: against him, this one is well written, it's well presented,
- 21:27Speaker 8: and it does present a very important issue of law,
- 21:31Speaker 8: one that the courts will have to take seriously. No
- 21:34Speaker 8: court has ever squarely decided the question of whether a
- 21:37Speaker 8: president enjoys absolute immunity from prosecution at all, because there's
- 21:42Speaker 8: never been a precedent for criminal charges being filed against
- 21:45Speaker 8: a former president. But there are two issues that the
- 21:48Speaker 8: courts will have to address in ruling on the motion.
- 21:52Speaker 8: The first is whether, in fact presidents do enjoy absolute
- 21:56Speaker 8: immunity from criminal prosecution for acts taken during the president
- 22:00Speaker 8: vinci And if they find that there is such a
- 22:03Speaker 8: thing as absolute immunity for president from criminal prosecution, then
- 22:07Speaker 8: they would have to apply that doctrine of immunity to
- 22:11Speaker 8: the facts presented in this case. If the court told
- 22:14Speaker 8: that there is no absolute immunity for a president from
- 22:17Speaker 8: prosecution even after they leave office, then they don't necessarily
- 22:21Speaker 8: have to address this second question of whether or not
- 22:25Speaker 8: Trump's actions fall within the scope of such immunity. If
- 22:28Speaker 8: they find that there isn't such.
- 22:29Speaker 2: Immunity, Trump's attorneys say the judge should look at Trump's
- 22:34Speaker 2: actions on their face to determine if they're official, and
- 22:37Speaker 2: also that even if they were a mix of official
- 22:40Speaker 2: and campaign related, they should still be covered by the
- 22:43Speaker 2: legal shield the immunity. Do you agree with that?
- 22:47Speaker 8: So, in asking whether or not the actions fall within
- 22:50Speaker 8: the outer perimeter of the president's official responsibility, one has
- 22:55Speaker 8: to ask at what level of generality do we look
- 22:58Speaker 8: at the acts. Trump's atturns invite the court to look
- 23:01Speaker 8: at them at a very high level of generality and
- 23:04Speaker 8: say these are statements on matters of public concern in
- 23:08Speaker 8: his tweets meant his public statements. For example, at the
- 23:10Speaker 8: rally on January sixth, he is communicating with state officials
- 23:16Speaker 8: about elections and communicating with members of the Department of
- 23:20Speaker 8: Justice about whether or not the presidential election was conducted
- 23:24Speaker 8: consistent with law. At that level of generality, it's easy
- 23:28Speaker 8: to characterize his actions as within the outer perimeter of
- 23:32Speaker 8: the president functions to take care that the laws of
- 23:35Speaker 8: the United States are faithfully executed. But when you look
- 23:38Speaker 8: at a more granular level, and also in context of
- 23:43Speaker 8: all the actions that are alleged in the indictment taken together,
- 23:47Speaker 8: it's much easier to characterize them not as being within
- 23:50Speaker 8: the outer perimeter of Trump's official duties as president, but
- 23:54Speaker 8: instead as crimes or part of a course of conduct
- 23:57Speaker 8: that was a conspiracy to return the election and obstruct
- 24:01Speaker 8: the official proceedings of Congress and defraud the United States,
- 24:05Speaker 8: as alleged in the indictment. And so the case law
- 24:08Speaker 8: does hold that the court should not look into the
- 24:12Speaker 8: motives behind a particular action and instead look at the
- 24:16Speaker 8: acts objectively and whether or not they further a presidential function,
- 24:21Speaker 8: but saying that the court should not look at motives
- 24:23Speaker 8: does not mean that the court can't look at the
- 24:25Speaker 8: statements and the actions in context.
- 24:28Speaker 2: Trump's attorneys also point to his acquittal in the Senate
- 24:32Speaker 2: impeachment trial in the days after the January sixth attack
- 24:36Speaker 2: and argue that he can't be tried again after the
- 24:39Speaker 2: Senate failed to convict and remove him from office.
- 24:42Speaker 8: I do not think the court will agree with that analysis.
- 24:46Speaker 8: The language that they point to has to do with
- 24:50Speaker 8: I think the court would find whether a president could
- 24:53Speaker 8: be indicted and prosecuted while in office and if one
- 24:58Speaker 8: goes back in sitters. For example, the analysis in the
- 25:02Speaker 8: Office of Legal Council memo that was prepared initially in
- 25:06Speaker 8: nineteen seventy three during the Watergate era, which looked into
- 25:10Speaker 8: whether or not a sitting president could be subject to
- 25:13Speaker 8: prosecution while in office. That memo, which was then reaffirmed
- 25:17Speaker 8: in two thousand by the Office of Legal Counsel, essentially
- 25:20Speaker 8: held that because of separation of powers concerned primarily, a
- 25:24Speaker 8: sitting president could not be prosecuted, but instead would have
- 25:29Speaker 8: to be subject to impeachment first and removed from office
- 25:33Speaker 8: before the president would be amenable to criminal prosecution. What
- 25:37Speaker 8: Trump's lawyers are doing, in effect, is taking that same
- 25:40Speaker 8: language that provides for the impeachment of a president and
- 25:44Speaker 8: then contemplates that a president could be criminally prosecuted after
- 25:48Speaker 8: being removed from office, to say that the exclusive remedy
- 25:52Speaker 8: for a president who commits crimes while in office is
- 25:55Speaker 8: to be impeached, and that a criminal prosecution could only
- 25:59Speaker 8: follow as an additional consequence if the president had been
- 26:02Speaker 8: in fact convicted in the Senate. I think that's not
- 26:05Speaker 8: a fair reading of that language, and I don't think
- 26:07Speaker 8: a court would agree with it.
- 26:08Speaker 2: Has Judge Chuckkin ruled on an issue involving presidential immunity
- 26:13Speaker 2: before she has.
- 26:15Speaker 8: In a different context. It was a case, I believe,
- 26:17Speaker 8: involving former President Obama who had been sued by individuals,
- 26:23Speaker 8: and she held that he enjoyed absolute immunity from that
- 26:27Speaker 8: civil action against him in his individual capacity. She has
- 26:30Speaker 8: not ruled on a question of immunity from criminal prosecution
- 26:35Speaker 8: in a case that presents many of the same facts
- 26:38Speaker 8: in the civil context. Judge Meta from the DC District
- 26:42Speaker 8: Court ruled that former President Trump did not enjoy absolute
- 26:47Speaker 8: immunity from civil prosecution with respect to many of the
- 26:50Speaker 8: claims in a case that was brought by members of
- 26:52Speaker 8: Congress and members of the Capitol Police who were injured
- 26:55Speaker 8: in the January sixth ryot. That case is pending before
- 26:59Speaker 8: the DC Circuit Court of Appeals in pending since December,
- 27:03Speaker 8: and that case I think will be very instructive to
- 27:06Speaker 8: jutch Chutkin in ruling on whether or not if she
- 27:10Speaker 8: gets to the question of whether much of the conduct
- 27:12Speaker 8: alleged in the Special Council of January sixth indictment falls
- 27:15Speaker 8: within the outer perimeter of his official responsibilities. If the
- 27:19Speaker 8: DC Circuit renders an opinion holding that it does not
- 27:23Speaker 8: fall within the outer perimeter, that would be very instructive
- 27:26Speaker 8: to her if she gets to that problem. Obviously, in
- 27:28Speaker 8: the meantime, she may also find persuasive the ruling of
- 27:32Speaker 8: her fellow judge on her Court judge meta that these
- 27:34Speaker 8: actions largely did not fall within that outer perimeter.
- 27:38Speaker 2: Tump is the first former president to face a federal indictment,
- 27:42Speaker 2: So this is uncharted territory. What has the Supreme Court
- 27:46Speaker 2: ruled in the past in the area of presidential immunity.
- 27:50Speaker 8: So the Supreme Court has ruled on presidential immunity in
- 27:54Speaker 8: the context of damages, actions and civil suits. In the
- 27:58Speaker 8: most important case is a case called Nixon versus Fitzgerald,
- 28:01Speaker 8: in which the court said there is a doctrine of
- 28:04Speaker 8: absolute presidential immunity that shields the president even after he
- 28:09Speaker 8: leaves office from damage's actions brought by individuals for actions
- 28:14Speaker 8: taken within the outer perimeter of the president's official responsibilities.
- 28:20Speaker 8: The court in that case drew on precedents from the
- 28:24Speaker 8: context of other executive officials, such as prosecutors, but it
- 28:28Speaker 8: also looked to immunity doctrine that court had developed in
- 28:31Speaker 8: the context of judges, other officials whom the Court said
- 28:35Speaker 8: would if they were not provided immunity, would be potentially
- 28:38Speaker 8: subject to damage's suits.
- 28:41Speaker 2: Thanks so much for your insides, Jessica. That's Professor Jessica
- 28:44Speaker 2: Roth of Cardozo Law School. Coming up next. What is
- 28:48Speaker 2: a legal honked up? I'm Jim grossoh and you're listening
- 28:51Speaker 2: to Bloomberg.
- 28:59Speaker 1: Is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 29:05Speaker 2: You're listening to a special best of edition of the
- 29:07Speaker 2: Bloomberg Law Show. We all know what hot tubs are,
- 29:12Speaker 2: but what exactly is a legal hot tub. Well, it's
- 29:16Speaker 2: not as exciting as it may sound, and it really
- 29:19Speaker 2: has nothing to do with hot tubs. It's formally called
- 29:23Speaker 2: concurrent expert testimony or a concurrent expert evidence proceeding, and
- 29:28Speaker 2: it's like a discussion among experts, but it's not very
- 29:32Speaker 2: popular in US courts at least so far. Here to
- 29:35Speaker 2: tell us about it and how it got that name
- 29:38Speaker 2: is Bloomberg Law reporter Dan Papskin, So tell us exactly
- 29:42Speaker 2: what this legal hot tub is.
- 29:44Speaker 3: Dan.
- 29:45Speaker 9: You can kind of think of it as a debate
- 29:46Speaker 9: between experts, often economic experts, but not necessarily where instead
- 29:51Speaker 9: of one sitting on the stand in a trial or
- 29:54Speaker 9: on the pre trial hearing and getting examined and then
- 29:57Speaker 9: cross examined by one size attorneys and on the other
- 30:00Speaker 9: vote or all of the witnesses sit together before the
- 30:03Speaker 9: judge and are basically prompted to debate each other on
- 30:06Speaker 9: a series of predetermined topics or questions.
- 30:08Speaker 2: And where did they get the name hot tub for this?
- 30:11Speaker 9: Australia these originally pretty much right around the beginning of
- 30:15Speaker 9: the decade, and it was deployed originally by the Australian
- 30:19Speaker 9: Competition Tribunal that their kind of antitrust dedicated courts system
- 30:23Speaker 9: basically to get a clearer understanding of what experts we're
- 30:26Speaker 9: talking about and make them really drill down on their
- 30:29Speaker 9: agreements and their disagreements. It was pretty successful there, and
- 30:32Speaker 9: it's taken off in a bunch of other countries in Europe,
- 30:35Speaker 9: in South Africa, Canada has used it. Mostly been unpopular.
- 30:38Speaker 9: In the US. We've only found a little less than
- 30:41Speaker 9: two dozen instances of federal judges using on it. Hasn't
- 30:44Speaker 9: It hasn't taken off.
- 30:45Speaker 2: Maybe the name has something to do with that. I
- 30:47Speaker 2: know you witness one of these legal hot tubs when
- 30:50Speaker 2: federal Judge James Denado held one in San Francisco. So
- 30:54Speaker 2: tell us about that.
- 30:55Speaker 9: So Donado held this the second hot sub he's held
- 30:58Speaker 9: in this case a lawsuit alleging Google basically has anti
- 31:02Speaker 9: competitive control over the payment systems in his playstore, and
- 31:07Speaker 9: so the second hot tub was to basically determine whether
- 31:11Speaker 9: the plaintiff's experts have reached kind of valid models for
- 31:15Speaker 9: figuring out how much consumers were harmed by these playstore
- 31:20Speaker 9: policies and what the impact was on the market.
- 31:23Speaker 2: Is the judge the only one asking questions, or are
- 31:25Speaker 2: the lawyers asking questions? Is their cross talk between the experts.
- 31:30Speaker 9: There's a lot of crosstalk. It's almost exclusively Tonato asking
- 31:33Speaker 9: the questions. He allows a couple attorneys to sit with
- 31:36Speaker 9: the experts in the hot tub, but they're really only
- 31:39Speaker 9: allowed to ask questions right at the end. They they
- 31:41Speaker 9: have kind of clarifying questions for either expert. Otherwise not
- 31:45Speaker 9: a prompts one side or the other. We'll say like, yeah,
- 31:49Speaker 9: I read your report, I had this question about this,
- 31:51Speaker 9: you know, one part of the model, and then we'll
- 31:54Speaker 9: prompt the other expert to be like, do you disagree
- 31:57Speaker 9: with that? So why it got pretty heated several times
- 32:00Speaker 9: there was I don't know if you would call it yelling,
- 32:02Speaker 9: but definitely raised voices. The court reporter had to interrupt
- 32:06Speaker 9: I think three separate times because two experts in the
- 32:10Speaker 9: judge were talking over each other and she couldn't transcribe
- 32:13Speaker 9: that in real time. So it definitely is a little
- 32:15Speaker 9: more chaotic than your average court oral testimony.
- 32:18Speaker 2: Is this because the expert testimony is so complex for
- 32:23Speaker 2: the judge to understand or is it because this is quicker?
- 32:28Speaker 2: I mean, what's the real reason behind this.
- 32:30Speaker 9: The reason do not out held the hotsub was to
- 32:33Speaker 9: answer this Google motion over whether the experts should be
- 32:36Speaker 9: allowed to testify or not. And Donato told me in
- 32:39Speaker 9: an interview afterwards that it's very useful for him understanding
- 32:43Speaker 9: their testimony and their models. It is really complicated, and
- 32:46Speaker 9: that's a big reason why judges are deploying hotas that
- 32:50Speaker 9: they haven't deployed too many of them. But it's not
- 32:52Speaker 9: just about the complexity. It's also faster. Tonata said, it's
- 32:56Speaker 9: a lot cleaner compared normal expert testimony on hot tub
- 33:00Speaker 9: testimony to a game of telephone. Right, You've got the
- 33:03Speaker 9: expert on the stand, you've got their attorney questioning them,
- 33:05Speaker 9: and then you've got the judge hearing their answers. So
- 33:07Speaker 9: it's kind of filtered through what questions the attorney wants
- 33:10Speaker 9: to ask, and then how the economist in this case
- 33:13Speaker 9: answers those questions. The judge might not necessarily be getting
- 33:16Speaker 9: the exact answers they're looking for.
- 33:19Speaker 2: Well, we'll see if the use of these legal hot
- 33:21Speaker 2: tubs picks up, But I think a name change is
- 33:23Speaker 2: in order. Thanks so much, Dan, that's Bloomberg Legal reporter
- 33:27Speaker 2: Dan Paskin. This is Bloomberg Law on Bloomberg Radio. I'm
- 33:31Speaker 2: June Grosso. Stay with us. Today's top stories and global
- 33:34Speaker 2: business headlines are coming up right now