Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Through the Legal Looking Glass: BC Court Cases That Matter
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment with Michael Mulligan, with Mulligan Defence Lawyers Legally Speaking on CFAX 1070.
- 0:06Adam Stirling: Afternoon Michael, how are we doing?
- 0:09Michael Mulligan: Hey, I'm doing great.
- 0:10Michael Mulligan: Always good to be here.
- 0:11Adam Stirling: Some interesting topics on the show this week.
- 0:12Adam Stirling: I'm reading the first one.
- 0:13Adam Stirling: It says real estate disclosure form with a line through.
- 0:16Adam Stirling: It is quote still a material misrepresentation.
- 0:20Adam Stirling: What does that mean?
- 0:22Michael Mulligan: Well, really, it's a cautionary tale for anyone who's buying or selling a house.
- 0:26Michael Mulligan: So that's why I thought it'd be worth knowing about this decision that just came out from the BC Court of Appeal and the case involved a house sale right and there's a common practice although I should say it is not a legal requirement in most circumstances that there be a disclosure statement filled out by a person who's selling a house.
- 0:51Michael Mulligan: Now, there are some circumstances where disclosure statements are mandatory, like I think, with some new property, condo sales and things like that.
- 1:00Michael Mulligan: But this one deals with the sort of statement that somebody might be asked to fill out if they were selling a house, and it's a form that asks a whole bunch of questions about the property.
- 1:12Michael Mulligan: It would ask questions like are you aware of any problems with the electrical system?
- 1:17Michael Mulligan: Are you aware of any problems with the plumbing system?
- 1:19Michael Mulligan: There's an interesting question that used to be on.
- 1:22Michael Mulligan: It used to be.
- 1:23Michael Mulligan: It's been modified but it asks are you aware that the premises have never been used to grow cannabis?
- 1:27Michael Mulligan: They've added now bracket other than, as permitted by law, close bracket, because in the past that wasn't so.
- 1:34Michael Mulligan: Anyways, it's this form that would be filled out and where they are filled out, ordinarily included as part of the contract to buy or sell a house.
- 1:47Michael Mulligan: Now, in this particular case, a house is being sold by a fellow who was not living in it.
- 1:53Michael Mulligan: This is being rented out and there was a deposit paid when the original contract was signed for some $300,000.
- 2:02Michael Mulligan: Was signed for some $300,000.
- 2:08Michael Mulligan: And there was a request for one of these forms that was filled out and sent over to the real estate agent for the buyer and in this case, the person selling the house drew a line through all of the questions asked on the form and wrote at the bottom tenanted property.
- 2:22Michael Mulligan: Owner has never occupied.
- 2:24Michael Mulligan: And that's what the form said.
- 2:26Michael Mulligan: Now you can probably see where this is going, or maybe not, but anyways, one of the questions on there was whether there had been anything built on the property without a building permit.
- 2:37Michael Mulligan: Now, that was one of the questions.
- 2:40Michael Mulligan: Had the line drawn through it?
- 2:41Michael Mulligan: Now, after that first deposit had been paid the $300,000, and before the $200,000 second deposit had been paid, the buyer discovered through their own efforts that there had been an unpermitted addition built on to the home and for that reason refused to close on the deal and that resulted in the seller keeping the $300,000 first deposit and suing to get the $200,000 second deposit, saying, well, hold on, you just haven't complied with this deal.
- 3:10Michael Mulligan: I didn't make any representation about whether there had been any permits for some addition that was added onto the house, and so that's the case that went to court.
- 3:27Michael Mulligan: A case that went to court and at trial, the judge hearing the case relied on a previous decision from back in 2005, another BC Supreme Court decision and in that case there was a similar form that was filled out and in that case the seller wrote at the bottom of the form quote buyer to satisfy themselves property is sold as is, in capital letters, the as is.
- 3:45Michael Mulligan: And in that case, in that 2005 case, the judge concluded well, look, this person didn't make any representations on this form and so you can't rely on it.
- 3:56Michael Mulligan: And the judge dealing with the trial of the case that we're talking about now followed that case.
- 4:02Michael Mulligan: Well, this is the same.
- 4:03Michael Mulligan: The person had drawn a line through everything and wrote that you know, tenant and property owners never occupied.
- 4:08Michael Mulligan: Well, at trial, the seller or the buyer lost and the seller got to keep the damaged, the first deposit of $300,000 and a judgment for another $200,000.
- 4:20Michael Mulligan: I guess the cautionary tale there is when you enter into a real estate contract.
- 4:23Michael Mulligan: It's a contract and if you don't complete you may find yourself sued.
- 4:28Michael Mulligan: Now the case went to the Court of Appeal.
- 4:31Michael Mulligan: A lot of money involved and the decision on that just came out and the Court of Appeal reversed what the trial judge had done.
- 4:39Michael Mulligan: And the Court of Appeal said that.
- 4:43Michael Mulligan: Well, the judge overlooked some material evidence, which is interesting.
- 4:46Michael Mulligan: Generally the Court of Appeal is pretty differential to sort of findings of fact and things the judge relied upon, but here they went in a different direction and they pointed to several things.
- 4:58Michael Mulligan: They pointed to, first of all, the fact that the seller was an experienced in real estate sales, had previously been a licensed realtor, although was not in this particular case, and they found that the seller was aware that there had been this addition added on to the house without a permit, described as a back garden room, whatever that might be, that it had been enclosed without a permit.
- 5:26Michael Mulligan: And there was evidence that he knew that because that was written on the disclosure form that he got when he bought the place.
- 5:31Michael Mulligan: I guess he didn't care, he just bought it anyways, right?
- 5:35Michael Mulligan: And so they found, well, he would have been aware of it.
- 5:37Michael Mulligan: And then they found that his drawing a line through all of the things and writing on it that he was tenanted and he'd never lived there didn't amount to the same thing as when the person wrote on it property is sold as is and found that that wasn't really responsive to what was written on the form and then relied upon some of the other fine print that's included at the bottom of the form about how the form and its comments and so on must be filled out completely and form part of the contract for the purchase and sale of the home completely and form part of the contract for the purchase and sale of the home.
- 6:17Michael Mulligan: And so found that there was a basis to conclude that the buyer had relied upon that thing before entering into the contract and, given the wording on it, that what he'd written on there wasn't sufficient, and so reversed the judge's decision.
- 6:30Michael Mulligan: The court of appeals ordered the $300,000 deposit return and overturned the award of.
- 6:34Michael Mulligan: Ordered the $300,000 deposit returned and overturned the award of the additional $200,000.
- 6:38Michael Mulligan: And so the takeaway for people with this is pay really careful attention to this document.
- 6:44Michael Mulligan: Know that if you're selling a house, you're generally not required to fill one out, but if you start filling one out and making representations about things like you know, are you aware of any problems with the electrical system?
- 6:56Michael Mulligan: Are you aware of any problems with the plumbing system?
- 6:58Michael Mulligan: You know, are you aware that anyone grew marijuana in the house without a permit, for example?
- 7:04Michael Mulligan: And it turns out that those things are wrong.
- 7:08Michael Mulligan: You did know about some problem with the system or the plumbing, or the electrical or the whatever it might be.
- 7:12Michael Mulligan: You might find yourself either the deal not concluding and the person being able to get out of it, or you might find yourself sued.
- 7:19Michael Mulligan: Right If you say, well, hold on, you know the plug didn't work or the faucet leaked, or the you know something or other on there turns out to be inaccurate.
- 7:29Michael Mulligan: So if you do choose to fill one of these things out, when selling a property, you need to be very careful that it's accurate.
- 7:36Michael Mulligan: If it's not filled out accurately, you are effectively warrantying the house in every way.
- 7:41Michael Mulligan: You're putting down there oh yes, everything's fine, I'm not aware of any problem.
- 7:45Michael Mulligan: That turns out to be wrong.
- 7:46Michael Mulligan: You may wind up on the hook for it.
- 7:48Michael Mulligan: And if you decide you don't want to fill one of these things out, you might either not fill it out at all, just no thanks.
- 7:54Michael Mulligan: Or you might choose some language along the lines of what that person chose back in 2005,.
- 8:00Michael Mulligan: As is, other things that are not responsive to what's there, given this Court of Appeal decision may not be enough to mean that that doesn't form part of the contract.
- 8:10Michael Mulligan: To mean that that doesn't form part of the contract, and so this is the sort of thing which I rather expect is going to be affecting a lot of people.
- 8:19Michael Mulligan: Right, there are thousands of people buying and selling homes, and this is a decision which is materially going to affect how those contracts are interpreted.
- 8:27Michael Mulligan: So pay very careful attention to the form.
- 8:29Michael Mulligan: If you're filling one out and you're selling a property, also bear in mind you might have received one of these things, and so if somebody told you there was a problem with the plumbing five years ago, or somebody 10 years ago told you they didn't get a permit for the back garden room enclosure, well you better make sure that's written on the same form, or the form that you're passing along to the potential buyer, or you better make sure you don't either fill one out at all or write on it very clearly that it's as is and none of that is to be relied upon.
- 8:57Michael Mulligan: So that's the very latest from the Court of Appeal on disclosure statements in real estate transactions.
- 9:02Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 9:04Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking will continue right after this.
- 9:06Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking continues here on CFAX 1070.
- 9:09Adam Stirling: Joined, as always, by Michael Mulligan, barrister and solicitor, with mulligan defense lawyers.
- 9:13Adam Stirling: Michael up.
- 9:14Adam Stirling: Next, our second story on the day.
- 9:16Michael Mulligan: I'm reading 150 000 awarded, says here, for discrimination against a first nations woman by a first nations child protection agency upheld by the bc court of appeal yeah, I must say this is a story that I think highlights just how far off the rails some of the issue of care for Indigenous children is in the province, or just how troubled many Court of Appeal here in terms of the grossly disproportionate number of Indigenous children that are in government care.
- 9:48Michael Mulligan: And just to give listeners some idea of what that amounts to, as of the end of January 31st 2024, of the 4,835 children that were in care, that's to say they've been apprehended by social workers that are in care of the government in some form or other, and 68% of them, more than 3,000, are Indigenous, and that's to say there's about 6% of the population that's Indigenous and 68% of the children who are in care are Indigenous.
- 10:31Michael Mulligan: So that's just not good by any measure.
- 10:34Michael Mulligan: And so the particular case here that the Court of Appeal just dealt with was a case out of Vancouver and, interestingly, the agency dealing with the, in this case the apprehension of this woman's four children, is itself an Indigenous agency.
- 10:58Michael Mulligan: In Vancouver, the responsibility for child safety has been turned over to the Vancouver Aboriginal Child and Family Services Society and they've got delegated authority under the provincial legislation to deal with safety and care of children, and the case involved a Indigenous woman who had four children.
- 11:22Michael Mulligan: She had a fifth one who tragically died as an infant, and this woman had all sorts of problems described by the Court of Appeal, including things like being an intergenerational survivor of residential schools that's code, for she didn't go to residential school, but likely her parent or grandparents did.
- 11:40Michael Mulligan: She as a child, was in care herself and as an adult she dealt with low income, housing, insecurity, mental health issues and substance use disorder and described as having.
- 11:54Michael Mulligan: The three of the four children are described as having quote complex needs, so you just imagine what that all looks like.
- 11:59Michael Mulligan: She's a single mother too, so you can just imagine what that looks like.
- 12:04Michael Mulligan: And in this case the children were apprehended by the Vancouver Aboriginal Child and Family Services Society as a result of things including a report from her eldest child that she had been physically abused by her mother or physically assaulted by her mother.
- 12:20Michael Mulligan: Two of the middle children claimed they were scared and hungry at home, had been locked in their rooms with bungee cords and had been pinched and slapped, and there were marks that the doctor indicated looked like they could be cigarette burns.
- 12:32Michael Mulligan: So you can imagine apprehension.
- 12:36Michael Mulligan: Probably not a large surprise given that fact pattern.
- 12:40Michael Mulligan: There were investigations and various multiple other complaints some 33 complaints, although only three of them were investigated in a thorough way and found to be substantiated.
- 12:49Michael Mulligan: Some of the original complaints.
- 12:51Michael Mulligan: Issues arose about them.
- 12:54Michael Mulligan: One of the quoted cigarette burns turned out to be a birthmark.
- 12:57Michael Mulligan: Other cigarette burns were reportedly caused by the child running past the mother with a lit cigarette, reportedly caused by the child running past the mother with a lit cigarette and then later the eldest child retracted the allegations of physical assault.
- 13:14Michael Mulligan: So tragic and very sad.
- 13:20Michael Mulligan: The details some of those details, you just never know what the truth of them were.
- 13:23Michael Mulligan: While in care, the mother continued to have concerns about the children, which were also turned out to be well-founded, and I must say they are rather an indictment of what it looks like when a child winds up in care, remembering, of course, that this mother wound up in care herself when she was a child.
- 13:38Michael Mulligan: Things including one of the middle child, while in care in foster care, attempted suicide twice.
- 13:45Michael Mulligan: One of the, the eldest child, ran away from foster care for as absent for several days and then engaged in what's described as serious self-harm.
- 13:55Michael Mulligan: One of the child children described being held down by arms and legs and there was bruising consistent with that, although that was investigated and turned out not to be abuse.
- 14:04Michael Mulligan: So horrific right On every level, right In terms of the, no doubt, what the challenges were for this person trying to raise children, all of the various things that she was dealing with and the circumstances these children found themselves in.
- 14:22Michael Mulligan: In any case, they wound up out of her care for some three years approximately and eventually they were placed back with her and it resulted in her then bringing a human rights complaint against the Vancouver Aboriginal Child and Family Services Society, alleging that they discriminated against her because that she was Indigenous, alleging that they discriminated against her because she was Indigenous.
- 14:46Michael Mulligan: And so it's a human rights complaint that the Indigenous Child and Family Services Society discriminated against the woman because she was Indigenous, arguing that they had made racially informed assumptions about the impact of things like mental health or substance use and so on.
- 15:06Michael Mulligan: And she won.
- 15:09Michael Mulligan: The Human Rights Tribunal found that the Aboriginal Child Family Services Society had discriminated against her on the basis that she was Indigenous and they awarded her $150,000 for injury to her dignity, feelings and self-respect by the government to the BC Supreme Court.
- 15:33Michael Mulligan: The Supreme Court trial judge, who heard it, allowed the appeal, found that the tribunal member had unfairly expanded the scope of the complaint and overturned the award.
- 15:41Michael Mulligan: That was just appeal to the Court of Appeal and that decision just came out.
- 15:45Michael Mulligan: Also interestingly, the decision is written by the Chief Justice of the BC Court of Appeal, who is himself Indigenous.
- 15:53Michael Mulligan: The Chief Justice of the BC Court of Appeal, who is himself Indigenous.
- 15:57Michael Mulligan: And so you have an Indigenous woman making a human rights complaint about the Indigenous Child Family Services Society, which is ultimately decided by the Chief Justice of the Court of Appeal for British Columbia, who is himself Indigenous.
- 16:07Michael Mulligan: The Chief Justice overturned the trial, the judge at trial who determined that that decision was not proper and restored the $150,000 award for injury to dignity and self-worth and so on.
- 16:23Michael Mulligan: And one of the things pointed to by the judge who overturned the award was to say well, look, if that's how this is interpreted, that's to say how the human rights codes interpret.
- 16:34Michael Mulligan: In relation to the Child Family Community Services Act, which is intended, as its core principle, to protect children, One of the concerns was that would hamstring social workers.
- 16:46Michael Mulligan: You know, if you have a report from somebody saying, hey, you know, I'm being abused by my mother, or there's cigarette burns on the children, or they say they're being trapped in the room with bungee cords or something that they're going to feel like they can't do anything for fear that there might be a complaint made, the Chief Justice concluded that wasn't a legitimate concern, that those two acts could be read harmoniously, and pointed out that the Child Family Community Services Act the one that deals with child protection, which delegates authority to the Indigenous Family Services Society in Vancouver, the social workers enjoy legal protection as long as they don't make decisions that are in bad faith, and so what that means effectively is that you can't sue the social worker right, and so the social worker isn't protected, and so the Court of Appeal has found that the social workers will not be hamstrung by this award, and so the award can be upheld, and instead these two acts are to be read in a harmonious fashion, and so that's the decision of the Court of Appeal the $150,000 award is restored.
- 18:04Michael Mulligan: But I must say, the entire case start to finish in virtually every aspect.
- 18:08Michael Mulligan: When you read it is a rather disheartening history of just how seriously troubled the circumstances are for these children, for the children's mother, for the agency trying to protect the children, in terms of how they're doing that, and when you still look at the stats about how many, what percentage of children that are in care are Indigenous, I must say the entire thing just leaves you at least leaves me just really disheartened about what chance do these 3,000-some-odd children in care have, right, and what do we do about it.
- 18:47Michael Mulligan: And I'm not sure that we've solved the problem with the Human Rights Tribunal complaint or the award that might help this particular woman somewhat.
- 18:56Michael Mulligan: But you know, where are we right in 2025 when this is what's going on?
- 19:03Michael Mulligan: This is the state that First Nations kids are finding themselves in in British Columbia.
- 19:08Michael Mulligan: You know these kids are our future.
- 19:10Michael Mulligan: This is a pretty disheartening state of affairs.
- 19:12Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from the BC Court of Appeal on liability for discrimination by the Aboriginal Child Care Society against an Indigenous woman.
- 19:24Adam Stirling: We have about 90 seconds left and we have the costs against 7-Eleven story.
- 19:30Michael Mulligan: Yeah, that one.
- 19:30Michael Mulligan: I think we can sum up in about that time.
- 19:32Michael Mulligan: So this case we talked about when the original trial decision came out and it was a woman who she tripped in a pothole going in to get coffee from 7-Eleven on her way to work and unfortunately the trip in the pothole caused just terrible damage to her ankle.
- 19:50Michael Mulligan: It broke in three places.
- 19:52Michael Mulligan: She wound up on crutches, eventually in a wheelchair.
- 19:54Michael Mulligan: Long-term problems caused her to fall down again swollen foot, lost her job just horrific circumstances for her and she was ultimately awarded north of $900,000 in compensation for her lost income and pain and suffering and future care and all of this.
- 20:11Michael Mulligan: But the amendment to that, or the add-on to that story, is a decision that just came out dealing with costs, and the reason that was an issue is that the woman in this case who was suing, she had not much money and made various offers to settle while the litigation was going on over a period of years, and she made a total of three offers to settle the case one for $125,000, another for $345,000, and another for $250,000 plus various costs and so on and then wound up and none of which were accepted by 7-11.
- 20:45Michael Mulligan: And so the case went to trial, and she wound up with more than $950,000.
- 20:49Michael Mulligan: What that led to is an application for double costs, which he was successful on.
- 20:54Michael Mulligan: And the point there is that in a civil case where there's an offer to settle something, if it would be reasonable to have accepted the offer to settle, and you don't accept it when it would be reasonable to have done so and more money is awarded, there's a presumption that you're going to get double costs from the time that the offer was made.
- 21:11Michael Mulligan: And that's exactly what's happened here double costs from the time that the offer was made.
- 21:15Michael Mulligan: And that's exactly what's happened here.
- 21:16Michael Mulligan: And the intention of that is to strongly encourage people look, if there's a reasonable offer to settle something, take it and don't carry on and engage in litigation if that isn't necessary.
- 21:26Michael Mulligan: And the court here on that front found that.
- 21:30Michael Mulligan: Well, 7-eleven would have been fully aware of all the facts, including pothole maintenance and everything else, and so it would have been reasonable to have accepted the much lower offers prior to trial.
- 21:40Michael Mulligan: And so that's the final judgment on the case of the terrible pothole in the 7-Eleven parking lot.
- 21:48Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 21:49Adam Stirling: After the second half of our second hour every Thursday, it's Legally Speaking on CFAX.
- 21:53Adam Stirling: Michael, thank you so much.
- 21:55Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.