Latest / Educating All Learners Alliance / From Think Tanks to Do Tanks: Coaching for Equity in Education
Transcript
- 0:01Hi, this is Aurora from the Educating All Learners Alliance,
- 0:05and today we're speaking to Alicia Ciocca for a deeper look into the ELA Community of Action.
- 0:10In December 2024, the Educating All Learners Alliance brought together an unlikely
- 0:15group of educators, leaders, and innovators to tackle shared challenges and
- 0:19create real solutions for students with disabilities and learning differences.
- 0:23Joining us today is Alicia Ciocca, a seasoned coach and advisor who played a
- 0:28key role in guiding this community. Thanks so much for joining us today, Alicia.
- 0:32Hi, thank you for having me. I'm very excited to be here. So let's talk a little
- 0:36bit more about you and tell us about your background and what led you to become
- 0:41an advisor or a coach for this community of action.
- 0:45Yeah, so I'm now an inclusive education coach and consultant.
- 0:51And before I became a coaching consultant, I taught students with disabilities
- 0:56in New York City public schools for over a decade.
- 0:59And New York City has a really great approach to inclusive education through
- 1:03a model called integrated co-teaching in which students with disabilities are
- 1:06educated with their non-disabled peers.
- 1:08And there's two teachers in the classroom. So one focuses more on the content.
- 1:12The other teacher focuses on how to support students with disabilities.
- 1:15So were there any pivotal moments that shaped your approach to this work and
- 1:19your mindset around working with students with disabilities?
- 1:22Yeah. So throughout my time in the DOE, I realized we did a really good job
- 1:27in Department of Education, New York City Department of Education.
- 1:29I realized that we did a very good job in terms of like including students in
- 1:35the general education classroom, but we didn't really talk about disability identity or history.
- 1:42It wasn't included in the curricula when we did DEI work.
- 1:45And so I also noticed how we taught neurodiverse students.
- 1:48And when I say neurodiverse, I mean, students are folks whose brains are wired
- 1:53differently and often like differently than I'm putting in air quotes.
- 1:56Y'all can't see that because I'm on audio, but the norm is a societal construct.
- 2:01So that's why I did that. And neurotypical, when I say neurotypical,
- 2:04that's folks whose brains are wired in a way that is considered quotes the norm.
- 2:08So I noticed how we taught neurodiverse students how to navigate and interact
- 2:12with a neurotypical world, but rarely did we teach neurotypical students how
- 2:16to navigate and interact with the neurodiverse world, which very much exists
- 2:19and is real and is valuable and important.
- 2:21So it led to me developing a disability studies and justice curricula in a senior English classroom.
- 2:27And all the students were like, why are we getting this now,
- 2:29your second semester of senior year? We should have had this earlier.
- 2:33All the students who identified as neurodiverse in the class,
- 2:36like essentially for the first time in their high school careers like came out
- 2:40as neurodiverse or whatever however they identified.
- 2:43And then the students who didn't often talked
- 2:46about like oh wow I was a bystander to bullying or
- 2:49some students were even like I bullied in the past like I wish I
- 2:52feel like I've you know I would have done differently had I known um so that
- 2:58was like a big ah pivotal moment like this work matters and it needs to happen
- 3:01and it needs to be scaled so it led to me developing a disability justice elective
- 3:06course and a partnership with a really great organization called Voices of a People's History.
- 3:10We did a great showcase at Lincoln Center.
- 3:12Then it led to developing professional development for teachers in my school
- 3:16and then in the DOE at large, and then also like training teachers through the
- 3:21CUNY system in disability studies and education approach.
- 3:24And then I decided to launch my own coaching and consulting practice to see
- 3:27how I could scale it in different ways as well.
- 3:30And through that time, I came across the ELAverse, which very much aligned with
- 3:35the, I love Aurora calls it the Eloverse and I feel very much a part of it now.
- 3:39And our mission and our values are very much aligned. And that got me to the community of action.
- 3:45Awesome. Yes, we're always happy to expand our Eloverse.
- 3:49So thinking about all of your experiences, in your experience,
- 3:54what makes a great coach, especially when it comes to collaboration and problem solving?
- 3:59And are there any strategies or mindsets that really helped you or that you find really effective?
- 4:05Yeah, for sure. I've been thinking about this, too, as I've been pivoting more
- 4:10to focusing my energies on coaching educators and adults rather than coaching students.
- 4:16And I was like, wait, all I learned about coaching, though, came from,
- 4:18you know, coaching students, essentially, working with students.
- 4:22And it's so important for us as coaches when we're working with adults,
- 4:25when we're working with students, to be in tune with our own emotional state
- 4:29and values, as well as the emotional state and values of our coaches,
- 4:32whether they be adults or whether they be children.
- 4:33So I think the first thing to always do is just keep an open mind, right?
- 4:38If we have an open mind as coaches, then our coachees will have an open mind
- 4:42about the possibilities and the places that they can go.
- 4:44And that involves active listening. As a coach, I'm usually listening more than
- 4:48speaking. And that's important because it allows the coachee to really figure
- 4:53out their, gives them agency, figure out how they want to approach a problem.
- 4:57It really helps with problem solving as well and developing those skills because
- 5:01as coaches, we want, we're not going to be with our coachees all the time,
- 5:05but we want them to be able to take what we're working on and apply that into their everyday lives.
- 5:11And that also really involves, I think, the third thing, asking the right questions,
- 5:15which is as teachers, what we've really developed and honed,
- 5:18asking students questions to get them to think deeper.
- 5:20I've applied that to my coaching model. So really asking those right questions
- 5:24that allow, that are nonjudgmental, right, open minded, and allow coaches to
- 5:28become reflective about how they want to go about things in a more inclusive,
- 5:34just, equitable way, and in a way that supports their students.
- 5:38For folks who are interested actually because you
- 5:40asked about like different strategies or mindset i really
- 5:43highly recommend elena aguilar's work she's an
- 5:46educator and a coach and she has a model called transformational coaching and
- 5:50i used that when i was at the community of action and her coaching practice
- 5:54promotes compassion equity and i think like just it's so human-centered that's
- 5:59what i love about it and she has four different kind of like guideposts i guess you could call them.
- 6:05So it's to allow participants to surface their current reality,
- 6:10recognize the impact of their mental modes, explore, release,
- 6:14and practice emotional regulation, and then create new practices,
- 6:18beliefs, and ways of being.
- 6:19So this is really helpful, especially if you want to take like an equity mindset.
- 6:23So her work really adopts like an anti-racist approach, but you can apply it
- 6:26to like anti-ableism for any ways in which you want to build a more just,
- 6:31inclusive, loving world, like all the worlds we want to see, right?
- 6:34So I try to use that model whenever I'm coaching, whether it be educators,
- 6:38new teachers, students, folks I come across.
- 6:42And two books that I recommend are Arise, The Art of Transformational Coaching
- 6:47and Coaching for Equity.
- 6:49Those are two of her books, although all her books are great if you want to
- 6:51kind of adopt this mindset.
- 6:53Love that. We'll definitely share out some of those links and resources. That sounds great.
- 6:58So let's think a little bit about the community of action and.
- 7:03You participated as a coach. You were able to help facilitate and guide our attendees.
- 7:10What have been some of the biggest insights or takeaways from the community of action?
- 7:15Yeah, so I loved it. That was my first one, and I hope it's my first of many
- 7:19because I loved it so much. One of my biggest takeaways.
- 7:24Well, so first of all, just some context, the group I worked with mostly.
- 7:28So the model, what I love about the community of action is it's very flexible
- 7:32and it's an organic process.
- 7:34And I believe there was like a suggested guideline of how many people,
- 7:39I almost said students, how many educators should be in a group.
- 7:42I can't remember what that number was, but our group was definitely above that number.
- 7:46But they worked so well together and they all wanted to be together and they
- 7:50all had such great energy.
- 7:51So I spoke with Aurora and Aurora was like, let's see how this works.
- 7:54Like maybe, you know, coaches are supposed to float around because every coach
- 7:57has something different to offer, but maybe you kind of stick with this coach, with this group.
- 8:01And the group sticks with the one coach, which would in that case be me.
- 8:05And it worked out. We stayed together.
- 8:08So we had this really energetic big group that was, you know, brimming with ideas.
- 8:14But then at one point, since it was a big group, right, things can get messier
- 8:18sometimes when you have a lot of voices, there was one person who was still
- 8:22an educator on the ground.
- 8:23So of all the folks in that group, only one was still like working directly
- 8:27in the classroom on a day-to-day basis.
- 8:29And at one point she started getting emotional, right?
- 8:33Because there seemed to be like
- 8:35a lot of ideas coming down. And she was like, how am I going to do this?
- 8:38But like all the competing demands with everything going on in my classroom,
- 8:42what my bosses are telling me to do, what's coming from everywhere,
- 8:44she felt emotional. So she started to bring that up and got teary.
- 8:49And the group kind I took a pause there. And this is also when we're talking
- 8:54about emotions coming up, like Elena Aguilar's to work with coaching.
- 8:57She was able to express those emotions and felt vulnerable enough to,
- 9:01and the group members were able to like be compassionate and be open to her thoughts.
- 9:05And it really shifted the project, right? The project ended up going in a completely
- 9:10different, different direction because of that. I will call it like a pivotal moment.
- 9:14And it was a reminder, like a big takeaway for me from that was that we really need to like,
- 9:21Sometimes there's such a focus on all these like top-down approaches and they're
- 9:25all complex and they're all like great ideas, right?
- 9:28People are putting their hearts and their minds into this, but sometimes they're
- 9:31just too complex and they're overwhelming and we're forgetting about the folks on the ground.
- 9:35And we really need to listen and honor the voices of those folks who are on the ground directly.
- 9:41And it also aligns, they do a lot of disability justice work.
- 9:45There are 10 principles of disability justice by Sins Invalid.
- 9:47And the second one is leadership of those most impacted.
- 9:50And that reminded me like yes this is why we need
- 9:53to honor the voices of the folks who are most impacted by
- 9:56the work and by what's happening in our in our world and the
- 9:59systems right and that was a key
- 10:02moment that showed us like when we do that we're able
- 10:05to shift for the better and then going along those lines
- 10:08the second biggest takeaway for me again you know centering the voices of those
- 10:14most impacted was we need to center student voice so a big question for me when
- 10:19I'm like doing curriculum development or curriculum auditing or any kind of
- 10:22work is whose voices are missing, right?
- 10:25Whose voices aren't being heard and who should we pay attention to?
- 10:28And so as a group, we all looked around and we were like, who's missing in this room?
- 10:33And our aha was the students, like the students.
- 10:36There weren't students in this room. They were all in their classrooms learning
- 10:38from their wonderful teachers all over the country, but they weren't in the room.
- 10:43So we were like, wait a minute, how do we get student voice?
- 10:47And that led the group to shift their thinking
- 10:50and it led the group to pretty much essentially do
- 10:53what the community of action is as it's it's called the do tank right not
- 10:55a think tank but a do tank and do a do tank with students and our group became
- 11:00like the youth action project so the biggest takeaway is like you have to like
- 11:06listen to the students and let the students guide the work the students know
- 11:09what they need the youth know what they need it's our job to listen to them
- 11:13as good coaches, as we talked before,
- 11:15and also to act with students, but not for them.
- 11:19So again, leadership of those most impacted, who's most impacted our youth.
- 11:24Yeah, I love this. I'm so excited to follow this project along,
- 11:28the Youth Action Project.
- 11:29It really takes the community of action model and they're putting together a
- 11:34toolkit and a framework so that folks can implement it with their students and
- 11:39in their communities. It's really, really cool to see that coming along.
- 11:43Yeah, I'm excited, too, because I got to coach it, but then I'm not part of
- 11:48the group per se, so I can't wait to see how it comes along. Right, right.
- 11:51That's an interesting piece of this is working so hard and so intensely over
- 11:58the 36 hours that the event is.
- 12:02But then afterwards, your role as a coach, you let them go with your students, right?
- 12:08You let them go out into the world and do their thing.
- 12:13So yeah, we're definitely going to see some great things coming from them as
- 12:17the pilots and the program progresses. So.
- 12:22Folks who are thinking about how to strengthen collaboration within their own
- 12:25teams or networks, what's some advice that you would give them specifically
- 12:29thinking about what you learned at the COA? So let me rephrase that question with less ums.
- 12:35For those who want to strengthen collaboration within their own teams or networks,
- 12:39what advice would you give them based on what you learned and saw at the Community of Action? Yeah.
- 12:46For me, I feel like the biggest way to ensure that collaboration is effective
- 12:52is by building community and dedicating that time to exploring our shared values,
- 12:58creating community agreements.
- 12:59That's one thing that I realized I wish we kind of had had more time to do,
- 13:03create those community agreements, because conflict is inevitable and conflict
- 13:07is good and conflict will arise.
- 13:09It's more about how we and we're going to grow from
- 13:12conflict or you know as I was talking about with the
- 13:15emotional bringing emotions in our work is
- 13:18going to get stronger when conflict happens because it pushes us
- 13:20to get stronger it's how we address conflict that matters so I
- 13:24think building that time to create those shared values those
- 13:27community agreements is so key I like as a model I
- 13:29like Adrienne Marie Brown's book Emergent Strategy she has
- 13:32some really great tangible resources to facilitate and transformational
- 13:36change and collaboration and community building also the
- 13:39learning accelerators real-time redesign toolkit was
- 13:43a tool that we used throughout this process of at the community
- 13:46of action it's accessible i remember on the helo website
- 13:49they have models they have tools that's all great if you want to put the thinking
- 13:53into action with the do tank and then for me too the last part is like that
- 13:58inner work matters like as a coaches we have to be also doing that inner work
- 14:02and then helping our coaches do that inner work too So if we want to become those caring.
- 14:09Compassionate members of community, we have to be addressing,
- 14:11you know, the ways in which we resolve and we respond to conflict and how our
- 14:15relationship to conflict is, how our relationship to emotional regulation is.
- 14:19I remember one of the most impactful things I heard from a professional development
- 14:22when I was a teacher was that the biggest factor in emotionally regulated youth
- 14:27are the emotionally regulated adults around them.
- 14:30So if the adults are emotionally dysregulated, students will be.
- 14:33And so that involves inner work. And then, of course, like societal biases, right?
- 14:37We're all influenced by these societal biases, and we need to do that inner
- 14:40work to root it out to create more compassionate and loving communities.
- 14:44So I think the inner work, the building community, and then looking out for
- 14:48all those tools that are already available to help.
- 14:50We don't have to always recreate the wheel. There's really great resources out there.
- 14:54I love that. This wasn't a question that I gave you beforehand,
- 14:58but just to kind of wrap it up.
- 15:00Do you have any final thoughts, parting words for folks who are looking to get
- 15:08involved with more community or action oriented work?
- 15:12Any parting words or final thoughts?
- 15:15I think one thing that I loved about ILA, because when I went,
- 15:19I was like, oh, everyone's going to have a focus on supporting students with disabilities.
- 15:23Like I assumed that everyone's background would be that. And that wasn't the case.
- 15:27And that was perfect and beautiful and valuable because all our lives are touched
- 15:32by disability, whether we recognize it or not.
- 15:35And so we need to get more voices in and more perspectives in and more folks
- 15:41being like, yes, this is part of the work that we do.
- 15:43It's integral to our work. And I think when we think of communities,
- 15:47again, like our communities expand and our communities should be expanding and
- 15:51they should be inclusive of all different folks.
- 15:54So for community work, I think sometimes it's important or not sometimes, always,
- 16:00it's important to stretch our minds about the audiences of folks that we think
- 16:03should be there because then we'll be missing out on the true folks that we
- 16:07can be bringing in and that can be making our work stronger. I love that.
- 16:11Thank you so much for joining us today, Alicia. It was really good to talk with you.
- 16:15It was great talking with you
- 16:16as always. I love our time together when we get it. Love it. All right.
- 16:21That's it for us today, folks. Thank you to Alicia Choka. And to learn more,
- 16:25check out our website at educatingalllearners.org.
- 16:28I'm Aurora from ELA, and this was the Deep Dive into the Community of Action.