Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Post-Judgment Motions: Appellate Lawyers’ Perspectives with John Metzidis Greines & Alana Rotter
Transcript
- 0:06Hello, everyone, and welcome to Post -Judgment
- 0:08Motions, Appellate Lawyers' Perspectives. I'm
- 0:11Samantha Savitz, and I am one of the membership
- 0:13chairs of the barrister section of the Barely
- 0:15Hills Bar Association. And I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:18today's speakers, John Mitsidis and Alana Rotter.
- 0:22John is an appellate lawyer with a broad practice
- 0:24covering civil matters. John spent the first
- 0:2715 years of his career litigating matters, mostly
- 0:30at the trial level, first at a large international
- 0:33law firm and then at a trial litigation boutique.
- 0:35He knows and has lived the challenges that trial
- 0:38lawyers face. Working now as an appellate lawyer,
- 0:40John has served well by his extensive law and
- 0:42motion experience, his sharp research and writing
- 0:45skills, and his strategic and analytical mind.
- 0:48Alana is a go -to lawyer for appeals and writ
- 0:51petitions in many fields. Clients and trial lawyers
- 0:54seek her out for her clear writing, thorough
- 0:56research, and efficiency. Alana respects client
- 0:59relationships and is adept at working hand in
- 1:01hand with trial lawyers. Her substantive experience
- 1:04includes trust and probate, profit participation,
- 1:07and other contract disputes, employment claims,
- 1:10and issues facing public entities. Alana helps
- 1:13clients, both plaintiffs and defendants, defend
- 1:15victories and reverse adverse rulings in the
- 1:18California appellate courts and the Ninth Circuit.
- 1:20Now let's get started. Feel free to take it away.
- 1:24Hi, everyone. We are going to break up the presentation
- 1:27with I'll be presenting about approximately the
- 1:29first half and John, approximately the second
- 1:31half, and then we'll come back for Q &A at the
- 1:34end. So if you've got any questions, feel free
- 1:36to throw them into the chat or into the Q &A,
- 1:38I should say. I will also say, because I will
- 1:43forget at the end otherwise, if you like this
- 1:45kind of tip, we offer a monthly appellate tip
- 1:49for litigators. And if anyone wants to email
- 1:51me after the presentation, I'm happy to add you
- 1:53to the distribution list. Comes out once a month,
- 1:55usually short and hopefully relevant to your
- 1:58practice. So today's topic, post -judgment motions,
- 2:02which is very much something that happens in
- 2:05the trial court and yet is very appellate -y.
- 2:08for several reasons. One is that it is often
- 2:12an appellate's last chance to develop or preserve
- 2:15things that are going to be relevant for the
- 2:16appeal later. Another is because these are often,
- 2:21there's often a lot of law involved in these
- 2:23motions and so it's within sort of an appellate
- 2:25skill set. Also a lot of esoteric deadlines and
- 2:30requirements, which we'll touch on today, that
- 2:33we happen to see a lot of. and that you may run
- 2:36into less frequently if you're a litigator who
- 2:39doesn't necessarily go to trial all the time.
- 2:44So to get us started, here's a brief overview
- 2:47of some topics that we'll be covering today.
- 2:50We'll talk about what issues must be addressed
- 2:54in post -judgment motions in order to preserve
- 2:57them for appeal, as opposed to what does not
- 2:59have to be, but you may want to. We'll talk about
- 3:02practical tips for achieving success and for
- 3:05using post -judgment motions to cure record gaps
- 3:08or other issues to tee things up for appeal.
- 3:12We'll talk about the jurisdictional deadlines
- 3:14and requirements. Again, as I said, this is a
- 3:17very esoteric area with a lot to keep track of.
- 3:20Talk about motion procedures and potential pitfalls
- 3:23and how to avoid those or perhaps take advantage
- 3:26when your opponent maybe steps into one. And
- 3:29we'll talk about differences between federal
- 3:31and state court. Most of today's program is going
- 3:34to focus on state court. There are a lot of similarities
- 3:38between federal and state, but there are also
- 3:40some important differences. So we will try to
- 3:42touch on what those differences are. So getting
- 3:49started, general themes. Take these motions seriously.
- 3:54And that, I don't know, maybe sounds a little
- 3:56bit silly, but you know, after you've been through
- 3:58an entire trial, it can feel a little bit like
- 4:01I need to be done. Let me just check this box
- 4:04and move on. But post -judgment motions are actually
- 4:07a wonderful opportunity if something has not
- 4:10turned out the way that you wanted it to. Sometimes
- 4:13it is your best or only realistic chance at reversal.
- 4:17We'll talk about why, but in general, the theme
- 4:20is that the trial judge has much more discretion
- 4:24to revisit what has happened so far than the
- 4:27court of appeal will. It could be your last chance
- 4:31to talk to the decision maker with the discretion
- 4:34before you get yourself into a different form
- 4:36where there is no such discretion. And there's
- 4:43just a picky quote. It has been said that the
- 4:47appellate, sorry, cameras in the way, appellate
- 4:48judges watch from on high the legal ballot box
- 4:51below. And when the dust and smoke of the ballot
- 4:53clears, they come down out of the hills and shoot
- 4:55the wounded. We are trying to be helpful here
- 4:59and figure out things instead of just having
- 5:01the shooting of the wounded. Sometimes if we're
- 5:03in the trial, as I said, we can still have a
- 5:06better chance to course correct before this all
- 5:08happens. As I mentioned, there are aspects of
- 5:15post -judgment motions that are necessary with
- 5:18an eye towards appeal. As in, if you don't put
- 5:21it in your post -judgment motion, an appellate
- 5:23lawyer cannot help you once you get to the court
- 5:25of appeal. I also mentioned they could be used
- 5:28to fix record gaps. And as we'll touch on later,
- 5:31one of the great things on appeal is that if
- 5:33it's not on the appellate record, it didn't happen.
- 5:35Doesn't matter if you know it happened in a sidebar
- 5:38or discussions with the other side, if it's not
- 5:41in the record, the court of appeal is not going
- 5:43to see it. And sometimes if you realize that
- 5:46something was not in the record, you can use
- 5:49a post -judgment motion to put in a declaration
- 5:51or something else to help explain what what happened
- 5:56and what is in the record. Another theme of post
- 6:00-judgment motion, sometimes you know they're
- 6:02worth a shot because the trial judge was signaling
- 6:04that it thought a case should come out a certain
- 6:06way and the jury came out a different way. And
- 6:09in that case, post -judgment motion gives the
- 6:12trial court a chance to express its view and
- 6:15perhaps change what happened. But sometimes you
- 6:19don't know what the judge is thinking. The judge
- 6:21has been playing with parts close to the chest
- 6:22the whole time and So it could be worth a shot
- 6:27even though you don't know that the judge might
- 6:29go your way. And as I said in the beginning,
- 6:35and not just because it's a commercial for us,
- 6:36it doesn't have to be us, but I would strongly
- 6:40advise that you consider bringing in an appellate
- 6:42attorney, whether it's someone from your own
- 6:43firm who knows this area of the law or from outside.
- 6:46But again, because the post judgment motions
- 6:48are the last chance to set things up for appeal,
- 6:50and because appellate attorneys happen to see
- 6:53these issues more often than trial lawyers, It
- 6:55can be helpful to have someone on your team helping
- 7:00with the post -judgment motions. Bringing in
- 7:02someone who can also present a fresh set of eyes.
- 7:06You've been living with the case for a very long
- 7:08time by the time you get a verdict, and having
- 7:12someone else look at it might help identify what
- 7:15are the most salient issues, or is there a fresh
- 7:18perspective to bring, or things like that. So
- 7:24now we're going to turn to issues that must be
- 7:27raised in a new trial motion if you want the
- 7:29potential to present them on the field. The first
- 7:33one is excessive or inadequate damages. If the
- 7:37verdict comes back and it is too high or too
- 7:41low by a wide margin, not just you think it should
- 7:44have been a little bit higher, a little bit lower,
- 7:48excessive damages or inadequate damages, the
- 7:50place to raise this is a post -judgment motion.
- 7:53This is kind of a nuanced area. So I will say
- 7:57the general rule is if you don't raise it in
- 7:59your post judgment motion, you can't raise it
- 8:01on appeal. It's not quite as clear as it sounds
- 8:03though because there are certain types of inadequate
- 8:06or excessive damages arguments that can be raised
- 8:08if you didn't put them in a post judgment motion.
- 8:11For example, if the damages are too high or too
- 8:14low because the judge instructed the jury with
- 8:17the wrong measure of damages. That is a purely
- 8:21legal argument. That is something that can be
- 8:23raised on appeal if it wasn't raised in your
- 8:25post -judgment motion. But you don't want to
- 8:29start trying to parse this and figure out after
- 8:31the fact that you parsed it the wrong way. It's
- 8:33safer to raise any excessive or inadequate damages
- 8:36argument in a post -judgment motion. It is especially
- 8:40important where it has to do with, for example,
- 8:44inflammatory argument by opposing counsel. or
- 8:48things that would start to trigger concerns about
- 8:52jury prejudice, bias as a reason for the award.
- 8:59So those kinds of arguments are always gonna
- 9:01need to be on a new trial motion. The other thing
- 9:04about new trial motions in terms of excessive
- 9:07and inadequate damages is the court of appeals
- 9:11power on one of these motions versus the trial
- 9:14court on excessive or inadequate damages versus
- 9:16the trial court's power. And this is one of those,
- 9:20we're not only raising this to present it for
- 9:22appeal, but we're raising it because of the decision
- 9:25maker's discretion. So when a trial judge is
- 9:30considering a new trial motion, it sits as a
- 9:3313th juror, which means that it has the power
- 9:37to weigh the evidence differently than the jury,
- 9:40to make different credibility determinations
- 9:42than the jury. to draw different inferences than
- 9:46the jury. So you can make arguments to the trial
- 9:50court about whether a witness was believable
- 9:53or not believable, or how persuasive evidence
- 9:55was. And if you happen to get a trial court that
- 9:58feels strongly about your view versus what the
- 10:01jury must have thought, the trial court has discretion
- 10:04to reach a different result than the jury and
- 10:09to award a new trial on damages based on its
- 10:12view. The Court of Appeal does not have any such
- 10:16power. The Court of Appeal is locked into what
- 10:20happened. So whatever credibility determinations
- 10:24the jury implicitly made, however it weighed
- 10:27the evidence, the Court of Appeal will only be
- 10:30looking at was there enough evidence in the record
- 10:33to permit that inference or that credibility
- 10:36determination. And even if the Court of Appeal
- 10:39would have judged credibility differently or
- 10:41weighed the evidence differently, The court of
- 10:44appeal cannot grant a new trial on that grounds.
- 10:48The court of appeal is only going to be looking
- 10:49at, is there enough evidence for what the jury
- 10:53did? And so again, to the extent that you think
- 10:57the jury just got it wrong on a credibility determination
- 11:01or inferences or weighing the evidence, the trial
- 11:05court is your last opportunity to try to persuade
- 11:08someone that the jury just got it wrong in terms
- 11:10of its assessment. And once you're on appeal,
- 11:13as I said, you are locked in. The court of appeal
- 11:16will be very deferential. And so as I say, this
- 11:20is the time you make a pitch to the judge as
- 11:23the 13th juror. You would include in your motion
- 11:27all the authorities about the judge being the
- 11:2913th juror to stress how much power the judge
- 11:32has. And turn yourself over to the judge and
- 11:35see if you can get a different result. And here
- 11:42is just the legal authority for what I said before,
- 11:45which is how the judge can grant a new trial
- 11:49motion. So as I said, the court has a lot of
- 11:52discretion. The trial court has a lot of discretion,
- 11:55although it's not unfettered discretion. It must
- 11:58weigh the evidence, and it must be convinced
- 12:00that the jury got it wrong. Not just a wobbler,
- 12:03but convinced. But I have absolutely had trial
- 12:07courts do this. I've succeeded. I've been brought
- 12:10in. after an adverse verdict or towards the end
- 12:13of a case, made a pitch and gotten it reversed.
- 12:17So just anecdotally as examples, I had a case
- 12:20involving alleged water intrusion into a house
- 12:24that the tenant said had destroyed all of her
- 12:28belongings and had caused health consequences
- 12:31and was claiming quite a lot of money. And we
- 12:35had some indications from the court's comments,
- 12:38but not a clear indication that the court thought
- 12:41that the case was worth a lot less than the jury
- 12:43thought it was worth and that the court was very
- 12:45skeptical of some of the plaintiff's testimony
- 12:47about what belongings happened in the house and
- 12:51whether her health concerns were in fact related
- 12:55to mold. So we moved for a new trial. The jury
- 12:59had awarded two million. The judge found that
- 13:02really the maximum the evidence supported was
- 13:04895 ,000. The judge cannot unilaterally impose
- 13:12a new damages award. But what the court can do
- 13:14is say, plaintiff, I am going to award a total
- 13:18new trial unless you consent to a reduction of
- 13:22damages to this number. And the plaintiff then
- 13:26can choose whether to accept the reduced damages
- 13:29or to roll the dice on a new trial. And in that
- 13:32case, the plaintiff agreed with, accepted the
- 13:35reduction. I had an elder abuse and negligence
- 13:39case where the non -economic damages by far exceeded
- 13:44a cap that is imposed by law under MICRA. And
- 13:49the court used the new trial motion to bring
- 13:52the damages down to the maximum supportable amounts
- 13:55or required that or granting a new trial. In
- 14:01that case, the economic damages also exceeded
- 14:03what was allowable under a line of cases referred
- 14:07to as Howell, which had to do with the billed
- 14:10amounts or medical bills versus the paid amounts.
- 14:12The court found that that required a reduction
- 14:15of the damages. In that case, the plaintiff rejected
- 14:19the conditional reduction and decided they would
- 14:22rather roll the dice on a new trial. That is
- 14:25now on appeal. I had another one where the punitive
- 14:28damages were too high. California requires evidence
- 14:31of financial condition that show that a defendant
- 14:35is able to pay a punitive damages award. There
- 14:38are also, people may know, certain rules that
- 14:41come about ratios between compensatories and
- 14:43punitive damages. In that case, the court found
- 14:48that the punitive damages were double what they
- 14:51sustainably could have been issued in order to
- 14:54that effect the case settles. This doesn't work
- 14:58in every case, but often enough that it can be
- 15:01worth trying. And I will say in that first case
- 15:08I mentioned with the rental, that was an example
- 15:10of the judge drawing a different credibility
- 15:11inference or credibility findings and inferences
- 15:16than the jury did. The other two just had to
- 15:18do with the court's sense of what was supportable,
- 15:21either under the law or under information that
- 15:24had been presented or not presented. So another
- 15:28kind of new trial argument that needs to be made
- 15:31in the trial court before you go up on appeal
- 15:34is jury misconduct. And this is just as a practical
- 15:38matter, jury misconduct often doesn't come to
- 15:41light until after the verdict. And therefore,
- 15:45there will be no evidence in the record of the
- 15:47misconduct unless you do a new trial motion,
- 15:51putting that evidence in in the form of generally
- 15:53juror affidavits. So if you are considering going
- 15:58this route, often it involves a jury investigator
- 16:01who will talk to the jurors and try to find out
- 16:03what happened in the jury room. Make sure that
- 16:06you look closely at the standards for what is
- 16:09admissible in terms of juror declarations because
- 16:13it is a very nuanced area and I see lots and
- 16:19lots of juror declarations that have large chunks
- 16:22that are inadmissible and subject to being stricken.
- 16:24So jurors may testify to overt acts and objectively
- 16:28ascertainable events, such as statements or conduct.
- 16:32They can't testify as to subjective reasoning
- 16:36processes of the jury, which is hard because
- 16:39part of the standard for getting a new trial
- 16:42for jury misconduct is showing prejudice. But
- 16:45the misconduct, there's a reasonable chance that
- 16:47it made a difference. But you still can't have
- 16:50a juror saying, well, I thought X. So we describe
- 16:55this as a fly on the law standard. Could someone
- 16:57outside the jury room, you know, a fly or someone
- 16:59else looking in, see what's being described,
- 17:02which is, you know, juror X said that he went
- 17:04on a site visit and he told us about it. Juror
- 17:06Wari told us they have a family member who knows
- 17:08this and they told us about it, as opposed to
- 17:11what was going on in people's heads. And again,
- 17:14this is a very nuanced area. There's the statute.
- 17:17There's also case law. So if you're delving into
- 17:20this, make sure someone on your team knows. what
- 17:23the standards are. Another category that fits
- 17:29in a post -judgment motion, if you want to be
- 17:31able to raise it on appeal, is generally accident,
- 17:34surprise, or newly discovered evidence. Again,
- 17:36like the jury misconduct issue, it's likely to
- 17:39not be in the record as of the time of the verdict
- 17:41because the point is that this is new. And so
- 17:45a new trial motion with declarations and attachments
- 17:49would be the way to get this into the record
- 17:50and before the judge. So this is your chance
- 17:53to offer new evidence or explain surprise. You
- 17:56need to show ordinary prudence wouldn't have
- 17:59prevented the accident or surprise. So diligence,
- 18:03no undue delay. And you need to show that the
- 18:06evidence is material. And this is like with the
- 18:09juror misconduct, you need to show that it was
- 18:11prejudicial. Generally in our system, we don't
- 18:13overturn results. For an error, errors happen
- 18:17all the time. We only overturned for an error
- 18:20that impacted or likely impacted the outcome
- 18:24in most situations. There are a few exceptions,
- 18:26but mostly. And so that's always going to be
- 18:29the focus is how much did this matter and what
- 18:31can I show about how much it matters. So another
- 18:38time where new trial motions can be very helpful
- 18:42in terms of knowing your audience and speaking
- 18:44to the trial court versus the court of appeal.
- 18:47So there are many requirements. There are requirements
- 18:53about objecting to jury instructions, about objecting
- 18:56to opposing counsel misconduct. And those are
- 19:00forfeiture rules. If you don't timely object
- 19:03and seek a curative instruction or a directed
- 19:08verdict in the case of misconduct, or if you
- 19:12don't object to jury instructions and propose
- 19:14correct jury instructions. You can't argue on
- 19:18appeal about what happens. You forfeit in the
- 19:20error. A trial court can overlook the forfeiture.
- 19:25So if, for example, juror -inclosed arguments,
- 19:29opposing counsel gets into a golden rule argument
- 19:33or something else that is off limits, and you
- 19:37don't object right away. And then later, while
- 19:41you're still in the trial court, You say to the
- 19:43trial court that behavior over there was prejudicial
- 19:46and it was improper. The trial court can say
- 19:50too bad not to object contemporaneously. And
- 19:54I had that happen once where my trial counsel
- 19:56waited until the next jury break to raise something.
- 19:58The trial court said too late. You didn't object
- 20:00at the time. I'm not looking at it. But the trial
- 20:02court can also say, you know, you're right. That
- 20:04was that was pretty serious and crossed the line.
- 20:09And I'm going to entertain the objection. So
- 20:12the trial court has wide discretion as to whether
- 20:14to overlook or excuse the failure to timely object
- 20:18or whatever the case may be. And the trial court's
- 20:23decision, once you get up on appeal, is going
- 20:25to be reviewed only for an abuse of discretion.
- 20:27Was the trial court way outside the bounds? But
- 20:30the Court of Appeal does not have the same discretionary
- 20:34role in its review in what happened. It's reviewing
- 20:36with much more constrained standards. And so
- 20:39if there was no objection, and either you don't
- 20:43ask the trial court, you don't make a pitch to
- 20:45the trial court that the court should overlook
- 20:46the forfeiture and decide your argument, or you
- 20:49make the pitch to the trial court and the trial
- 20:51court says, no, you didn't kindly object, the
- 20:54court of appeal is only gonna say, was there
- 20:57an abuse of discretion here? It doesn't have
- 20:59the same broad power to excuse a forfeiture if
- 21:03it wants to. So for this reason, if you fail
- 21:07to timely object, or for example, if you hired
- 21:09an appellate lawyer after the fact within still
- 21:11the period for post -judgment motions, and they
- 21:15catch something, there was no objection, a new
- 21:18trial motion is your chance to try to get the
- 21:21court to consider the substantive issue anyway
- 21:23despite the lack of an objection. And we've got
- 21:31some cases here that you can look at in terms
- 21:34of where this discretion is and sources of it.
- 21:42Post judgment motions are also, in a similar
- 21:44vein, a chance to clear up the record. So if
- 21:49videotape depots were played at trial and transcripts
- 21:52were not lodged, just in case people aren't aware
- 21:55of this, the court reporter generally does not
- 21:57report. what's being said in a videotaped deposition
- 22:00played at trial. So there's just a gap in the
- 22:02record where it says video deposition played.
- 22:05You can cure that gap by saying what pages were
- 22:07being played and then putting in a copy of the
- 22:09transcript. But if that didn't happen when the
- 22:12evidence came in, you can try to fix it with
- 22:14a post -judgment motion where you put in what
- 22:18the pages were that were played and here's the
- 22:20testimony that was played. If there was an issue
- 22:23with Jory Boitier that wasn't reported, and try
- 22:27to put in a declaration as to what happened,
- 22:30if there were discussions in chambers, unreported
- 22:33sidebars. Anything that was going on that is
- 22:36not yet transcribed by a reporter or reflected
- 22:39in a filed document could try to use your post
- 22:43-judgment motion and declarations to get that
- 22:46into the record and then make an argument based
- 22:48on it. On appeal, you can't for the first time
- 22:51present declarations about what happened. These
- 22:53gaps are much harder to fill. So this is where
- 22:56having an appellate lawyer on the team can be
- 22:58helpful to try to identify where there may be
- 23:00gaps and to try to fill those gaps. So related
- 23:09to this, just another piggy quote. In practicing
- 23:13appellate law, there are at least three unmitable
- 23:14rules. First, take great care to prepare a complete
- 23:18record. If it's not in the record, it didn't
- 23:20happen. When in doubt, refer back to rules one
- 23:23and two. So this, again, is the record cleaning
- 23:27up function of a post -judgment motion. Other
- 23:33details about when new trial motions are and
- 23:37aren't necessary. I will say one thing people
- 23:40don't always realize is that you can do a new
- 23:41trial motion after a bench trial, not only after
- 23:44a jury trial. And after a bench trial, the court
- 23:48has powers under CCP 662. to not only grant a
- 23:53full new trial, but essentially just to reconsider
- 23:55its results and enter a new statement of decision
- 23:58or a new judgment reflecting its change outcome.
- 24:01I know of a case where after a bench trial, the
- 24:04court reached a certain result and flipped itself
- 24:07on post -judgment motions. And so it's something
- 24:11to think about in that context as well. New trial
- 24:16motions are not necessary to preserve issues
- 24:18of law. So if you've got a purely legal claim
- 24:21or if you think the evidence was insufficient,
- 24:24you don't have to do any trial motion. You can
- 24:27go straight to appeal. Although, again, there
- 24:30are reasons to try it. If there are problems
- 24:35with a jury verdict, important to object, ideally
- 24:40before the jury is discharged. But if that hasn't
- 24:44happened, there are things that you could try
- 24:46raising in a new trial motion, for example, inconsistent
- 24:48jury findings. You can refer a new trial after
- 24:54summary judgments. And then one point here, which
- 24:58is sort of a straight point, but needs to be
- 25:00said somewhere, which is that in the period between
- 25:04entry of judgment and appeal, if it was a money
- 25:07judgment, it's going to be enforceable. Once
- 25:10you get up on appeal, you can post a bond to
- 25:13get a stay. And there are other kinds of judgments
- 25:15where they automatically stay once you get the
- 25:18appeal. But that means that there is this gap
- 25:20between the entry of judgments and when you got
- 25:24an appellate state kicking in and the judgment
- 25:25is enforceable during that period. So if your
- 25:28client has a judgment against them and you're
- 25:31going to be doing these post -judgment motions
- 25:32and you don't want enforcement to be happening
- 25:34during the post -judgment motions, One option,
- 25:37obviously, is to talk to the other side and try
- 25:38to reach an agreement that they will be reasonable
- 25:40because they know there's an appellate stay coming.
- 25:43But another option is to ask the trial court
- 25:45to help you. The trial court has discretion to
- 25:47grant a temporary stay under CCP 918 to stay
- 25:53execution of a judgment. Even if a bond would
- 25:55ordinarily be required, the court can just stay
- 25:58the judgment without a bond until 10 days after
- 26:00the last day to file a notice of appeal. Courts
- 26:03commonly grant these sometimes on an ex -party
- 26:06basis, sometimes it's, you know, you make a request
- 26:09earlier in the case conditionally, but the idea
- 26:12is, if you can, to get that stay in place so
- 26:15that you're not doing post -judgment motions
- 26:17under threat of enforcement, but rather everyone
- 26:20has time to write their motions, you know, go
- 26:23back and forth, we'll talk in a minute, John
- 26:25will talk about the timing, but asking for a
- 26:29918 stay before the other side starts trying
- 26:31to execute, can create some breathing room for
- 26:34you and for your clients. So with that, I'm going
- 26:38to turn it over to John. All right, thank you,
- 26:47Lana. So I'm going to talk about the procedural
- 26:51nuts and bolts of filing new trial motions, of
- 26:54course, in state court. It's really important
- 26:58because these procedures, the neutral practice
- 27:01is strictly statutory. It's governed by statutes
- 27:04and the statutes are rather detailed. And the
- 27:06neutral motion looks very different from ordinary
- 27:09motion. So to start out this discussion, I've
- 27:12prepared this chart that compares a lot of procedural
- 27:14aspects about filing a neutral motion versus
- 27:17an ordinary motion to kind of show how they're
- 27:19different. So let's start with the first thing
- 27:21here, the deadline to file a motion. Generally
- 27:23for ordinary motions, there is no deadline or
- 27:27maybe there's something prescribed by statute
- 27:29in a particular kind of motion. Neutral motion
- 27:33is different. There is a very clear deadline
- 27:36mandated by statute. It's a jurisdictional deadline,
- 27:39and it's triggered by an event. I'm going to
- 27:41talk about that in detail in the next couple
- 27:42slides, but you should just know this now. There's
- 27:45a deadline to file your motion. The second thing
- 27:49is the hearing. How is the hearing reserved?
- 27:51Well, ordinarily, you get reservation through
- 27:54the court reservation system before you file
- 27:57your motion. You put that in the notice of motion,
- 27:59and you say, I'm going to be heard on such and
- 28:02such date. New trial motions are different. You
- 28:05file a motion without reserving a hearing beforehand,
- 28:08and the clerk or the court is supposed to set
- 28:10the hearing on its own motion. You might need
- 28:13to remind the court or clerk to do that, but
- 28:15that's how it works. This ties into the next
- 28:18procedural aspect, is the notice document. With
- 28:21an ordinary motion, you file a notice of motion
- 28:24and a motion and then you attach the memorandum
- 28:26of points and authorities. With new trial motions,
- 28:29it's different. You file what's called a notice
- 28:31of intention to move for a new trial. That is
- 28:35a jurisdictional document. It's again governed
- 28:37by the statute, CCP 659. And that notice of intention
- 28:41has to have important things in it. It has to
- 28:45designate the grounds. And that is a term of
- 28:48art, designating the grounds. And I'm going to
- 28:49talk about what those grounds are later. The
- 28:52next procedural aspect is, when is the brief
- 28:54get filed? Well, normally with an ordinary motion,
- 28:57you would file a notice of motion and a brief
- 29:00all in one filing. In new trial motions, it's
- 29:04different. You file the notice of intention to
- 29:07move for new trial first. And then the supporting
- 29:10brief and declarations are due 10 days later.
- 29:14That's governed by a statute called CCP 659A.
- 29:18And that's not subdivision A, that's a distinct
- 29:21statute itself, 659A. You'll see it in the statute
- 29:24books. So that's a different practice. Same thing
- 29:29with oppositions and replies. With ordinary motions,
- 29:31they're usually triggered or tied to the hearing
- 29:34date on the motion, nine court days and five
- 29:36court days before. With neutral motions, they're
- 29:39triggered by the filing of the opening brief.
- 29:41and then the filing of the opposition brief.
- 29:44They are due 10 days after and five days after
- 29:46those respective briefs. The next procedural
- 29:49aspect is a deadline for decision. Usually with
- 29:52ordinary motions, there is no deadline for the
- 29:54court to rule. In neutral motions, there is,
- 29:58and it's a big jurisdictional deadline. I'm going
- 30:01to talk about that next. Another thing is the
- 30:05requirements for the court's order. Summary judgments,
- 30:08there may be some requirements that have to be
- 30:10in the court's order. But generally, for ordinary
- 30:14motions, there are no specific requirements.
- 30:16For neutral motions, there are requirements.
- 30:19In the order, the court is required to, quote,
- 30:22state the ground or the grounds for the motion.
- 30:24And again, that word grounds has specific meaning
- 30:26in the statutes. And in addition to that, the
- 30:29court is required to provide a written specification
- 30:32of reasons for those grounds. That can come later,
- 30:35but talk about that later. And then lastly is
- 30:38the proposed order. Normally, the moving party
- 30:41or the prevailing party will prepare a proposed
- 30:44order for the court on an ordinary motion. With
- 30:47neutral motions, there's actually a statutory
- 30:49provision that says the court must prepare the
- 30:52order itself. The council cannot prepare the
- 30:54order. So keep that in mind. So I want to talk
- 30:58first about the Slide here to the next one. The
- 31:06big deadlines, the jurisdictional deadlines.
- 31:09So the first is the filing of the notice of intention
- 31:12to move further trial. That is a document that
- 31:15is triggered by service of notice of entry of
- 31:18judgment. Once judgment gets entered, then there's
- 31:22service of notice of entry of judgment or service
- 31:25of a file stamped copy of the judgment, which
- 31:27is equivalent to service of notice of entry.
- 31:29That can be served by either the clerk or by
- 31:32a party. But once it is served, that triggers
- 31:36the 15 -day jurisdictional deadline to file notice
- 31:39of intention to move for a new trial. If neither
- 31:42the clerk nor the parties serve notice of entry
- 31:45of judgment, then there's an outer limit of 180
- 31:47days. But usually someone's going to serve notice
- 31:49of entry of judgment. Very important. The ordinary
- 31:53extensions that you get for method of service,
- 31:56two court days for service by electronic or five
- 31:59calendar days for service by mail, those extensions
- 32:02do not apply. The statute says this expressly.
- 32:06So once notice of entry of judgment gets served,
- 32:08you've got 15 days to file your notice of intention
- 32:12for a new trial. The other big jurisdictional
- 32:17deadline is the time for the trial court to issue
- 32:20its order on the motion. The general is 75 days.
- 32:2675 days from what? Well, if notice of entry of
- 32:30judgment is served by either clerk or party,
- 32:32that's the trigger for the 75 -day limit. If
- 32:35neither the parties nor the clerk serves notice
- 32:38of entry of judgment, then the 75 days is triggered
- 32:41by the filing of the first notice of intention
- 32:43to move for a new trial. The statute say that
- 32:47the court is without power to rule on the motion
- 32:50after that 75 day period has elapsed. And if
- 32:54it elapses without an order, then it's treated
- 32:56as a denial of the motion. So make sure that
- 32:59your court knows that there is a jurisdictional
- 33:04deadline to rule on the motion. I usually include
- 33:07a warning in the notice of intention on the caption
- 33:10page, you know, jurisdictional deadline going
- 33:12to expire on date and state the date, don't just
- 33:15say 75 days later, calculate it for the court
- 33:18so that there's No ambiguity about when the power
- 33:21of the court to rule the motion expires. There's
- 33:25a point here too that you might be filing a motion
- 33:29for a new trial with a motion for judgment notwithstanding
- 33:32the verdict for JNOV. Even if the court is going
- 33:36to grant you JNOV, let's say you're a moving
- 33:38defendant, you should also ask the court for
- 33:41a ruling on the motion for a new trial because
- 33:43if your JNOV grant gets reversed on appeal, you
- 33:46can still save some of what you achieved by falling
- 33:50back on the grant of the motion for your trial.
- 33:53So keep that in mind. What's not jurisdictional
- 33:59is the briefs and the declarations are affidavits
- 34:05in support of an opposition to motion. Those
- 34:08again, the supporting declaration by the moving
- 34:11party and the supporting brief by the moving
- 34:12party, those are due 10 days after filing the
- 34:15notes of intention. So obviously you want to
- 34:18file them on time, but there's this California
- 34:20Supreme Court case, Cabron versus Sharp Memorial
- 34:22Hospital, that explains that those inside deadlines
- 34:26within the two outer jurisdictional periods,
- 34:29those inside deadlines are not jurisdictional.
- 34:31You still want to be sure to file them on time.
- 34:34And importantly, you can negotiate and stipulate
- 34:36to extend the time to file the supporting brief
- 34:39or the opposition brief or the reply up to 10
- 34:43days per brief. or you can seek an ex -part A
- 34:45order from the court giving you that extension.
- 34:48So those deadlines can be changed, but those
- 34:50are not jurisdictional deadlines. The next thing
- 34:58is talking about the order on the motion. So
- 35:02as I stated earlier, the court's order on the
- 35:06motion must state the grounds for granting the
- 35:09motion and there must also be a written specification
- 35:13of reasons. Stating the grounds for the motion
- 35:16are different from the written specification
- 35:19of reasons for those particular grounds on which
- 35:21the motion is granted. When you get an order
- 35:24on a motion for new trial, assuming hopefully
- 35:26it's timely, you should be sure that it states
- 35:28the ground because if you don't have an order
- 35:31that states the ground for granting the motion
- 35:33within the 75 -day jurisdictional deadline, the
- 35:36order is void or it's ineffective. It has no
- 35:41effect. The court is not necessarily required
- 35:45to file the written specification of reasons
- 35:47at the same time that it files the order granting
- 35:50the motion for new trial that states the grounds.
- 35:53But if it does that, if it files an order that
- 35:56states the grounds without a specification of
- 35:57reasons, it then has 10 days to file a separate
- 36:00written specification of reasons, 10 days after
- 36:02issuing the order. This is especially important
- 36:13if you are seeking a new trial and are granted
- 36:17a new trial on two particular grounds, the grounds
- 36:20of insufficiency of the evidence to support the
- 36:23verdict or the grounds of excessive or inadequate
- 36:25damages. When you get a new trial granted on
- 36:30those grounds, the court's specification of reasons
- 36:35are presumed by the appellate court to be the
- 36:37only reasons, they're conclusively presumed to
- 36:39be the only reasons for granting the motion.
- 36:42So it plays a very important role in appellate
- 36:45review. So that's, especially if you're getting
- 36:47a motion granted on those two grounds, you wanna
- 36:49be sure that you are satisfied with the specification
- 36:51of reasons and that it's timely. Their slide
- 37:00is to be wary of a procedural trap. The statute
- 37:06governing the notice of intention to move for
- 37:09a new trial, CCP 659, provides you the option
- 37:14of filing a notice of intention, quote, after
- 37:16the decision is rendered and before the entry
- 37:18of judgment. You can do that, but if you want
- 37:22to do that, you want to be sure it happens after
- 37:24the decision is indeed rendered. If you do it
- 37:27before a decision is rendered, then it is premature
- 37:30and then it is, in fact, void of no effect. meaning
- 37:34it's jurisdictionally defective. Generally, in
- 37:37my experience, though, moving parties that need
- 37:40to move for a new trial, they're not in any rush
- 37:42to file the Notice of Intention. They want to
- 37:45avail themselves of as much time as possible.
- 37:48And it kind of puts you in an interesting bind
- 37:49because, on the one hand, you want as much time
- 37:52as possible because you have to draft these briefs
- 37:56and gather evidence, and sometimes you may not
- 37:58even have the evidence yet if you're raising
- 38:01a jury misconduct issue. So you want as much
- 38:04time as possible to draft the briefs and gather
- 38:05the evidence. On the other hand, you don't want
- 38:07to blow the 15 -day jurisdictional deadline.
- 38:10I really highly recommend that you not file a
- 38:13notice of intention on the 15th day. You probably
- 38:16should do it the day before the 15th day. But
- 38:20otherwise, try to give yourself as much time
- 38:22as possible. This case, Maroney versus Jacobson
- 38:29from 2015, is a really good illustration. of
- 38:33just how profoundly these jurisdictional quirks
- 38:36can screw up a motion for a new trial. So what
- 38:40happened here, this was a personal injury case.
- 38:43The plaintiff got a verdict. The plaintiff was
- 38:45actually unsatisfied with the amount of damages
- 38:47awarded. The clerk never served notice of entry
- 38:50of judgment. The moving party, the plaintiff,
- 38:53then files a notice of intention. And the opposing
- 38:56party, in their opposition, they say, hey, You
- 38:59know what? This notice of intention is untimely.
- 39:02And the reason why it's untimely is because even
- 39:04though the clerk never served notice of entry
- 39:06of judgment, I found some other motion that the
- 39:10moving party filed, and that motion attached
- 39:13a file stamped copy of the judgment. So the clerk
- 39:17never served notice of entry, but a party served
- 39:19notice of entry. That service that attached this
- 39:23file stamped copy of the judgment, that triggered
- 39:25the 15 day deadline, and you moving party, filed
- 39:29outside the 15 -day deadline. So trial judge,
- 39:33you have no jurisdiction to grant this motion.
- 39:36The trial judge shakes his head and says, you
- 39:39know what? I think you're right. I think I have
- 39:42no jurisdiction to grant this motion. If I had
- 39:44jurisdiction, I would have, actually. And so
- 39:47what I'm going to do is I'm going to enter a
- 39:50conditional order granting a new trial stating
- 39:54that It is granted if the appellate court later
- 39:57concludes that I have jurisdiction. Now, step
- 40:01back. The code of civil procedure does, in fact,
- 40:05refer to a conditional order granting a new trial,
- 40:08but not this kind of conditional order. It has
- 40:10to do with remitted or inattentive. When the
- 40:13trial judge, as Alana was discussing, is convinced
- 40:15in his or her rule of certitude that the damages
- 40:18are inadequate or excessive. That is the only
- 40:21kind of conditional new trial order, quote unquote.
- 40:24that the Code of Civil Procedure contemplates.
- 40:26And, in fact, what the Court of Appeal held in
- 40:28Moroni is that, number one, the trial court did,
- 40:34in fact, have jurisdiction. The trial court was
- 40:36wrong in its conclusion that the service by the
- 40:40moving party of a foul stamp copy of the judgment
- 40:43triggered the deadline because it has to be serviced
- 40:46on the opposing party, not you can't serve yourself.
- 40:49That was, of course, the conclusion there. But
- 40:51number two, and this was the really big issue,
- 40:54the Court of Appeal concluded that this conditional
- 40:57order that the trial judge purported to grant
- 40:59was an absolute nullity because it did not result
- 41:02in a valid order within the jurisdictional period.
- 41:05And there was no statutory authority for the
- 41:08trial court to grant this kind of conditional
- 41:10order. So the result is that the motion was denied
- 41:13by operational law and that there was no jurisdiction
- 41:16for the trial court. to grant any kind of new
- 41:20trial motion, period. So this is kind of a sad
- 41:24result for the party that moved for a new trial,
- 41:25because it won a new trial. The trial court agreed
- 41:28that it should have a new trial and just had
- 41:31a question about jurisdiction. And as a result,
- 41:36it could have just said, the trial court could
- 41:38have just said, you know what? I think I probably
- 41:40don't have jurisdiction, but I'm going to grant
- 41:42the new trial motion and let the court of appeal
- 41:43figure it out. But instead, Did this compromise,
- 41:47it resulted in a jurisdictionally defective order
- 41:49that couldn't give the moving party the relief
- 41:52that it wanted and probably should have gotten.
- 41:57Okay, so I talked earlier about the Notice of
- 42:00Intention. This is a document that's jurisdictionally
- 42:04prescribed by Crystal Procedure 659, and what
- 42:07you're required to do is designate the grounds.
- 42:10The grounds for a motion for a new trial are
- 42:14statutorily prescribed grounds. They are listed
- 42:16in CCP Section 657. There are seven of them.
- 42:23Let's see if we can get them to display purpose.
- 42:25I'm not going to reread them all here, but these
- 42:27are essentially summaries of the grounds. Because
- 42:31the new trial procedure is so governed by statute,
- 42:34the motion for a new trial can be granted only
- 42:37on statutory grounds. You can't make up your
- 42:40own grounds that are outside of any of these
- 42:41seven listed in 657. And number two is that the
- 42:45motion can only be granted on grounds that you
- 42:48list in your notice of intention. In other words,
- 42:52if you do not list one of any of these seven
- 42:56statutory grounds in your notice of intention,
- 42:59the trial court has no power, no jurisdiction
- 43:01to grant a motion for a new trial on that ground.
- 43:05For that reason, we recommend that you list all
- 43:09seven statutory grounds in your notice of intention.
- 43:13This kind of goes back to my explanation of why
- 43:16notices of motions for a new trial are different
- 43:18from ordinary motions. You know, with a notice
- 43:20of motion for an ordinary motion, you kind of
- 43:23give a preview, a summary of the bases for the
- 43:26motion, but you know, you've got the most, the
- 43:28memorandum of points in the floor is attached
- 43:29to it. The new trial motions is different. You
- 43:32should see this notice of attention document
- 43:34as a jurisdictional document, kind of akin to
- 43:36a notice of appeal. And what you need to do in
- 43:39this document is designate the statutory grounds
- 43:42that give jurisdiction to the trial court to
- 43:45grant the motion on that ground. Even if these
- 43:48are grounds that you don't think you're going
- 43:49to actually argue in your subsequently filed
- 43:52brief that you're going to file 10 days later.
- 43:54The safest route is to list all seven statutory
- 43:57grounds. So we have cases discussing this. Number
- 44:00one, it gives the trial court jurisdiction to
- 44:04grant a new trial on an alternative ground that
- 44:07you didn't brief or that you never argued. You
- 44:09don't know what the trial judge is thinking.
- 44:11Maybe the trial judge sees a different problem
- 44:14than you saw. By listing all grounds, you give
- 44:17the trial judge jurisdiction to grant the motion
- 44:20on that one. Number two is that it gives the
- 44:23appellate court jurisdiction to affirm the grant
- 44:27of a new trial on nearly any other ground other
- 44:30than those two special grounds, sufficiency of
- 44:32the evidence and excessive or inadequate damages.
- 44:36Number three is that you give yourself a chance
- 44:39to argue other grounds if evidence develops later.
- 44:43Think about jury misconduct issues. It may take
- 44:47time for your jury investigator to speak to your
- 44:51juror. it may take time before a juror is willing
- 44:53to come forward or sign the declaration. And
- 44:56maybe you might not have that declaration or
- 44:59that evidence by the time that you file your
- 45:01notice of intention, but you do have it by the
- 45:0410 -day or if you've extended it by 20 days,
- 45:07your deadline to file the supporting brief in
- 45:10support of your motion. So that's another good
- 45:13reason. Another reason is that these grounds,
- 45:17they might overlap with one another. These are
- 45:20special words listed in a statute, but they're
- 45:22not exactly clear. Is it an error of law? Is
- 45:25it an irregularity in the proceedings? It's not
- 45:28always clear. I had a case recently where we
- 45:31had a hearty debate about whether what happened
- 45:33was accident or surprise or new evidence. We've
- 45:39listed both grounds and we argue both grounds,
- 45:41and that's helpful. And lastly, is that failing
- 45:44to include an omitted ground cannot be cured
- 45:47later outside the 15 day jurisdictional deadline.
- 45:51So all of these reasons counsel in favor of listing
- 45:54all grounds. There are four grounds, these four
- 46:00here, the first four, for which declarations,
- 46:04the statute for affidavits, but declarations
- 46:08are substitutable for affidavits. They must be,
- 46:13if you're moving on these grounds, they must
- 46:15be supported by declarations. So keep those in
- 46:20mind, and I believe you're required to state
- 46:22this fact in the Notice of Intention as well.
- 46:24The statute says that. Okay. I'm going to talk
- 46:31now about the other two related siblings to Motions
- 46:34for Neutrality, and that's Motions for Judgment
- 46:36Not Understanding the Verdict, JNOB, and Motions
- 46:39to Set Aside and Dedicate the Judgment. These
- 46:42are when you're seeking a reef as a matter of
- 46:43law and motions you set aside and vacate the
- 46:46judgment or a 663 motion, that's sort of the
- 46:49JNOV equivalent for a court -tried case. You
- 46:52can use these for partial JNOV or partial locator
- 46:57if you're basically making sort of a legal challenge
- 47:00to certain categories of damages, like unsupported
- 47:04or unconstitutional amounts of punitive or medical
- 47:07damages. And again, as Alana was discussing,
- 47:10because these are legal issues, it's not a prerequisite
- 47:13to raising these issues later on appeal, but
- 47:17it helps the appellate argument later that a
- 47:20reversal with directions is required. These statutes
- 47:26have been amended to follow the same kind of
- 47:29jurisdictional and timing deadlines as a motion
- 47:32for new trial. So that's sort of why I wanted
- 47:34to talk about the motion for new trial first.
- 47:38And there's also a procedure or a requirement
- 47:41that if you are filing a motion for JNOB and
- 47:45you're concurrently filing a motion for a new
- 47:46trial, then those two have to be heard together.
- 47:49And so they both have to be heard within the
- 47:51same 75 -day jurisdictional deadline. Just a
- 47:56quick contrast now with the practice in federal
- 47:59courts, to be clear. Everything I've been talking
- 48:01about has been in California state court. These
- 48:03are California state statutes that govern this
- 48:05procedure. Federal procedure is different. The
- 48:09deadline is governed by the federal rules, and
- 48:12it's a 28 -day deadline that is triggered by
- 48:16entry of judgment, not notice of entry of judgment.
- 48:20Punitive damages issues. A state court cannot
- 48:25restrict review of punitive damages. It's constitutionally
- 48:29required by constitutional federal due process
- 48:31mandates. If you find yourself with a state law
- 48:36claim in federal court that presents an eerie
- 48:39issue, and state standards for trial courts review
- 48:46of an excessive damages argument are going to
- 48:50apply rather than a federal standard. And lastly,
- 48:54what are the big differences between a federal
- 48:57district judge's power and a California state
- 48:59judge's power, trial judge's power? is that there's
- 49:03no added in federal court, only remitted. And
- 49:07if the federal district judge believes the damages
- 49:09are inadequate, their only power is to order
- 49:13a new trial. They can't order additive. I'm also
- 49:21gonna talk about the judgment as a matter of
- 49:23law. So this is a big difference between federal
- 49:27court and state court practice, is that unlike
- 49:29state court, a motion for judgment as a matter
- 49:32of law, JMAAL, or a new trial motion is necessary
- 49:36to challenge sufficiency of the evidence on appeal.
- 49:39You have to make that motion to preserve a sufficiency
- 49:42of the evidence argument on appeal. So JMAAL
- 49:45is a two -step process. Before the case is submitted
- 49:50to the jury, but after a party has been heard,
- 49:54you have to move for judgment as a matter of
- 49:56law under Rule 50A. And then after, the judgment
- 50:01is entered, you have to file within 28 days a
- 50:04renewed motion for judgment as a matter of law
- 50:06under Rule 50B. These requirements are important.
- 50:10If you don't move pre -verdict for JMAW, the
- 50:1650A motion, then any new arguments that you raise
- 50:19a post -judgment JMAW motion, a 50B motion, are
- 50:23gonna be reviewed only for plain error, which
- 50:25is a very deferential standard. And then even
- 50:28worse, without a post -judgment JML motion, 50B
- 50:33motion, then sufficiency of the evidence arguments
- 50:36cannot even be raised on appeal, not even for
- 50:38plein air. Lastly, there's a question about what
- 50:43happens if you previously moved for summary judgment
- 50:45in the case and the motion was denied. Well,
- 50:49if it is a motion that was based on the sufficiency
- 50:56of the evidence, then you do need to raise the
- 50:59motion again, not as a motion for summary judgment,
- 51:02but as a motion for judgment as a matter of law,
- 51:0458 DB motion at and after trial. If it is a purely
- 51:08legal issue though, that's some kind of purely
- 51:13legal issue, then that is not something that
- 51:15you need to re -raise to preserve the issue for
- 51:18appeal. That was a recent Supreme Court case.
- 51:21I will say though, what's purely legal and what
- 51:25is a factual argument or sufficiency of the evidence,
- 51:27it's not always clear. So the safer route is
- 51:30to re -raise a 50A and 50B JMAW motion arguments
- 51:37that you raised in a previous summary judgment
- 51:40motion that was demanded. Climbing on appeal
- 51:49for state and federal court, the general rule
- 51:53in California State Court is you have a 60 -day
- 51:56clock after service of notice of entry of judgment
- 51:59by either the clerk or the party, or an outer
- 52:03limit of 180 days from entry of judgment if there
- 52:06is no notice. The filing of these post -trial
- 52:09motions that I've been talking about gives you
- 52:11an extension. It's 30 days after the earliest
- 52:15service of denial of the order or denial of the
- 52:19order by operation of law. In federal court,
- 52:24you're under a shorter deadline. It's 30 days
- 52:26after entry of judgment or 60 days if the United
- 52:29States is a party, but that can be extended by
- 52:31the district court. And there's a similar 30
- 52:35-day extension if you are filing a post -judgment
- 52:39motion. The big points to remember here are these.
- 52:46You don't get the extension to file a notice
- 52:49of appeal. unless you have a post -judgment motion
- 52:52that is both timely and it asserts the legally
- 52:56cognizable ground. It has to be a valid motion.
- 53:00Valid means procedurally valid. If you, for instance,
- 53:03follow a notice of intention that didn't list
- 53:06any of the seven statutory grounds listed in
- 53:10CCP 657, that would not be, and it couldn't be
- 53:15construed as possibly raising any of those seven
- 53:17enumerated statutory grounds. That would be an
- 53:20invalid motion, and you would have a big problem.
- 53:22And you'd have a bigger problem if your notice
- 53:25of appeal depended on the extension of time for
- 53:28having filed what you thought was a valid post
- 53:31-trial motion. So these are deadlines you should
- 53:33always double check and calendar yourself. Don't
- 53:36rely on an assistant. Have a lawyer calculate
- 53:39the deadlines. As I say here, a jurisdictionally
- 53:43defective post -trial motion might mean a jurisdictionally
- 53:47defective notice of appeal. if your notice of
- 53:50appeal depends on the 8108 extension for time
- 53:54limits. And again, no extension of time for service
- 53:59and notice of entry of judgment by mail or electronic
- 54:01service that applies to the notice of appeal
- 54:03as well. That's why it's here. Let's see. I have
- 54:11a few more slides, but we could also... Okay.
- 54:15We'll keep going. There are also some appealability
- 54:19issues that come up with post trial motions.
- 54:24First is what's appealable and then how does
- 54:26it affect the trial court's jurisdiction to decide
- 54:28the motion. On the appealability issue, so these
- 54:31are the ones that are appealable and these are
- 54:33the ones that are not. A trial court order granting
- 54:36a new trial motion is appealable. It is directly
- 54:40appealable. Meaning if you want to challenge
- 54:42it, you need to appeal. A trial court order denying
- 54:45a new trial motion is not appealable. Even though
- 54:47a lot of people will file notices of appeal from
- 54:49orders denying a neutral motion, it is technically
- 54:52not appealable. It is still reviewable, however,
- 54:55on appeal, but it is reviewable on your appeal
- 54:58from the judgment itself. It is not itself directly
- 55:01applicable. The grant or denial of a JNOV or
- 55:06a vacator motion, a motion to set aside and vacate
- 55:08the judgment under 663, those are appealable
- 55:11motions. And finally, another common type of
- 55:15post judgment motion that's not so much a challenge
- 55:19to the judgment are motions for attorney's fees
- 55:22and motions to tax or strike costs. Those you
- 55:26want to proceed with caution. Generally, they
- 55:30are going to be independently appealable, and
- 55:31so you need to file a notice of appeal of them.
- 55:34There are some situations, though, where they
- 55:37are considered as a part of the judgment, so
- 55:39you don't need to file a separate notice of appeal.
- 55:42When in doubt, though, appeal. The other thing
- 55:48that I wanted to talk about, I think this is
- 55:50the last one, yes, is how does the filing of
- 55:54a notice of appeal affect the trial court's ability
- 55:57to rule on a post -judgment motion? I mean, so
- 56:00you've got a judgment, and you know you're gonna
- 56:02move for a new trial, but you also know you're
- 56:04gonna appeal it too. Do you wait to file the
- 56:08notice of appeal, or do you let the new trial
- 56:11motion get decided first and then file a notice
- 56:13of appeal? The concern is this. Don't establish
- 56:18case law that once you file a notice of appeal,
- 56:22you divest the trial court of subject matter
- 56:24jurisdiction over any matters that are embraced
- 56:27in or affected by the judgment from which the
- 56:30appeal is taken. And subject matter jurisdiction
- 56:33is thereby transferred to the court of appeal.
- 56:36But there are exceptions to this. So one exception.
- 56:41Frankly, I don't think this language is terribly
- 56:42helpful because it just kind of creates this
- 56:44concept of something called collateral. Well,
- 56:46if it's collateral to the judgment, then the
- 56:49trial court is allowed to proceed on the matter.
- 56:51Well, then we get into discussions about what's
- 56:52collateral. So the bottom line is this. Case
- 56:57law has established pretty clearly that even
- 57:01though a notice of appeal has been filed, there
- 57:04are some things that a trial court can still
- 57:06proceed on, one of which is a motion for a new
- 57:09trial. So filing a notice of appeal does not
- 57:11divest the trial court jurisdiction to grant
- 57:14or deny a motion for new trial. Same thing with
- 57:18motions to tax costs and motions for attorney's
- 57:20fees. Even though a notice of appeal from the
- 57:22judgment has already been filed, trial court
- 57:24can still proceed on those motions. With JNOV,
- 57:28there's actually a split of authority among the
- 57:31courts of appeal, and this has not been decided
- 57:33yet by the California Supreme Court. So that
- 57:36may be a question if you are contemplating filing
- 57:39a motion for JNOV, you may want to think very
- 57:42carefully about whether and when you're going
- 57:45to file that notice of appeal, if you do it before
- 57:47or after you file a motion for JNOV. And lastly,
- 57:52with a motion to set aside to vacate the judgment,
- 57:54there's actually only one court of appeal decision
- 57:56that we're aware of that says the trial court
- 58:00actually cannot proceed on a motion. to set aside
- 58:03to vacate the judgment if there's a notice of
- 58:05appeal pending from the judgment. So again, considerations
- 58:10of when you file the notice of appeal are things
- 58:13you want to think carefully about and come talk
- 58:15to us or any kind of appellate lawyer before
- 58:19you proceed. I'll just add two quick things on
- 58:23that last slide. The first one is the reason
- 58:26people sometimes feel the urge to file the notice
- 58:28of appeal. while the post -vegetate motions are
- 58:30pending is the stay issue that we talked about
- 58:32before, that they want the advantage of the appellate
- 58:34stay and you need the notice of appeal to get
- 58:36that appellate stay. And this is where that CCP
- 58:39918 temporary discretionary stay can be your
- 58:43savior. If you can get the court to implement
- 58:45that stay, then you don't have to worry about
- 58:47enforcement and getting your appeal filed so
- 58:49fast. The other thing to note is that this is
- 58:51another point where federal law diverges from
- 58:53California law. So in federal court, if you file
- 58:56your notice of appeal, while your post -judgment
- 58:58motions are pending, that notice appeal will
- 59:01just get held in abeyance until after the post
- 59:04-judgment motions are decided, as opposed to
- 59:06California, where you're potentially divesting
- 59:08the trial court of jurisdiction to address those
- 59:11post -judgment motions. So I think with that,
- 59:14we're going to wrap this up. I know this has
- 59:15been a ton of information to digest in a very
- 59:18short time. Hopefully, the PowerPoint will be
- 59:21a helpful resource for you. The takeaway is just
- 59:24that there are a lot of nuances here to be aware
- 59:26of and consult an appellate expert or the rudder
- 59:29guide or your favorite other source when you're
- 59:32getting into this area. And I see we have a question.
- 59:35Should trial attorneys have appellate counsel
- 59:37review the draft jury instructions and verdict
- 59:39forms prior to them being coming final in the
- 59:41court? Yes. I love that question. I love that
- 59:44question. And this is not a closed judgment motion
- 59:46issue, but rather a pre verdict issue and a super
- 59:49important one. This is another area where you're
- 59:52looking ahead towards appeals to make sure you've
- 59:54done everything necessary to avoid inviting an
- 59:58error, to avoid forfeiting an error, anything
- 1:00:01like that. The public lawyers are happy to be
- 1:00:04on your team to look at the verdict form and
- 1:00:06the jury instructions as they are evolving. Thanks,
- 1:00:09Kerry. I think that brings us to the end of our
- 1:00:13presentation. Here are our email addresses in
- 1:00:15case you want to contact us. I said I might forget,
- 1:00:18but I'm going to remember that if you're interested
- 1:00:20in the appellate tips that we offer monthly,
- 1:00:22feel free to email me and let me know. We can
- 1:00:24add you to that list. I hope this has been helpful.
- 1:00:27Thank you for your time.