Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Budget 2025, North Sea plan, and decommissioning
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:05podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:09the UK energy market, the budget, North Sea certificates
- 0:15and decommissioning. There's an awful lot to discuss
- 0:18this week. I'm Aberdeen features lead Ryan
- 0:20Duff, and joining me is news editor Erica Askland.
- 0:24How are you doing this morning, Erica?
- 0:25Hi Ryan, I'm feeling pretty good.
- 0:28I slept asleep of an exhausted journalist last night.
- 0:34It was a long day, but a really crazy day, right?
- 0:37Budget day is always a bit crazy.
- 0:39So, I mean, you kind of saw that you were in Saint Andrews in a
- 0:42pub watching the chancellor stand up.
- 0:45I don't like this accusation, right?
- 0:47I know that was. Like I wasn't actually at a.
- 0:49Pub as the scene. The plan didn't go ahead.
- 0:51Essentially, I wasn't in the pub, I was in the media room at
- 0:54Ouk's decommissioning conference.
- 0:56And that's his story. He's sticking to it.
- 0:58That's damn right. But no big day yesterday.
- 1:02I stuck around to listen from the conference floor.
- 1:04I listened to this. Is a decommissioning conference
- 1:06Yeah in Saint Andrews. So it's very exciting stuff.
- 1:09Listen to Rachel Reeves speak and then sort of scooted off to
- 1:15Lookers to get on the train back up to Aberdeen.
- 1:18You were in situ for listening to all things budget and keeping
- 1:22up to date with that. We'll have more on the
- 1:24decommissioning conference later and an interview with John
- 1:27Underhill right from Aberdeen University about certificates
- 1:31and what is a North Sea certificate.
- 1:33We'll find out. There's a, there's a rather good
- 1:35thread, I think, going through all of the pieces that we have
- 1:38in today's podcast. Actually it's.
- 1:40Almost like we planned it. Like I say, the harder you work,
- 1:45the luckier you are. It's my kind of theory, although
- 1:49maybe our friends at Offshore Energies UK might not agree
- 1:54because they were really hard. I think up to the fateful day
- 1:59where Chancellor Rachel Reeves yesterday stood up and did not
- 2:02even mention the North Sea, she did not even mention oil and
- 2:05gas. What's, And this is despite the
- 2:08fact that, you know, she basically had a bribe on the
- 2:12table. So I mean, this is how lobbying
- 2:14works, right? The on the table basically she
- 2:17had an offer from the North Sea offshore industry, which is you
- 2:23can have 50 billion worth of investment which will give you
- 2:2715 billion in taxes over 10 years and she went no, not
- 2:33interested. Yeah.
- 2:34And that's not to mention the sort of the income tax that'll
- 2:37cut off of workers as. Well, oh, sure.
- 2:39But OUKOUKI mean, I know Dave Whitehouse, CEO of the trade
- 2:44Party, doesn't like being called a lobbyist.
- 2:47It's definitely lobbying. I'm sorry, Dave, but you know,
- 2:51yeah, they were they were campaigning right up until the
- 2:5411th hour. You know, he kicked off the,
- 2:57the, the conference at Saint Andrews on Tuesday morning,
- 3:01essentially say, he said, how dare they, if they don't, you
- 3:05know, go forward with our offer. Like, you know, we've we've
- 3:08given them an ironclad opportunity here, which made me
- 3:12think back to offshore Europe a little bit because, you know, it
- 3:15was kind of it feels like they adopted what Bob Keeler was
- 3:17suggesting in September because up and I felt maybe I'm.
- 3:22Broad don't, don't, don't let you know, Don't give Bob all the
- 3:25credit. No, but essentially, you know,
- 3:28up until September, I felt like the, the campaigning around the
- 3:31windfall tax was a little bit fragmented.
- 3:36I think it was very much like we want, we want, we want to give
- 3:39us a tax break, give us a tax break.
- 3:41And I think, yeah, there was, there was a bit of sort of, oh,
- 3:44and, you know, look at the investment we could unlock and
- 3:46look at this. It was the first time I think OE
- 3:49UK or industry as a whole said this is what will happen because
- 3:54you don't, you know, if you think about it like an offer,
- 3:56like a business deal, you don't sign a contract on, you give us
- 4:00this and we might, we could possibly do this.
- 4:03You need a firm. Offer they they pulled together
- 4:05a case and which was soundly rejected.
- 4:08So just to summarize, so it's interesting when you cover
- 4:12budgets, I've covered a few in my day, but but you know, the
- 4:16big news certainly for this part of the world, not in other parts
- 4:19of the world or other parts of the UK indeed, who don't really
- 4:22care as much about people in the Northeast region as much as we
- 4:26do. But you know, the basically
- 4:30there was no extension to the OR change to the energy profits
- 4:34levy. There was people who said needs
- 4:36to be reformed or just needs to be scrapped.
- 4:39And you know, Rachel did nothing of the sort.
- 4:43But instead we got the North Sea futures a deal which involved,
- 4:50you know, kind of bringing on licensing.
- 4:52So the question is now, though, so pretty much everyone you know
- 4:56from industry who's come back, you know, kind of in response to
- 5:00the budget, which kind of didn't come as a surprise Tuesday
- 5:03night, everyone was kind of going, no, I don't think we're
- 5:05going to get the. OBR made it less of a surprise
- 5:08by publishing it well ahead of. Time, right?
- 5:11Oh my goodness. Yeah, they got a rap on the
- 5:13knuckles for that a lot. They sure did.
- 5:15Funny enough when I was watching that and realized that OBR had
- 5:21screwed up so royally. My husband, who, you know, did
- 5:24that sort of thing back in the day, he's like going if that had
- 5:26happened back in the day, someone would have been shot.
- 5:31But we don't do that anymore. Is that an official comment?
- 5:34A former OBR spokesperson said. I'd have been shot had been.
- 5:38Shot. Absolutely.
- 5:39So no one got shot, thankfully. Well, we don't know.
- 5:42We don't. Know there haven't been any
- 5:44reports of any shootings. Absolutely.
- 5:47Well, but but what we have are people, you know, in industry.
- 5:50I was just, you know, on my in my inbox got an update from
- 5:56Brian Gilberry at Ineos Energy who is saying that this is
- 6:00catastrophic for investment. And you know, again, you just
- 6:04kind of think like these people aren't just saying this for
- 6:07shits and giggles. Like they're actually saying it
- 6:09because they think it's important.
- 6:10And then the question is, so we did get this North Sea future
- 6:14plan. And, you know, there is a lot of
- 6:17benefit to it. We'll talk a little bit more
- 6:18about that later on in the podcast today.
- 6:21But I mean, what we did and the question is, is this just about
- 6:26polishing a turd? What are they?
- 6:29What are people going to invest, you know, in the North Sea?
- 6:32And are they going to bother, you know, kind of doing drills
- 6:37to kind of fields next to existing licenses when you know,
- 6:42this is a dying basin? So just to kind of when I was
- 6:46looking at another thing and this is actually a go shout out
- 6:49to Martin Finley, he's flagged a little piece of like the OBR
- 6:55analysis on LinkedIn and I'm like going Oh my God.
- 7:00And he kind of basically said that's crazy.
- 7:02Basically, the OBR is saying revenues to the exchequer are
- 7:10going to be 27 billion this year from the basin, and by 20-30
- 7:14they're going to be 300 million, which is practically nothing.
- 7:18They are killing the golden goose and they don't mind.
- 7:21Well, it's. Consistent with what the?
- 7:23Folks at Stifel were saying a couple of months ago, 10, I
- 7:25think they said ten billion could be lost if they're if they
- 7:29retain the windfall tax as is. And they did retain the windfall
- 7:32tax as is. Over the past couple of days
- 7:36I've been saying, oh, you know, maybe, maybe they include
- 7:40investment incentives. That was the optimist of me.
- 7:42I. Didn't the optimist?
- 7:43I didn't see who. Thought you were still an
- 7:45optimist? Do you know what I love this.
- 7:47You know, This is why I'm not is because every time I be I, I
- 7:50show a little bit of optimism, it gets slapped out of me.
- 7:54But you know, essentially. I don't slap.
- 7:56Him no, you don't know if HR are listening.
- 7:59Erica doesn't slap me, but eventually I was like, you know,
- 8:03but the rate's probably going to stay the same.
- 8:05That's 78% headline rate of tax and operators probably isn't
- 8:09going to change. Maybe investment allowances are
- 8:11coming in the place to be optimistic.
- 8:13Is licensing adopting John Underhill's proposal of permits?
- 8:17And they've called them North Sea transition certificates or
- 8:20some bollocks like that, sorry. Or some really.
- 8:24Changed. They changed the wording, you
- 8:25know, because it just wasn't good enough.
- 8:27Yeah, they just scrubbed off his headline and wrote a new one so
- 8:30they could steal the byline to use journalistic terms.
- 8:34You know, essentially that was where I was thinking, oh, that's
- 8:37where there's going to be a real change.
- 8:39And I completely get your point on this.
- 8:41Sort of are firms going to invest?
- 8:45However, if you look at the state of the North Sea right
- 8:48now, there's been a real sort of trend of M&A in in the basin
- 8:52100%. And John and I, we're speaking
- 8:53about this and you'll hear from that in the next segment after
- 8:56the break. But essentially, I asked them,
- 8:59you know, you've got Equinor and Shell combining to form a Jura
- 9:03potentially on Monday. Yeah.
- 9:04December 1st, 1st of December. Woo Hoo it's a Jura day on
- 9:08Monday. Can't wait.
- 9:09Yeah, that's the word on the street.
- 9:11And then you've got obviously Ethica, you know, putting all
- 9:13its eggs in the UK with Neptune energy coming on board and any
- 9:18or Eni, the Italian giant putting its putting all its UK
- 9:23all its UK eggs in that basket too.
- 9:26Then you've got companies like Cerika, who you know, the CEO
- 9:29Chris Cox this morning was coming out and saying, while
- 9:32disappointing, at least we know what rules we're playing to now
- 9:35we understand and we can that can inform our future M and a
- 9:38strategy or future sort of drilling and exploration with a
- 9:43with such a focus on there being as many firms in the UK that
- 9:47exclusively focus on the UK now. Yeah, is is there a chance, do
- 9:53you think you'll find out what John thinks later?
- 9:55But so you think that there's a chance that there is going to be
- 9:58investment for the simple reason that the reason the UK doesn't
- 10:02stack up right now for Shell and BP and so on and so forth is
- 10:06they've got international portfolios and they say we could
- 10:08invest millions to drill a new, you know, do a new five well
- 10:12campaign near say, clear as BP or whatever.
- 10:16But why would we if we could spend that same amount of money
- 10:19in Brazil, the Orange Basin, West Africa and make a shed load
- 10:25more money off of it? But when you've got a company
- 10:28like Ajura, solely UK focused, it doesn't need to stack up to
- 10:31international markets and their job isn't going to be to close
- 10:36the doors as soon as possible. I would imagine Neil McCulloch
- 10:39will be wanting to have some longevity with this company.
- 10:42Otherwise, why leave his very secure job at Spirit?
- 10:46Sure, sure. Well, basically we also now have
- 10:50a new four letter acronym. No, not that's not right, but
- 10:54it's the four letter. Word in the North Sea.
- 10:56It's a new 4 letter word in the north.
- 10:58Sea. It doesn't start with AC.
- 11:01Oil and gas price mechanism that's going to come in 20-30
- 11:05and that gives so Jersey oil and gas this morning was saying
- 11:08well, we're going to take a little bit of time to look at
- 11:11that. So, but basically what we now
- 11:13have to do is see if this stacks up for four key areas or the
- 11:19North Sea, which might still, you know, kind of like have a
- 11:22bit of life left in them and that's over West of Shetland.
- 11:26So, you know, kind of we've got Rosebank maybe.
- 11:28Campbell. Potential area, you know.
- 11:30Victory has just come online. Victory.
- 11:33And then of course, BP Claire, Claire.
- 11:36And you know, there's a lot of question over whether they're
- 11:39going to continue on with that expansion.
- 11:42Then there's a greater Buchan area, Yeah.
- 11:45And then that's about it. J Area.
- 11:49Yeah. So I mean, these are what we
- 11:52have to kind of keep focused on. And if these companies are going
- 11:56to make sense of whatever the regime is now, it'll probably
- 12:00involve a lot of tax weeds losses.
- 12:04Some seem to be making sense of it, but it's still think that we
- 12:09have to kind of take it as read that this still will mean 1000
- 12:13jobs losses a month in this basin for the foreseeable.
- 12:17And you know what? That's on you, Rachel.
- 12:21Well, hell of a way to make friends and influence people at
- 12:24the end of this segment, Erica. But no, I feel like that's a
- 12:27sound sound conclusion. Well, for those of you watching
- 12:31the video version, hop on over to your podcast platform of
- 12:34choice because we've got two extra exclusive interviews for
- 12:37this weeks podcast. But if you are already listening
- 12:40on your podcast platform of choice, up next we're speaking
- 12:44to John Underhill from Aberdeen University about how his
- 12:47permitting suggestion earned certificates.
- 12:52Be the first to hear breaking energy news through the Energy
- 12:55Voice app, available to download for free.
- 12:58You get features like saving the articles you want to return to,
- 13:03access to the Energy Voice supplement.
- 13:05You can read exclusive E Forward content and even listen to the
- 13:10Energy Voice Out Loud podcast. If you work in the UK energy
- 13:14sector. Stay in the loop by saving the
- 13:16Energy Voice app to your home screen.
- 13:19Download the app through the Apple App Store or Google Play
- 13:22for breaking energy news on the go by searching Energy Voice
- 13:27app. John Underhill might have just
- 13:31become the man who saved the North Sea this week, as
- 13:34licensing now has at least a glimmer of hope in the form of
- 13:38the permitting that he suggested or the certificates that the
- 13:42government have named them. So I caught up with them to find
- 13:46out what informed the study that suggested the permitting and
- 13:51also who paid for that. Did you do this work?
- 13:54Who funded it? And what I can point to is that
- 13:59the only funding that I received from that was effectively my
- 14:02salary from Aberdeen University. And it was a curiosity LED piece
- 14:08of work. I didn't know when I set out on
- 14:11it that the last five licensing rounds over the last decade had
- 14:16only produced what it it it had in terms of that 40 million
- 14:21barrels of oil equivalent. And you look back and you think,
- 14:24well, that's actually a medium size, small to medium size field
- 14:29compared to some of the the giants of the past, you know,
- 14:32your Brents and Minions and so on 40s.
- 14:38And that was a surprise to me to realise that that that was the
- 14:42case and led me to think there is something wrong that, you
- 14:46know, either industry haven't set up or the basin is in
- 14:50decline, maybe both. But it led me to think that the
- 14:56current licensing regime was not fit for purpose.
- 15:00And then if you accept that argument, you think, well,
- 15:05actually the UK government are saying no new licenses.
- 15:09They could, if they went for something as a solution
- 15:14thereafter, basically go for a situation where there would be
- 15:20no new licenses issued, but things that have been found and
- 15:25that could be prospects that could be discoveries as yet
- 15:29hadn't produced or indeed fields that were producing that had to
- 15:34stop production when a critical piece of infrastructure closed
- 15:38down. And the case to Murdoch Schooner
- 15:41pipeline into Fedorthorpe in the sub North Sea is one example of
- 15:45that. So I, I felt that there was an
- 15:48opportunity to talk about tie backs into existing
- 15:53infrastructure for those types of prospect discovery and fields
- 16:00that could extend the life of the North city.
- 16:04Now we, we may not be talking of course about going back to the
- 16:08days of the 70's, the 80s, No, because we've seen the decline
- 16:12in production. We're no longer self-sufficient
- 16:15in our oil and gas reserves. But does it mean that the basin
- 16:19is completely over? No, we're in the end game, yes,
- 16:23but there are prospects, discoveries and fields that
- 16:29could be produced and be looked out on a case by case bespoke
- 16:34basis on the basis of energy security, affordability and that
- 16:40climate compatibility. And I think that's the other
- 16:43thing that if you look at the domestic oil and gas production,
- 16:47North Sea whilst it has a higher carbon intensity than Norway, it
- 16:54is far lower than imports from elsewhere.
- 16:57So when you realize that the climate compatibility scorecard,
- 17:01for want of a better phrase, maybe it's climate emission
- 17:04scorecard, is calculated on a nation by nation basis, you
- 17:10realize that you could decarbonize by shutting things
- 17:14down, hence deindustrialization. But are we still going to need
- 17:19some of the products that could be cement, that could be
- 17:22concrete, oil and gas, of course, because of how dependent
- 17:25we are on those products for our energy consumption currently or
- 17:30our gas supplies to domestic homes that would be importing it
- 17:34from overseas. And other than Norway, which is
- 17:38a lower carbon intensity, the other import sources, Qatar, the
- 17:44USA where it's frack gasicles, Trinidad, Peru, Algeria, they
- 17:50all come with a higher carbon footprint.
- 17:53So actually you could argue that what we do in developing
- 17:58continuing to produce in North Sea has a better effect on the
- 18:05the climate than the import of the equivalents through LNG from
- 18:09those other sources. And also you can look at each
- 18:13project arguably more rapidly assess them rather than every
- 18:20two years you have a theatrical politicized licensing round.
- 18:24You instead look at bespoke permitting on a case by case
- 18:27basis and judge whether it's worth going ahead on energy
- 18:31security, affordability and climate compatibility grounds,
- 18:35assessing the full life cycle of those prospects, discoveries and
- 18:42fields against the equivalent imports from overseas.
- 18:46On on the sort of permitting suggestion that came out of the
- 18:49study, I'd be interested to hear you mentioned the idea of
- 18:53current the current licensing round set up as being a bit
- 18:56politicized and so quite theatrical when it came to.
- 19:01You. Sending your findings to
- 19:03government and so that that. Proposal of the Bespoke.
- 19:06Permit system. It felt an awful lot to me like.
- 19:12A get out of jail free card for the government in terms of what
- 19:15it had suggested in the past. In terms of.
- 19:18No new fields, no new licences, but then, you know, sort of
- 19:22maintaining the existing infrastructure we have.
- 19:25It felt, it felt an awful lot. Like it was too good to be true
- 19:28to be decided upon. Purely based on the facts.
- 19:31Did you? Did you?
- 19:34Finesse the this sort of suggestion.
- 19:37Of the bespoke permits to make sure it felt within the the
- 19:40Government's current signalling. No, the, the, I think going
- 19:49through the sort of thought process, it was first of all,
- 19:53it's the current licensing system, fit for purpose or not,
- 19:58that was the first step. And when realising actually it
- 20:00wasn't, and I went into that exercise agnostic, I didn't know
- 20:05what the outcome would be. And when seeing that, I just
- 20:08thought, well, yeah, that fits with what was in the manifesto.
- 20:13I wonder if anyone's realised this.
- 20:15And the natural thing to do, of course, is not just simply to
- 20:20highlight a problem. But offer a solution and the in,
- 20:25in this particular mix, I think given that the stresses that are
- 20:30on the industry, the fact that renewables are, are arguably
- 20:35lagging behind where they need to be to have the transition
- 20:39from the existing system to the other one to a new one, a new
- 20:44model for the North Sea. And also the fact that we, we
- 20:49have, we have to manage and have an orderly transition, not a
- 20:55Cliff edge. And you begin to see that there
- 20:58are job losses and not jobs to replace them.
- 21:02So I, I was beginning to sense that there was a, a
- 21:05deindustrialization that was having an adverse impact in the
- 21:10way that back in the 80's the coal mining industry was.
- 21:14So I didn't definitely set out to offer something that was
- 21:23simply, if you like a negative, the old licensing system doesn't
- 21:27work, you have to offer something in return.
- 21:30And when you think about some of the pressures that are on the
- 21:32sector currently and on on jobs and you see that directly in and
- 21:36around Aberdeen in particular, you feel that it's really
- 21:41important to put on the table a suggestion now.
- 21:45I fully expected it to be challenged and quite rightly to,
- 21:50to be for, for both my credentials and the workings to
- 21:55be looked at in detail. You talk about sort of the
- 22:01government. I, I was fortunate and I feel
- 22:04honoured and privileged to have a week after Offshore Europe be
- 22:08asked to meet with teams in desners.
- 22:11And they were asking these sorts of questions about and, and
- 22:16getting down to specifics about examples, things like togemory,
- 22:21things like Katie and Ketch, even things like Celine,
- 22:28Pensacola, Ossian and Croscan. How would they fit into this
- 22:32mix? And I think they were very
- 22:36appropriate, challenging questions, which I hope I was
- 22:40able to address and also give the reassurance that this was an
- 22:47independent piece of work that was credible and authentic.
- 22:52And I would being the first person, if it was shown to have
- 22:56a deficiency, then to move, you know, you follow the science and
- 23:01if new evidence and data comes to the mix, you must change your
- 23:05mind. What was interesting about it,
- 23:08Ryan, was that I think as the data got presented and
- 23:13interrogated, the idea of that bespoke infrastructure and
- 23:20energy security and tie backs into it to keep it going
- 23:24gathered some momentum over the summer and we shall see tomorrow
- 23:30whether it has played through to a positive government response
- 23:37to the intervention that I made. And you know, there was an
- 23:41interesting question raised during the panel session.
- 23:44Today which we had a little chat.
- 23:45About around commerciality and this sort.
- 23:48Of Oh yeah, that was a really good question.
- 23:50Yeah. And then essentially.
- 23:51Even if we do unlock. These permits, is there a
- 23:54guarantee that anything can go ahead if we still have the so,
- 23:58so, so? Company companies will make
- 24:00commercial decisions based on where they see the viability or
- 24:06otherwise of of projects. But I can't help but notice that
- 24:11although Shell and Equinol may be departing the province,
- 24:15Madura is the new integrated joint venture.
- 24:20They're there, you know, arguably to manage the decline
- 24:24of the existing assets, but a decline that might be longer in
- 24:29its taper if there is a change in licensing.
- 24:32And indeed with the EPL doesn't seem to me that, you know, a
- 24:37juror starting on on the point where they're going to announce
- 24:40an exit, they're going to try and make this this work.
- 24:44I would also say, Ryan, I think that in and of itself the
- 24:50intervention that I made and the solution that was tabled for
- 24:54industry and I fully accept this industry might say it's, it's
- 25:00not enough. But I think in a package of
- 25:03measures perhaps with changes to the EPL and to your point some
- 25:09form of greater incentive to develop those fields and
- 25:16discoveries that have been made. So tying back fields that were
- 25:20previously producing and then then cease their production but
- 25:24have still got resources in them and discovery some perhaps
- 25:29prospects too. There is a a pathway there for
- 25:34some companies to take this this forward and of course if that
- 25:38happens, there will be revenue generated for the treasury that
- 25:42otherwise wouldn't be. So there is a greater benefit
- 25:46there to make that even more attractive.
- 25:49It might mean trying to align some of the tax systems closer
- 25:53to Norway and give some incentive to expiration and
- 25:58appraisal, which currently doesn't exist in the UK other
- 26:01than through the allowances, but does in Norway.
- 26:04There is quite considerable rebate 78% minimum on expiration
- 26:11and appraisal costs in the Norwegian shelf to try and
- 26:14generate those prospects leads the production and then pay the
- 26:20higher rate of of tax that the EPL is is charging at currently.
- 26:25So I absolutely accept the question this morning the
- 26:28challenge of can you make that commercial.
- 26:30I would say some companies already think there is still
- 26:33commerciality here, but it might take a little bit of a leap of
- 26:39faith from treasury and government to make it even more
- 26:42attractive. So that was my conversation with
- 26:44John from the Saint Andrews conference this week.
- 26:47Some really interesting insights.
- 26:49And you can hear in there that it was definitely recorded the
- 26:52day before the budget. He said that he was optimistic
- 26:55that they'd accept his his proposal and well, he was right.
- 27:00So stick around, because after this we've got more from the
- 27:02decommissioning conference out in Saint Andrews.
- 27:05Energy Voice leads the global energy conversation, which is
- 27:09why we're excited to introduce our newest offering, E Forward.
- 27:12E Forward is the essential and exclusive community of senior
- 27:15North Sea leaders driving the movement to secure clean energy.
- 27:19The energy transition is not just a climate issue, but an
- 27:22economic imperative. We have a leading position in
- 27:25this race and E Forward can help you take advantage in a discrete
- 27:28environment where thought leaders and recognized experts
- 27:31can collaborate on moving energy forward.
- 27:34This is the specialist membership designed exclusively
- 27:36for North Sea innovators, offering a focus program of
- 27:40events, valuable data-driven insight, and an exclusive
- 27:43digital hub. This is where you can set the
- 27:45agenda and shape the energy transition.
- 27:48If you're 1 of Energy's forward thinkers, it's time you joined
- 27:51us. Visit E forward dot energy.
- 27:53That's EFWD dot energy to learn more and to join this exclusive
- 27:58community. So Offshore Energies UK was
- 28:02hosting its decommissioning conference out in Saint Andrews
- 28:05yet again this month, and I caught up with Walter Thane from
- 28:09360 Energy to discuss the findings from a workshop that
- 28:14kicked off the conference. It's going to impact how the
- 28:17decommissioning Task force approaches next year.
- 28:22So I think, you know, we had, we had, we have the sessions.
- 28:25That's like a fourth, a fourth workshop we've had.
- 28:29And we, we hold them because we want to give people the chance
- 28:32to talk openly before the main conference itself, because the
- 28:36main conference is quite time bound and there's a lot of
- 28:40structured stuff goes on in the main conference itself.
- 28:42So this, the, the theme this year was like the, the good, the
- 28:45bad and the collaborative was, was the theme.
- 28:49And you know, really what we're trying to tease out is kind of
- 28:52what's the blockers and what's the enablers that we make
- 28:56collaboration happen more effectively in the
- 29:00decommissioning market. So that was the drivers for the
- 29:04chat. Obviously the, the being
- 29:05conference is all about, you know, the, you know, the
- 29:09decommissioning supply chain being sustainable, you know,
- 29:13for, you know, for, for a lot of years to come.
- 29:17So we wanted to try and to, because we all believe that
- 29:19working together can actually deliver a better result, which
- 29:22is ultimately safe, effective, cost effective decommissioning
- 29:27activity. So that was the backdrop to, to
- 29:32the workshop. We, we had three sessions.
- 29:35We had, we, we can, we rotate 100 people through three
- 29:38different working groups. So we had three work groups set
- 29:42up. So we'd, one, it was all based
- 29:43on technical, one it was all based on commercial and one
- 29:47which kind of based on the regulatory workforce element.
- 29:50So we split the team, three teams of 30 and they spent 40
- 29:53minutes in each session and they come up, they all have that
- 29:57chance to talk and they come up with the things that are kicking
- 29:59around. So I think some of the key
- 30:01things that came out was supply chain engagement.
- 30:06So early supply chain engagement is a key thing for the supply
- 30:10chain companies. So the earlier they're in the
- 30:13loop with what's coming up on decommissioning, the better.
- 30:16And there's some really good examples out there of of
- 30:20operators with multi year decommissioning campaigns to
- 30:24deliver who are now engaging with supply chain.
- 30:26They're very open. They're saying this is our
- 30:28timeline, this is what we want to do.
- 30:30These are the type of services we're going to need.
- 30:32So some great examples of that. The downside of that is there's
- 30:36people who they want an answer tomorrow, there's a tender comes
- 30:40out tomorrow and they want a response in four weeks.
- 30:42And people have to put their best foot forward and they're
- 30:44caught off guard. So one of the things that people
- 30:47generally felt was more time for supply chain companies to, to
- 30:52understand what the requirements, what the
- 30:55requirements are from a regulatory perspective.
- 31:02There is some pressure being put on companies to act on certain
- 31:06things, which of course supply chain like because that brings
- 31:10work to to happen. But also the, the operators, the
- 31:14ENP companies, they have to get their own your plans together
- 31:18and do things in a timely manner and fund it and make sure
- 31:21that's, that's, that's quite an open dialogue that, that, that's
- 31:25gone. But the regulators are very
- 31:26supportive of collaboration and companies working together to
- 31:31deliver solutions. So that was another key theme
- 31:36that that, that came out. And then from a commercial
- 31:41perspective, so technical, regulatory and commercials.
- 31:43So from a commercial perspective, it's more about
- 31:47risk and reward really about, you know, both supply chain and
- 31:54operating companies really understanding what's the level
- 31:58of risk being accepted by supply chain and why can't they accept
- 32:02more risk. And, and that understanding
- 32:05being actually communicated very well between between the the
- 32:09companies. And then of course you have
- 32:11supply chain to supply chain collaboration where companies
- 32:15are coming together to offer a more integrated solution to
- 32:21operators who have decided to go down the route of more
- 32:25outsourcing. We've done that recently.
- 32:27You'll be aware we've done that with AF grouping for a project
- 32:31with BP on, on Andrew. And so people are seeing, you
- 32:36know, more supply chain companies coming together.
- 32:38And I think the general theme of supply chain companies working
- 32:41together is a little bit of, we ideally want this perfect mix of
- 32:46we do this and you do that. So 2 + 2 makes 5, where
- 32:50sometimes you've just got to accept there's a little bit of
- 32:52overlap and you just be honest and mature about that overlap.
- 32:55And that's fine. You've got an overlap and you'll
- 32:57deliver that part together. So coming together as integrated
- 33:03solution providers is a great thing, I think for supply chain
- 33:06to embrace. So I think also the majority of
- 33:08the themes that that came out with it, everybody wants to do
- 33:12more, but also it takes time. And I think the last point was
- 33:17about commitment. You know, if you if you commit
- 33:19to doing something in a collaborative manner, follow
- 33:23through and then if you do land something, it'll be a journey.
- 33:26It will be perfect to start with, but keep that commitment,
- 33:30keep that commitment going and things will things will
- 33:32hopefully span out. OK, so it's a bit of an overview
- 33:36of what went on. But so on on that.
- 33:38Collaborative piece, I suppose specifically within the supply
- 33:41chain there of like you're saying your collaboration three
- 33:4460s collaboration with the AFD com on the BP project.
- 33:50We we see an industry quite a lot right now.
- 33:53Job loss, headlines, and yes, so on and so forth.
- 33:56The project's being delayed, which creates uncertainty in the
- 33:59supply chain. We we had a little catch.
- 34:02Up in between some of the sessions there and you.
- 34:04You were speaking about UKPLC? Yeah, sure.
- 34:07That we'd get, you know. Bring value to that.
- 34:11When it comes. To sort of that collaboration.
- 34:13Piece 2. UK.
- 34:15Firms that are working. Together to deliver a project.
- 34:18To make sure it doesn't, the engineering work doesn't go
- 34:20over, so whatever it might be. Is is that the solution to
- 34:24delivering value at supply chain I'm?
- 34:26No, I don't. I'm not sure it's the solution.
- 34:29I just think it's, it's an opportunity and I think, you
- 34:32know, there, there is an opportunity to do more activity
- 34:35in the UK, but you got to have the competency here as well.
- 34:39So you know, infrastructures and you know, people that own subsea
- 34:44vessel rigs and stuff like that, you know, they're not heavy lift
- 34:47vessels, they're not typically UK owned companies.
- 34:50So, so if you don't have it, you don't have it, right, You know,
- 34:53unless somebody's prepared to invest in and and create and and
- 34:59that sort of thing. So I do think there's a, and I
- 35:01can only talk for our company, but we see decommissioning as a
- 35:04growth market. I think we I mentioned to this
- 35:06earlier where you know, the E&P guys, it's the kind of end of
- 35:09the line for their asset, you know, the stock producing, it's
- 35:12the end of line for them. And they've also had people
- 35:15involved with these assets for 4555, sixty years type stuff in
- 35:19terms of it being a coming through a project and into
- 35:21operations. So decommission is the end of
- 35:23line, you know, for a specific asset.
- 35:26But for some the supply chain, it's a massive growth market,
- 35:30not only in the UK, but across very, a lot of the mature
- 35:34geographies that people are very comfortable in.
- 35:36You know, whether it's UK, Norway, South East Asia,
- 35:39Americas, you know that that sort of environment, there's a
- 35:41huge opportunity for, for decommissioning.
- 35:44And I think that's the role of the supply chain to promote, you
- 35:48know, decommissioning as a growth market.
- 35:51I also see decommissioning as a big project market, whereas you
- 35:56know where these assets were first put into the UK, North
- 36:00Sea, there's been a lot of us around when they were first.
- 36:03Put. Put.
- 36:04Put in me probably seen some of the back end of it, but but
- 36:07generally the a lot of people that were involved in that big
- 36:10projects are that experience isn't around anymore.
- 36:13So decommission is an opportunity for the younger
- 36:17generation, younger engineers, whatever, to get involved in big
- 36:20project delivery because it's a massive spend.
- 36:23And if you can get that big project experience, that project
- 36:28experience can go from decommissioning to nuclear to
- 36:31offshore winds to, you know, whatever.
- 36:33You know, it's, it's just project experience at the end of
- 36:35the day. You still do the same planning
- 36:37effort. You still have to rely on supply
- 36:38chain, you still place contracts, you have all that
- 36:41things. You see, decommissioning is a
- 36:42massive opportunity for people to learn project delivery
- 36:46experience and actually deploy that into other industries when
- 36:50the other new energy industries come around.
- 36:52So I, I, I do, do you think decommission brings that big
- 36:55project opportunity for people to cut their teeth on bigger
- 36:58projects rather than smaller brownfields and stuff?
- 37:01So I think there's a huge opportunity here, not only to do
- 37:04it in the UK, but to then take that expertise and take it into
- 37:07other geographies. Now other geographies aren't
- 37:13waiting for the UK to gain the experience either, right?
- 37:16They've got their own stuff to do.
- 37:17So we need to be careful, I think as an industry not to
- 37:21overplay that. Yes, there's a role to do it in
- 37:24the UK and take that experience elsewhere.
- 37:26Great. But there's also people want
- 37:28getting after this and other geographies now.
- 37:30You know, Australia and America as people are doing
- 37:32decommissioning, offshore decommissioning now and they're
- 37:34getting after it. And I think as supply chain
- 37:37companies, we need to think about how do we, how do we
- 37:41develop into these, you know, how do we do a geographical
- 37:44entry strategy into these other geographies, bringing our decom
- 37:48experience to the fore. It's a good opportunity, but I'm
- 37:52not going to wait forever. These geographies, they, they
- 37:54like the UK, have to get on and on and do it.
- 37:57Last question to round out, as you said, this isn't the first
- 38:02year you've run this. Yeah, yeah.
- 38:03It's a four workshop, so over the, over the last.
- 38:06Four years have you seen the dial move you know I because.
- 38:10I often I often. Think at these conferences
- 38:12every. Conference ends with a panel
- 38:14that. You know, people say.
- 38:15What's your key take away and everyone guarantee?
- 38:18Says. We need to collaborate.
- 38:20We need to work together. That whole panel, that whole
- 38:23workshop, was based on collaboration.
- 38:26Yeah. Is it happening?
- 38:28Is it getting? Is it more happening more
- 38:31frequently? Obviously it's happening because
- 38:32UNAF. Are working together.
- 38:34You know, we're not the only ones.
- 38:35There's different companies out there doing different, different
- 38:38things. And I'm very conscious that, you
- 38:40know, to wear an industry hat when I'm at these these events.
- 38:43I'm not here to overly play with the 360 for OPA.
- 38:47I think there's more conversations around
- 38:49collaboration now than there's ever been.
- 38:52And I think that's because we're seeing a higher level of
- 38:54activity coming. And also operators really
- 38:58knowing now look over the next 10 years, this is what our plan
- 39:02is. And I think a lot more people
- 39:04are now thinking about what that plan is, which allows supply
- 39:07chain to have more engagement. I think there's a lot more
- 39:11collaborative conversations going on whether they're
- 39:15transpiring into actually them being successful.
- 39:19I think there's more of that happening and that's actually
- 39:24lower down in supply chain. There's other examples, but we
- 39:27tend to think about what we call, we talk about beyond
- 39:31collaboration in our business. And that's because we want to Co
- 39:36create a solution with our customer.
- 39:39So you know, if you talk, we talk about cooperate,
- 39:41collaborate and Co create, right?
- 39:43So cooperate is your typical tendering based thing, right?
- 39:46Here's a scope, but and we'll cooperate with you, we'll sign a
- 39:49contract and you'll deliver it. Collaboration, I mean, a lot of
- 39:52people define it in so many different ways, but it tends to
- 39:55refer to some sort of closer working relationship, more a
- 39:58term based contract, bit more risk and reward and involved in
- 40:03it. We're trying to get to this
- 40:05place where we're saying we will sit and listen to you.
- 40:09Just a customer and we will Co create the right solution of
- 40:13what your challenge is. And if that means it's working
- 40:17with these guys on your project, that's fine.
- 40:19We don't have to collaborate with the same company for
- 40:22everything that we do because instances are different than
- 40:25decommissioning. Sometimes there's floating
- 40:27facilities involved, something there's a fixed facilities and
- 40:29sometimes there's no it's also subsea facilities that are
- 40:32involved. So and also some people might
- 40:34have a preference for UK ours rather than other guards in
- 40:38other European countries. So we're willing to collaborate
- 40:42with lots of different companies.
- 40:43But I think for us it's more about trying to create the
- 40:46solution. We talk about Co creation and
- 40:48beyond the collaboration, but I think there's definitely more
- 40:51talk about it and I think there's definitely more examples
- 40:54of people at least trying, trying to do it.
- 40:58And that's why we wanted to have the session today.
- 41:00This kind of the good, the bad and would typically be the ugly,
- 41:03but it's actually the collaborative, which isn't that
- 41:05ugly when it when it works. But I think a lot more people
- 41:08are coming together genuinely people are talking to, which is
- 41:12a great thing because I think if if two small companies come
- 41:17together, it's actually can make quite a compelling, compelling
- 41:20argument because they bring the nimbleness and agility to to the
- 41:24offering that some of the bigger guys don't do so.
- 41:27I'm glad to hear it. Well, it's.
- 41:29It seems like we've went from the.
- 41:30Good, the bad, and. Ugly to $1,000,000 Baby in the
- 41:33form. Yeah, yeah, to keep the keep the
- 41:36movie theme going. Well, thank you very.
- 41:39Much for joining me today, Walter.
- 41:40And it definitely sounds like we're moving out of a Wild West.
- 41:43Yeah, Yeah. No, I think so.
- 41:45I think it's definitely heading in the right direction, that's
- 41:47for sure. So.
- 41:51Budgets and licensing and decommissioning.
- 41:54Oh my. That was one hell of an episode
- 41:57this week. So thank you very much, Erica,
- 42:00John and Walter for joining me. If you'd like to stay up to date
- 42:04with everything that's happening because I'm sure there'll be a
- 42:06lot more fallout from this week's headlines, stay tuned to
- 42:10energyvoice.com.