Latest / MBA Training Data / How Walmart proved data ROI to its board: lessons from a $1 billion bet on supply chain intelligence
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Leaders Insights podcast.
- 0:07Today's episode, How Walmart Proved Data ROI to its Board, lessons from a $1 billion
- 0:13bet on supply chain intelligence.
- 0:15Walmart just made a billion dollar bet on its supply chain data and somehow got the
- 0:19board to say yes.
- 0:21Most CDOs can't get sign off for a new dashboard.
- 0:24What did they do differently?
- 0:25They stopped pitching data as a virtue and started pitching it as a P&L line, profit
- 0:30and loss, the actual money in and money out.
- 0:34The board didn't approve a data platform.
- 0:37They approved a return.
- 0:38That sounds like a slogan.
- 0:40What's the mechanics underneath it?
- 0:41The mechanics are the whole story.
- 0:44Walmart tied the spend to inventory it could count.
- 0:47There reported billion in supply chain intelligence maps to things like reduced out of stocks,
- 0:52supply, empty shelves where a product should be, and lower excess inventory sitting in
- 0:56warehouses eating cash.
- 0:58Those are line items a board already understands.
- 1:02So the trick is translation.
- 1:04But everyone claims their data improves inventory.
- 1:07Why did Walmart's board believe it?
- 1:09Because they baselined first.
- 1:11Before spending, they measured exactly how much money out of stocks were costing them
- 1:15and how much overstock was tying up.
- 1:18When you have a hard number for the pain, the fix isn't a hope.
- 1:21It's arithmetic.
- 1:23Most companies skip the baseline because it's embarrassing and slow.
- 1:27Embarrassing how?
- 1:28Because you have to admit you don't actually know your own numbers.
- 1:32I've sat in rooms where a retailer couldn't tell me their current out of stock rate within
- 1:3610 points.
- 1:38If you can't measure the problem today, you can't prove you fixed it tomorrow.
- 1:43Walmart did the boring part.
- 1:44Let's be honest though.
- 1:46Walmart has scale nobody else has.
- 1:48Is this even portable to a company that isn't the biggest retailer on earth?
- 1:52The billion isn't portable.
- 1:54The method absolutely is.
- 1:56Three things translate.
- 1:57First, pick one process where waste is visible and countable.
- 2:01Second, baseline it in dollars before you spend a cent.
- 2:05Third, agree with finance before the project on how you'll attribute the improvement.
- 2:11Attribution is where these things always fall apart.
- 2:14Sales went up?
- 2:15Was it the data or the good weather?
- 2:17Exactly.
- 2:18That's the fight that kills most data programs.
- 2:20Walmart's advantage was picking supply chain, where the causal chain is short.
- 2:25You cut out of stocks, the sale that would have been lost now happens.
- 2:29That's easier to defend than our data lake improved customer sentiment.
- 2:34Pick problems where the line from action to money is nearly straight.
- 2:37A data lake being the giant pool where you dump all your raw data hoping it's useful
- 2:42later?
- 2:43Right, and the graveyard of most data budgets.
- 2:46We spent the last decade building lakes and then couldn't say what any of it earned.
- 2:50Walmart inverted it.
- 2:52The outcome came first.
- 2:53The infrastructure was justified by the outcome, not the reverse.
- 2:57You keep praising them.
- 2:59Where's the catch?
- 3:00A billion is a lot to bet on arithmetic.
- 3:02The catch is that you can game a baseline.
- 3:05If you set your before number pessimistically, any improvement looks heroic.
- 3:10A good board asks who validated the baseline and whether finance signed it, not the data
- 3:15team.
- 3:16If the same people who set the target grade the homework, the ROI, return on investment,
- 3:21is fiction.
- 3:22And when a vendor hands you the ROI figure?
- 3:25You discount it on site.
- 3:27Every supply chain software vendor has a case study claiming 20-30% inventory reduction.
- 3:32Those are their best customers on their best day, and often modeled, not measured.
- 3:38Walmart's number is credible, partly because it's their own reporting on their own books,
- 3:43not a vendor deck.
- 3:44When the number comes from someone selling you the tool, treat it as marketing until
- 3:48your finance team reproduces it.
- 3:51So what does a CDO who isn't Walmart actually do Monday morning?
- 3:54Pick the single most expensive operational waste you can name.
- 3:58Stockouts, late deliveries, whatever bleeds cash visibly.
- 4:02Then go to your CFO this week and get them to co-sign the current cost of that waste
- 4:06in dollars before you propose any solution.
- 4:09That shared baseline is the whole game.
- 4:12If finance owns the before number with you, the after becomes their win too.
- 4:17And boards fund their own wins.
- 4:19Get finance to sign the problem before you sell the fix.
- 4:21That's the takeaway.
- 4:22Thanks for this.
- 4:23That's it.
- 4:24The CDO decision tools are live at MBA-training.com.