Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When Your Company Is Hiring a New Boss
Transcript
- Lucas: So a listener question came in that I think we haven't really touched on yet, and it's one of those situations where the timing feels impossible. They've been at their company for three years, they're getting good reviews, and suddenly their manager leaves and a new boss is hired from outside. And now they're wondering — do I ask for a raise while I'm still trying to make a good impression? Luna: That's a real pickle. It's like, you want to show you're a team player, but you also know you might be underpaid compared to this new person. Lucas: Exactly. And the new boss premium is real. When someone is hired from outside, they often come in at a higher salary than someone who's been there for years. A 2024 survey from the job site Hired found that new hires earn on average nine percent more than existing employees in the same role. So the listener's instinct isn't paranoid — it's statistically likely. Luna: Nine percent is significant. That's a whole year of standard raises in one move. Lucas: Right. And the question becomes, how do you approach that conversation without making your new boss feel like you're challenging their authority before you've even worked together? The key is to frame it as wanting to be aligned with market rates, not as a demand. And the timing actually matters more than you'd think. There's a window — usually the first thirty to sixty days — where your new boss is still forming their team and wants to build goodwill. Luna: So you don't wait a year to prove yourself. You use that early window. Lucas: Yes. But you have to be smart about it. You don't walk in on day two and say, 'Hey, I deserve more money.' You do it after you've had a few productive weeks, maybe after you've delivered something tangible. Then you ask for a meeting to discuss your role and compensation. And you bring data — not just 'I want more,' but 'Here's what someone with my experience and results typically earns, and here's what I've contributed in the past year.' Luna: Do you have a concrete example of that working? Lucas: I do. A friend of mine, she's a product manager at a mid-sized software company. Her boss left, and a new VP was brought in from a competitor. She waited about six weeks, then she had a one-on-one where she showcased a project she'd just shipped that had increased customer retention by twelve percent. Then she said she wanted to review her compensation to make sure it was competitive, and she had a few data points from comparable roles in the city. He listened, and he actually came back a week later with a twelve percent raise. Luna: Twelve percent? That's exactly the kind of outcome that makes people think it's worth the risk. Lucas: It is. And the reason it worked, I think, is that she framed it as a mutual alignment — she wasn't threatening to leave, she was saying, 'I want to make sure my compensation reflects the value I bring, so we can have a good working relationship.' That's a much easier conversation for a new boss to say yes to, because it doesn't put them on the defensive. Luna: But what if the new boss says no? Then you feel like you've poisoned the well. Lucas: That's the fear. And it does happen. But the way to mitigate it is to not make it a take it or leave it ultimatum. You're asking for a review, not a demand. And you can always ask, 'What would it take for us to revisit this in six months?' That keeps the door open. Also, if you've done your homework, you might find out that your boss actually has a budget for their team that they can use to give you a bump without any trouble. Luna: So a no isn't necessarily the end of the world. Lucas: Not at all. But there's another angle here that a lot of people don't think about: your new boss might not have any idea what you're paid. They might assume you're already at market, and they might be surprised to learn you're not. So the conversation is partly educational. You're giving them information they need to manage you fairly. Luna: That's a good way to think about it. It's not just asking for help, it's helping them be a better manager. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a mindset that makes the whole thing feel less like a confrontation. Which brings me to a quick honest thing — a handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's literally what funds making this many of these episodes. It keeps the show ad-free, which we love, and we're grateful for everyone who does that. Luna: Yeah, it really does make a difference. It's those listeners who let us keep digging into these specific questions instead of chasing sponsors. Lucas: So back to the new boss situation. One more tip: be careful not to compare your salary to your new boss's. That's a fast way to make it personal. You're not saying 'you're paid more,' you're saying 'I want to be fairly compensated for my role.' Keep the focus on your worth, not their numbers. Luna: And what about the case where your new boss was hired at a higher level than your previous one? Like, maybe they're a director instead of a manager. Does that change the conversation? Lucas: It can. If the company is restructuring or upgrading the leadership, they might be planning to expand your role too. That's an opportunity to ask for a title change along with the raise — 'If we're building out this team, I'd love to take on more responsibility and have my compensation match that.' That's a bigger ask, but it can position you well for the future. Luna: So it's not just about the money, it's about the trajectory. Lucas: Right. And that's the long game. You want to be seen as someone who thinks about the team's growth, not just your own paycheck. So when you have that conversation, you might say something like, 'I'm excited to work with you, and I'd love to align on how I can contribute more and also make sure my compensation reflects that.' That's a collaborative frame. Luna: I like that. It's not 'I deserve more,' it's 'let's figure out how we both win.' Lucas: And if you do get a no, don't panic. You can ask for a follow-up in six months, and you can also ask for a clear path to a raise — what do you need to accomplish between now and then to justify it? That gives you a blueprint. Luna: That's the kind of advice that can change someone's career. Lucas: I hope so. And one more thing, if you're in a position where the new boss is actually someone you know from before — like a former colleague who got promoted above you — the dynamics are even more complicated. You have to be extra careful not to come off as entitled, because there's history there. But the same principles apply: data, timing, and a collaborative tone. Luna: That's a whole other episode, honestly. Lucas: We could do that. But for today, the takeaway is: don't wait for the new boss to figure out you're underpaid. You have more leverage in those first months than you think, because they're trying to build a team and they want you on board. Just approach it with the right frame. Luna: And be prepared to hear 'no' and have a plan for that. Lucas: Exactly. Whether it's a yes or a no, you'll have shown your new boss that you're professional, proactive, and clear about your worth. And that, in itself, is a good impression to make.