Latest / Frangela: The Final Word / SPECIAL CONVERSATION WITH DR. AMANDA STURGILL OF THE UNSPUN PODCAST
Transcript
- 0:00[SPEAKER_01]: M-S-S-W-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E-M-E
- 0:17[SPEAKER_01]: extremely because we have with us the most amazing woman teacher educator writer and I mean in all podcast diva dr Amanda Sturgeon thank you for joining us are you happy to be here your podcast unspon is the podcast that makes you better at finding the truth and that is something we clearly all need so much right now
- 0:42[SPEAKER_01]: Absolutely.
- 0:43[SPEAKER_01]: You're a former reporter and marketing writer.
- 0:44[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, you're book detecting deception tools to fight fake news.
- 0:49[SPEAKER_01]: I believe should be required, read it.
- 0:52[SPEAKER_02]: Absolutely.
- 0:54[SPEAKER_02]: And just in case you didn't know, Dr. Sturgeon gives presentation seminars on misinformation to all kinds of audiences.
- 1:04[SPEAKER_02]: So for those of you who are sitting around going, what can I do?
- 1:09[SPEAKER_02]: to make sure that I'm fighting back.
- 1:12[SPEAKER_02]: You know, invite Dr. Sturgeon to come speak to a group of y'all, okay?
- 1:18[SPEAKER_02]: Also, her podcast, Unspon, is a critical thing is critical thinking about news.
- 1:24[SPEAKER_02]: Where you can hear real examples pass and present of newsmakers attempting to mislead you and then how you can understand how they manipulate the truth, okay?
- 1:36[SPEAKER_02]: Welcome, welcome, welcome Dr. Sturgeon.
- 1:38[SPEAKER_03]: Thank you so much.
- 1:39[SPEAKER_03]: I'm really, really happy to be here.
- 1:41[SPEAKER_02]: Thank you.
- 1:41[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 1:43[SPEAKER_01]: There is okay.
- 1:44[SPEAKER_01]: There's so many things that are hard right now.
- 1:47[SPEAKER_01]: We had a freak out yesterday, I believe.
- 1:50[SPEAKER_01]: When we were recording our podcast, The Final Word, because this administration, and you studied this, how to media, you know, so we were like, we need to talk to the doctor, man, so she can tell us.
- 2:02[SPEAKER_01]: This week is especially challenging to understanding what's happening in our country, and particularly in how we, it's not only speak to each other, but how we are spoken to.
- 2:13[SPEAKER_01]: I had to watch, as I did all of us, had to watch a, I believe, as a Fox reporter, standing in front of the reflecting pool, which is bright green, telling us it was blue.
- 2:28[SPEAKER_01]: And I could, I was just thinking about truth and media.
- 2:33[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, and what, what do you even call what's happening right now?
- 2:39[SPEAKER_01]: Like what that, there's something it makes me feel crazy to have a human being stand in front of a green, I mean shamrock ring.
- 2:47[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, body of water and say, try to get me to say it's blue.
- 2:53[SPEAKER_03]: That is really interesting because I think we are
- 2:57[SPEAKER_03]: where it's something of an inflection point, right?
- 2:59[SPEAKER_03]: Because the past almost 10 years now, I guess that we've been sort of living with this kind of blatant misinformation.
- 3:09[SPEAKER_03]: Most of it is coming from officials.
- 3:12[SPEAKER_03]: But to see media become so complicit in it is a little bit surprising.
- 3:20[SPEAKER_03]: And particularly, you're talking about it was a Fox News reporter.
- 3:28[SPEAKER_03]: somewhere in the middle and maybe shifted a little bit more than I might call something like a news max or a real America's voice or so like that that's clearly just a propaganda kind of thing right you can find you can find elements of news in Fox News usually um but to send a report around to tell you that green is blue is uh
- 3:46[SPEAKER_03]: That's Orwellian.
- 3:48[SPEAKER_03]: Right.
- 3:49[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 3:49[SPEAKER_01]: When you talk about that a lot like how media in generally I know um on was it this week's unspundamental club.
- 3:56[SPEAKER_01]: Well, why do conservatives think the media hates them?
- 4:00[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 4:00[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, this is first all I love journal club.
- 4:02[SPEAKER_01]: Love it, love it.
- 4:03[SPEAKER_01]: Um, but I just I found that it
- 4:08[SPEAKER_01]: that the whole concept of how media is generally, you talk about the his in historically, that the media is, you know, does tend to be partisan, or you talk, they talk about the journal, it tends to be partisan, but that this goes way beyond that.
- 4:22[SPEAKER_01]: And the idea that media has always been connected to power.
- 4:27[SPEAKER_03]: And that is definitely true for a bunch of reasons.
- 4:30[SPEAKER_03]: It's kind of interesting because a lot of the sort of restrictions that people think there are on like news media in particular, right?
- 4:38[SPEAKER_03]: Or actually because of things, decisions that news media themselves made in order to resist being regulated.
- 4:45[SPEAKER_03]: Historically, but yeah, you're absolutely right.
- 4:47[SPEAKER_03]: They talked about that in this paper and I think it's important to know that sort of like the kind of middle of the 20th century and maybe like the first five years of the 21st.
- 4:58[SPEAKER_03]: That was really unusual, and I mean, it has usually been done.
- 5:04[SPEAKER_03]: You know, whenever you've been able to mass produce messages, people who want to have power or want to be able to control those messages.
- 5:11[SPEAKER_03]: Right.
- 5:12[SPEAKER_03]: And so, you know, if you even think back to like artists, you know, like a a Mozart or a Rembrandt or something like that, they had to have patrons.
- 5:20[SPEAKER_03]: in order to be able to do their work, and you kind of see some of that same thing happening now with news in a way that I don't think we're used to because that brief sort of aberration period where we had the non-biased news was also like our entire lifetimes.
- 5:40[SPEAKER_03]: So it feels to us like it's always been that way.
- 5:42[SPEAKER_03]: Right.
- 5:42[SPEAKER_03]: But it hasn't.
- 5:45[SPEAKER_01]: That's so interesting, because I know that like, it makes me think of Reagan.
- 5:47[SPEAKER_01]: Like, wasn't it Reagan who did away with, or what did the fairness doctorate?
- 5:53[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and the fairness doctorate.
- 5:54[SPEAKER_03]: Yep.
- 5:54[SPEAKER_01]: Can you talk a little bit about that or do you know it?
- 5:57[SPEAKER_03]: Um, I can't talk about that in a whole lot of depth because I would have to go and look it up to make sure I'm not telling lies.
- 6:02[SPEAKER_03]: But basically, yes, sort of a theme of Reagan's presidency was that we were going to have less government control and interference.
- 6:11[SPEAKER_03]: things that people did right into you saw that in business.
- 6:14[SPEAKER_03]: And you also saw that in removing the fairness doctrine, which was an attempt to say basically the media were compelled to be less biased by providing like equal time for people and those kind of things.
- 6:26[SPEAKER_03]: And honestly, that kind of thing is going to be very hard to legislate anyway.
- 6:32[SPEAKER_03]: because I could give you the same number of minutes, but they might be less impactful minutes for a variety of reasons that could be you and could be me.
- 6:39[SPEAKER_03]: And, you know what I mean?
- 6:41[SPEAKER_03]: Just counting minutes probably wasn't the most productive thing to do anyway.
- 6:45[SPEAKER_03]: But, you know, Reagan was the time when we were kind of starting to move into 24-hour cable news and those kind of things and because of the shift in the audience, when stuff just became a lot more.
- 6:56[SPEAKER_03]: more available stuff like the fairness doctor and like who just that applied to.
- 7:01[SPEAKER_03]: Right, because it only applied to people who use the public air waves, but I don't know about you all, but I can't even think of the last time I sat down at 6 p.m. and watch the evening news.
- 7:11[SPEAKER_03]: I get a lot of you that I don't do that.
- 7:13[SPEAKER_03]: Sorry.
- 7:14[SPEAKER_02]: I said local even, you know?
- 7:16[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah.
- 7:18[SPEAKER_03]: And my students have never seen, like, an even news broadcast.
- 7:23[SPEAKER_01]: Because we as growing up, that's right.
- 7:25[SPEAKER_01]: You watch the news at night, and then everybody watched 60 minutes on Sunday.
- 7:29[SPEAKER_01]: That's right.
- 7:30[SPEAKER_03]: And you've got a dead tree delivered to your house every day with the news on it.
- 7:33[SPEAKER_03]: That's right.
- 7:34[SPEAKER_03]: Is that now?
- 7:35[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 7:35[SPEAKER_01]: And they read it.
- 7:36[SPEAKER_02]: I remember watching my parents read it.
- 7:38[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.
- 7:39[SPEAKER_02]: You got both, got both papers delivered in the morning.
- 7:43[SPEAKER_02]: And, you know, you had the in Chicago, we had the Workers' Paper, which was the Sun Times, and then the rich people's paper was the Chicago Tribune, and my mother read both of them every single day, because how could you be a citizen?
- 8:02[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 8:03[SPEAKER_02]: without it.
- 8:04[SPEAKER_02]: And so I'd like my question to you right now is, what should be our relationship to the media right now as it exists?
- 8:17[SPEAKER_02]: Be as an average person because there are some of us who are walking around going, I can't believe nothing that comes out of anybody's mouth.
- 8:27[SPEAKER_02]: Then there are some of us who are only on YouTube going, you know, Shelley 33512 says this is going on in the government and I believe her because she got a cousin who works in the department of defense.
- 8:43[SPEAKER_03]: Well, she says she has a cousin.
- 8:44[SPEAKER_02]: She says she has a cousin.
- 8:47[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, she wouldn't lie though.
- 8:49[SPEAKER_01]: She really was selling 3, 5, 7, 2, 8 never lies.
- 8:58[SPEAKER_03]: absolutely.
- 8:58[SPEAKER_03]: And so there's an interesting thing.
- 9:00[SPEAKER_03]: We'll take a little nerdy journey into media theory for a second.
- 9:04[SPEAKER_03]: So when they first started having communication theory about like mask communication, they had what they called the hypodermic needle theory of media and it kind of went along with something called a magic bullet.
- 9:14[SPEAKER_03]: theory of media, which basically said, you just tell people things and then they believe them.
- 9:19[SPEAKER_03]: And then they buy your products because you told them it was great or they vote for your thing because you told them it was best for them or something like that.
- 9:25[SPEAKER_03]: Right?
- 9:26[SPEAKER_03]: And those theories at the time I was in graduate school back in 19 something.
- 9:35[SPEAKER_03]: We're going away, and they're being replaced by something called Active Audience Therapies.
- 9:39[SPEAKER_03]: And so Active Audience Therapies assume that people are smart and that people are taking in information and they're judging the information and they're comparing it against or the things they believe and stuff like that.
- 9:48[SPEAKER_03]: And it was like, we have those stupid Hepatomic Needle theories, like that would never work.
- 9:54[SPEAKER_03]: I feel like what we're seeing now is we're seeing an audience that is too overwhelmed to be active.
- 9:59[SPEAKER_03]: So as an ordinary person who is a news user, I feel like what you need to do is be strategically active, right?
- 10:07[SPEAKER_03]: Strategically, which is to say like you will need breaks from the fire hose of information.
- 10:13[SPEAKER_03]: If you are spending all day scrolling social media and thinking that's making you more informed, it's probably just making you upset and worse at judging news.
- 10:24[SPEAKER_03]: get information from a variety of sources and you do need to go out and seek information.
- 10:29[SPEAKER_03]: There was a new study that came out this week about local reporting.
- 10:34[SPEAKER_03]: So the status of local reporting, and it made me very sad.
- 10:38[SPEAKER_03]: Because they, I mean, first of all, like local reporting's been collapsing for a while.
- 10:42[SPEAKER_03]: Just like the number of people that we have covering local news is way, way, way smaller.
- 10:47[SPEAKER_03]: But even when they do cover it, most of what they're covering is sports.
- 10:52[SPEAKER_03]: and politics, which means things are not covering or things like food inspections and education.
- 11:00[SPEAKER_03]: And they cover crime, but only like sensational crime.
- 11:03[SPEAKER_03]: But that's always kind of been true.
- 11:05[SPEAKER_03]: I used to be a crime reporter.
- 11:07[SPEAKER_03]: And it would be shocking to you some of the things that go on in cities that don't get reported because you couldn't report it all.
- 11:15[SPEAKER_03]: But
- 11:17[SPEAKER_03]: People just, they don't know that they're missing these things, right?
- 11:21[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
- 11:22[SPEAKER_03]: So being an active consumer of media includes both being active in what you take in, and then also being active in what you demand.
- 11:29[SPEAKER_03]: Right.
- 11:30[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah.
- 11:31[SPEAKER_03]: So if you look at the Code of Ethics for the Society of Professional Journalists, which
- 11:37[SPEAKER_03]: People who don't consider themselves like an independent journalist will tend to follow this code about that.
- 11:41[SPEAKER_03]: So you can just look it up at spj.org online to find that one of the tenants, and there's not that many of them, is that you have to be responsive to your audience, but if you want your journalist to be responsible to you and the audience, have to communicate with them.
- 11:56[SPEAKER_02]: right.
- 11:57[SPEAKER_03]: And there's a big generational shift in how we communicate now.
- 12:02[SPEAKER_03]: So I see this in my classroom all the time.
- 12:05[SPEAKER_03]: So I teach reporting classes.
- 12:07[SPEAKER_03]: And getting my students to the point that they will pick up a phone, you know, the little device are carrying around in their pocket all the time, right?
- 12:19[SPEAKER_03]: They're not good at that.
- 12:21[SPEAKER_03]: It's a huge leap for them because they had the first to, right?
- 12:24[SPEAKER_02]: And teaching them in your teaching them professionalism at a level where this is how you get you move forward.
- 12:33[SPEAKER_02]: Things the story is never going to land in your lab.
- 12:36[SPEAKER_02]: You're never, how are you going to, your interest needs to be peaked?
- 12:41[SPEAKER_02]: You need to have input, but we do really do believe that the information is coming to us through that phone as we're scrolling up.
- 12:50[SPEAKER_03]: Right.
- 12:51[SPEAKER_02]: That that is the inspiration.
- 12:53[SPEAKER_03]: Yes.
- 12:54[SPEAKER_03]: And so you feel informed, but you're not informed is kind of what the research shows.
- 13:00[SPEAKER_03]: If you want to communicate with your media, picking up your phone and calling a reporter is way better than posting something shady on social media about them or even sending an email those are easy to ignore my students and I we talk a lot about like the art of creative harassment of people.
- 13:17[SPEAKER_00]: I love that, yeah, I'm going to bring this out.
- 13:20[SPEAKER_03]: You know, which is basically, people don't, they don't want to talk to you as a reporter, particularly when you're asking them questions about difficult things.
- 13:28[SPEAKER_03]: And so you have to, you have to come up with ways to do that.
- 13:32[SPEAKER_03]: And so thinking about the people who might be covering your community, and it may be that you don't have.
- 13:40[SPEAKER_03]: local media anymore.
- 13:41[SPEAKER_03]: That's, you know, posted on blue sky this week.
- 13:43[SPEAKER_03]: I'm map of like the growing news deserts where people have nothing that covers their local news anymore.
- 13:48[SPEAKER_03]: So you may be relying on the PR person for your school board.
- 13:52[SPEAKER_03]: Wow.
- 13:52[SPEAKER_03]: To be your local media for what's going on with that.
- 13:55[SPEAKER_03]: That person still works for you.
- 13:58[SPEAKER_03]: And you can still call them and say, you know, I would expect that you would publish on your website like not just like the minutes of the meetings, but like what it means for parents.
- 14:08[SPEAKER_03]: or something like that.
- 14:09[SPEAKER_03]: So that's information that the public needs.
- 14:13[SPEAKER_03]: And if the PIO is not interested in communicating with you about this, it has to learn how to do this this time.
- 14:19[SPEAKER_03]: You can go to the people you will like to do to your school board and say, hey, your PIO needs to do this.
- 14:24[SPEAKER_03]: Right, and when they call that, yeah, it'll accept the phone.
- 14:27[SPEAKER_01]: So, that's so interesting to me because I see this all the time with younger people.
- 14:33[SPEAKER_01]: They, I think partly probably because of COVID and because of a lot of other media and phone and just devices.
- 14:43[SPEAKER_01]: I've noticed the younger people, like it is the face-to-face conduct that throws them completely off.
- 14:49[SPEAKER_01]: You know, and the, and they just don't seem to be able to find a way in.
- 14:55[SPEAKER_01]: And I thought it was interesting in the study that you talked about in the journal club that, that I would have thought that most people would have said the place they got their news with social media.
- 15:05[SPEAKER_01]: And the fact that that was the fifth place was that correct.
- 15:09[SPEAKER_01]: And that, that shocked me.
- 15:11[SPEAKER_01]: I was like, oh, maybe it's not as bad as I think, but I hadn't really considered, are they getting anything?
- 15:17[SPEAKER_03]: really.
- 15:18[SPEAKER_03]: I feel like their participants were a little anomalous in that because there's a a bunch of studies that have shown that it's been social media for five or six years now that people have been getting their news from that.
- 15:31[SPEAKER_03]: But yeah, for this group, they were not as much.
- 15:34[SPEAKER_03]: And I thought that study was also interesting because and this is something else that the audience can do.
- 15:38[SPEAKER_03]: you probably don't have time to look at all the school board meetings and all the city council agendas and read their whole packet and everything like that.
- 15:46[SPEAKER_03]: But if you know people who do that, maybe like you have something you're really interested in like I have kids in school so I'm really interested in the school board and someone else is running a small business so they're really interested in like zoning and permitting or something like that, you can actually talk to the humans in your life about the news and you can share information that way and that's part of being
- 16:09[SPEAKER_02]: that we don't give ourselves enough credit in our own active daily lives of the actual work that is happening.
- 16:19[SPEAKER_02]: And I don't think we term it as contributions, right?
- 16:24[SPEAKER_02]: And I think that
- 16:26[SPEAKER_02]: Reframing our narratives, our definitions in our understanding of our actual work that many mothers and fathers are doing and are involved, but they don't consider it that, right?
- 16:42[SPEAKER_02]: They don't look at themselves as being important.
- 16:47[SPEAKER_02]: in daily lives.
- 16:48[SPEAKER_02]: And I think that that is going back to like when we were in COVID.
- 16:54[SPEAKER_02]: And everybody understood how important a nurse really is in this life.
- 17:02[SPEAKER_01]: right and how important a a civil engineer is in your world and that in that garbage people you know what I'm saying like all these jobs the guy who bags groceries the girl bags groceries in it like they became essential workers in a way that people hadn't thought they were.
- 17:25[SPEAKER_02]: And I think what you are talking about is getting people to understand that number one, you're already engaged.
- 17:37[SPEAKER_02]: And it's already important to you.
- 17:40[SPEAKER_02]: So I just think that we need to maybe redirect how we think about who we are to in our lives.
- 17:49[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah.
- 17:50[SPEAKER_03]: And it's not just important to us.
- 17:51[SPEAKER_03]: It's important to our community.
- 17:53[SPEAKER_03]: That's a, I did an episode on local journalism a couple weeks ago on the journal club and one of the things that they talked about was that local news just.
- 18:05[SPEAKER_03]: having somebody sit in a meeting just says, hey, people are paying attention to what you're doing.
- 18:09[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.
- 18:09[SPEAKER_03]: So it'll be pass and shady stuff.
- 18:11[SPEAKER_03]: You know what I mean?
- 18:12[SPEAKER_03]: So even just you're willing this to do that, even if like, a lot of the stuff is broadcast or live streamed now.
- 18:19[SPEAKER_03]: You know, even if you watch the school board two days later online and you just send an email to someone on the school board and say, you know, I have a question about this.
- 18:26[SPEAKER_03]: Then they know people are watching.
- 18:28[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.
- 18:28[SPEAKER_03]: And it changes their behavior.
- 18:30[SPEAKER_02]: Yes, yeah, and what it sounds like you're saying is it is about behavior because what I'm watching is are the walls coming in.
- 18:40[SPEAKER_02]: There's a pay wall.
- 18:42[SPEAKER_02]: Yes, wall of be disinterested be disconnected.
- 18:49[SPEAKER_02]: You're too busy.
- 18:50[SPEAKER_02]: We understand you.
- 18:52[SPEAKER_02]: You know what, land softly into HBO.
- 18:55[SPEAKER_02]: That's where we want your focus.
- 18:57[SPEAKER_02]: You know?
- 18:59[SPEAKER_03]: You know, there's another wall too, which is that everybody who doesn't agree with me on one thing is a terrible person who disagrees with me on everything.
- 19:08[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
- 19:09[SPEAKER_03]: And that is, a lot of that feeling is a direct result of the misinformation campaigns that we've been subjected to for the past two years.
- 19:16[SPEAKER_02]: Can you talk to us about a little bit speak to misinformation?
- 19:21[SPEAKER_02]: Is it still going on in the, is it, well, how has it changed from 2020 from 2016 to 2020 to 24?
- 19:33[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, okay.
- 19:34[SPEAKER_03]: So, yes, it has changed.
- 19:37[SPEAKER_03]: 2016, you were seeing kind of a mix of sources for that.
- 19:43[SPEAKER_03]: So, there are actual like efforts and we do this too to other countries.
- 19:48[SPEAKER_03]: But actual efforts to have like weakening propaganda campaigns that go across national borders.
- 19:54[SPEAKER_03]: And the idea basically is that if people are fighting each other, they're not paying attention to you.
- 19:58[SPEAKER_03]: Right, and so that's what we saw in 2016 with the Cambridge Analytica, and all the other things that happened around that.
- 20:05[SPEAKER_03]: 2020, a lot of it was focused on COVID kinds of stuff, but kind of the same actors, but we've seen a big sea change with AI.
- 20:14[SPEAKER_03]: Because what AI has made it possible to do is to create a lot of good looking bad information quickly and at a low cost.
- 20:23[SPEAKER_03]: Wow.
- 20:25[SPEAKER_03]: Yes, and, you know, Hintley talked about the paywalls, right?
- 20:31[SPEAKER_03]: And I think what is going to happen is that only people with resources are going to have access to quality information.
- 20:39[SPEAKER_03]: Thank you.
- 20:40[SPEAKER_01]: I'm because it's crazy because we, you know, we use the news because we do a news podcast and I can't tell you how long every time I want to send her an article or she wants to send me an article, we can't do it.
- 20:56[SPEAKER_01]: You know, because you get to read it once that was your one for the month or that was your one for the week or that, you know, and we have to pay for all these services and I'm like, okay, I do this for my job, so we'll do that, but if I'm just somebody, you know, somebody who doesn't do this for my job, especially nowadays in the economic mess that we're in am I going to pay.
- 21:17[SPEAKER_01]: you know, $20 a month or whatever, $5 even a month to read news?
- 21:22[SPEAKER_01]: No, I'm just going to look for where is it free.
- 21:27[SPEAKER_02]: And to add on to what she's saying, the way that they hooked us on Uber,
- 21:34[SPEAKER_02]: right, was these cheap rides?
- 21:37[SPEAKER_02]: What do I even need a car, right?
- 21:40[SPEAKER_02]: And that we've gotten, they've destroyed the cabin industry, the medallion industry, all of those things and then jacked up the prices, right?
- 21:49[SPEAKER_02]: Same thing to me with AI with, uh,
- 21:53[SPEAKER_02]: This is going to add 60 IQ points.
- 21:56[SPEAKER_02]: Wonderful.
- 21:57[SPEAKER_02]: That's great.
- 21:58[SPEAKER_02]: But if we get everybody hooked on that, and then that becomes a, becomes a paywall to information, because we've decided to stop learning because AI can do it for us.
- 22:13[SPEAKER_02]: What, what happened?
- 22:15[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, we weren't learning that well before, too.
- 22:17[SPEAKER_01]: Like, we weren't not going out of the park on learning.
- 22:20[SPEAKER_03]: Before they say, yeah, that's even like a whole different issue.
- 22:25[SPEAKER_03]: Like, people getting news from AI, which is,
- 22:29[SPEAKER_03]: rapidly increasing trends.
- 22:30[SPEAKER_03]: So actually getting news from AI chat bots using them as search engines.
- 22:35[SPEAKER_03]: And yeah, that could be a whole other episode for that.
- 22:40[SPEAKER_03]: There's like all kinds of costs with doing that.
- 22:43[SPEAKER_03]: But you know, we're starting to see something even with some of the, uh,
- 22:46[SPEAKER_03]: large AM models.
- 22:47[SPEAKER_03]: It's called Monaco Labs.
- 22:49[SPEAKER_03]: We're basically AI's trained on publicly available data rate.
- 22:53[SPEAKER_03]: And people who work like and marketing love AI because they can write all their articles that are going to show up in search and they don't really have to write them anymore because they're right them for them.
- 23:04[SPEAKER_03]: And what's happening is now AI is training itself on the stuff that it produced.
- 23:07[SPEAKER_03]: So there's like there's nothing real in there anymore.
- 23:09[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah.
- 23:11[SPEAKER_01]: And it's the which is like crazy.
- 23:15[SPEAKER_03]: But, you know, if you're not the person who's going to be able to pay 250 dollars a year to subscribe to the new times or whatever, that is the information that you have access to.
- 23:25[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.
- 23:26[SPEAKER_03]: And that's going to be really scary.
- 23:29[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, and because what I'm watching it, it's an aura of us, but at the end of the day, nobody ever asks, is eating yourself nutritious?
- 23:39[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 23:43[SPEAKER_02]: Because the product is, because if it isn't nutrition, that means that every time that it's creating it, it's recreating itself, it is degraded.
- 23:54[SPEAKER_01]: That's right, because we can't actually recreate it, or so.
- 23:57[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 23:58[SPEAKER_01]: We just start disappearing.
- 24:00[SPEAKER_01]: I think if we're in here, so.
- 24:03[SPEAKER_02]: So the capitalism of AI, feeding on itself is my question in terms of media.
- 24:12[SPEAKER_02]: In terms of, because every time it spits out a product, it's degraded.
- 24:21[SPEAKER_02]: Because, you know, there is no new, if it's eating itself, you know what I'm saying?
- 24:28[SPEAKER_02]: Right, right.
- 24:28[SPEAKER_02]: Speeding on itself, if it's educating itself, especially based on, I cannot believe.
- 24:38[SPEAKER_02]: that we are dependent in terms of media on something that already was flawed, that we're just putting our flawed information into a system and saying now spit it back to us.
- 24:55[SPEAKER_03]: Right, spit it back to us and make it better and by better and it's more of what we like, but it's empty calories.
- 25:00[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, I see what you're saying.
- 25:01[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 25:02[SPEAKER_01]: I, you know, one of the things I thought was interesting too in the journal club, this was the idea they, you know, talking to this, so this was a study research into why conservatives think that the media is liberal, liberally biased.
- 25:19[SPEAKER_01]: And so I thought that one of the things that they came up with is the conservatives will see the news as biased if it does not
- 25:32[SPEAKER_01]: See, that to me says, you know, this is a losing battle, having a conversation with conservatives.
- 25:42[SPEAKER_03]: So, you know, went out the only as conservatives in the study.
- 25:45[SPEAKER_03]: Yes, they only did.
- 25:46[SPEAKER_03]: I don't know if you look at the blue sky feed.
- 25:48[SPEAKER_03]: I think you would find a lot of people who would say the same thing, the other direction.
- 25:52[SPEAKER_03]: Yes, I'm sorry.
- 25:54[SPEAKER_03]: So like, you know, the Washington Post published this A column by a conservative writer, like, oh, the post is completely a piece of garbage now.
- 26:00[SPEAKER_03]: Right.
- 26:01[SPEAKER_03]: I think that on both sides, for sure.
- 26:02[SPEAKER_03]: Yes.
- 26:04[SPEAKER_01]: I just find it fascinating that we can't agree on reality.
- 26:11[SPEAKER_03]: That is the huge problem.
- 26:13[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I do.
- 26:16[SPEAKER_01]: Because I don't know how to, you can't, it feels like, okay, I tend to be a little bit of a Vulcan, you know, and so I have this problem with, if we can't both agree that green is green, how do we have a conversation, particularly about color?
- 26:30[SPEAKER_01]: So I, you know, and it feels like we're stuck in these sorts of, just head budding, sort of moments where you've got Kellyanne Conway, who I think should be considered a criminal for coming up with alternative facts as a phrase.
- 26:48[SPEAKER_01]: What do we do?
- 26:50[SPEAKER_03]: you agree on, if you don't agree on the facts themselves, you agree on a methodology for finding facts were a long way away from that.
- 26:58[SPEAKER_01]: But yeah, because they'll believe that there's a lot of people, Trump, in particular, don't believe that President Obama was born in the United States.
- 27:05[SPEAKER_01]: And the only way we could prove that to their satisfaction would be to have a time machine where we took them back to the birth.
- 27:13[SPEAKER_01]: Like they won't take the documents.
- 27:15[SPEAKER_01]: They won't take the witness statements.
- 27:19[SPEAKER_01]: I, you know, it feels like we're in this trap.
- 27:22[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah.
- 27:24[SPEAKER_03]: Oh.
- 27:24[SPEAKER_03]: We can all agree that.
- 27:26[SPEAKER_01]: And I'd like you to solve it right now.
- 27:27[SPEAKER_01]: No.
- 27:28[SPEAKER_03]: Okay.
- 27:29[SPEAKER_03]: So we could all agree that we're going to go to the reflecting pool with a pantong book.
- 27:33[SPEAKER_03]: I'm going to hold a college ship since I went past to win matches and then read what the name says.
- 27:38[SPEAKER_03]: Right.
- 27:38[SPEAKER_03]: We could all agree that that's what we're going to do.
- 27:40[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 27:41[SPEAKER_03]: Right.
- 27:41[SPEAKER_03]: We can make that choice because fundamentally all the stuff that we agree on for how we find truth.
- 27:46[SPEAKER_03]: We've made choices on, we chose to follow the scientific method and now we've chosen to not always follow the scientific method and we've chosen to put trust in courts and now we've chosen to not put trust in courts.
- 27:56[SPEAKER_03]: Right.
- 27:56[SPEAKER_03]: But those are all choices that we've made.
- 27:58[SPEAKER_03]: We could continue to make those choices, but we can only do that if we're still talking to each other.
- 28:02[SPEAKER_03]: Right.
- 28:12[SPEAKER_02]: And so my question in terms of, let's talk about media and talking to each other and having the conversation and making connections, right?
- 28:24[SPEAKER_02]: Because, you know, I see it all the time.
- 28:28[SPEAKER_02]: There are literally people who go, I say, we watch something on thoughts.
- 28:33[SPEAKER_02]: People won't look at it.
- 28:36[SPEAKER_02]: They won't, they won't spend the time.
- 28:45[SPEAKER_02]: include more conversation into the conversation, more ideas, the end stop rejecting them because what I see often happening are arguments being made.
- 28:59[SPEAKER_02]: Yes.
- 29:00[SPEAKER_02]: And people having to defend arguments if it's slogans.
- 29:05[SPEAKER_02]: Yes.
- 29:05[SPEAKER_02]: Instead of, you know, concepts.
- 29:09[SPEAKER_02]: What do we do?
- 29:11[SPEAKER_03]: Oh, so we
- 29:14[SPEAKER_03]: ask people about why they believe what they believe.
- 29:19[SPEAKER_03]: I haven't done this in a while.
- 29:20[SPEAKER_03]: But are you still always talk about a series of questions that you could use to figure out where someone's coming from, right?
- 29:31[SPEAKER_03]: What are you saying?
- 29:32[SPEAKER_03]: When you say this, I'm understanding that you mean this, is this what you mean?
- 29:36[SPEAKER_03]: And that's a really great place to start because a lot of times, like,
- 29:40[SPEAKER_03]: You know, to mean, and then, you know, why do you believe this, where did you hear it, why do you think that's a good source, you know, and not like, well, that's a bad source, which is usually right, want to jump in and say, but just like, you know, explain to me, right, oh, so, you know, this person says that their cousin works for the department of defense, how do you know that?
- 30:01[SPEAKER_03]: Do you know anything beyond what they said?
- 30:02[SPEAKER_03]: Could I say my cousin's a space alien?
- 30:04[SPEAKER_03]: Would that be the same kind of thing?
- 30:06[SPEAKER_03]: And you don't have to be obnoxious about that?
- 30:08[SPEAKER_03]: Right.
- 30:09[SPEAKER_03]: You can have a genuine sense of curiosity about other people and what they think and what they believe.
- 30:13[SPEAKER_03]: When I feel like that's both courteous and effective.
- 30:16[SPEAKER_03]: So...
- 30:17[SPEAKER_01]: You know, it reminds me of, this comes up from me all the time in our work, but we were filling in for Stephanie Miller many years ago, one week in a guy called in, it must have been right when the elections like 2015 or something like that, and he said, he called in and he said, this is a liberal news show, absolutely a hundred percent.
- 30:40[SPEAKER_01]: But he, and I don't know if he was a regular listener, I don't know anything about him.
- 30:43[SPEAKER_01]: But he called it and said Hillary Clinton belongs in jail.
- 30:47[SPEAKER_01]: She just does, belonging in jail.
- 30:48[SPEAKER_01]: And I was like, OK, and I'm not being so... And they literally said something like, I'm not being sarcastic.
- 30:53[SPEAKER_01]: I just want to ask you, what is the charge?
- 30:56[SPEAKER_01]: And this was, he went, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh.
- 31:00[SPEAKER_01]: What is the charge?
- 31:01[SPEAKER_01]: What do you mean?
- 31:01[SPEAKER_01]: What is the charge?
- 31:03[SPEAKER_01]: I'm not trying to be flippant or sarcastic.
- 31:05[SPEAKER_01]: I'm just asking because the way our system works is you have to charge someone
- 31:10[SPEAKER_01]: to put them eventually in jail, right?
- 31:13[SPEAKER_01]: If they found guilty, whatever.
- 31:14[SPEAKER_01]: So what do you want to charge with?
- 31:16[SPEAKER_01]: Well, isn't it clear?
- 31:17[SPEAKER_01]: I'm like, not to me, it's not clear to me.
- 31:19[SPEAKER_01]: So do you have any ideas, even?
- 31:21[SPEAKER_01]: I'm not saying that you'd be right.
- 31:22[SPEAKER_01]: I just want to know, and he wouldn't.
- 31:24[SPEAKER_01]: He couldn't answer, and it felt like this is, and then he just was like, you know, said something hostile and hung up.
- 31:31[SPEAKER_01]: And that's, it feels like,
- 31:34[SPEAKER_01]: One of my feelings in that is that I feel like we spend an enormous amount of time concerned about, as I call it, I'm a shorthand to try to recruit at the clan rally.
- 31:43[SPEAKER_01]: Like we just, I don't know why we do this.
- 31:45[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know why we engage in in this back and forth with grand dragons of the Ku Klux clan, sometimes.
- 31:52[SPEAKER_01]: But also, just, I was just asking, what did she do that's criminal?
- 31:58[SPEAKER_01]: What does, what do you hear in that moment?
- 32:02[SPEAKER_03]: I think you did the right thing, um, even though they're going to have a hostile reaction like confirmation bias is a hell of a drug, um, right?
- 32:10[SPEAKER_03]: People believe what they believe and it's like,
- 32:13[SPEAKER_03]: actually physically demanding on your brain from what I understand from neuroscientists to change your mind about things.
- 32:18[SPEAKER_03]: Wow.
- 32:19[SPEAKER_03]: Right.
- 32:19[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, like physically uses extra energy in your brain or something like that, not neuroscientists, so don't call me.
- 32:25[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah.
- 32:25[SPEAKER_02]: But I want to stay safe in whatever beliefs they are, even if they harm us.
- 32:30[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah.
- 32:31[SPEAKER_03]: And it's like, so.
- 32:34[SPEAKER_03]: And people can't change their mind, but they have to change their mind.
- 32:37[SPEAKER_03]: I can't do it for them.
- 32:38[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 32:39[SPEAKER_03]: But if I let them know that it's safe to think about it, right, because I'm not just gonna yell at you or hang up on you or something like that, that's where you gotta start.
- 32:49[SPEAKER_01]: You know, I who I think did that masterfully and I have no proof of this is President Obama.
- 32:54[SPEAKER_01]: I know not for one minute believe that President Obama had a problem with gay marriage.
- 32:59[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think he did.
- 33:04[SPEAKER_01]: transformation.
- 33:05[SPEAKER_01]: I forget the word that they generally were used all the time for it in the way he approached it was, it made it okay for everyone who maybe had a thought, thought something, need to sort of like this version.
- 33:17[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 33:18[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 33:18[SPEAKER_01]: But he made it okay to to feel to have felt that way.
- 33:22[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.
- 33:22[SPEAKER_01]: And okay to, yeah, created a permission, permission structure for not having been woke, if you will, about this.
- 33:29[SPEAKER_01]: And I thought that was brilliant because I just don't believe that they don't know him, but that's how it struck me.
- 33:37[SPEAKER_01]: It's like I was like, I think what he just did was actually really smart.
- 33:40[SPEAKER_01]: Because there are all these people who kind of care don't care, you know, about something like this, but they may have a feeling about it.
- 33:48[SPEAKER_01]: Providing a thing in space.
- 33:50[SPEAKER_03]: Yes.
- 33:52[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, absolutely.
- 33:53[SPEAKER_03]: And you don't.
- 33:55[SPEAKER_03]: you don't always have to get into a fight someone's trying to drag you into right.
- 33:59[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know.
- 33:59[SPEAKER_01]: I think about like the president and the Pope.
- 34:01[SPEAKER_03]: Like only one person's really fighting there.
- 34:03[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, amazing.
- 34:05[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah.
- 34:06[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.
- 34:07[SPEAKER_02]: So what should we be doing with the media that we are exposed to in terms of being good consumers of media and not just swallowing everything we we read or rejecting you know, when we can give us some tips on balancing this information that we are
- 34:33[SPEAKER_02]: consuming.
- 34:35[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, so step one is always click the links.
- 34:38[SPEAKER_03]: Um, whenever you see stuff in social media or like at least before you share something at least like the link and read it most people don't Like a huge percentage of people don't but you should do that.
- 34:50[SPEAKER_03]: Oh, yeah, so that would be number one Looking for the source behind the source can sometimes be helpful if it's something that you're not familiar with So you can sometimes they'll just have an about page and that will tell you a lot and it's not
- 35:07[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 35:08[SPEAKER_03]: I feel like information is information and you can make a judgment on the information.
- 35:12[SPEAKER_03]: If that makes sense, I'm not always like, oh, well, it's came from the source.
- 35:16[SPEAKER_03]: Therefore, the fact must be wrong.
- 35:18[SPEAKER_03]: That's a kind of fallacy.
- 35:20[SPEAKER_03]: But you can see, like, if somebody, like, would be motivated to share with you in a particular way, and that just kind of helps you understand what it is that you're seeing.
- 35:29[SPEAKER_03]: So, like, what am I seeing?
- 35:31[SPEAKER_03]: What does it actually say?
- 35:32[SPEAKER_03]: I
- 35:34[SPEAKER_03]: Why did this person say this?
- 35:36[SPEAKER_03]: Right, what did they want from me when I saw it?
- 35:40[UNKNOWN]: interesting.
- 35:42[SPEAKER_02]: What do they want from me versus what do I want from this?
- 35:46[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 35:46[SPEAKER_02]: You know, verse, you know, because I think what motivates a lot of us to click a link to dive deeper is a issue or a warrant or desire from within.
- 36:01[SPEAKER_02]: And I never think about what does the person from the
- 36:11[SPEAKER_02]: I think everybody, when I'm reading, I'm thinking, I'm reading thinking about what I want from this piece of information.
- 36:21[SPEAKER_03]: But everybody communicates for a reason, right?
- 36:23[SPEAKER_01]: That's exactly.
- 36:24[SPEAKER_01]: One of my favorite quotes from Gregory Robasa, every act of communication is an act of translation.
- 36:33[SPEAKER_01]: And in terms of a judge, making a judgment on the information, I have a brother who,
- 36:39[SPEAKER_01]: He was lean, he was, he leaned conservative, and he, uh, not Trump, but conservative, and he sent me some books that he wanted me to read because, you know, I'm the family crazy radical liberal.
- 36:52[SPEAKER_01]: So, and I read one, it was supposedly, it was supposed to be about Al Qaeda, but it ended up being about ISIS, and, and I was reading it, and I, you know, I'm a person who looks at footnotes, which I know isn't maybe not normal.
- 37:05[SPEAKER_01]: Um, so I looked at the footnotes and every piece of so-called information in this book was the source was an article written by the guy who wrote that book.
- 37:17[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, self-requencing himself.
- 37:19[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, but yeah, but exactly, but if you looked at the pages and you never looked at, you never went and checked out where these all these footnotes were from.
- 37:26[SPEAKER_01]: You're just like, oh, this is sourced.
- 37:28[SPEAKER_01]: He got this in out someplace, but the source is him.
- 37:33[SPEAKER_01]: And, and I was told that to my brother, and it just sort of made a angry.
- 37:35[SPEAKER_01]: I was like, I'm just saying that if you're using this as information, I don't know if that's a great.
- 37:43[SPEAKER_01]: That's the or a bus eaten itself.
- 37:45[SPEAKER_02]: That's what that is.
- 37:47[SPEAKER_01]: And I also just felt like fraud almost because it's like you're gust seeing this up like you said good looking.
- 37:52[SPEAKER_01]: I thought struck me earlier when you said that good looking in bad information.
- 37:56[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.
- 37:56[SPEAKER_01]: That they, you know, they can make it look really good.
- 38:00[SPEAKER_01]: But it isn't, but then I don't know if you're familiar with this study and I don't remember any of the statistics I'm still going to talk about it.
- 38:08[SPEAKER_01]: But I know a few years ago there was a study about high school students not being able to tell what was opinion and what was being stated as some sort of fact.
- 38:18[SPEAKER_01]: And that I find in.
- 38:21[SPEAKER_01]: That's where I get really stuck in watching the news, because I feel like they do a lot of all of them do these sort of subtle editorials, it by word choice, and this is a great example, but one example is when we call people who leave America a wealthy country to move someplace else, we call them expats, but people who come here, we call refugees or immigrants.
- 38:52[SPEAKER_01]: But they have different terms and different connotations, and I feel like there's an editorialization, you know, there's a judgment in the use of those terms.
- 39:00[SPEAKER_01]: How do we?
- 39:00[SPEAKER_01]: I feel like I'm parsing it out in a way that just makes people's tune me out.
- 39:05[SPEAKER_01]: But what do you think about that about this, the way that words matter and we aren't training ourselves or each other and how to to deal with that?
- 39:18[SPEAKER_03]: I think we've been told for so long that the news is not biased, or it's not supposed to be biased, that we fail to recognize that information is always biased, just by what you choose to store in what you don't have to write that down to, if it's always biased.
- 39:35[SPEAKER_03]: And I feel like, it's interesting that you mentioned high school students because whenever I talk about people being media literate, usually people like, yeah, we need to put that in schools.
- 39:47[SPEAKER_03]: And like, that's not the problem.
- 39:49[SPEAKER_03]: Like kids are in schools.
- 39:50[SPEAKER_03]: We could fix that easily.
- 39:51[SPEAKER_03]: There's lots of good curriculum.
- 39:52[SPEAKER_03]: And like, that's just a, that's an easy fix.
- 39:54[SPEAKER_03]: It's the adults, right?
- 39:56[SPEAKER_03]: Like it's, it's people my age and it's people.
- 39:59[SPEAKER_03]: you know, younger than me, but at the time that they stopped teaching that because we went into more like math and language testing.
- 40:06[SPEAKER_03]: So I feel like that is just being aware of how people communicate, right, and that like people are going to be choosing words.
- 40:15[SPEAKER_03]: And ideally, you have friends who see things in different ways and you talk to each other.
- 40:19[SPEAKER_03]: And someone can say, you know, I noticed that
- 40:26[SPEAKER_03]: Right, or something like that.
- 40:29[SPEAKER_02]: Right, right, right.
- 40:30[SPEAKER_02]: And I would love for you to take us out here talking about detecting deception, your book.
- 40:40[SPEAKER_02]: And what I love about this book is it's tools for fighting to fight fake news and every chapter title.
- 40:50[SPEAKER_02]: Every, I mean, I need every chapter title because it is all of the things that we are experiencing and watching on shows for me like CNN.
- 41:04[SPEAKER_02]: I feel like we are.
- 41:07[SPEAKER_02]: we are the audience to watch the them set up again almost like a UFC fake fight every night on television with words.
- 41:18[SPEAKER_02]: Can you talk to us about your book and talk to us a little bit about the tools for a little bit?
- 41:23[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, absolutely.
- 41:24[SPEAKER_03]: So a lot of it.
- 41:27[SPEAKER_03]: The reason it feels like that on CNN again is because everyone communicates with goals right and so they want to set up conflict and you can't agree because the motion keeps you watching essentially and their business needs to make money all media or businesses.
- 41:39[SPEAKER_03]: So that's like first principle.
- 41:41[SPEAKER_03]: So I actually wrote that book to be like a supplementary textbook for journalism students.
- 41:46[SPEAKER_03]: with the idea being that a lot of journalism now is more transcription than it is reporting.
- 41:54[SPEAKER_03]: If that makes sense, like you go to a, you know, event and you hold your phone up and you record it and then you publish the clips from that and that's what most people are going to see.
- 42:02[SPEAKER_03]: And so we need to
- 42:05[SPEAKER_03]: We need to develop the skills to tell when people are using language deceptively, which happens early and often.
- 42:15[SPEAKER_03]: There is a body of knowledge on how to do that, like the formal study of rhetoric that my colleagues do over in the English department.
- 42:21[SPEAKER_03]: And that is the same things that are in the book that I wrote, but with fancy Latin names and truth tables and stuff like that.
- 42:28[SPEAKER_03]: And it's super fascinating if you have a lot of time and you really want to dig into it and most people don't have that.
- 42:34[SPEAKER_03]: So I wanted to have like kind of quick reference ideas that you could have so that when you hear that you're like, oh, that's wrong.
- 42:39[SPEAKER_03]: Why must that be wrong?
- 42:43[SPEAKER_02]: and and what I love about it and for the lay person like me or us or anybody who might be listening to it's a really wonderful study of what am I hearing?
- 42:55[SPEAKER_02]: What am I seeing in my media?
- 42:58[SPEAKER_02]: And now this is the name for it, right?
- 43:02[SPEAKER_02]: Oh, yeah, he's using the straw man strategy.
- 43:05[SPEAKER_02]: Oh, yeah.
- 43:06[SPEAKER_02]: This is the sunk cost fallacy here going on right now.
- 43:10[SPEAKER_02]: It allows it helps us see and name what is happening to us.
- 43:18[SPEAKER_03]: You know, yeah, I know.
- 43:20[SPEAKER_03]: I mean, that's all it's critical thinking kind of things.
- 43:23[SPEAKER_03]: But what I hope for is that when people get good at noticing that kinds of things, they'll stop sharing them.
- 43:31[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you so much, Dr. Sturgeon.
- 43:34[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you so much for being here and cheering with us.
- 43:38[SPEAKER_01]: Everybody you need to check out her podcast on Spun on MSW Media.
- 43:41[SPEAKER_01]: What are you doing if you aren't already?
- 43:43[SPEAKER_01]: And get the book, y'all, so we can talk about.
- 43:45[SPEAKER_01]: We don't have a supplemental textbook for our lives, called Detecting Deception Tools to Fight Fake News.
- 43:51[SPEAKER_03]: Thank you so much.
- 43:52[SPEAKER_03]: Thank you.
- 43:53[SPEAKER_03]: It was great to be here.
- 43:54[SPEAKER_02]: Thank you.
- 43:56[SPEAKER_02]: I'm Francis Calier.
- 43:57[SPEAKER_02]: I'm Angela V. Shelton.
- 43:58[SPEAKER_02]: We are Franchola.
- 43:59[SPEAKER_02]: Thank you so much for listening to the final order.