Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / Expert insight: Interview with Senior Advocate Vivek Sood on his new book on India's Criminal Justice System
Transcript
- 0:12Welcome to this episode of our special series, 10 minutes with
- 0:15Vivek suit with Supreme Court senior Advocate and country's
- 0:19top legal Minds the man who coined the expression the
- 0:22fundamental right to internet. Today we will understand from
- 0:27him about his upcoming book shelf and rain that's going to
- 0:30be released in a few weeks from now.
- 0:33Welcome to the show sir. Thank you.
- 0:36So sir what is this new book all about?
- 0:41I guess it is your sixth or seventh books.
- 0:44Yes it is my seventh book and Chef and grain is about the
- 0:51criminal justice system in India.
- 0:56Nobody has written about the criminal justice system that we
- 1:00have in India. So therefore, I chose this
- 1:04subject which is close to my heart because I have been a
- 1:09defense counsel the criminal side Council for three decades
- 1:13now. Chef and grain is about the
- 1:17functioning and malfunctioning of the Criminal Justice System,
- 1:22he deals with some of the pressing issues.
- 1:26Is that confront the Indian criminal justice system today?
- 1:32Okay. Okay.
- 1:33Who is this book for sir? Is it only for the legal
- 1:36Community? Or is it for leaders like me
- 1:39too? So I have taken care to ensure
- 1:46that the book is not only for the legal Community.
- 1:51You know, anybody interested in this subject of the Indian
- 1:55criminal justice system, can pick up this book and browse
- 2:01through it, you know, AJ, whenever we open the newspapers
- 2:07in the morning, Crime stories evoke special interest in the
- 2:15minds of the general readers also.
- 2:18So I thought that I should write a book which appeals to the
- 2:23Common Man, the common reader, the general reader, you know,
- 2:27General readers across the Spectrum are interested in the
- 2:33Indian Criminal Justice System, how it functions, how it
- 2:37malfunctions, you know, Bailey. Not jail.
- 2:40People are being arrested and all these murder cases and rape
- 2:45cases and all kinds of criminal cases.
- 2:48You know, they are highlighted in the media.
- 2:51So I wanted to give a perspective about the Indian
- 2:54criminal justice system to the lady does also apart from the
- 3:00legal community. So therefore, I have written
- 3:03this book in a journalistic format devoid of, you know,
- 3:08technical job. Argan devoid of, you know, those
- 3:12provisions of law sections, when so, of so-and-so, Etc.
- 3:16So, I've written it everything. This book in a story like
- 3:20format, Right? Sir?
- 3:24Or audience would be interested to know what are the issues and
- 3:28subjects you have covered in this book because this is such a
- 3:32vast area about the criminal justice system, and people would
- 3:36be interested to know more about this.
- 3:39So, I have selected pressing issues contemporary issues, you
- 3:45know that can send the Indian criminal justice system today,
- 3:50for instance, you know, the false case is that enter the
- 3:54criminal justice system, that is the abuse of criminal law, that
- 3:59happens rampantly in the Indian criminal justice system.
- 4:04So, I've written about How old is false cases make their way
- 4:10into the criminal justice system and what are the imperative
- 4:13reforms required to put a check on the abuse of criminal law,
- 4:20they have, then I have gone on to examine the question bail,
- 4:25not jail or jail, not bail, you know, should bail be liberally?
- 4:29Granted in all kinds of cases. Or in certain cases, jail,
- 4:35should be the rule and bail should be an exception.
- 4:39So I have critiqued, this bail Justice in India, in one of my
- 4:44chapters, then I have gone on to examine the problems in the
- 4:51investigative part of the Criminal Justice System, shoddy
- 4:55investigation, corrupt investigation, dishonest
- 4:59investigation, false implication, through
- 5:02investigation. In fact, I have coined, the
- 5:05expression Mal vestigation in my book And then I have gone on to
- 5:11examine some of the media highlighted cases.
- 5:16You know for example the Jessica LOL Case Creator son Ima to rape
- 5:20murder case, the nearby aquellas and I and J I have given my take
- 5:27on the other, Russia murder case.
- 5:29Also you know because you have a verdict of conviction by the
- 5:34session spot and you have a verdict of conviction, you have
- 5:38a verdict of acquittal Tell by the high court.
- 5:41So I have given my views on this on this arushi murder case.
- 5:46You know I have tried to unravel this mystery of all Russia
- 5:51murder. Then a j.
- 5:54I have gone on To write on social media, abuse, you know,
- 6:02should it be an offense? How should it be word it?
- 6:06Because section 66 a, as we all know was grossly misused.
- 6:12And finally it was struck down by the Supreme Court in Shreya
- 6:16singles case. So I have gone on to examine
- 6:20whether do we need an offence of social media abuse?
- 6:24If so how should it be? How should it be defined?
- 6:29I have also redefined sedition for the policymakers in the, how
- 6:35should say addition we defined it should be defined in a manner
- 6:39that the law is not abused by the law enforcement agencies.
- 6:43You know, sense are not roped in for the offense of sedition.
- 6:48So these are some of the pressing issues.
- 6:51I have dealt with in this book. Right sir, sir, you have been a
- 6:55senior Advocate now especially at the Supreme Court of India.
- 7:00You have dealt with many cases. How have you dealt with issues
- 7:05looking from the accused point of view, or looking at, from the
- 7:09point of victims of crimes? This book definitely leans in
- 7:15favour of the accused. You know, if I compare this book
- 7:20talks about criminal justice, And criminal Injustice in India.
- 7:27And definitely I have looked at more from the perspective of the
- 7:32accused, who's The Condemned man?
- 7:34You know, every every accused is presumed to be innocent until
- 7:39proven guilty. So the book focuses on the
- 7:44accused in fact, in one of my chapters, I have called the
- 7:48accused who are falsely. Implicated, in criminal cases,
- 7:53What incarcerated for years together in jail on false
- 7:58accusations? I have called such acused men.
- 8:02As victims of crime, they are the real victims of crime.
- 8:07So the book in my view leans in favour of the accused, but at
- 8:12the end of it, you know, the book is about Criminal Justice,
- 8:18right sir. That's a very interesting topic
- 8:21and interesting subject that you have chosen sir and I'm sure a
- 8:25lot of people including people like me will be looking forward
- 8:29to this book. So when exactly is this book
- 8:32coming out The book is likely to be released at the end of this
- 8:36month. And and I think, you know, I am
- 8:41told by the Publishers Bloomsbury, that one can
- 8:45pre-order this book on Amazon and some of the other sites.
- 8:51The book is already available for pre-order.
- 8:55Right. Sir, thank you so much for all
- 8:57this information, sir. And thank you for your take on
- 9:00such an important subject that concerns us all.
- 9:04Thank you once again. Thank you, thank you.