Latest / Interfaiths / Jewish-Muslim Declaration of Fraternity in Faith
Transcript
- 0:00So imagine, imagine discovering this like incredibly
- 0:03old legal contract, like written over a thousand
- 0:06years ago. Okay. I'm with you. Right. And you're
- 0:09reading through it and you suddenly realize that
- 0:11it proves your absolute bitterest rival, like
- 0:14the person you've been fighting with forever
- 0:16is actually written directly into your own family's
- 0:20will. Oh, wow. That is, yeah, that's a massive
- 0:23plot twist. It gets crazier, though, because
- 0:26not only are they in the will, but the patriarch
- 0:29of your family specifically left instructions
- 0:31saying that your own inheritance, like your cut
- 0:34of the deal, is completely dependent on how well
- 0:37you treat them. That is wild. I mean, that completely
- 0:41shatters the whole paradigm, right? Exactly.
- 0:44It totally upends the entire narrative you've
- 0:46been told your, you know, your whole life about
- 0:48who your enemies are and like who actually belongs
- 0:51in your house. Yeah, because suddenly you aren't
- 0:54just fighting over a property line anymore. You're
- 0:57dealing with this massive foundational crisis
- 1:00of your own identity. Right. Because the text
- 1:03you claim to revere so much is basically demanding
- 1:05that you embrace the exact person you've been
- 1:08conditioned to fight. Which brings us to today.
- 1:10Welcome to today's deep dive. And, you know,
- 1:13if you've been feeling just completely overwhelmed
- 1:16by the... Oh, the relentless 24 -7 cycle of international
- 1:21conflict. Which I think is everyone right now,
- 1:23honestly. Seriously, everyone. And just those
- 1:25deeply entrenched geopolitical narratives that
- 1:28seem to offer literally nothing but endless war.
- 1:33Well, today's focus provides this genuinely surprising,
- 1:36historically grounded rupture in that cycle.
- 1:40It really is a rupture. It's a total shift. So
- 1:43our mission today is to unpack a really... quiet,
- 1:47but I think monumentally ambitious event. It
- 1:50took place just three days ago, actually, on
- 1:52October 15, 2026. Right. Out at the G20 Interfaith
- 1:56Forum in Salt Lake City. Yeah, exactly. And the
- 2:00primary document on the table for us today is
- 2:02this newly released manifesto. It's called the
- 2:05Jewish Muslim Declaration of Fraternity in Faith.
- 2:08And we are also going to be examining its theological
- 2:11companion texts, right? Along with the... the
- 2:14speeches from its initial launch, which was back
- 2:16in 2025 in Cape Town, and this really highly
- 2:19detailed analytical article by Iqbal Akhtar.
- 2:22Right, the Akhtar article, which is titled From
- 2:25Coexistence to Co -Elevation. Yep, that's the
- 2:28one. But before we go literally any further,
- 2:31I want to establish a very, very clear framework
- 2:34for you, the listener. Super important. It really
- 2:37is, because the sources we are examining today,
- 2:39they are operating in the shadow of an ongoing...
- 2:42Absolutely devastating three year war. Yeah.
- 2:44And deeply painful geopolitical conflicts that
- 2:47have just fractured Jewish and Muslim relations
- 2:49globally. So I want to be absolutely clear here.
- 2:52Our mission today is not under any circumstances
- 2:55to endorse any political viewpoints. Right. We
- 2:58are absolutely not taking sides in the geopolitical
- 3:01arena here. No, not at all. And we are certainly
- 3:04not pretending that we're going to solve a generations
- 3:06long crisis on a deep dive today. Yeah. If only
- 3:09it were that easy. Right. But the goal here is
- 3:12strictly impartial analysis. We are looking at
- 3:15the architecture, basically, of the philosophical
- 3:17and theological ideas contained within these
- 3:20specific texts. Right. What they actually wrote
- 3:22down on paper. Exactly. Because the authors of
- 3:25this declaration, they're attempting to build
- 3:27what they call a theological grammar. A theological
- 3:30grammar. Yeah. Okay. Let's unpack this. What
- 3:33does that actually mean? Well, they're trying
- 3:34to reconstruct the underlying vocabulary and
- 3:37the structural rules of a relationship that,
- 3:39you know, in the modern era has been violently
- 3:42reduced to just mere politics. Right. It's like
- 3:45they're trying to find a new language because
- 3:46the old one is just completely broken. Yeah.
- 3:49A language that goes deeper than just treaties
- 3:51or borders. Okay. So let's start with the architects
- 3:55of this new grammar, right? Because their identities
- 3:57alone immediately challenge our expectations
- 3:59of who is in the room. Absolutely. The two main
- 4:02figures are fascinating. Yeah. So you have two
- 4:04primary authors stepping up to the podium in
- 4:07Salt Lake City. First, you've got Imam Talib
- 4:09Sharif. Right. And he is an African -American
- 4:12Muslim leader. He's actually a retired U .S.
- 4:15Air Force veteran with. I think over 30 years
- 4:17of military service. Wow, 30 years. Yeah, a long
- 4:20time. And he's the president of Masjid Muhammad,
- 4:23which is often referred to as the nation's mosque
- 4:26out in Washington, D .C. Okay. And then standing
- 4:29right beside him is Rabbi Dr. Yaakov Nagan. Right.
- 4:32So he is an Israeli rabbi. He's the president
- 4:35of the Jerusalem Interfaith Center. And he's
- 4:38this Orthodox scholar who has literally spent
- 4:41decades trying to bridge... rigorous religious
- 4:44study with practical peace building. So you've
- 4:48got these two men representing the International
- 4:51Coalition for Peace and Reconciliation and the
- 4:54Jerusalem Interfaith Center. And they are stepping
- 4:57forward right in the middle of the third year
- 5:00of really brutal war. Like they aren't ignoring
- 5:02the friction. The text explicitly names the agonizing
- 5:06reality on the ground. They have to. Yeah. Otherwise,
- 5:08no one would take them seriously. But they are
- 5:11demanding this shift in vocabulary that I just
- 5:13find kind of staggering. The entire document
- 5:16hinges on rejecting the word tolerance, and instead
- 5:20it demands what they call co -elevation. Co -elevation,
- 5:24yeah. That's the core of it. But wait, I have
- 5:27to push back here for a second. Both of these
- 5:29religions have these exclusionary theologies
- 5:32built directly into their fundamental texts,
- 5:35right? They do, historically speaking, yeah.
- 5:37So isn't co -elevation just like this? theological
- 5:40utopianism just written by two guys in a room
- 5:44completely detached from the reality of rockets
- 5:46and blockades and ethno -nationalism? Well, I
- 5:50mean, that is the immediate cynical critique
- 5:52that political realists always bring up, right?
- 5:54It's the obvious question. Sure. But Oktar's
- 5:56analysis points out that the authors actually
- 5:58view the current political reality, you know,
- 6:00the violence and the ethno -nationalism, as a
- 6:03symptom of a much deeper theological disease.
- 6:06Oh, interesting. A symptom, not the root cause.
- 6:09Exactly. So if you try to treat the symptom with
- 6:12just a generic political treaty or like a call
- 6:15for tolerance, you're going to fail. Because
- 6:18tolerance doesn't actually solve the underlying
- 6:20animosity. Right. And Oktar actually breaks down
- 6:23the functional mechanics of these terms in a
- 6:25really helpful way. He says tolerance is functionally
- 6:28a posture of restraint. A posture of restraint.
- 6:32OK, say more about that. So it is a calculated
- 6:35mechanism of holding back violence. It basically
- 6:38translates to I have the power to harm you, but
- 6:43I will consciously choose not to. As long as
- 6:45you stay on your side of the line. Oh, wow. So
- 6:48it's basically a heavily armed truce. Yes. An
- 6:51armed truce. And then you have coexistence, which
- 6:54is, you know, the classic buzzword of liberal
- 6:56democracies everywhere. Right. Everyone loves
- 6:58a coexistence bumper sticker. Exactly. But Oktar
- 7:02defines coexistence as just a posture of mere
- 7:05proximity. Proximity. by just being physically
- 7:08near each other. Yeah, it's the sociological
- 7:11reality of sharing a subway car or living on
- 7:14the same city grid. You occupy the same physical
- 7:16space, your economic lives might overlap at the
- 7:19grocery store, but your spiritual and cultural
- 7:22lives remain entirely parallel. Oh, I see. They
- 7:27never truly intersect, and they definitely don't
- 7:30nourish each other. Okay, so the Declaration
- 7:33essentially looks at tolerance and coexistence
- 7:36and says, Yeah, that's completely insufficient
- 7:38for actually avoiding war. Completely insufficient.
- 7:41So it demands fraternity instead. And it defines
- 7:46fraternity not as like a warm, fuzzy feeling,
- 7:49but as a binding relationship of obligation.
- 7:52A binding obligation. That's a heavy word. Very
- 7:57heavy. And then it pushes even further into this
- 7:59concept of co -elevation. The text actually explicitly
- 8:03states that the world is more blessed. because
- 8:06of the presence of the other. Wait, read that
- 8:09again. The world is more blessed because of the
- 8:13presence of the other. That is a massive mechanism
- 8:17to introduce into religious dialogue. It's huge.
- 8:19Because it's literally arguing that Judaism is
- 8:23functionally and spiritually incomplete without
- 8:25Islam. And Islam is incomplete without Judaism.
- 8:29I know it sounds really radical today, but the
- 8:32authors are actually sort of... playing the role
- 8:34of historical archaeologists here. Archaeologists.
- 8:37Right. How so? Because they're pointing out that
- 8:40this concept of co -elevation isn't some brand
- 8:43new modern invention. It is a historical fact
- 8:47that modern ethno -nationalism has just violently
- 8:50erased from our collective memory. Oh, right.
- 8:53They point to the Judeo -Islamic civilization.
- 8:56Yes, exactly. deeply integrated symbiosis that
- 9:01lasted for roughly a thousand years. See, this
- 9:03is the part of the background material that just
- 9:05blew my mind. We suffer from such acute historical
- 9:09amnesia. We really do. Like when we think of
- 9:12Jewish -Muslim relations, we tend to project
- 9:14the conflicts of the 20th and 21st centuries
- 9:16backward, right? We just assume they have literally
- 9:19been fighting for millennia. Which is just factually
- 9:22incorrect. Akhtar points out that for a millennium,
- 9:26The intellectual and the cultural centers of
- 9:28the Jewish world were actually entirely embedded
- 9:31within the Islamic world. Entirely embedded.
- 9:35You literally cannot separate them historically.
- 9:38Look at the mechanics of how knowledge transferred
- 9:40during this era. Take Moses' Maimonides, for
- 9:44example. Okay, Maimonides. Arguably the most
- 9:47influential Jewish philosopher and Torah scholar
- 9:49of the entire Middle Ages. Exactly. He lived
- 9:52in the 12th century. And he served as the personal
- 9:55physician to Saladin's court down in Egypt. Right.
- 9:58But more importantly, look at how he wrote his
- 10:00masterworks, like The Guide for the Perplexed.
- 10:03He wrote it in Judeo -Arabic, didn't he? Yes.
- 10:06He used the Arabic language, but he wrote it
- 10:08in Hebrew script. That is wild to think about
- 10:11today. It is. But it goes way deeper than just
- 10:15the language. Maimonides relied incredibly heavily
- 10:18on the philosophical frameworks that were developed
- 10:20by Islamic thinkers. People like Al -Farabi and
- 10:23Avicenna. Okay, so he's reading Islamic philosophy.
- 10:27Right, to synthesize ancient Greek Aristotelian
- 10:29logic with the Hebrew Torah. So Jewish theology
- 10:33literally evolved and expanded through its deep
- 10:36engagement with Islamic philosophy. Wow. That
- 10:39is what co -elevation looks like in practice.
- 10:41One tradition actually growing stronger because
- 10:44of the intellectual tools provided by the other.
- 10:46And it wasn't just elite philosophers hanging
- 10:49out in royal courts either. The sources mention
- 10:51the Cairo Geniza, which I think is perhaps the
- 10:54greatest historical proof of this day -to -day
- 10:56integration. The Geniza is absolutely fascinating.
- 10:59So just for the listener, a Geniza is essentially
- 11:02a storeroom and a synagogue. And it's where old
- 11:05documents that contain the name of God are kept
- 11:08because they're considered too holy to just throw
- 11:10in the trash. Right. You can't just discard them.
- 11:12Exactly. And in the late 1890s, scholars opened
- 11:15the Geniza of the Ben Ezra Synagogue in Cairo
- 11:18and they found... hundreds of thousands of documents
- 11:21that had just been preserved there for centuries.
- 11:23Yeah. And it was this unparalleled window into
- 11:26the actual mechanics of daily life back then.
- 11:28Because you didn't just find religious texts.
- 11:31You found the mundane, everyday paperwork of
- 11:33the Geniza merchants. Right. Grocery lists, receipts,
- 11:36trade agreements. Exactly. These were vast networks
- 11:39of Jewish traders whose businesses spanned from
- 11:41the Mediterranean all the way to India. And they
- 11:43were operating entirely within the legal and
- 11:45economic framework of the Islamic world. So you
- 11:48had Jewish merchants writing letters back home
- 11:50to Cairo discussing trade deals with their Muslim
- 11:52partners, right? Yeah. And utilizing Islamic
- 11:55courts for dispute resolution and basically sharing
- 11:58in the overarching cultural fabric of the time.
- 12:00And they were still distinct communities, right?
- 12:03They maintained rigorous adherence to Jewish
- 12:04law, but they were completely integrated into
- 12:07the broader Islamic civilization. You also see
- 12:10it in the art from that time, like in Andalusian
- 12:12Spain, the Jewish and Muslim poets were constantly
- 12:15exchanging structural techniques. Oh, the poetry
- 12:19is such a good example. Yeah, there's this specific
- 12:21form of Arabic stanzaic poetry called the Muwashah.
- 12:25Right. And it was completely adopted by Jewish
- 12:28poets. They use it to write these breathtaking
- 12:30Hebrew liturgical poems that are literally still
- 12:33sung in synagogues today. The languages and the
- 12:37rhythms were in this constant, beautiful conversation.
- 12:40So the overarching argument the Declaration is
- 12:43making here is that ethno -nationalism and religious
- 12:46supremacism, those are actually relatively modern
- 12:4920th century ideological imports. Like a virus.
- 12:52Yeah. They deformed the relationship, acting
- 12:54like a virus that just gave both communities
- 12:57this massive collective amnesia. So the Declaration
- 13:00is basically saying, hey. We don't need to invent
- 13:02some progressive modern compromise here. We just
- 13:05need to remember our own shared civilization.
- 13:07Exactly. But, and this is crucial, that transition
- 13:11from historical ambition to actual textual mechanics
- 13:14is where the brilliance of the companion documents
- 13:17really comes into play. Because you can't just
- 13:19tell millions of deeply faithful Orthodox believers
- 13:22to, you know, go remember the Andalusian poets
- 13:25and expect them to just drop their political
- 13:27grievances, right? No, of course not. You have
- 13:30to prove that this co -elevation is demanded
- 13:32by the divine texts themselves. You have to use
- 13:35their own holy books to rewire the theological
- 13:38grammar we talked about earlier. Which brings
- 13:40us to the textual engine of the Declaration.
- 13:42The companion text essentially lays the foundational
- 13:45scriptures of both faiths, the Torah, the Mishnah,
- 13:48the Quran, the Hadith. It lays them side by side
- 13:51on the table. Right. And reveals them operating
- 13:53as these astonishing mirror images of each other.
- 13:57It really does. And it begins at the absolute
- 13:59bedrock of both faiths, which is strict monotheism.
- 14:03The document actually pairs the two greatest
- 14:05declarations of the human race. Okay, let's hear
- 14:08them. For Judaism, it's the Shema. Hero Israel,
- 14:11the Lord is our God, the Lord is one. And for
- 14:14Islam, it's the Shahada. There is no God but
- 14:17God, and Muhammad is the messenger of God. But
- 14:20declaring belief in one God is really just step
- 14:22one, right? The text then traces the... The mechanical
- 14:26outcome of that belief. Like if there is only
- 14:28one creator, what is the nature of the creation?
- 14:32Exactly. So the companion text places Genesis
- 14:35127 directly next to Quran 4 .1. And what do
- 14:39those say for those who don't have them memorized?
- 14:41So Genesis 1 .27 establishes the concept of Imago
- 14:45Dei. That the human being was created in the
- 14:48image of God. Right. Which implies an inherent
- 14:51untouchable sanctity to the human form and spirit.
- 14:54And then the Quran. In Surah 4 .1, establishes
- 14:57that all of humanity was created from a single
- 15:00soul. Nafswahida. Nafswahida. Wow. So the declaration
- 15:04takes the friction of our modern hyper -categorized
- 15:07world and it basically drops an absolute hammer
- 15:09on it using these verses. It really does. Because
- 15:12it states that human dignity is not a political
- 15:15right granted by a constitution. It is not bestowed
- 15:18by your race or by a nation state or your wealth
- 15:21or the government. Right. It's an inherent trait
- 15:24bestowed by the creator, which means any political
- 15:28ideology that strips a person of their dignity
- 15:30is acting in direct defiance of God. That is
- 15:33so powerful. That is the foundation, but the
- 15:36textual engine really hits its highest gear when
- 15:39it addresses the absolute value of a single human
- 15:41life. Oh, yes. This is where Octor highlights
- 15:45a parallel reading in the companion text that
- 15:47is... Just incredible. He pairs the Jewish Mishnah,
- 15:51Sanhedrin 4 .5, with the Islamic Quran 5 .32.
- 15:55And when you read these two passages side by
- 15:57side, the mechanism of the scriptural transmission
- 16:00is just chilling. It really is. Walk us through
- 16:03it. Okay, so the Mishnah is this compilation
- 16:06of Jewish oral tradition codified around the
- 16:09year 200 CE. And it sets up a legal framework
- 16:13for capital cases, specifically warning judges
- 16:16about the immense weight of human life. Right.
- 16:19It's cautioning them. Yeah. It states that humanity
- 16:22began with a single individual for the sake of
- 16:25peace so that no person could ever look at another
- 16:27and say, my ancestors greater than yours. It
- 16:31just strips away all ethnic superiority right
- 16:33at the root. Exactly. But then the Mishnah delivers
- 16:37its most famous ethical ruling. It says, whoever
- 16:41destroys a single life is regarded by scripture
- 16:44as though he destroyed an entire world. And whoever
- 16:48saves a single life is regarded as though he
- 16:51saved an entire world. It is the ultimate legal
- 16:54protection against the cheapening of human life.
- 16:56It really is. But then, fast forward 400 years
- 17:00to the 7th century, and the Quran is revealed.
- 17:03Right. Surah 5 .32 says, we prescribed for the
- 17:07children of Israel. The mechanism there is profound.
- 17:21Did you catch it? It explicitly says it was previously
- 17:24given to the children of Israel. Exactly. The
- 17:26Quran explicitly acknowledges that this divine
- 17:28teaching was previously given to the Jewish people.
- 17:31It validates the prior Jewish revelation, confirms
- 17:34its absolute moral truth, and then seamlessly
- 17:37incorporates it into the new Islamic revelation.
- 17:39It's an undeniable structural link connecting
- 17:42the two faiths at their most fundamental ethical
- 17:44level. It really is. Which honestly brings me
- 17:47back to the family will analogy from the beginning
- 17:49of the show. Because the way the declaration
- 17:51handles the patriarch Abraham and his two sons,
- 17:54Isaac and Ishmael. It is the perfect example
- 17:56of finding hidden clauses in a contract you thought
- 17:59you already understood perfectly. Yeah. Abraham
- 18:01is the shared patriarch. He's revered by both
- 18:05as the friend of God. Right. But historically,
- 18:08the communities have engaged in this massive
- 18:10theological tug of war over his legacy. Who gets
- 18:13to claim him, basically. Right. Judaism traces
- 18:16its covenantal lineage through Isaac, while Islam
- 18:18traces its lineage primarily through Ishmael.
- 18:21And this has historically been used to create
- 18:23a really hard boundary. You know, us versus them,
- 18:26the chosen versus the rejected. But Octor calls
- 18:29the Declaration's reading of these specific texts
- 18:32quietly brilliant. Because it doesn't ask either
- 18:34side to give up their lineage. Not at all. Instead,
- 18:37it points to the explicit blessings given to
- 18:39the other side. Let's look at the mechanics of
- 18:42Genesis 21, for example. Because this is the
- 18:44foundational text for Judaism regarding the family
- 18:47split. The story of Hagar and Ishmael. Right.
- 18:51Hagar and Ishmael are sent away into the desert.
- 18:53But God intervenes. And the Torah explicitly
- 18:56records God's promise to bless Ishmael, to be
- 18:59with him, and to make him a great nation. So
- 19:02the Jewish text actually demands recognition
- 19:04of the Muslim ancestor's divine blessing. Exactly.
- 19:08Okay. And then you cross the aisle to Quran 37.
- 19:12This is the foundational Islamic text detailing
- 19:15the immense test of Abraham's willingness to
- 19:18sacrifice his son. Right. A huge moment in the
- 19:21text. But immediately after that intense narrative
- 19:23of devotion, The Quran states that God gave Abraham
- 19:27glad tidings of Isaac, a prophet from among the
- 19:30righteous. And it explicitly sends blessings
- 19:33upon both Abraham and Isaac. Wow. So the Islamic
- 19:38text demands recognition of the Jewish ancestors'
- 19:41divine blessing. Each scripture acts as a literal
- 19:43witness for the other. So the Declaration is
- 19:46utilizing the very texts that have typically
- 19:48been weaponized for division. uses them to enforce
- 19:52a legal and spiritual obligation to honor one
- 19:54another. Yeah, it concludes that section by saying,
- 19:57Abraham must be a bridge, not a boundary. That's
- 20:00a beautiful line, but... And I have to stop you
- 20:03there. Oh, here it comes. Because it is incredibly
- 20:06easy for, you know, scholars sitting in an air
- 20:09conditioned room in Salt Lake City to highlight
- 20:11the beautiful poetic verses about saving the
- 20:13world and blessing your cousins. Right. Sure.
- 20:15Absolutely. But anyone who has actually read
- 20:17the Bible or the Koran knows there are exceptionally
- 20:20difficult, exclusionary and violently awarded
- 20:23passages in those exact same books. Oh, there's
- 20:26no denying that. So if this declaration is just
- 20:29highlighting the friendly verses to make everyone
- 20:31feel good. Aren't they just engaging in liberal
- 20:33cherry -picking? Like, how does a scholarly reading
- 20:35of Genesis actually stop an extremist who is
- 20:38quoting a violent verse from the same book to
- 20:40justify a war? That is the most rigorous challenge
- 20:43to any interfaith document, honestly, because
- 20:45if you ignore the violent texts, you lose all
- 20:48credibility with the orthodox believers you are
- 20:50actually trying to reach. Right, they'll just
- 20:52dismiss you. Exactly. But Okta argues that the
- 20:54Declaration anticipates this perfectly. It addresses
- 20:57the dangerous texts head -on in a section titled,
- 20:59Religion Must Serve Life. And it completely,
- 21:02fundamentally rejects modern cherry picking.
- 21:05Okay, so how do they neutralize the violent verses
- 21:07without just saying, well, we're going to ignore
- 21:10that part of God's word? By returning to the
- 21:12mechanisms of classical hermeneutics. Okay, stop
- 21:14right there. Break down how that actually works
- 21:16in practice, please. Because hermeneutics usually
- 21:18just gets brushed off as interpretation, which
- 21:22to a lot of people just sounds like anyone can
- 21:24make the text mean whatever they want it to mean.
- 21:26It sounds like a buzzword, yeah. But it's actually
- 21:29quite the opposite. Classical hermeneutics in
- 21:31both Judaism and Islam is an intensely rigid,
- 21:34rule -bound science of reading scripture. It's
- 21:37like a formula. Yeah. And it acts as a safety
- 21:40valve against extremism. Let's look at the Islamic
- 21:43concept of azbab al -nuzul, which basically translates
- 21:47to the occasions of revelation. The occasions
- 21:50of revelation. Okay. When a classical Islamic
- 21:53scholar reads a verse that commands fighting
- 21:56or violence, They do not read it as a universal,
- 21:59eternal command for all times. Oh, they don't?
- 22:01No. They use the science of Azbab al -Nuzul to
- 22:04lock that specific verse to the exact historical
- 22:07battle, the specific political betrayal, and
- 22:10the exact context in which the Prophet Muhammad
- 22:12received it in the 7th century. Oh, I see. So
- 22:16when an extremist today rips that verse out of
- 22:18the 7th century, pastes it onto a modern geopolitical
- 22:21conflict and uses it to justify terrorism, they
- 22:24aren't just being violent. They are actively
- 22:26violating the classical rules of their own religion.
- 22:29Exactly. They are committing theological malpractice.
- 22:32Theological malpractice. That's a great way to
- 22:34put it. And the same rigorous mechanism exists
- 22:36in Judaism through the Talmud. The Torah contains
- 22:40verses that sound incredibly brutal to modern
- 22:43ears. The classic example is an eye for an eye.
- 22:46Right. Everyone knows that one. Yeah. And if
- 22:48you read that literally, it is a mandate for
- 22:51endless violent retaliation. But classical Jewish
- 22:54hermeneutics never allowed it to be read literally.
- 22:57Never. Never. The rabbis of the Talmud, using
- 23:00rigorous legal deduction, interpreted an eye
- 23:04for an eye. to mean strict monetary compensation
- 23:07for damages. Wait, really? Just money. Just money.
- 23:09The classical tradition acts as a filter, ensuring
- 23:12the text aligns with the overarching divine mandate
- 23:15for justice and the preservation of life. Wow.
- 23:19Okay, so the companion text uses a truly terrifying
- 23:22metaphor from the Talmud to illustrate the stakes
- 23:24of this. It cites Tractate Yoma 72b, which offers
- 23:29a warning about the Torah itself, which is obviously
- 23:32the holiest object in Judaism. Right. The Talmud
- 23:35says that the Torah can act as either a potion
- 23:37of life or a potion of death. Think about the
- 23:40mechanism of pharmacology, right? A highly potent
- 23:43drug, when administered by a trained physician
- 23:45who actually understands dosage, contraindications,
- 23:49and the patient's history, will save a life.
- 23:52But if that exact same drug is handed to someone
- 23:55with zero medical training. Or someone who actively
- 23:58wants to cause harm. Yeah. It becomes a lethal
- 24:00poison. So the text itself is basically neutral.
- 24:04The danger lies entirely in the hands of the
- 24:06reader. Yes. And it is an incredibly sobering
- 24:09admission for Orthodox rabbis to make. To say
- 24:12that their own sacred scripture can become a
- 24:15potion of death if it is stripped of its ethical,
- 24:17scholarly guardrails and weaponized for ethno
- 24:21-nationalism. And the Muslim authors bring an
- 24:24equally devastating mechanism from the Quran
- 24:26to match it, don't they? They do. They point
- 24:29to Surah 107. Which is known as Surat Al -Ma
- 24:32'un. Right. And this passage is a terrifying
- 24:36critique, leveled at people who genuinely believe
- 24:38they are devout. It says, So it is condemning
- 24:51the performative mechanics of religion. Exactly.
- 24:54It's basically saying you can have your rituals.
- 24:57perfectly aligned. You can pray exactly on time
- 25:00in the exact right posture. But if that ritual
- 25:03is severed from your ethical obligation to the
- 25:06most vulnerable members of society, your religion
- 25:08is completely empty. Both traditions are using
- 25:11their own texts to build an internal defense
- 25:13mechanism against extremism. It's built right
- 25:15in. Yes. The Declaration mandates that any interpretation
- 25:18of scripture that results in the degradation
- 25:20of human life or justifies cruelty must be rejected
- 25:25by the scholarly class as a corruption of the
- 25:27text's ultimate purpose. OK, so we have established
- 25:30the ambition of co -elevation and we've broken
- 25:33down the textual engine and these hermeneutical
- 25:36guardrails. But there's always a but. There's
- 25:38always a but. Because a philosophical framework
- 25:40discussed in Salt Lake City does not automatically
- 25:43stop a war in the Middle East. Getting scholars
- 25:46in a room to agree on 7th century texts is one
- 25:49thing, but how do you actually change the deeply
- 25:52ingrained animosity of millions of people? It's
- 25:55the multi -million dollar question. Seriously,
- 25:56how do you change what a 12 -year -old learns
- 25:59in a yeshiva or a madrasa tomorrow? And that
- 26:02is the crucial pivot of Akhtar's analysis. He
- 26:04maps out the massive multi -decade blueprint
- 26:06the authors have designed, which is... actually
- 26:09modeled explicitly on one of the most successful
- 26:11theological pivots in modern history. Which is
- 26:13Nostra Aetate. Nostra Aetate, exactly. We really
- 26:17need to explain the mechanics of Nostra Aetate
- 26:19because it proves that this kind of massive generational
- 26:22shift is actually possible. What was it and how
- 26:25did it work? So Nostra Aetate was a landmark
- 26:29declaration issued by the Catholic Church in
- 26:311965 during the Second Vatican Council. Okay,
- 26:341965. Prior to 1965, the relationship between
- 26:38the Catholic Church and the Jewish people was
- 26:40basically defined by nearly two millennia of
- 26:43intense hostility. 2 ,000 years. Right. The dominant
- 26:46theological position was supersessionism, and
- 26:49the church largely held Jews collectively responsible
- 26:51for the death of Jesus, which, as we know, fueled
- 26:54centuries of European anti -Semitism. But in
- 26:561965, they just completely flipped the script.
- 26:59They really did. The document formally repudiated
- 27:02the concept of collective Jewish guilt. It forcefully
- 27:06condemned anti -Semitism. It affirmed the eternal
- 27:09validity of God's covenant with the Jewish people.
- 27:11And it fundamentally rewired Catholic theology
- 27:14regarding Judaism. But, and this is the key mechanism
- 27:17for our deep dive today, it did not change the
- 27:20world on the day it was signed. Not at all. Like
- 27:22people didn't just read it in the paper and suddenly
- 27:25drop their prejudices. No, because a document
- 27:27signed in Rome doesn't instantly change the prejudice
- 27:30of a parishioner sitting in a small town in Ohio
- 27:33or Argentina. Right. So how long did it take?
- 27:36It took 60 years. 60 years. Yes. It required
- 27:41a generational rewiring of the entire institutional
- 27:45apparatus. Wow. The theology had to be translated
- 27:48into entirely new seminary textbooks. A new generation
- 27:51of priests had to be trained in this new framework.
- 27:54Those priests then had to spend decades preaching
- 27:57it from the pulpit until the children who grew
- 28:00up hearing it just believed it was the normal,
- 28:02unquestioned stance of the church. Okay, so the
- 28:06authors of the Jewish Muslim Declaration are
- 28:08looking at the success of Nostra Aetate and they're
- 28:12designing a similar 60 -year horizon? Exactly.
- 28:15They know they won't see the final result in
- 28:17their lifetimes. Which is a profound kind of
- 28:19patience. It is. But to ensure it survives that
- 28:22long, Octor points out that this declaration
- 28:24relies on three specific methodological pillars.
- 28:27It is bilateral, it is textual, and it is covenantal.
- 28:32Okay, let's break those down. First, why does
- 28:34it matter that it is strictly bilateral? Because
- 28:37the presence of a third party completely changes
- 28:40the mechanics of the dialogue. How so? Well,
- 28:42most interfaith dialogue in the West operates
- 28:44on what they call an Abrahamic model. Meaning
- 28:47you have a Christian, a Jew, and a Muslim sitting
- 28:49on a panel together. Sounds like the start of
- 28:52a joke. Right. But Akhtar argues that in North
- 28:55America or Europe, where Christianity is the
- 28:57dominant cultural hegemony, a three -way dialogue
- 29:00is always implicitly mediated by Christian theological
- 29:03categories. Oh, and secular post -Christian assumptions
- 29:08about what religion even is. Exactly. It essentially
- 29:11forces the Jew and the Muslim to translate their
- 29:13identities into a language the Christian majority
- 29:15finds palatable. Oh, I see. That waters it down.
- 29:18Yeah. But this declaration strips that away entirely.
- 29:22It is just Jew and Muslim directly facing one
- 29:25another, speaking in Hebrew, Arabic, and English,
- 29:29using only the authority of the Torah and the
- 29:31Quran. So there is no mediating secular or majority
- 29:35culture filter at all? None. It forces a much
- 29:38rarer, much more honest engagement. Which feeds
- 29:41right into the second pillar. It is rigorously...
- 29:44textual. The sources use this Arabic term, which
- 29:47basically means mutual knowing. Right. But it's
- 29:51not the mutual knowing of like a generic cultural
- 29:53festival where you share some food and play some
- 29:55music. No, not at all. It is the rigorous scholarly
- 29:58discipline of placing the Mishnah and the Hadith
- 30:01on the same table and doing the grueling intellectual
- 30:04work of reading them together. And that intellectual
- 30:06work is what makes the third pillar possible,
- 30:09the covenantal approach. And this is where the
- 30:12Declaration pulls its most brilliant historical
- 30:14mechanism, the Constitution of Medina. Oh, the
- 30:17Constitution of Medina is such a crucial piece
- 30:20of this puzzle. Walk us through how it actually
- 30:23functioned, because this is the blueprint for
- 30:25how they plan to avoid requiring anyone to compromise
- 30:27their theology, right? Yes. So in the year 622
- 30:31CE, the Prophet Muhammad migrated to the city
- 30:33of Medina. Okay, setting the scene. And the city
- 30:36was a very volatile mix of different tribes.
- 30:38You had several distinct Jewish tribes like the
- 30:41Banu Nadir and the Banu Kaynuka, as well as early
- 30:45Muslim converts and pagan tribes. So it's a powder
- 30:48keg, basically. Total power keg. So to prevent
- 30:51constant civil war, the prophet drafted a document
- 30:54known as the Constitution of Medina or the Sahifa.
- 30:56And it essentially created this massive pluralistic
- 31:00alliance. But how did the laws actually work?
- 31:03Did they force everyone to adopt a watered -down
- 31:07unified religion so they could all get along?
- 31:08Absolutely not. And that is the absolute genius
- 31:11of the mechanism. The Constitution established
- 31:14a unified political and social entity called
- 31:16the Ummah. The Ummah. But it explicitly guaranteed
- 31:20that the Jewish tribes would retain their own
- 31:22religion, their Din, and the Muslims would retain
- 31:26theirs. So they were religiously autonomous.
- 31:29Entirely. They maintained their own internal
- 31:31legal systems. They paid their own expenses.
- 31:33But they were covenantally bound to one another's
- 31:36survival. Yes. The contract stipulated that if
- 31:39Medina was attacked by an external enemy, the
- 31:42Jewish and Muslim tribes were legally obligated
- 31:45to defend one another. They formed a community
- 31:47of mutual responsibility while entirely maintaining
- 31:50their theological distinctions. It's basically
- 31:52covenantal pluralism. Exactly what it is. You
- 31:55are not asking a Jewish scholar to accept the
- 31:57Koran as divine revelation. And you aren't asking
- 32:01an imam to convert to Judaism. Right. You are
- 32:03asking them to enter into a legally and morally
- 32:06binding contract to protect the physical life
- 32:08and the inherent dignity of the other. And that
- 32:11framework is exactly how Akhtar maps out the
- 32:13four decade timeline for this declaration to
- 32:16actually take root. OK, let's trace that timeline
- 32:18because it's fascinating. Decade one focuses
- 32:21on scholars for peace. This is essentially the
- 32:23R &D phase, right? The research and development,
- 32:26yes. You need study circles operating in Jerusalem,
- 32:29in Rabat, in Washington, in Miami. You need scholars
- 32:33doing the grueling work of reading Maimonides
- 32:36alongside al -Ghazali, debating the text, and
- 32:39producing a massive shared body of intellectual
- 32:41commentary. Because without that intellectual
- 32:44foundation, the project collapses under the very
- 32:46first wave of political pressure. But once that
- 32:49foundation is solid, you move to decade two.
- 32:52Institutionalization. Yes. This is where the
- 32:54R &D gets integrated into the factory floor,
- 32:57so to speak. You have to establish endowed chairs
- 33:01in Judeo -Arabic thought at major global universities.
- 33:04Right. And you have to actively rewrite the curricula
- 33:07in yeshivas and madrasas. So that a 12 -year
- 33:10-old student doesn't just learn some caricature
- 33:12of the other faith, but actually encounters their
- 33:15texts with respect. Exactly. And this is also
- 33:18the decade where the process must drastically
- 33:20expand its demographics. Right. The Cape Town
- 33:22call. Yeah, the Cape Town Call in 2025 explicitly
- 33:25mandated the expansion of women -led dialogue
- 33:28tracks. Because a theology built entirely by
- 33:30men will inevitably have massive blind spots
- 33:33regarding the full lived experience of the communities.
- 33:36Which naturally paves the way for Decade 3, the
- 33:39generational turnover. This is the Nostra Aetate
- 33:42tipping point. The 60 -year mark. Well, 30 years
- 33:45from now in this case. You'll have an entire
- 33:47cohort of young rabbis and imams who are trained
- 33:50in these reformed seminaries. And when they stand
- 33:53at the pulpit or the mimbar and preach that Genesis
- 33:562 -1 and Quran 37 demand the protection of their
- 33:59cousin's life, it won't sound like some progressive
- 34:02interfaith compromise anymore. No, it will just
- 34:05be standard Orthodox theology. They'll be preaching
- 34:08co -elevation from the absolute center of their
- 34:10own traditions. And finally, decade four is the
- 34:13realization of the goal, the restoration of a
- 34:16Judeo -Islamic civilization. an intellectual
- 34:18and cultural ecosystem so deeply intertwined
- 34:21and robust that it can withstand the shocks of
- 34:24the geopolitical world. The author sees a really
- 34:26beautiful metaphor from Rabbi Yehuda Leon Ashkenazi
- 34:30to explain this end state. He compared humanity
- 34:33to a bouquet of flowers. The bouquet metaphor.
- 34:37The mechanism of the bouquet is perfect here,
- 34:39actually, because when you want a beautiful bouquet,
- 34:42you don't genetically modify all the flowers
- 34:44to be the exact same shape and color. No, that
- 34:47would be... incredibly boring. Right. The aesthetic
- 34:49power of the bouquet relies entirely on the flowers
- 34:52retaining their distinct, vibrant differences.
- 34:55The contrast is literally what makes the arrangement
- 34:57work. Unity does not equal uniformity. The Jewish
- 35:01flower and the Muslim flower must remain distinct.
- 35:04Their differences are what allow them to co -elevate
- 35:07the entire human arrangement. I love that. But
- 35:09this is where I want to push back again. OK,
- 35:11let's hear it. Because we have to look at the
- 35:13real world friction of this document. The sources
- 35:16we are looking at are remarkably honest about
- 35:18their own vulnerabilities. And if we just sit
- 35:20here and praise the bouquet metaphor, we are
- 35:23ignoring the structural weaknesses that Oktar
- 35:25explicitly points out. Yes, the critique within
- 35:28the analysis is absolutely vital. Oktar notes
- 35:31three massive blind spots that the declaration
- 35:33must overcome. OK, let's go through them. First
- 35:37is the problem of representation, right? Yeah.
- 35:39Imam Sharif and Rabbi Nagin only represent two
- 35:41specific organizations. They do not have the
- 35:44hierarchical authority of a pope. They cannot
- 35:47unilaterally command the global Jewish or Muslim
- 35:50populations to just fall in line. So the authority
- 35:53of this document will only be generated by the
- 35:54sheer number of subsequent institutions that
- 35:57choose to sign on to it. Exactly. It's grassroots.
- 36:01Second, while they acknowledge the need for women
- 36:03-led dialogue, The document itself was born from
- 36:06a predominantly male process, operating within
- 36:09deeply patriarchal religious structures. Which
- 36:12is a real limitation. It is. And third, there
- 36:16is the glaring issue of political capture. The
- 36:19political capture. This is the scary one. Very.
- 36:22The entire framework relies on classical hermeneutics
- 36:25and healthy scholarly institutions acting as
- 36:28a guardrail against extremism. But what happens
- 36:31when those very institutions have been corrupted?
- 36:34by ethno -nationalism. Right. Because in many
- 36:37parts of the world right now, religious institutions
- 36:40are essentially acting as the public relations
- 36:42arm of the state. If the scholarly class is entirely
- 36:46captured by a geopolitical agenda, the guardrails
- 36:49are just gone. The potion of death is already
- 36:51being distributed. That is the incredibly fragile
- 36:54tightrope these authors are walking. They are
- 36:56trying to rebuild the bridge while people are
- 36:58actively bombing the supports. It's a daunting
- 37:01task. It is. But understanding that extreme fragility
- 37:04is exactly what makes the personal stakes of
- 37:06these two men so incredibly compelling. Like,
- 37:09these aren't naive academics who don't understand
- 37:11violence. No, they really aren't. Let's look
- 37:13at Imam Talib Sharif's background. As an African
- 37:16-American Muslim leader whose theology is heavily
- 37:19influenced by the late Imam W. Dean Muhammad,
- 37:21he's bringing the deep generational weight of
- 37:24the African diaspora into this dialogue. In his
- 37:27speeches, Imam Sharif is very, very clear. He
- 37:29is no stranger to systemic oppression, violence,
- 37:32and racism. He understands what it means to inherit
- 37:35a legacy of profound pain. He does. But the mechanism
- 37:39of his leadership is this absolute refusal to
- 37:41let that inherited pain become a perpetual engine
- 37:44for blame. Right. He insists that looking back
- 37:47in anger only destroys the future and that true
- 37:50elevation requires stepping forward into the
- 37:52vulnerability of understanding. He is basically
- 37:55mapping the spiritual resilience of the American
- 37:57civil rights struggle onto a global theological
- 38:00crisis. Which is incredible. And then you have
- 38:02Rabbi Yaakov Nagin's story, which provides an
- 38:05intensely visceral physical dimension to this
- 38:09concept of co -elevation. Oh, Rabbi Nagin's story
- 38:11is amazing. So three years ago, he suffered a
- 38:14catastrophic brain hemorrhage. A brain hemorrhage.
- 38:16Yeah. He was literally hovering between life
- 38:18and death. And during his agonizing recovery,
- 38:21word spread and communities of various faiths
- 38:25across the region just began praying for his
- 38:27survival. Wow. He survived, and he actually attributes
- 38:30his return to life to that multi -faith net of
- 38:33prayers. And he connects this near -death experience
- 38:35to a specific mechanism in the text of the prophet
- 38:38Zephaniah, chapter 3, verse 9, doesn't he? He
- 38:41does. The verse envisions a future where all
- 38:44peoples will call upon the name of the Lord and
- 38:46serve him shoulder to shoulder. Shoulder to shoulder.
- 38:49Yeah. Rabbi Nagin realized that the prayers for
- 38:52his life fulfilled the first half of the verse,
- 38:54but the second half, the physical reality of
- 38:57serving shoulder to shoulder, he says he didn't
- 39:00fully grasp until the exact moment he met Imam
- 39:02Sharif. The way he describes their meeting is
- 39:05so striking because Despite all the geopolitical
- 39:08reasons they should be wary of one another, he
- 39:10says Imam Sharif pulled him into this enormous
- 39:12embrace. Nagin wrote, face to face, heart to
- 39:16heart. Our shoulders touched and we became one.
- 39:19That physical embrace is the literal incarnation
- 39:22of the theology they are writing. It explains
- 39:24why the declaration includes a mandate that challenges
- 39:26every modern political instinct we have. What's
- 39:29that? It demands that Jews and Muslims must grieve
- 39:32the loss of innocent life without first asking
- 39:35the victim's nationality or religion. Wow. Let
- 39:37that sink in for a second. Seriously. Because
- 39:40the psychological mechanism we normally use when
- 39:42we see a tragedy on the news is to immediately
- 39:44categorize the victim, right? Are they an ally?
- 39:46Are they the enemy? Are they us or are they them?
- 39:49We basically withhold our empathy until the algorithm
- 39:52tells us if they are on our team. Exactly. But
- 39:55the declaration demands radical empathy. It demands
- 39:58that you see the imago dei, the divine spark
- 40:01in the victim before your brain can even apply
- 40:04a political label. It is a total rejection of
- 40:07collective blame. It is. And when you understand
- 40:10that these two men have faced the absolute limits
- 40:12of human fragility, you know, systemic historical
- 40:15racism and the literal edge of mortality, you
- 40:19realize this declaration isn't just a polite
- 40:21academic theory. No. It's an emergency lifeline
- 40:24they are throwing directly into the machinery
- 40:25of war. So we have covered an immense amount
- 40:28of ground today. We started with the aha moment
- 40:31of a quiet signing ceremony in Salt Lake City,
- 40:33this radical attempt to rewrite the theological
- 40:36grammar of a fractured world. We dug deep into
- 40:39the historical reality of the Judeo -Islamic
- 40:41civilization, the Genizah merchants and the Andalusian
- 40:45poets. We explored the textual mechanics, how
- 40:48Genesis and the Quran act as mirror images. demanding
- 40:51that we recognize the divine blessing in our
- 40:53cousins. We analyzed how classical hermeneutics
- 40:56actually disarms the weaponization of sacred
- 40:58texts, preventing them from becoming a potion
- 41:02of death. And we mapped out a rigorous 60 -year
- 41:05blueprint modeled on Nostra Aetate and the Constitution
- 41:08of Medina that's designed to construct a reality
- 41:11of covenantal pluralism. It's a huge vision.
- 41:15It is. But I want to explicitly connect this
- 41:17back to you, the listener, because the mechanics
- 41:20of covenantal pluralism are universally applicable.
- 41:23Like even if you are not Jewish, even if you
- 41:26are not Muslim, or even if you operate from a
- 41:28fiercely secular framework, this still matters.
- 41:31It matters a lot because we live in an economy
- 41:34of attention that profits immensely from our
- 41:37division. The political algorithms are quite
- 41:39literally designed to make us define ourselves
- 41:42entirely by who we oppose. Right. But the architecture
- 41:46of this declaration offers a counter -narrative.
- 41:49It proves that you do not have to dilute your
- 41:51own fiercely held identity to achieve peace.
- 41:54You can hold on to your specific traditions,
- 41:56your specific texts, and your specific history,
- 41:59while simultaneously binding yourself morally
- 42:02to the dignity and survival of the person you
- 42:05vehemently disagree with. It is about utilizing
- 42:08your core identity as a bridge rather than a
- 42:12boundary. And that brings us to the final provocative
- 42:15thought we want to leave you with today. We spent
- 42:18significant time on the Talmudic warning that
- 42:20the holiest of texts could be either a potion
- 42:23of life or a potion of death, and that it's determined
- 42:26entirely by the hands of the person using it.
- 42:28I want you to apply that exact mechanism to your
- 42:32own life. Think about your most closely held
- 42:35fundamental beliefs, whether they are religious
- 42:37doctrines, political ideologies, or secular moral
- 42:40codes? Are you currently administering those
- 42:43core beliefs as a potion of life, actively utilizing
- 42:47them to elevate and protect the dignity of the
- 42:49people around you? Or are you weaponizing them
- 42:52as a potion of death, using your ideology to
- 42:55build walls, justify cruelty, and isolate yourself
- 42:59from the humanity of others? What would the hard
- 43:01work of co -elevation actually look like in your
- 43:04community tomorrow? It really forces a complete
- 43:07reassessment of how we operate in the world.
- 43:09It does. Well, thank you so much for breaking
- 43:11down this incredibly dense and profoundly important
- 43:14blueprint with me. It has been an absolute privilege
- 43:17to do this deep dive with you. And thank you
- 43:19for joining us on this journey. We will catch
- 43:21you on the next deep dive.