Latest / Chatter that Matters / Dr. Stuart Gillespie - Food Fight
Transcript
- 0:03Children, you know, what kind of world do we want our kids or their kids
- 0:06to grow up in? You know, when we have obesity and three year olds,
- 0:10Something has to change. Food means the world to each of
- 0:14us and all of us.
- 0:18For some, sadly for many, food is about
- 0:22survival, making daily choices. Do I
- 0:26put gas in my tank? Food on my table? For others,
- 0:29it's about indulgence, exploration, crafting.
- 0:33It's a social connector, a personal ritual. Food
- 0:37can break down barriers, connect cultures, create
- 0:40memories and meaning. But food doesn't simply arrive on our
- 0:44plates. Behind every bite is a complex, fragile system
- 0:48shaped by science, policy, economics, power and profit. The
- 0:52damage of the global food system at $15 trillion
- 0:57a year, from farm. To fork, hunger to hope, and
- 1:00profit to planet, the food system touches everything and everyone.
- 1:04So today I want to explore what happens when food becomes a
- 1:08battleground. All about driving profit by prioritizing the
- 1:11production of ultra processed foods, which are the most profitable
- 1:15and the least healthy. So there you have challenge right there.
- 1:19A place where corporate interests outweigh public health, where
- 1:23marketing trumps nutrition, and where what feeds us can
- 1:27also harm us. My guest is someone who has spent more than four
- 1:30decades inside the system, researching it, challenging it, and now
- 1:34offering a bold vision to transform it. It's kind of incumbent on me to make
- 1:37a decision. Do I just continue to compromise and continue to work
- 1:41in this environment, or do I just take a risk, take a step,
- 1:45step aside and try something different? Dr. Stuart Gillespie has
- 1:48worked with the UN, led major global nutrition initiatives, and has written
- 1:52Food Fight From Plunder and Profit to People and Planet. It's a part
- 1:56memoir, part manifesto. It's also a searing indictment of her current food
- 2:00system and a hopeful call for change. The book is not about
- 2:04banning UPFs ultra processed foods. It's really about balance
- 2:07and it's really about power. And it's realizing power
- 2:11where it may be latent or inert and
- 2:14bringing it to bear on this, on this challenge across the board.
- 2:22Hi, it's Tony Chapman. Thank you for listening to Chatter that Matters, presented
- 2:26by rbc. If you can please subscribe to the podcast
- 2:30and ratings reviews. Well, they're always welcome and are always
- 2:33appreciated.
- 2:37So Stuart, welcome to Chatter that Matters. Thank you. Great to be here.
- 2:41So, Food Fight, I thought it was a compelling read and I'm always
- 2:45curious what motivates an author to write a book,
- 2:49especially one that required so much research and
- 2:52context. Basically got to a point when
- 2:56I through my career been doing a lot of work with the UN
- 3:00around the world and also More recently, recently with
- 3:04a large research organization, kind of a think tank on food
- 3:08policy research. I got to the point where I felt we
- 3:12had enough research and knowledge and evidence and we
- 3:16weren't having enough impact. And I felt I needed to
- 3:19change and be a bit more creative. I actually did a creative
- 3:23writing course and decided to take a step back or a step sideways
- 3:27and write in a different way for a different audience
- 3:31to try and convey what I felt was
- 3:35the crux and the structural drivers of the challenge of
- 3:38this dysfunctional food system. We have globally
- 3:42options from around the world for policies and
- 3:45programs and actions that could turn the situation around and
- 3:49generate a much better food system that is equitable, sustainable,
- 3:53and healthy. How did your science community, your peers, when
- 3:57you're using words like Food Fight is the title, and it's much more written
- 4:01for the average consumer, did you get a little bit of blowback from the community?
- 4:05You're writing a pop music song as opposed to.
- 4:10Quite a few actually quite liked it. I mean, it's obviously a bit confrontational.
- 4:14Some would say, oh, we shouldn't be writing in a way that
- 4:17sounds divisive, as if there's a struggle. And I felt that was
- 4:21like sort of airbrushing out the reality. But most people
- 4:24figured I was heading in that direction. Anyway, I kind of did this
- 4:28project called Stories of Change, where kind of a halfway
- 4:32house, if you like, wherein we tried to interview.
- 4:36Well, we did interview a lot of people in six countries initially
- 4:40who had been struggling to change food systems and
- 4:44basically to capture their experience of that. So
- 4:48alongside what we saw as the evidence of the harms and the
- 4:51responses, and tell a story, tell a story of countries, tell a story of
- 4:55districts or regions, tell a story of individuals, but also as
- 4:58I. As I wanted to do, through my eyes, which
- 5:02meant a kind of a blended memoir aspect.
- 5:06I'm a believer in memes and titles as a way to hook people in.
- 5:10And yours is Food Fight, which is very bold. One that had an impact on
- 5:13yours was you early on was Susan George's how the Other
- 5:17Half Dies. It also sort of wove together your
- 5:20time working rural India. So was that really where you started
- 5:24shaping the sense that maybe my life would be much more of a. A
- 5:27justice warrior versus just simply someone that would publish
- 5:31papers? I mean, I studied food science. My first degree is
- 5:35food science. But I felt that particular course I did in
- 5:39University of Reading was a good course, but it was very much steering people towards
- 5:42the food industry. And to me, food. I got into food because I
- 5:45was interested in nutrition and health and access
- 5:49equity on the part of people. So this particular course wasn't right
- 5:53for me. And then I picked up this book, amazing book. I was
- 5:56probably about 17, I was in Cambridge in the middle of a heat wave and
- 6:00sort of ducked into this sort of back alley, found a secondhand bookstore,
- 6:04picked the book up, read it on the way back to where I lived in
- 6:07Chester, and I realized, okay, this is what I. This
- 6:11is shining a light on something that is really amazing and fascinating.
- 6:15And ultimately, it was about justice. And that was what was driving me to then
- 6:19look for opportunities to work in, to use the
- 6:23skills that I picked up, actually, after doing a master's. And I ended up in
- 6:26India as a volunteer on what was called a development integrated
- 6:30rural development project. You know, I was completely out of my depth,
- 6:34but the one reason I was there, because I believed in this notion of
- 6:38nutrition as being a marker, if you like, of the human condition and
- 6:41an indicator of justice. But I had to learn very fast while
- 6:45I was there. And it was, I guess, a pivotal time, really, for me. I
- 6:48was about 24. In one of the interviews I listened to, you said you
- 6:52became more of an activist over time. But it sounds like even
- 6:56back in those early days, you realized that there was a problem
- 6:59to be solved, and it wasn't just going to be solved by
- 7:03citations and papers that you really had to. It sounded like even
- 7:06back then, you were thinking about, how do I get more people
- 7:10involved in a topic that I'm very passionate on? Basically, I was young.
- 7:14Many young people are activists. They feel they want to change the world,
- 7:18which is all fine. And then they think, okay, maybe I don't know enough.
- 7:22Maybe I need to learn a bit more. So then it was a hard, cold
- 7:25reality of thinking, okay, let's just figure this out a bit more. Get a job,
- 7:29because you obviously need a job. And then. Which actually ultimately means you end
- 7:32up compromising to a certain extent, but you're also hopefully learning.
- 7:36And then it gets to a point in life when you think, actually, now I
- 7:39know enough. And it's still pretty lousy, this situation. And
- 7:43I'm not having, personally not having a big enough impact. Therefore,
- 7:47it's kind of incumbent on me to make a decision. Do I just continue
- 7:51to compromise and continue to work, innocent environment, or do I
- 7:55take a risk, take a step, step aside, and try something
- 7:59different. And that was a second, if you like, a second period of activism
- 8:02about 35 years after the first. I love the way you.
- 8:06You frame your life around food as well, in another interview
- 8:10you talked about where you thought the biggest problem to solve was
- 8:14undernutrition, but now you're also realizing the
- 8:17obesity and chronic disease are also part of the crisis. And I thought that was
- 8:21interesting because it's often one way or the other.
- 8:25But you're almost saying this is a teeter totter that we're on and both sides,
- 8:28when they hit the ground, hurt. And we have been learning a lot about the
- 8:32commonalities in terms of the drivers of both
- 8:36undernutrition and overweight and obesity. They collectively,
- 8:40it's malnutrition, it's poor nutrition, whether it's
- 8:43undernutrition, a deficit or deprivation or
- 8:46an imbalance and an excess, which is, which is overweight and obesity.
- 8:50And they do have similar structural drivers. And poverty is one
- 8:54of them. Marginalization in different ways. So food justice
- 8:57requires us, if we are to achieve and attain it, to
- 9:01actually take on board the full spectrum of nutritional
- 9:05challenges in this case. But what was interesting
- 9:09in terms of my journey was that I started looking really only at
- 9:12undernutrition and really only with kids, so under 5
- 9:16year olds. And that's. I spent a lot of time in India and then later
- 9:19in Africa. But over time we could see the
- 9:23rise in overweight and obesity and that required us to
- 9:27reconsider the drivers of the problem. And the moment you do
- 9:30that, the arena widens to incorporate
- 9:34and encompass commercial private sector actors,
- 9:38the big food companies. Then you realize that you have to get
- 9:41politically streetwise, you have to understand the commercial
- 9:45determinants of the problem. Because basically all these companies
- 9:49are all about driving profit in the bottom line, obviously.
- 9:53And the way they do that is prioritizing
- 9:56the production of ultra processed foods which are the most
- 10:00profitable and the least healthy. So there you have the challenge right
- 10:04there. And the reality is you can be overfed and
- 10:07undernourished at the same time. As an individual. You
- 10:11certainly see overweight and undernutrition in many communities
- 10:15around the world. Now, a lot of time I spent in India and when I
- 10:18used to talk about overweight and obesity, my Indian colleagues
- 10:22and friends from about 20 years ago said, we'll never have that here. And they
- 10:25have a massive obesity problem now, India, because that's how fast
- 10:29things can change for the worse. But I think they can also be
- 10:33turned around. Are you following Kennedy south of our border but across
- 10:37the pond from you? How do you feel, how he's approaching it?
- 10:40With sort of this very direct confrontational attacks
- 10:44on members of Parliament. Some ways the allegations he's making,
- 10:48whether it's big Pharma or big food, is that they are
- 10:52puppets to the master versus for the people and by the people. I'm
- 10:55following it. Obviously it's moving very fast and I have quite a lot of American
- 10:58colleagues and friends, some of whom have actually quit their job because of the
- 11:02way the Mahal movement has been behaving. Yes,
- 11:06he's right. Ultra processed foods are a big problem. Yes, he's right. Conflict of interest.
- 11:10Industry malpractice is a big challenge. A lot of his focus
- 11:14is on food additives, colorants,
- 11:18seed oils. Okay, they are a bit challenging, part of the problem, but
- 11:22they're not the big picture. The biggest challenge and the biggest
- 11:25contradiction in the entire scenario in the US right now is
- 11:29that Maha and Maga are absolutely at loggerheads with each
- 11:33other. They're diametrically opposed. And MAGA is
- 11:36slashing benefits for the SNAP program for
- 11:40nutritional support programs for low income families which would
- 11:43enable an access to affordable healthy diets,
- 11:47while Maha is trying to take on the food industry. And you
- 11:51cannot shut down access to one food
- 11:54without and shut down access to another, a better,
- 11:58healthier option at the same time. So that kind of teeter, totter
- 12:02or seesaw as we say, needs to be leveled out. We need to
- 12:05disincentivize harmful food, but also and importantly
- 12:09incentivize and improve access and affordability of healthy
- 12:13foods, especially low income families. So that second part is not happening at all.
- 12:17It's going on reverse direction in the. US as we're talking about the
- 12:20system and peeling back the onion. Another way you framed it was the five
- 12:24deadly Ds. That was chapter 13. It's called the
- 12:28dark arts. And that was actually the first chapter I wrote in the book. And
- 12:31it just got bigger and bigger. And the dark arts is the way in
- 12:35which huge market and financial power of these big
- 12:39corporations is translated into political
- 12:42power by various means. And they're
- 12:46the deadly Ds. The first is doubt, sowing doubt on the
- 12:50evidence of the harms of their products. Second D is
- 12:53distort and that relates to distorting the evidence base.
- 12:57Third is distraction. Distraction could be in the form of
- 13:01corporate social responsibility initiatives which are very small scale,
- 13:04which are designed to take the pressure off any
- 13:08regulation on the large scale harms. And then as
- 13:11disguise, all of the corporations are members of trade associations
- 13:15or front groups which act like Trojan horses to get them to the
- 13:19policy table. And then last is dodge, which often is about tax
- 13:23dodging due to the ability to move their tax Liabilities around the world,
- 13:26wherever the low tax opportunities are. That's the
- 13:30corporate playbook basically to stop politicians getting in
- 13:34their way. One way they do that, One of the Ds is about
- 13:37lobbying and the revolving door. That's the distortion side because
- 13:42lobbying in many ways is cherry picking evidence to make a case again
- 13:45not to get in the way of profit. Where politicians
- 13:49are offered incentives in the way of board positions,
- 13:53future employment opportunities, so long as
- 13:56they don't act now to rein in corporate power.
- 14:01It's not just these big corporations. You have to look upstream
- 14:04too, to look at the big investment fund hedge funds,
- 14:08the asset management firms like BlackRock, Vanguard, State,
- 14:13Free Capital, because they are buying up so much
- 14:17of the shares of these big food corporations and just
- 14:21driving profit at all costs. They're not interested in
- 14:24improving the healthiness of the portfolios of these companies. So the more you
- 14:28dig, the more you find really. But it allows you to actually know where
- 14:32to, where to target in terms of change. Another statement that you
- 14:36made before we move on to sort of reimagining the future is the global
- 14:39food system destroys more than it produces. And
- 14:43that kind of just had me stop and think it's true.
- 14:47It totally blew me away when I read this. And I read it in the
- 14:49form of the report which came out the end of 20, no, it was
- 14:5324 by the food Systems Economic Commission. And they costed out
- 14:57the damage of the global food system at 15
- 15:01trillion and the actual
- 15:05benefits of the global food system around about $10 trillion a year. So
- 15:08it's completely outweighing. And the damage comprises
- 15:12of that $15 trillion of damage, 11 trillion is due
- 15:16to health harms or early death due to
- 15:19unhealthy diets, malnutrition, lost
- 15:22productivity, inability to work, the
- 15:26hit on health services, social services, welfare services,
- 15:30three out of the 15 are environmental harms. And that
- 15:34the plastic pollution, water pollution, air pollution related to this industry,
- 15:37which generates one third of all global greenhouse gas
- 15:41emissions and the last 1 trillion, it relates
- 15:45to the poverty of food system workers on the front line who are just not
- 15:47being paid enough to be healthy.
- 15:51So you cannot say the argument that we cannot touch this
- 15:55food system because it's a net driver of economic
- 15:59growth is a nonsense. You also talk about the food system isn't broken,
- 16:02it's working exactly as designed, just for the wrong purpose.
- 16:07Because normally it's like we got to smash this up and rebuild it. You're going,
- 16:10no, actually it's firing on all cylinders. It just happens to be not the direction
- 16:14we need it to go absolutely. So basically, the system was designed in
- 16:18a different century for a different purpose. It was designed ultimately, if you
- 16:21go way back after the Second World War, over time, food became
- 16:25seen less and less as a, as a basic need and a human right, but
- 16:28more as a commodity. The system, big corporations weighed it in,
- 16:33took more and more control, and now, you know, there are a handful that control
- 16:36at least 70% of every single step along the food
- 16:40system, from production to consumption. They control it and it's
- 16:44doing exactly what they want. So to them, it's not broken. We need to
- 16:47look at the purpose of our food system. And if we want one that
- 16:51nourishes us rather than maximizes profits for a
- 16:55handful of transnationals, we need a different system, which means we need to
- 16:58transform it. We can't repair it, we need to radically
- 17:02overhaul it. And it's going to take time. You know, it'll take 10 years.
- 17:06I don't know. We have to push things in the right direction.
- 17:11When we come back, Dr. Gillespie and I talk about
- 17:15what can be done to reverse the tide and
- 17:19have food mean the world to all of us in terms of not just what
- 17:22we eat, but what that food does for our body.
- 17:30Hi, it's Tony Chapman. Food does mean the world
- 17:34to each of us and to all of us. Some of
- 17:37us have the privilege that food can be something we explore,
- 17:42learn about new cultures, test our creativity in the kitchen,
- 17:46dine and enjoy the creativity of a master chef.
- 17:50But for many people in Canada and around the world, each day they're dealing
- 17:54with food insecurity and Canada can play a role in
- 17:57changing it. We can become a superpower in food,
- 18:01but to do so, we really need to support our farmers.
- 18:05And so I want to give a big shout out to Farm Credit Canada, the
- 18:08University Guelph, and RBC for putting together the
- 18:12foundations of Agricultural Management, an online
- 18:16course. It's free, but it gives people that work in the agricultural
- 18:19sector the knowledge and confidence to make a lifetime of better
- 18:23informed decisions, to learn about business strategy and
- 18:26planning and farm management, succession planning and financial
- 18:30fundamentals. But here's to the University of Guelph, FCC
- 18:33and rbc. And here's to making Canada a
- 18:37superpower in agriculture. This food means the world
- 18:41to you, to me, and to rbc.
- 18:48The first thing we talk about, actually, when we talk about food systems or one
- 18:52of the number one things that's mentioned is the system is broken.
- 18:55It's not broken. It's not. It's fit for purpose. It's just fit for
- 18:59the wrong purpose. We need a different system. We need to change
- 19:03the system, we need to transform it. We can't just repair it. We shouldn't
- 19:07be doing incrementalist tinkering at the margins. We need a
- 19:11significant radical overhaul of the overall system.
- 19:15Joining me today is Dr. Stuart Gillespie. He's
- 19:19been in the epicenter of food. From a kid wandering around India
- 19:22seeing what malnutrition is doing to
- 19:26working across the entire food spectrum to see what the food industry
- 19:30is doing to us.
- 19:33You've identified four levers where you see
- 19:37this possibility for change. You talk about institutions, incentives,
- 19:40information and interests. I wonder if you could unpack those four. Sure.
- 19:44Well, these are the four, conveniently all beginning with iron
- 19:48options that any government can take. So first of all,
- 19:52in the last third of the book, which is what are we going to do?
- 19:55The actions and the manifesto that relates to
- 19:59various actors, if you like, in the food system, one of which, and the
- 20:02biggest of all is our governments and other is citizens, ourselves,
- 20:07civil society, media, researchers, food industry,
- 20:10UN at the international level. But when it comes to
- 20:14governments, these four ins, incentives,
- 20:17information, institutions and interests.
- 20:21The first and the easiest is institutions whereby
- 20:25governments have the power for public procurement of
- 20:28healthy foods for schools, for clinics, for
- 20:32hospitals and any government agency. Second in is
- 20:36incentives that's taxing harms through sugar
- 20:39taxes, through potentially junk food taxes, but importantly
- 20:43using that tax dividend and benefit to
- 20:46subsidize access and affordability by low
- 20:50income families to healthy diets through maybe food stamps, food
- 20:54transfers, whatever. That's a shifting of the incentive, that's a leveling
- 20:57of the seesaw or teeter totter, that
- 21:01and can be done and has been done in various countries. And the third in
- 21:05is information, making it crystal clear what is healthy and what's not.
- 21:09And the way that Latin American countries are doing that was with the black
- 21:12octagon. Every time a threshold in a food product that
- 21:16is breached with regard to sugar, saturated fat,
- 21:19salt or energy density, they get a big black octagon slapped on
- 21:23the packet in a way that cigarettes were
- 21:27similarly kind of labeled. And then they start having to take off
- 21:31cartoon characters for kids products when they hit a certain number of black
- 21:34octagons. And then the final in is
- 21:38interests and that's ridding conflicts of interest from government advisory
- 21:41bodies because we know that that will always be pro industry and
- 21:45not pro people in terms of the decisions, cleaning
- 21:49up, lobbying, proper lobbying, disclosure. So we know who's meeting who for what
- 21:53purpose. And these protocols exist in
- 21:56several countries Actually, Canada is one of the best. Canada
- 22:00and Ireland have a very good system of lobby disclosure
- 22:04is one of the worst. US is terrible. What we need to do is
- 22:08know who's meeting whom for what purpose, because
- 22:11it's a government that we've elected. Talk to me about the
- 22:15manifesto and such. You hold on to what you call radical
- 22:18hope. And yet when I went through the first part of your book, I thought
- 22:22this was radically hopeless because as you
- 22:26said, as the institutions get involved in Prophet
- 22:29Trump's purpose, as one of my colleagues once said, no doubt
- 22:33we're going to end up with corporations running the world. What's interesting is that
- 22:37quite a few people have read the book, said, oh, it made me really angry.
- 22:40And then I said, but did you get to the last. Yeah, I started getting
- 22:43a bit more hope, or I could start to see how things could
- 22:47change and should change. But I just believe we've got to have the revelation before
- 22:51the revolution. We have to really unpack what's happening
- 22:55in all its gory details. Hope.
- 22:59And Rebecca Solnit has written really well about radical hope.
- 23:02It's different to optimism hope. It has more agency
- 23:06built into it and it's more of a springboard to
- 23:10action, but it's based on. It should be based on
- 23:13what we know can work and is working in different parts. If we
- 23:17start to put together a package of these actions in a
- 23:21proper, strategic, comprehensive food and
- 23:24health strategy. I really believe that two
- 23:28plus two equals five. In the same way as you get
- 23:32the cascade that I talk about in the early part of the book of
- 23:35vicious cycles in terms of problems
- 23:39spiraling, connecting and spiraling down, we have the option to turn
- 23:43that into virtuous cycles and generate
- 23:46reinforcing and mutual benefits by being
- 23:50more systematic across the whole food system, not being
- 23:54ad hoc or piecemeal. And a lot of what I'm arguing for is a more
- 23:58systematic approach. I do think, as I say, it'll take
- 24:01time, but there is every chance that we will see major
- 24:05changes which then will become kind of self fueling. In as much as
- 24:09I think people start to see benefits, governments realize it wasn't
- 24:13necessarily a no go area for them in terms of policy.
- 24:17The other part of it is children. What kind of world do we want our
- 24:21kids or their kids to grow up in when we have
- 24:24obesity and 3 year olds? Something has to change.
- 24:28One area you talked about and I questioned is this sense
- 24:31of we're not just consumers, we're citizens. I get that. But I
- 24:35don't see a lot of Individuals standing
- 24:39up and exercising their democratic power or even
- 24:42their power to protest this. I see a lot of people that
- 24:46are happy in social media and they sign petitions and they,
- 24:50they feel they've done this and that. But what you're calling for,
- 24:54almost like you did with the HIV and AIDS movement, which is,
- 24:58or I would even argue we saw some of it through the pandemic,
- 25:01is that there's a collective consciousness and, and I wonder
- 25:05if people that as they're thinking about all you're doing and slamming
- 25:09down a ultra processed sandwich from their local
- 25:12convenience store as a consumer, how do you really get them to
- 25:16speak, to start acting like a citizen? What I would love to do is really
- 25:19dig into the history of activism and I started to do that a little bit
- 25:23in the book and then towards the end, but not just in this food
- 25:27health space, going back to the HIV era,
- 25:31looking at climate, even political change, suffragette
- 25:35movement, the minimum wage. There are
- 25:38fundamental lessons that flow from that. One of them is really
- 25:43we can do certain things on our own, but we can do a lot more
- 25:45together. So how do we generate that collective
- 25:49agency and use it? What I
- 25:52think can be done is by again, it's
- 25:56working across the board. If you're talking about individuals or
- 26:00groups, we have the ability to question right to our
- 26:04MPs, vote the right party in power, work through
- 26:07NGOs, community groups, beyond social media
- 26:11petitions. There are no easy answers. But my simple
- 26:14reason for focusing on that word citizen was
- 26:19we're not just downstream passive mouths that are fed.
- 26:23The other part I wanted to say is really the book is not about banning
- 26:26UPFs ultra processed foods. It's really about balance and it's
- 26:30really about power and it's realizing power where
- 26:34it may be latent or inertia and bring it to
- 26:38bear on this challenge across the board. I guess
- 26:41my final question, if you could whisper one sentence into the ear of
- 26:45every policymaker, every food executive, every citizen,
- 26:49is there a meme or something that we can put out there that people should
- 26:52start saying that's created an itch? I want to know more, I want
- 26:56to act on it. Actually, I just thought a little side story very quickly.
- 27:00The first question I was asked in the biggest sort of launch event I did
- 27:03in Yorkshire was asked by a 9 year old kid and 300 people
- 27:07and he said, what do I do tomorrow when I wake up? And I thought,
- 27:11wow, that's amazing. I said, well, have a conversation at your school,
- 27:14see if you can get your teacher on board, maybe have a project, bring in
- 27:17food, ask where different ingredients have come from and I had to think on my
- 27:21feet. But there is no one single thing to be said beyond
- 27:25learn about the drivers of the problem, understand the experiences around
- 27:29the world, understand you have power in where you are and what you
- 27:33do. It will take more than one thing and it will also take time.
- 27:37But I think there's no simple single solution, no
- 27:40magic bullets in this. But there's every,
- 27:44every opportunity for, for positive change overall. Stuart I
- 27:48always end my podcast with my three takeaways and the
- 27:51first is imagining you as that young kid hiding
- 27:55from the rain, skipping into this secondhand bookshop
- 27:59and somehow or other you walk out with how the other half dies
- 28:03and how life changing that was for you and I hope how
- 28:07many lives you saved because of that. You sometimes wonder
- 28:10if that was meant to be or what the coincidence
- 28:14was but something that day. And you strike me someone that's bought a lot of
- 28:17books over your life, but that one seems to be one that you held and
- 28:21read in a very different way. The second one is just the way
- 28:25you built your book is to me, I think, a great
- 28:29celebration. There's a lot of people on one side that
- 28:32will point their fingers at all the things that are wrong and
- 28:36there's others that will benefit from, as you call it, the five deadly Ds.
- 28:40But you're always finding that middle ground. And it's funny that I came up with
- 28:43this teeter totter a seesaw because you're always saying we don't have to get rid
- 28:46of all ultra process, but there has to be balance. And I like that and
- 28:50I like the way your book was balanced that I, you know, I was so
- 28:52depressed at the beginning, but I started to really see that there's things
- 28:56we can do. But probably the three words that'll stand
- 29:00out most on this podcast and I'm going to use again.
- 29:03Revelation before revolution. And I think we're very easy
- 29:07to, as I said earlier, sign petitions and feel like we're part of a
- 29:11revolution. But if we take the time and I call it head, heart and hands,
- 29:14to understand it, emotionally attach to it and
- 29:18then act upon it. If we can find a way to sort of link the
- 29:21head, the heart with the hands, I think we'll go from just simply
- 29:26firing social media spitballs and really start
- 29:29realizing that as citizens there's an awful lot we can do just in terms of
- 29:33what we're willing to put in our mouth mouth, because I think that'll also vote.
- 29:36I mean I think the whole food chain will respond to the fact if we
- 29:40say no to ultra processed foods, they're going to have to start doing things. And
- 29:43we've already seen that companies are stripping away bad ingredients. And, you know, it's
- 29:47a start, but I think we just got to keep doing it. So if I
- 29:50could frame it all. You're like Bill Nye the science Guy to me in the
- 29:53sense that you probably within your academic circles, as enlightening
- 29:57as possible to them and as boring as possible to the mass, but you're really,
- 30:00really bringing it and framing it in a way that I don't want to use
- 30:04the word average, that people that haven't got your scientific currency or
- 30:07credentials can act upon it. And I think that that could be your superpower
- 30:11going forward. Great. Well, thank you. I appreciate that.
- 30:21Many of you know that I often end my show by bringing on somebody
- 30:24from rbc. And more often than not, it extends
- 30:28beyond banking to the role organizations can play
- 30:32in helping individuals, corporations, communities, even
- 30:35Canada get to where it needs, wants and deserves to go.
- 30:39Joining me today is Lisa Ashton. She's the Agricultural Policy lead at
- 30:43RBC Thought Leadership. And Lisa, it's fantastic to have you on the show.
- 30:46Yes, thank you for having me. Tony, tell me a little bit about what you're
- 30:50doing as the agricultural policy lead and why is
- 30:54agriculture something that really RBC is focusing a lot of attention
- 30:57on? My role provides the opportunity to
- 31:01spearhead our agricultural research from most
- 31:05topical issues like trade and tariffs, but also
- 31:09important issues including climate and policy as
- 31:12well. So complimentary to that, engage with
- 31:16stakeholders across Canada to understand what
- 31:19issues are most important to them and work together
- 31:23to drive action. Because we're not only a think tank, but we're also a do
- 31:27tank. So I want to talk to you a little bit about Canada can become
- 31:30a superpower in agriculture. The quality of our
- 31:34food, the efficacy moving up from a commodity to value
- 31:38added, all of these things can play into this North Star.
- 31:42Is it possible that as a country we can play that role
- 31:45in terms of providing the food that the world so desperately needs?
- 31:49I would actually argue that Canada is already a
- 31:53powerhouse superpower in agriculture and agriculture, food production,
- 31:57but also export and believe under a high
- 32:01growth scenario, Canada could actually add $44 billion
- 32:05within the next 10 years. So there is certainly a North Star
- 32:09to move towards. I think there's a lot that needs to happen domestically. A
- 32:13lot needs to happen in terms of our trade growth and diversification
- 32:17approach. Emerging economies such as Brazil and
- 32:20Argentina are biting up some key
- 32:24categories that Traditionally are very important to Canada. So oil,
- 32:28seeds, grains and meats, that's one key
- 32:31challenge that Canada faces. It is somewhat in a way, kind of
- 32:35dulling its competitive edge relative to some of our traditional
- 32:39competitors like Australia, for example, who is really
- 32:43taking an aggressive leadership approach in terms of
- 32:46accessing what we're calling the growth market. So markets that you
- 32:50would expect to see high GDP and high population
- 32:53growth. Part of the issue is not so much our ability to grow,
- 32:57it's our ability to be a reliable exporter.
- 33:01Transportation infrastructure is a key,
- 33:04I guess linchpin in terms of our growth. When we
- 33:08compared ourselves to other key agri food exporters, including
- 33:11Brazil, Australia and the US we're behind all of them in terms
- 33:15of our turnaround time. And there's key challenges that
- 33:19slow that down for us in terms of getting product to market fast,
- 33:23such as rules around loading grain onto ships
- 33:27when it rains. I think the other element is also
- 33:30being a little bit more aggressive in how we are exploring
- 33:34and delivering on trade diversification.
- 33:38Canada has roughly 15 free trade agreements. That gives us access
- 33:42to more than two thirds of the global economy. So
- 33:45that's a lot of opportunity that's already on Canada's plate
- 33:49that it can be taking more advantage of, including within the
- 33:52European Union through the Trans Pacific
- 33:57Partnership and even some of our bilateral agreements
- 34:00with Ukraine, Chile, Colombia. We have access to all
- 34:04those markets. So taking a more aggressive approach to enter
- 34:07those markets and deliver our products to them is a key opportunity.
- 34:11Talk to me about technology, regenerative farming,
- 34:15some of the moves that are being made on the chessboard to not only
- 34:18maybe drive efficiency, but the efficacy of food. And
- 34:22how does that play into Canada in terms of our position globally?
- 34:26We are very fortunate to have a significant amount of
- 34:30natural resources, from water to land, a very efficient
- 34:33production system. So when we looked at Canada's agricultural
- 34:37total factor productivity. So basically how efficient
- 34:41are you using your inputs relative to your outputs? We
- 34:44exceed the OECD average. I think. I, I think it's important to note
- 34:48that we can't be productive if we don't have healthy soils and we don't
- 34:52have resilient ecosystems. So RBC
- 34:56works very closely with some of our corporate partners to help
- 34:59scale the adoption and access to climate smart
- 35:03practices. And we do that through one of our climate action
- 35:06alliances. I'm spending a lot of time helping youth
- 35:10find their path in life. A lot of them seem to dispute
- 35:14agriculture is a career. I have to believe that a career in
- 35:17agriculture has got to be something that's incredibly rewarding,
- 35:21purposeful, has nothing but creativity, innovation as part of it.
- 35:25That is a missed opportunity that agriculture is not kind of top of
- 35:28mind for many young people that are determining kind of
- 35:32what they want to do for their career because it is such an
- 35:36evolving and growing space. There's lots of exciting technology
- 35:40applications, so generative AI has a role from
- 35:44on farm efficiency all the way through the value chain.
- 35:47There's a lot of diverse opportunities. So for example, I'm
- 35:51technically a researcher, but I say I work in the agricultural sector.
- 35:55There's opportunities in marketing, communication, engineering,
- 35:59and it is really an exciting field and also a leading sector for
- 36:03Canada. So a place for you to really grow your career
- 36:07with the number of different avenues that can be taken. I
- 36:11really want to do more shows on why food means the world
- 36:14to all of us and why Canadian food means the world to the
- 36:18world. So I really appreciate you joining me in Chatter that Matters. Thank you Tony.
- 36:22Happy to join anytime. Once again,
- 36:25a special thanks to RBC for supporting Chatter that Matters. It's
- 36:29Tony Chapman. Thanks for listening and let's chat soon.
- 36:35Sam.