Latest / Before you say yes / Ep 4. What happens if there's no happily ever after? Before you say yes to a joint account
Transcript
- 0:02Before you say yes, have the conversation with your partner, with your sibling, with your family member.
- 0:10What happens if one of us gets sick?
- 0:13What happens if one of us is no longer able to pay?
- 0:17Have the conversation.
- 0:18Before you say yes, take the time.
- 0:22to make sure you've looked at the products, thought about whether this is the right thing for you.
- 0:29Just that little bit of extra time in almost any part of a financial transaction is time well spent to keep yourself that bit safer.
- 0:40I'm Catherine Fitzpatrick, former senior bank executive, now working with companies, governments and regulators around the world to change the way financial products are designed.
- 0:51This podcast is about financial consent, what to check, what to ask before you share your money, your accounts and your digital life with someone you love.
- 1:02So before you say yes to a joint account, listen to this.
- 1:08Not many of us get to adulthood without a bank account.
- 1:11Whether you've started with a passbook or you're only ever used to using an app, bank accounts are part and parcel of every day.
- 1:20And usually they're pretty simple, pretty frictionless actually.
- 1:24Then you meet someone, you move in together, you join finances and life gets busy.
- 1:30It's easy to overlook simple account settings or terms and conditions that are really important down the track if life throws you a curveball.
- 1:38So today I'm starting at the end, when the curveball comes.
- 1:43By starting at the end, thinking about what if, we give ourselves an opportunity to set it up properly from the start.
- 1:51Rebecca Glenn is the founder of the Centre for Women's Economic Safety.
- 1:56She'll tell you the decisions couples make about whose name goes on what, from the bank account to the car rego to the insurance to the bills, are some of the most consequential they'll ever make.
- 2:10And most people make them without thinking about it at all.
- 2:14The healthy money conversation is something that I think has the greatest preventative power possibly because it says, okay, you and I are two separate individuals.
- 2:28We have our own lives, but we're choosing to bring them together at this point.
- 2:34That doesn't mean we have to completely abandon our own financial identity.
- 2:39I think that's a really key proposition.
- 2:42Yeah, I've seen a lot of older women who have managed the accounts in their house for a very long time by using the credit card.
- 2:53And it happens to be a credit card that is actually in their husband's name or their partner's name.
- 2:59And unfortunately, when they're widowed, they get told
- 3:03Sorry, you can't have a credit card anymore.
- 3:04It wasn't your credit card.
- 3:06That's right.
- 3:07And so going in a bit eyes wide open, I think, is very helpful, but hard to do because, you know, young people are talking about consent when it comes to sex.
- 3:18What's my, you know, how do I ask you for consent?
- 3:22What is it?
- 3:22How do I give it?
- 3:23How do I take it away?
- 3:25How do we keep negotiating?
- 3:27We're not having the same conversation about money.
- 3:29Right.
- 3:29I mean, I think it's been a big missed opportunity, the respectful relationships curriculum, talking about all of these things, but not talking about money.
- 3:38So, you know, it is important.
- 3:40And it's important that we start having those conversations from a pretty young age.
- 3:44You know, people are getting jobs.
- 3:45They're, you know, sharing costs of a dinner.
- 3:49You're already a financial identity, you know, in current society.
- 3:53So why not have those conversations from teens?
- 3:57when people need to separate or change their financial arrangements, what makes it really complicated?
- 4:04And what is the thing that might surprise people about this is hard to do?
- 4:11So my brain automatically goes to it's really hard when someone's being obstructive, right?
- 4:16So when someone's being abusive, that's where the problems come.
- 4:19And you and I have talked about this, you know, for many, many, many hours.
- 4:24Joint products are just so sticky, right?
- 4:26Yeah.
- 4:27Because joint products don't work unless both people are pulling in the same direction.
- 4:31Yeah.
- 4:33And as soon as you get to, you know, as soon as there's abuse, someone's not.
- 4:38And that is all about exerting their power and control over the other person.
- 4:43So it doesn't even matter if there's a financial incentive for them to do the right thing.
- 4:48They need to show control.
- 4:49So obviously, you know, having an obstructive person is the biggest challenge.
- 4:55But I think there are other challenges.
- 4:56There are, you know, challenges where there's a mismatch between, you know, one person's income and another person's income.
- 5:04And there might be an informal arrangement between a couple.
- 5:07Well, I'll pay for this, but you can pay for all those things.
- 5:11Fair enough.
- 5:12We all manage our finances in couples in varying ways that make sense to us.
- 5:18But if it turns out that that informal arrangement is, well, you pay the mortgage and I'll pay all of these bills, and actually what you have is...
- 5:29you know, one liability in one person's name and all of the informal things and someone else has taken care of, actually one person can be left with the liability.
- 5:39Yeah.
- 5:40So, you know, I was taking responsibility for these things, but actually there's no, you know, the groceries and all of the day to day expenses that, you know, I can just stop tomorrow.
- 5:50Yeah.
- 5:51And someone else has got the bill in their name.
- 5:53So it's the joint accounts, but it's also then the accounts where, well, I'll put the rego in my name for the car.
- 6:00And that's fantastic.
- 6:01You're going to pay that.
- 6:02I'll have paid this other stuff.
- 6:04But if I then don't pay the rego or someone doesn't pay the rego, but I'm driving the car, I'm the one who gets pulled over with invalid rego.
- 6:13So how would you encourage people to look at that in the setup?
- 6:20Because it's really common that you might say, well, we'll just sort it out like this and not really pay a lot of attention to whose name is on what bill.
- 6:30What would you be saying to them, well, if you are setting it up, here's how you need to think about that?
- 6:38One helpful lens can be, and I sort of touched on this a bit earlier, one helpful lens to look at this can be, what happens if one of us is in an accident?
- 6:48What happens if one of us is sick?
- 6:51What happens if one of us dies?
- 6:53Again, that's not something people like to look into either.
- 6:57But can I keep driving this car if you're sick or in a coma in hospital?
- 7:06Well, in the case where the reg is in that person's name, no.
- 7:09So maybe we need to think about if it's the car that I drive, the rego should be in my name.
- 7:13Yeah.
- 7:14So is there an alignment between the actual way a product is being used and who has the responsibility on paper?
- 7:23That's one way to get into the nitty gritty without going, oh.
- 7:28all the way to you might abuse me one day.
- 7:30Yeah, yeah.
- 7:31And, you know, we're not trying to scare people about this too, but there are simple things you can do that are going to protect you regardless.
- 7:40If someone's sick, if someone does...
- 7:43die, awful, terrible, loses their job for a long period of time.
- 7:48So the assumption is you get married or you move in together as life partners and you live happily ever after.
- 7:56And there's never a problem that when you want to make a change to the product, you both agree that that's in both of your best interests.
- 8:04And it simply isn't set up for a disagreement for one party to think differently about a product or for people to separate often, you know, unless they both have each other's best interests at heart.
- 8:24When a relationship breaks down, things can get a lot more heated up.
- 8:28It's pretty common business practice to have the exit clause, which is if both parties disagree, we'll end this contract in this way.
- 8:35Yeah.
- 8:36Why isn't it the case with financial products?
- 8:39It's so true.
- 8:40And I think about financial products not just as a bank account or a loan.
- 8:45I think about it as your energy bill, which is a credit product, your water bill, which is a credit product.
- 8:52Telco tends to be the same.
- 8:54Yeah, your phone or your internet.
- 8:55Yeah.
- 8:56All of those things are you are getting something that you have to pay a bill for later.
- 9:01And you're right, there is normally those exit clauses, but it feels like it's been a bit icky to step into that when we're in love.
- 9:10And so we surely cannot talk about that as a contract term.
- 9:16If you were to go back in time...
- 9:19and you're with someone who's about to sign up to their bank account, they might have a joint bank account, or they're getting a loan together for the first time, or even they're just working out whose name's going to be on the electricity bill, or are both of them going to be on the electricity bill?
- 9:38What would you want them to understand at that moment?
- 9:41Yeah, I think we would want people to ask,
- 9:45what is my liability with this product?
- 9:48We talked previously about illness and accident.
- 9:51What happens if?
- 9:52And I think if they understand that, then there's at least some options around, well, we should both be on that one, or alternatively not, if maybe one person has an income.
- 10:04There are different decisions that people are going to make.
- 10:07And so what I'd be really keen to see is providers providing more options.
- 10:13So whether that is, you know, a term and condition that allows for, look, if both parties can't agree, then this product is just going to be ended, null and void.
- 10:24I think that would give people options where they could have a conversation to say, that sounds like something we want to go in for.
- 10:33I think the game-changing piece of the last decade has really been the manner in which smartphones have become our everything.
- 10:47We've supported at the money clinics recently young women who, while they were sleeping, their partner used their phone to take out a personal loan and
- 10:58The money was taken out of their accounts by their partner before they even realised they had a loan.
- 11:05And it's just so easy now.
- 11:07If you have a few pieces of personal information about someone and their smartphone, that's all you need.
- 11:16And unfortunately, while the financial institutions have really upped their game around frauds and scams, in this case, this young woman went to the bank and said what had happened.
- 11:28The fraud team investigated, said she hadn't reported her phone stolen.
- 11:33IP address says she's right here.
- 11:35So no, no can do.
- 11:37We can't help.
- 11:38So I think the sophistication around frauds and scams, you know, it's about how do we bring that?
- 11:43And I agree it is a much more complex issue.
- 11:46But how do we start to become more sophisticated about what is happening, particularly in intimate partners, but it could also be obviously, you know, a sibling, a carer, a family member that's happening.
- 11:58I think that's where we've got to look at.
- 12:00The money conversation is something that keeps coming up again and again.
- 12:05But these conversations usually involve two people with emotions in a relationship.
- 12:11And let's be honest, it's complex.
- 12:13On the one hand, you've got your bank.
- 12:16We all know they're slightly serious, less emotional, and the thousands of words in their terms and conditions make it really complicated.
- 12:25But banks have a role to play when life gets tricky.
- 12:28Simon Birmingham is the CEO of the Australian Banking Association, the peak body for Australia's banks and custodian of the Banking Industry Code of Practice.
- 12:39He knows what the code says your bank will do for you and what it can't do, no matter how much you may need it to.
- 12:46I really want to dive into parts of the code.
- 12:49I know it's got specific sections in it that talk about joint accounts and what consumers can expect of their banks when they're going to start having a joint account.
- 13:00That's right.
- 13:01Joint accounts, of course, by their very name and title indicate what it is and people step into that.
- 13:08always usually hopefully thinking the best in terms of what they're signing on to and in doing so, thinking that there is a joint access and joint pathways, and that is accurate.
- 13:21There are also, because it is joint,
- 13:23then legal provisions that apply in terms of what can or can't be done by individuals.
- 13:30Joint accounts are legally held as joint accounts.
- 13:33Each individual has rights under those joint accounts.
- 13:38And that means that there are many things that banks cannot do just because one person asks without necessarily seeking the authority of the other person, which is
- 13:48why very sensitive and careful conversations are needed when things do go wrong and somebody is seeking help in those circumstances.
- 13:56I've been talking a lot recently about joint and several liability.
- 14:00People think I get very nerdy because I really like terms and conditions and I've spent far too long reading people's terms and conditions, but I don't think a lot of people really understand what that...
- 14:11construct is in a contract that it means both people are on the hook for a loan 100%.
- 14:17A lot of people think they're getting a loan.
- 14:18It might be 50-50 or something.
- 14:21So that's been an interesting conversation to me about joint accounts.
- 14:24So you talked about the code says, here's what banks can and can't do, say, if somebody wants to exit a joint account because relationships change and circumstances change, or
- 14:39What does the code say about changing those joint arrangements?
- 14:44So you can't just walk in and say, I want to exit an account, take half the money with me, and I want you to do it without any engagement with the other person.
- 14:58It's unfortunately in terms of those difficult circumstances, the case that those legal rights, those legal obligations, create a set of circumstances where banks are,
- 15:09need to go through certain steps to uphold their legal responsibilities.
- 15:14The code tries to provide the basis for them to make clear what those legal responsibilities are in terms of where they do need to get joint authority, but also, and especially when it then comes to the
- 15:33how bank staff should actually engage with people to do that sensitively in a way that is trying to achieve the best possible outcome that can meet
- 15:44the reasonable needs and wants of somebody who's making a request while upholding those legal frameworks.
- 15:52The advice about how that can be done, of course, how existing credit arrangements or other things will impact on that, and making sure that people understand
- 16:04perhaps the transition steps that might be necessary.
- 16:08And it can happen in all manner of circumstances.
- 16:11We're focused on perhaps the hardest of circumstances being those of family and domestic violence and abuse, but equally older couples and circumstances where a credit card might be in the primary name of a
- 16:33Usually, historically, the man having conversations about, well, what will that mean?
- 16:38How do we manage those finances?
- 16:41Far more easily done before you're bereaved or in those circumstances of separation,
- 16:50I'm glad you raised that as an example.
- 16:53It's one that I talk about all the time, actually, because most people will know a widow where they've then been told, what do you mean I don't have a credit card anymore?
- 17:03I've been using this credit card for years, but actually it was their husbands.
- 17:08And I say it's widows and husbands because that's what you hear about and it's
- 17:15The data does show that that's how it works.
- 17:18And they're really surprised by that and then maybe can't get another credit card later.
- 17:23It's an issue that I would really like banks to fix.
- 17:26I hope we can work through it.
- 17:28It's front of mind because, to be perfectly honest, probably as we're sitting here right now, I think my mum is in the bank having told me she was going to go in today and...
- 17:39Stepfather, her husband, in aged care, knowing it will come at some point.
- 17:45Yeah.
- 17:46And is in exactly that circumstance where the cards are all historically in his name.
- 17:51Yeah.
- 17:52And it's why I'm doing this podcast too, to help people think about what are
- 17:57What are these circumstances?
- 17:59It's not necessarily about financial abuse because it could be someone is ill or they're sick or they pass.
- 18:09But also there's been a lot of work in banking about fraud and scams and detecting those and preventing those.
- 18:17And I think a lot of the safer design and the monitoring that banks do may also apply to financial abuse because the tactics are quite similar.
- 18:27Why is it that banks have said we need to do something about domestic and family violence and financial abuse?
- 18:35Because banks have recognised that joint accounts, financial instruments, loans, deposits, all of those things that become ever more entangled in relationships can be used as weapons and that in using them as weapons, that can be inflicting trauma in a whole manner of different ways.
- 18:58And this is where the complexity between sometimes what...
- 19:02The law says in all of those joint circumstances versus what the circumstances actually are is a difficult point.
- 19:09So guidelines have been developed to try to help navigate a pathway for banks and for staff and institutions through those difficult sets of circumstances.
- 19:20Tragically, we've seen things like the weaponisation of messages on account transfers, as well as the threats around what people will or won't do with assets and finances that people have.
- 19:38So it can manifest itself in a whole range of ways.
- 19:42I think it's a really critical but hidden role that a bank might play to support somebody.
- 19:50But what other support could bank staff provide if you needed to go and get some help?
- 19:57So bank staff can provide assistance and referral.
- 20:02And so the expectations on bank staff in terms of the way in which they are honest about what can and can't be done, that they are compassionate in the way they go about that.
- 20:15but also the options that they can present in terms of how people may be able to act within their rights to establish some of their own financial assets or products.
- 20:29So there are, in the guidelines, expectations for banks in terms of the conversations that can be had in confidence, in terms of protecting certain information that people may share in relation
- 20:46Those things that are sensitive to obviously a circumstance of potential violence, harassment, threats or intimidation.
- 20:54And so making sure that staff are aware, appropriately trained.
- 21:01And that really goes, of course, to how to engage with a bank and staff.
- 21:07Not everybody's going to be able to have the right conversation with the right person the first time.
- 21:15And so going into to as best you can outline the circumstances and why you are trying to exit an account or change in arrangements, absolutely.
- 21:29and making sure that you're then asking who is the right person to talk to and getting the person at the end of the phone, at the end of the chat line if you'd rather type a message and don't feel like talking to somebody, or the teller across the counter, making sure that they're understanding that you want to make sure you're speaking to somebody who understands, is trained, is skilled, and is able to help you.
- 21:53Sometimes that will be the first person you talk to
- 21:56But sometimes it will be a case that because of the complexity, it's better that a specialist gets involved.
- 22:03I would encourage lots of people to control F in their terms and conditions and look for the words financial abuse, because Australia is the first country in the world to have made it really clear in their product terms for customers that if you misuse our products for financial abuse, there'll be consequences.
- 22:24banks are the biggest adopters of those terms.
- 22:27How do you think that that has come about and why are banks so keen to support such an initiative?
- 22:38There's a responsibility banks have
- 22:41to their customers and to society generally, but also to their frontline staff and others to try to get these things right and to respond to increased awareness and knowledge.
- 22:55And the reality is the understanding of financial abuse and, of course, of family and domestic violence overall is far greater today
- 23:07than it was in years gone by.
- 23:09If you can get the terms and conditions and the product design better, then you can harm minimise before you've actually got the problem.
- 23:22My takeaway from Beck and Simon, the word joint is doing a lot of heavy lifting in most financial products, even the ones you don't think of as a financial product, like a bill from your energy or your water company.
- 23:35It sounds like equal, but it's not.
- 23:38It means both of you are responsible for all of that debt.
- 23:44And most products have been built on the assumption that the relationship lasts forever.
- 23:49And both of you always agree.
- 23:51Nobody told you that, but now you know.
- 23:53So before you say yes to a joint account, do this.
- 23:57Your phone is a bank.
- 23:59If someone has your phone and a few pieces of your personal information, they can take out a loan in your name, even while you're asleep.
- 24:08Treat your phone and its financial apps like your wallet, your own PIN, your own credentials, and not shared.
- 24:15Keep a separate account in your own name.
- 24:19maybe even at a different institution.
- 24:22Your financial identity needs to be independent of your relationship.
- 24:27So think about your salary hitting your account first, and from there you're transferring it to shared accounts or to shared mortgages.
- 24:35But it starts with yours.
- 24:37If you need to talk to your bank about a joint account and something that might have gone wrong, ask for the right person.
- 24:44The person you reach out to may not be trained for complex situations.
- 24:49You can ask for someone who specialises in financial hardship or sensitive circumstances.
- 24:54And the banking code means your bank has obligations, confidentiality, compassion, and options.
- 25:02You're entitled to that conversation.
- 25:05This isn't about expecting the worst.
- 25:07It's about not being surprised by it because love shouldn't cost you freedom.