Latest / The Film Hobbyist / It Happened One Night (1934) : The First Rom Com
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:31We're sitting here in a nook of my attic room.
- 0:36It's below freezing outside, and this room is
- 0:39poorly insulated. To your left is a space heater
- 0:43working at its highest temperature, so it is
- 0:46somehow both too cold and too hot. Feel free
- 0:51to move about, to adjust. You can get closer
- 0:54to the windows or the space heater, or just bury
- 0:58yourself under a granny square blanket. I myself
- 1:02am in a hoodie and fuzzy Crocs. But the freezing
- 1:07weather is proof of a new year. I understand
- 1:11that to many the shift is arbitrary. Not that
- 1:14much really changes between the last day of December
- 1:17and January 1st. And yet, there is a psychological
- 1:22reality, a sense that cracking open a new planner
- 1:26or setting up a new calendar causes a genuine
- 1:30shift in the air. New beginnings are a beautiful
- 1:34thing to witness. They may be echoes of the past,
- 1:38but they may also set up a template for the future.
- 1:42One of my joys as a film hobbyist is to discover
- 1:46the beginnings of things, of tropes, of storytelling
- 1:50conventions, of visual language. It's a wild
- 1:55thing to watch a movie and realize you are witnessing
- 1:58the first version of a particular sequence or
- 2:02the origin of a catchphrase. And the firsts are
- 2:05very interesting. Occasionally, yes, they can
- 2:10be less exciting because of subsequent innovations,
- 2:14but more frequently, they're fascinating and
- 2:17bizarre for what they get right away, where they
- 2:20stumble, and the weird and interesting bits that
- 2:24get filed away as an idea matures. Today we're
- 2:29going to talk about Frank Capra's 1934 film,
- 2:32It Happened One Night. The first rom -com. Now,
- 2:38of course, this isn't the first romance. It isn't
- 2:41the first comedy. It isn't the first comedy to
- 2:45contain a romance. Heck, Shakespeare was exploring
- 2:49the comedic hijinks of romance and misunderstanding
- 2:52way back in the 16th century. Jane Austen matured
- 2:57those ideas by embracing the complexities of
- 3:00class and cultural expectations and using that
- 3:03to build intrigue while still giving us the sincerity
- 3:07of a happy ending. Silent film also explored
- 3:13comedic romance, but it couldn't fully establish
- 3:16the genre as we understand it today. The modern
- 3:21romantic comedy as it stands, has several important
- 3:24non -negotiables. The romance should be the main
- 3:28plot. Any other plot should be secondary. There
- 3:33have to be hijinks or misunderstandings, but
- 3:36there also have to be sincere moments together.
- 3:40The couple must end up together at the end of
- 3:43the film, and there has to be some kind of verbal
- 3:46sparring. Now, this wordplay doesn't have to
- 3:49be in person. It can be through letters, or it
- 3:53can even be with friends or colleagues rather
- 3:55than the romantic interest, as is in the case
- 3:58with Sleepless in Seattle. But these verbal interactions
- 4:02are a really important part of the genre. It's
- 4:06a holdover from the Shakespearean roots carried
- 4:08all the way through Austen, and it's the one
- 4:11thing that silent film absolutely cannot do.
- 4:16Now, early talkies put romantic plots to use
- 4:20right away. The Broadway Melody of 1929 is a
- 4:24wild film, with double romances all messed together
- 4:28and too much melodrama. It took a couple of years
- 4:32for film screenplays to be more than sentences
- 4:35strung together, and by the time Capra and his
- 4:39co -screenwriter Robert Riskin penned It Happened
- 4:42One Night, standards were a little higher. And
- 4:46what they put together stands out as surprisingly
- 4:49fresh. I grew up in a post -When Harry Met Sally
- 4:54world, a veritable heyday for rom -coms, thanks
- 4:57to the efforts of Nora Ephron. Both 1994's Sleepless
- 5:03in Seattle and 1998's You've Got Mail were major
- 5:07trendsetters, high -water marks influencing and
- 5:10encouraging the other explorations of the genre.
- 5:14It's not a coincidence that both of them are
- 5:17in conversation with classic films, Sleepless
- 5:20in Seattle discussing 1957's romantic drama An
- 5:24Affair to Remember, and You've Got Mail being
- 5:27a remake of 1940's The Shop Around the Corner.
- 5:31Nora Ephron was heavily inspired by screwball
- 5:35comedies, the zany... and romantic comedies of
- 5:39error that thrived in the decade between the
- 5:42mid -1930s and the end of World War II. These
- 5:46films relied heavily on clever dialogue to hide
- 5:50innuendo and conversations about both sex and
- 5:54violence. Because in June of 1934, the Hollywood
- 5:58studio system fully implemented the Hays Code,
- 6:02a set of rules about what could and could not
- 6:05be depicted on screen. Self -censorship, so that
- 6:09no government entity would have to be created
- 6:12to monitor and crack down on film content. So
- 6:16all depictions of sex went underground, hiding
- 6:19in misunderstanding and wordplay. Nora Ephron's
- 6:24innovation was to pull the patter of the screwball
- 6:27comedy into a day and age where the film could
- 6:30be entirely frank conversations about sex. No
- 6:35having to pretend that either character wasn't
- 6:37interested. One of the things that makes It Happened
- 6:41One Night such a fascinating beginning to the
- 6:45romantic comedy is that it was released just
- 6:47four months before the Hays Code was established.
- 6:51It squeaked in just before the crackdown. And
- 6:55while it's definitely tamer than When Harry Met
- 6:58Sally, it does exist in a world where people
- 7:01sleep together. Women have to be careful of predators,
- 7:05and men have to go the extra step to communicate
- 7:08that they're not a sexual threat. Also, just
- 7:12because someone is married doesn't mean that
- 7:14they are immune to physical attraction and romantic
- 7:17chemistry. Not to mention the iconography of
- 7:21hitchhiking by hiking up a hemline. And perhaps
- 7:25that's a big part of why It Happened One Night
- 7:28feels so fresh. even as it feels old -fashioned.
- 7:33We're not used to seeing old black -and -white
- 7:36movies that are pretty frank about the existence
- 7:39of sex, and so it really does set a template
- 7:42for both the cleaner films that followed under
- 7:45the Hays Code and the raunchier films that populated
- 7:49the cinemas of my childhood. I don't know if
- 7:53you've seen this movie, but I'm going to give
- 7:56you a full rundown of the plot here. I have no
- 7:59qualms doing so. So much of a romantic comedy
- 8:02is already knowing where the plot is headed and
- 8:05enjoying it anyway. It's about the sheer pleasure
- 8:09of the journey. So here we go. It Happened One
- 8:14Night is about a young heiress named Ellen, or
- 8:17Ellie Andrews, played by Claudette Colbert, whose
- 8:20elopement to the dashing pilot King Wesley was
- 8:23just interrupted by her wealthy banker father.
- 8:27She has been sequestered aboard a Florida yacht
- 8:29while he tries to annul the marriage. Ellie,
- 8:33who will not be told no or manipulated, despite
- 8:36her father's doubts about King Wesley's values,
- 8:39jumps from the boat and swims to shore, pawning
- 8:42her jewelry and fine things to take a night bus
- 8:45up the length of the country to New York City.
- 8:49On the bus as well is Peter Warren, played by
- 8:52Clark Gable, a hard -on -his -luck reporter.
- 8:55The two are the last passengers to enter the
- 8:58bus and tussle over the final bench. Ellie tries
- 9:01to take the whole seat to herself, assuming it
- 9:04as her privilege, and Peter is able to use his
- 9:07knowledge of the night bus to get her to budge
- 9:10over. The following morning, Ellie takes a luxurious
- 9:14hotel breakfast, assuming the bus will wait for
- 9:16her, and misses her ride. Peter, having read
- 9:21about her escape in the paper, makes her a deal.
- 9:24He'll travel with her to New York, offering his
- 9:27street smarts as protection if she'll give him
- 9:30an exclusive interview about the experience.
- 9:33Otherwise, he'll tell her father where she is
- 9:36and collect a reward. Ellie reluctantly agrees,
- 9:40especially after another passenger, married and
- 9:43looking for an affair, hits on her. Peter protects
- 9:47her with the ruse that he and Ellie are married.
- 9:51That night, Peter uses the ruse again to get
- 9:54them a cabin at a motor camp, who would not rent
- 9:57to an unmarried couple. Ellie is clearly uncomfortable,
- 10:01but Peter strings a rope between the two beds,
- 10:04hung with a blanket, that he calls the Walls
- 10:06of Jericho, making it clear that she's not in
- 10:09any sexual danger from him. The next morning,
- 10:13Ellie gets another privileged wake -up call when
- 10:16she has to wait in line for the shower and make
- 10:18do with half an egg and half a donut for breakfast.
- 10:21She and Peter bond over the adventure, especially
- 10:25when they have to pretend to be a squabbling
- 10:27married couple to hide from private detectives
- 10:29sent by her father. Along the ride, a passenger
- 10:34recognizes Ellie from the newspaper. And when
- 10:37the bus gets stuck in a swamp, Peter has to come
- 10:39up with another ruse to scare him off. He and
- 10:43Ellie continue on foot, bantering and squabbling
- 10:46and bonding. Ellie experiences hunger for the
- 10:50first time, going to bed on a haystack with an
- 10:53empty stomach and having to accept raw carrots
- 10:56as an acceptable breakfast. Peter has to learn
- 10:59that he doesn't know everything as his hitchhiking
- 11:02attempts go wrong and Ellie is able to get a
- 11:04car by sticking out a bare leg. After obtaining
- 11:07a car in an attempted robbery, they stop at another
- 11:10motor inn under false pretenses, though the wife
- 11:13of the owner is suspicious of them. That night,
- 11:17between the walls of Jericho, Ellie shares the
- 11:21doubts she's begun to have about remaining married
- 11:24to King Wesley. Peter admits that he wouldn't
- 11:28mind being married if he could take his wife
- 11:30on a trip to a Pacific island he'd once seen.
- 11:34Ellie crosses her side of the wall and confesses
- 11:38that she's in love with him and wants to run
- 11:40away from Wesley and her father and keep the
- 11:42adventure going. Peter initially refuses, but
- 11:48can't stop thinking about this suggestion. He
- 11:51asks if she really meant it, but she's cried
- 11:55herself to sleep. Peter, moved by sudden impulse,
- 12:00packs up his things and drives to New York City
- 12:03to his old editor and one -time friend, writing
- 12:06up his account of the trip in print and asking
- 12:08for a loan of $1 ,000, planning to return to
- 12:11Ellie before she awakes and run away with her.
- 12:15The motel owner's wife wakes up in the middle
- 12:18of the night and, seeing the car gone, assumes
- 12:21the couple has fled without paying. They storm
- 12:24into the cabin, waking up Ellie and kick her
- 12:27out when she doesn't have money to pay. Ellie,
- 12:30assuming Peter has abandoned her, calls her father,
- 12:34who has since teamed up with Westley. Peter,
- 12:38ironically uncynical for once, is passed by Ellie's
- 12:42father in a police escort and sees Ellie curled
- 12:46up next to Westley. He drives back to New York
- 12:50and returns the money to his editor. Ellie's
- 12:54father has agreed to throw an official wedding
- 12:56for Ellie and Wesley, but the morning of he finds
- 12:59a sad and distracted Ellen. She confesses that
- 13:03she fell in love with Peter, even though he doesn't
- 13:06think very highly of her or her father. Her dad
- 13:09declares he can pay off Wesley and track Peter
- 13:12down and make him marry her, but Ellie refuses.
- 13:16She will do the responsible thing and honor her
- 13:20marriage to Wesley. She's not going to be a brat.
- 13:24as Peter Chumily called her, anymore. But then
- 13:28she learns that Peter has asked to meet with
- 13:30her father over a financial affair. She assumes
- 13:34he's come to claim the $10 ,000 reward, and the
- 13:37two have a very frosty interaction while she
- 13:39attempts to drink her cares away. Peter, however,
- 13:42has come to ask for a payment of $39 .60, all
- 13:46of the money he spent to bring Ellie home. After
- 13:50some pressure by Ellie's father, he admits that
- 13:53he is in love with her and deeply frustrated
- 13:55by it. While walking Ellie down the aisle, her
- 13:58dad tells her the truth about Peter and that
- 14:01there's a car waiting for her out by the street
- 14:03if she wants to escape. She does. Later, we learn
- 14:08that Wesley was easily paid off, the marriage
- 14:11was annulled, and Peter and Ellie are together
- 14:13at a different motor camp, toppling the walls
- 14:16of Jericho. As I said, I feel no qualms outlining
- 14:22that entire plot to you. It's not the most original
- 14:26plot in the world. You've probably seen a dozen
- 14:30or so films with similar plot beats. The lover
- 14:33that the female lead dumps for the male lead
- 14:36is such a common trope that he's even named the
- 14:39Baxter and has his own eponymous movie. The enemies
- 14:44-to -lover plot is incredibly popular in romance
- 14:47novels right now. It's practically its own genre
- 14:50at this point. The lying and scheming and ruses
- 14:54were all over screwball comedies and show up
- 14:58in While You Were Sleeping and How to Lose a
- 15:01Guy in 10 Days, which even has the whole relationship
- 15:05for a newspaper article plot. The proposal is
- 15:09an extension of the lying about being in a relationship
- 15:12thing and poor little rich girls wishing for
- 15:15a real man on an adventure. is all over romances
- 15:20in general. I can tell you for certain that I
- 15:24didn't spoil the real joy of watching this film.
- 15:28The phenomenal chemistry between Claudette Colbert
- 15:32and Clark Gable. An amazing experience that absolutely
- 15:37matches Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan. We never see
- 15:42them kiss, but... Good lordy, there are sequences
- 15:46here where the tension is absolutely palpable.
- 15:50It actually kind of helps. Because old movie
- 15:53kisses can sometimes be weird, just two faces
- 15:57smashing into each other. So the fact that they
- 16:00just get close makes it even more awesome. But
- 16:05I am talking about this movie as a first. As
- 16:08the beginning of a new genre. And how it is different.
- 16:13What pieces from the first stand out as oddities?
- 16:18So we have to talk about King Wesley. Typically,
- 16:22the Baxter is kind of a sad sack. He's not as
- 16:26interesting or exciting as the male lead. We
- 16:30have to feel good about our female protagonist
- 16:33dumping him. Also, I don't know another movie
- 16:37where the female lead has already done a grand
- 16:41romantic gesture to marry a dashing stranger
- 16:44that the rest of the movie undoes. I can't think
- 16:48of another romantic comedy where the Baxter is
- 16:50the female protagonist's husband. Now, he's usually
- 16:54her fiancé, or her long -term boyfriend, but
- 16:58modern romances don't like to start with a divorce.
- 17:03Unless it's a romantic drama, in which case the
- 17:07lover is abusive or a jerk. Wesley isn't abusive.
- 17:13He's a slimy show -off. He's posh and a party
- 17:18boy and an aviator, which at the time was not
- 17:22too dissimilar to being a drag racer. But he's
- 17:26never mean to Ellie. He just indulges her worst
- 17:31impulses. He's a brat that wants her to be a
- 17:36brat. Ellie explains at one point that she's
- 17:40always been shadowed by security. The first time
- 17:44she was alone with a man, it was King. I think
- 17:48this is a really insightful detail about Ellie
- 17:51and her life. She's been stuck in an ivory tower.
- 17:57But the only way she's claimed freedom is to
- 18:01rail like a petulant child, to throw things and
- 18:04run away, to take what she wants for herself.
- 18:08King feels like freedom, but he's actually just
- 18:13another ivory tower. An ivory tower where she's
- 18:17trapped being a brat. For the rival to be a good
- 18:23match for the protagonist's worse self, is pretty
- 18:27interesting. The fact that this movie contains
- 18:31actual character growth is even more so. Rom
- 18:36-coms aren't known for character development
- 18:39or change. The change of circumstances, yes,
- 18:43but actual character development isn't usually
- 18:46part of the package. Yes, the entire hook of
- 18:50When Harry Met Sally is about real character
- 18:53change. I would argue that 27 Dresses is two,
- 18:57but more frequently, the characters stay the
- 19:01same. It's the external circumstances and relationship
- 19:06dynamics that change. This is also why rom -coms
- 19:11aren't exactly my favorite genre. A lot of them
- 19:15are about beautiful, terrible people with great
- 19:18chemistry being terrible to each other and everyone
- 19:21else until they kiss. It Happened One Night is
- 19:26about a spoiled brat who realizes she's a spoiled
- 19:30brat and a cynic who learns to believe in something.
- 19:36Ellie begins the movie with a grand romantic
- 19:39gesture. She jumps off a yacht and swims to shore
- 19:43to escape to be with her husband. She's not very
- 19:46aware of the world around her and is often impulsive.
- 19:51Peter is incredibly cynical. and aware of the
- 19:55world around him. He's going to hold his cards
- 19:58close to his chest. And yet, he believes. He's
- 20:06the one who takes the grand romantic risk. He's
- 20:10the one who impulsively drives off to New York
- 20:13City in the middle of the night. He types up
- 20:16his actual real feelings toward Ellie. He barters
- 20:20his hat for a tank of gas. He sings at the top
- 20:23of his lungs like a romantic fool. Ellie, meanwhile,
- 20:27makes the responsible, pragmatic choice. She
- 20:32decides to settle down, to avoid all this nonsense.
- 20:37She's very aware at the end of who Wesley is.
- 20:41She knows what kind of life lies before her.
- 20:44Her choice to stay with him is well thought out.
- 20:50The dramatic irony of the two learning from each
- 20:53other only to miss each other like a twisted
- 20:56gift of the magi is a beautiful way to set up
- 20:59a compromise of an ending. Ellie makes another
- 21:04grand romantic gesture backed by a well -reasoned
- 21:08plan. Peter goes off with her on an adventure
- 21:12to Michigan. But they're going to wait until
- 21:15her first marriage is officially annulled so
- 21:17as to not risk any legal consequences. And boy,
- 21:22even though we don't see anything but a blanket
- 21:26falling to the floor, our imaginations are very
- 21:30aware of the absolute fireworks going off in
- 21:33that cabin as the walls of Jericho fall. So if
- 21:38you want something fresh from a stale genre,
- 21:41Go find where it all began. Where it happened
- 21:46one night. Thanks for coming.