Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use the Law of Scarcity to Build Office Influence
Transcript
- Lucas: You know that coworker who somehow always gets pulled into every important meeting, even when the agenda barely touches their area? The one whose calendar looks like a game of Tetris, and everyone knows if you need something done you go through them. Luna: Oh, I know exactly the type. There's a woman in our marketing analytics team, Priya, who basically owns the company's customer segmentation model. If you want a slice of that data, you go to her. Lucas: Right. And Priya has something most of us don't: scarcity. Not the manufactured kind — genuine, irreplaceable expertise that the organization depends on. Today I want to talk about how the law of scarcity operates in office politics, and how you can put it to work without becoming a bottleneck or a jerk. Luna: That last part is key. I've seen people try to create artificial scarcity — hoarding information, making themselves the sole gatekeeper — and it usually ends with everyone resenting them. Lucas: Before we dig into the mechanics, quick honest thing. This show is ad-free, and that's only possible because a handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. If the show has helped you think through a career move or a tricky workplace situation, that link is there. No pressure, just wanted to say it. Luna: Yeah, it's a small thing that keeps the lights on. And I love that we can stay independent. Okay, back to scarcity. Lucas: So the law of scarcity is a cognitive bias: we place higher value on things that are rare or hard to get. In the office, that translates to people, skills, and access. If you're the only one who can run a certain report or fix a legacy system, you've got built-in scarcity. Luna: Priya is a good example. She built that segmentation model from scratch over two years. No one else fully understands the data sources or the weighting logic. So when the VP of product needs a quick customer cohort analysis, he goes straight to her. Lucas: And that gives her leverage. She can prioritize her own projects, push back on unreasonable deadlines, and even negotiate for resources. But here's the trap: if she never documents her process or trains a backup, she becomes a single point of failure. That's not influence — that's a hostage situation. Luna: Exactly. The organization might depend on her, but they'll also see her as a risk. I've seen managers get passed over for promotion because their boss was afraid to move them out of their current role — they were too valuable where they were. Lucas: That's the scarcity paradox. To use it well, you need to be valuable enough that people seek you out, but replaceable enough that you're not stuck. The trick is to own the expertise while deliberately sharing the knowledge. Luna: So how do you do that without losing your edge? Lucas: Let's break it into three strategies. First, develop a skill that's genuinely rare in your organization. It could be data analysis, contract negotiation, public speaking, or knowing how the legacy ERP system works. But it has to be something the business actually needs, not just a niche you find interesting. Luna: Right. No one gets leverage from being the only person who knows how to use the 1998 copy machine. Lucas: Second, make your expertise visible. Don't hide it. Volunteer for cross-functional projects, write a quick internal guide, present at team meetings. The goal is to be known as the go-to person, not the secret keeper. Luna: And third? Lucas: Third, document and train. Teach someone else your core process. Create a knowledge base entry. That might feel counterintuitive — why give away your advantage? But here's the thing: when you're the person who trained others, you become the expert's expert. People will still come to you for the hard questions, and you free yourself up to work on higher-value stuff. Luna: That makes sense. Priya actually did that last year. She trained two junior analysts on the segmentation model. Now she's leading a new initiative on predictive analytics, and the model runs fine without her day-to-day involvement. But when something breaks, she's still the one they call. Lucas: Perfect example. She increased her scarcity by moving upstream. She's now the only person who can build the next generation of models, while the old model runs on autopilot. That's the sweet spot. Luna: What about the dark side? I've seen people try to manufacture scarcity by creating urgency — 'I need this by Friday or the deal falls through' — even when it's not real. That always backfires, right? Lucas: Almost always. The problem with manufactured scarcity is that it's transparent. People figure out quickly that every deadline is 'critical' and every project is 'top priority.' You lose credibility. The real leverage comes from actual scarcity — the kind that's rooted in genuine expertise or access. Luna: But what about access scarcity? Like being the only person on the team who regularly talks to the CEO. That's a form of scarcity that isn't a skill. Lucas: It is. And it can be valuable, but it's also fragile. If the CEO leaves or your relationship sours, that scarcity evaporates. Skill-based scarcity is more durable. That said, access scarcity can be a stepping stone. If you're the one who can interpret the CEO's priorities for your team, you become a translator — and that's a skill you can build on. Luna: So the playbook is: pick a valuable skill, make it known, share it, then move to the next level. That's actually a career growth strategy, not just a political tactic. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why I think the law of scarcity, used well, is one of the most ethical influence tools in office politics. It rewards genuine competence and generosity. You build influence by being good at something and by helping others get better. Luna: I want to push back on one thing though. What if you're in a role where you don't have a clear rare skill? Like a generalist in a small team? Can you still use scarcity? Lucas: Great question. Generalists can create scarcity through pattern recognition. If you're the person who can connect dots across departments — who knows what marketing is working on and how it affects operations — that cross-functional visibility is rare. You become the hub. That's a form of informational scarcity. Luna: So it's about being the node in the network, not the deepest expert. Lucas: Right. And that's actually harder to replicate than a technical skill because it's built on relationships. So for generalists, I'd say: invest in understanding the big picture, and become the person who can translate between silos. Luna: One more nuance. Scarcity can also backfire if you're too scarce. If you're always booked out two weeks, people stop coming to you. They find workarounds. So there's a Goldilocks zone. Lucas: Totally. You want to be accessible enough that people think of you first, but not so available that you're taken for granted. That's where the training and documentation helps — it creates capacity without diluting your expertise. Luna: I think a lot of people get this wrong. They either hoard knowledge and become a bottleneck, or they overshare and become a commodity. The art is in the middle. Lucas: Let's wrap with a practical exercise. Pick one skill you have that's somewhat unique in your team. It doesn't have to be huge. Maybe you're really good at writing clear email summaries after meetings. That's a form of clarity scarcity. Document your approach, offer to show a colleague, and then look for the next gap. Luna: I like that. Small steps. And if you want a deeper dive, there's a great book called 'Influence' by Robert Cialdini that covers scarcity along with five other principles. It's still the gold standard. Lucas: We'll link to it in the show notes. Next episode, we're going to talk about the law of consistency — why saying yes to a small request makes people more likely to say yes to a bigger one later. It's another classic from Cialdini's playbook. Luna: Can't wait. Until then, think about what you bring that no one else does — and how to share it without giving it away. Lucas: See you next time.