Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / Why Post-IPO Buybacks Surge When Stocks Fall
Transcript
- Lucas: So Microsoft is down almost ten percent in the last five trading days. Palantir down over fifteen percent. Coinbase off more than sixteen. We're sitting here on June sixth, 2026, and a bunch of high-profile post ipo tech names just got hammered. Luna: And what's interesting is what those companies are doing about it. We're seeing a surge in share buybacks from these very same names. Lucas: Exactly. This week alone, we saw two major buyback announcements from post ipo tech companies. Not just talk — actual authorizations. And it's part of a much bigger pattern: buybacks among companies that went public in the last five years are on pace for a record year. Luna: You'd think after a steep drop, a company might conserve cash. Instead, they're spending billions to buy their own stock. Lucas: Right, and the logic is actually pretty straightforward. When a company believes its stock is undervalued, buying it back is a direct signal to the market. It says: we think the sell-off is overdone. Plus, it mechanically boosts earnings per share — fewer shares outstanding means the same profit gets divided into a smaller pie. Luna: But not all buybacks are created equal. Microsoft's buyback history is very different from, say, Palantir's. Lucas: That's the real conversation. Let's start with Microsoft. They announced a sixty billion dollar buyback authorization last September. That's not reactive — that's a standing program. They've been buying consistently for years. Their stock drops ten percent in a week, and they just keep executing. It's almost automatic. Luna: They have the balance sheet for it. Over seventy billion in cash and short-term investments. They can absorb that. Lucas: Exactly. For Microsoft, a buyback is a routine capital allocation tool. It's like saying we're going to return cash to shareholders, and we'll do it regardless of the tape. That's very different from a company that announces a buyback specifically because the stock cratered. Luna: And that's where Palantir comes in. They went public in 2020, and they've been aggressive about buybacks. But last week they announced a new five hundred million dollar authorization right after that fifteen percent drop. Lucas: Which feels more reactive. Palantir is still free cash flow positive, but they're not Microsoft. Five hundred million is meaningful relative to their market cap — it's about one percent of their current valuation. But here's the key question: is this opportunistic or defensive? Luna: Defensive meaning they're trying to offset dilution from employee stock compensation. Lucas: Bingo. Palantir issues a lot of stock-based compensation. In 2025, stock-based comp was roughly twenty-five percent of revenue. That's high. So when they buy back shares, part of it is just neutralizing the dilution from all those RSUs and options. The net share count might not even shrink. Luna: And if the net share count doesn't shrink, the EPS boost is an illusion. You're just treading water. Lucas: Right. So a buyback announcement during a sell-off can be a positive signal — management is putting money where their mouth is. But investors need to check the dilution math. If the buyback barely keeps pace with stock-based comp, it's not a vote of confidence. It's maintenance. Luna: Is there a good rule of thumb for telling the difference? Lucas: I'd look at two things. First, the size of the buyback relative to the market cap. A one percent authorization feels different from a five percent one. Second, compare the buyback rate to the dilution rate. Companies report diluted shares outstanding every quarter. If the diluted count is flat or declining, the buyback is real. If it's still rising, the buyback is just a Band-Aid. Luna: So when Microsoft buys back stock, their diluted share count has actually been falling for years. It's around 7.4 billion shares now, down from 7.6 billion five years ago. Lucas: That's a real reduction. Palantir, on the other hand, had about 2.1 billion diluted shares at the end of 2025, up from around 1.8 billion in 2021. The buybacks haven't kept up with issuance. Luna: So the same action — buying back shares — means completely different things depending on who's doing it. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the nuance that gets lost in headlines like 'Tech Buybacks Surge.' It's true that the aggregate number is high. But when you peel it back, a lot of it is defensive. Companies like Coinbase, Roku, and Snap have all announced buybacks in the last year, and they all have significant stock-based compensation. Luna: There's also a timing angle. When a stock is falling, a buyback can act as a floor. The company becomes a buyer in its own stock, absorbing some of the selling pressure. Lucas: That's the tactical play. And it can work. But it requires the company to actually execute — to be in the market buying. Some companies announce authorizations and then never use them. Or they use them slowly over years. The market tends to reward actual buying, not just announcements. Luna: What about regulatory scrutiny? There's been talk in Washington about taxing buybacks more heavily. Lucas: The current one percent excise tax on buybacks, introduced in the Inflation Reduction Act, is still in place. There have been proposals to raise it to four percent. That would change the math for some companies. But for now, the tax is small enough that it doesn't deter most buybacks. Luna: And the alternative to a buyback is a dividend. But tech companies, especially post ipo ones, tend to prefer buybacks because they're more flexible. Lucas: Right. A dividend is a promise — once you start paying it, cutting it is a disaster. A buyback is discretionary. You can start and stop based on cash flow. That flexibility is valuable for growth companies that don't want to commit to a recurring payout. Luna: One more thing: employees. When a company buys back shares, it can also help with employee morale. If your stock is down and the company is buying, it signals that management has faith. Lucas: That's a real, if intangible, benefit. Especially for companies where a big chunk of compensation is in equity. If employees see the company supporting the stock price, they're less likely to flee. Of course, if the buyback is just covering dilution, employees might not feel that confidence. Luna: So what's the takeaway for someone listening right now? A post ipo tech stock drops hard, and management announces a buyback. Should you be encouraged? Lucas: First step: don't just react to the headline. Go look at the diluted share count trend. If it's flat or declining, the buyback is real and likely bullish. If it's rising, the buyback is probably defensive. Second step: check the authorization size relative to market cap. A small authorization can be noise. Third: see if they actually buy. Companies report buyback activity in their cash flow statement. If the authorization is sitting unused, it's just talk. Luna: I think that framework is really helpful. And it's one of those things that makes you realize how much context matters in finance. Lucas: Totally. And speaking of context — conversations like this one are exactly why we keep making these episodes. If you've gotten something useful out of them, a couple of dollars a month genuinely helps keep them going. You can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just putting it out there. Luna: Yeah, it really does make a difference. Even a small amount adds up and lets us stay independent and ad-free. Lucas: So back to the data. I want to circle back to one more example: Coinbase. Down sixteen and a half percent in five days. They announced a buyback last November, and they've been active in the market. Luna: Coinbase is an interesting case because their stock-based compensation is even higher than Palantir's — around thirty percent of revenue. Lucas: Right. So when you see Coinbase buying back shares, you have to ask: are they actually reducing the share count? Their diluted shares outstanding have been roughly flat over the last year. So the buyback is offsetting dilution, but not much more. That doesn't mean it's bad — it's just not the same as a Microsoft-style reduction. Luna: So the next time you see a headline like 'Coinbase announces $1 billion buyback,' you know to check the dilution math. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the kind of insight that separates informed investors from the rest. It's not about whether buybacks are good or bad — it's about what they mean in context.