Latest / Elon Musk Podcast / Elon Musk Fights Supreme Court

Transcript

Elon Musk Fights Supreme Court · Elon Musk Podcast

• 0:00
  Hey everybody, welcome back to the Elon Musk podcast.
• 0:03
  This is a show where we discuss. The critical.
• 0:05
  Crossroads That Shape, SpaceX, Tesla X, The Boring Company, and
• 0:09
  Neuralink, and I'm your Host Will Walden One.
• 0:12
  More thing before we start Google Podcasts is being
• 0:16
  discontinued by Google. So if you want to continue
• 0:20
  getting episodes of the Elon Musk podcast, please check us
• 0:23
  out over at YouTube Music. Search us out over there and
• 0:27
  that's where you'll be able to find our our podcast through
• 0:31
  Google products. Thank you.
• 0:32
  So much. For understanding I had no
• 0:34
  control over this, Google pulled the Google Podcast app off of
• 0:38
  Android and I want to let you know where to continue finding
• 0:41
  the show over at YouTube Music Search for.
• 0:44
  Elon. Musk Podcast So Elon Musk is
• 0:46
  currently defined a Brazilian Supreme Court order aimed at
• 0:50
  censoring certain user content under the guise of combating
• 0:53
  fake news. This legal conflicts shows that
• 0:57
  there's a huge issue regarding freedom of expression and
• 1:00
  freedom of speech and the role of social media in Brazil.
• 1:05
  Now the Brazilian judiciary has demanded that X block content
• 1:09
  from Brazilian users, which the court labels as false
• 1:12
  information, are fake news. And Musk's refusal to comply
• 1:15
  with these demands has led to significant legal scrutiny,
• 1:19
  positioning him against Brazil's federal judiciary.
• 1:23
  Now, the inquiry, known as Digital Militia investigation,
• 1:27
  does not concern the common issues of controlling big tech's
• 1:30
  influence, safeguarding democracy or child protection
• 1:33
  online. Instead, it focuses on a
• 1:36
  political clash involving the Supreme Court and critics of
• 1:40
  Brazil's president. This indicates A politicized
• 1:44
  judicial system as of right now. Now, critics argue that the
• 1:49
  Supreme Court's actions represent a departure from
• 1:52
  democratic norms, suggesting that the Brazilian judiciary no
• 1:56
  longer operates independently. The scenario portrays A grim
• 2:01
  situation for democracy in Brazil, which they claim is
• 2:05
  deteriorating publicly. The controversy stems from the
• 2:08
  court's attempts to silence commentators with opposing
• 2:11
  political views, though, especially those who command
• 2:13
  significant influence through social media platforms.
• 2:16
  Musk and many Brazilians regard these actions as undemocratic
• 2:20
  and indicative of a tyrannical approach to governance.
• 2:24
  Now, historically, though, Brazil has championed civil
• 2:27
  liberties with the constitution upholding freedom of speech.
• 2:30
  This principle has been foundational since Brazil's
• 2:32
  return to democracy all the way back in 1985, making the current
• 2:37
  judicial actions against free speech particularly jarring.
• 2:41
  Now the situation escalated following scandals involving the
• 2:44
  Workers Party and former president Lula, who was
• 2:47
  imprisoned in 2017 due to corruption charges.
• 2:50
  These events tarnished the party's image and LED to a shift
• 2:53
  in political power with the election of Bolsonaro in 2018.
• 2:59
  Now Bolsonaro, a former army captain known for his
• 3:02
  straightforward style, was elected on promises to uphold
• 3:05
  privacy, private property rights, restore order and
• 3:10
  freedom of speech, and challenging prevailing social
• 3:12
  and political norms in Brazil. His support largely came from
• 3:16
  that was disillusioned with the previous regime's corruption of
• 3:18
  policies and despite his controversial manner and
• 3:21
  rhetoric, Bolsonaro's administration made significant
• 3:24
  strides in fiscal management, deregulation and improving the
• 3:28
  business environment through digital initiatives.
• 3:30
  Now by 2021, though, Bolsonaro's potential re election seemed
• 3:34
  threatening enough to his opponents that efforts were
• 3:37
  intensified to rehabilitate Lula's political image.
• 3:40
  The Supreme Court annulled Lula's conviction, enabling him
• 3:44
  to participate in the 2022 presidential race.
• 3:47
  This judicial intervention sparked widespread dissent,
• 3:50
  particularly online where Brazilians express their
• 3:53
  disapproval. Now the electoral tribunal
• 3:56
  responded by increasingly censored online speech and
• 3:59
  targeting digital platforms to comply with their directives.
• 4:02
  The punitive measures extended to financial sanctions and also
• 4:06
  social ostracism, with some critics facing severe
• 4:09
  repercussions like imprisonment and exile, often without due
• 4:13
  process for merely questioning the legitimacy of Luda's
• 4:17
  election victory. Now, despite the absence of
• 4:20
  legislation supporting the judiciary stance on fake news,
• 4:23
  the court persists in its demands for social media
• 4:26
  platforms to block alleged misinformation, a stance that
• 4:29
  Musk has publicly challenged now.
• 4:31
  On April 6th, Musk highlighted the opaque nature of these
• 4:35
  judicial orders on X, emphasizing the lack of
• 4:38
  transparency about the reasons behind the blocking orders and
• 4:41
  the identity of the missing authority.
• 4:44
  He also noted the legal threats posed by non compliance,
• 4:48
  including potential fines. Now, Musk's resistance took a
• 4:52
  more active form when he recently unblocked several users
• 4:55
  and threatened to disclose his communications with a Brazilian
• 4:58
  court, arguing that the public deserves transparency about
• 5:01
  these judicial interactions. There's another thing going on
• 5:04
  at X. We'll touch on that real quick.
• 5:07
  It's significant for its operations.
• 5:09
  The platform's brand safety score, as rated by Double
• 5:12
  Verify, was mistakenly low due to a display error affecting
• 5:17
  advertiser confidence and investment in the company.
• 5:21
  Now they have to keep the lights on in order to keep this fight
• 5:24
  going with Brazil. Now the misinformation about XS
• 5:28
  brand safety persisted for several months, though,
• 5:31
  influencing advertising decisions detrimentally.
• 5:34
  The correction of this error in Musk's ongoing public fight
• 5:37
  against censorship in Brazil shows that X is in a tough spot
• 5:41
  right now. They're not making a lot of
• 5:44
  money, they're doing OK. But this brand awareness from
• 5:49
  Double Verify, the brand safety score could hurt them, and it
• 5:53
  was months in the making. So I'm expecting a lawsuit from
• 5:57
  Elon Musk and X in the future for this.
• 6:03
  Check, check. Hey, thank you so much for
• 6:06
  listening today. I really do appreciate your
• 6:08
  support. If you could take a second and
• 6:10
  hit the subscribe or the follow button on whatever podcast
• 6:13
  platform that you're listening on right now, I greatly
• 6:15
  appreciate it. It helps out the show
• 6:17
  tremendously and you'll never miss an episode and each episode
• 6:20
  is about 10 minutes or less to get you caught up quickly.
• 6:24
  And please, if you want to support the show even more, go
• 6:26
  to patreon.com/stage Zero and please take care of yourselves
• 6:32
  and each other and I'll see you tomorrow.