Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin's Conquest of Jerusalem 1187: The Bloodless Victory
Transcript
- Lucas: So after the disaster at Hattin in July 1187, Saladin’s forces swept through the Crusader kingdom. By September, he was at the gates of Jerusalem. But unlike the bloody siege the Crusaders had launched in 1099, this one ended very differently. Luna: Right — the city had been in Christian hands for almost ninety years at that point. Lucas: Exactly. And Saladin knew that taking Jerusalem would be a massive symbolic victory. But he also knew that a brutal assault would tarnish his reputation. So when he arrived on September 20th, his first move was actually to offer terms. Lucas: He sent envoys to the city’s defenders, led by Balian of Ibelin — a Frankish noble who had managed to escape from Hattin. Balian had rallied what remained of the Crusader forces inside the walls. Luna: What did Saladin offer them? Lucas: He proposed a peaceful surrender: the city would be handed over, and in return, the inhabitants could leave safely with their belongings. But Balian refused — he said the city would fight to the death. So Saladin began a siege. Lucas: For about a week, his engineers worked to breach the walls. They focused on the northern side, near the Damascus Gate. The defenders fought fiercely, but they were outnumbered and demoralized. Luna: How many defenders were there? Lucas: Balian had maybe a few thousand men against Saladin’s army of around twenty thousand. By September 29th, the walls were so badly damaged that a successful assault seemed imminent. Balian realized he had no choice. Lucas: So he came out to negotiate in person. According to Baha ad-Din ibn Shaddad, Saladin was initially reluctant to grant generous terms — he wanted to take the city by force to avenge the 1099 massacre. But Balian warned him that if the city fell by storm, the defenders would destroy everything — including the Dome of the Rock and the al-Aqsa Mosque. Luna: That was a powerful threat. Lucas: It was. Saladin cared deeply about those holy sites. So he agreed to a surrender. The terms were surprisingly lenient: the city would be handed over peacefully, and the inhabitants could ransom themselves — ten dinars for a man, five for a woman, one for a child. Lucas: But many of the city’s poor couldn’t afford even that. Saladin’s advisers urged him to be generous, and eventually he allowed Balian to take out about seven thousand people who couldn't pay — using funds from the Crusader treasury that was inside the city. Luna: So the city wasn't sacked? Lucas: No. Saladin entered Jerusalem on October 2nd, 1187, and he ordered his troops not to harm anyone. The contrast with the 1099 Crusader conquest was stark. Back then, the streets ran with blood. Now, the city changed hands with almost no violence. Lucas: Saladin immediately set about restoring the city's Islamic character. The cross was removed from the Dome of the Rock, the al-Aqsa Mosque was purified with rose water, and the call to prayer was heard again. Luna: What about the Christian holy sites? Lucas: That's a key point. Saladin allowed Christian pilgrims to continue visiting — including the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, which remained open. He even placed guards to protect it from any possible attacks. Some Christian clergy were allowed to stay. Lucas: But the Latin Patriarch and most of the Crusader clergy left. The city's Jewish population, which had been expelled by the Crusaders, was invited to return. Saladin actively encouraged Jewish settlement in Jerusalem. Luna: That's remarkable — given how the Crusaders had treated Muslims and Jews. Lucas: It was a deliberate policy. Saladin wanted to present himself as a just and merciful ruler, both to his own subjects and to the wider world. And it worked — even his enemies admired his clemency. Lucas: But the conquest of Jerusalem also had huge political consequences. The loss of the city shocked Europe and directly led to the Third Crusade, which brought Richard the Lionheart and Philip Augustus to the Holy Land. Luna: Right — and that's where the rivalry with Richard comes in. Lucas: Exactly. But for a moment, Saladin had achieved what no Muslim ruler had done since the 11th century: he held Jerusalem. And he did it with a combination of military strength and political savvy that became legendary. Luna: You know, I've been really enjoying these deep dives into Saladin's world. If today was actually useful to you, the way these stay ad-free is listener support — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small way to keep these conversations going. And we really appreciate it. Lucas: So, back to Jerusalem — after the surrender, Saladin faced the challenge of governing a multi-religious city. He appointed a qadi to oversee Islamic law, but he also allowed existing Christian and Jewish communities to maintain their own religious courts. Lucas: This wasn't just tolerance for show. Saladin's own chronicler, Baha ad-Din, records that the Sultan personally reviewed cases and ensured that no injustice was done to non-Muslims. Luna: Was there any backlash from his own side? Lucas: Some of his commanders wanted a more punitive approach. They argued that since the Crusaders had massacred Muslims in 1099, retaliation was justified. But Saladin overruled them. He said, 'I want to be remembered as a man of mercy, not a tyrant.' Lucas: The conquest also had economic dimensions. The ransoms brought in a huge sum of money — maybe as much as 200,000 dinars. That funded Saladin's ongoing campaigns and helped him pay his troops. Luna: So it was a financial victory too. Lucas: Absolutely. And strategically, holding Jerusalem gave Saladin immense prestige. He could now claim to be the true defender of Islam, which helped him unite the various Muslim factions under his rule. Lucas: But the Third Crusade was coming. And Saladin knew that the Europeans would not let Jerusalem fall without a fight. So he spent the next few years fortifying the city and preparing for the inevitable counterattack. Luna: And that's where the story gets even more intense. Lucas: It does. But for now, Jerusalem was Saladin's, and he had proven that a Muslim ruler could be both a conqueror and a statesman.