Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / How to Avoid Sinking Your Civil Appeal Before It Sets Sail
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to how to avoid sinking your civil appeal
- 0:06before it's set sail. I'm Belinda McCauley, executive
- 0:10director and CEO of the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:13I am delighted to be here today to introduce
- 0:15our speaker, Brendan Begley. Brendan is a shareholder
- 0:18at Weintraub Tobin and a certified appellate
- 0:21law specialist who has served as lead counsel
- 0:23in more than 70 appellate matters, including
- 0:26cases before the California Supreme Court, Ninth
- 0:28Circuit, and U .S. Supreme Court. He brings extensive
- 0:31experience across complex civil litigation, class
- 0:34actions, and appellate advocacy with multiple
- 0:37published decisions and a successful certiorari
- 0:40grant in the landmark Elk Grove United School
- 0:44District versus Nadeau case. And now let's get
- 0:48started. Thank you, Belinda, for that very kind
- 0:51introduction. And thank you, everyone, for joining
- 0:53me today. If you haven't already seen, you'll
- 0:57quickly see that my presentation today has a
- 1:00bit of a nautical theme to it. And so I've included
- 1:06some clips from different popular films to try
- 1:09to kind of as a memory aid. If I think you see
- 1:12these things, it will help you remember these
- 1:14somewhat. dull and boring appellate concepts.
- 1:17It kind of spices them up a little bit and makes
- 1:19it easier to remember these important things
- 1:21that you need to practice. And so since it has
- 1:24a theme, it just seemed to me it should have
- 1:25a suitable opening, just like every successful
- 1:28presentation has had since the old TV series
- 1:31Batman and Mission Impossible, all the way to
- 1:34the more recent Mad Men and Game of Thrones,
- 1:36I guess. So Susie, if you would advance to the
- 1:40next slide and let's play the beginning theme.
- 1:45Just sit right back and you'll hear a tale, a
- 1:48tale of a fateful trip that started from this
- 1:52tropic port aboard this tiny ship. All right,
- 1:57Suzy, next slide, please. Now, everyone. Oh,
- 2:00sorry. There we go. I don't want you to wind
- 2:03up like the SS Minnow on Gilligan's Island in
- 2:05your appeal, okay? You don't want to be stuck
- 2:07somewhere that you can't get the reversal that
- 2:09you need. So we're going to talk about the ways
- 2:11not to sink your appeal, like Gilligan and the
- 2:14skipper and the storm sunk the Minnow on Gilligan's
- 2:17Island. So there are six steps and just to kind
- 2:21of give you an idea of what they are. The first
- 2:23step is to make sure your potential appeal is
- 2:26seaworthy by recognizing appealable orders. So
- 2:30we're going to spend a little time talking about
- 2:32what is appealable and what's not appealable.
- 2:33Because if you miss something that is appealable,
- 2:36you're not going to be able to resurrect it later.
- 2:38It's going to be on the bottom of the ocean.
- 2:40You won't be able to pull it up. Second step
- 2:43is to enhance your ability to keep afloat by
- 2:46getting a court reporter. Sometimes you can't.
- 2:49And if you can't, you're going to have to deal
- 2:50with some struggles. And we're going to talk
- 2:52about the struggles. And once you see them, I
- 2:54think you're going to be very, what would be
- 2:57the word? encouraged to do everything you can
- 3:02to get a court reporter. The third step we're
- 3:05gonna talk about today is to reduce the risk
- 3:07of being capsized by getting a statement of decision.
- 3:11It can be tricky here too. Sometimes you think
- 3:13you already got one and so you don't need to
- 3:14ask for it. Sometimes you might think all I need
- 3:16to do is ask for it and that's it. There's more
- 3:19to it than that. Fourth step we're gonna talk
- 3:21about is making sure you can leave the harbor.
- 3:25by timely filing a notice of appeal. You gotta
- 3:28get that notice of appeal file that goes hand
- 3:30in hand with the first step of recognizing an
- 3:32appealable order. So we're gonna talk about the
- 3:34deadlines. Although that can be complicated,
- 3:37I've got a really neat trick to make it very
- 3:39easy. And then the fifth step is you wanna help
- 3:43the appellate court to track your course. of
- 3:46your nautical journey, if you will, by designating
- 3:48a proper appellate record. Another way to say
- 3:50this is you want them to be able to hear what
- 3:53happened in the trial court by giving them a
- 3:56proper appellate record. And so we're talking
- 3:58about the different options there and what I
- 4:00would recommend. And then six, the last step,
- 4:04you have to avoid getting torpedoed. If you misunderstand
- 4:09how pellet stays apply, it can create a lot of
- 4:12friction between you and your client. We're going
- 4:13to see a lot about that when we get to it. So
- 4:17those are the six steps we're going to talk about.
- 4:20Let's go to step one. And Susie, if you would,
- 4:22play this slide for us. No, I'm sorry, Susie.
- 4:31It begins from this slide. I apologize. We're
- 4:34going to skip this one because we want to make
- 4:35sure we get that on time. So the next one, please.
- 4:40Next slide, please. There, let's play this one.
- 5:06Just tie me a sheep shank. All right, next slide
- 5:12please, Suzy. Folks, I'm not talking about unappealable
- 5:16orders. I'm talking about appealable orders here.
- 5:18You need to recognize the appealable ones. You
- 5:21don't want the dog, fish, or whatever he says,
- 5:23whatever Quint says. You want the porkers. You
- 5:26want the real appealable judgment or order. Now,
- 5:30you have to be able to distinguish. You have
- 5:32to be able to know what's appealable and what's
- 5:33not. The list of unappealable orders is going
- 5:36to be way too long for us to talk about. So we're
- 5:38going to kind of focus on what is appealable.
- 5:41You know, you don't want to waste time appealing
- 5:43from an unappealable order. You're going to charge,
- 5:46you're going to run up your client's fees and
- 5:48lead to a lot of frustration if you're doing
- 5:50that. But more importantly, you definitely don't
- 5:53want to miss the great white shark out there.
- 5:55You do not want to miss. an appealable order,
- 5:58because as I'll tell you later, if you overlook
- 6:01it and you don't appeal from it, your deadline
- 6:03to appeal will have passed. And when you get
- 6:06a different appealable judgment order, you're
- 6:08not going to be able to resurrect that prior
- 6:09one. You will have lost the ability to change
- 6:14a bad decision. So the list of appealable orders
- 6:19is about 14 or 15 of them. The unabridged This
- 6:23is an abridged version that I have on the slideshow.
- 6:25I have an unabridged version in the handout.
- 6:28And so there's only a few things you need to
- 6:31recognize. The first two are pretty easy to see.
- 6:33A judgment, a final judgment. The case is done.
- 6:37That's it. Final judgment. That's going to be
- 6:39appealable just about every time. There's almost
- 6:41no exception to that. And then also sometimes
- 6:44there's an order that comes after a judgment.
- 6:47think of like a motion for attorney fees if you
- 6:49have an employment case or a contract case where
- 6:52there's a shifting fees provision and so you
- 6:55get the judgment and then after the judgment
- 6:57you have a post -judgment motion for fees that
- 7:01post -judgment for fees is also appealable it
- 7:04doesn't mean that everything that happens after
- 7:06a judgment is appealable it sort of has to be
- 7:08a final order so if you have a judgment somebody
- 7:12files a motion for fees and then somebody else
- 7:14files a motion to you know, continue that motion
- 7:18for fees. The motion for continuance, if granted,
- 7:21is not going to be an appealable post -judgment
- 7:23order. It sort of has to have its own level of
- 7:25finality. Next slide, please, Susan. Other common
- 7:30ones would be an order granting or dissolving,
- 7:32or even refusing to grant or dissolve an injunction.
- 7:36Anytime there's some sort of injunctive relief,
- 7:38Red alert should be going off. I'm looking at
- 7:40an appealable order here. You ask for an injunction,
- 7:42the court says no, appeal. The other side asks
- 7:45for an injunction and gets it, appeal, okay?
- 7:49So this is important. Also, orders made appealable
- 7:53under the probate code and the family code. They
- 7:55are way too numerous for us to cover in this
- 7:57basic presentation. I do sometimes specialized
- 8:01appeals in probate and specialized appeals in
- 8:03family law cases, and then I will talk in those
- 8:05presentations about all those different kinds
- 8:07of orders. But if you're doing family law probate,
- 8:10law, you need to know there are quite a few appealable
- 8:13orders and they're specified in the codes. The
- 8:15probate code, I remember they're like between
- 8:171300 and 1310 of the probate code. Appealable
- 8:20family law orders are sort of scattered around
- 8:23in different statutes and in case law. Also in
- 8:26order directing a payment of monetary sanctions
- 8:28over $5 ,000. Hopefully that's not too common
- 8:32in your experience, but being an appellate practitioner,
- 8:34I do see that happen. So that is an appealable
- 8:37order. And also, orders granting or denying special
- 8:41motions to strike under section 424 .16 of the
- 8:45Code of Civil Procedure. Slap appeals have mushroomed
- 8:49over the last 25 years. They consume a big part
- 8:53of the court's docket. So if you're in the slap
- 8:56case, you need to know that you're probably looking
- 8:59at an appealable order as soon as the court grants
- 9:01or denies or partially grants or partially denies
- 9:04the anti -slap ruling. Funny quirk with anti
- 9:07-slap, there's a split among the different courts
- 9:11of appeal in California as to whether the order
- 9:15that comes after that, awarding fees or denying
- 9:18a request for fees, is separately appealable.
- 9:20Some courts say yes, some courts say no. So if
- 9:25you're doing anti -slap, which I do a lot of,
- 9:27keep that in mind. Next slide, please. Okay,
- 9:32so the second step. is you're going to really,
- 9:36you're going to have to recognize and appreciate
- 9:38the need for a court reporter. And let me tell
- 9:40you why. The appellate court simply cannot hear
- 9:43what was said in the trial court without either
- 9:47a reporter's transcript or its very poor alternatives,
- 9:51an agreed statement or a settled statement. And
- 9:54so let me just play this little clip in our next
- 9:57slide so that you kind of get an idea of what
- 9:59I'm talking about. Beautiful. I wonder what they're
- 10:07saying. Well, that was the sludge tanker over
- 10:09there, but there you go. OK, so next slide, please.
- 10:17Here's the thing that Bill Murray, I think, is
- 10:19illustrating for us is that, you know, if you
- 10:23don't have a report as transcript and you use
- 10:25one of these alternatives and agreed statement
- 10:26or settled statement, a whale song that was played
- 10:30in court is going to sound like a sludge tanker.
- 10:32it's going to come out distorted and different
- 10:34than what you might have remembered it to be.
- 10:37So an agreed statement, as my slide says, the
- 10:41rule that governs it is 8 .134. And there's an
- 10:45abridged version of that in your handout materials.
- 10:49An agreed statement, I don't think they really
- 10:51exist. Finding one, as my slide says, may be
- 10:53more difficult than finding a unicorn under the
- 10:56waves of the ocean. I've heard about them. i've
- 10:59never really seen one because you know what you
- 11:01have to do you have to agree with opposing counsel
- 11:04about what was said about what the questions
- 11:07and answers were from the witness. You know on
- 11:11the stand and you're never gonna agree about
- 11:13that your memories are gonna be different and
- 11:15so. I've seen people try this step and then it
- 11:19fails and then you have to come back and you
- 11:21have to redesignate the record and so you've
- 11:24expended a lot of effort and run up a bill for
- 11:27your client and it usually doesn't lead to anywhere
- 11:30good. The alternative is not much better. It
- 11:33does exist. It's a settled statement. A settled
- 11:36statement is where You and opposing counsel cannot
- 11:40agree, which is you can expect that, about what
- 11:42was actually said. And so you propose one version
- 11:46as the appellant to the trial court, the judge
- 11:49who presided over the case, and the other side
- 11:53presents their version of what happened, and
- 11:55the trial judge settles the statement. Now listen,
- 12:00if you just take a little spin through your handout,
- 12:02you're going to see all kinds of complications
- 12:05with this. I mean you have to do a proposed statement
- 12:08and the good news is the Judicial Council has
- 12:12created a Judicial Council form to help you do
- 12:15this because otherwise you're just making it
- 12:18out of, you know, you're making it from scratch.
- 12:21But this form can help navigate what you need
- 12:23to do and you check the boxes and you fill in
- 12:24the information and it kind of is a good assistance
- 12:27for preparing a proposed settled statement. Then
- 12:32the other side, there's a judicial counsel form
- 12:34for the other side to use to say, no, that's
- 12:36not really happened, what really happened. And
- 12:39then you both submit your forms to the trial
- 12:41court. Well, then all kinds of deadlines get
- 12:44triggered and you can ask for a hearing, but
- 12:45the trial court doesn't necessarily have to give
- 12:47you one. And then the trial court issues its
- 12:50modified or corrected settle statement. And then
- 12:52you got time, both sides can object to that and
- 12:55maybe even propose further modifications. And
- 12:57then you kind of run around it again. until the
- 13:00trial court says, I've had enough. I had one
- 13:02case like this recently. We started the proposal
- 13:05because we didn't have a court reporter. We won.
- 13:08The other side appealed. They didn't have a court
- 13:10reporter. They opted for a settled statement.
- 13:13We had six hearings on this, six hearings on
- 13:15this over the course of about seven months. Each
- 13:17hearing was between a half hour and an hour.
- 13:20Not only that, but beyond the hearings, both
- 13:22sides were spending all kinds of time. The lawyers
- 13:24were trying to figure out what was really said
- 13:27and how to articulate it in the best light and
- 13:30whatnot, and how to object to what the other
- 13:31side is saying, a court reporter's transcript
- 13:35is going to be a lot cheaper. Trust me, it's
- 13:36going to be a lot cheaper, and usually it's going
- 13:38to be a lot faster. It's going to expedite your
- 13:40appeal. So you're really going to want to see
- 13:43if you can get that. Next slide, please, Susie.
- 13:48Okay, I'm hoping I've convinced you about how
- 13:52you really need a reporter's transcript and how
- 13:54you really need to be able to spot those appealable
- 13:57orders and judgments. The next thing is just
- 14:02as important. I mean it. You're going to have
- 14:04to get a statement of decision. And so I have
- 14:07a little bit of footage to share with you that
- 14:09sort of is a representation of what an appellate
- 14:12lawyer will see and say to you if you call and
- 14:16say, I want to appeal, but I didn't ask for a
- 14:19statement of decision properly. Susie, can you
- 14:22play the clip in the next slide, please? you're
- 14:44gonna need a bigger boat. Okay, next slide please,
- 14:49Susie. Yeah, you're gonna need a bigger boat.
- 14:53So a statement of decision is a little more tricky
- 14:56than any of the other two steps that I told you
- 14:59about. I mean, step one, you just go to 904 .1A
- 15:03of the Code of Civil Procedure and you go down
- 15:05the list to see if you've got an appealable.
- 15:09judgment or order. Unless you're in a family
- 15:11law or probate case, then you got to take a couple
- 15:13other steps. Step one is pretty easy. Do I have
- 15:16an appealable order or not? Step two, call a
- 15:18court reporter. It might take a little effort.
- 15:20You might have to make a few calls because there's
- 15:22kind of a shortage now, but that's not that hard.
- 15:25It's a lot harder to do the alternatives as I've
- 15:28tried to illustrate. Step three is trickier than
- 15:31the first two steps. It seems easier, but it's
- 15:34not. It seems like you should just ask for a
- 15:36statement of decision and it might even seem
- 15:38to you that the judge already gave you one, so
- 15:39you don't even have to ask. Nonsense. Please
- 15:42don't fall into this trap door. I'll be telling
- 15:45you when you call me, you're going to need a
- 15:46bigger boat because this shark just ate your
- 15:49appeal. So the two rules that you need to know
- 15:53about, well, the two. authorities you need to
- 15:55know about primarily are Section 632 of the Code
- 15:58of Civil Procedure and Rule 3 .1590 of the California
- 16:03Rules of Court. Now listen, as you can see in
- 16:05this caution, which I'm embarrassed I have a
- 16:08misspelling in there, it's not dead liens, it's
- 16:10deadlines, and procedures that I'm talking about
- 16:14today are only effective through December 31st
- 16:16of this year. After that, they're going to change.
- 16:20It has mostly to do with timing. And you'll come
- 16:23back to my presentation and watch my movie clips
- 16:25next year, okay? When the changes come about
- 16:28and I'll tell you about them then. But for now,
- 16:30you just need to know how to do things this year.
- 16:33Now this year, when you have a bench trial, the
- 16:36trial court is supposed to issue a tentative
- 16:38ruling. And upon the request of a party, it will
- 16:43issue a statement of decision. Look, it's upon
- 16:45the request. It doesn't have to, it just has
- 16:48to issue a tentative ruling. It can do it on
- 16:50the record. from the bench orally at the end
- 16:54of, you know, once the case has been submitted
- 16:56or it can do it in a written tentative decision.
- 16:59Sometimes the courts call these tentative decisions,
- 17:01proposed statements, a decision. Sometimes they
- 17:04call them tentative rulings. Sometimes they just
- 17:06call them statement of decision. All three of
- 17:08those things are kind of misleading except for
- 17:10tentative ruling. I'm sorry. Tentative ruling
- 17:12is not misleading. Proposed statement of decision
- 17:14and statement of decision is a little bit misleading.
- 17:17I'm not saying the courts are deliberately misleading
- 17:19here. I'm just saying that those titles are somewhat
- 17:22misleading. Now, you have to make your request
- 17:25for a statement of decision within 10 days after
- 17:27the court announces its tentative decision, unless
- 17:31the trial was less than eight hours in one day,
- 17:34or two days, but still less than eight hours,
- 17:36or three days and less than eight hours. Trial's
- 17:38less than eight hours, one, two, or however many
- 17:40days. Then the trial court, sorry, then you have
- 17:46to request your statement of decision. before
- 17:48you submit and before you get the trial courts
- 17:51ruling. Now here's the thing this part that I've
- 17:55highlighted in blue the request for a statement
- 17:57decision shall not should not maybe not well
- 18:03the best ones do no it's shall specify those
- 18:07controverted issues to which a party is requesting
- 18:10a statement decision you have to you have to
- 18:13list the principal controverted issues in your
- 18:16request for a statement of decision or else in
- 18:19my opinion your statement of decision is defective
- 18:22and you haven't asked for a statement of decision
- 18:24and if you don't ask for a statement of decision
- 18:27that leads to the imposition of this thing called
- 18:30the doctrine of implied findings. And so even
- 18:34though in the court's tentative decision, which
- 18:37has been labeled maybe as a proposed statement
- 18:39of decision, or even as a statement of decision,
- 18:42the trial court left out findings on vital factors
- 18:45that had to be, you know, there has to be a finding
- 18:48on this. Well, if you don't ask for a statement
- 18:50of decision in the list, that factor is a principal
- 18:53controverted issue. The Court of Appeal is going
- 18:55to infer that the trial court made the necessary
- 18:59factual findings. to support that, you know,
- 19:02ultimate decision even though they are not listed
- 19:05in the proposed statement of decision and the
- 19:07so -called statement of decision in the actual
- 19:10tentative ruling. Susie, can I have the next
- 19:13slide, please? So, you know, it's not really
- 19:17misleading for the court to call it these things
- 19:20because the rule more or less says that it can
- 19:22do it. These common provisions are authorized
- 19:25It can say that it's the court's proposed statement
- 19:27of decision subject to objections under 3 .1590
- 19:32G, or it can direct that a tentative decision
- 19:35will become the statement of decision unless
- 19:38a party specifies those principal, controverted
- 19:41issues, which I'm telling you to do, which a
- 19:43party is requesting in a statement of decision.
- 19:46Now, the timing to request a statement of decision,
- 19:48as I've already said, is 10 days after the announcement
- 19:50of the tentative ruling. If a tentative ruling
- 19:52comes out and it says statement of decision,
- 19:55and there was no tentative ruling before, that
- 19:57statement of decision is a tentative ruling.
- 20:00You have 10 days from then to request a statement
- 20:03of decision and list the principal controversial
- 20:05issues. You can be easily misled by thinking,
- 20:08it says right here that I have 15 days under
- 20:11subpart G to make my objections. That's to make
- 20:15objections. Objections are different than requesting
- 20:18the statement of decision and listing the principal
- 20:20-controverted issues. You can do both in one.
- 20:23You can request a statement of decision, list
- 20:26the principal -controverted issues, and then
- 20:28add objections under subpart G of rule 3 .1590,
- 20:33and say, here's why I'm objecting to the court's
- 20:35tentative decision. And you can do it in reverse
- 20:38order. You can say, here are my objections, and
- 20:40in addition, I'm requesting a statement of decision,
- 20:43and here are the principal controversial issues
- 20:45that I think the statement of decision needs
- 20:46to address. You can do both of them together.
- 20:49You can do it separately, but I'd say make sure
- 20:51you do it within the 10 -day deadline. Susan,
- 20:53can I see the next slide, please? It's a little
- 20:58bit duplicative here, but the first bullet point
- 21:00is the thing I really want to drive home. The
- 21:02tentative decision does not constitute a judgment,
- 21:05and it is not binding on the court, regardless
- 21:08of how the court labeled it. if it regarded,
- 21:10if it labeled it as a tentative, if it labeled
- 21:12it as a proposed, if it accidentally labeled
- 21:14it as an actual statement of decision before
- 21:17any tentative came out, that's still a tentative.
- 21:20You can still challenge that by requesting a
- 21:23statement of decision and listing the principal,
- 21:25principal contributed issues, and if you like,
- 21:28objecting under subpart chief. And next slide,
- 21:32Susie. Now, as you can see in my last bullet
- 21:38point here, the court may, by written order,
- 21:41extend any of the times prescribed by this rule.
- 21:44And if good cause is shown, it can excuse your
- 21:47tardiness. It can do that. Most courts are not
- 21:51going to be thrilled about doing this. Sometimes
- 21:53there's good reason. And if you ask the court
- 21:55at the beginning, at the outset, hey, we want
- 21:57a little more time to do these things. Will the
- 21:58court let us do it? Yeah, generally the court
- 22:01might go along with that. But if you've already
- 22:03missed your deadline to request a statement of
- 22:05decision, and you're the one that's looking like
- 22:07it's going to appeal, I mean, a judge might grant
- 22:12you it, but I just don't see a judge having a
- 22:14lot of incentive to help you tell the court of
- 22:16appeal that he or she is not fit to be the dog
- 22:18catcher because they got your case so wrong.
- 22:20Now, I know that's not really what you would
- 22:22say, and judges get it wrong. They're still fit
- 22:24to be judges. We're all human beings. I'm not
- 22:26disparaging judges here. I'm just saying there's
- 22:29not a lot of incentive to help you, you know,
- 22:32tell the court of appeal that the judge was bad.
- 22:35And judges are busy. So you know what? If you're
- 22:37already late, they might think, look, you should
- 22:39have done this. Why didn't you go to Brendan's
- 22:41seminar? He would have told you, you got to get
- 22:43this done. And so, you know, I've got a lot of
- 22:46business on my plate. That was your mistake.
- 22:47I'm not going to give you the extension of time.
- 22:51So you have to request a statement of decision.
- 22:53I know I'm repeating myself. Everybody in my
- 22:56family and everybody I've ever dated, they all
- 22:58tell me, you say things at least three times.
- 23:00Well, it's because I really want you to make
- 23:01sure you get it. Request that statement of decision.
- 23:04Don't be fooled by the tentative ruling being
- 23:06labeled as something else. Not only request a
- 23:09statement of decision, but list, this is critical,
- 23:11list the principal, controversial issues in your
- 23:14request for a statement of decision. Next slide,
- 23:19please, Susie. Now, once you request a statement
- 23:24of decision and triggers deadlines, you know,
- 23:26the trial court then has 30 days from the announcement
- 23:31of the tentative decision to prepare a proposed
- 23:33statement of decision. It can also direct the
- 23:37parties to do that. If you're the one asking
- 23:39for the statement of decision and you're the
- 23:41one that the bench trial went against, likely
- 23:43the court is not gonna ask you or direct you.
- 23:46to prepare the proposed statement of decision,
- 23:48likely it's gonna be the other attorney. And
- 23:51you know, after the proposed statement of decision
- 23:54then comes out, then you have 15 days, 15 more
- 23:57days to list objections. If a new proposed statement
- 24:01of decision comes out, you have 15 days. Sometimes
- 24:04after you've already requested a statement of
- 24:07decision and made your objections to the proposed
- 24:10statement of decision, which could have been
- 24:12labeled, like I said, a tentative, or an actual
- 24:15statement of decision. Well, then the court can
- 24:17just issue its final statement of decision and
- 24:19there's no more objections. You're done at that
- 24:21point and that's okay. Listen, if you take these
- 24:24steps, very slight possibility, you'll have a
- 24:28light bulb go on for the trial court and the
- 24:29trial court will see, oh, you know what? I didn't
- 24:32think that one through. I'm going to reverse
- 24:34myself and I'm going to give judgment in your
- 24:36favor instead of the other side's favor. That
- 24:38doesn't happen a lot, but it can happen. But
- 24:41even if it doesn't. The critical thing is you've
- 24:45preserved your issues for appeal. You're not
- 24:47gonna get dinged by the doctrine of implied findings.
- 24:51Okay, so next slide please, Susie. Now, it's
- 24:57very, very important to file a timely notice
- 25:00of appeal. And I've borrowed a little footage
- 25:03of what approaching and missing. this deadline
- 25:08will look like and feel like. So Susie, if you
- 25:10can play the clip on the next slide, please.
- 26:18Okay, Susie, next slide. Yes, if you miss the
- 26:21deadline to file your notice of appeal, you and
- 26:23your client are gonna feel like you're on the
- 26:24Titanic, like you were on the Titanic with maybe
- 26:27two differences. One, I can't remember how many
- 26:29hours it took the Titanic to sink. Your appeal
- 26:32is gonna sink just a little bit more slowly,
- 26:35which is gonna be actually more excruciating
- 26:37because the court of appeal will probably issue
- 26:39an order to show cause telling you to explain
- 26:42why they shouldn't dismiss your appeal from being
- 26:44from an unappealable order, I'm sorry, from...
- 26:47being untimely or which you know then it's going
- 26:51to drag it out for you know 10 days two weeks
- 26:54three weeks whatever so you're sitting there
- 26:56waiting and you're realizing i missed the deadline
- 26:58and there's not much i can say about it and there's
- 27:00no remedy for that that's number one it's going
- 27:02to be a little slower than the titanic um number
- 27:06two there won't be any lifeboats okay there are
- 27:09no lifeboats if you miss the deadline to file
- 27:12your Notice of Appeal. You're not going to be
- 27:14able to file a 473 motion and say it's excusable
- 27:18neglect and fall on your sword. You're not going
- 27:21to be able to find some kind of case that says
- 27:23this gets told because of whatever. There's no
- 27:27lifeboat. If you miss the deadline to file your
- 27:29Notice of Appeal, you're done. The rule that
- 27:32sets it forth, and you know this is in the handout,
- 27:368 .104, the California Rules of Court, And, you
- 27:40know, this sets forth the timeliness. And normally
- 27:43the deadline is going to be 60 days. There are
- 27:46times where it's 60 days plus, and then there
- 27:49are times where it's 180 days. And, you know,
- 27:52all right, so it already sounds kind of confusing.
- 27:54Like I said, I got a simple rule that's going
- 27:56to help you avoid all this complication. The
- 27:59other complicating factor is you might think
- 28:01that there's this exception in rule 8 .66, you
- 28:05know, because it's a public emergency. You know,
- 28:08I got in a car accident that day and I wasn't
- 28:10able to get to the Court of Appeal, I'm sorry,
- 28:12to the trial court to file my notice of appeal.
- 28:15Or, you know, my kid got kicked out of school
- 28:18and I had to go talk to the principal. I mean,
- 28:20these are emergencies. They're not public emergencies,
- 28:24okay? So, rule 8 .66 is not going to help you.
- 28:27Those are not public emergencies. Distraction
- 28:30or danger to a building or the housing where
- 28:34a reviewing court sits. Absolutely one of these
- 28:37things, no court can extend the time to file
- 28:39a notice of appeal. There's no lifeboat there
- 28:41for you. So if you file an appeal late like this
- 28:46says, the reviewing court must dismiss the appeal.
- 28:50Now, for gosh, 20 years of my practice, we never
- 28:56ever saw such public emergency. The pandemic
- 28:59was one, so we do have a recent one. But you
- 29:04know what? It's not likely we'll see another
- 29:06one while I'm still practicing. I shouldn't say,
- 29:09I hope we don't see another one while I'm still
- 29:12practicing. But in our lifetimes, I think we've
- 29:15all sort of really just experienced one. So that's
- 29:17how rare a public emergency is. You're not gonna
- 29:20get extra time for that. Now, there is one other
- 29:24little thing that the reviewing court can treat
- 29:26a notice of appeal. as a writ petition, if it
- 29:31wants to, but not a late filed appeal. So there
- 29:35again, there's no lifeboat there. Sometimes if
- 29:37you appeal from an unappealable order, the court
- 29:39of appeal can save you and they can say, well,
- 29:41we're just gonna treat this as a writ petition
- 29:43and then we're gonna do appellate review on that
- 29:45basis. But if you file a late notice of appeal,
- 29:48they don't have that discretion, they can't do
- 29:50that. Now, if you file an early notice of appeal,
- 29:55no big deal usually. The reviewing court can
- 29:59treat a notice of appeal that was filed prematurely
- 30:03as an appeal from the final judgment. I don't
- 30:07want to encourage you to do that though. You
- 30:08really want to figure out when your appealable
- 30:11order happens and then appeal from it within
- 30:15the deadline. Summary judgment is a good example.
- 30:18An order granting a summary judgment motion is
- 30:20not appealable. You have to wait for the judgment
- 30:23that comes later. In a lot of appellate courts,
- 30:26if you appeal from the order, I shouldn't say
- 30:28a lot, in some appellate courts, if you appeal
- 30:31from the order granting summary judgment, and
- 30:33then later on the actual judgment comes out,
- 30:36the court of appeal can save your appeal by saying
- 30:39that your notice of appeal, construing it as
- 30:42though it was from the final judgment. I know
- 30:45for sure the third appellate district does not
- 30:47do that anymore. I have a recollection that the
- 30:50second appellate district, at least certain divisions
- 30:52of it, will not. do that. And so, some courts
- 30:56still might. I just say, don't try to file it
- 31:01early. Look for and make sure you have an appealable
- 31:05order and then calendar your deadline from that.
- 31:08If an order for summary judgment comes out, turn
- 31:10to rule 904 .1, I'm sorry, section 904 .1A of
- 31:14the California Code of Civil Procedure and see
- 31:17if that's appealable. If it's not, sit and wait.
- 31:19But then when the judgment comes out, there it
- 31:21is. 904 .1A1. I got a judgment. I'm going to
- 31:26appeal. Now, what did that guy who looks like
- 31:28Conan O 'Brien said about the deadlines? He said
- 31:30they were kind of tricky. There's 60 days. There's
- 31:33a 60 day plus. There's a 180 day. The 60 days
- 31:41is if the court issues a notice of appeal, I'm
- 31:45sorry, issues a ruling that has a proof of service
- 31:52showing that it was served to you or if one of
- 31:54the other, any of the parties issues a notice
- 31:57of entry of judgment or order. And then the proof
- 32:01of service starts the 60 days taking. So 60 days
- 32:05from the judgment, if the court attaches a proof
- 32:08of service saying, here, I've served the judgment,
- 32:11a week later, somebody else issues a notice of
- 32:15entry. Well, that's not going to extend it. You
- 32:17don't get the 60 days plus because there was
- 32:21a proof of service with the original judgment.
- 32:23That's when the 60 days starts running. If the
- 32:25court issues a judgment without that proof of
- 32:27service, a week later somebody issues a notice
- 32:31of entry of judgment or order with the proof
- 32:34of service. You get the 60 days plus. It's not
- 32:3760 days from the judgment. It's 60 days from
- 32:41the notice of entry. So you got a little more
- 32:43than 60 days from the judgment. If you calendar
- 32:47it, here's the trick. If you calendar it 60 days
- 32:50from when that judgment comes out, regardless
- 32:52of whether there's a proof of service, regardless
- 32:54of whether there's a notice of entry, you're
- 32:57going to be okay. You're going to be safe. The
- 32:59last fallback option is the 180 -day deadline.
- 33:03That's if the trial court issues a judgment or
- 33:06order without a proof of service or notice of
- 33:09entry. Nobody else issues a notice of entry.
- 33:13Then you have 180 days from the judgment. You
- 33:16should only be thinking about that 180 days if,
- 33:19through some wild accident, you forgot to count
- 33:22the 60 -day deadline that I told you about, and
- 33:25now you're scrambling to see if there's some
- 33:27way you can still save it. If anybody issued
- 33:29a notice of entry with the proof of service,
- 33:31that 180 -day deadline is a fiction. It doesn't
- 33:35exist. So, 60 days from the actual court's entry
- 33:41of the judgment. That's not what the rule says,
- 33:43but if you do it that way, you're going to be
- 33:45safe. If you do it the other ways, you're getting
- 33:48into complexities and ifs, ands, or buts, and
- 33:53just 60 days. Tell yourself, I'm going to do
- 33:56it 60 days from when the judgment came out. Susie,
- 33:59can I have the next slide? Now, listen, if you
- 34:03want to appeal and the other side appeals before
- 34:05you, you get a little bit extra time there. Sorry,
- 34:10did I skip a slide? Sorry, prior slide, Susie.
- 34:19Maybe it comes later. All right. Well, I'll tell
- 34:23you, if a, oh no, sorry, here, extension of time
- 34:26for press appeal. If appeal on time, the appeals
- 34:30of judgment are appealable order, the time for
- 34:32any other party gets extended by 20 days. And
- 34:34so this prevents gamesmanship where, you know,
- 34:38you're thinking about appealing, but maybe you'll
- 34:40let it go if the other side doesn't appeal. and
- 34:42they're thinking the same thing but they wait
- 34:44until the 60th day and then they wait till four
- 34:47o 'clock that afternoon and they have a courier
- 34:48standing there at the trial court and they file
- 34:50their notice of appeal and now your 60 days have
- 34:53gone by put well no if they do that you get 20
- 34:58more days okay you get 20 more days but if they
- 35:01file their notice of appeal on day 10 you don't
- 35:06get the 20 day extra time at the end of your
- 35:0960 days you only get 60 days Okay, you only get
- 35:12that 20 extra days if they're filing it in a
- 35:16way that, you know, beyond the 40 days, if you
- 35:18will, actually even further beyond that. So you
- 35:21get that little bit extra time to file your appeal.
- 35:25And Susie, I'm sorry, can we go back to the slide
- 35:30about rule 8 .104? I think it's the 21st slide.
- 35:34Yeah, there we go. All right, yeah, we'll get
- 35:39covered up slide. I want to talk about tolling
- 35:41motions. Oh, there we go. Yeah, next slide. Slide
- 35:4422, rule 8 .108. There are tolling motions and
- 35:48they are listed in your handout. It's rule 8
- 35:51.108 of the California rules and forth. And I
- 35:55just have a gander at them and the slide show
- 35:57doesn't indicate what they are, but they are
- 35:58in your handout. So I'm not leaving you stranded
- 36:03on a desert island. And so a motion for new trial
- 36:08will be a tolling motion. So will a motion to
- 36:13vacate the judgment. So will a motion for judgment
- 36:17notwithstanding the verdict. So will a motion
- 36:20to reconsider an appealable order. And public
- 36:25entity actions under a certain section of the
- 36:27government, certain sections of the government
- 36:29code are also, they get a little extra time.
- 36:34So if you're, if you represent a public entity,
- 36:36you want to know about, you know, government
- 36:38code sections 962, 984, and 985. But otherwise,
- 36:42you want to think about these other motions,
- 36:44these post -judgment motions can toll your deadline
- 36:47to file a notice of appeal, and then the deadline
- 36:50will get triggered depending on various outcomes
- 36:53of those motions. And so I just want to pause
- 36:56to mention one little tricky thing though, a
- 36:59motion for reconsideration. In federal court,
- 37:02You can ask for reconsideration for just about
- 37:05anything. Okay. The dog ate my homework. Even
- 37:07but in state court, which is what I'm talking
- 37:11about here. I'm not talking about federal appeals.
- 37:13All this presentation is about your California
- 37:15state law field. A motion to recon for reconsideration.
- 37:21It can only be limited to, like, discovery of
- 37:23new facts or new law coming out in the interim.
- 37:27And so if your motion isn't based on one of those
- 37:30things, it's an invalid motion for reconsideration
- 37:33and therefore an invalid motion does not toll
- 37:36the deadline to file a notice of appeal. So if
- 37:39you're going to do a motion for reconsideration,
- 37:41be very careful about it. Make sure you are doing
- 37:44it under one of the statutory, you know, statutorily
- 37:47permitted bases for asking for reconsideration.
- 37:51And I would say that probably applies also to
- 37:53a motion for a new trial. motion for judgment
- 37:56and outstanding verdict. I've not seen appellate
- 37:58decisions on those. I've seen one about reconsideration
- 38:01where it wasn't a valid motion, so it didn't
- 38:03toll. So you got to make sure that these motions
- 38:05are valid. Don't just file them to think you're
- 38:07going to buy extra time. If they're not valid,
- 38:09they're not going to get you the extra time you're
- 38:11hoping. Okay, now next slide, Suzy. That's the
- 38:17extension of time for the cross -appeal that
- 38:19I've already covered to give you 20 extra days.
- 38:21So next slide, please, Suzy. Step five, you're
- 38:25gonna have to designate a proper record. I've
- 38:28already talked about getting your court reporter,
- 38:29so hopefully you've remembered that and you've
- 38:32designated the court reporter. Now, designating
- 38:36a record, it's a judicial counsel form, it's
- 38:38a check the box form, it's a few pages, I think
- 38:40it's four pages. There's a lot of information
- 38:42to include. There's also a lot of information
- 38:44to leave out of it. And so in that sense, it
- 38:48takes timing and precision. I'd say to designate
- 38:52the appellate record, you have to think about
- 38:54what you really need and how to get it. Now,
- 38:57this timing and precision is a little bit like
- 39:00turning a submarine away from a fatal torpedo
- 39:03impact. And, you know, you have to do it at exactly
- 39:07the right moment and exactly the right way. And
- 39:09so, Susie, if you'll play this next clip, I think
- 39:11it really hits that home. Thirty seconds. Turn
- 39:18it massive. Seven, six, five, four, three, two,
- 39:28one, mark. Torpedo impact, 25 seconds. Right
- 39:38full rudder, reverse starboard engine. Right
- 39:40full rudder, hold back starboard shaft. Hold
- 39:42back starboard shaft. 12 seconds, 10, 9... Okay,
- 40:19so as you can see, you know, not all my slides
- 40:21are doom and gloom. This one shows how, you know,
- 40:24if you designate that appellate record the right
- 40:26way at the right time, you can avoid this impact.
- 40:29So happy ending for that one, right? Now, I've
- 40:33given you a link here on the slide and also in
- 40:35your handouts to the Judicial Council form to
- 40:38fill out, you know, what you need to designate
- 40:41the appellate record. Now, I'm going to tell
- 40:44you there are two parts to the appellate record
- 40:46basically. One, is everything in writing that
- 40:49was filed in the trial court. And two is the
- 40:52oral things that were said in trial court. Now
- 40:55part two, the second component is the reporter's
- 40:58transcript, okay? Or if you didn't get one, the,
- 41:01you know, fictional agreed statement or the really
- 41:07aggravating settled statement, aggravating and
- 41:09expensive, I would say, settled statement. So
- 41:13that's the oral proceedings. You're going to
- 41:15have to designate them. but let's talk about
- 41:17the paper proceeding, the paper that got filed
- 41:20in the trial court that you need to designate.
- 41:22You're gonna see on this form, if you click the
- 41:24link and it's a fillable form, that you can designate
- 41:28sort of three different things. One, a clerk's
- 41:30transcript. When I started practicing 25 years
- 41:33ago, that was still probably the most common
- 41:37thing to see for the appellate records, a clerk's
- 41:39transcript. You tell the trial court clerk all
- 41:42the things you want to include in the appellate
- 41:44record, He or she runs around, gathers them all
- 41:47up, puts them in chronological order, and arranges
- 41:50them in different volumes of 300 pages each,
- 41:55and then sends a copy to you, and sends a copy
- 41:57to the opponent, and sends a copy to the Court
- 41:59of Appeal. That can be time consuming. The other
- 42:05option, which I want to tell all you lawyers
- 42:07never to use, is just to opt for the entire Superior
- 42:11Court file. And so the clerk will then, instead
- 42:14of having to run around and find the specific
- 42:16things you asked for, he or she is just going
- 42:18to box up everything and ship it over to the
- 42:20court of appeal. Sounds great, right? That sounds
- 42:22really easy. Then you're sure you're not going
- 42:24to leave anything out. No, that's actually an
- 42:27epic fail. That is an epic fail because when
- 42:30you write your brief, you're going to be citing
- 42:32to something and you're going to require the
- 42:34staff attorney and the appellate court justices
- 42:36who are handling your appeal to wade into an
- 42:40ocean. of all kinds of stuff with, you know,
- 42:45eddies and whirlpools and sharks and waves and
- 42:47whatnot to misguide them and mislead them. And
- 42:50it's gonna be, you're gonna make it really hard
- 42:52for them to find what you need to show to them
- 42:55to prove that there was error in the trial court.
- 42:59It's gonna aggravate them and it's gonna increase
- 43:02the risk of human error. I wouldn't say a court
- 43:05would ever deliberately overlook something you
- 43:07cite because they don't wanna go look for it,
- 43:09but. listen we're all human we all make mistakes
- 43:11there's a fair chance that they're going to go
- 43:14look for it they're not going to find it because
- 43:15it's not organized very well you know the trial
- 43:18court sent boxes and who knows how they organized
- 43:20them they're probably not going to be in chronological
- 43:23order you know they might be discovery motions
- 43:25in one box and dispositive hearings in another
- 43:28box and jury instructions and a different one
- 43:31you know it's going to be all over the place
- 43:33so don't use that listen It's a multi -syllable
- 43:38word, appendix. There's three syllables to it,
- 43:41but that's the other option. Don't be scared
- 43:44by three syllables and by the fact that maybe
- 43:46you've never done an appendix. There are attorney
- 43:50services out there that will prepare an appendix
- 43:53for you and show you how to do it. Paralegals
- 43:56can easily learn how to do it. Heck, I have a
- 43:58secretary. She's brilliant. She does all of mine.
- 44:02An appendix is where you prepare your own court's
- 44:05transcript, basically. You have to do it in chronological
- 44:06order. It used to have to be 300 pages per volume.
- 44:11They're sort of expanding that a little bit now
- 44:13because we're in the digital age, and so now
- 44:14they're starting to measure it more by megabytes,
- 44:17how many megabytes is in your volume, but it's
- 44:20got to be in chronological order. It's sort of
- 44:22a PDF, and you file it digitally with the Court
- 44:25of Appeal. Trust me, you can learn how to do
- 44:27this, or you can get a secretary or a paralegal
- 44:29or hire an attorney service that does this for
- 44:32you quite capably. But that's the best option,
- 44:36and I'm going to tell you why. Because when you
- 44:38fill out the form designated in the record, you
- 44:41just check that box and you're done. And then
- 44:43you've got months as you're writing your appellate
- 44:46brief to be thinking about, what do I want to
- 44:48include in the appellate record? Oh, I'm saying
- 44:50this in my brief. I better include that in the
- 44:53appellate record, right? And so The contrast
- 44:57is if you do a clerk's transcript, you have to
- 44:59list in this form all the things you want the
- 45:02clerk to go find. And then later on, after she
- 45:05finds it and sends the clerk's transcript to
- 45:07the Court of Appeal, you're writing your brief
- 45:09and all of a sudden you realize, I should have
- 45:11included this other thing. And now you know what
- 45:14you need to do? You need to file a motion to
- 45:16augment the appellate record. Or I suppose in
- 45:19the alternative, you might do a request for judicial
- 45:22notice. in the court of appeal, asking them to
- 45:25see this document that you need to win your appeal.
- 45:28Both those options are going to take you a couple
- 45:30hours anyhow, and there's no guarantee. Usually
- 45:34the court of appeal will grant that stuff, but
- 45:36sometimes they won't. If they think you took
- 45:38too long, if you didn't convince them you've
- 45:40got a good reason for it, they might deny it.
- 45:43You know what? You don't have to fuss with any
- 45:45of that stuff if you designate an appendix. You're
- 45:47putting your appendix together as you're putting
- 45:49your brief together, and you file them both at
- 45:51the same time. And better still, even if you
- 45:54forget to do it in your original appendix and
- 45:56the respondent files a brief that says, oh, there's
- 45:59some important thing you left out, you can do
- 46:02a reply appendix. You can put it in your reply
- 46:05appendix. It's not like a summary judgment motion
- 46:08where you cannot file evidence with your reply
- 46:10papers. The reason for that in summary judgment
- 46:13is to prevent ambush and surprise. But in an
- 46:16appeal, Everybody has already seen this stuff
- 46:18once in the trial court. You're watching this
- 46:20Jaws movie again, you know, for the second time.
- 46:24And so everybody's already seen it. They sort
- 46:25of know what comes. They know the ending. And
- 46:28so you can stick it in your reply brief, your
- 46:31reply appendix. I'm sorry to follow that with
- 46:33your reply brief. So I'm all for an appendix.
- 46:36The other stuff about, you know, a reporter's
- 46:38transcript, you just have to tell them the date
- 46:40of the hearing, the department, what the hearing
- 46:42was about. you know, was it a trial, was it dispositive
- 46:46motion, was it discovery motion, whether or not
- 46:49it was previously transcribed, and if so, the
- 46:51name of the court reporter who did it and the
- 46:53department where the hearing was held. And so
- 46:56it's pretty easy to fill out that part of the
- 46:58form. It's got other stuff in there for agreed
- 47:00statements and settled statements that you'll
- 47:02see. Again, because you followed my advice, you
- 47:04won't have to worry about reading any of that
- 47:06stuff. All right. Next slide, please, Susie.
- 47:12Okay, so listen, you've done everything right
- 47:14to get your appeal launched and it's floating
- 47:16along out of the harbor, okay? What have you
- 47:18done? Let me run down the list. So far, you've
- 47:21recognized the appealable orders and you've ignored
- 47:23the ones that were not appealable. And so once
- 47:25you recognize the appealable order, you've calendared
- 47:28correctly the deadline to file the notice of
- 47:30appeal. At the same time, before then, you took
- 47:34caution and got a court reporter there so that
- 47:37you're gonna have a suitable appellate record
- 47:39and When the case came to the end of the submission,
- 47:43you either asked for a statement of decision
- 47:46and listed the principal controverted issues.
- 47:49Before it got submitted, if it was a less than
- 47:528 day bench trial, or if it was more than 8 days
- 47:55within 10 days after the. Tentative ruling, which
- 48:00may have been mislabeled as a statement of decision
- 48:02or a proposed statement of decision. you've in
- 48:05writing requested a statement of decision and
- 48:08listed the principal contributed issues. You've
- 48:09done all this stuff. And then you timely file
- 48:12the notice of appeal and you've correctly designated
- 48:15the appellate records. Smooth sailing so far,
- 48:19except that you really need to have a little
- 48:21bit of a handle on appellate states. And listen,
- 48:26because you need to advise your client about
- 48:27how they worked and how you're going to deal
- 48:29with it and the risks and how sometimes you might
- 48:33have to live with or without the stay that could
- 48:36be good or bad for you. So if you don't understand
- 48:39Plan 4 and advise your client about how a stay
- 48:41might impact the appeal, your later conversation
- 48:45when that stay or absence of a stay happens with
- 48:49your client might look like this. Susie, can
- 48:51you play the next clip, please? Who are you to
- 48:55say anything to me? Who are you to tell me anything?
- 48:59Actually, I really really do not want to be on
- 49:01this boat with you. I can't move without You
- 49:05give me the creeps Okay, Susie next slide actually,
- 49:21you know what You and your you and your client
- 49:24are not going to want to be on the same boat.
- 49:26I'd say 99 times out of 100 if the stay goes
- 49:29differently than what you and your client might
- 49:31have thought and you have to explain that. Susie,
- 49:34could you skip ahead just three slides and play
- 49:36the clip there so we can show everybody the Hollywood
- 49:39ending, which maybe it will happen like this,
- 49:41but I don't think so. Let's see what it might
- 49:43look like. Skip, we made the right call. We had
- 49:55to try. So close. Hey, who's the hell of a fight,
- 50:07though? Huh? Okay, Suzy, if you would back us
- 50:19up to slide 29, please. All right, so listen,
- 50:24maybe when you misapprehended how the stay was
- 50:29or was not going to work and you tell your client
- 50:31about it, he's gonna take it like Mark Wahlberg
- 50:34and George Clooney and you know, well, it was
- 50:37a heck of a fight though, wasn't it? But listen,
- 50:40I'm betting it's gonna be more like Jude Law
- 50:43and Matt Damon out there on that little boat
- 50:45alone with no rescue ships in sight. Okay, it's
- 50:49going to be quite unpleasant to ride that appellate
- 50:52wave the rest of the way through. Now, appellate
- 50:55stays, the general rule is everything is automatically
- 50:58stayed, right? Everything is automatically stayed
- 51:00under Section 916 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
- 51:05Although Section 916 doesn't expressly say it,
- 51:08I'm here to tell you mandatory injunctions are
- 51:11automatically stayed, but prohibitory injunctions
- 51:14are not. And that's probably where it's going
- 51:17to get really tricky about appellate stays. Because
- 51:24a mandatory injunction just basically is often
- 51:27thought of as something that changes the status
- 51:30quo, whereas a prohibitory injunction is something
- 51:33that preserves it. But that gets a little tricky
- 51:37because where do you measure when the status
- 51:40quo was? Was it before the lawsuit? after the
- 51:45lawsuit but at some point in time when the parties
- 51:47filed some kind of stipulation was that after
- 51:50the lawsuit but when the court issued some kind
- 51:53of preliminary injunction that nobody appealed
- 51:56you know where do you measure the status quo
- 51:58and what status quo is it that the court of appeal
- 52:00really wants to preserve to avoid mooting and
- 52:03appeal it gets very very complicated the california
- 52:07supreme court issued a decision called daily
- 52:09maybe about three years ago Daily versus San
- 52:14Bernardino, I think. And it tried to clarify
- 52:17when an injunction is mandatory and when it's
- 52:19prohibitory. And it did help someone. I'd say
- 52:23it's still kind of murky. And they say shark
- 52:26attacks happen in cloudy water. So this is still
- 52:30sort of a cloudy area. You want to get a handle
- 52:32on your appellate stay. Not only are prohibitory
- 52:36injunctions not automatically stayed. But Susie,
- 52:39can we see the next slide? there are an awful
- 52:42lot of exceptions listed in the statutes. They're
- 52:45all in one place, luckily for you. They're in
- 52:48917 .1 through 917 .9 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
- 52:52Money judgments is a classic example. A money
- 52:55judgment is not automatically stayed. So if your
- 52:59client has a judgment against him or her or it,
- 53:02you know, it's for a million bucks and you file
- 53:04your appeal, you might be thinking we filed the
- 53:07appeal and now there's not going to be any collection
- 53:09activity and all of a sudden there's a recorded
- 53:11judgment, there's a till tap, there's a lien,
- 53:14there's a foreclosure, there's a debtor's exam,
- 53:17all these things are happening and you're inclined
- 53:19to saying, wait a minute, I don't even see the
- 53:21shark, where's it coming from? We're going to
- 53:24be on that boat with Jude Law and Matt Damon,
- 53:28right? You're going to be out there on that boat.
- 53:31The truth is, a money judgment is only stayed
- 53:34if under Section 917 .1, the party against whom
- 53:38the judgment is issued posts a bond. And a bond
- 53:42is usually going to be, if you get a surety to
- 53:44do it, 150 % of the money judgment. And that
- 53:47money judgment includes the awards of attorney
- 53:51fees when you're calculating 150%. It includes
- 53:54the attorney fees and costs that come after that.
- 53:57Now, there is an exception to this. If you get
- 54:00a judgment that's really just like an injunction
- 54:03or something like that. But then on top of that,
- 54:06there's an award of attorney fees and costs.
- 54:08That's not really a money judgment. There's a
- 54:10money judgment aspect to it, but it's not really
- 54:12a money judgment. And so if it's just purely
- 54:15an award for fees and costs, then that is automatically
- 54:19stayed under 916 of the Code of Civil Procedure
- 54:22coupled with section 917 .1 D like Daniel of
- 54:27the Code of Civil Procedure. Okay, so that's
- 54:30one example of something that is automatically
- 54:34stayed. If you look at those statutes, you'll
- 54:37see the different ones that are automatically
- 54:40stayed, I'm sorry, that are not automatically
- 54:42stated out posting a bond. An order that directs
- 54:45the conveyance of real property, an order that
- 54:48directs the conveyance of personal property,
- 54:51stocks, bonds, things like that, cars, boats,
- 54:55what have you. those also require the posting
- 54:57of a bond. And in those instances, you have to
- 55:00go to the trial court and ask the trial court
- 55:02to fix the amount of the bond. Unlike a money
- 55:04judgment where it's set at 150 % of the judgment
- 55:08if you use a surety, these other kinds of judgments
- 55:14and orders require the trial court to fix the
- 55:16amount. And there's lots of different ways to
- 55:18try to do that. So listen, we are near the end
- 55:21of the time. I'm not going to stop right now.
- 55:23I'm going to have a look at the Question, the
- 55:26answer is here to see if there's anything I can
- 55:28answer. Does a notice of ruling along with a
- 55:31copy of the minute order suffice as a notice
- 55:34of entry? Generally, I'm gonna say the safe answer
- 55:38would be yes. There may be exceptions. I would
- 55:40definitely treat that as enough to where you
- 55:45really look into it and figure out if you're
- 55:47talking about an appealable order. Just because
- 55:49somebody issues a notice of entry with a minute
- 55:51order. It might not be. A minute orders generally
- 55:55are not appealable unless they really are final.
- 55:58There can be exceptions to whether or not a minute
- 56:01order is a final order. Usually they're not.
- 56:04But listen, if you're getting 60 days past notice
- 56:07of entry of a minute order and a subsequent order
- 56:09that's a real order, it hasn't come out, I'd
- 56:12say the safer money would be to file a notice
- 56:14of appeal. It might get thrown out later as an
- 56:17appeal from a non -appealable order, but that's
- 56:19a lot easier to fix when you get the appealable
- 56:21order. than blowing the deadline. Then there's
- 56:24no, like I said, if you miss the deadline to
- 56:26file your notice of appeal, there's no boat coming
- 56:28to save you. Okay, another question. California
- 56:32has no equivalent to rule 4A5, allowing 30 days
- 56:35to file a motion for extension of time, file
- 56:38a notice of appeal. Oh my. Well, that's not a
- 56:40question. That's a statement that a shark is
- 56:43probably going to eat my boat if I treat it like
- 56:47a federal case instead of a state case. Yes,
- 56:49thank you for pointing that out. That's absolutely
- 56:51right. So listen, I don't see any more questions.
- 56:55I'm going to run down the list and then I'm going
- 56:56to leave you with one little clip at the end
- 56:58just for fun. So you can see, you know, all the
- 57:02different ways that your appeal can sink. And
- 57:06so you want to Susie, we're going to go back
- 57:10to the clip on slide four, but before we play
- 57:16it, I'm going to the one before that. There we
- 57:18go. Before I play it, I'm going to run down the
- 57:21list again. Make sure your appeal is seaworthy
- 57:23by recognizing appealable orders. Spot those
- 57:26appealable orders. Enhance your ability to stay
- 57:29afloat by getting a court reporter. Only use
- 57:32a settled statement if you have to because you
- 57:34forgot to get a court reporter. Reduce the risk
- 57:36of being capsized by getting a statement of decision
- 57:39and don't just ask for a statement of decision.
- 57:42Do it timely and list the principal controverted
- 57:44issues, even if you think the court has already
- 57:47given you a statement of decision. That's a tentative
- 57:50ruling. Make sure you can leave the harbor by
- 57:53timely filing that notice of appeal. You will
- 57:56be anchored in the harbor if you don't do it.
- 57:58There's no rescue for you if you don't timely
- 58:00file a notice of appeal. Help the appellate court
- 58:04to hear what happened in the trial court and
- 58:06to track the course of your appeal by designating
- 58:10the appellate record properly and avoid getting
- 58:13torpedoed by misunderstandings about appellate
- 58:16states. So with that, I'm going to leave you
- 58:19with this last clip that shows how appeals can
- 58:22sink. That's it. I don't see any further questions.
- 59:58And so I really want to thank you all for joining
- 1:00:00me. And I want to thank the Beverly Hills Bar
- 1:00:01Association and the Linda and Susie for helping
- 1:00:05me launch this presentation. This concludes today's
- 1:00:10presentation. Thank you so much, Brendan, for
- 1:00:11an excellent program. And thank you so much to
- 1:00:13our audience. Have a great afternoon, everybody.