Latest / The Slippery Slope / ‘It really is a scam’: University of Sydney professor hits out at international student ‘rort’

Transcript

‘It really is a scam’: University of Sydney professor hits out at international student ‘rort’ · The Slippery Slope

• 1:06
  way. OK, so.
• 1:10
  Probably a month. Did every month ago something
• 1:14
  like that maybe. I was.
• 1:15
  I was around town, I was. I went into a shop had to look
• 1:18
  for something. I was looking for something
• 1:20
  musical. And so I.
• 1:22
  Went into. This really tiny music shop and.
• 1:26
  They just. Happened to have a certain.
• 1:28
  Guitar in. There.
• 1:29
  I went. Looking.
• 1:30
  For something else. And then and I come across this
• 1:33
  guitar, they had a guitar in there and it was on sale.
• 1:37
  Really great price and it was a small.
• 1:40
  It was one of those mini. Maintains like those half sized
• 1:43
  maintains that you get and I looked at I thought.
• 1:47
  I would. Love this guitar.
• 1:48
  I've always wanted one. Always wanted.
• 1:51
  One and I thought it was there and it was like I said, it
• 1:54
  wasn't a bad price at all and I thought I should get that.
• 1:57
  Guitar and. Then I could all I could hear
• 1:59
  was my wife saying why in my my head I'm sitting and thinking
• 2:04
  yet more like imagine her saying why are you getting another
• 2:08
  guitar. And although the the problem is
• 2:13
  I already have several guitars so she's always like well you
• 2:15
  can't play them all at once I think yeah, but I can.
• 2:18
  I like having guitars, even if even if they are just sitting
• 2:22
  there sometimes and not really just play one or two one at the
• 2:26
  moment. But I like the fact that I have
• 2:28
  other guitars that I can play if I want to.
• 2:31
  So anyway. I really like this guitar.
• 2:33
  I wanted this guitar. All I could think of is my wife
• 2:36
  saying you don't need another guitar, Jay.
• 2:39
  So I walked out and I thought, well.
• 2:41
  It'll be. There.
• 2:42
  This this. Probably won't sell.
• 2:45
  You know. One of these guitars like this.
• 2:48
  In the town where I am, it's probably not going to.
• 2:50
  Sell and I thought, well, I'll, I'll come.
• 2:53
  Back. I'll come back.
• 2:54
  I'll convince myself that I could wait.
• 2:57
  So anyway. I'm in.
• 2:58
  Town yesterday I go into the shop.
• 3:00
  I thought you know stuff this. I'm gonna go buy this guitar
• 3:03
  and. Just.
• 3:07
  Maybe I just won't tell my wife I'll just buy it.
• 3:09
  I'll play it. Will she even notice?
• 3:11
  She'll just think it's one of the guitars I've.
• 3:12
  Already got anyway and. As long as long as she doesn't
• 3:17
  knows. The spare.
• 3:18
  Another case. Laying around anyway, I go into
• 3:21
  the. Shop the guitar's gone.
• 3:23
  Lady goes. Yeah, no, it was a nice guitar.
• 3:26
  Someone. Obviously someone bought it.
• 3:28
  And I walked out. I thought, You know what?
• 3:31
  Should have. Should have.
• 3:32
  Bought the guitar. And that that same.
• 3:36
  Came to me. You know, sometimes it's better
• 3:38
  to to seek forgiveness than ask. Permission and which?
• 3:44
  Which I'm not saying is the best, the best saying, but that
• 3:47
  did come to me. I thought, Yep, Jay, that's what
• 3:50
  I should have done. When I.
• 3:51
  Saw the guitar. I should have just thought, Yep,
• 3:55
  I should just bought the guitar, I said.
• 3:57
  Well, sorry, babe. The.
• 4:00
  Board and other guitar. You know, it's too late.
• 4:03
  I've got it. I own it.
• 4:05
  It's a it's an investment. Or can I say?
• 4:08
  But I didn't so. I'm walking out yesterday.
• 4:10
  Thinking. Yep.
• 4:12
  I should have asked. Forgiveness I should, I should
• 4:14
  have. Should.
• 4:15
  Have been seeking forgiveness. And then asking permission.
• 4:20
  Then I would have had another guitar.
• 4:21
  I would. Have had one of those mini
• 4:22
  maintains. Played it two walls in the shop.
• 4:25
  It was good. It was a good guitar.
• 4:28
  I have to go get another one anyway.
• 4:30
  So I was reading this. I was reading this.
• 4:33
  Article I. Thought this.
• 4:34
  Is exactly what the government. Are doing.
• 4:36
  You remember if you a few weeks ago, I think it was.
• 4:39
  I was doing a I did an episode and it's about how Australia is
• 4:44
  struggling with housing at the moment and also employment in
• 4:49
  some areas. OK the problem is the government
• 4:53
  is just allowing more and more immigrants in it's and like I
• 4:57
  said there's nothing I I am I think Australia needs
• 5:01
  immigration. However, the way Australia is
• 5:05
  doing it at the moment, I mean they've they've allowed
• 5:07
  something like. It's over half.
• 5:10
  A million. New migrants within a.
• 5:12
  Really short time frame, I think it was between in within a two
• 5:16
  year time frame. I think it might have been just
• 5:19
  under 600,000 actually. And.
• 5:23
  I thought. Well.
• 5:23
  This is ridiculous. You can't sit there saying we
• 5:25
  have a housing shortage. And then you're continually
• 5:29
  looking you're. Continually allowing this amount
• 5:32
  of new migrants to come into the land, into the country, and then
• 5:38
  you sit there and blame everything else on the housing
• 5:40
  shortage. It's, you know.
• 5:42
  Everything. Everything else, other than the
• 5:44
  fact that you're letting hundreds of thousands of new
• 5:47
  people into the country and then they stepped up and they go, oh,
• 5:50
  we'll have to look into it. They're like Windows.
• 5:52
  They're always. Looking into it, but The thing
• 5:56
  is, it dawned on me this is what they're doing.
• 5:59
  They I'll, I'll read the article.
• 6:03
  I'll read the article. So this headline here says.
• 6:06
  It really is a scam. University of Sydney.
• 6:10
  Professor. Hits out at International
• 6:12
  Student Raught, OK. So.
• 6:16
  A landmark report by the property industry which argued
• 6:19
  international students are not to blame.
• 6:23
  Not to blame their saying. But the housing crisis has been
• 6:26
  slammed by an expert highlighting how simple math in
• 6:31
  the study's own figures appear to contradict one of its key
• 6:34
  claims. The.
• 6:35
  Report released late. Last month by the Student
• 6:38
  Accommodation Council, part of the National Property Council
• 6:42
  lobby group. OK, so in other words.
• 6:45
  You know, these are people that make money.
• 6:48
  They they make money out of these reports and and painting a
• 6:51
  good picture on things. So don't.
• 6:53
  Anyway, they said that international students had
• 6:56
  unfairly worn the blame for Australians Australia's rental
• 7:00
  crisis. But they were not the cause,
• 7:02
  they said, either of rising rents or low vacancies making up
• 7:07
  just 4% of rent renters nationwide.
• 7:10
  In fact, far bigger impact on rental housing availability has
• 7:13
  been the post COVID trend to work from home.
• 7:16
  Oh yeah, OK, Hams that make a difference.
• 7:19
  Seriously, you already had a place to live, and So what?
• 7:22
  You're gonna you're gonna work from the place, from your, from
• 7:26
  your house. How does that makes no sense?
• 7:32
  This so this is what? Student Accommodation, Council,
• 7:34
  executive. Director Tori.
• 7:36
  Brown wrote in an opinion piece for the Herald Sun.
• 7:39
  So he's just gaslighting. It's telling us basically,
• 7:42
  you're all a bunch of naughties, you don't understand anything.
• 7:45
  It's really because people have decided.
• 7:46
  To work from home that we no longer that we have this.
• 7:49
  Shortage. On a of accommodation, which
• 7:53
  makes absolutely no sense. Anyway, we need to grow the
• 7:57
  amount of student. Accommodation to provide greater
• 7:59
  housing options for. Students without forcing them to
• 8:01
  compete for private rentals. It's time to stop pointing the
• 8:04
  finger at international students and instead pointed.
• 8:06
  At ourselves. However, University of Sydney.
• 8:10
  Associate Professor Salvatore Salvatore.
• 8:14
  Babones. Babones.
• 8:16
  That's a great name. Salvatori.
• 8:18
  Bones, and a vocal critic of the sector who has labelled the
• 8:23
  international student market a scam, said the the report had
• 8:29
  unintentionally made an incredible admission.
• 8:32
  Their own statistics, damn them, Professor Bonners, Bones told
• 8:38
  news.com. Then what have we got here?
• 8:41
  So this is the actual reports. These are the figures.
• 8:44
  International students are concentrated.
• 8:46
  OK, so if you go to page 15, it says 13 of this is of the
• 8:51
  report. OK.
• 8:52
  So he's saying if you go to page 15, it says 13 out of 556 local
• 8:57
  government areas have international students that
• 9:00
  exceed 10% of the rental markets.
• 9:04
  It's huge. And in 73% of LG AZ
• 9:07
  concentration is under 1%. That means in 27% of LG's, which
• 9:13
  are virtually all in capital cities, not rural areas, the
• 9:17
  concentration is over 1%. Well, what is the rental vacancy
• 9:24
  rate? It's 1%.
• 9:27
  You get that. So the concentration is over 1%
• 9:32
  in 27% of LG's in all these capital cities.
• 9:36
  And that's the the vacancy rate is only 1%, which means if there
• 9:39
  were no international students in 27% of LG's the rental.
• 9:44
  Availability by. A very rough cut, according to
• 9:47
  their analysis, would double, and that's only for LG's where
• 9:52
  the where the concentration is 1% for those that are above 10%
• 9:57
  or up at 24%. That's incredibly warping to the
• 10:02
  rental market. The Student Accommodation
• 10:05
  Council report identified Adelaide and Burwood as the
• 10:08
  LPGA's with the highest concentration of international
• 10:11
  student renters at 24%, followed by Melbourne at 21.8%,
• 10:15
  Strathfield on 17.6% Bayside on, 15.8% in Sydney, 14.6% Perth.
• 10:23
  Hobart, Monash. Georgia's River, Kenning,
• 10:26
  Cumberland and White Horse were all above 10%.
• 10:29
  They didn't do the simple maths. The professor.
• 10:32
  Babones said in their mind they were showing their that
• 10:36
  international students had no impact on the rental market.
• 10:38
  They didn't realise their own data they're promoting actually
• 10:42
  contradicts their claims. It's because they that is
• 10:47
  because they treat us. They treat us, the general
• 10:52
  public, like we're idiots. They've just.
• 10:55
  Decided it's. Better for them if they ask
• 10:58
  forgiveness at a later date rather than beg permission now.
• 11:04
  That's all they've done. They don't want to tell everyone
• 11:07
  what's going on. They don't want to admit what's
• 11:09
  going on, even though the the. Figures bear out.
• 11:11
  Exactly what's happening. And even though we all know
• 11:14
  what's happening, because we're not, we're not the fools that
• 11:17
  they think us, that they think we are, that they treat us like
• 11:21
  everyone can see, that, you know, we've got a housing
• 11:24
  shortage. And it's because we have all
• 11:26
  these international students, all these new migrants coming
• 11:29
  into the land, but they treat us like fools anyway.
• 11:33
  But this is what they're doing. They're simply going to do what
• 11:36
  they want. And then later down the track,
• 11:39
  when you know when it's all too late, then they'll say, Oh yeah,
• 11:42
  we made a mistake, please forgive us.
• 11:46
  And then give us another term, please forgive us.
• 11:49
  And can you vote for us again? We'll promise we'll fix it in
• 11:51
  the future, but by then it's too late.
• 11:55
  They've already got it. Anyway, let me know what you
• 11:59
  think. I'm Jay Fallon.
• 12:02
  Thanks for listening to The Slippery Slope.