Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / BYD Dolphin versus MG4: Electric Vehicle Comparison
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the Deep Dive. Our mission, as always, is to
- 0:13take a stack of complex sources and really pull out the
- 0:18sharpest, most important insights for you.
- 0:20Today we are plunging straight into a genuine automotive
- 0:24phenomenon, the battle for the title of Australia's most
- 0:27affordable electric car pitching the BYD Dolphin against the MG
- 0:324. And this isn't just about two
- 0:34new cars. I mean, this is a direct
- 0:35comparison where the stakes are incredibly high for you, the
- 0:38listener. The base models, the Dolphin
- 0:41Dynamic and the MG4 Essence are often separated by what, $100 is
- 0:45basically nothing. They're positioned as the
- 0:47definitive economical alternative to, you know, the
- 0:50Champions, like a top spec Toyota Corolla Hybrid or Mazda
- 0:533. That's the core of it, isn't it?
- 0:55So we're going to be analyzing everything.
- 0:56The specs, the actual ride quality, the controversial cabin
- 1:00tech, and crucially, the long term ownership costs.
- 1:03We really need to figure out which one of these delivers on
- 1:05that promise of affordability and reliability, and maybe which
- 1:08one is just a better fit for your life.
- 1:10Exactly. If you're ready to make that
- 1:12switch from Etrol, understanding the tradeoffs here is essential.
- 1:15You've got the MG4's driving dynamics versus the Dolphins.
- 1:19Well, clever tech and efficiency.
- 1:22Let's let's start with the hard numbers, OK?
- 1:24Let's do it. So unpacking the core
- 1:26specifications on paper, I mean they look almost like twins,
- 1:29right? Both are compact C segment
- 1:32hatchbacks around 4.3 meters long.
- 1:34Put some squarely in that small car class and the boot space is
- 1:38effectively identical. 350 liters for the MG4345 for the
- 1:43Dolphin. Both are on these dedicated EV
- 1:46platforms, which you know means more interior space because the
- 1:49battery is just flat under the floor.
- 1:50They do look similar, but that's where it gets a bit deceptive.
- 1:53The moment you see them side by side or definitely when you
- 1:56drive them, you notice the differences.
- 1:58The sources all point out that the MG4IS notably wider, and
- 2:02that's great for shoulder room, especially if you're trying to
- 2:04squeeze three people in the back.
- 2:05OK, so the MG4IS wider. Right.
- 2:07But the Dolphin's a bit taller. It has more of that sort of mono
- 2:10volume profile. It's really trying to maximize
- 2:12headroom and give you that airy cabin feel.
- 2:15It's a little bubble, like in its shape.
- 2:16OK, but the thing that really jumped out at me from the
- 2:19sources was the weight. The BYD Dolphin is 152 kilograms
- 2:23lighter than the MG four. That feels huge in a car this
- 2:27size. Why are they so different in
- 2:28mass? That difference is really
- 2:30significant, yeah, and it's mostly down to manufacturing
- 2:33choices and the battery configuration.
- 2:36That 152 kilos saving is almost certainly the reason the Dolphin
- 2:40claims better energy efficiency. In real world testing, the
- 2:43Dolphin averaged 14.9 kilowatt hours per 100 kilometers.
- 2:47The MG 4 was noticeably thirstier, coming in at 16.2, so
- 2:51that efficiency difference means the dolphin can get away with a
- 2:53smaller, lighter and, you know, cheaper battery to get a similar
- 2:56range. That makes a great case for the
- 2:58Dolphin as just a city commuter. But if you're looking for
- 3:01performance, the base MG 4 is the immediate winner, isn't it?
- 3:05It hits 100 kilometers an hour in a pretty quick 7.7 seconds.
- 3:09The base Dolphin, by contrast, only has about 70 kilowatts of
- 3:12power. It's it's quite a bit slower.
- 3:15That's true for the entry level models, yeah.
- 3:18But this is where it gets really interesting.
- 3:19If you can stress your budget just a little bit to the premium
- 3:22versions, The Dolphin Premium actually matches the MD Fours
- 3:25power output at 150 kilowatts. But because the Dolphin has
- 3:30superior torque, we're talking 310 Newton meters versus the MG
- 3:33Fours 250. The Dolphin Premium is actually
- 3:36quicker. It claims a 0100 time of 7.0
- 3:40seconds flat. So wait, the Dolphin can win the
- 3:42acceleration war, but only if you buy the more expensive one,
- 3:45which kind of cancels out that initial price advantage.
- 3:47I mean, you have to choose what you care about more, the
- 3:49absolute lowest price or the fastest acceleration.
- 3:51Precisely. And that theme of wildly
- 3:53different choices continues. Inside the cockpit is where
- 3:56these cars really established. They're completely separate
- 3:59identities. If the outside is a bit
- 4:01confusing, the cabin experience is absolutely clarifying.
- 4:05Let's get into the tech and the design because these cars
- 4:08represent two well 2 completely opposite philosophies.
- 4:13Yeah, one source described them as antithetical, and I think
- 4:16that's perfect. The MG 4 is very conventional,
- 4:19sensible, functional. It feels like a European
- 4:21hatchback. Everything is matte black,
- 4:24conservative, and you know it's exactly where you'd expect it to
- 4:27be. The BYD Dolphin, on the other
- 4:29hand, is a whole sensory experience.
- 4:32It's quirky, tech pack, colorful, and just full of these
- 4:35little design gimmicks. The biggest gimmick, of course,
- 4:37is that rotating screen. You get this massive 12.8 inch
- 4:40display that you know at the touch of a button, it just
- 4:43swivels from portrait to landscape.
- 4:44And while you might think it's a novelty, having the map and
- 4:47portrait and then flipping it for a better Android Auto view
- 4:49is. It's genuinely useful.
- 4:52And beyond the swivel, the Dolphin just has more standard
- 4:54tech. The interface is really snappy,
- 4:56user friendly. It's got these high resolution
- 4:58cameras with a kind of interactor 3D view for parking,
- 5:01which is fantastic, and the sound system is just better, two
- 5:04extra speakers compared to the MG4's standard setup which is a
- 5:08bit muffled. The sheer volume of standard
- 5:10features the dolphin packs in is almost embarrassing for the MG4I
- 5:14mean, even on the cheaper trims you get hey BYD voice control, a
- 5:18panoramic glass roof, heated seats and a heat pump, which is
- 5:23a huge deal for preserving battery range in the cold.
- 5:26That's just amazing value for money right there.
- 5:28The MG Four tries to counter that with conventional
- 5:32practicality. It's screen is intuitive enough,
- 5:35and crucially it keeps some physical buttons for things like
- 5:37volume and climate. The MG4 has its own set of
- 5:40really frustrating quirks, primarily that very strange
- 5:44almost Tesla like start procedure.
- 5:46Oh yeah, the one that the reviewers found so unnerving.
- 5:49You get in, and if you twist the gear dial before the car's
- 5:51software has fully booted up, the transmission goes into
- 5:54neutral and the parking brake just turns off.
- 5:56Precisely. And if you're on a hill, you
- 5:59just start rolling backwards until the software finally
- 6:01catches up and the handbrake desperately slams back on.
- 6:04That's not just a quirk. That's, you know, a moment of
- 6:06genuine terror that kind of undermines the whole
- 6:09sophisticated feel of the car. And we also saw notes about the
- 6:12MG4's climate control. That tiny 1° shift from 25 to
- 6:1626°C can turn the cabin from comfortable into a sauna.
- 6:21It's a small thing, but it points to a lack of software
- 6:24refinement. For sure, on basic practicality
- 6:26the Dolphin does edge ahead in the backseat.
- 6:29Passengers get 2 USB ports and a proper full down armrest, but
- 6:34this is a big but for both. They frustratingly lack even a
- 6:37space saver spare tire. Which is a major point to
- 6:40consider, especially when we get to driving dynamics and road
- 6:43feel. This is where the MG4 absolutely
- 6:45pulls ahead, isn't it? It's the car you'd actually want
- 6:47to take on a longer trip. This is the biggest difference
- 6:49between the two. The MG 4 is all about driving
- 6:53enjoyment. It has a rewarding chassis, the
- 6:55steering gives you good feedback, it feels light and
- 6:58nimble. It's engineered to feel just
- 7:01like a really well sorted European family car like a Ford
- 7:04Focus or AVW Golf. It's composed and familiar on a
- 7:08winding Rd. And the Dolphins seems to have
- 7:10aimed for a completely different target.
- 7:12Comfort almost to a fault. The sources described the riot
- 7:15as soft, kind of wallowy with very little body control.
- 7:19When you push it, it's great as a quiet city commuter, but out
- 7:23on the open Rd. the steering feels light, a bit sticky and
- 7:26just unnatural. You're always making little
- 7:28corrections. And here's where those initial
- 7:30cost savings on the Dolphin become a bit clearer, and it
- 7:33could lead to future costs for you as a buyer.
- 7:35The tires that often uses Linglong Comfort Master tires,
- 7:39and the testers noted they break traction a bit too easily under
- 7:41acceleration. This suggests that the moment
- 7:44you upgrade to that faster Dolphin Premium, the tires will
- 7:46immediately be the weakest link. A smart buyer should probably
- 7:50budget for a set of Continentals or Michelins.
- 7:52That's a fantastic piece of insight.
- 7:54Saving money on the car might just mean spending it later on
- 7:57better rubber. The MG4IN contrast comes
- 8:01standard with quality Continental tires.
- 8:03It just shows where their priorities are.
- 8:05You also see that refinement difference in the brakes.
- 8:08The MG4's brake pedal feels natural and easy to modulate
- 8:11dolphins and mushy. There's a really clumsy blend
- 8:14between the regenerative braking and the physical brakes.
- 8:17It makes the MG4 feel much more predictable.
- 8:20OK, let's talk charging, because this really determines if the
- 8:23car is a city machine or a credible Rd. tripper.
- 8:27And for public fast charging, the MG4IS the clear winner.
- 8:30Absolutely. The MG4 offers significantly
- 8:33faster DC charging. It can peak at 140 kilowatts.
- 8:37This means a 10 to 80% charge can be done in a very quick
- 8:40tummy 6 minutes. That kind of speed is essential
- 8:42for long distance driving. The Dolphin, sadly, is much
- 8:45slower. It peaks at around 89 kilowatts,
- 8:48so you're looking at a full 40 minutes for that same charge.
- 8:50So if you're planning regular long haul trips, it's the MG4,
- 8:53no question. However, this is a big However,
- 8:56the Dolphin completely flips the script for home charging, it is
- 8:59superior. It has an 11 kilowatt AC
- 9:02charging capacity, compared to the MG4's cap of 6.6 kilowatts.
- 9:06OK. For a listener, can you just
- 9:07clarify why that 11 kilowatt number is such a big advantage?
- 9:11It's a major technical difference.
- 9:13Most homes have single phase power, which is limited to about
- 9:167 kilowatts of the MG. 4 is fine there, but many modern or
- 9:19upgraded homes in Australia have three phase power, and if you
- 9:22have that and the right wall box, the Dolphin can charge at
- 9:25that full 11 kilowatts. That dramatically cuts down the
- 9:28time it takes to recharge fully overnight.
- 9:31For home charging convenience, the Dolphin wins.
- 9:33That makes perfect sense. So the MG 4, the fast charging
- 9:35Rd. tripper with a great chassis and the Dolphin, the efficient
- 9:39city commuter with faster home charging and a tech risk cabin.
- 9:42Now for the ultimate question, the 10 year outlook, reliability
- 9:46and true economy. Right, and this is maybe the
- 9:48most crucial part for an affordable car.
- 9:51Both of them absolutely save you money over a comparable petrol
- 9:54car like a Golf. You know, when you factor in
- 9:57fuel insurance servicing, the savings are huge, especially if
- 10:01you charge at home. But if you plan to keep the car
- 10:04for a decade, the battery chemistry is vital.
- 10:07So layout the difference for us. What are the two chemistries
- 10:10being used here? The BYD Dolphin uses Lithium
- 10:13Iron Phosphate, or LFP. It's what they call their Blade
- 10:16battery. Think of the LFP battery like a
- 10:18sturdy work boot. It's heavy, maybe a bit dense,
- 10:21but it's incredibly robust and durable.
- 10:24This chemistry is very resilient.
- 10:25You could frequently charge it right up to 100% without really
- 10:28worrying about degradation. It suggests excellent longevity
- 10:31over 10 years of hard use. And the MG4.
- 10:34The MG 4 uses NMC or NCA chemistry, Nickel, manganese,
- 10:39cobalt. This is more like a high
- 10:42performance running shoe. It's lighter, more energy dense,
- 10:45which is why it gets better range figures, but it's a bit
- 10:47more delicate. It's more sensitive to sitting
- 10:50at 100% charge or being in high temperatures.
- 10:53To keep that battery healthy for a decade, you'd want to limit
- 10:55daily charging to around 80%. It just requires more careful
- 10:59management. Which makes the Dolphins 8 year
- 11:01160,000 kilometer battery warranty a real show of
- 11:05confidence in that LFP chemistry.
- 11:08But the MG4 has a stronger overall vehicle warranty, right?
- 11:12Seven years, unlimited kilometers.
- 11:14Yeah, the warranty and service costs are really competitive.
- 11:16The MG4 has fantastic service intervals every two years or
- 11:1940,000 kilometers. The Dolphin requires yearly
- 11:21check UPS. They're both incredibly cheap to
- 11:23run compared to their petrol rivals.
- 11:25This all sounds like a slam dunk for savings, but here comes the
- 11:28financial risk the sources uncover.
- 11:30We have to talk about that three-year depreciation gap.
- 11:32This is the shockwave moment. Both of these are new brands to
- 11:37the market, which means they're predicted 3 year resale values
- 11:39are weak. We're talking around 48.5%
- 11:43depreciation. Now compare that to a car like
- 11:46the Toyota Corolla Hybrid. When you factor in that huge
- 11:49depreciation hit on the EV, you're looking at a potential
- 11:52seven and a half $1000 gap against the Corolla over just
- 11:56three years. $7500 That's a massive difference.
- 12:01That means the running cost savings you get from cheap
- 12:03electricity could be completely wiped out by that initial
- 12:06depreciation. Exactly.
- 12:08It reinforces one key point. The savings only truly
- 12:12materialize if you commit to the car for the long haul, say 8 to
- 12:1510 years and if you can use cheap home charging.
- 12:18If you only use expensive public chargers and then sell the car
- 12:21in three years, you lose the financial battle against a fuel
- 12:25sipping hybrid. So what does this all mean?
- 12:27They're both reliable, they're both economical, but they demand
- 12:29very different things from you. Which one should the listener
- 12:32choose? It depends entirely on your
- 12:34priorities. If you're the kind of person who
- 12:36really appreciates driving enjoyment, wants that
- 12:39sophisticated European feel, needs maximum range flexibility
- 12:43and requires quick DC charging for Rd. trips, then you should
- 12:46choose the MG 4. It's engineered for the
- 12:49enthusiast. And conversely, you should
- 12:51choose the BYD Dolphin if you prioritize that superior city
- 12:55efficiency, the faster 11 kilowatt home charging, the tech
- 12:59quirks like the rotated screen, and the long term Peace of Mind
- 13:03from that really robust LFP battery.
- 13:06It is the champion for the urban commuter who is focused on
- 13:09maximum longevity. If we pull back a bit, the
- 13:12arrival of these two cars proves that affordable, competent EVs
- 13:16aren't some future promise. They are here today pay and they
- 13:18are seriously challenging the established brands.
- 13:21The crucial question is no longer if you can afford an EV,
- 13:23but whether you're willing to manage the trade-offs, the
- 13:25charting infrastructure, and that financial risk of high
- 13:27depreciation to actually realize the impressive long term savings
- 13:31that these cars promise. That is a fascinating dilemma
- 13:34for the modern car buyer. Pay a premium for guaranteed
- 13:37resale or commit to the long haul for true savings.
- 13:41Thank you for joining us on this deep dive into the world of
- 13:43affordable electric mobility. If you found these insights
- 13:46valuable, please follow the channel for more detailed
- 13:48explorations of the topics that matter most to you.