Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Subjective Well-Being (SWB) Explained: The Science of Happiness & Buddhism
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the psychology undergrad. So what
- 0:03if I told you that winning the lottery or landing
- 0:07your absolute dream job or finally buying that
- 0:10massive house, what if that only accounted for
- 0:13at most 10 % of your actual happiness? I mean,
- 0:16I would probably say you're crazy. But yeah,
- 0:19that is exactly what the data says. And for you
- 0:21listening, you're the third member of our study
- 0:23group today as we get into this. We're just two
- 0:26psychology students trying to make sense of our
- 0:27coursework. And this week's deep dive is, well,
- 0:30it's a lot. It really is. Usually when we prep
- 0:32for an exam, the material is super precise, right?
- 0:35You memorize the lobes of the brain, or you learn
- 0:39the diagnostic criteria for a disorder. It's
- 0:41very binary. It's either broken or not broken.
- 0:43Right, totally. It rarely leaves any room for
- 0:46interpretation. into the empirical science of
- 0:49happiness, suddenly all that clean precision
- 0:51just, it vanishes. We are looking at this landscape
- 0:54of human emotion that is really murky. Yeah,
- 0:57because we naturally want well -being to be easily
- 0:59categorized. Like, it gives a simple checklist,
- 1:01you know. But human psychology stubbornly refuses
- 1:04to work that way. Exactly, especially when we
- 1:07start intersecting modern evolutionary psychology
- 1:10with the ancient philosophy of Tibetan Buddhism,
- 1:14which is basically our mission for today's study
- 1:16session. Yeah, we need to figure out exactly
- 1:18what subjective well -being actually is, why
- 1:21our brains are, like, evolutionarily hardwired
- 1:25to make us profoundly dissatisfied, and how ancient
- 1:28moral concepts, specifically compassion, hold
- 1:31the data -backed keys to hacking our own neurochemistry.
- 1:35It's so fascinating. But before we get into the
- 1:38ancient philosophy, we really have to establish
- 1:40the modern scientific baseline, because researchers
- 1:43don't even use the word happiness in the literature,
- 1:45right? Right. No, they use subjective well -being
- 1:46or SWB, because it isn't just one blanket emotion.
- 1:50It's broken down into three distinct components.
- 1:52You need high life satisfaction. frequent positive
- 1:55feelings, and infrequent negative feelings. And
- 1:58the underlying causes for those three components
- 2:00operate on completely different tracks. You have
- 2:02internal top -down influences. That's your inborn
- 2:05temperament, basically your genetic predisposition
- 2:07to be optimistic or neurotic. And then you have
- 2:10the external bottom -up influences. So those
- 2:12are your material resources, your social network,
- 2:15and the stability of the society you actually
- 2:18live in. I always think of subjective well -being
- 2:20like your overall college GPA. Oh, that's a good
- 2:24way to look at it. look at it yeah like just
- 2:25like you need decent grades across multiple distinct
- 2:28subjects to get a 4 .0 you need high life satisfaction
- 2:31and frequent positive feelings and low negative
- 2:34feelings to have high SWB right right you can
- 2:37be entirely satisfied with your broad life accomplishments
- 2:39like maybe you got the promotion you wanted but
- 2:42if that promotion brings chronic daily stress
- 2:45and zero positive daily feelings your overall
- 2:48SWB is going to take a massive hit you can't
- 2:51ace biology bond camp and expect a perfect GPA.
- 2:55That's such a perfect analogy. And let's apply
- 2:57that to Sandra Lubomirski's meta -analysis because
- 3:00her breakdown of where our happiness actually
- 3:02comes from completely shatters how most people
- 3:04view the world. Oh my gosh, the 50 -10 -40 rule.
- 3:07Yes. She reviewed decades of studies and created
- 3:10this pie chart. 50 % of our happiness is a biological
- 3:14set point dictated by our genetics. 40 % is determined
- 3:17by intentional activity like the choices we actively
- 3:20make. And a mere 10 % is determined by our life
- 3:23circumstances. 10%. That statistic is staggering
- 3:28to me. It really is. I mean, most of us spend
- 3:30our entire lives assuming the circumstance is
- 3:33a slice is the whole pie. Just think about it.
- 3:36How much time do you, listening right now, spend
- 3:39obsessing over your circumstances? Oh, totally.
- 3:42Believing that if you just lived in a better
- 3:43city or had a different relationship or made
- 3:46another $20 ,000 a year, everything would magically
- 3:49fall into place. Exactly. But the data categorically
- 3:52proves that is an illusion. And we can see that
- 3:54illusion play out in the real world with Pima.
- 3:56She's the 16 -year -old Tibetan nomad documented
- 3:58in the research. All right, Pima. Her story is
- 4:01wild. Yeah, she lives in the high mountains.
- 4:04Her family literally moves their tent, according
- 4:06to the seasons, facing these incredibly harsh
- 4:09winters where starvation is a genuine threat.
- 4:12By Western materialistic standards, she lives
- 4:15in absolute poverty. But her subjective well
- 4:18-being scores are remarkably high. Exactly. So
- 4:21how does the psychology explain that? Because
- 4:23it isn't just... ignorance of the outside world,
- 4:26right? She knows what's out there. Right. It
- 4:28comes down to maxing out the other two slices
- 4:30of the pie. She has a positive inborn temperament,
- 4:32so she's leveraging that 50 % genetic factor.
- 4:35But more importantly, she utilizes the 40 % intentional
- 4:39activity slice. By deeply embedding herself in
- 4:42her social and religious community. Yeah. She
- 4:45is fully aware her family lacks material wealth,
- 4:47but she feels fortunate because her family owns
- 4:4910 yaks while her aunt and uncle only have three.
- 4:52She actually finds genuine psychological reward
- 4:55and being able to share resources with her extended
- 4:57family. She is pulling her happiness from intentional
- 5:00social bonds, not from a change in circumstances.
- 5:03But that leaves a massive glaring contradiction
- 5:05for us to figure out. Yeah, like, if circumstances
- 5:08only account for 10 % of our well -being, why
- 5:11is the human brain so obsessed with chasing them?
- 5:15Why do we feel a physical agonizing craving for
- 5:18a newer car or higher status? The mechanism driving
- 5:21that obsession is called hedonic adaptation.
- 5:25Evolution essentially programmed us with a baseline
- 5:28set point of happiness. OK, so when a major life
- 5:31event happens, good or bad, we experience a spike
- 5:34or a crash in emotion. Exactly. But the brain
- 5:37inevitably habituates to the new normal and drags
- 5:41us right back to our baseline. People usually
- 5:43call it the hedonic treadmill, but honestly,
- 5:45that doesn't really capture the mechanism of
- 5:47what the brain is doing. No, it really doesn't.
- 5:49To me, it's more like a video game with a level
- 5:51scaling algorithm. You know, when you grind for
- 5:53hours to get a rare high level piece of armor,
- 5:56thinking the game will finally be easy. Oh, yeah.
- 5:58And then the moment you equip it, the game's
- 6:00code automatically levels up all the monsters
- 6:02around you. Exactly. The difficulty remains exactly
- 6:05the same. You never actually get ahead. The environment
- 6:08just adapts to your new stats. It makes you wonder,
- 6:11is our brain basically running a biological scam
- 6:14on us? Well, evolutionary psychologist Robert
- 6:17Wright argues exactly that. Natural selection
- 6:20doesn't care if you are happy. It only cares
- 6:23that you are productive enough to survive and
- 6:25pass on your genes. That is so bleak, but it
- 6:27makes sense. Right. If a caveman caught a mammoth
- 6:30and felt permanent lasting joy, he would stop
- 6:32hunting. He would starve. So to force us to keep
- 6:36hunting, Natural selection makes the anticipation
- 6:38of pleasure overwhelmingly strong, but ensures
- 6:41the pleasure itself evaporates almost immediately.
- 6:44So our brains are literally diluting us to ensure
- 6:47the survival of the species. Basically, yeah.
- 6:49And the crazy part is, Buddhism diagnosed this
- 6:52exact psychological trap centuries before Darwin
- 6:55was even born. Oh, the First Noble Truth, right?
- 6:57Yes. It's often translated as, life is suffering.
- 7:00But scholars argue a much more accurate translation
- 7:02is, life brings unsatisfactoriness. That's a
- 7:07great word for it. It describes samsara, which
- 7:09is the constant cycle of grasping for permanence
- 7:12in a world where pleasure is biologically designed
- 7:15to be temporary. And the ultimate proof of this
- 7:18biological fading is that study on the college
- 7:20student, Harry, the one who's diagnosed with
- 7:23Hodgkin's lymphoma. Oh, that study's mind -blowing.
- 7:25It really is. Researchers tracked his daily mood
- 7:28over six weeks. Midway through the study, he
- 7:31received the greatest news a human being can
- 7:33possibly receive. His cancer was in remission.
- 7:36And obviously, his mood spiked off the charts.
- 7:38Right. But the adaptation kicked in almost instantly.
- 7:42Within a remarkably short period, the psychological
- 7:44thrill of literally cheating death wore off,
- 7:47and Harry's mood drifted right back down to his
- 7:50pre -remission baseline. It's hard to wrap your
- 7:52head around, I mean, if avoiding death doesn't
- 7:54grant permanent happiness, a new iPhone certainly
- 7:56won't. But, you know, this evolutionary design
- 7:59isn't entirely stacked against us. The brain
- 8:02tricks us into wanting the wrong things, which
- 8:04researchers call miswanting, but it also possesses
- 8:08a remarkable defense mechanism for when we inevitably
- 8:10fail to get those things. Oh, Dan Gilbert's concept.
- 8:13The psychological immune system. Yeah. We all
- 8:17know about our physical immune system fighting
- 8:18off infections, but Gilbert points out we have
- 8:21a cognitive mechanism that neutralizes existential
- 8:24threats. And the defining feature of this system
- 8:27is immune neglect. Basically, we are entirely
- 8:31unaware it even exists. Which is wild. I like
- 8:34to think of it like the airbags in a car, right?
- 8:36You don't even know they are there until you
- 8:38crash, but they end up saving your life. Or like
- 8:41the GPS in your car. When you miss a crucial
- 8:43exit, the GPS doesn't just shut down and let
- 8:46you drive into a lake. Thankfully, no. It instantly
- 8:49recalculates. It finds a new route and essentially
- 8:51tells you, actually, this scenic detour is perfectly
- 8:54fine. When we experience a massive failure, the
- 8:58brain experiences unbearable cognitive dissonance.
- 9:01To resolve that friction, the psychological immune
- 9:04system recalculates our reality and actively
- 9:07synthesizes happiness. Let's focus on that term
- 9:10for a second. Synthesized. Because it sounds
- 9:12fake, you know? It sounds like the brain is just
- 9:14settling or being sarcastic. Yeah, well I didn't
- 9:16want that job anyway. Exactly. But Gilbert's
- 9:19research proves synthesized happiness is chemically
- 9:22and practically indistinguishable from the natural
- 9:25happiness we feel when we get exactly what we
- 9:28originally wanted. The brain actively rewrites
- 9:31our weighting of certain values. Like the student
- 9:34in the case study, Salem. She desperately wanted
- 9:37to go to medical school. Oh, right. And her grades
- 9:39weren't high enough, so she was rejected. It
- 9:41was a catastrophic failure of her primary life
- 9:44goal. Yeah. Without a psychological immune system,
- 9:47that kind of failure could permanently cripple
- 9:49her subjective well -being. But the recalculation
- 9:52began almost immediately. Her brain literally
- 9:54shifted her attention away from the prestige
- 9:56of being a doctor and hyper -focused on the negatives
- 9:58she had previously ignored, like the crushing
- 10:01debt, the grueling 80 -hour work weeks, the burnout.
- 10:04And simultaneously, she pivoted to organizational
- 10:07psychology. Her brain highlighted the stable
- 10:10hours and the fascinating social dynamics of
- 10:12that field. She didn't just pretend to be okay.
- 10:15She genuinely synthesized happiness by altering
- 10:17how she evaluated her options. It's amazing.
- 10:20We have this invisible software running in the
- 10:22background, recalculating our route when we fail.
- 10:26But it makes you wonder what actively sabotages
- 10:29it. What introduces malware into that system?
- 10:32According to the research, it points directly
- 10:34to the comparing mind and something evolutionary
- 10:36psychologists call... the modularity of the mind.
- 10:39Right, because social comparison is the absolute
- 10:41fastest way to artificially suppress your SWB.
- 10:45Upward comparison, like fixating on people who
- 10:47have more status or wealth, just breeds resentment
- 10:50and anxiety. And then downward comparison, looking
- 10:53at those with less, I mean, that might provide
- 10:55a fleeting ego boost, but it really just breeds
- 10:57a fragile defensive arrogance. Both states rely
- 11:00on a fundamental illusion about how the brain
- 11:02is structured. OK, this is where the material
- 11:04gets intensely philosophical. So evolutionary
- 11:06psycho - Scientology suggests there is no central
- 11:09self operating the control room of your brain.
- 11:12Which is super hard to grasp. It really is. The
- 11:15mind is not a monarchy with a single soul calling
- 11:17the shots. It is a committee of different computational
- 11:21modules, each designed by evolution to solve
- 11:24specific survival problems, like mating, resource
- 11:27gathering, social status. So the part of our
- 11:30brain that feels like a unified self is essentially
- 11:32just a public relations module. Yes. The PR module's
- 11:35only job is to manage your reputation within
- 11:38the tribe. It makes you feel righteous. It justifies
- 11:41your actions to others. And it screams that your
- 11:43cravings are absolute life or death emergencies.
- 11:46It constructs the illusion of a permanent ego
- 11:49to ensure you fight for your share of the resources.
- 11:52Okay, I have to push back on this because it
- 11:53is incredibly difficult to process. If both evolutionary
- 11:56psychology and Buddhist philosophy agree there
- 11:58is no central permanent self, who exactly is
- 12:02experiencing the very real pain of jealousy when,
- 12:05like, I see a classmate land a prestigious internship?
- 12:08If I'm not me, who is hurting? Right, that's
- 12:11the big question. The literature says the pain
- 12:13you feel is just a localized alarm bell triggered
- 12:16by the status monitoring module. It feels all
- 12:18-consuming because the PR module broadcasts it
- 12:21to the rest of the brain to force you into action.
- 12:24And Buddhism aligns perfectly with this modular
- 12:26view. Yeah, exactly. The Buddha taught that when
- 12:29you break down human experience, you cannot find
- 12:31a permanent self and physical form in sensations
- 12:34or in consciousness. The suffering of jealousy
- 12:37only happens because you mistakenly believe that
- 12:40the PR module's alarm bell is your core identity.
- 12:43You basically attack your entire existence to
- 12:46a temporary algorithmic output. Which is terrifying,
- 12:49but also kind of freeing. Grasping at circumstances
- 12:51to satisfy an illusory ego is just a recipe for
- 12:54psychological distress. And nothing illustrates
- 12:57the absurdity of the comparing mind better than
- 12:59the 1992 Olympic medal study. Oh, I love this
- 13:02study. Researchers analyzed the facial expressions
- 13:04of athletes on the podium. And they found that
- 13:06bronze medal winners were objectively happier,
- 13:09like smiling more genuinely, than the silver
- 13:12medal winners. Which is crazy because silver
- 13:14is a higher achievement. It requires more skill
- 13:17and beats more competitors. But the PR module
- 13:19doesn't care about objective achievement. It
- 13:21only cares about reference points. The silver
- 13:24winner's comparing mind is locked into upward
- 13:27comparison. Right. They're looking at the gold
- 13:29medalist thinking, I just missed it. I am the
- 13:32first loser. Their brain is synthesizing misery.
- 13:36While the bronze winner is locked into downward
- 13:38comparison, they're looking at the person in
- 13:40fourth place thinking, I almost didn't make the
- 13:43podium at all. I survived. The exact same objective
- 13:46environment produces two entirely different chemical
- 13:49realities based purely on where the comparing
- 13:52mind focuses. On an Olympic podium, that is a
- 13:55fascinating quirk of psychology. But in the modern
- 13:57world, it is a literal public health crisis.
- 14:00Yeah, because the comparing mind evolved to monitor
- 14:03status within a tribe of maybe 50 to 100 people.
- 14:07Today, technology forces that same PR module
- 14:09to compare your life against the curated, digitally
- 14:12altered highlights of 8 billion people. The reading
- 14:16cites a devastating statistic on this. There
- 14:18was a 189 % increase in hospital admissions for
- 14:21non -fatal self -harm among 10 to 14 -year -old
- 14:24girls between 2001 and 2015. A 189 % increase?
- 14:28That is... That's just heartbreaking. It is.
- 14:31Our evolutionary hardware is simply not equipped
- 14:33to process global upward comparison. The PR module
- 14:36is constantly screaming that our status is critically
- 14:39low, leading to immense manufactured suffering.
- 14:41Which really... forces us to ask, if grasping
- 14:45to satisfy the PR module ruins our well -being,
- 14:48how do we desire wisely? Because we can't just
- 14:50stop wanting things. We still need to eat and
- 14:53work and function in society. Right. And the
- 14:55framework for healthy desire is called Knative
- 14:57Balance. It entails holding intentions and setting
- 15:00goals that are actively conducive to your own
- 15:02well -being and the well -being of others. Basically,
- 15:05healthy goal setting with a conscience. Exactly.
- 15:07It mirrors the Buddhist concept of the Middle
- 15:09Way. You avoid the extreme of completely selfish
- 15:12indulgence, but you also avoid the extreme of
- 15:14total self deprivation. So you are allowed to
- 15:17want a successful career, provided the pursuit
- 15:19of that career doesn't require you to destroy
- 15:21your health or, you know, exploit the people
- 15:23around you. Yeah. Martin Seligman, one of the
- 15:26founders of positive psychology, mapped out how
- 15:28to achieve this through the PERMA model of flourishing.
- 15:32Positive emotions, engagement, relationships,
- 15:36meaning, and accomplishment. When you pursue
- 15:38goals across all those domains, you achieve co
- 15:41-native balance. And what's wild is that Buddhism
- 15:44maps onto those exact same domains, but it introduces
- 15:47a crucial hierarchy. The Dalai Lama argues that
- 15:50while wealth and worldly accomplishments play
- 15:52a role, the ultimate non -negotiable driver of
- 15:55happiness is the morality of compassion. And
- 15:58Sandra Lubomirski's meta -analysis empirically
- 16:01proves him right. Her data shows that intentional
- 16:03acts of kindness are among the most powerful
- 16:05interventions for sustainably boosting that 40
- 16:08% slice of subjective well -being. Which is entirely
- 16:10counterintuitive to the PR module. I mean, giving
- 16:13away resources, time, or energy should theoretically
- 16:16lower your status. Right. But practicing compassion
- 16:19bypasses the comparing mind entirely. When you
- 16:22focus on alleviating someone else's suffering,
- 16:25you forcibly shut down the module that constantly
- 16:27monitors your own perceived inadequacies. It's
- 16:30amazing. And we can actually see what happens
- 16:32when a society tries to legislate Knative balance.
- 16:35Oh, the Bhutan case study? Yes. The country of
- 16:39Bhutan practices a derivative of Tibetan Buddhism.
- 16:42In 2008, they did something radical. They embedded
- 16:45gross national happiness into their constitution
- 16:48as their primary metric of success, actively
- 16:51deprioritizing gross domestic product. They essentially
- 16:53built a government designed to avoid the hedonic
- 16:56treadmill. Totally. They measured psychological
- 16:58well -being, ecological diversity, and community
- 17:01vitality. To protect that balance, they spent
- 17:03decades intentionally delaying the introduction
- 17:06of cars, television, and widespread internet
- 17:08access. Because they knew that introducing those
- 17:10technologies would instantly activate the population's
- 17:13comparing mind. Exactly. They prioritized their
- 17:16connection to nature and community over pure
- 17:19materialistic gain. But it is a precarious experiment.
- 17:23The reading notes that younger generations in
- 17:25Bhutan are now demanding access to cable TV,
- 17:28smartphones, and global fashion trends. The biological
- 17:31pull of the PR module is just relentless. They
- 17:34are currently testing whether a foundation of
- 17:37co -native balance can withstand the psychological
- 17:39malware of global social media. So why does compassion
- 17:43work so universally? Whether it's in a psychology
- 17:46lab or a Himalayan kingdom, why does shifting
- 17:48focus away from the self heal the self. It comes
- 17:51down to a concept called interbeing. Right. Interbeing
- 17:54is the view that the entire universe arises from
- 17:57a single interconnected source. The PR module
- 18:00desperately wants you to believe you are an isolated
- 18:02independent entity fighting against the world.
- 18:04Interbeing argues that independence is a biological
- 18:07fiction. We are all familiar with the standard
- 18:09golden rule, right? Do unto others as you would
- 18:11have them do unto you. It is very transactional,
- 18:14but the Buddhist translation viewed through the
- 18:17lens of interbeing is structural. As you do unto
- 18:20others, you are doing unto yourself. Because
- 18:23there is no separate self to protect. It's like
- 18:26a giant ecological web, but applied to human
- 18:29empathy. Yes. The Vietnamese monk Thich Nhat
- 18:32Hanh uses an incredibly eloquent analogy to explain
- 18:35this. He says if you look deeply at a flower,
- 18:38you do not just see a flower. You see the clouds.
- 18:41Because without the rain, the flower could not
- 18:44exist. You see the soil, the sun, the mineral.
- 18:47Exactly. The flower is made entirely of non -flower
- 18:49elements. It inter -is with the rest of the universe.
- 18:52If you destroy the clouds, you destroy the flower.
- 18:55You can apply the exact same logic to your breakfast.
- 18:57Like, when you pour a glass of milk and eat a
- 18:59chocolate chip cookie, you aren't just consuming
- 19:01a product. Right. To understand reality, you
- 19:03have to acknowledge the grass the cow ate. You
- 19:06have to acknowledge the farmer who woke up at
- 19:08dawn. You have to recognize the worms that aerated
- 19:10the soil so the grass could grow. If you harbor
- 19:13anger toward the farmer or disregard the health
- 19:16of the soil, you are actively poisoning your
- 19:19own ability to enjoy the milk. When you view
- 19:21the world through the lens of interbeing, the
- 19:24strict barriers between you and them dissolve.
- 19:27Empathy isn't a moral sacrifice or a chore. It
- 19:29is an act of pure self -preservation. When you
- 19:32fully understand that harming another person
- 19:35structurally harms your own environment, compassion
- 19:37becomes the only logical response. And returning
- 19:40to the empirical data, that compassion is the
- 19:43engine driving the 40 % of happiness we actually
- 19:45control. So let's synthesize the ultimate study
- 19:48guide for you, our third partner in this session.
- 19:51First, stop obsessing over the 10%. Your circumstances
- 19:54do not define your psychological baseline. Second,
- 19:57recognize the level scaling algorithm of the
- 19:59hedonic treadmill. Earning the rare armor won't
- 20:02make the game easier, so stop sacrificing your
- 20:04peace of mind to get it. Third, rely on your
- 20:07psychological immune system. When you fail, trust
- 20:11that your brain will recalculate the route and
- 20:13synthesize genuine happiness. Avoid the upward
- 20:16comparison traps that sabotage that system. Remember
- 20:19the bronze medalist, your reference point dictates
- 20:22your reality. Finally, realize that practicing
- 20:25compassion isn't just a religious platitude.
- 20:28It is scientifically proven, data -backed cognitive
- 20:32maintenance. Before we wrap up, we want to leave
- 20:34you with one final provocative thought regarding
- 20:37the modularity of the mind. Based on everything
- 20:39we discuss, the next time you feel a sudden,
- 20:42intense surge of anger or jealousy or self -righteousness,
- 20:45force yourself to pause. Ask yourself, who exactly
- 20:48is feeling this? Is it the real you, or is it
- 20:51just an outdated evolutionary PR module ringing
- 20:53a false alarm, trying to trick you into fighting
- 20:55a threat that doesn't actually exist? Identifying
- 20:57the algorithm is the first step to breaking the
- 20:59cycle. Until next time, keep studying, guard
- 21:02your co -native balance, and remember that when
- 21:04the data gets murky, compassion clears it up.
- 21:07See you at the next Deep Dive session.