Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / The Rational Light of Value Investing
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. We have an absolutely massive
- 0:03one for you today. We are looking at money, but you
- 0:06know, not just looking at the charts.
- 0:08We're looking at money through the lens of physics, the lens of
- 0:11survival, and honestly through the lens of how to live a good
- 0:14life. But before we get into all the
- 0:16heavy philosophy and the hard numbers, we actually have a tool
- 0:20to share with you right off the bat.
- 0:22We do, and it's a really useful one.
- 0:23If you're trying to navigate these choppy waters, you really
- 0:26need a compass to track total market temperature.
- 0:29Welcome to search and download the iOS App Buffett Indicator
- 0:32from the Apple App Store. And for our global listeners who
- 0:36might want to get that in its native language?
- 0:39Apple Store Sources E Alishida Apple Store EEEE.
- 0:44OK, let's unpack this. Today isn't just another How to
- 0:47pick stock show. Not at all.
- 0:49We are diving into a transcript of a conversation that, frankly,
- 0:53it kind of blew my mind a little bit.
- 0:55It's between the economist Wang Kin Yu and a man named Chong
- 0:58Jing. And Chang Jing is a name you
- 1:01might not see in the headlines every day, but in the world of
- 1:05high stakes capital allocation, he is a very serious player.
- 1:09He's a core partner at Himalaya Capital.
- 1:11And for context, Himalaya Capital was founded by Lelu.
- 1:14Right, Lelu is. I mean, he's legendary.
- 1:17He's widely considered the primary inheritor of the Charlie
- 1:20Monger and Warren Buffett philosophy, especially in the
- 1:23Asian markets. Wow.
- 1:24I mean, think about it, he's the only person Charlie Monger ever
- 1:27gave his own family money to invest.
- 1:29So when Chang Jing speaks, he's speaking from that, you know,
- 1:33that direct lineage. That's some serious validation.
- 1:35It is, but what makes Chang so fascinating is that he isn't
- 1:38your typical finance bro. He didn't come up just crunching
- 1:41Excel sheets. No, his background is in
- 1:43atmospheric physics. Exactly.
- 1:45Which I mean, that sounds like he should be predicting
- 1:47hurricanes, not market crashes. But I think as we go through
- 1:50this, we're going to see that those two things are actually
- 1:52pretty similar. They're both complex, chaotic
- 1:55systems, but Chang is incredibly modest about it.
- 1:58All throughout the source material, he keeps referring to
- 2:01himself as merely an assistant to Lelu.
- 2:04An assistant, yeah. But the insights he drops here,
- 2:07they bridge the gap between hard science, gritty
- 2:10entrepreneurship, who's a salesman, which we have to get
- 2:13to, and, you know, managing billions of dollars.
- 2:15So the mission for this deep dive is really specific.
- 2:18We want to deconstruct the gap between knowing something and
- 2:21actually doing it because, and I think you'll agree with me here,
- 2:24the concepts of value investing are, well, they're simple.
- 2:26Oh, they're deceptively simple. I mean, buy low, sell high, keep
- 2:31a margin of safety, don't lose money, right?
- 2:32You can teach a 10 year old the rules of value investing in an
- 2:35afternoon. But actually doing.
- 2:37Them doing them when the market is melting down or when you know
- 2:40everyone around you is getting rich on some bubble, that is
- 2:42excruciatingly hard. It really requires a rewiring of
- 2:46your entire psychology, and that is what Changing focuses on.
- 2:50So let's jump right into that, into the core philosophy.
- 2:53He starts with a word that we teach toddlers, but he applies
- 2:56it to hedge funds. Honesty.
- 2:59But he's not talking about, you know, don't tell a lie.
- 3:02He's talking about intellectual honesty.
- 3:04It is a rigorous, almost painful standard.
- 3:08And he uses this analogy that I think perfectly captures the
- 3:11human condition. Which one is that?
- 3:13The penny versus the $1,000,000 test.
- 3:14OK, I want to dig into this because on the surface it sounds
- 3:17simple, but walk me through the psychology here.
- 3:19OK, so imagine you're walking down the street.
- 3:21It's broad daylight. You see a penny on the sidewalk,
- 3:24or hey, maybe it's a $10.00 bill.
- 3:26What do you do? I mean, if it's a penny, I'll
- 3:28probably just leave it. If it's 10 bucks, I might look
- 3:30around, you know, ask did anyone drop this?
- 3:32It's low stakes. I'm a good citizen.
- 3:34Exactly. Most people are honest when the
- 3:36stakes are low and the social pressure is high, But Chang
- 3:39flips the script. He asks, what if you're walking
- 3:42down a dark alley in the middle of the night?
- 3:44OK, no security cameras, no witnesses, and you stumble upon
- 3:48a black bag filled with $1,000,000 in cash.
- 3:51That is a very different scenario.
- 3:53The test is do you take it? And more importantly, if you
- 3:57take it, do you admit to yourself why you took it?
- 4:00Well, I mean, obviously taking it as theft, but in the
- 4:03investing world finding a bag of money isn't a crime.
- 4:06So how does this apply to buying stocks?
- 4:08This is the crucial link in the market.
- 4:10That dark alley is complexity, and the bag of money is a hot
- 4:14stock or a trend that you don't actually understand but it's
- 4:17making everyone else rich. OK.
- 4:20Let's say there's a new crypto token or an AI startup that has,
- 4:23I don't know, tripled in value in a week.
- 4:25Right. And I'm looking at it and I'm
- 4:26thinking I need to get in on this.
- 4:28I've got that FOMO. The temptation is to grab that
- 4:30bag of money. But here is where the dishonesty
- 4:32kicks. You don't just grab and say I'm
- 4:35gambling. Your brain creates A narrative
- 4:37to protect your ego. You tell yourself, oh, I've read
- 4:40a few articles about blockchain. I get it.
- 4:41I understand the paradigm shift. I'm investing based on
- 4:44fundamentals. So I'm lying to myself to
- 4:46justify the greed. Precisely.
- 4:48You are convincing yourself that you found the money because
- 4:51you're smart, not because you were lucky or just reckless.
- 4:55Chang argues that this lack of intellectual honesty, this
- 4:59inability to just say I don't know when the money's on the
- 5:01table, is the number one killer of wealth.
- 5:05Because eventually the owner of that bag comes looking for it.
- 5:08Or, in market terms, reality catches up.
- 5:11If you bought something because you pretended to know the
- 5:13future, but you're actually just guessing, Mr. Market will
- 5:16eventually find the flaw in your logic.
- 5:19And when the bubble bursts because you didn't actually
- 5:21understand what you bought, you won't know when to sell.
- 5:25You'll be left holding the bag when it's empty.
- 5:27So I don't know, isn't just modesty, it's actually a
- 5:29survival shield. It is the highest form of risk
- 5:31management, you know. Chang talks about his early days
- 5:33as a management consultant. He was young, fresh out of
- 5:35school, but he was charging these huge fees to tell veteran
- 5:38CE OS how to run their businesses.
- 5:40He admits he had to pretend to know things in consulting.
- 5:44You can kind of get away with that.
- 5:45You make a PowerPoint, you get paid, you leave.
- 5:48Fake it till you make. It but in investing, the
- 5:50feedback loop is brutal and absolute.
- 5:53If you fake it, you lose your capital.
- 5:55The market does not care about your PowerPoint presentation.
- 5:57This bleeds right into the next pillar, which is the safety
- 6:01margin. Now I've heard this term 1000
- 6:03times margin of safety. It's usually described as buying
- 6:06a dollar for $0.50. And that's the financial
- 6:09definition. But Chang, he expands it into a
- 6:11life philosophy. He uses this great analogy about
- 6:14getting to class or a meeting. The 9.0 AM rule.
- 6:17Right. If you have a class at 9:00 AM,
- 6:20do you plan to arrive exactly at 90?
- 6:22Well, if I'm being official, I plan for 900.
- 6:25Why waste time sitting in the hallway?
- 6:26But that efficiency is fragile. If you plan for 900 and you hit
- 6:30one unexpected red light, or you can't find your keys, or the
- 6:33elevator is slow, you're late, you fail, the whole system
- 6:36breaks. So Chang suggests aiming for
- 6:388.50. Aim for 850.
- 6:40Build in a buffer, A cushion. Now apply this to a business.
- 6:43Many modern businesses are obsessed with optimization.
- 6:47Oh yeah, lean manufacturing. Just in time.
- 6:50Just in time, supply chains maxed out leverage running at
- 6:53100% capacity to squeeze out the highest possible profit margin.
- 6:57That sounds like good management.
- 6:58Though it sounds like it until something goes wrong.
- 7:01If a business needs perfect execution just to be profitable,
- 7:05it has no safety margin, Chang says.
- 7:08True value lies in a business that can have a screw up.
- 7:12OK, it can have a factory fire a bad product, launch a recession
- 7:15and still survive. It's like engineering a bridge.
- 7:18You don't build a bridge to hold exactly the weight of the cars
- 7:20you expect, you build it to hold five times the weight exactly.
- 7:24But here is the catch, and This is why it's so hard.
- 7:26Psychologically, aiming for 8.50 feels inefficient.
- 7:29Building a stronger bridge cost more money.
- 7:31And in finance, holding cash, which is the ultimate safety
- 7:34margin, feels like losing. Right.
- 7:37If I'm holding 20% of My Portfolio and cash to be safe
- 7:39and the market goes up 20%, I feel like an idiot.
- 7:42I missed out. I left money on the table.
- 7:44That is the pain of the safety margin.
- 7:46You have to be willing to look stupid and feel inefficient in
- 7:49the short term to ensure you survive the long term, Chang
- 7:52says. If you can do 100% percent
- 7:54effort, promise 80% leave room for the unexpected.
- 7:57That gap isn't waste, it's your Peace of Mind.
- 8:01I love that the inefficiency is the price of survival, but let's
- 8:04you know, let's play devil's advocate.
- 8:06Chang talks about speculation versus investing.
- 8:09He admits you can make money speculating.
- 8:11He does. He's not dogmatic about it.
- 8:12He brings up James Simons of Renaissance Technologies.
- 8:15The Quant King. The man who cracked the code.
- 8:17The Quant King Simons and his team used massive computing
- 8:20power and you know these complex algorithms to speculate on short
- 8:23term in price movements in me billions.
- 8:25Chang acknowledges this. He says yes, speculation works
- 8:29if you are James Simons. But I am not James Simons.
- 8:32And neither are 99.99% of professional fund managers.
- 8:35Chang's point is that speculation is a 0 sum game.
- 8:38It's a poker table. For you to win a dollar, someone
- 8:40else has to lose a dollar. And if you're sitting at the
- 8:42table with Renaissance technologies?
- 8:43You're the Paddy, you're the leak, the jukai, the sucker
- 8:46waiting to be harvested. Chang argues that unless you
- 8:49have a supernatural talent for math and better data than
- 8:52everyone else, speculation is just a slow way to give your
- 8:55money to people like James Simons.
- 8:57Whereas value investing is positive sum.
- 8:59Is that the idea? That's the argument.
- 9:01If you buy a piece of a company that actually creates value,
- 9:04makes cars, sells food, provides healthcare, and that company
- 9:08grows, the pie gets bigger. You win.
- 9:10The employees win, the customers win.
- 9:12You aren't winning because someone else lost, you're
- 9:15winning because the world got richer.
- 9:16OK, so if we accept that we need to be honest, we need a buffer
- 9:20and we shouldn't gamble, how do we actually pick the winners?
- 9:23Chang gives us a framework, a sort of matrix for evaluation.
- 9:26He breaks it down into strategic, financial and
- 9:29operational layers. The financial stuff is what
- 9:31you'd expect, high return on equity or Roe, strong cash flow,
- 9:35low debt. He specifically looks for
- 9:37companies that distribute more dividends than they raise in
- 9:40capital. A cash cow, not a cash
- 9:41incinerator. You got it.
- 9:43But the part that I found most interesting and honestly the
- 9:46most fun is the subjective stuff.
- 9:48He calls it the restroom test. OK, I have to stop you there.
- 9:52This sounds like investor folklore.
- 9:54Are you seriously telling me that a multi billion dollar
- 9:57investment decision hinges on whether the janitor cleaned the
- 10:01stalls that morning? I mean, isn't that a bit
- 10:05trivial? It sounds trivial, doesn't it?
- 10:07It sounds like something a quirky uncle would say at
- 10:08Thanksgiving, but Chang insists it's a rigorous data point.
- 10:12Think about entropy. Disorder.
- 10:14Things falling apart. The natural state of the
- 10:16universe is disorder. Things fall apart.
- 10:18Dust collects, systems breakdown.
- 10:21To keep a factory restroom clean, I mean really clean, in a
- 10:24facility with 5000 workers, requires A relentless, almost
- 10:28obsessive system of management discipline.
- 10:30So it's not about the toilet, it's about the discipline.
- 10:32It's entirely about the discipline, Chang says.
- 10:34When you visit a company, you can feel the key field, the
- 10:36atmosphere. Look at the workers.
- 10:38Are they focused? Are they relaxed?
- 10:40Are they stressed and chaotic? And then check the restroom.
- 10:43If the lobby is all marble and gold to impress the investors,
- 10:46but the employee restroom is filthy, it tells you something
- 10:49very profound about the culture. It tells you they cut corners
- 10:52when they think no one is looking.
- 10:53And if they cut corners on hygiene, Chang argues they will
- 10:56eventually cut corners on product quality or safety
- 10:59standards, or, worst of all, financial reporting.
- 11:02That connects right back to the penny versus $1,000,000 thing.
- 11:05It's about character. It is.
- 11:07He quotes Duong Young Ping, another investing giant, who
- 11:10says a company can make strategic mistakes, but it can't
- 11:13make mistakes on quality or culture.
- 11:16You can fix a bad marketing campaign.
- 11:18You can't fix a rotten culture. The next time I visit a
- 11:21headquarters, I'm skipping the boardroom and going straight to
- 11:23the stalls. It might be the most valuable
- 11:25due diligence you do. But beyond the bathrooms,
- 11:27there's this concept of the circle of competence.
- 11:30We hear this all the time. Stay in your circle.
- 11:33But how do you know where the circle ends?
- 11:37I think most of us, our ego tells us our circle is bigger
- 11:39than it actually is. That is the Dunning Kruger
- 11:42effect in a nutshell. We all think we're experts.
- 11:45Chang gives 2 brutal tests to see if you were actually in your
- 11:49circle. The 1st is what he calls the
- 11:50conversation test. OK, how does that work?
- 11:53He asks, can you talk to an industry expert, a real veteran
- 11:57in the field, and tell them something they didn't know?
- 12:01Or can you point out a blind spot in their thinking?
- 12:04That is a wildly high bar. I mean, if I'm talking to the
- 12:07CEO of a biotech company, I'm usually just nodding and trying
- 12:10to understand the big words they're using.
- 12:12If you're just nodding, you're not in your circle, you're a
- 12:14tourist. But if you can say actually
- 12:17looking at the phase two data from your competitor in Germany,
- 12:19their efficacy rate suggests your target market might be
- 12:22smaller than you think. And the CEO pauses and says, I
- 12:25didn't consider that. Then you're in the circle.
- 12:27OK. That rules out about 99% of the
- 12:29stocks I've ever looked at. What's the second test?
- 12:31The ownership test. This goes back to the difference
- 12:33between, say, renting a stock and owning a business.
- 12:36If you own a restaurant, what do you worry about?
- 12:38I worry about the price of tomatoes, I worry if the chef is
- 12:41happy, I worry if customers are coming back on Tuesday nights.
- 12:45Right. Do you worry about what someone
- 12:46is willing to pay for your restaurant every 10 seconds?
- 12:49No, of course not. I'm not trying to sell it every
- 12:5110 seconds. Chan says if you find yourself
- 12:53obsessing over the stock ticker, Oh no, it's down 2% today.
- 12:56Oh wait, it's up 3%, you don't understand the business.
- 13:00You're treating it like a gambling chip.
- 13:02If you truly understand the value, the price fluctuation is
- 13:05either irrelevant noise or even better, an opportunity.
- 13:08He gave a great example of this true understanding involving
- 13:12Apple and this this answers a question we got from a lot of
- 13:15listeners regarding Duong Yongping.
- 13:17Yes, the large screen prediction.
- 13:19Right. Years ago, Apple refused to make
- 13:22big phones. Steve Jobs famously said no one
- 13:24wants a big phone, you can't reach the corner with your
- 13:26thumb. But Duong Yongping was buying
- 13:29Apple aggressively, predicting they would make a big phone.
- 13:32That he was right. But the question is why was he
- 13:34right? He wasn't an insider.
- 13:36He didn't have a spy in Cupertino.
- 13:38He just understood the consumer. He knew that people were using
- 13:41phones for video and games, not just calling.
- 13:44He knew the demand for more screen real estate was
- 13:46irresistible. So he understood the business
- 13:48logic better than the management did at the time.
- 13:50Exactly. He knew that Apple was, at its
- 13:53core, a rational company, and eventually rationality would win
- 13:57out over dogma. That is deep competence.
- 14:01He wasn't betting on a rumor. He was betting on human nature
- 14:04and fundamental business logic. So let's say we do all this
- 14:07work. We check the bathrooms, we pass
- 14:08the conversation test, we buy the stock, and then the market
- 14:12crashes. Everything goes down.
- 14:14Which brings us to the hardest part of the equation, handling
- 14:17volatility. Chang talks about this in the
- 14:19context of opportunity cost, which he notes is a concept
- 14:22Chinese investors often ignore. It's a fascinating cultural
- 14:25observation he makes, he says. In fast growing markets like
- 14:28China, historically, people just looked at absolute return.
- 14:31You know, I put in 100, I got back 120.
- 14:33I won. Seems logical.
- 14:34But Sophisticated Capital asks a different question.
- 14:37What else could I have done with that 100?
- 14:39Right. If the market index went up 40%
- 14:41and you only made 20%, you actually lost.
- 14:43Exactly. You destroyed value relative to
- 14:45the passive opportunity. For a fund manager, their
- 14:48opportunity cost is the benchmark index, like the S&P
- 14:51500. If you can't beat the index over
- 14:53time, you shouldn't exist. You should just give the money
- 14:55back. This concept perfectly explains
- 14:58the divergent we saw recently with Apple and BYD.
- 15:01Why did Warren Buffett sell some Apple while Duan Yongping kept
- 15:04it? And why did Buffett sell some
- 15:06BYD while Himalaya Capital, Chang's firm, held onto it?
- 15:09It's not that one guru is smart and the other is dumb.
- 15:12It's that their opportunity costs and their safety margins
- 15:15are different. Take Buffett.
- 15:16He's managing hundreds of billions.
- 15:18He has a massive cash pile. When Apple's valuation got sky
- 15:22high, his safety margin shrank. For him, moving that money into
- 15:26Treasury bills earning 5% risk free might have been a better
- 15:29risk adjusted bet than holding an expensive stock.
- 15:32He has a different menu of options than the rest of us do.
- 15:34Exactly. But let's look at Himalaya and
- 15:36BYD. This is the case study that
- 15:38really blew me away. We need to spend a minute here
- 15:41because it captures the sheer agony and the conviction
- 15:44required for value investing. OK, so they bought BYD in 2002.
- 15:482002, before EVs were cool, before Tesla was a household
- 15:51name. And since 2002, Chang notes that
- 15:53BYD stock price has dropped by more than 50%.
- 15:56Wow. Six separate times?
- 15:586 times. Not 1-6 separate.
- 16:02Times you just sit with that for a second.
- 16:03Imagine you put $1,000,000 into BYD.
- 16:06It goes up, you feel like a genius.
- 16:08Then it crashes to $500,000. You feel sick, you hold, it goes
- 16:11back up, then it crashes again. Most investors, even
- 16:14professional fund managers, would vomit and sell after the
- 16:17second drop. They'd say this is too volatile,
- 16:18I can't take it, my clients will fire.
- 16:20Me. So why did Himalaya hold?
- 16:21I mean, are they masochists? No, they were looking at the
- 16:24business, not the ticker. Chang mentions a specific
- 16:26crisis. He calls it the dealer revolt.
- 16:28What happened there? At one point BYD pushed their
- 16:31sales targets way too hard. The dealership network just
- 16:33collapsed. Dealers were quitting, suing.
- 16:36It was a total mess. Sales tanked.
- 16:38The stock tanked with it. The narrative in the media was
- 16:41BYD is done. That sounds like a perfectly
- 16:44valid reason to sell. The business is failing.
- 16:47It does. But Himalaya watched the
- 16:49management. They asked the crucial question,
- 16:51are they in denial? And the answer was no.
- 16:54The management admitted the mistake.
- 16:56They spent three painful years fixing the dealer network,
- 16:59apologizing, restructuring. They show they could learn from
- 17:01their mistakes and solve huge problems.
- 17:03So the volatility was a stress test of their character and
- 17:06competence. Precisely, Chang says if a
- 17:09company can make a catastrophic mistake, fix it and come out
- 17:12stronger on the other side, that is the ultimate buy signal.
- 17:15But you only see that if you have the iron stomach to ignore
- 17:18the stock price falling 50% while they're in the middle of
- 17:20fixing it. That is the difference between
- 17:21renting a stock and owning a business.
- 17:23If your house has a leak, you fix the leak.
- 17:26You don't sell the whole house for half price.
- 17:28Exactly. But sometimes, and this is
- 17:31crucial, a drop is just a drop. Sometimes the house is termite
- 17:35infested and it is going to collapse.
- 17:38Chang shared a story about a value trap.
- 17:40That I think is really important.
- 17:41We don't hear investors talk about their losses enough.
- 17:44This was the failure story to show they're not perfect.
- 17:47Yes, they invested in a company that looked perfect on paper.
- 17:50Low PE ratio, profitable, simple business model.
- 17:53It was statistically cheap. So what went wrong?
- 17:56What did they miss? They missed the governance risk.
- 17:59The major shareholder, the guy running the show, was a crook.
- 18:02Not technically, maybe, but ethically he was using the
- 18:05company's cash to do merger and acquisition deals.
- 18:08You'd buy other companies that inflated prices.
- 18:10Let me guess, he was buying companies that he secretly owned
- 18:14or his family owned. Or that his friends owned he was
- 18:17siphoning the shareholders money into his own pockets through
- 18:20these crooked M&A deals? That is straight up theft
- 18:23disguised as corporate strategy. It is, and Chang admits they
- 18:26missed it because they were looking at the cheap stock price
- 18:27and got greedy. They didn't scrutinize the
- 18:29character of the owner enough. The lesson being cheapness is
- 18:32not a safety margin if your partner is dishonest.
- 18:35Exactly. A cheap price cannot compensate
- 18:37for bad character if the management doesn't have a
- 18:40fiduciary duty mindset. If they don't treat the
- 18:43company's money like it's your money, you're just the Turkey at
- 18:45their Thanksgiving dinner. OK, I want to pivot.
- 18:48We've talked history, we've talked philosophy.
- 18:50Let's talk about right now. You cannot have a conversation
- 18:53like this in 2026 without talking about AI.
- 18:56The artificial intelligence revolution, it's the only thing
- 18:59anyone is talking about. Chang compares it to the
- 19:02Industrial Revolution. You know, steam engines replace
- 19:04muscle, AI replaces brainpower. He thinks it's inevitable.
- 19:08He does. He's a believer in the
- 19:10technology, however, he is terrified of the current stock
- 19:14valuations. He used an analogy that I think
- 19:16every listener needs to hear, especially if they are holding
- 19:19NVIDIA or these massive chip stocks.
- 19:21He called it the Solar Peckle analogy.
- 19:23This is a warning about what he calls technological deflation.
- 19:27Break that. Down.
- 19:27What does that mean? OK, think back to say 2010.
- 19:31Solar energy was the future. Everyone knew it, and they were
- 19:33right. Solar is everywhere now.
- 19:35It's cheap. It's efficient.
- 19:37The technology won. So the investors must have
- 19:39gotten rich. No, most of the solar
- 19:41manufacturing investors got wiped out, annihilated.
- 19:44How is that possible? If the technology won, why did
- 19:47the investors? Lose because the technology
- 19:49improved too fast. If you build a solar panel
- 19:52factory in 2010, you spent say $100 million on equipment and
- 19:57your panels cost $2.00 per Watt to make.
- 19:59OK, makes sense. But two years later, a new
- 20:02technology comes out. Now new panels only cost $1.00
- 20:04per Watt to make. Your factory is now off sleet.
- 20:07Your $100 million investment is worthless because you can't
- 20:10compete with the new guys who have the better tech.
- 20:12Your asset became a liability overnight.
- 20:14Exactly. It's CapEx destruction, capital
- 20:16expenditure destruction and Chang worries.
- 20:18This is exactly what's happening with AI right now.
- 20:20With the GPU chips. Right Companies are spending
- 20:23hundreds of billions of dollars buying H-100 chips right now, A
- 20:26massive gold rush. But NVIDIA is releasing a new
- 20:29chip every year that is two or three times faster and more
- 20:32efficient. So if I spend a billion dollars
- 20:34on chips today. In two years, those chips are
- 20:37basically junk. They're electronic waste because
- 20:40the electricity cost to run them is higher than the value they
- 20:43produce compared to the newer, more efficient chips.
- 20:46That is a terrifying thought. So all this investment we see on
- 20:50the balance sheets of big tech might actually be a future write
- 20:53off. It might be unless, and this is
- 20:56the key, unless they find a killer app right now that
- 20:59generates enough cash flow to pay for those chips before they
- 21:02become obsolete. And currently are they?
- 21:05Is there a killer app? Chang argues not really.
- 21:08Not yet. Right now it's a lot of BDB
- 21:10selling. One company sells chips to a
- 21:12cloud provider who sells compute power to a startup who uses the
- 21:15compute to well and mostly to make demos or chat bots that
- 21:18aren't making massive consumer profits yet.
- 21:20It's a game of hot potato with capital.
- 21:22He calls it a potential Ponzi game, not in the criminal sense,
- 21:25but in the structural sense. Money is circulating between all
- 21:28these infrastructure players, but there isn't enough real
- 21:31consumer revenue coming in at the bottom to justify the
- 21:35trillions in spending in a top. That is a very sobering reality
- 21:38check. Just because the technology
- 21:40changes the world doesn't mean the first movers make money.
- 21:43Railroads changed the world, but most railroad stocks went to 0.
- 21:46Exactly the same Let's. Zoom out even further.
- 21:48Macro Chang talks a lot about China, and let's be honest, the
- 21:52mood on the Chinese economy lately has been gloomy.
- 21:55Gloomy is putting it mildly. You hear about the real estate
- 21:58crisis, export slowdowns, youth unemployment.
- 22:01It sounds dire. But Chang takes a very
- 22:03contrarian, long term view. He's actually optimistic.
- 22:06Why? I mean, what is he seeing that
- 22:08everyone else is missing? He looks at the structural
- 22:09transition. He says China is moving from an
- 22:11investment and export LED economy to a service and
- 22:14consumption LED economy, and he explains why this is inevitable
- 22:18using a really smart observation about efficiency.
- 22:21The Robot versus the Doctor. Right.
- 22:23Think about manufacturing. What is the ultimate goal of a
- 22:26car factory? To make cars as fast and as
- 22:29cheap as possible with as few defects as possible.
- 22:31Exactly to increase efficiency. And how do you do that?
- 22:34You use robots. You remove humans.
- 22:37Manufacturing, by its very definition, tries to reduce the
- 22:40amount of Labor needed per unit of output.
- 22:42It destroys jobs to create goods.
- 22:44OK, I follow that. But the service industry, things
- 22:47like healthcare, elderly care, entertainment, education,
- 22:50design, it's different. The value is the human.
- 22:54You don't want a robot doctor to rush you out in 30 seconds.
- 22:57You don't want a highly efficient concert that lasts
- 22:59only 5 minutes. The value comes from the human
- 23:02time and the connection. Exactly so.
- 23:04Chang argues that the service industry is the only sector that
- 23:06can sustainably absorb the workforce and create real income
- 23:09growth. You can't robot your way to a
- 23:12thriving middle class. As China gets richer, the money
- 23:14must flow into services. So the transition we're seeing
- 23:16now is painful, but the destination is a high income
- 23:19service economy. That's his thesis.
- 23:21But to invest in China, you also have to understand the
- 23:23government, the policy cycles. Oh, the stroke of a pen risk.
- 23:28We've seen entire industries like for profit tutoring or
- 23:31Internet platforms get crushed overnight by a new regulation.
- 23:35Chang views this differently. He sees the market as a complex
- 23:39adaptive system. Remember, he's a physicist, he
- 23:41said. The government is just part of
- 23:43that system. It acts in cycles.
- 23:45When a sector overheats or causes social instability, the
- 23:49government intervenes. So it's a reaction, not a random
- 23:51attack. Right.
- 23:52And he views these crackdowns as stress tests.
- 23:55If a company like Tencent or New Oriental can get hit by a
- 23:58massive policy hammer, survive, adapt and come out the other
- 24:02side. They are anti fragile.
- 24:05They are buys. You price in the policy risk you
- 24:07don't run from. It exactly, which, you know,
- 24:09brings us back to his roots. To physics.
- 24:11I promise we'd get back to this life as an algorithm.
- 24:14Chang views the market as being much harder than weather
- 24:16prediction because clouds don't have emotions.
- 24:18A storm doesn't decide to change its path just because you bought
- 24:20an umbrella. Right, but the market does.
- 24:22If I buy a stock, my action changes the system, even if just
- 24:25a tiny bit. It's reflexive.
- 24:28The act of observation changes the outcome, so Chang uses the
- 24:31scientific method. Hypothesis, data test, revise.
- 24:36He says you must never ever assume a static state.
- 24:39And this leads to my favorite story in the whole transcript,
- 24:41the cold calling story, because it really humanizes him.
- 24:45He wasn't born a guru. No, not at all.
- 24:47He was a terrified 20 something in Silicon Valley back in the
- 24:5090s. He was trying to sell computer
- 24:52memory chips during a downturn. And he was introvert.
- 24:55I think anyone who has ever done sales knows that feeling.
- 24:57Just staring at the phone, dreading the rejection.
- 25:00He. Failed for two weeks straight. 0
- 25:04sales. He was about to quit but then
- 25:06the physicist brain kicked in. He realized I can't out talk
- 25:08these Americans. I'm not a schnoozer but I can
- 25:10out think. Them he went to the data.
- 25:12He built a database of all the potential clients.
- 25:14He categorized them, but more importantly, he went to the
- 25:16library. He read every computer magazine
- 25:18he could find, PC World Byte magazine.
- 25:20He memorized the specs of every motherboard and every new chip.
- 25:23He became a walking encyclopedia of computer hardware.
- 25:26So when he called a client, he didn't say please buy my chips.
- 25:30He said, hey, I see you're using this particular motherboard.
- 25:34Did you know that the memory chip you're ordering actually
- 25:36has a compatibility issue? You should be using this other
- 25:39one instead. He flipped the entire dynamic.
- 25:41He wasn't a beggar, he was a consultant.
- 25:43He was helping them. He was adding value and suddenly
- 25:46he wasn't selling, he was advising.
- 25:48He became the top salesman in the company.
- 25:50And that connects all the way back to the beginning.
- 25:52Honesty. Yes, he could have lied.
- 25:54He could have just pushed whatever product had the highest
- 25:56Commission. That would have been the
- 25:57$1,000,000 in the dark alley move.
- 25:58Exactly. But he chose the hard path, the
- 26:01path of competence and truth, and that is what built the trust
- 26:07that made him successful. So bringing this all home, yeah,
- 26:09why do this? Why stress about safety margins
- 26:12and dirty restrooms and dealer revolts?
- 26:15Chang says value investing is ultimately A framework for a
- 26:18happy life. A happy life.
- 26:20That's a big promise for a financial strategy.
- 26:22But think about the components we've discussed.
- 26:25If you are intellectually honest with yourself, you don't have to
- 26:28carry the weight of lies or imposter syndrome.
- 26:31If you have a safety margin in your life, you don't live in
- 26:33constant fear of the unexpected. You sleep well at night.
- 26:36You sleep well at night, and if you focus on your circle of
- 26:39competence, you do work that you actually understand and enjoy.
- 26:43You aren't chasing someone else's dream or getting swept up
- 26:46in a trend you don't believe in. And you weren't jealous of the
- 26:49speculator making fast money next to you because you
- 26:52understand the risks they're taking and you've chosen not to
- 26:54play that game. Chang concludes that wealth is
- 26:57just a byproduct. If you run this algorithm
- 27:00correctly. Honesty, safety, competence.
- 27:02The money tends to show up over time, but the real asset you
- 27:05gain is Peace of Mind. That is a beautiful place to
- 27:08land, from the gritty details of a factory floor to the algorithm
- 27:12of happiness. It really is a complete
- 27:13worldview. So to recap our journey today,
- 27:16we started with the penny versus the $1,000,000 test.
- 27:19The brutal need for intellectual honesty.
- 27:22We looked at the safety margin not just as a number, but as the
- 27:25willingness to be inefficient to survive.
- 27:28We did the restroom test for culture.
- 27:30We analyzed the gut wrenching volatility of BYD and the
- 27:32potential solar panel trap of the current AI bubble.
- 27:36And finally, we saw how a terrified physicist use data and
- 27:40honesty to become a master salesman and ultimately a master
- 27:43investor. It's a master class.
- 27:45So before we sign off, what is the final provocative thought
- 27:48for our listeners to take away? Well, connecting this to the
- 27:51bigger picture, Chang mentioned a profound idea.
- 27:54Knowledge is knowing what you know.
- 27:56Wisdom is knowing what you don't know, right?
- 27:58We live in the age of AI. Information is infinite.
- 28:01Chat JPT can give you an answer to anything in seconds.
- 28:04In a world where answers are cheap and abundant, perhaps the
- 28:07ultimate competitive advantage for you, the listener, is simply
- 28:10being the person who can stand up and say, I don't know.
- 28:13Because I don't know is the start of real inquiry.
- 28:15It's the beginning of wisdom. Exactly.
- 28:17I don't know keeps you safe from the bubble.
- 28:19I don't know makes you curious. And I don't know allows you to
- 28:23wait patiently for the fat pitch, the opportunity that is
- 28:26so obvious, so clearly in your circle of confidence.
- 28:29You don't need to guess. In an algorithmic world,
- 28:32humility might be the ultimate algorithm.
- 28:34That is definitely something to chew on.
- 28:36All right. Before we go, we need to handle
- 28:38the official business. Indeed.
- 28:40Disclaimer All analysis is based on publicly available sources
- 28:44and may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 28:47The content is for educational purposes only and does not
- 28:50constitute investment device. Conduct your own due diligence
- 28:53before making investment decisions.
- 28:55And for those of you who want to go even deeper with us on topics
- 28:57like this. If you want to listen our full
- 28:59Deep Drive about this topic or access more advanced contents,
- 29:02welcome to join the Deep Value Club membership or subscribe to
- 29:06us on Apple and Spotify, Podcasts Channel, Deep Value
- 29:09Investing and luluvc.com. And for our bilingual friends
- 29:12out there, yeah. One.
- 29:14Yeah, sure. One Shocking Susiana.
- 29:17Any long flop? She keeps.
- 29:19You you born She wants 1. Xiao Shinji Shinzo Wang Wang
- 29:35then Sen Siao Wang Wang Board Sen.
- 29:38Pasan Board Tu Chuan Sen Sen Sen Sen Sen Sen Sen Sen Sen Sen
- 29:56since since since since since since since since since since
- 29:58since since since since since since since since since since
- 30:00since since since since since since since since since since
- 30:03since since since since since since since since since since
- 30:05since since since since since since since since since since
- 30:06since since since since since since since since since since
- 30:08since since since since since since since since since since
- 30:10since since since since since since since since since since
- 30:12since since since since since since since since since since
- 30:15since since since since since since since since since since
- 30:17since since since since since since since since since since
- 30:19since since since since since since since since since since
- 30:21since since since since since since since since since since
- 30:22since since since since since since since since since since
- 30:24since since since since since since.
- 30:25Since. Well, I suppose this, this,
- 30:31this, this, this, this, this, this, this, this, this, this,
- 30:44this, this, this, this, this, this.