Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Spousal Support Modification and Establishing Arrears: Documentation, Enforcement and Remedies
Transcript
- 0:03All right. Good afternoon. I'm Jack McMorrow.
- 0:06I am co -chair of the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 0:10Family Law Section. Thank you for joining us
- 0:12today. The Family Law Section is sponsored by
- 0:16White Zuckerman, Worzowski, Luna, Hunt, LLP,
- 0:21Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company, Soberlink,
- 0:24and Our Family Wizard. White Zuckerman, Worzowski,
- 0:28Luna, and Hunt provides a wide variety of resources
- 0:31to complete almost any project, large or small.
- 0:35They also provide traditional accounting and
- 0:37tax practice services. We invite you to contact
- 0:40them to discuss your specific accounting needs
- 0:42and learn how they can be of service to you.
- 0:45Learn more at WZWLH .com. Silverlink provides
- 0:52objective, real -time data that can be used to
- 0:55reduce disputes over alcohol consumption, leading
- 0:58to less conflict in custody cases. To help ensure
- 1:02smoother negotiations for a more efficient legal
- 1:05process, consider using Silverlink's trusted
- 1:07alcohol monitoring system to eliminate hearsay
- 1:10and protect your client's best interests. With
- 1:13an unprecedented combination of features, including
- 1:16advanced reporting, facial recognition, tamper
- 1:19resistance, real -time results, and customized
- 1:22testing, the discrete system has been the leader
- 1:24in remote alcohol monitoring since 2011. Learn
- 1:28more at soberlink .com. For five decades, Lawyers
- 1:32Mutual Insurance Company has been the only California
- 1:35-based company to continuously provide lawyers
- 1:38throughout the state with professional liability
- 1:41insurance coverage. Their experience and expertise
- 1:44are complimented by the fact that LMIC is directed
- 1:48by a group of dedicated lawyers. They offer special
- 1:53rates with competitive premiums for a wide variety
- 1:56of practice areas, including family law. Learn
- 1:59more at lawyersmutual .com. Our Family Wizard
- 2:02is a co -parenting platform designed to help
- 2:05families communicate more efficiently and more
- 2:08effectively, reduce conflict, and create reliable
- 2:11court admissible records. Features like Tone
- 2:14Meter, AI, excuse me, Tone Meter AI, shared calendars,
- 2:21expense tracking, and in -app audio and video
- 2:25calling helps support compliance and better outcomes
- 2:28for families navigating custody matters. Having
- 2:32said that, I am delighted to introduce our speaker,
- 2:35Commissioner Patty Radekin. She brings over 31
- 2:40years of experience in the family law court system.
- 2:43She's a certified family law specialist. Her
- 2:46expertise spans alternative dispute resolution,
- 2:50child support, and spousal support matters. She
- 2:53has served on the California Guideline Child
- 2:57Support Task Force, the Department of Child Support
- 3:01Services Guideline Child Support Calculator Task
- 3:04Force, and the Superior Court Family Law Committee.
- 3:08and the CJER Family Law Curriculum Committee.
- 3:13She created the curriculum for the preliminary,
- 3:17excuse me, the primary assignment training for
- 3:19AB 1058 child support commissioners and has lectured
- 3:24extensively on family law across California.
- 3:29I'm so happy to have you here. Let's get started.
- 3:33Thank you, Jack, for your kind words. I appreciate
- 3:35those. Good afternoon, everyone. Thank you for
- 3:38taking time out of your busy schedule to be here
- 3:40with us today. I would like to take a moment
- 3:43to thank Suzanne Jimenez for her assistance through
- 3:46this three -part series. Her hard work, organization,
- 3:49and dedication have been instrumental in making
- 3:52these programs possible. I'm truly grateful for
- 3:55her efforts. In this session, which is part three
- 3:58of a three -part program, we will be discussing
- 4:01spouse support modification establishing arrears,
- 4:04and enforcement issues. Hopefully you'll walk
- 4:07away with some tools to pursue a modification
- 4:10of spousal support for your client and enforce
- 4:12the orders that you get. Let me see. Okay. So,
- 4:25what comes first? A modification of spousal support
- 4:29begins with three questions. What facts supported
- 4:32the existing order? So we're looking at the last
- 4:35order. Right again. I'm sorry to interrupt. It
- 4:38looks like we can't see the content of your screen
- 4:40right now. Oh, I don't know why. Let me see.
- 4:45Let me try again. Can you see now? It's loading.
- 4:56Yes, we can see it now. Okay, sorry about that.
- 4:59Okay, so the modification begins with three questions
- 5:02that you should ask yourself. What facts supported
- 5:05the existing order or judgment? What has changed?
- 5:09And does the change justify a different order?
- 5:12If you cannot answer these three questions, modification
- 5:15will likely fail. One of the most important concepts
- 5:20in the support modification is that every case
- 5:23begins So when you're talking about what facts
- 5:29were the support, you know, in the prior order,
- 5:34what were the party's incomes? What findings
- 5:37did the court make, hopefully, or what findings
- 5:40were included in your stipulation? We talked
- 5:42in the last seminar about how important it was
- 5:44to include the family code section 4320 factors
- 5:48each and every time you either enter a stipulation
- 5:51or make sure that the court makes those findings
- 5:54for you. You can't prove that circumstances have
- 5:58changed unless you first know what circumstances
- 6:00existed. So California law requires a material
- 6:05change of circumstance. Change might be an increase
- 6:08or decrease in income retirement, a significant
- 6:11change in the health of one of the parties, a
- 6:14change in the supported spouse's needs, or some
- 6:17other event that was not anticipated when the
- 6:21prior order was entered. Simply disagreeing with
- 6:24the original order or the length of time is not.
- 6:27usually going to get you a modification of the
- 6:30support. The key here is that the change of circumstances
- 6:34was not anticipated at the time the last order
- 6:37or stipulation was entered into. On the third
- 6:41question, not every change is legally sufficient
- 6:44to justify a modification. The court must determine
- 6:48whether the new circumstances warrant an increase
- 6:51or decrease or termination of the order. If you
- 6:55remember nothing else about spousal support modification,
- 6:59remember these three questions. They provide
- 7:02a roadmap for every successful modification case.
- 7:06Without understanding what the original order
- 7:08is and identifying material change of circumstance
- 7:12and then demonstrating why that change justifies
- 7:15a different result, the request for modification
- 7:18will certainly fail. Okay, your statutory authority
- 7:26for spell support modification is family code
- 7:30section 3651. Retroactivity is dealt with in
- 7:343653. Of course, the 4320 factors. Then we deal
- 7:39with 4323, which is cohabitation. 4330 is the
- 7:44duration, the marital standard of living. The
- 7:464336 deals with the long -term marriage, and
- 7:504337 deals with death or remarriage. We're not
- 7:53talking about modification at that point, we're
- 7:55talking about termination. So the threshold issues
- 8:02that you need to deal with when you're seeking
- 8:04a modification for your client is... Make sure
- 8:07you obtain a copy of all the orders. The original
- 8:10order, if there's any modification order, make
- 8:13sure you read those carefully. Determine whether
- 8:17or not the court has jurisdiction to modify the
- 8:19support. was there a previous non -modifiable
- 8:22support order, which you wouldn't get from the
- 8:25court because the court doesn't have the authority
- 8:27to do that. But if it's a stipulation, make sure
- 8:30that you're not going to end up in court with
- 8:33an order that can't be modified. You consider
- 8:36the length of the marriage, the short -term marriage
- 8:38versus long -term marriage, and that's not in
- 8:41concrete. Whether or not a gavron admonition
- 8:45was given. And so if you're seeking a modification
- 8:48of support based upon the uh pays a failure to
- 8:52become self -supporting you may have to make
- 8:54sure the gavron admonition was given because
- 8:57the case law says the court can't terminate unless
- 9:00that happened. If you're dealing with a Richmond
- 9:03step -down order, you have to consider whether
- 9:05or not the expectations that were outlined in
- 9:09the Richmond step -down order have been met.
- 9:13If you have a failure of expectation, which if
- 9:17you're representing the party seeking the modification
- 9:20of the Richmond step -down, they should know
- 9:23hopefully whether their spouse has had any unrealized
- 9:27expectations. I'll give you an example. I had
- 9:30a case where I negotiated a step down and my
- 9:35client was gonna be a teacher and she couldn't
- 9:39get the classes she wanted and she broke her
- 9:41ankle and couldn't attend class. So I was successful
- 9:44in convincing the court that there was a failure
- 9:47of expectation and got her order continued. Make
- 9:52sure that there's not a termination date fixed
- 9:55in the order because sometimes judges look at
- 9:57those kind of orders and think that Somehow it's
- 10:01non -modifiable even though it doesn't say it's
- 10:03non -modifiable So that's something to consider
- 10:06and spend some time trying to overcome if you
- 10:09have that case So material changes circumstance
- 10:17identify what the what the order was. Do a chart,
- 10:22you know, here's the factors now, here's the
- 10:25factors for then, and here's the factors now.
- 10:28If we're talking about an increase in income
- 10:30for the payor spouse, consider in remarriage
- 10:34of Hofmeister and the Hofmeister II case because
- 10:37what it says is that an increase in income for
- 10:41the payor spouse is usually not a justification
- 10:44for an increase in support unless the original
- 10:47order stated that it did not meet the needs under
- 10:51the marital standard of living. Has there been
- 10:53an increase in expenses and what you need to
- 10:56look at there is if the payee spouse Increase
- 11:00their expenses intentionally that goes back to
- 11:05analyzing it under the marital standard of living.
- 11:09A reduction in income alone does not necessarily
- 11:12justify a modification if the reduction of income
- 11:15was voluntary and not made in good faith. You
- 11:18have that one case where the. gentlemen wanted
- 11:20to go into the to become a priest and they said
- 11:24that that was acceptable. The other types of
- 11:28changes you might expect are the supported party
- 11:31obtained employment or increased their earning
- 11:33capacity, a completion of education or training,
- 11:37cohabitation, new inheritance by the payee spouse,
- 11:42a sale or acquisition of assets, assuming they
- 11:45weren't part of the original order. A vocational
- 11:48evaluation that you had done at the time of the
- 11:52order and the party has not met the expectation
- 11:57under the vocational order. A reduction in earning
- 12:01capacity by the payor or health changes. Next,
- 12:08we're going to deal with the 4320 factors. A
- 12:13lot of judgments, orders, stipulation, not judgments,
- 12:16but stipulations that I found had no 4320 factors
- 12:19in them at all. They just had the numbers, what
- 12:22the incomes were. And so if you run into a situation
- 12:27where you have a client who wants a modification
- 12:30on that, you should identify what the factors
- 12:35were at the time they entered into that stipulation.
- 12:39or if the judge fails to do the 4320 and no one
- 12:43objected, you should do the same thing. What
- 12:47are the factors then and what are the factors
- 12:49now? Because the judge can't determine that without
- 12:53knowing both of those things. Cohabitation issues.
- 13:00A common ground for seeking a modification is
- 13:02cohabitation by the supported spouse under family
- 13:05code section 4323. That is, there's a rebuttable
- 13:09presumption of decreased need for support. However,
- 13:12I have seen judgments and stipulations that said
- 13:17cohabitation is a terminating event. So the order
- 13:21is going to control on the cohabitation issue.
- 13:26It does not automatically terminate or reduce
- 13:30support. It shifts the burden to the supported
- 13:33spouse to show that despite the cohabitation,
- 13:37his or her financial needs have not actually
- 13:41decreased. The first question that you should
- 13:44ask yourself, however, is when did the cohabitation
- 13:46begin? Because if it started after the order,
- 13:50it is a change of circumstance. If the supported
- 13:52spouse was already cohabiting when the prior
- 13:55order was entered, you then have to show a different...
- 13:59material change of circumstance since the prior
- 14:02order, such as have they bought a house together?
- 14:05Have they commingled their assets? Are they holding
- 14:09themselves out as married people? All of those
- 14:11things would be important to present those facts
- 14:16to the court on your motion to modify. So the
- 14:23next issue that comes up are retirement issues.
- 14:26Somebody retires. Is it going to be a material
- 14:31change in circumstance? First of all, is it of
- 14:35an age where they can retire? We all know that
- 14:3765 is the magic age at this point in time, which
- 14:40I keep wondering why someone doesn't seek a good
- 14:44faith extension of that, because most people
- 14:46today who are in the realm of pain support are
- 14:51there. maximum retirement age at Social Security
- 14:54is 67 years old. So I think that there's room
- 14:57to argue that that's what the court should adopt.
- 15:02But since I'm not litigating, I'm not going to
- 15:04take on that burden. The second consideration,
- 15:08was it a good faith retirement? Because you have
- 15:10these places where companies require that people
- 15:16Retired a certain age pilots. I think they're
- 15:1955 firemen. I think they're 55 or something like
- 15:23that. And then there's certain there was an accounting
- 15:27firm that that demands they retire at 60 or 61.
- 15:33I think so. You have to look at their contract
- 15:36or where they were working and wasn't a mandatory
- 15:38retirement. The key takeaway is a retirement
- 15:45is not an automatic ticket to a reduced support
- 15:48order. It does signify a change of circumstance,
- 15:53but the person who's retiring needs to demonstrate
- 15:56that it was reasonable. in good faith and it
- 16:00materially affected their ability to pay support.
- 16:03So one of the things that comes up is if the
- 16:06person gets a pension and so if the pension was
- 16:10contemplated in the judgment and it was awarded
- 16:14to the party The current case law says that abstinent,
- 16:19what's called a white waiver, where that can't
- 16:22be used to calculate support, even though that
- 16:24was awarded as a property settlement, it is still
- 16:27available to pay support. So when you're negotiating
- 16:30that, you may want to consider trying to get
- 16:32a white waiver on everybody's portion of their
- 16:35retirements. If the party has passive income,
- 16:40that income is usually available to pay support.
- 16:44Except I think if it wasn't part of the marital
- 16:47standard of living, let's say that after the
- 16:50party separated, the judgment was entered, the
- 16:54payer spouse got a huge inheritance from their
- 16:57family and the income that they're getting from
- 17:00that inheritance is this passive income. The
- 17:03argument can be made that wasn't part of the
- 17:06marital standard of living and therefore should
- 17:07not be counted as the income available for support.
- 17:12So now we're going to head into enforcement of
- 17:14support orders. Every support order is an installment
- 17:21judgment, and it becomes a judgment when under
- 17:24family code section 290 and 4502. Each unpaid
- 17:29installment is a money judgment and is immediately
- 17:32enforceable under 685 .020B of the Code of Civil
- 17:36Procedure. It does not require a separate judgment
- 17:40before enforcement. It generally may not be modified
- 17:45retroactively once due, and think of every mispayment
- 17:49as creating an enforceable judgment for your
- 17:52client with interest. Calculating arrears. I've
- 17:59seen this done inappropriately more often than
- 18:02not. So one of the things that happens is when
- 18:06the court makes an initial support order on an
- 18:09RFO and grants it retroactively. For instance,
- 18:13let's say that the motion was filed in December,
- 18:18December 24th of a year. the court grants retroactive
- 18:23support back to January 1st, but it's done at
- 18:26a hearing on April 1st. The support for January
- 18:30through March becomes a lump sum entry in the
- 18:34calculation of arrears. You don't start calculating
- 18:37January 1st because it was an unliquidated amount.
- 18:43The next issue that people run into trouble with
- 18:46calculating arrears is when there's a child in
- 18:48spousal support order and the payer makes partial
- 18:51payments, how do you credit those payments? It
- 18:54goes first to child support, ongoing child support,
- 18:58second ongoing spousal support, third principal
- 19:02child support arrears, fourth principal spousal
- 19:05support arrears, then fifth to child support
- 19:07interest, then to spousal support interest. So
- 19:11that's how you apply payments when you're trying
- 19:14to do your calculation of arrears. Any other
- 19:19credits, you apply those. You have to explain
- 19:24them. Keep in mind you can't, I'm not dealing
- 19:26with child support today, but you can't credit
- 19:28the payment of something to support, to child
- 19:34support at least. Support judgments carry interest
- 19:37at 10%. And it is something that the court has
- 19:41no jurisdiction to reduce or eliminate. And that's
- 19:46CCP 685 .010A1. So if you have a judge that's
- 19:52trying to, we're going to take questions at the
- 19:54end. So I will take any question you want, and
- 19:59I'll stay as long as anybody wants me to answer
- 20:01questions. So if a judge attempts to waive interest
- 20:05or reduce interest or arrears, the same thing
- 20:09applies. So when you're finally to enforce your
- 20:15arrears, you have to file an FL -420, which is
- 20:18a mandatory form. And there's an FL -421 That's
- 20:23an optional form but you need some form of calculation
- 20:27of arrears such as I use an executioner when
- 20:30I was in practice or there's different programs
- 20:34that calculate arrears. My suggestion to you
- 20:38as a practice tip is to try to do your best to
- 20:41gather payment documentation from your client
- 20:44so that you can be sure that you're applying
- 20:46the payments that they receive properly. So there's
- 20:51Equitable defenses to spousal support. Latches
- 20:55is not one of them. Latches is not available
- 20:58for child or spousal support. Equitable estoppel,
- 21:02waiver, accord and satisfaction, unclean hands,
- 21:06and domestic violence. On domestic violence,
- 21:12one of the most interesting cases was Henry Marriage
- 21:15of Kelkar. It's a 2014 case, 229 Kallap, 4th,
- 21:21833. The court held the family code section 4325
- 21:26applied retroactively and a stipulated judgment.
- 21:30It was actually a non -modifiable spousal support
- 21:33judgment. could be modified because husband agreed
- 21:36to the order without knowledge of 4325's limitation
- 21:41on spousal support. That's a good case to have
- 21:45if you're in that situation. Today we're not
- 21:48talking about. child support arrears, but one
- 21:51of the things you need to keep in mind is if
- 21:53you're going to attempt to compromise a child
- 21:55support arrears, you must include in the stipulation
- 21:59that there's a good faith dispute over the amount
- 22:01owed and a consideration for the compromise of
- 22:05the arrears. That case is Henry Marriage of M,
- 22:09and it's Sabine and Toshio, 2007, 153 CalAP 4th,
- 22:151203. Enforcement remedies. The gold standard
- 22:22is the abstract of support judgment. Every support
- 22:25order that you get for your client should be
- 22:29followed up immediately with a recorded abstract
- 22:32of support judgment because what that does is
- 22:35if the payer ever attempts, is in arrears and
- 22:40ever attempts to buy or sell a house, your client
- 22:44will get paid their arrears from escrow because
- 22:46the escrow will make a demand on the abstract.
- 22:52And so it's important to tell your clients that
- 22:54they'll have an abstract on file. If they change
- 22:57their address, they should notify or rerecord
- 23:00the abstract so that the escrow company has a
- 23:04way to get a hold of them when the demand needs
- 23:08to be issued. We all know about income. with
- 23:11holding orders, the wage assignments. A writ
- 23:14of execution is what you can get for a support
- 23:17arrears. Check with your local rules how they
- 23:21require that you do that. But here in San Diego,
- 23:24we issue a writ of execution that has a declaration
- 23:27regarding what the arrears are. If there's any
- 23:31concern about the amount of the arrears, it's
- 23:33probably a better practice to file an RFO and
- 23:36have the court set those arrears before you issue
- 23:39the writ. But if you are sure that you have the
- 23:42correct amount of arrears, you can just go through
- 23:44the writ of execution process, get the writ issued,
- 23:47go to the sheriff, you can execute on bank accounts,
- 23:50you can execute on wages. And one of the least
- 23:56used tools is a judgment debtor exam. A judgment
- 24:00debtor exam, you can do every 120 days. And it
- 24:05makes the judgment creditor or the debtor's life
- 24:09miserable. You bring them into court every 120
- 24:12days and ask them questions about their personal
- 24:15life. And if you believe, have a good faith belief
- 24:19that the judgment debtor has transferred property
- 24:22to a third party, you can ask for a judgment
- 24:24debtor exam of the third party also. Contempt.
- 24:30That could be a whole day seminar all by itself.
- 24:35But as a judicial officer... I didn't like contempt
- 24:38cases because most of the time people didn't
- 24:41know how to plead them properly. They misquoted
- 24:45the date of the order. They did something. And
- 24:48for a judge, they're very technical. They have
- 24:51to be 100 % correct. You cannot make a mistake
- 24:55in pleading a contempt. It's like a criminal
- 24:58complaint. So if you do want to do a contempt,
- 25:01one of the things that I used to do as a lawyer
- 25:04is I would hire the guy that they appointed on
- 25:06all the contempt and he usually won them all
- 25:08I hired him to review my complaint which did
- 25:11two things one my complaints were usually good
- 25:14and two it conflicted him out from representing
- 25:17the other party so my suggestion is if you are
- 25:23going to file a contempt find somebody like that
- 25:26hire them and have them review your complaint
- 25:28before you file it so that the judge doesn't
- 25:31dismiss it under Penal Code Section 1385. But,
- 25:38you know, one of the things that I found that
- 25:40happened is when somebody got a contempt dismissed,
- 25:43it was basically like the person believed that
- 25:46the court had no power over them. So it oftentimes
- 25:49made it worse than better. So really consider
- 25:52whether that's the best option for you. Attorney's
- 25:57fees, this is often one of the things that everybody
- 25:59forgets on enforcement is attorney's fees are
- 26:02available for enforcement. And one of the thoughts
- 26:06I had as a judge when I was dealing with somebody
- 26:08who had to chase their money is it comes out
- 26:12of the support. So I was usually more inclined
- 26:14if I could to order all the fees that the lawyer
- 26:18had, all the reasonable fees the lawyer had incurred
- 26:21to enforce that support so that the party had
- 26:23the benefit of all of their support. So practice
- 26:29tips and takeaways. Audit the file first before
- 26:33you file an arrears motion. Never rely solely
- 26:36on your client's memory. Try to calculate your
- 26:39interest accurately. It's often substantial.
- 26:42Use all your remedies, your abstracts. First
- 26:45of all, do your abstract. Do your wage assignment.
- 26:48Do your RIT. Do your debtor exam. Get a lien
- 26:51if possible on real property if you know they
- 26:53have it. request attorney's fees and document
- 26:57everything. Your enforcement case is only as
- 27:01strong as your accounting because if you file
- 27:04something and the other side presents a whole
- 27:06lot of evidence that they paid these arrears
- 27:10and your client loses credibility, that can hurt
- 27:14in an enforcement action. So questions. Any questions?
- 27:31It looks like we have quite a few questions within
- 27:33the Q and A. So far to start us off, one from
- 27:36Martha. Does the age of the GAVRN order make
- 27:39a difference in a modification? Example, GAVRN
- 27:41issued 18 months ago versus five years ago. I
- 27:47think it does have some weight. But, you know,
- 27:51read the Shaughnessy case because that's kind
- 27:53of a real good case about a GAVRN warning. But,
- 27:56you know, A lot of it depends on the facts of
- 27:59the case. The longer the marriage, the less impact
- 28:03a gaurant is going to have early in the proceedings.
- 28:06But it really is very factually determinate for
- 28:09a judge. you know, whether they're still kids,
- 28:12whether they're, you know, there's any type of
- 28:14disability, whether the party traveled, like
- 28:18you have a military spouse where the spouse went
- 28:22all over for their career, the gathering's not
- 28:25going to have as much impact on that type of
- 28:27a case as it is on someone who, you know, didn't
- 28:31do anything, didn't help the other party, didn't
- 28:34work, didn't, you know, and there's no kids to
- 28:37consider, it's going to have more impact. Okay,
- 28:44so this is a little bit of a longer question
- 28:46here. Party stipulated judgment recites there
- 28:49is no order for the payment to spousal support
- 28:52from 1 party to the other at the present time.
- 28:54End quote, leaving the spousal support issue
- 28:56open and unresolved retaining and reserving the
- 28:59court's jurisdiction for later education. The
- 29:02judgment does not reference the parties or the
- 29:05court. considered the family code section 4320
- 29:09factors in and not resolving the spousal support
- 29:11issue in the decision to leave it at a later
- 29:13date nor does it make any findings of marital
- 29:15standard of living post judgment seeking a spousal
- 29:18support order is this an original order or a
- 29:20modification of a quote unquote zero dollar previous
- 29:24order that requires a change of modification
- 29:27i think it would probably require a change of
- 29:33circumstance to be shown from why was there no
- 29:36support in the judgment and why is it requested
- 29:39now? So I think I would, in an abundance of caution
- 29:45in your pleading your RFO to outline what factors
- 29:49were existed at the time they agreed to just
- 29:52delay the issue of spousal. And a lot of it depends
- 29:57on what length of marriage it is. If it's a,
- 30:00let's say it's a three year marriage and the
- 30:02judgment was entered three years ago, I think
- 30:04you're out of luck. So you have to consider all
- 30:08of that and just make your best educated guess
- 30:12at what your judge is gonna do. All right, I
- 30:18actually have someone here asking if you could
- 30:21go through the order of applying payments once
- 30:24again, if you could repeat that question a little
- 30:26bit. Yes. When you get payments, you have arrears
- 30:32and you get partial payments. The payment goes
- 30:35first to ongoing child support, next to ongoing
- 30:40spousal support, next to child support arrears,
- 30:45spousal support arrears, child support interest
- 30:49and spousal support interest. And that doesn't
- 30:52apply if you're in DCSS, because there's a different
- 30:55thing going on over there about how you apply
- 30:58child support. So if you're in DCSS, you may
- 31:01want to read the code sections that deal with
- 31:03DCSS specifically. But they apply it for you,
- 31:07so you really don't need to worry about it. Let's
- 31:14see another one. Did you say that when a support
- 31:16order is made retroactive to the day of the filing,
- 31:19that you input it into the arrears calculation
- 31:22as a lump sum owing on the day the order is made?
- 31:25What is the authority for this? I'm not sure,
- 31:31but that's because it's an unliquidated amount.
- 31:36And so unless you were to have the court issue
- 31:39prejudgment interest, because you don't have
- 31:41an order. So there's no order. from January,
- 31:45the example I use, there's no order from January
- 31:48through April 1st. So April 1st would be your
- 31:52ongoing support, but those three months, they're
- 31:56now a liquidated sum and that's why it goes in
- 32:00the, I'll see if I can find the authority for
- 32:03that and I'll get it out. I have another question
- 32:15here. If a judge makes an order that the supported
- 32:18party has an obligation to become employed full
- 32:21time by a certain date, can it be argued that
- 32:24it is an likened to a Gavron warning? I wouldn't
- 32:31rely on that. And, you know, we talked a little
- 32:37bit about Gavron last time. I think it's safer
- 32:40to, if the judge were to make that order, I might
- 32:42follow it up with, Judge, could you please make
- 32:45a formal 4320 L Gavron admonition to the party?
- 32:51You could argue it. And, you know, it's like
- 32:54a lot of questions that people ask in seminars
- 32:56where judges are speaking. It depends. It depends
- 32:59on the judge. The judge could interpret it that
- 33:02way. The judge could say no. What the appellate
- 33:05court would do with it, I'm not really sure.
- 33:08But the better practice would be to follow up
- 33:12and ask the judge to actually issue the gavron.
- 33:17All right. And let's see. Is it ever appropriate
- 33:21to grant a motion to dismiss an RFO regarding
- 33:24contempt? based on alleged errors in calculation
- 33:28of arrears? Well, you're not dealing with arrears
- 33:33in a contempt action. I mean, the amount. You're
- 33:37only dealing with whether or not they paid their
- 33:39support. So I don't think that's a basis to dismiss.
- 33:46If they failed to identify the order properly,
- 33:50yes, then that's a basis to dismiss. So let's
- 33:53say that the order said the support starts January
- 33:571st, 2026, and the contempt is filed for January,
- 34:01February, March, April, May, and they identify
- 34:05the order as February 1st, the contempt is dismissed.
- 34:10It's a, you know, the defective pleading. But
- 34:14I don't think the amount of arrears comes into
- 34:16play. Unless you're talking about dismissing
- 34:19an RFO because the arrears are incorrect, but
- 34:23I don't think a judge would do that either. All
- 34:31right. If someone retired in good faith after
- 34:33paying spousal support for 10 years on a 20 -year
- 34:35marriage and he's only relying on his retirement
- 34:38distributions to live, how much is he required
- 34:40to take for distributions if the other side is
- 34:43fighting the modification? Well, I need a few
- 34:48more facts on that one. How old was he when he
- 34:53retired? Was there. Are there any other factors
- 35:03that would justify modification like failure
- 35:05to become self supporting? Is the other party
- 35:08still capable of working? That's a real I mean.
- 35:14That that one is just without further facts would
- 35:17be too hard to answer. If you want to give me
- 35:21more facts, I'll I'll do my best. So far I got
- 35:2665 is the year, but I'll keep my eye on other
- 35:29submissions of information. Let's see. I have
- 35:34a question from Terez and if in an RFO for spousal
- 35:39support arrears, does the legal interest start
- 35:42when the 1st payment is due and is it compound
- 35:45interest? No, it's simple interest and the interest
- 35:49begins when the first payment is missed. So let's
- 35:52assume they had a payment due January 1st and
- 35:55they didn't pay it. Interest accrues from January
- 35:581st onward until it's paid in full. So when you're
- 36:04doing your, I like the executioner if you can
- 36:08get your hands on it. It's hard because CFLR
- 36:11doesn't do it anymore but I have one on an old
- 36:13computer. But you just put in the day the order
- 36:17starts and the date you're calculating to and
- 36:21it automatically calculates the interest from
- 36:23the first day of support being due. What defense
- 36:32does an obliger have who has never served with
- 36:37the RFO and does not know that a spousal support
- 36:41order existed and W is now attempting to obtain
- 36:47a rate of execution seven years later and husband
- 36:50is retiring with a CalSTARS pension? Okay. So
- 36:57if husband was never served, he has to file a
- 36:59motion with the court to quash the writ, first
- 37:03of all, and then outline that he never got served
- 37:08with it. He had no idea of the order and see
- 37:12what the judge does with that. So in San Diego,
- 37:17we had a situation where one of the process servers
- 37:21that was hired by the county instead of serving
- 37:25people, Just threw it in the trash and then they
- 37:29got all these orders against them. There was
- 37:31child support order, of course, but then what
- 37:33happened actually read my case in rain marriage
- 37:36of Gorham because it basically said wouldn't
- 37:40that there was no jurisdiction to make an order
- 37:43because there was no service. And so if the client
- 37:46could prove that he was never served with that.
- 37:50You probably stand a good chance of setting aside
- 37:52all of those arrears. So one of the things I
- 37:58would do on that is I would go to court and pull
- 38:00the proof of service and see what the proof of
- 38:03service says. So if you have a process server
- 38:05that signed a proof of service, you got to go
- 38:08find that process server and track down it, you
- 38:12know, basically find out where that came from.
- 38:22Right. So, let's see. I do have some more facts
- 38:25regarding the, the retirement. Okay. So, the
- 38:31client retired at sixty five. The other side
- 38:33was imputed image minimum wage in the judgment.
- 38:36Other side claims can't work due to health issues
- 38:39because. Has an O. H. D. Oh, has a P. H. D. that
- 38:43has authored several books, but claims not earning
- 38:46income. Well, if. It says nobody can be forced
- 38:52to work pack 65 to pay support so the client
- 38:56files a motion he has a good faith retirement.
- 38:59Issue so he files a motion saying I want to terminate
- 39:02my support because I'm 65 I'm I'm taking my pension
- 39:06the other party has it's been 10 years on a 20
- 39:10year marriage the other party hasn't taken reasonable
- 39:14steps to to become self supporting and and so
- 39:18one of the things that you want to look at in
- 39:19your. Discovery is this alleged disability that's
- 39:24now there. When did it happen? So can you prove
- 39:29the failure to take reasonable steps become self
- 39:32supporting before the disability? Those are the
- 39:35ways I would handle and target the. You know
- 39:40the modification. Sounds reasonable to me, but
- 39:44I'm not your judge, so. All right, let's see.
- 39:52It looks like someone is asking regarding, would
- 39:57you mind restating the notice requirement for
- 39:59non -modifiable support orders? Notice for non
- 40:05-modifiable? What I was talking about is if you
- 40:10have a non -modifiable spousal support order,
- 40:12you shouldn't file a motion to modify it. Is
- 40:15that what you meant? Because there's no notice
- 40:23for, I mean, if you get somebody to agree to
- 40:25a non -modifiable support, they don't need notice.
- 40:27They just sign the stipulation. The other thing
- 40:36I said was if you have a MSA or a judgment or
- 40:41a stipulation that has an order that says it's
- 40:46going to be paid this is the amount of money
- 40:48and it will terminate at that point in time let's
- 40:51say it's going to terminate two years from now
- 40:53the judge may interpret if you file before the
- 40:57two years may interpret that hey you negotiated
- 41:00for this two year period of time i'm not going
- 41:03to give you a modification if there's no change
- 41:06of circumstance So I don't see any other comments
- 41:17from that one. All right. For points and authority
- 41:21authorities and the RFO for arrears, I have the
- 41:24pair who hasn't asked X, H, X husband to pay
- 41:28the order in five years. Will that be an issue
- 41:31or does she still get all which what is owed?
- 41:36Can you read the question again? Yeah, for points
- 41:40and authorities and the RFO for arrears, I have
- 41:43the pair who hasn't asked um ex -age to pay the
- 41:47order in five years will that be an issue or
- 41:50does she still get what is owed she still gets
- 41:54what's owed unless you have you know people modify
- 41:58orders outside and these oral modifications the
- 42:01alleged you know he said she said he told me
- 42:05that you know i didn't have to pay because he
- 42:08lost his job he says or she said No, I just said
- 42:15you could delay it a month. They still owe the
- 42:18support arrears. So, yeah, unless there's an
- 42:23oral modification that you can prove, then I
- 42:26think the person who is out of luck, they're
- 42:29going to have to pay the five years of support
- 42:31and the interest on it. It looks like we have
- 42:40a couple of requests regarding, I guess, legal
- 42:42authority and. Also cases or citations. So, this
- 42:501 is asking, will you please provide the legal
- 42:52authority for the order of applying payments
- 42:54with that being. C, S, S, C, S principle, assess
- 43:00principle, et cetera. Okay, I have that here
- 43:03and let me give it to you. Hold on. Let me see.
- 43:17Thought I wrote it down. I'll find it. So they
- 43:27want the legal authority for applying payments.
- 43:31Yes. Okay. All right, I'll get that. Anything
- 43:44else they want? Yeah, let's see. Um, it looks
- 43:49like someone is asking for the case citation
- 43:51for the I. R. M. O. gorm case. Or, okay, I'll
- 43:57get you that too. Let's see, I think that's it
- 44:07for that. Just regular questions again. Okay.
- 44:11All right, so. Someone is actually asking for
- 44:15a follow up question from, um, your, your 2nd
- 44:18session, your last session, if that's okay, if
- 44:21not, we can proceed to other. Okay. So, um, this
- 44:24question being, if we are submitting a thorough,
- 44:27um, 1 57, should all factors be restated in the
- 44:31declaration or just certain ones. Well, you know,
- 44:381 of the things that if you think a factor is
- 44:41more important. than another factor. There's
- 44:45no reason why not highlight it and go into more
- 44:49detail in your declaration. List the factor in
- 44:52your 157, but go into more detail in your declaration
- 44:56supporting your RFO. Keep in mind people remember
- 45:07what they read first and last. So if you have
- 45:11something that's really important that you want
- 45:13a judge to read, one, I did a pleading seminar
- 45:18one time and I said, you know, I understand that
- 45:21your clients want to pontificate on everything
- 45:24that's wrong in their life. So if you'll just
- 45:28give me the most important stuff in the beginning
- 45:32of your declaration and then start with, my client
- 45:37wants the court to know, then I know I can stop
- 45:41reading at that point in time because you're
- 45:44telling me that you know that that's not legally
- 45:46relevant, but then you've met your client's need
- 45:52of saying things. Just don't say, you know, he
- 45:55cheated on me because we know that that's not
- 45:57acceptable. But, you know, sometimes they just
- 45:59need to think that the court listened. Even though
- 46:02I, you know, I shouldn't say I stopped reading
- 46:04because I did not always read everything, but
- 46:07at least I know that you know that it's not legally
- 46:10relevant. If you say my client wants the court
- 46:14to know. Then I know you understand that. I understand
- 46:21it's not that relevant. If there are no latches
- 46:30or enforcement is sought over a decade later,
- 46:33what does the court do about lack of evidence?
- 46:36Is it just testimonial? Yes, and that is a problem,
- 46:42you know. Because you read these cases where
- 46:46the person has waited 10 years and never made
- 46:49any attempt to collect, never made any, hey,
- 46:52you're not paying me. Hey, you're not. These
- 46:54were really hard cases for me because the law
- 46:58is pretty clear. There are no latches to support
- 47:01the person. And the theory behind that is the
- 47:04person knows they have a support obligation.
- 47:06They know they haven't gone to modify it. They
- 47:09should know that if they don't pay it, they have
- 47:12interest on it. So therefore, I'm really sorry
- 47:15that this sits right here, but you gotta pay
- 47:19it. I mean, you know, there's been situations
- 47:23where there's 400, 500 ,000 in arrears based
- 47:26upon that particular scenario. Is it fair? No,
- 47:30but is it, it's the law. Unless you can prove
- 47:34that the pay ease conduct was so egregious can
- 47:43you know convincing them that they didn't have
- 47:46to pay you can try that you know that's the equitable
- 47:50estoppel argument so but no uh supports do until
- 47:58it's paid and interest accrues until it's paid
- 48:00and it just you know when you get a four hundred
- 48:04thousand dollar judgment the payment amount that
- 48:07you would have to make on that is to even pay
- 48:11the You'd have to pay $3 ,333 a month just to
- 48:21cover the interest alone. So yeah, it becomes
- 48:25a huge problem. Great. I have a question here.
- 48:35What is the best way to have a permanent spell
- 48:38support order modified if the recipient is totally
- 48:41disabled? Well, you know, there's an old case
- 48:45by the name of Baker and one of the things that
- 48:47the client said in the Baker case was I don't
- 48:51want to be tied to the dead carcass of my marriage
- 48:54and I always thought that that was Language that
- 48:59was very flowery and made some sense but at some
- 49:05point in time people need to understand that
- 49:08the support isn't going to go on forever unless
- 49:11you have a 1650 year marriage. Um, at some point
- 49:15in time, the court, the court is going to pull
- 49:17the plug on it because of a change of circumstance.
- 49:21So, you know, those are the hard cases where
- 49:24you have somebody who's truly disabled. I mean,
- 49:27and especially if they've been declared disabled
- 49:29by the state or the federal government, like
- 49:32Those are much harder cases to overcome a disability
- 49:36than the ones who just go to a doctor and the
- 49:39doctor says, oh, they're disabled for life. You
- 49:42know, those were very questionable those types
- 49:44of declarations that I got. So, yeah, the cases
- 49:50where the party's disabled are much more difficult
- 49:53to overcome. Let's see. Looks like this is I
- 50:04think this is a follow up regarding the, um,
- 50:07the retiree, um, with the authorship. Um, is
- 50:11my client required to take a certain percentage
- 50:14from his pension as a distribution annually?
- 50:19Well, that it depends on the judge, I, I would
- 50:21not make somebody take, you have to take a minimum
- 50:24distribution from your pension at age 73. So,
- 50:29at 73. Yes, it's going to be counted as income
- 50:33because you have to take it. But before that,
- 50:37I at a 10 year on a 20 year marriage, I'm not
- 50:40going to make somebody take a distribution just
- 50:42to continue to pay support. There's another judge
- 50:45who probably would. So a lot of it depends on
- 50:49do you know your judge, you know, and That's
- 50:55a fairness argument. It's not fair that I assume
- 50:59some of the pension that or the retirement that
- 51:02she's asked he or she's asking the other person
- 51:04to take was given to them in the as a property
- 51:08distribution. That's an even though you didn't
- 51:11get a white waiver at the time of the judgment.
- 51:14The argument is it's really unfair that I have
- 51:17to invade my retirement accounts to continue
- 51:21to pay support. But it could happen, especially
- 51:28if the judge believes the person is disabled
- 51:31and the judge believes that the support of that
- 51:34person is going to fall to the public, that's
- 51:38another consideration. Did request the citation
- 51:49for this one. I think I mentioned it when we
- 51:51previous went over. Just want to confirm. I have
- 51:55someone is asking regarding the previous question
- 51:57regarding oblige or not being served. Could you
- 52:00give us the citation on in regards to marriage
- 52:02of? Yes, however, that is felt as well. Perfect.
- 52:16And the next question being, is it correct that
- 52:18an abstract of support only clouds title not
- 52:21act as a lien against the property and a LIS
- 52:27pendants, not available post judgment? No, the
- 52:33lease pendants is a dispute over the property.
- 52:36And when you have arrears and you're just owed
- 52:38a judgment, you don't have a dispute over the
- 52:40property. One of the things, while we're here
- 52:42on Liz Pendants, one of the things you need to
- 52:44know about a Liz Pendants is you should never
- 52:46record a Liz Pendants unless on a piece of property
- 52:50in a family law action, unless you have identified
- 52:52the property in the petition or the response,
- 52:55because you as a lawyer can be liable for recording
- 52:59an inappropriate Liz Pendants. And if you don't
- 53:01have the property description in your petition
- 53:05or response, that could get you in trouble. So
- 53:09remember to do that. But a list penance isn't
- 53:11available for arrears. An abstract of judgment
- 53:14puts a cloud on the title. If you, you know,
- 53:19one of the things if you want to go forward and
- 53:21get a lien or, you know, foreclose on property,
- 53:24I would highly suggest you get a lawyer who knows
- 53:26how to do that because it's really difficult.
- 53:35All right, let's see. Holly is asking, what are
- 53:38some examples of such egregious behavior to justify
- 53:41an estoppel, estoppel defense? Estoppel, equitable
- 53:45estoppel. Okay, the one I thought about is let's
- 53:50say that this person is not in arrears, but arrears.
- 53:58And the person actively goes and causes the person
- 54:02to lose their job. so that they don't have them
- 54:06funds to pay. You got unclean hands on one side
- 54:11and equitable estoppel on the other. I'm trying
- 54:16to think of another example where equitable estoppel
- 54:23might play in. I actually can't think of one,
- 54:30but I'll put it on my list of things and if I
- 54:32can think of one, I'll send it out. Great, let's
- 54:39see. What's the best argument to overcome a 100
- 54:42% disabled veteran finding? Can income still
- 54:46be imputed? They're 100 % disabled by the Veterans
- 54:54Administration. Is that what we're talking about?
- 54:57Because even if you're 100 % disabled from the
- 55:00Veterans Administration, you can work. There's
- 55:02plenty of people out there getting 100 % of disability
- 55:05and working full time. It's going to be a harder
- 55:10call. And a lot of it depends on what is the
- 55:14disability? You know, are they in a wheelchair
- 55:16and a quadriplegic? Then you're going to have
- 55:18a really hard time. Is it PTSD and they mentally
- 55:25can't work? Maybe, you know, they have a hard
- 55:29time. So a lot of it depends on what the disability
- 55:33is. There's plenty of people with disabilities
- 55:36who, I had a Client one time is 100 % disabled
- 55:40from the military 100 % disabled from the civil
- 55:43service and and then working full time at a casino.
- 55:46So it does. I mean, they do are able to work.
- 55:51One of the things you might consider in that
- 55:53isn't an independent medical exam. So your client
- 55:58pays for an independent medical exam that that
- 56:00looks at the medical records from the. organization
- 56:04that has declared them disabled, and then they
- 56:07do their own examination and provide a report
- 56:10to the court. It is a harder, it's an uphill
- 56:15battle when you have somebody who's been declared
- 56:17100 % disabled by a government agency. Can you
- 56:26explain what specific language is needed in a
- 56:31white waiver? That something to the effect of
- 56:36the parties agree that the division of the petitioners
- 56:42pension. That the interest received by each party
- 56:46will no longer be available for support. At any
- 56:51later date. All right. Okay, so recently I successfully
- 57:00obtained an order expunging 5 lease pendants
- 57:03because opposing party's petition merely indicated
- 57:06the boilerplate language rather than identifying
- 57:08each property at issue. That's right, that's
- 57:14what will happen. And let's see if government
- 57:18determines a party is disabled, is the family
- 57:21court bound by that finding or do they have to
- 57:24establish their own finding? I don't think a
- 57:29family court is bound by that finding, but you
- 57:33would need some pretty strong evidence to overcome
- 57:37that. I think one of the things, judges who work
- 57:43in military towns understand this a little bit
- 57:46better than judges who don't, because we all
- 57:50know that there are people who work full time,
- 57:54even though they're disabled. But the burden
- 57:57is on you to overcome that finding by the government
- 58:02agency. And like I said, the IME is probably
- 58:06your best tool. Or if you know that the person
- 58:09is working under the table, get a private investigator
- 58:11and go at it that way. Then you have the credibility
- 58:16issue established. And so, because that happened.
- 58:22You know, sometimes too, where they working under
- 58:25the table. Hey, and then that looks like just
- 58:321 more question is a DCSS case. Yes, 186 Cal,
- 58:39I guess. Thank you. Yeah. All right, so that
- 58:44does look like that's it for questions now. Commissioner,
- 58:48do you have any. closing remarks or comments
- 58:52you'd like to make before we close this off.
- 58:55I want to thank everybody for taking time to
- 58:57be here today. I really appreciate it. Hopefully,
- 59:01you got some good tips to take away for your
- 59:04practice. I want to thank the Beverly Hills Bar.
- 59:07I really enjoyed speaking. Thank you. Perfect.
- 59:12This concludes today's presentation. Thank you
- 59:14so much again, Commissioner Radekin for an excellent
- 59:16presentation today and thank you so much to our
- 59:18audience for joining us. Have a great evening,
- 59:21everybody. You too. Bye bye.