Latest / And Now For Something Completely Machinima / S6 E208 Bad endings = new beginnings? (Jan 2026)
Transcript
- Phil Rice 01:00 welcome to a now for something completely machinima, the podcast about machinima, virtual production and related technologies. My name is Phil rice, and I'm here with my co hosts Tracy Harwood and Damien Valentine. So this week we're talking about my film pick. This is one I'd kind of hoped Ricky would be here for, because he's probably the biggest Half Life nut of us all. But it's an interesting and very different type of video that we're looking at, because it's not really, it's, I don't want to say it's not a narrative video, because it, I guess it is, but the narrative doesn't come from the video. The narrative comes from what's being played. Now, we've seen half life, you know, or we're at least familiar with half life generally, even if, if all of us haven't played it, I have many times. But half life, the original movie or the original game, has kind of this famous ending where, okay, so you're Gordon Freeman, and you've gone through this whole adventure, and there's this mysterious the G Man figure, who I'm, no one will ever convince Me, is not just the cigarette smoking man from The X Files. It's the same guy. I don't care what you say, it's him. So he is this mysterious figure that seems to be able to kind of move freely between these worlds and realms, and knows way more than anybody and all of that. And at the end of the half life game, you are in this face to face confrontation with him, where he asked, actually asks you to to join him in whatever it is he's, you know, up to, or you can go off and into this through this portal, into this realm and face, you know, you're a grisly death, and it does actually give you that choice in the game. But when you if, for whatever reason, you choose to not join the G Man, you do indeed go through a portal and into a place. And then there's this impossible scenario, kind of like, what it reminds me of is the end of the first, the first third of the original Doom. That this is the doom that was released as a shareware game in the early 90s. It's the first nine levels or so, and at the end of the ninth level, you teleport into this place that is just surrounded by just this horde of monsters that no matter what your weaponry, no matter how fast you move, whatever you're just obliterated. There's just no way. And there's no way out of it. Damien Valentine 03:58 Even if you're using the cheats, you still can't survive it. Phil Rice 04:01 Yeah, yeah. They've set it up to where it's just not possible to survive it. When you get the full version of the game, then chapter two, you start out on the next moon of Mars, and you're fine. So I don't know if it's like in the cartoons, where you know that the coyote gets smashed by a boulder and then he's fine in the next scene, but it's, it's that type of thing, right? So half life had the similar thing, if you chose not to go with the G Man, which would then take you, presumably, into the next leg of the story in the next game, then you would go into this room, this impossible room, and you'd get slaughtered, right? So somebody decided, What if we made it to where that wasn't an impossible scenario, just a really hard scenario. And so they made a mod that basically starts telling the story from that point of you going through that portal, and it looks. Just like the real end of the game. But there's a way through it. There's a way through it. And it, it's quite extensive, the additional gameplay, additional areas, at times, without the visual look of the back rooms, it feels like, kind of like the back rooms, in a way that you're like, you feel like you're kind of behind the scenes of what's going on in in other parts of the game world, and you're weaving in and out of these different areas, and either just found that fascinating that somebody would basically do a mod that essentially is fan fiction that extends this dead end of the game into something that's playable and enjoyable. So my video, which is called Surviving the bad ending of half life, is somebody basically playing through that. So really, this is more about the I'm intrigued by the mod and the concept of doing that, of extending we've seen fan fiction countless times in all different sorts of games where maybe it takes a tangent from the original story, or it tells the original story, or weaves into the original story, but this is one where that was a dead end, and now they've added some new thing onto it, a new challenge to work your way through. And just a fan, a free fan project that just somebody made, and the amount of detail like It looks like an authentic Half Life does like it look if someone told you, hey, this was designed by the same people who made half life, you wouldn't be surprised. But it's not. It's just a user mod. So that's just fascinating to me, and that it's, it's, let me see if I can figure out I didn't check to see when this was made, okay, released 2019 so what? 15 or no? More than that, more than 15 years after the original game was released Damien Valentine 07:01 about 20 Yeah, 99 there was your game 99 okay? Phil Rice 07:05 Because it was originally like, wasn't it? Was Quake engine, wasn't it? Or quake two, one of those id Software actually modified quake, yeah. So it's, it's, it's interesting on a number of levels. First of all, just the whole concept of someone doing that, but also the fact that this world, this story, world that was created by Valve for Half Life, the endurance that it has, you know, the persistence. You know, many people marvel at Minecraft for the the length of time that the game has stayed actively used, heavily, actively used and relevant, and it does all that with no story whatsoever. It's just gameplay on that. This is a story that I think enchanted The world of of people who play video games. It was, it was as rich as any Hollywood movie, even though it was made in a very primitive engine at the time, the next installation of Half Life, Half Life two caught attention for a different reason, because it was not only again, extension of this amazing story, but then visual fidelity and gameplay That was really interesting all these offshoots of half life that have happened in terms of additional expansion packs or adjacent games like Portal that still feels like that world as well. Team Fortress two doesn't really feel like that same world, but that is ultimately was an offshoot of Half Life Counter Strike. I don't know if people still play Counter Strike, but that was many, many, many, many years. Yeah. So it's quite a phenomenon. And now there's talk, although I don't know whether to believe any of it, but there is talk that half life three actually, may actually really happen. Damien Valentine 09:01 By the time this goes out, you'll have an answer to that, because it's the rumor is it's going to be released, announced on the during the Video Game Awards, which is on the 11th of December. Phil Rice 09:13 Okay, that was that I've been hearing about. Yeah, people never know with Valve. You know? You never know. Damien Valentine 09:20 I think people hopeful because Valve have just announced a load of new hardware, including the Steam Machine, which is basically a cube like, sort of that, right? And it's basically a PC you can play games on, using steam OS rather than Windows, and you can plug it into your TV. Phil Rice 09:38 Are they speculating that half life three might be like the flagship game to go with that new hardware. Yeah, that would be a smart move. Damien Valentine 09:46 It would, yeah. On the other hand, if they don't do it, which would be a shame for Half Life fans, but if they don't do it, they still don't need it, because you could, you've got the entire Steam library available to you, right, right? Phil Rice 09:58 Anyway, so. I don't know. I know that this would be something that Ricky would have just been tickled to death to see. But I don't know what your you guys's level of engagement with half life has been, or if it's at all interesting, but what did you guys Damien Valentine 10:13 think of it? So I played the original Half Life when it was released, and I really enjoyed the game. I can't say I'm I wasn't just heavily invested in but the world's bit. I'm very enjoyed the game, and I got this ending, and I got really frustrated with it and quit, which I didn't realize that was the point. And you know, back then, the Internet was very small. There weren't these communities, though. There were Internet communities about various games, but there was no one out there to say, yeah, that's not the ending you should have picked. You're supposed to go with a G Man if you want the real ending for the game. So I didn't do that. I didn't actually know that was a thing until I watched this video. No, it's great. So now after all this time, I finally understand why I was so frustrated with the ending of the game. Tracy Harwood 11:02 But from my point of view, I think what's fascinating about this, I mean, obviously I know, yeah, what you what I know about half life, you can bot on a postage standby compared to what you guys, guys know. But the bit that absolutely fascinates me is that we're not just now talking about a creator community that, sort of, you know, is invested in the game and builds on it, but we're actually talking about a community that that extends that gameplay and shares it with others through the mods. And I guess a question I might ask you guys is, when this new hardware comes out, will these mods that this, you know, this fan community has put so much effort into making Will that still work on the new hardware? Yeah, it will. Damien Valentine 11:53 So steam rise is the same operating system that works on the Steam deck, which has been available for three years now, and any game that's moddable, you can play on the Steam Deck, the mods apply to that, especially if they're really through the Steam Workshop. You subscribe, when you look at browsing the mod workshop for whatever game, and you browse and subscribe to whichever mods you want, they'll automatically get installed to the game, and that's whether you're playing on your PC or in your steam deck. It's all done automatically, and you know, they'll be downloaded, and then it'll be exactly the same on the Steam Machine. It will so even if you've got a game like, like half life, and you've heavily modified it, and you've got a whole list of mods installed, and installed. As soon as you set up your steam deck and you log in for the first time you download the game, all those mods that you've subscribed to will be included in that download. So you don't even do anything other than say you want to download that game. Phil Rice 12:57 And my understanding of that too is that that does not just apply to Valves own source engine games. Yeah, any any game that has gone through the process of properly registering those mods and delivering them to the Steam Workshop that that's all part of that's a brilliant, brilliant move on valves part to support that. So that means that games made by Bethesda that are heavily modded, like Fallout, for example, or Project Zomboid for that matter, that any any games that are delivering their mods that way, my understanding is that that's true for them too, which is really smart. Damien Valentine 13:35 And for games that don't use the Steam Workshop but still have big mod communities, you can still download those mods and install them manually, the same way that, or whatever the process is to install them, Phil Rice 13:47 you just on Steam. OS, you mean, yeah, because I didn't know that, I have not used it. Okay, that's okay. Damien Valentine 13:52 So you got the main interface was like a game console, like an Xbox or Playstation, where you just have big posters for the games and you click what you can play. There's desktop mode, which is basically a desktop version of Linux that you just go into. And it's a full PC experience if you want that. So Steam Machine will have that too, so you can Tracy Harwood 14:14 and am I right in saying that these are free, these mods are free. Yeah. So what's the incentive then, I mean, you know, it's not like the creator community that gets a share of ad revenue from from views. Say, if they get enough, what's the incentive here for the creators? Yeah, just the fun of it. Fun. Damien Valentine 14:35 Love of the game, making something for the community. Some, I think some Mod creators have, like, a donate button where you can Patreon Phil Rice 14:45 or, yeah, a lot of private donation channels for stuff like that. Certain modding communities outside of Steam, they've set up a monetized platform where the site itself generates ad revenue and they share it with the creators based on. And download stats. Curse Forge is one of them, which is mostly Minecraft stuff. There are little communities out there like that that do that. And it's, it's a pretty decent stream, but most of them, it's private donations. Yeah, that's, I'm sure some people who do this kind of work. Some of them do it for the same reason that that, you know, some of the the Machinima VIPs from from the lost boys and girls back in the day, right? They were doing it knowingly, hoping that it would be able to be effectively a resume item to get them work in this industry that they loved. You know, I know for a fact that at least some of the people who were doing it were doing it, knowing that that was a possibility, a possibility, hoping it was and for modders, even more so, you know, like to have the skills of someone like, you know, Paul Marino or Michelle or something where there it's cinematic storytelling. That's a pretty small portion of the video game community. You know, there's a relatively few, you know, comparatively few amount of jobs that are that specific skill set, but this, which involves, often programming and packaging of the things and modeling and texturing and all those skills. Yeah, someone who could demonstrate that not just say it on a piece of paper, that's got to be a huge advantage in a fiercely competitive job market. Damien Valentine 16:31 Isn't this version of the mod for the they remade Half Life in the Source engine, because this is not the original version of the game, if you look at the textures of Phil Rice 16:43 it, oh, no, no, yeah, this is for the remade. Yeah, Damien Valentine 16:45 right. So we know from just looking at machinima, the Source engine is incredibly complicated platform to use, yes, so it's Phil Rice 16:55 a big flex, yeah, to be able to do this, yeah, yeah, a lot of a lot of overlapping skills, including some that would be useful for machinima as well. But there's, there's modding is that's, that's some pretty big brain stuff going on there. Yeah, it's pretty neat. Yeah, some, yeah, the fact that so many people do that for, you know, let's face it, for what's the, what's the diplomatic way to say this less than full time income, yeah, if they have anything coming in at all, it's, it's a pittance compared to, you know, what full time work in this market would be. And yet they do it. And that's been going on for, well, for decades, yeah. Tracy Harwood 17:37 But the bit that strikes me, that's the interesting bit here is, you know, we all know what the visibility reward is for those that do the film side of it, but for these guys, they're almost hidden in the process, almost, you know, you kind of use it, but they're never top of what you see at the end of it. It's just, well, it's just, I mean, it's, it's a, it's a mod, and knowing that somebody's going to get some enjoyment out of having played the mod, Damien Valentine 18:08 that's basically it. It's great. Back when Command and Conquer Red Alert was released, which is a long time ago. Now it's about three decades long time ago it, yeah, it was love that game, me too, but included on the disk a map editor so you could build your own maps. And there were some very small geo cities websites where you could upload your maps for other Command and Conquer fans to download. So I did that. I made a few maps, and I kind of wish I still had them to see if they work with the remastered version game, right? It was just something fun to do, to create some new environments to play in. And I download other people's, and then people downloaded mine, because your little counter. And I can't remember how many got not that many. I think maybe 100 or something like that. It's just fun. I didn't, which was Phil Rice 19:01 no small deal back then. Well, no, I think I was about in the world of GeoCities, 100 download was like, Yeah. Damien Valentine 19:08 And, you know, I was, must have been about what, 12 years old. So for 12 year old, seeing that people that downloaded that map, I spent enough to do in creating that was, that was huge, yeah. Phil Rice 19:20 But I did that. I did that for the original Doom and Doom too, as well. Made some maps and learned a little bit about how modding worked and stuff. And, yeah, with without money, without money in mind at all. It was just, this will be fun. And I bet other people think this is fun. Damien Valentine 19:35 Yeah, that's it. It's like when we went to the New York missionary Film Festival. We're all there in that museum. And it wasn't there about money, it was just, we all make the stuff. We all like sharing it with each other, and we're having a great time meeting each other. It was the same thing with the mods. It's like, I made this thing, I'm going to share it with the rest of you, and I'm going to enjoy the stuff that you're sharing. It was the same kind of mentality Tracy Harwood 19:58 behind it, but this has been. Played 10s of 1000s of times, right? Yeah. So they've Damien Valentine 20:03 done a bit more than my Command and Conquer maps, yeah, Tracy Harwood 20:06 exactly, exactly, because the ending of it is so much more uplifting than what you explained as the actual end of the game. I think it's, it's, it is a lot of fun, and you can see why people would want to play it, because it does leave you on a bit more of a high. Yeah, very it's cool. It's a really interesting pick, and I really like it. And you have another pick as well, don't you? Phil Rice 20:36 Well, somebody put this on here. I'm not sure if it was, oh, wasn't it? You? Was it? Was it? Damien Valentine 20:41 Damien, did you know it wasn't me? Phil Rice 20:45 Put this, but, yeah, we'll include it a link to this as well. I'm not going to do a full review of it. Oh, it might have been me, you know, it might have been you. But Ryan Gosling in Half Life two, and it's one of these kind of and we've, we've covered content of this, this type, at various times. But this, it's one of these. It's a compositing masterpiece of scenes of Ryan Gosling from, I think, mostly from the movie drive, yeah, if not all. Really good movie, by the way, even better book, but scenes from that, you know, overlaid with, you know, goings on in Half Life two and it's, it's, it's fun. Damien Valentine 21:31 It's really well done, too. That shot from above where he's beating someone up, but the shot of the game, of the person being beaten up perfectly matches each punch. That's a huge amount of work to go into that, because you can't change the Ryan Gosling footage. Phil Rice 21:49 It reminds me a lot of the you found an example of one of these a few months back, where it was red, dead, redemption two, I think it was John Wick, yeah, that was John Wick. And read, yeah, yeah. That kind of thing where there's just some really careful timing and coordination and lighting, a lot of attention to that kind of stuff. So, yeah, it's a it's a fun little things. We'll include that as well. Tracy Harwood 22:13 But this is not modded Damien Valentine 22:17 a little bit for the some of the cut scenes, like that punching I was talking about the matter of fact the time the punching modified the animation or something. But I don't know. I don't know. Phil Rice 22:27 I don't know what. I don't know what, as far as, like, what machinima elements were THIS to THIS of my of manipulating the game and stuff that I'm not sure about. Tracy Harwood 22:35 Okay, yeah, okay, well, two really interesting films for slightly different reasons. I think Phil slightly out of my depth commenting, though, because obviously I don't, I don't play it, but I could see where you were going with it. And I think it's, it's a fascinating way of extending the gameplay. For sure. Phil Rice 22:53 Yeah, absolutely. Well, audience, what did you think? Let us know in the comments wherever you're watching or listening to this, or drop us an email at talk at completely machinima.com my name is Phil rice, and on behalf of my co hosts, Damian Valentine and Tracy Harwood, we will see you next time bye.