Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Carvana’s “Grift For The Ages”, Tesla’s Drop In Deliveries, Cursive Coming Back
Transcript
- 0:00Oh, I still get used to the new record button, but it's Friday, January 3rd. [laughs] This is the end of the, like, five days that will start on the normal 2025- Yeah, right...
- 0:11because no one seems to know what day it is. [laughs] Yesterday, I can't tell you how many times- Someone told me yesterday, they were like, "Have we had seven Mondays in the last two weeks?" Like, what happened?
- 0:21How did that work? Yesterday, all day, I was referring to Tuesday as Friday. Oh. I was like, "Well, we talked about this on Friday,"
- 0:28because, like, Wednesday- Even though it wasn't Tuesday, it was Thursday, and it was not Friday yet... see, we didn't have this problem when we worked retail, right?
- 0:37'Cause you know exactly what day it is, because you're working. It's New Year's Day, because you're working. Just, you know, we don't have that anymore. [laughs] We don't have that. We're on the other side.
- 0:47It's been all a mess. We're on the other side. We're ready for next Monday, reset, be on time. You know what I mean? Yeah. Right, [laughs] exactly. Yeah. Um, hey, a bunch of stuff going on.
- 0:54Make sure you go to nadaparties.com- Yep... and, uh, check out our party, but also check out our sponsors, check out all the other parties that are listed. Uh, we're pl- over between 20 and 30 right now.
- 1:05There's gonna be more. This is gonna be the authoritative guide to what you're doing after the show, every day at NADA. Make sure, if you have a party going on, you submit it on the site so we can post it.
- 1:17Doesn't cost anything to post your party up there. Uh- Yep... we'll make sure we get the info and links and, uh, get some people coming your way. Maybe we'll stop by and visit, too. Yeah. That's...
- 1:27Uh, it's really selfish, because we're like, "How do we... Once we're done with ours, how do we- How do we know where we're going?... how do we plan the rest?" [laughs] I know.
- 1:34We'll just build the parties- It's, it's kind of for you-... site... but it's also for us, you know what I mean? Yeah. This is the way that we do that.
- 1:38And we want, want to thank our friends at Clairvoy for helping us make nadaparties.com possible. Yep. Absolutely. It takes a little bit of a village to make sure everyone knows where they're going. Yeah. You know?
- 1:47It's okay. Hey, Paul, did you know that next week- Uh-oh... next week- I feel it... we are planning... Oh, I haven't told you the day. I don't think we even know the day- [laughs]...
- 1:55that we're gonna be fully dropping the ASOTU CON website, the tickets, the app. I didn't know that. It's all coming in hot. So there were some people that, uh, got early tickets.
- 2:04If you wanna be the first person to know that there are tickets available, still go to asotucon.com and you can sign up, be on the email list.
- 2:13There's a few hundred people right now that are waiting on, uh, o- like, waiting on their knees, just hoping that they'll be the first one to get in. So, uh, you can, you can get that information.
- 2:25We'll have some basic schedule, all that type of stuff up. And also, if you were at ASOTU CON last year, and you have the app on your phone still, like I do- Yep, yep... you will notice the icon is now updated.
- 2:37So it's got the new- Oh... ASOTU CON app. That's great. App adoption, by the way, our app usage last year was through the roof. It was nuts. It's a really- It's a great app... good app. Yeah.
- 2:44Yeah, and so, uh, if you are, like, always wanted to go to a conference with a good app, you're about to go to one. You're gonna do it. Yeah. And the date. There you go. Hey, so I, we, every day we put out this email.
- 2:53Um, it's, um, the daily... W- what do we even call it? The Daily Pushback. The Daily Pushback. The Daily Pushback. Yeah. I was the troublemaker, the pushback, it's the things. But it's a daily email.
- 3:01It gives you a quick digest of what's going on, has a lot of fun stuff, and I thought I'd share a few things from it this morning, because it's so much fun. Um- There's some good stuff, yeah...
- 3:09oh, somebody's bringing me coffee. I'm so excited when someone- Oh... brings me coffee on the live stream. Thank you. Oh, my goodness. [laughs] That's awesome. Bringing you coffee on the live stream. Look at that.
- 3:17Can you imagine? Thanks to you. Can you believe that? [laughs] That's unbelievable. So, um, in eight- we always include some fun facts, um, in the bottom of the email, like this day in history.
- 3:27In 1899, this day in history, the first use of the word automobile happened in The New York Times. That's crazy. 1899. Yeah. That kind of is shocking to me.
- 3:39I always think of, like, the 1900s as the car, but you know, the 1890s, things were starting to, like, warm up, and, and people were starting- Yeah, they moved the-... to make these things...
- 3:47I, I wonder if they, like, uh, probably that article- I-... I wonder if we can find it. They probably was the first, like, tossing across the net, like, maybe we shouldn't say motor carriage. Right. You know what I mean?
- 3:57Like, [laughs] maybe we should say this other- Golly, that's, that's such a wild, like- Yep... January 3rd- Uh, that felt good... 1899. It was a little bit of media- Yeah...
- 4:04a little bit of, you know what I mean, what we're in. Yeah. Also, this day- What we do, yeah... mem- 'member, 'member the brand Pontiac? Oh, that sad brand. 1926.
- 4:12And we're doing so- No, Pontiacs were- I think they were just ahead of their time... dope. They were so cool. Yeah. And then they got- So cool... so mid, um, you know, [laughs] toward the end of the years.
- 4:20But 1926, the first Pontiac came out. I would drive an old Pontiac. Yeah. Maybe that's you and me. Like, maybe like, you know, like, down the line a little bit- I would...
- 4:28Yeah, the, it's- We're gonna, we're gonna get some old muscle cars, like, you know, old GTO- What we need to do is, we need an old Pontiac to go around, like, like, that we ship to the next More Than Cars- That's a good idea...
- 4:38and that's what we drive around the city when we're doing More Than Cars. Look, if you have a car that's amazing, that you wanna let us use for our More Than Cars intros, outros on our s- You just ship that over...
- 4:46we will do it. Just putting that out there. Yeah. We will do it. All right, let's talk about some news. Um- Let's get into it... this has been k- it was kind of the talk yesterday. I didn't see too much- For sure...
- 4:55about it, but Hindenburg Research, known for exposing automotive startups like Nikola and Lordstown Motors, has published a scathing report on used car retailer Carvana, alleging questionable accounting practices and underwriting concerns.
- 5:09Basically, they're saying Carvana sold $800 million in loans to a suspected related party, um, and used accounting manipulation to inflate profits.
- 5:19They allegedly sold the vehicles to DriveTime, as we know, a company founded and owned by Ernie Garcia II, the father of Ernie Garcia, who we all know, uh, who runs Carvana. Um, and they inflate...
- 5:29They're saying they inflated the prices to invo- avoid recording markdowns, you know, and keeping profits high. A former- Yep... director reported, uh, reportedly, they did all these employee interviews.
- 5:38I read about the process, right? It's really in-depth. They go Freedom of Information Act. They in- interview former employees. They claim Carvana approved 100% of every loan applicant- That's unbelievable...
- 5:48suggesting they took on all this risk to show higher sales. Uh, Carvana shares did drop 1.9% following the report, closing at under 200 now.
- 5:57The company called the report, however, you know, Carvana, Ernie, the PR department said, "This is intentionally misleading and inaccurate," asserting a focus, that their focus is on learn- long-term growth, and everything they're doing, it being part of their strategy.
- 6:11You can read the full X thread, um, on our LinkedIn page. But I mean, like, you know- Here's, here's what... Uh, okay, couple things on this. OneI-
- 6:21I think people, at least in the industry, and I think why this isn't, like, as big a news, like 30 people not posting on LinkedIn about it yesterday- Yep...
- 6:30is some of the stuff I feel has been kind of known, that they've leveraged- Drivetime... Drivetime, their finance- Absolutely... companies to, like, accelerate retail. Um, so, you know, whether or not the spin on
- 6:47this is how they, quote unquote, "inflated prices" or took on riskier loans, like, that's kind of the business strategy, to take on riskier loans- To grow the customer base... to grab more market share. Absolutely.
- 6:57And so- Um... that- that's a really good insight... which is why I think it, it, like, after the report, you would think a- a report like this as- as, quote unquote, "scathing" as it would be- It was...
- 7:06would see a 5, 10% drop, um, in- in shares, and you're not seeing that. So I think there's some wisdom out there on... So I wouldn't go running at, like, you know, "Ah, burn the ships!" I knew it. You know? Yeah.
- 7:19Yeah, yeah. Exactly. Yeah. I mean, and- and time is, time will tell, right? It's, we're in a media environment where one thing comes out and the reflex to, like, pile on the person being accused- Yep...
- 7:30has kind of been the norm, but that temperature seems to be changing pretty quickly. Um, and I hope this is, you know, I hope that there's nothing shady going on. I hope- I know, right?...
- 7:39that, uh, yeah, you know, every time I've- I've met or talked to or interviewed Ernie Garcia, F- CEO of Carvana, he's been really great, really nice. Right. Yep. Shared his insights with the industry. Um, and we'll see.
- 7:49But- but that's the news, folks. Yeah. Ta-da. That's the news. Oh, [laughs] speak- I have to say, like, what a recovery, and also the things that Carvana has brought an impetus for our industry to change
- 8:02are, like- Oh, we can thank them-... we would've never done it... a thousand times over for that... had Carvana not- not been there. Speaking of another company that forced us to do things we weren't gonna do.
- 8:10[upbeat music] That's right. Segway time. In a Segway. That's a long Segway, but it's a good one. I just had to get it out. It's a long, it's a long Segway, but it's a good one. It's, I mean, it's Friday.
- 8:16I'm proud of you. Fridays are- Yeah... for long Segways. Tesla's [laughs] Q4 production and delivery numbers are in, making a challenging end to 2024 for the EV giant, with its first annual drop in deliveries ever.
- 8:28I think since 2011. Wow. Right? Like, when they were just getting started. That's wild. They delivered, they delivered 1.78 million vehicles in 2024, falling short of the 1.81, uh, delivered in 2023.
- 8:39Q4 deliveries hit 495,000, falling short of analyst expectations of 500,000. So they're just coming in under. Just under. But the story is that it's under.
- 8:48It's the first time they've taken a step back in overall deliveries. The shares dropped 7% following the report, despite a 63% rally in 2023, or 2024.
- 8:58Um, declining sales in Europe, slower growth in China, BYD and Hyundai gaining market share.
- 9:03Some experts worry that Musk's $277 million support for President Trump and his advisory role, advisory role may have diverted focus from Tesla's operations. Doubt it. Yeah. [laughs] I don't either.
- 9:16Patrick George, editor-in-chief of InsideEVs said, quote, "Tesla still does many things better than any other EV maker, but the challenge remains the nuts and bolts job of being a car company."
- 9:28It- it will continually be hard for the- harder for them as new entrants make it.
- 9:33I- I would be interested, and I- I didn't look at the specific details, but I would be interested to see the growth in the US ver- versus- Oh... the growth in China. Mm-hmm. Right?
- 9:42'Cause it, I'm- I'm gonna look that up actually today, because, uh, I would suspect that there was still growth in the US, but that they, but that they got beat in, uh, overseas- China...
- 9:53markets, especially- Oh, especially BYD... in China. Yeah. Uh, because of BYD and other automakers in China. Uh, and that was a major market for them always. So, uh, you know, I- I still, like, was there a distraction?
- 10:06No, because there's a legit amount of people that are doing the work day in and day out. Yeah. And we've had the fortunate opportunity to meet some of those that have been inside of it.
- 10:16Um, and, uh, yeah, so I, like, they're doing fine, fam.
- 10:22I don't think- The Cybertruck, I will say, the Cybertruck, I've seen [laughs] more Cybertrucks on used car lots than I ever would've thought in the first year of them being delivered, so- That's true. That's true...
- 10:32people are obviously trying to flip those. We'll see what happens when they do the price drop. Nathan, our producer, puts in a note, they're also struggling in Europe, right? Yep. No BYD cars in Europe yet, right?
- 10:41Is that true? Can you buy a BYD- No, no, no. BYD's in Europe. Okay. Yeah. Well, anywhere- Yeah... BYD is, right? [laughs] In general. Anywhere BYD is, Tesla's struggling probably.
- 10:49Um, I will say, though, I don't think it has anything to do with him being on the campaign trail for President Trump. No. Yeah. Because that's not, I mean, the a- I see from, like- Look... the conventional wisdom, right?
- 11:02I mean, it probably has more to do- Yeah... with him being the number one video game player on whatever that game is than the Trump thing. Oh. [laughs] That's probably the- I don't think he sleeps.
- 11:11That's the whole thing, actually. No. I don't think he actually sleeps. Yeah, I think, I think he'll be fine. Yeah, I mean, we're...
- 11:17The s- [laughs] One of the companies, SpaceX, is literally catching rockets with chopsticks. Yeah. [laughs] Like, come on, guys. They're doing fine. That- You know? That had nothing to do with it either. I know.
- 11:24Like, how are you gonna peg this- I know. Yeah, I don't know. I don't know. Speaking of having nothing to do with it. [upbeat music] Yeah. Or maybe- Segway time... maybe everything to do with it, actually.
- 11:31Maybe everything. We're about to change the entire ASOTU brand and bring back Skip because Lord & Taylor has done it.
- 11:38[laughs] They've turned back the clock, reviving its cursive logo as it prepares to relaunch an online discount luxury retailer under new ownership, Regal Bla- Brands Global.
- 11:48The classic script logo, first introduced in 1945, replaces the modern sans serif wordmark, which the new leadership called the biggest betrayal- Oh... of the brand. Look at that.
- 11:59Um, founded in 1826, Lord & Taylor is embracing its legacy, branding itself as the signature of American style for its digital comeback.
- 12:07Um, obviously we've seen over the last 10 years a lot of brands move away from cursive and into sans serif style logos.
- 12:15Um, the, uh, the brand's, uh, Regal Brands Global strategy s- chief officer, uh, Sinja Jeno, said, "I understand going after young customers, but this?"... is not a startup. All right, I have thoughts on this.
- 12:29[laughs] Number one, when they first changed it, it was like a major diss. They were like, "We don't think millennials can read cursive." [laughs] Oh, juicy. That's literally was one of the issues. Yeah. Yep.
- 12:39Um, there is so m- I think there's so many right reasons to d- make this change go back. Uh, I think we're in the middle of this, like the pendulum always swings on fonts, on branding. Yep.
- 12:51And I think the pendulum is starting to shift back away from the clean, plain font, right? Like, we're kind of at the end of that cycle. They're still really popular.
- 13:00Lord & Taylor, people, if you do a good job with the brand, people will know what it means, people will know what it says. Yep. And I think l- the, the cursive one, it just has so much more character. That one, uh, uh,
- 13:13e- especially them, because they went with, like, an extremely rigid, basic sans serif font. Yeah. Yeah, I don't know what they were going for there.
- 13:20Um, I, I, it's almost like, it's like a Montserrat lookalike, so- It's, like, expanded... a very kinda like standard type thing. And you go and look at the, the original thing- Yeah...
- 13:29that they're bringing back, the, it is dynamic. You can see it on the screen if you're watching. It's dynamic. It's cool. It stands out. I'd put that on a shirt. Nobody else is doing it. Yeah. I'd put that on a shirt.
- 13:37You throw that on a shirt, it's like, "Oh, I know what, I know what that brand is." Yeah. I, I'm not quite sure, but I think that is the actual handwriting of, like, an influential person back then in the brand.
- 13:46Like, that was their handwriting script. That's cool. So it's got a story to it. Awesome job. They closed the Lord & Taylor in Syracuse. I used to really love that store.
- 13:54I'm not a big department store person, but for some reason, the Lord & Taylor store was, like, this nice in-between between, like, Macy's and Nordstrom. We don't have Nordstrom either. It's Syracuse. Yeah.
- 14:03[laughs] We have Nor- we have Nordstrom Rack. We don't have Nordstrom either. [laughs] We have Nordstrom Rack.
- 14:08Have you e- Well, and, and I think, like, to, to speak to s- you know, some of even, like, the legacy automakers that are trying to, to, to rewrite their brands- Mm-hmm...
- 14:19um, you know, this is gonna be something where I think we see more people go back to origin stories in their brands and recognize that that, that was a powerful thing. Yep. Um, I will say,
- 14:29origin stories of car logo brands that have the little, like, shadow car, that's not what we're talking about here. That's not an origin story. You can still get rid of that thing, okay? [laughs] No.
- 14:38If you can go on Fiverr and see your logo in the first three- [laughs] Go to Fiverr, F-I-V-E-R-R.com, type in automotive logo, and if your logo looks anything like what comes up in the first page of search results- Yeah...
- 14:53call your boys. It's time to change the logo. Call your boys. We'll help you. We can make a little bit of it. [laughs] I don't know what we're doing out here this morning. [laughs] I don't know what that's all about.
- 14:59Look, we hope you end the week strong. Look, going into the first weekend of the year for all of our dealer friends- Let's go... it's gonna be a good one this year. 2025, tons of momentum. Go out there and get it.
- 15:09We'll see you tomorrow. [upbeat music]