Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Assisted and Other Mergers with Mike Macchiarola of Olden Lane
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03Today, I'm with Mike Macchiarola from Olden Lane.
- 0:06Mike, how are you doing today?
- 0:08Mike Mac: Doing pretty well.
- 0:09Good to be with you, Mark.
- 0:10Treichel: Yeah.
- 0:10Good to be with you.
- 0:11We've had a couple other podcasts we've done on the NCUA's.
- 0:16Annual plan and perhaps a couple other topics.
- 0:18But today, let's see earlier this summer or in this summer in August,
- 0:22you wrote an article with Kevin Maitleke navigating an opportunity
- 0:27for an NCOA assisted transaction.
- 0:30And after taking a look at that, it intrigued me that I thought
- 0:33this might be something worthy of chatting with you on the podcast.
- 0:37But before we dive into that.
- 0:39Mike, if you could give a little bit of your background and what Old and
- 0:42Lane does for credit unions for people who may not have heard those previous
- 0:47podcasts that I made reference to.
- 0:49Mike Mac: Sure.
- 0:49All the lane at this point is about 7 years old.
- 0:53We originally started because we thought there was an opportunity where
- 0:57credit unions were being underserved, most notably in the capital markets.
- 1:02The 1st thing we really did was we focused our attention on what
- 1:06was at the time called secondary capital now called subordinated debt.
- 1:10At the time, I believe it was about 100 million dollars outstanding in that space.
- 1:14Now it's north of four and a half billion outstanding and Olden Lane
- 1:19has done more of those transactions as advisor than anyone else in
- 1:23the space by a pretty good margin.
- 1:25We really believe that credit unions could use sub debt as a growth tool.
- 1:31Up until that point, it was really used for credit unions that were struggling.
- 1:34It was meant as really triage and use properly as a growth function.
- 1:39It could really accelerate what credit unions were able to do for its members.
- 1:43So we've been very excited to do well, north of a billion dollars
- 1:47of transactions in that space.
- 1:49We've taken probably 60 credit unions across the threshold with
- 1:52the regulatory approval required.
- 1:54The space has grown by leaps and bounds, a lot of the
- 1:57complexity that's in that space.
- 1:59And some of the newer structures are thoughts originally of our clients
- 2:04and or the folks here at Olden Lane.
- 2:06So we're very proud of that.
- 2:08In about the last year or so, Mark, honestly, a lot of our attention has moved
- 2:12to the M& A space, which we'll get into some a subset of that today, but the M&
- 2:17A space is hot as a pistol, whether it be credit union to credit union merger.
- 2:22Or the credit union purchase of banks or bank assets.
- 2:26That has been something that obviously in 2024 has been very pronounced.
- 2:31Whether we were lucky or smart, we saw a lot of that coming.
- 2:34We had spent a lot of attention with white papers and thought
- 2:38pieces and internal discussions.
- 2:40Study to get that business up and running.
- 2:43We now have a full throated business that can do everything from identifying
- 2:47and screening targets to working on the merger binders for the NCOA and
- 2:52all the regulatory approvals to doing everything required in the valuation
- 2:55suite, both credit union to credit union and credit union to bank.
- 2:59So we're very proud of that.
- 3:00We've built our team out and that's really an exciting feature of what we
- 3:04can do now and builds out a lot of the suite of offerings that we have here.
- 3:09Treichel: No, that's great.
- 3:10I know every year since I've started at NCUA, 300 credit unions seem to go
- 3:15away and it's probably in the 200s now because once the law of large numbers
- 3:19or small numbers, now we're down between what, 4, 500, 4, 600 charters, but
- 3:24it's just the reality of any business that there's going to be mergers and
- 3:29then with what we've gone through here recently, I think you were smart to.
- 3:33To see where the puck was going on this, because I think there's
- 3:36going to be an intense period here for a lot of reasons that whether
- 3:40it's fee income being attacked or.
- 3:42Low losses going up, et cetera, et cetera.
- 3:44It's definitely arena.
- 3:46Where that's going to be increasing as a percentage of remaining
- 3:50charters versus decreasing despite.
- 3:53Efforts to push things in the other directions, if you will, but so in that
- 3:56regard, the article that I made reference to and NCUA assisted transactions, of
- 4:03course, there's merger where credit union a wants to merge with credit union B,
- 4:08and they both have 12 percent capital.
- 4:11They're both in the same field of membership, any town USA, and the field
- 4:15membership fits together perfectly.
- 4:17That's one variety.
- 4:19I've never seen
- 4:20Mike Mac: that one.
- 4:20Incidentally, that one doesn't come around a lot of often.
- 4:24Happy to work on it, though.
- 4:25Treichel: And we are not here to talk about those simple ones.
- 4:28We're going to talk about one that where NCUA might have to kick some money in.
- 4:32And so if you could maybe walk through what you've gleaned from that process,
- 4:37and as it relates to this article that you wrote relative to that one particular
- 4:41transactions or other things that you're seeing at this arena recently.
- 4:46Okay.
- 4:46Mike Mac: Perfect.
- 4:47Perfect.
- 4:48The first thing I'd say is we anticipate that we will see
- 4:51more of these on the horizon.
- 4:53And you've alluded to some of the reasons why, but just to
- 4:57give you a little backdrop, in 2022, there were six failures.
- 5:00And those failures cost the NCAA insurance fund.
- 5:049.
- 5:058 million.
- 5:05So a touch under 10 million in 2023, there were three failed
- 5:10credit unions that cost the fund 1.
- 5:122 million.
- 5:14So that trend line has been good, but so far this year, there's
- 5:17going to be more than that.
- 5:19There's more than that we've seen in the market or have been working
- 5:21with clients on, including the one that you alluded to with Kevin.
- 5:25But there's a difficult environment out there as you well know, right?
- 5:28If you just look at the share insurance.
- 5:30Financial report, which comes out every quarter.
- 5:32And I know you look at it intently more than 10 percent of our credit unions
- 5:36are now in a camel three, four or five.
- 5:38I know that's a number that you watch in the greater than 500 million asset
- 5:43class camel fours and fives tripled.
- 5:47They went from three to nine in the last report, the last quarter camel
- 5:5166 credit unions above 500 million.
- 5:57And when I look at the camels that are 3, 4, or 5 across the whole
- 6:01country, almost 20 percent of credit unions are now a 3, 4, or 5.
- 6:06That's 879 of that roughly 4, 500 base.
- 6:10Number 1 is, if the NCOA is good at tagging these things,
- 6:14we've got some difficulties.
- 6:16Ongoing or ahead of us.
- 6:18We can also look at profitability.
- 6:20ROA is at 69 basis points in the last quarter.
- 6:25If I just took out and normalized for COVID and took out the dip
- 6:29that happened when COVID really struck, that's the lowest it's
- 6:32been in the industry for a decade.
- 6:34That's a problem, right?
- 6:36I know we're a not for profit, but you need that engine of profitability
- 6:42to be higher than 69 basis points as an industry, certainly.
- 6:46There are 764 credit unions in the country that have zero or negative ROA.
- 6:51That's a significant number.
- 6:53You've got 1, 300 plus credit unions that aren't earning 25 basis points.
- 6:59And that's a difficult environment and it really starts to question
- 7:03your go forward strategy.
- 7:05We've all known what the drivers are.
- 7:07We've got cost of funds that are rising.
- 7:09We've got, I think we're a little further along now in the cycle where
- 7:12we're going to start to care about asset quality and the delinquencies.
- 7:15And we've seen that number start to tick up and continue to tick up.
- 7:18And that trend line is troubling.
- 7:20There are good signs, right?
- 7:21Nim hangs in.
- 7:23I think we're probably peaked in the interest rate cycle.
- 7:26But at the same time, you really have to have your wits about you to
- 7:31keep both sides of that balance sheet moving along and maintain your spread.
- 7:35So we're going to see folks struggle.
- 7:37The tech cycle, the regulatory cycle, the fee compression or fee pressure.
- 7:43All of those are going to make it increasingly difficult, and I think it
- 7:47gets more and more difficult as you're down in asset level, simply because you
- 7:52have not picked up the scale to be able to be nimble enough into those headwinds.
- 7:58We see a lot of that coming.
- 8:00Long winded way of saying more NCUA assisted mergers on the horizon.
- 8:04Now, why?
- 8:05What is an NCUA assisted merger?
- 8:07When a credit union decides.
- 8:10Or the NCA decides for them that it is not going to survive as a going concern.
- 8:16You've got 4 options.
- 8:18You can voluntarily liquidate.
- 8:21You can have an involuntary liquidation.
- 8:23You can have an involuntary liquidation where you have some
- 8:26purchase and assumption behind.
- 8:29Or let's focus in on what we want to talk about today.
- 8:31A merger.
- 8:33The first thing to say is if you get to a place where you have a merger, do
- 8:40it sooner rather than later, because that allows you to have a voluntary
- 8:45merger, which allows for some bilateral negotiation, which allows you to protect
- 8:51the constituencies you should care about.
- 8:54If you get beyond that point, we are now in a situation where Assisted land where
- 9:00the NCA has nudged you or pushed you and you've got a merger where you don't
- 9:07control the terms or the negotiation.
- 9:09So you're already in a place where as the target or as the merging credit
- 9:15union, it's going to be uncomfortable.
- 9:18And frankly, you waited too long.
- 9:21Treichel: Yeah, I totally 100 percent agree with that.
- 9:24The verbiage I would use at NCUA when I was meeting with credit unions
- 9:28or my staff was meeting with credit unions was self determination, right?
- 9:33At some juncture, you're going to lose that self determination.
- 9:36And if you're looking for the best fit culture wise, because culture is very
- 9:42important in the world we live in.
- 9:44It's very important in the credit union industry.
- 9:47Where's the best fit when you still have a little bit of capital before you
- 9:51start, before you go from making 100 basis points to making 50 basis points
- 9:56to making 25 basis points to losing money to the capital ratio going down to NCUA.
- 10:01By the way, you mentioned the camel codes deterioration.
- 10:05There's a country western sign.
- 10:07How can I miss you if you won't go away?
- 10:10And NCOA does not go away once you become a Code 5 or a Code 4.
- 10:15And when you're a Code 3, they're there every six months.
- 10:17When you're a 2 starting to slip to be a 3, or you're well capitalized,
- 10:23but contemplating being adequately capitalized, and you're sitting down and
- 10:26doing that long term strategic planning on what's the long term plan look like,
- 10:31There's just the reality that many of those unprofitable credit unions, you
- 10:35mentioned what's about almost 800 that are losing money, almost 1300 with
- 10:4125 basis points or less, they need to look at that and say, okay, what's in
- 10:45the best interest of the membership?
- 10:47What's in the best interest of our staff?
- 10:49How can we best serve our community?
- 10:51Our select employee group?
- 10:52Etc.
- 10:53Because if you can avoid the NCWA assistance arena, you do
- 10:56have that self determination.
- 10:58Mike Mac: I couldn't have said it any better, Mark.
- 11:00And here's the thing that when we counsel credit unions that are on this knife's
- 11:05edge, there's so much pride involved.
- 11:08And I get it.
- 11:09We all have pride in what we do, where we work, what our business is.
- 11:12But I want to explain to folks, and I oftentimes I just want to, I just want
- 11:17to tell them we've seen it enough times that we know and we're not fibbing.
- 11:24The world has changed.
- 11:27Things change needs change.
- 11:30So the world doesn't need a single seg credit union for the purpose
- 11:36of a single seg credit union.
- 11:37There are other places that the members there can find banking.
- 11:41Banking services are available.
- 11:43The nature of banking services has changed what people demand or want
- 11:48from in terms of convenience or price or deposit level is different.
- 11:54And it's okay if you just can't.
- 11:58Make it as profitable as you could 5, 10, 15 years ago in a different environment.
- 12:04And I know there's a lot of pride, but you really have to
- 12:07go back to basic fiduciary duty.
- 12:10And you've got to understand why am I in this chair as either a manager, a member
- 12:13of management or a member of a board.
- 12:16And really, I've got to go back to the basics and the foundational principle.
- 12:20And we're going to say, what is in the best interest of members?
- 12:23And very often we find ourselves counseling a credit union that is holding
- 12:27on for dear life And they say, we started as a credit union in Northeast State X,
- 12:35and by gum, we're going to go down and it's, there's nothing wrong with it.
- 12:39The world's just moved a little bit away from you.
- 12:42And really your job is to tuck your members in.
- 12:45And very often I will open up.
- 12:47I'll say, okay, give me the credit union near you that you
- 12:50think's doing well, or give me a bigger credit union up the block.
- 12:54And I'll just put the 2 websites up and I'll say, look at what they
- 12:57have and look at what you have.
- 12:58Let's go through the level on deposits and the level on loans.
- 13:01Let's go for the convenience of a member.
- 13:03Let's go for the branch network.
- 13:04Let's go for the community outreach.
- 13:07The bigger and or the more sophisticated slash more efficient is just able
- 13:13to do more very often and has a lot more levers they can play.
- 13:18And that's okay.
- 13:20And it's sometimes okay to give up your name or your brand.
- 13:25And honestly, again, go back to self determination.
- 13:27If you make those choices earlier, you can have something to say about.
- 13:32How your members are treated, how your staff is protected, how your
- 13:37board of directors has a say in the going forward, how the community
- 13:41investment that you've made may be preserved or the legacy or the heritage.
- 13:46If you supported an event every year, put a maintenance clause in your merger
- 13:50agreement and make them keep doing it.
- 13:51If you have a set of scholarships.
- 13:54Make the acquiring credit union that you can bilaterally
- 13:57negotiate with double that.
- 13:59And then you've made a negotiation and you've done it on your terms and
- 14:03you've preserved something rather than let this thing go too long.
- 14:07In which case, as you said, you don't have enough control in the N.
- 14:10C.
- 14:10U.
- 14:10A.
- 14:10Is going to dictate.
- 14:12Treichel: That's a great.
- 14:12Yeah, I love those examples like the scholarship fund and Yeah.
- 14:16Building into your agreements, some things that give you some of what
- 14:20you've been able to build and make sure that legacy of how you're helping
- 14:25your particular members, as opposed to how they might choose that you build
- 14:29some of that into those negotiations, which is all okay with NCUA.
- 14:33NCUA is going to ask that and the merger rules ask that if there's You know,
- 14:38senior executive staff, or I can't remember exactly how they phrase it.
- 14:41Certain staff members, if there's going to be.
- 14:43Commitments in that regard that there needs to be things that
- 14:46are disclosed to the members.
- 14:48But as long as that's reasonable, that's something that, you know, that
- 14:51the members will support when they can see all the other things that
- 14:54they may be getting out of the merger.
- 14:56Any thoughts on anything I threw out there.
- 14:59Mike Mac: No, I think you're right.
- 14:59I think there's also for another day, but I think, and this is an
- 15:04issue that a lot of commentators had.
- 15:05Chip Filson beats this one up pretty good.
- 15:08Sometimes in these credit union mergers, there should be more
- 15:11consideration paid than there is.
- 15:12And so the question of a member dividend shouldn't necessarily be driven by a
- 15:17somewhat arbitrary rule at the NCOA when you're above a certain threshold or the
- 15:22distance between the 2 is at a threshold.
- 15:25Maybe sometimes a credit union should be willing to pay.
- 15:28To unlock the equity or the tradition or the heritage and to pay for the
- 15:32inconvenience to the membership of a name change and account numbers and
- 15:36all that has to happen on a merger.
- 15:38I'd love to see where credit union started to pay significant or real dividends,
- 15:43especially when you look at credit unions that are choosing to merge with banks.
- 15:47Or do bank deals where they're paying a multiple of the equity
- 15:51to shareholders in those banks.
- 15:52And so they're paying an awful lot of money.
- 15:55And in many cases, it would be easier for them to merge with another credit union.
- 15:59It's just that there are so many frictions around the pride and the personal.
- 16:05And I say all the time, those of us that are bankers in this space, It's incumbent
- 16:11upon us, Olden Lane, myself included, to articulate the value proposition
- 16:16to a potential merging credit union, to cutting that deal in this instance,
- 16:21before the NCUA gets here and makes you, because it'll be better but also
- 16:25where it's to your advantage to, to tuck in your members at an institution
- 16:30that together may be able to do more than either could do separately.
- 16:34Treichel: But as you're walking through that with the, before NCOA makes you do
- 16:38it, a thought just came into my mind.
- 16:42You think you can control that, but I'll know when it's time, right?
- 16:46I'll know when NCOA is about to tell me it's time to go away.
- 16:49And that's not the reality of what happens.
- 16:51Sometimes credit unions go from a code two to a code four, they go from a
- 16:55two to a three, they get a letter of understanding and agreement, whether
- 16:58it's a new program or just the reality of the economy in your area, kidding you.
- 17:05It's like doing the annual physicals, going to the doctor.
- 17:09Going to the dentist, getting things done and doing things when it makes sense.
- 17:13If you wait and you wait, you defer, you have all that deferred maintenance
- 17:16on your, how you're taking care of your health and you think at some
- 17:20point in time, you're just going to be able to pivot and okay, so now
- 17:23I've gained 25 point pounds, I'm going to go out and run a marathon, right?
- 17:26You're just not going to be able to do that physically.
- 17:28You're not going to be able to do that as a credit union.
- 17:31If you're thinking NCUA will give me some sort of warning when it's
- 17:35time for me to potentially merge.
- 17:37You really need to think it through.
- 17:38You really need to.
- 17:40Contemplate it because when N2A gets aggressive on it, it's too late.
- 17:46Mike Mac: And listen, they have a job to do.
- 17:47They've got 4, 000 folks that they have to oversee.
- 17:51They've got a share insurance fund that they're responsible for.
- 17:54And the last thing they are incented to do is wait too long.
- 17:57And we have this issue, which we've written about over here, the way the
- 18:02credit unions are dispersed, there's a significant number of credit unions that
- 18:06are below the 50 or a hundred million dollar watermark, like a large number.
- 18:11And when you look at that and you realize, Those guys that are very big
- 18:17are doing things that are complex that require more regulatory oversight.
- 18:21But at the same time, there are just so many that are small that
- 18:25also require a visit and an exam.
- 18:28It's a very difficult recipe for the NCOA.
- 18:31You start getting this barbell effect where they've got to really have a whole
- 18:36different level of scrutiny for the big guys because they're sophisticated.
- 18:40And then the little guys, there's just a lot of them.
- 18:43And it can get very difficult and unwieldy both as a regulator and as someone trying
- 18:48to run either of those institutions.
- 18:50The other thing is.
- 18:51The world doesn't work on your time.
- 18:53You may have the greatest plan in the world, but things
- 18:55happen and events change.
- 18:57We've had some significant natural disasters for goodness sakes.
- 19:00They change your business plan immensely.
- 19:03And in a second.
- 19:05So you really have to understand and go through these drills.
- 19:10It was good to see the NCWA, for example, go through a succession release.
- 19:15It forces people to think about a lot of issues that they could otherwise
- 19:18get away with not thinking about.
- 19:20And you need to have that rigor in your organization.
- 19:23Frankly, I wrote a comment letter.
- 19:24I wish they had gone further.
- 19:26But it's a start, right?
- 19:28We have to think about all of these things because the risk at an organization like
- 19:31this is multifaceted and very complex.
- 19:35Treichel: Great point.
- 19:35Yeah, and the succession planning, I wish they'd done it as guidance.
- 19:38I hope they'll go as guidance.
- 19:40I doubt that'll happen with this.
- 19:42Where the board's taking it.
- 19:43We also, we wrote our first comment letter on that.
- 19:46I'll probably, I haven't really shared it with anybody, but NCUA.
- 19:50Mike, I'll send it to you and I'll probably have a podcast or an
- 19:53article on that coming out as well.
- 19:56But the reality is a lot of those credit unions, tipping
- 19:59back to what you're saying there.
- 20:01So we'll evaluate it in four years when I have, when I'm ready to retire, right?
- 20:05That's a lot of.
- 20:06People have in their head is they're thinking about their self determination
- 20:10when they want to retire from the credit union, and they might
- 20:14not have somebody good in play.
- 20:15And the 1 thing you might have mentioned it, but that popped into my head to
- 20:19as well is with inflation, right?
- 20:21Everything costs more.
- 20:23So you to keep your own staff.
- 20:25You have to increase their pay.
- 20:27You might even need additional staff, but the reality is the way your balance sheet
- 20:31is put together isn't allowing for you to do that and keep your profitability up.
- 20:35And I think the inflation thing.
- 20:38During the exam, you'd always want credit unions to have.
- 20:44Appropriate expense levels if someone was above average and they were having
- 20:49challenges, and then you go through the inflation we've had for 2 or 3 years.
- 20:54It's like doubling down on the likelihood of them ever being
- 20:58able to be profitable again or in some reasonable period of time.
- 21:03Mike Mac: Yep, the other thing I look at, and I did this a few years
- 21:05ago, I went down to Florida and I was presenting to a large credit union.
- 21:09And the issue I had with them was there was a very large
- 21:14credit union next to them.
- 21:16And I started, I did a series of graphs that showed them.
- 21:20If you did better than the very large guy next to you, you're
- 21:24still losing ground because of the compounding effect of an asset level
- 21:29that's already bigger than yours.
- 21:31And so when you start looking at it in those terms, and I said, if the
- 21:34credit union next to you just decided, they like your CFO because he was
- 21:38really smart or she was really smart and just bid him away or bid her away,
- 21:45you're just going to keep getting attacked.
- 21:47Everybody has to understand that there's risks everywhere and
- 21:51you've got to play with them.
- 21:52You've got to just play every day, as hard as you can, understanding
- 21:56what they are and moving.
- 21:58But you've got to adjust because circumstances change.
- 22:01They
- 22:02Treichel: certainly do.
- 22:03They certainly do.
- 22:04So any other thoughts relative to we, we've talked a lot about
- 22:09pursuing the merger before, while you still have self-determination
- 22:12on the NCA assisted arena.
- 22:15Any, they've got the, what's the name of their, where you can sign up to
- 22:18become a ? Oh, the Member registry.
- 22:21Mike Mac: Member Partner.
- 22:21Partner Registry,
- 22:22Treichel: yes.
- 22:23Thank you.
- 22:23Yeah, that, that came out when, I think the first year I was executive director
- 22:2620 13 20 14, the member registry.
- 22:29And that was because the NCA Board would.
- 22:33Would go to these functions, CUNA's, GAC, and people would say, Hey, the
- 22:38credit union down the street merged, and I never had an opportunity.
- 22:41And what we would always tell the NCUA board is NCUA is
- 22:46not involved in most mergers.
- 22:48They'll approve it on the back end, but it's credit union A decides
- 22:51to merge with credit union B.
- 22:52The package comes in.
- 22:53Is it safe and sound?
- 22:54Is the field of membership okay?
- 22:55Did they do the vote?
- 22:56Okay, boom.
- 22:57NCUA approves.
- 22:58That's how NCUA is involved.
- 23:00The numbers of them, which will be going up as you've described where NCUA
- 23:04is kicking in money or NCUA is saying you need to merge are much less, but
- 23:09the NCUA board heard so much about credit unions complaining, saying
- 23:14they didn't invite me to dinner and my board out so that we could merge.
- 23:18How did I miss that opportunity?
- 23:20That's what led to the registry being born.
- 23:23And I'm sure when you're helping, when you're helping credit
- 23:26unions pursue an assisted merger, that comes into play some.
- 23:31Mike Mac: Yes.
- 23:31So the first thing you got to know, you're exactly right.
- 23:33It goes back to 2010, which will tell you.
- 23:35Treichel: Okay.
- 23:36It goes all
- 23:37Mike Mac: the way back in the Debbie Matz era.
- 23:39The member of the merger partner registry was established by the NCA.
- 23:44And I tell folks all the time that are in the acquiring
- 23:48side or on the acquiring side.
- 23:50If you think of yourself as an acquirer and you'd like to window shop from time
- 23:54to time, put yourself on that list at the NCUA and you can go on the website and
- 23:59you can find it and there's a portal and you sign your name up and they're going
- 24:03to take that information and it creates for them the first batch that they're
- 24:08going to screen or identify of potential acquirers when someone gets in trouble.
- 24:13So let's take, I'm in, I'm sitting in New Jersey.
- 24:16So a credit union in New Jersey hypothetically gets To where they are not
- 24:20going to make it as a growing concern.
- 24:22How does this process work?
- 24:24The NCUA has been in there as they've probably identified them.
- 24:27They've probably ratcheted up their camel's rating over time.
- 24:30And everybody said, all right, it's time.
- 24:32So what happens?
- 24:33The NCUA then says we're going out.
- 24:36And we're going to go to our registry and we're going to look who's in
- 24:39the neighborhood and it's more than neighborhood now because we have
- 24:43geography is a little different than it used to be because of digital.
- 24:47And so they're going to say who is in our registry.
- 24:49That's a potential acquirer and potential acquirer really has to have 2 criteria.
- 24:56Number 1, they have to when we push the 2 together, they have
- 25:00to survive safety and soundness.
- 25:02They have the ability to absorb financially and operationally the
- 25:06credit union that's being acquired.
- 25:09And then the second thing is compatibility of field of membership.
- 25:13And that second one, depending on how impaired my hypothetical
- 25:18credit union is, that second one kind of has some flexibility.
- 25:22Because in a, quote, emergency where we're not adequately capitalized, the NCOA can
- 25:27just blow through the field of membership rules and say, public interest dictates.
- 25:33And so we're going to let this one go, even though it's not fully compatible
- 25:36on a field of membership basics.
- 25:39So now the NCAA has identified a pool of potential applicants to
- 25:44be the acquiring credit union.
- 25:46So they go out to those folks and they say, Hey, ABC credit union,
- 25:49there's someone in your neighborhood that we think would be interesting.
- 25:53They'll give you a rough ballpark to say it's a hundred
- 25:55million dollar credit union.
- 25:57They've come on some tough times, ran into a regular Tory hip cup.
- 26:00We think it'd be a decent fit.
- 26:02You want to take a look.
- 26:03If you want to take a look, the price of admission is an NDA with the NCUA.
- 26:10So if you sign that NCUA NDA, you're now under the hood and they're
- 26:15going to put you into a data room.
- 26:17In that data room, you get what's called the bidder's package.
- 26:22You get a summary.
- 26:2420 page 30 page slide deck from the kind of laying out the story.
- 26:30Who's the credit union?
- 26:31What do they have for real estate?
- 26:33How many branches?
- 26:34Why did they fall in a ditch?
- 26:36What's the issue?
- 26:37How big are they?
- 26:39They'll give you some basics on the loan pool and the deposit pool and
- 26:43then there's more in the data room.
- 26:45You'll probably get all the material contracts.
- 26:47You'll probably get the loan tape and deposit tape.
- 26:50You'll probably get a summary of investments, which includes QSIPs.
- 26:53You'll get a summary of real estate.
- 26:54You'll probably get a summary, at least an org chart, probably
- 26:57a summary of the staff.
- 27:00It's you're now in a diligence process, and your diligence process begins with the
- 27:04question that says, do I buy this thing?
- 27:06Do I bid on this thing or not?
- 27:08That's a fundamental question.
- 27:11And honestly, you're doing it most likely against some time pressure.
- 27:16Depending on the alarm of the fire, is it a 1 alarm fire or a 5 line fire?
- 27:21You may have.
- 27:23A minute, or you may have a little bit more than that to
- 27:27decide what your bid looks like.
- 27:30And there's a lot of ways or a couple of ways to structure a bid.
- 27:33And there's some things you should think about here.
- 27:35The first and foremost thing that I would say, even in a small deal, and
- 27:40this is me talking my book, so put every disclaimer you want around it,
- 27:46please.
- 27:47If I could put one thing through the head of a credit union out
- 27:50there that wants to bid, please.
- 27:53Hire someone to help you.
- 27:56There's more than meets the eye here.
- 27:59No disrespect to any credit union in this space.
- 28:02I know you can read a balance sheet probably as well, or anybody that I work
- 28:05with here, we do this all day, every day.
- 28:09We've seen more of these than you have.
- 28:13We know where the bodies are buried.
- 28:15We can read these things and we understand and can bring experts
- 28:18in, including sometimes we would have to go out to someone like Mark
- 28:21and get his expert opinion on how something works or what's going on.
- 28:25And the magnitude of the issue at the credit union, because in most
- 28:29of these cases, there's an issue.
- 28:30It can be as simple as, Hey, we're just not profitable for a while.
- 28:34And we don't really have a business model that works anymore, too.
- 28:36We've got some version of fraud out and out fraud or a situation that
- 28:40smells like fraud, and we don't even have enough information to decide.
- 28:44So what the professional that you work with can help you with.
- 28:48Is dialing up the magnitude of that risk and understanding the
- 28:52magnitude of that risk is fundamental to any bid you're going to make.
- 28:59Treichel: That's very well said and I, they can be plain vanilla, but
- 29:02if NCUA is involved, there's usually some weird issues, whether it's the
- 29:07contracts, whether it's fraud, whether it's if there is fraud, and that's on
- 29:12the deposit side, what does that mean?
- 29:14If it's fraud and it's on the loan side, what does that mean?
- 29:17And then, of course, there's the clean merger where you acquire
- 29:20everything, or there's the purchase and assumption where you say okay.
- 29:23I'm willing to bid, but I only want these assets and I only want these liabilities.
- 29:29By the way, I want I want, is it going to be an emergency merger?
- 29:33Will the field of membership work?
- 29:34Does it all fit, et cetera, et cetera.
- 29:36So those are great points.
- 29:38If you're looking at one where N2A is involved, having someone who's
- 29:41been through the ringer before, as opposed to it being your first rodeo
- 29:45is really good advice, and one other thing that popped into my head is we're
- 29:49talking about the merger registry.
- 29:50So when I was a regional director back in the day, and I had one of these
- 29:54that I needed to shop, I would go, the way it would work is, I discuss it
- 29:59with my director of special actions.
- 30:01They'd be meeting with the credit union's board.
- 30:03They would be looking to see who was interested on the registry.
- 30:06Maybe they'd be kicking the can and making some other phone calls, but essentially
- 30:11on that safety and soundness side, they would be looking at, okay, when you add
- 30:14a plus B, where does the capital land?
- 30:17And there would be some natural cutoff.
- 30:19I don't want.
- 30:20You don't want to create a bigger problem.
- 30:21You don't want, you don't want to pick 8%, right?
- 30:24Capitalize.
- 30:24Someone's well capitalized.
- 30:25If you add them all together and it's more complicated now with
- 30:29how the merger accounting works, and then they overlay that with.
- 30:34Okay, they're interested in potentially buying someone.
- 30:37But what is their camel code, right?
- 30:39You might be a camel code 1 when you put your name on the list
- 30:42and you might be a camel code 3 when the opportunity comes up.
- 30:45So the 1st phase would be special actions taking a look at it.
- 30:49The 2nd phase would be.
- 30:51Okay, someone's a code 2, but they got a 3 in management, or they got a
- 30:553 in earnings, or someone's a code 3.
- 30:57Could those still stay on the list?
- 30:58Yes, but then you get the supervisory examiner who, whose examiners
- 31:03coded that credit union a 3.
- 31:05Again, we're talking the surviving credit unions, not the merging credit unions.
- 31:09Might they still be interested in?
- 31:11And the more, the less pool NCUA has, the more flexible that they
- 31:17tend to be with who can take them on.
- 31:19And what's the definition of unsafe and unsound?
- 31:22Because sometimes you would, I would have conversations with the supervisory
- 31:25examiner at NCUA and they were frustrated for whatever reason, but the world that
- 31:31they were living in and what they were aware of, Merging in a 100 million credit
- 31:36union into a 300 billion credit union where they were upset about one thing
- 31:40that happened at an exam shouldn't stop that, that from being considered in, in my
- 31:45mind, and that's how I would approach it.
- 31:46So I would sometimes have to push my staff to not be too risk averse in what the
- 31:53definition of safe and sound is, but the reality is you have 14 percent capital.
- 31:59You're, you've got a better shot at it than if you've got 7 percent capital.
- 32:03So a good capital ratio that you've been, whether you're building it through
- 32:07subordinated debt or natural earnings, or a combination of the two being
- 32:11positioned as the surviving credit union, well on capital was, is a big positive.
- 32:17And in addition to those time pressures you talked about, sometimes you only
- 32:22have a minute and that's because NCUA.
- 32:25By they, they either someone gets down to 4 percent capital because of fraud.
- 32:29For example, they're either going to have to merge it within 90 days.
- 32:34I believe it is under prompt corrective action, or they're
- 32:36going to have to conserve it.
- 32:37Guess what?
- 32:37They don't want to have to conserve it.
- 32:39They'd rather tie it up in a pretty bow, pay you a little bit of money, as opposed
- 32:44to going to the NCUA board and explaining in excruciating detail, how they missed
- 32:49that merger or how they missed that fraud.
- 32:52Getting it to go away.
- 32:54Conservatorships their goal is to avoid those that if they can
- 32:57spend a little bit of the insurance fund money, that's reasonable.
- 33:00They'll do that.
- 33:01So that's how that timeline.
- 33:02The
- 33:02Mike Mac: interesting thing is it would be really fun to see it from the side.
- 33:06You saw it from because the N.
- 33:07C.
- 33:07U.
- 33:08A.
- 33:08S.
- 33:08Charged with finding the lowest cost alternative, and it's not
- 33:15all that, it's not as simple as it sounds because it's multifaceted,
- 33:20because it may, as you alluded to, it may cost you in the long run.
- 33:24If you tuck this into someone who said, I'll bid in a merger.
- 33:28I don't need any dollars from the NCUA, and I'll take it on.
- 33:31If that turns into a problem two years from now where that
- 33:34credit union is impaired, it may be a bigger hit on the fund.
- 33:37As opposed to how do I weigh that against someone who says, I'll take it on.
- 33:42I'll even take it on in a merger, but you got to pay me 2Million dollars out
- 33:45of the share insurance fund, or you've got to terminate my core contract
- 33:51that costs 750 and breakage it just.
- 33:55It's not always apples to apples.
- 33:58There's a temporal part of it.
- 34:00There's a risk part of it over time.
- 34:02There are a couple of absolutes, right?
- 34:04Absolute number one, it is very clear that from the NCOA standpoint, they
- 34:11prefer a, an acquiring credit union to take a merger because in a merger
- 34:17versus a purchase and assumption or PNA in the merger, the acquiring credit
- 34:23union stands up and says, I take all.
- 34:27Of the assets and liabilities of the emerging credit union, all of their
- 34:32history, any liability, known or unknown.
- 34:37Now, that takes a lot to do.
- 34:38And again, not something I would suggest a credit union does without its advisors
- 34:42helping him because there's a lot of risk.
- 34:45You may see there's a lot of risk.
- 34:47You maybe have to be prepared for that.
- 34:50You may not have.
- 34:51I'm not privy to that information yet, because it's not in the data room
- 34:54where you can't get enough information.
- 34:56It reminds me of the first day I started as a trader on
- 34:59Wall Street, I got a lecture.
- 35:00The lecture was, you need to get comfortable making decisions on
- 35:06incomplete and imperfect information.
- 35:08If you can't get there, you're not a trader, and that's okay.
- 35:13Here is one of those places.
- 35:15In this event, if you're an acquiring credit union and you're bidding, you
- 35:19need to get some level of comfort.
- 35:22Around making a bid with terms on imperfect information.
- 35:29Some credit unions are very comfortable.
- 35:31Now, what you can do is you can mitigate that risk by learning as much as you
- 35:36can and studying what you've been given.
- 35:38But if you go the merger route, there will always be some, what Rumsfeld
- 35:42called unknown unknowns, right?
- 35:45We just don't know what they are, where they'll come from.
- 35:47And we have to be comfortable that we're big enough, strong
- 35:50enough, resilient enough.
- 35:51And we've studied enough that we don't expect a risk.
- 35:54That's too big for us to handle.
- 35:57Treichel: I, I've back in the day when I was on the West coast as a director
- 36:01of special actions, I can remember one particular situation where the credit
- 36:05union wanted to merge with credit union a, I already knew I had at least one
- 36:10cost free merger bid in from credit union B, which they didn't want to go with.
- 36:15They'd already invited a in who was helping them manage the place.
- 36:18And the, before they put their bid in, they were smart enough to call
- 36:22me and say, can I ask for something?
- 36:24I want to do a P and a is just one contract.
- 36:26I don't want it.
- 36:27It might have been the data processing and the way I framed it up to them
- 36:31was is yes, they want their self determination is they want to go with you.
- 36:36But if I get any other bid that is cost free and is a merger who
- 36:40will take that you will lose.
- 36:43And the guy was like, got it.
- 36:44So he just put, within an hour, I was sending him some smoke signals, if
- 36:49you will, that careful, you're going to lose this and NCOA can do that.
- 36:53Sometimes you can make those calls and say, okay, yeah, there might be a
- 36:56little bit of wiggle room around here.
- 36:58And then also, making imperfect decisions, it reminds me of the book Blink, which is
- 37:03how you make a decision in the blink of an eye, and it's really not in the blink
- 37:08of an eye, it's that journey, it's that journey of life that you've taken through
- 37:11all the things you've seen and done, so you start weighing it in your head, in
- 37:15your brain, and you fill in some of the gaps of the information based on your
- 37:20past history, which actually goes back to Get people involved in the process,
- 37:25whoever it is, whether it's Olden Lane or some other consultant that works on
- 37:29these things is fill up those gaps so you can make the best decision for you.
- 37:35But there are experts out there that have seen more than this.
- 37:38So that can, instead of having 75 percent perfect information,
- 37:42you can take it up to 80, 80%.
- 37:4485, 95 percent perfect information.
- 37:47Mike Mac: In these instances, my first call is you.
- 37:49And what am I doing?
- 37:50It's exactly what I'm doing, right?
- 37:51I'm saying Mark has been in that chair.
- 37:53Mark has seen this 35 times.
- 37:56And this is, this may not be exactly something he saw, but it's going to rhyme.
- 38:01Treichel: And
- 38:01Mike Mac: the insight I can glean from, you say, Yeah, you probably got a million
- 38:05or two to play with before the NCA gets, or, hey, there's another, they're
- 38:09telling you there's another bidder outside of you and you're either going
- 38:11to get this straight up merger with no cost or you're not, we could be wrong.
- 38:16I'll bet on your advice in that space or older lean plus you
- 38:20understanding a situation versus a credit union that's going down at
- 38:24somewhat blind in the first time.
- 38:26Treichel: Sure.
- 38:26And an example of that is if you ask for X dollars plus one, it's
- 38:30the NCUA board that decides it.
- 38:32If you ask for an X dollars minus two, it's the office of examination
- 38:36of insurance and or there's levels that it's just the regional director.
- 38:40And of course, the more hands that touch it in NCUA, the more
- 38:44potentially complicated it can get.
- 38:46So yeah, we
- 38:47Mike Mac: call those off ramps.
- 38:50You try to have a business with fewer off ramps.
- 38:53Treichel: Yeah, exactly.
- 38:54Exactly.
- 38:56Very good.
- 38:56This is, this has been fun.
- 38:57A lot of information here.
- 38:58Mike, if there was one question about mergers or assisted mergers that I
- 39:02should have asked you that I didn't, what would, what might that be?
- 39:06Mike Mac: I don't know.
- 39:06I think you've done a great job.
- 39:08I think we've gotten through sort of everything I thought
- 39:10we needed to say on this call.
- 39:12Again, if I could say really two points, one is don't get yourself to the place
- 39:16where the NCOA is dictating terms because your option set is closing.
- 39:20And you owe it to your membership, your staff, your management team
- 39:24your legacy of your institution, its brand and its community not to get
- 39:28there, honestly, because if you're going to go out, it's okay, we all
- 39:34have pride again, but it's okay.
- 39:36Do it on your terms.
- 39:37Do it in a negotiated setting where you can protect some of
- 39:39those things you care about.
- 39:41And again, there are professionals here who can help whether you're
- 39:44in that unassisted setting or you're early and you understand it.
- 39:47And if you don't know where you are on that continuum, we're here to help too.
- 39:51We can, again, we've seen folks in every version of it, waited too
- 39:55long, aren't there yet, have other options and we can help and assist
- 39:59in, in any way that's reasonable.
- 40:01We're happy to do it.
- 40:02Treichel: That's fantastic.
- 40:03And if so, if someone's listening and they want to reach out to you, what's
- 40:07the best way for them to get in touch?
- 40:09Mike Mac: www.
- 40:11oldenlean.
- 40:12com.
- 40:14Excellent.
- 40:14Treichel: All right, Mike, appreciate your time today.
- 40:17Mike Mac: Awesome.
- 40:18Thanks, Mark.
- 40:19And listeners, I want
- 40:20Treichel: to, yeah.
- 40:20And listeners, I want to thank you for listening.
- 40:23I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 40:25This is Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.