Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Why Morgan Stanley, Walmart, Rumble & Silicon Valley Are Betting BIG on Bitcoin
Transcript
- 0:02It all. Comes down to computers
- 0:04communicating the information superhighway can be a confusing
- 0:08mix of on ramps and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 0:20OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single network
- 0:28which can do a microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for reducing
- 0:41the role of gun. The one thing that's missing
- 0:44that that will soon be developed is a reliable E cash.
- 0:51All righty, gentlemen. Welcome back to another episode
- 0:54of Final SETTLEMENT. Today is Monday, January 12th,
- 0:582026, 11:15 AM Eastern Standard Time.
- 1:02Gentlemen, how are we doing? We got Michael, we got Liam, we
- 1:05have a special guest, Nick, which we'll, we'll get to a
- 1:07formal introduction for him a little later in the show.
- 1:10But we've got a big show, ton of links on the list.
- 1:12A lot has happened in the past week, the past few weeks.
- 1:16The world is changing quickly and yeah, we're going to jump
- 1:21right into it. So the the first, first headline
- 1:23we wanted to get to this actually dropped, I think
- 1:26shortly after we recorded last week.
- 1:29So we didn't get a chance to touch on it, but Morgan Stanley
- 1:33filed for their own Bitcoin ETF, also a salon ETF, but we'll
- 1:37we'll ignore that for now. They registered for a Bitcoin
- 1:39ETF and this is a big deal for a number of regions all sort of
- 1:43kick things off here and then and then get thoughts from the
- 1:45group. But this really stuck out to me.
- 1:47As you know, we've kind of become numb to a lot of the
- 1:50headlines around whether it's M and A activity, partnerships,
- 1:55ETF filings. But this one is different in the
- 1:57sense that Morgan Stanley's not a, you know, historically a big
- 2:01ETF factory or shop necessarily. They have a handful of funds
- 2:06that they manage, ETF funds that they manage and only two prior
- 2:11to this actually had the Morgan Stanley brand name on it.
- 2:14They have sort of sub brands like Calvert and Parametric that
- 2:18they manage ETFs for. But in terms of the the very
- 2:22short list of Morgan Stanley branded ETFs, Bitcoin one will
- 2:26be the third ever, which is a pretty big deal.
- 2:29I think what it also tells us is that they've seen the success of
- 2:32I bit and BlackRock and realized that, you know, they can allow
- 2:36their clients to access I bit, but they're only earning a a
- 2:39very de minimis sort of revenue on that.
- 2:42And if they really wanted to capture the economics of these
- 2:44massive inflows that we've seen to spot Bitcoin ETFs, then they
- 2:48should probably get into the issuer game.
- 2:49And that's exactly what they're doing.
- 2:51So there's more to this too, around sort of a broader Morgan
- 2:54Stanley push, but I'll kick it to you guys.
- 2:56What, what do we make of this? How big of a deal is it?
- 3:00Yeah. I mean, I think, I think this is
- 3:01huge. We touched on it and, and maybe
- 3:04I'll let Nicker and Liam if they want to touch on the ETF flows
- 3:08and just how big of a, a, a deal that is that Morgan Stanley
- 3:11launched or is going to be launching their own.
- 3:15We did go pretty deep last week on the last trade here.
- 3:18Where I wanna kind of focus, at least from my side is a report
- 3:22that came out from Barron's. I'll pull up my screen really
- 3:25quick because I'm not sure if you have it, you might, but it's
- 3:29really the Morgan Stanley head of wealth management, Jed Finn
- 3:33coming out and I'll read a couple quotes from there.
- 3:36One is it all fits together in a broader strategy of adapting to
- 3:39the change in the industry and in some cases driving the change
- 3:42in the industry. And it effectively brings out
- 3:46Wall Street announcing. You know, one of the big things
- 3:50that they announced they were investors in 0 hash.
- 3:52And then E*Trade is one of the platforms that says under the
- 3:55Morgan Stanley umbrella that I believe is either on or, or it's
- 3:59going to be turning on the ability to buy Bitcoin, ether
- 4:02and Solano. Oh, I guess it's it's on track
- 4:05to go live the first half of this year, but also Morgan
- 4:11Stanley's now rumored. I don't think it's rumored.
- 4:13I think it's confirmed via this Barron's article that is
- 4:15planning to launch its own digital wallet.
- 4:18And it effectively says the company envisions it's in house
- 4:20offering as a platform to eventually handle transactions
- 4:23not just involving coins, but also tokenized assets.
- 4:26With the excerpt, this is really a recognition that with the
- 4:30financial service infrastructure works is going to change over
- 4:33time. As our infrastructure develops,
- 4:34we'll be able to do more with blending of traditional finance
- 4:37or tratify and decentralized finance or defy ecosystems.
- 4:40This could mean barn against crypto holdings to buy equities
- 4:43or vice versa, for example, making loans against crypto and
- 4:45cold storages. And I think that is just kind of
- 4:50a very incredible exert in, in filing on what they're saying,
- 4:56what they're doing because it goes so much deeper than passive
- 5:00inflows from private wealth into I bet or an ETF shares into the
- 5:05recognition that the plumbing is fundamentally changing from
- 5:08stable coins, real world assets to the underlying Bitcoin.
- 5:12You can imagine some gold exposure will probably start to
- 5:15come about in 2026 as well. And then the realization that
- 5:19what people want to do with those assets from cross
- 5:22collateralization to to bi directional, right.
- 5:26So traditionally it'd be we've talked about individuals
- 5:29leveraging their underlying BTC or I bet holdings to get some
- 5:35dollars, but you can see the other side of it where you can
- 5:37leverage your equity holdings to get them, you know, margin to go
- 5:40and buy BTC or other shares. And I think that, but you take
- 5:46that and then you took you take a digital native way for a giant
- 5:49like Morgan Stanley that manages trillions of dollars in assets.
- 5:52And it it effectively tells you that there's a race inside Wall
- 5:56Street to develop best in class solutions across the spectrum,
- 5:59not just for other institutional investors.
- 6:03And I think that this is really kind of incredible, incredibly
- 6:06bullish to see that the markets understanding this just won't be
- 6:09in an ETF wrapper. Because if if it was that this
- 6:12wouldn't be out, they wouldn't be working on this.
- 6:14They wouldn't invest in 0 hash, they wouldn't be implementing it
- 6:16via E*Trade. So, yeah, I just thought that
- 6:20was probably one of the most incredible insights outside of
- 6:22obviously the the ETF filing. Yeah, it's a great point.
- 6:28And do you guys know for sure if they will be custodying it
- 6:32themselves or if they're going to be outsourcing that to
- 6:35Coinbase via the S1 filing? Did they share that?
- 6:38I believe it says they're outsourcing it, but I don't know
- 6:41if they named in the S1 who the custodian will be.
- 6:45Other qualified custodians, I'd imagine it's in the same realm
- 6:48of the bit goes Coinbase's potentially Fidelities dependent
- 6:51on the kind of competitive standing there.
- 6:54Yeah, for sure. That makes a ton of sense.
- 6:56And I would imagine just given whatever conversations that they
- 7:01had and, and likely not like doing their due diligence on
- 7:05Coinbase, Bitco, etcetera. They realize that they can't
- 7:08fundamentally know exactly everything that's going on with
- 7:11their custody. Otherwise there would be, you
- 7:13know, a point of failure with respect to how Coinbase or
- 7:17Fidelity or or whoever else is actually custodying their asset.
- 7:20And obviously Morgan Stanley isn't going to be, you know, as
- 7:24sophisticated in custody and digital assets themselves, but
- 7:27that's likely an impetus for the reason why they're investing
- 7:30themselves and just the fact that they know know that they
- 7:33need to have a solution for their customers.
- 7:36Their customers are going to want something differentiated.
- 7:39Otherwise, they're just going to go to the ETF, whichever has the
- 7:42most volume so that they can get, you know, just better
- 7:45pricing and to the model themselves.
- 7:48Yeah, this is this is a really, it can't be understated how big
- 7:52this is. The fact that they're really
- 7:55offering everything, not just exposure, but know that clients
- 7:58are going to cross collateralize across equities and other asset
- 8:01classes and bitcoins a big one. That's your stay across likely a
- 8:07large number of clients like this.
- 8:08This is something that I'm sure that they've been getting a lot
- 8:11of demand for because they were one of the first firms to turn
- 8:15on the I bit for their customers.
- 8:17They've had that going for almost 2 years and they've
- 8:19realized, I'm sure just from feedback from the customers that
- 8:22they need to get into this game in a bigger way.
- 8:25So it's it's pretty big to see. Yeah, it seems like that was a
- 8:28natural sort of like fact finding exercise for them to
- 8:31offer. I bit to their clients and then
- 8:34you know, see how material the the the flows actually were from
- 8:36their underlying clients. And then just to put a little
- 8:39bit more context around, I think what they saw in terms of the
- 8:43success. So Blackrock's I bid ETF,
- 8:46fastest growing ETF of all time, most, you know, quickly became
- 8:51Blackrock's most profitable product, more so than their S&P
- 8:54500 ETF. And, you know, they've amassed a
- 8:59a a pretty large substantial sort of head start or lead, you
- 9:02know, I think at peak assets and I bet broached 100 billion.
- 9:08And so if you're sitting in Morgan Stanley's seat like
- 9:12you're, you know, you did your fact finding, you realize there
- 9:14was a real underlying demand for this thing.
- 9:16It wasn't going away. The Tam was was very large.
- 9:20You know, more than than most people in on Wall Street
- 9:23probably anticipated. And so despite sort of being a
- 9:27late entry to this, they are going to try to compete with
- 9:30Flat Rock. And to your point, Lee, I'm
- 9:32like, the question then becomes it's like, OK, well, why is it
- 9:36different? Why should someone buy Morgan
- 9:37Stanley's spot ETF as opposed to I bet if it's, you know, at
- 9:42current much smaller, I'm sure they'll sort of ramp it up
- 9:45pretty quickly with some, some anchor investors or what not.
- 9:48But you know that that is an open question.
- 9:51How do they differentiate themselves?
- 9:52Do they pick a different single custodian than Coinbase?
- 9:57Do they go with someone else? So they have a little bit of
- 9:58differentiation. That becomes a real question
- 10:01because this is basically a commoditized market at this
- 10:03point, like spot Bitcoin, ETFs, the way they're constructed,
- 10:06most of them outsourcing, it's Coinbase.
- 10:08It'll be interesting to see how they actually plan to compete
- 10:11with I bet, because again, they are sort of behind at this
- 10:15point. Two things to call out that I
- 10:18think are incredibly bullish is to Liam's point that they've had
- 10:22ETF exposure turned on for, call it two years.
- 10:26If I recall correctly, when they first turned it on, it was
- 10:28relatively low exposure and maybe it was just for like
- 10:31private wealth investors over a certain net worth or assets
- 10:35under management. And you think about like a firm
- 10:39like Morgan Stanley and how slow tread 5 moves that you can bet
- 10:43that them turning that on, they already had plans for all this
- 10:47and it took two years to get it live, if not longer.
- 10:51And so that should set a precedent for a lot of the
- 10:54undercurrent, the things that we haven't seen that are being
- 10:57worked on. And then to the other point is
- 11:00they more than likely know what their clients want more than
- 11:04their clients do, right? Like these are people at the top
- 11:07of their game. They, this is how they make
- 11:11their money. And we've been talking about how
- 11:14we've been in this kind of like quasi bear market where the
- 11:16demand has historically been for this price uptrend outside of
- 11:19any like sovereign bid that there had been for 17 years,
- 11:25people like Morgan Stanley that had clients that were looking
- 11:29for exposure and the ETF allowed for simple exposure.
- 11:32So that's demand that had been sitting there on the sidelines
- 11:35waiting. Point being is that they know
- 11:37that there's interest across these products.
- 11:39And so that's why they're looking to go and develop them.
- 11:42And it really ties into the interest and opportunity to
- 11:44build in this space and build differentiate solutions because
- 11:47these firms are fully not going to be able to bring the talent
- 11:50in and come up with innovative ways.
- 11:51And so there's going to be a huge op as you go across,
- 11:54whether it's lending, custody, financial services that have
- 11:57that Bitcoin feel, whether it's today or the price is $140,000.
- 12:03And then they have to look different than their competitor.
- 12:05It's going to come because they are planning to win and winning.
- 12:09Is it going to be in an omnibus fashion holding hundreds of
- 12:11billions of dollars long term? Yeah.
- 12:16So I said Nick, any thoughts on this one or I can jump to the
- 12:18next? Yeah, I know.
- 12:20I mean, I think, I think in terms of added flows, I mean
- 12:24it's going to build on, on what we've already seen, right?
- 12:28You already knew that they were going to turn this on.
- 12:30It's already starting to happen. I think they probably will look
- 12:33to to bundle some stuff with like some of their existing high
- 12:37net worth client base. They're probably going to say
- 12:39like, hey, they may bundle some things to try to compete with
- 12:42Ibid. Because again, I mean, they're
- 12:44basically the same product, right?
- 12:46Yeah, Yeah. I'd say that's all I have on
- 12:48that one. Yeah.
- 12:48I mean, the only other difference that I thought was
- 12:50somewhat interesting was like, I believe BlackRock has an
- 12:53Etherium ETF as well. And so it's interesting that
- 12:58Morgan Stanley decided to do a Solana ETF as sort of like their
- 13:01extra outside of Bitcoin. And maybe that's how they think
- 13:03they're going to differentiate in terms of those sort of flows
- 13:06on the margin outside of Bitcoin, but remains to be seen.
- 13:10We did. Mention too, Morgan normally did
- 13:13file for Ethereum ETF, that was so they did.
- 13:16So maybe it just took an extra day because of whatever staking.
- 13:20I don't necessarily have any deep insight there too, but they
- 13:24also did file for that. Good to know.
- 13:27We mentioned wallet push from Morgan Stanley as well.
- 13:32Another wallet related news from last week was Rumble and Tether
- 13:37launched their crypto wallet. Liam, I'm going to hand this off
- 13:39to you. I know you've you've taken a
- 13:40look at this a bit and what do you think the implications of
- 13:43this are? Yeah.
- 13:44It just shows how fundamentally broken money is that any time
- 13:47that you want to get payouts for you know, providing value to
- 13:51society that like nobody actually wants to just use
- 13:55dollars in general or or the fact that you need to pair
- 13:58dollars with so many other assets right in the platform
- 14:01itself versus just going out and taking the dollars and going to
- 14:05best in cost financial services. Everything is starting to almost
- 14:09be gamified or you know, almost. So there's going to be
- 14:13prediction markets and into a number of different asset
- 14:16classes everywhere. But yeah, I mean, Rumble has
- 14:20almost 50 million monthly active users.
- 14:23So they're definitely not small incorporating stable coins,
- 14:28Bitcoin and tethers tokenized gold product in there is pretty
- 14:34interesting too. And the it's definitely more
- 14:39about, you know, I'll say libertarian type crowd on on
- 14:42Rumble. So it'll be interesting to see
- 14:44what type of traction they actually get.
- 14:47YouTube is obviously significantly bigger, almost 3
- 14:51billion users on there and they're just launching stable
- 14:54points in itself. So we'll be interesting to see
- 14:57what type of Bitcoin traction flow they get on there before
- 15:02others have to compete. But a big portion of that that
- 15:07makes it interesting for folks who are all across the world is
- 15:10just not having to you know set up a bank account etcetera to
- 15:14actually get capital directly to them and off board it
- 15:18themselves. So interesting to see to.
- 15:22I am not sure how much traction they're going to get outside of
- 15:26a fairly narrow people folks though.
- 15:31Yeah, I don't have much. I personally, I feel like the
- 15:38Tether barbell is is interesting because the tether on the side
- 15:42of sovereign exposure and what they're doing across dollarizing
- 15:48emerging markets and sweeping flows and really leading on that
- 15:52front I find really interesting. I think on the other side,
- 15:55there's this Mosaic, it's kind of chaotic they're trying to
- 16:00paint in how do they get to the distribution and utilization
- 16:05from day-to-day. And I don't necessarily, I think
- 16:08they're looking for something, right, because we look at Rumble
- 16:11and Tether and, and what does that look like?
- 16:14I know we've seen what YouTube's doing with stable coins.
- 16:17I think there's a lot of TBD. We talked about it last week of
- 16:19the week before that they're launching a wallet.
- 16:21I think that utilization on the end side, everyone's fighting
- 16:25for like the use case there, but I feel like they're very
- 16:28sophisticated 1 angle and the other side, it's like TBD to see
- 16:31how it plays out. And so you hear a lot of this
- 16:33stuff and Tether obviously has a big name, but it's really kind
- 16:37of still theoretical on like how will creators and content
- 16:41interact with Tether? And then it's still just, it's
- 16:44going to be fascinating to watch what USCC and being closer to
- 16:49the US markets, right? I feel like USCC, Google, JPM,
- 16:53that's more of a like trad kind of experience anything but like
- 16:58just Tether Rumble in itself or more of like on the outsides of
- 17:02kind of like specifically rumble and in what most people would
- 17:05associate that platform for and is.
- 17:10So yeah, I think, I think it's interesting to see the activity,
- 17:12but I don't necessarily know if it goes anywhere.
- 17:16Well, it's, it's an interesting point around the the
- 17:19distribution angle because you know, a few months ago Tether
- 17:23did a big push around USAT, like the US centric genius act
- 17:30compliant stablecoin that they launched and they had some
- 17:33marketing, some sort of commercials around it.
- 17:35But it's like, it's very difficult, I think in my mind to
- 17:38get individuals to adopt and use something like USAT.
- 17:42And much like you're doing like a Ubi air drop to them and then,
- 17:46you know, it's it's they're much more incentivized to use it.
- 17:49So in my mind, like this Rumble deal is basically a different
- 17:53parallel path to get like distribution people using
- 17:56digital dollars where you already have sort of an
- 17:59ingrained user base that is familiar with, you know, a lot
- 18:04of the ethos of Rumble is like, you know, anti censorship,
- 18:08freedom of speech oriented type thinking.
- 18:10So it it's kind of a natural fit to to integrate these things
- 18:13into that existing user base because, you know, there was
- 18:17some fanfare initially around USAT, but I haven't really heard
- 18:20much about it since then. Anything else in that one or we
- 18:27can jump to the Walmart 1 pay deal.
- 18:30No, I think I think just one thing I would say is like it
- 18:34wouldn't surprise me if you see a lot of people that are like
- 18:35doing streaming, like especially like pro gamers or like things
- 18:39like that, people that stream on Twitch and stuff like that.
- 18:41It wouldn't surprise me if some of those people pick this up.
- 18:44Also, like in terms of people who stream on YouTube and stuff
- 18:46like that, I know there have been a number of, there were a
- 18:48number of people, pretty well known YouTube streamers and, and
- 18:52creators who were banned off of the platform for various reasons
- 18:55because maybe they didn't post things that YouTube necessarily
- 18:58agreed with. And so it wouldn't be, it
- 19:01wouldn't surprise me if you see some of those folks use this
- 19:04because this would be a pretty like instantaneous way to get
- 19:06like YouTube donations and like receive, you know, stuff through
- 19:10Twitch and stuff like that. Wouldn't surprise me.
- 19:13Yeah, I agree with that. All right, switching gears a
- 19:18little bit here. So Walmart, Walmart backed Super
- 19:20App One pay hits $4 billion valuation.
- 19:23I'm going to pull up a different article here, but Michael, I was
- 19:25going to hand this to you. Why is this a big deal?
- 19:28Yeah. So I think the one pay stuff is
- 19:31much bigger than people have talked about.
- 19:33I think it kind of ties into the transition from the Rumble
- 19:37conversation that maybe there's going to be a lot if not future
- 19:42value on the margins, but today there really isn't.
- 19:45It reminds me a lot of like acts and not Even so much sub stack.
- 19:50Even the sub stack has monetized.
- 19:52I think they just raised it like or they just raised $60 million.
- 19:55Maybe maybe the value either the I think the valuation was much
- 19:58greater, but I think it was 60 million that they raised.
- 20:01Point being is that most people still say to acts like the
- 20:04network of facts where the conversation discourse is
- 20:07happening very similar to like YouTube and what's happening
- 20:09there. And so when we.
- 20:12Transition over into like capital markets, I think of it
- 20:15very similarly, where US centric market you're going to look
- 20:22there for value capture first in distribution before you start to
- 20:26get into like the fringes. Where because again, when you
- 20:29think about tether in emerging markets, in the amount of
- 20:32capital flow that would come in through a wallet or financial
- 20:34service, there just fundamentally different than AUS
- 20:37individual and, and their cohort demographic and and capital
- 20:41spend. So where the one pay aspect gets
- 20:46interesting is because it came out, you know, a few weeks ago
- 20:49that they were turning on buy sell into digital assets in
- 20:53Bitcoin. I think it was only a few
- 20:54cryptocurrencies. The thing that's really
- 20:57fascinating, I really recognize is 1 pay is top 12 finance apps.
- 21:03They're ahead of Robin Hood, Amex, Schwab, Coinbase around a
- 21:09few among a few others notable that you just wouldn't expect
- 21:12and that it's like this one kind of like super app and that it
- 21:15offers kind of debit cards via green dot reminisces banking,
- 21:19buy, sell. And so I think this is
- 21:22interesting because not only does Walmart in a certain
- 21:27segment of the market that they're focused on via one Pay
- 21:30is a traditionally kind of fits into that like Square Cash App
- 21:33cohort that may not be able to get access to the best financial
- 21:37services. And that digital asset rails
- 21:40offer the ability to build better financial technology,
- 21:44better banking apps and reduce a lot of the inherent friction
- 21:49that had traditionally occurred. And so I think One Pay via its
- 21:53distribution and what they're working on is kind of a signal
- 21:57where we will see other firms, whether it's like credit unions,
- 22:02challenger banks start to incorporate some of this tech
- 22:06because it's much easier to turn on pieces of like other
- 22:11additional products. And then also just net new
- 22:15players come in to be able to offer banking services to
- 22:18individuals that either couldn't be underwritten in a traditional
- 22:22financial sense that they make economics because of the
- 22:24customer acquisition cost a traditional bank has to incur
- 22:29when they want to win a client. And so I think that that's a big
- 22:32missing piece that we haven't really discussed in the market
- 22:35isn't focused on is when you disintermediate the ability to
- 22:38effectively be a bank, where will the value accrue from
- 22:42existing players that have better distribution and segments
- 22:45of the market that have they haven't been able to acquire and
- 22:48win and then net new players. So I think it's bullish in the
- 22:52sense of Bitcoin digital assets and net new players.
- 22:55I think it's somewhat bearish and either credit unions, old
- 22:58fintechs that are going to be a little slower in adopting some
- 23:02of this technology cousin of this or angle is like revolute
- 23:06Revolute. My understanding they're like
- 23:08stable coin remenses and and transactions have like blown to
- 23:11the roof the past call it 12 to 24 months where somebody like
- 23:16Western Union or I figure what the other money.
- 23:21Yeah, there's the other remittance firm.
- 23:23They've said they're coming into this game, but they haven't
- 23:25fully embraced or adopted it because of the legacy businesses
- 23:28are kind of like predicated on the the slowness of money and
- 23:31the fees they can transact and they may be in the back like
- 23:34the, you know, the net new firm trying to do something different
- 23:38because it benefits them like a Revolute may benefit
- 23:41tremendously. Yeah, all, all great points.
- 23:46Maybe if we pull that through a little bit farther, you'd shared
- 23:50this tweet from Simon Taylor just talking about effectively
- 23:54the difference between having access to the distribution like
- 23:57you're talking about. But then also, you know, how
- 23:59that compares to like actual expertise and the ability to
- 24:01win. Like those are two different,
- 24:03two different things effectively.
- 24:05So what is what is he talking about here in in that context?
- 24:09Yeah, I thought this was fascinating because it it was
- 24:12like Tyson to that meme that's been passed around after the new
- 24:14year. That COVID or March 2020 crash
- 24:17was seven years ago when it feels like 3 years ago.
- 24:20This idea that he throws out or timeline, it feels like the JP
- 24:24Morgan Apple Card was just launched, but it really was back
- 24:28and I think they said 20/19. It was really Goldman getting in
- 24:33or Goldman, if I said JP Morgan Goldman getting into the Apple
- 24:37consumer based products and consumer lending products with
- 24:40the Apple Card. So they partnered with Apple.
- 24:43He references they cost about $350.00 to win the client, but
- 24:48they started to really hit significant losses year over
- 24:53year because of the way that they were underwriting the loans
- 24:57and the type of borrowers that they were approving.
- 25:00And so we went from like, I want to say 2, it says 2.93% in 22
- 25:05jumps to 6.2% loss rates in 23. And then they started to slowly
- 25:09migrate and look for somebody to absorb that credit and they had
- 25:13to absorb it at a discount, which ended up sitting in as JP
- 25:16Morgan because of JP Morgan, I believe they're the largest
- 25:19credit issuer for Amazon. They understand how to
- 25:22underwrite that. They have the distribution, but
- 25:25they also have the technical and the economic expertise to be
- 25:29able to do this. And so Goldman really came in,
- 25:33had the distribution, but they they're not consumer based
- 25:35credit lenders. And so they suffered significant
- 25:37losses. And I thought this was
- 25:39fascinating just from a traditional market, you know,
- 25:43retrospective on like how you know, you want to develop a
- 25:47product, you want to get into a new space, but just because you
- 25:49want to do that, have distribution, if you don't have
- 25:52the experience and expertise, you may not be able to be
- 25:55successful. And it reminds me very similar
- 25:58as we start thinking about Bitcoin and custody, Bitcoin
- 26:00back lending and other financial products that unless you have
- 26:03the right taste, team and distribution and experience and
- 26:08expertise, we're going to see a lot of these firms get in this
- 26:11game. But again, naturally not know
- 26:14where to play or how to play. And the the easiest angle to go
- 26:18to is Bitcoin back lending because I think it's easily
- 26:21forgotten that while Bitcoin is the best, you know, asset when
- 26:26it comes to superior like not only for custody, but from the
- 26:31pristine collateral that you get thrown out a bunch.
- 26:34It doesn't really matter how pristine the collateral is if
- 26:36you don't know these new primitives that exist.
- 26:40What are they? Well, it trades 24/7.
- 26:42It's more volatile than traditional markets.
- 26:44Times that are liquid like real liquidity events happen, usually
- 26:48happen in nights and weekends. This is empirically scene I
- 26:51remember being back in the day running a lending buck.
- 26:54And it would be like the one that always comes to mind is
- 26:56Thanksgiving evening. And because there'd always be
- 26:59these crazy deleveraging moments around there and Trap Fight's
- 27:02not prepared for that. And then that's not even
- 27:05accounting for rehypothecation. And the reality, and Trap Fight
- 27:09always has that moral hazard that exists that if we blow up,
- 27:13we will be bailed out because we matter too much.
- 27:16There are no bailouts in Bitcoin.
- 27:18And so if you get offsides in your lending book, there's
- 27:20nobody to step in. And we saw this happen in 2022.
- 27:24And so I think that's where this ties directly into, you know,
- 27:29transfy is going to come in. They're going to, you know,
- 27:31participate in this economy. But the ones that are going to
- 27:34be prudent, conservative are the ones that are going to survive
- 27:36to kind of be players in the space.
- 27:38And I think a lot may you know, end up in the same example as
- 27:43Goldman Sachs and the credit rating or credit lending on
- 27:47consumer side. Yeah, I'd agree.
- 27:52I'd think that a lot of this ultimately is going to come from
- 27:55the consumer to who is who's been in the space and going to
- 28:00ask like they're going to come out with their V ones and it's
- 28:03going to be OK. And you know, it's going to be
- 28:06not not having the assurances that many folks who have been
- 28:11who took out loans of Bitcoin space before are are really
- 28:14looking for And and they naturally won't necessarily all
- 28:19know the stories of block by Celsius and what essentially
- 28:23went wrong there. And over time, the most
- 28:27sophisticated Bitcoin lenders who have who just have the most
- 28:30Bitcoin and have been in the space for the longest.
- 28:33We'll just ask that they upgrade their products otherwise they
- 28:37will only use it for a speculative amount and size
- 28:39their risk appropriately. And ultimately that's just going
- 28:43to drive the market. And I do think a lot of those
- 28:47folks are more like the Morgan Stanley side of the of the world
- 28:50than in one pay. And so it's great to have like
- 28:55Bitcoin and, and, you know, digital assets on there, but I
- 28:59think it's difficult to really make it a core part of your
- 29:02business or, or sell it without all the education that goes into
- 29:08Bitcoin. And just because there is so
- 29:10much confusion and conflation out there with digital assets in
- 29:14general. And so without that, I think it
- 29:17can be difficult to, to get the consumer on board.
- 29:19It's it's, you know, just having Bitcoin and and digital assets
- 29:23out there is going to be a net positive as long as they do
- 29:27everything like custody and making sure that the consumer is
- 29:31is safe. But I could see it not getting
- 29:35quite as much traction within the broader app, although it's
- 29:38so great to see just given the the large amount of
- 29:41distribution. Yeah, that's very well said.
- 29:46Expertise is going to be critical.
- 29:48You know, these, these players, these incumbents, whether it's
- 29:50the banks, Oregon, other fintechs have certainly realized
- 29:55at this point that they need to do something.
- 29:57And so now we're kind of watching the scramble, scramble
- 29:59mode period of a lot of M&A activity partnerships.
- 30:03But again, going back to the, the broader point here, it's
- 30:06like you can have distribution, but having the expertise, the,
- 30:11the domain expertise really around Bitcoin and digital
- 30:14assets is another thing. And the the issue there is that,
- 30:17you know, attracting that type of talent who has that
- 30:21expertise, it's difficult for those players because you know,
- 30:24what hardened Bitcoiner wants to go work for Morgan Stanley, you
- 30:29know, few and far between, I would say.
- 30:31And so that's why you've seen a lot of partnerships and and
- 30:35acquisition activity because they know, they know they're now
- 30:38in the time crunch to be able to offer things to their under
- 30:41underlying clients and they they don't have the expertise, they
- 30:43don't have the infrastructure in house.
- 30:46So maybe that's a nice transition to talk a little bit
- 30:48about Early Riders and the new year 2026 things we're focused
- 30:53on the team is growing. So that's a nice segue to
- 30:57formally introduce a new member of the team, principal and Early
- 31:00Riders, Nick Johnson, who joined from Tri Fi and, and I'll, I'll
- 31:05let him give a little bit more on his background.
- 31:07Maybe, Nick, if you could speak to your prior experience and
- 31:10then maybe how you got into Bitcoin and then more so you
- 31:14know what resonated with you about what we're doing at Early
- 31:16Riders and our thesis here. Yeah, no, for sure.
- 31:19Thanks, Brian. Yeah, no, so super excited to be
- 31:22here and and appreciate the the opportunity to join the pod.
- 31:25So Nick Johnson was born and raised in Dallas.
- 31:29Families lived here my whole life.
- 31:30I worked at City. So prior to to joining early
- 31:33writers, I worked at City and San Francisco doing exclusively
- 31:37technology M&A in terms of kind of my why Bitcoin, you know, in
- 31:43in 2020, my dad and I were watching an interview with
- 31:46Michael, Michael Saylor was on it and I heard him talking about
- 31:50it and and he kind of just gave his whole thesis on like.
- 31:53You know. Why money is broken, why
- 31:56Bitcoins to fix. And I just immediately got
- 32:00enamored by it. I was like, this is super
- 32:02interesting. And I knew there was just
- 32:07something different about it. I'd never heard anything.
- 32:09You know, I had a finance degree, so I learned in school
- 32:12about inflation and how all that works.
- 32:14But you know, there was just when I learned about Bitcoin, it
- 32:16was just different and it seemed like the first asset that's ever
- 32:19really been admitted. That's truly the closest thing
- 32:21to perfect. And so that really kind of won
- 32:24it over for me. So I kind of went down the
- 32:26rabbit hole just like everyone else and kind of realized, you
- 32:30know, I was having a really good experience and, and learning a
- 32:33ton and investment banking. But I just realized that the
- 32:37Bitcoin was just what I was super passionate about and I
- 32:39always wanted to do the buy side in terms of private equity
- 32:42venture, that kind of buy side world.
- 32:45But I really wanted to find a way to kind of intersect the buy
- 32:47side with Bitcoin because that's what I'm most passionate about.
- 32:51And so when early writers were the opportunity kind of came
- 32:55about, I was like, this is perfect.
- 32:56I was like, this perfectly combines my interest in the buy
- 32:59side, my interest in investing and also my, you know, beliefs
- 33:03in Bitcoin and and kind of my full thesis on that.
- 33:06So yeah, hopefully that's kind of helpful, but that that was
- 33:09kind of the key drivers for me. Yeah, thanks for thanks for
- 33:14walking through that. And I think, you know, I
- 33:17believe, you know, part of what would drew you in was our
- 33:20initial white paper that we published close to two years ago
- 33:23now. But I'm going to pull it up here
- 33:25and and we're going to be re releasing this this week, little
- 33:29refresh version, a little bit of a look back on on, you know,
- 33:33what we got right, what we got wrong, where we can improve.
- 33:35But maybe Liam, if you want to talk through a little bit about
- 33:38just the overall thesis and and where we're heading in 2026.
- 33:41Real, real quick. Sorry, just before we go into
- 33:43the white paper, I just wanted to to share super excited about
- 33:48Nick joining. I think 2026 is going to be a
- 33:51big year for Bitcoin early riders of portfolio companies
- 33:55and part of that is leveling up across experience and expertise.
- 34:00I think that part of the themes we'll be talking about with the
- 34:03white paper and in general is there really needs to be the the
- 34:06building of the bridge between Triadfi and digital assets.
- 34:10And a lot of that comes down to the commercial relevance and
- 34:14viability. And what that means is there's a
- 34:16lot of companies building great things in Bitcoin, whether it's
- 34:19slightly tweaking the product for the taste of mass market
- 34:23consumer demand or helping those companies.
- 34:26I think that's where we'll focus and Nick as well, because Nick's
- 34:29worked on very large M&A, he's worked on very large deals.
- 34:33And that's something that's just traditionally missing in a space
- 34:36like we know as people that have been listening to this podcast
- 34:39and follow the Bitcoin space is that there's certain prudent
- 34:42pragmatic ways that makes sense to build products long term.
- 34:46The reality is traffic doesn't appreciate them yet and it's our
- 34:49job to get that there. So it gets the right products
- 34:52with the right firms that are going to stay in for a long
- 34:55time. But it's not enough just to say
- 34:57it's the best product. You got to really be able to
- 34:59articulate it and then show that it benefits there and side and
- 35:04so excited there. Nick will be in Dallas.
- 35:09We are it's not fully announced. If you're listening to this,
- 35:12you'll get a head start. We will have a a Dallas
- 35:14satellite office for early riders and on ramp.
- 35:16You'll be able to meet us and the team because Dallas is going
- 35:19to be a very key and pivotal market given the the current
- 35:22macro in in US set up and what's happening in Texas.
- 35:26So super excited for Nick. And then you can kind of maybe
- 35:28go to Liam and and maybe Liam when you shot share about the
- 35:31the white paper, if you want to just give any highlights on what
- 35:34the purpose of the new white paper was before going into any
- 35:37of the the the particular themes.
- 35:41Yeah, for sure. Well, first of all, I think
- 35:43super excited to have you on the team here.
- 35:45And I can yeah, I think, I think the the white paper is, is a
- 35:49really pivotal, pivotal moment because it's to a lot of
- 35:55Michael's point too. There's so many principles that
- 36:01Bitcoin has, right and that so many folks really have
- 36:04identified with and have benefited significantly by
- 36:08adopting them themselves. Anything from you know, why
- 36:11understanding that Bitcoin is, you know, more of a signal than
- 36:16all the other digital asset tokens out there and why there
- 36:21is a need for you know, cold storage Bitcoin segregated from
- 36:24the Internet that is, you know, not, you know, re hypothecated.
- 36:30All the principles are exactly right and something that should
- 36:33be applied more broadly to the world.
- 36:35But also fact that many of the folks out there, especially
- 36:39those who are listening probably have a significant portion of
- 36:42their net worth in Bitcoin and insignificant is relative to
- 36:46whatever they've really identified with in the past.
- 36:49And then once the natural progression of that is once you
- 36:54have a significant portion of your assets in Bitcoin, you
- 36:57really start to understand, well, I, I at some point
- 37:01allocated to this or I made this personal expense, expense over
- 37:06here and realized, Oh well, especially earlier on, like
- 37:09maybe I would have been better off just buying Bitcoin itself.
- 37:12And that's kind of how we came to this whole conclusion of of
- 37:18early riders in general was both personally using Bitcoin as our
- 37:23way to denominate our expenses and, you know return on and just
- 37:28ability to you know, run circles around our peers who still we're
- 37:32not living in that mindset. And as well as just the insight
- 37:36of, you know, working at the Brown rather Herman's and and
- 37:39points of any use of the world to be able to come in and bridge
- 37:42the principles of the traditional financial world.
- 37:47And, and what really has has gotten right there.
- 37:51And then the on the other side, applying the principles of, you
- 37:55know, everything that we've done on the Bitcoin side of, you
- 37:57know, utilizing the right unit of account, doing more with less
- 38:01and building the bridge in order to create the right products and
- 38:05services for the market. So I'll take a pause there, but
- 38:10it's almost like a manifesto of how all capital formation will
- 38:16come out in the future. Really rooted in practice of
- 38:20being around this industry for a while and understanding what has
- 38:24been going right. And then what potentially needs
- 38:27to be improved upon in order to kind of cross the chasm from
- 38:31being an industry just for hobbyists to essentially
- 38:35creating the best in class products and services for folks
- 38:39like at the Morgan Stanley's in the highest degrees of finance.
- 38:45Yeah, maybe Brian, if you go to the top on some of the the
- 38:48outline, I would encourage anybody listening check out this
- 38:51new white paper. I think the the core idea is as
- 38:55Liam said, that this serves as a a capital, a manifesto for how
- 38:59capital formation will happen in the future.
- 39:01And it really was rooted in two aspects. 1 is building with a
- 39:06Bitcoin standard, whether it's a personal balance sheet or
- 39:08business balance sheet, you end up coming out to the most
- 39:10efficient outcomes because once you have the best form of money,
- 39:14you start to root everything into that, which is very
- 39:16valuable to know that money doesn't grow on trees in your
- 39:19decision making. And then on the other side of
- 39:21that, once individuals, if we believe that the majority, if
- 39:24not all individuals will have to come to that conclusion, well
- 39:27then the logical progression is they have to be credibly, you
- 39:29have to credibly understand how they will get more Bitcoin if
- 39:32they're going to participate in an economic endeavor.
- 39:35And so this white paper we initially put out in 23 and we
- 39:40decided to add to it this new white paper because it really
- 39:45exemplified there was a lot of things that we understood early
- 39:48that are starting to play out, whether it's the notion, The
- 39:50biggest one, I would say, and then I'd love to hear Brian's
- 39:52thoughts is the debate, the basement trade, right?
- 39:55We're still early in this theme, but the notion that the
- 39:58denominator is broken. Being early, people hear it,
- 40:03they hear gold, they understand it, but still tradify at the
- 40:07very margins, may start to think about how do they underwrite
- 40:10their return profile in some other unit, whether it's the S&P
- 40:14500, gold, Bitcoin, but it's still very small.
- 40:18But the logical progression is once people start to question
- 40:20that, then they start to still start the journey on like, well,
- 40:23what are the other denominators that I should be looking at?
- 40:26And then as they go through like, what makes a good form of
- 40:28money? What's the best investment, you
- 40:31know, profile when it comes to all the aspects of Bitcoin, you
- 40:33end up in this logical conclusion, whether it's gold or
- 40:35Bitcoin, you want to sound money to benchmark any returns against
- 40:39because everything else is effectively a derivative of
- 40:42that. And then that's really where
- 40:44this white paper goes deeper into like, why would you raise
- 40:48deploying return in there? What is Bitcoin as a hurdle
- 40:50rate? How does it change capital
- 40:51stacks when you think about a company that uses sound money as
- 40:55its denominator and it goes into like the next steps in that
- 40:58because once you get that you have a better form of money on
- 41:00your balance sheet. Well, that form of money is
- 41:03working in your favor. So you don't spend in the same
- 41:05way as value that's depreciating.
- 41:07So you start to do more with less.
- 41:10So we're really excited about this.
- 41:11We really encourage everyone to take a look at it because it
- 41:14really gives the clarity of thought that comes into how this
- 41:18firm came about. And it's really helped us get a
- 41:20lot on both the investor side because this is what they've
- 41:24been looking for. But then also on the builder
- 41:28side, because builders out there deeply understand these
- 41:30concepts, but they haven't had them articulated.
- 41:32And once they do, they find kind of like that, that group, that
- 41:36team, that version that they want to work and build with.
- 41:38And we really attracted some of cornerstone portfolios based on
- 41:42this white paper that's come out.
- 41:45Yeah, all that's very well said. I would say, you know, the, the,
- 41:49this notion of the denominator being broken is core to
- 41:53everything we do. Quarter of the thesis.
- 41:56And to your point, the a version of that story really entered the
- 42:00zeitgeist this year with gold running, with silver running
- 42:03really all precious metals, commodities.
- 42:06People are waking up to the realities of inevitable Fiat
- 42:10debasement. And while in sort of mainstream
- 42:14circles, it's still viewed as, you know, quote, UN quote the
- 42:17debasement trade, you know, I would say we, we view it
- 42:20slightly differently in that this is a structural long term
- 42:23ship. This isn't just something that
- 42:25you trade in and out of because these these trends, these the
- 42:31debasement realities happen slowly over time, but they're
- 42:35not, you know, there's no really going back from it, right?
- 42:38Like as Lynn Alden says, there's nothing stopping this train.
- 42:40There's nothing stopping the inevitable Fiat debasement.
- 42:43And so you need to be positioned in a way where you can capture
- 42:48or, or really preserve value into the future in this world
- 42:51where, you know, AI is making everything abundant, you need a
- 42:54sound asset to absorb a lot of that.
- 42:57And, and the other thing I would say is that, you know, as we've
- 43:02looked at, you know, one of the themes in here that we talked
- 43:04about is, is doing more with less.
- 43:06And the way I would posit that that theme or that part of the
- 43:10thesis is, is goes back back to a, a quote from Michael Dell
- 43:15that he had a few years ago around constraints, breeding
- 43:18creativity. And that's really the essence
- 43:21of, of what we mean when we say Bitcoin's a hurdle rate.
- 43:23It's the opportunity cost. It it by using a sound unit as
- 43:28your denominator, as your benchmark, you're naturally
- 43:33going to be more disciplined, more prudent in your decision
- 43:35making because you're assessing everything against a, a, a
- 43:39benchmark, a, a form of money that's actually going to
- 43:41appreciate in value. As opposed to the opposite,
- 43:44which most of traditional VC has been sort of stuck in this loop
- 43:47for decades of, you know, raising as much money as
- 43:49possible, deploying as much, you know, spending as much as you
- 43:52can, trying to show top line growth, revenue numbers by, you
- 43:55know, via that spending. And ultimately comes back to
- 43:58chasing the wrong unit and then distorting how capital is
- 44:02deployed, distorting proper price signals in the market.
- 44:06Because again, the, the unit itself that is being chased
- 44:09typically is, is not sound. And so you're constantly on the,
- 44:12the hamster wheel of, of trying to show growth, redeploy
- 44:16capital, you know, raise at a higher valuation, etcetera.
- 44:19Whereas if you were just more disciplined and, and held a
- 44:22better form of money, you wouldn't have to worry about,
- 44:26you know, that that sort of vicious cycle or that loop of,
- 44:28of deployment re raising, you know, getting a higher
- 44:31valuation, etcetera. So, so it's it, it really cuts
- 44:35across various themes in this, in this white paper.
- 44:37So implore everyone to to read through this.
- 44:40And like we said, we're, we're releasing a sort of refreshed
- 44:42version of this, but any other thoughts on on this guys?
- 44:46Yeah, Maybe it's a good transition and then we can go
- 44:49wherever is the the last link with the AI, because I think AI
- 44:53is a a key component of this AI is acceleration.
- 44:57And what Brian just did is exemplified into the notion of
- 45:01everyone's building these vibe coded apps.
- 45:04There's a theme that's been building for the past couple
- 45:07years is like there will be the first billion dollar company,
- 45:10but with by one individual. And I've always had this vision
- 45:15that that person, it will happen, but it'll be somebody
- 45:18that deeply understands these concepts of ethos.
- 45:21Because ultimately, if you're competing with somebody else
- 45:25that has access to the same tools to buy code and app.
- 45:28And obviously, like there is execution in the entrepreneur
- 45:30entrepreneurial taste for distribution of the market.
- 45:33But let's say those both existed pretty similarly.
- 45:36Well, it all comes down to how are you sweeping your capital
- 45:40into and what are you chasing? Because if you're holding a
- 45:42better form of money, it's appreciated in value.
- 45:45You're going to have a sharper lens and how you build.
- 45:48And so sorry it was it was the last one where why the latest
- 45:52craze of PE and BC roll ups won't work.
- 45:55This video, yeah. You don't have to click the
- 45:57video, but just if you pull it up because it'll show well,
- 46:00Liam's or Brian's pulling it up. I thought this was super
- 46:03fascinating because this was a recent podcast that was, I guess
- 46:09it had to do with all In interview, which was Mackenzie
- 46:11and General Catalyst senior exec execs, if not the CEO of General
- 46:17Catalyst. But the point being is there's a
- 46:19craze going on right now. It includes these firms,
- 46:22includes like 8 BC and others that are doing these roll ups
- 46:26around. And like it's like venture kind
- 46:28of migrating because they're realizing that like the venture
- 46:31model doesn't won't historically work in this new world.
- 46:35And what they're looking at is like cash flow positive
- 46:39businesses that are pretty like unsexy that they can either
- 46:43invest in businesses that will roll them up or roll them up or
- 46:46funds and then integrating in Fuse, like best practices in AI.
- 46:50And at first glance, it sounds great.
- 46:52I expect a lot of capital to flow into these themes.
- 46:55But when you really start to peel back the layers as an
- 46:57entrepreneur, you realize that that is one approach, but it's
- 47:02an approach that won't be the most efficient because you're
- 47:05effectively having to re architect the foundation that is
- 47:07just fundamentally broken when it comes to the inefficiencies
- 47:10and the people that have been hired and the processes that are
- 47:13part of the totality of the culture versus if it's just
- 47:17embedded from day one, meaning that you're going to be
- 47:20utilizing these tools, your team is going to be utilizing the
- 47:24tools from a mindset and also from a productivity perspective.
- 47:27And I think that's really embodies like we are focused on
- 47:30Bitcoin returns. Doesn't mean we only focus on
- 47:33Bitcoin infrastructure because there is a much more value
- 47:36that's been delivered to the world that has a lot of fat and
- 47:39inefficiencies. But once you have somebody that
- 47:41understands these concepts and themes and wants to effectively
- 47:44infuse them into building that new companies that compete with
- 47:47the incumbents, that are historically fat, mired with
- 47:50inflation, mired with return over bad unit economics, this is
- 47:54how we'll rebuild the world to be more efficient and net new
- 47:57value to be delivered. And so I just thought this was
- 48:00interesting because I, I was always like fascinated by this
- 48:03concept and I thought it would go somewhere.
- 48:05And I still think it will, but it it will be like a migration
- 48:08point, not the end state to basically net new company
- 48:11building what this will be the category winners.
- 48:14And that's super exciting for what we're working on and who
- 48:16we're looking for to get involved with what we build.
- 48:19Yeah, that's a great point. And as soon as I heard about
- 48:24Bitcoin denominated firm while I was still at my old private
- 48:27equity shop, I it initially clicked like, oh, we're cocked.
- 48:32If this has any credible way to actually outperform or even
- 48:37denominate returns in Bitcoin, it's just so much superior to
- 48:42the existing status quo. But over time, capital, all
- 48:46capital allocation will need to come this way.
- 48:48It's just like how overtime better, better money will drive
- 48:52out bad money and you know it. It definitely takes time.
- 48:55And there's the entrenched bureaucracies and status quo
- 48:58that will limit adoption, especially by the the
- 49:03established funds who, you know, probably know that this is how
- 49:07they should be operating, but can't because it admits that how
- 49:11they were previously doing business is, you know, generally
- 49:14not the right way. But on the other side of things
- 49:18too, I think it's important to call out that, you know, some
- 49:21folks just literally have, no, they're like, well, all these
- 49:24concepts are 100% right and I agree with, but there's just no
- 49:27way to outperform Bitcoin. And that's just essentially
- 49:30saying that the world will look exactly as it does in the
- 49:33future, which I generally don't agree with.
- 49:36I think that it will change significantly.
- 49:38And you know, everyday we're seeing like more and better
- 49:42opportunities come through the door in terms of just the
- 49:45acceleration of kind of human progress and technology.
- 49:48And so I would say it's never been a more exciting time in
- 49:52both venture and and to be thinking about capital
- 49:54allocation. This way, yeah.
- 49:56Just to maybe put a, a loop around this discussion, I, this
- 50:01tweet caught my eye over the weekend from Akash Gupta.
- 50:05He started a, a company called Product growth.
- 50:08But what he's saying here is the, basically the, the broken
- 50:11traditional BC and, and founder math.
- 50:14And we've talked about this in the past.
- 50:16So like the way traditional BC works is, you know, effectively
- 50:20you assume that, you know, 9 out of 10 bets are going to go to 0
- 50:23and you really need to hit a home run with one or two of
- 50:26those bets. So this says BCS need 3X fund
- 50:28returns to stay in business, $100 million fund needs to
- 50:31return 300 million if they own 20% of their company at exit,
- 50:34you need to sell for 1.5. So basically he's saying, you
- 50:37know, there's a, there's a misalignment of incentives here
- 50:39between these mega funds and founders.
- 50:42Effectively where it says here the incentive structures are
- 50:45pointed in the opposite direction.
- 50:46VCs optimized for portfolio returns, founders optimized for
- 50:49personal outcomes. These only align at $500 million
- 50:52plus exits. And really the take away from
- 50:54this to me was like the this misalignment of incentives
- 50:59traces back to again, chasing the wrong unit.
- 51:02So the these dynamics that are being described here are
- 51:06effectively a function of broken money and the, you know, broken
- 51:10denominator that we referenced and the need to basically chase
- 51:16hyper growth outcomes for, you know, 10% or or less of of a
- 51:20fund. And so, you know, the, the way
- 51:23that you combat this is you, you use a better form of money and
- 51:26you don't have to effectively be on that hamster wheel of, of
- 51:30trying to achieve these outsize exits.
- 51:33And, and just assuming that the rest of your portfolio gets to 0
- 51:36like that is not a prudent or efficient way of doing things.
- 51:39And so I think people are starting to wake up to a lot of
- 51:42these sort of misalignments. They're, they're still missing
- 51:46the broader solution of, of tying it back to the money being
- 51:49broken. But I thought this was
- 51:51interesting in in sort of the context of this discussion that,
- 51:55you know, most people are still missing this, but they are, you
- 51:57know, at least somewhat waking up to the the misaligned
- 52:02incentives that are sort of pervasive throughout the
- 52:04traditional VC space. What do you guys think on this?
- 52:09Yeah. I mean it's a great, it's a
- 52:11great call out. I mean, what we're talking about
- 52:12here reminds a very similar of sometimes we talk past each
- 52:16other when it comes to Bitcoin and where it sits in a
- 52:18portfolio. Because for vast majority of
- 52:21people that are interested in Bitcoin, they don't necessarily
- 52:25underwrite it based on like where gold SAT for hundreds, if
- 52:28not thousands of years and specifically around capital
- 52:30formation. So it, it doesn't end up as an
- 52:33end state. It ends up as like a sleeve in a
- 52:35portfolio. And it's very similar here when
- 52:38you talk about like VC math and the insanity of the VC industry
- 52:43that's grown over the past 50 years.
- 52:46To really understand how it's a Frankenstein aberration,
- 52:50whatever you want to call it, construct, you really have to go
- 52:52back to how venture started, the purpose of it.
- 52:56And then the reality of whether it's institutional family
- 52:59offices put in any bucket and have to go further and further
- 53:03out on the risk curve to hit the return profile and benchmark.
- 53:08And then ultimately looking at these like outliers that have
- 53:11provided air cover for everyone to raise a fund because the vast
- 53:14majority of funds underperform the S&P when it looks at look at
- 53:18quartiles, there's very few venture funds that hit their
- 53:20targets. And so this will only increase
- 53:24because of the amount of monetary units.
- 53:26And it really gives like a negative connotation to like
- 53:29venture in it in itself, because the notion of capitalizing
- 53:34somebody to return, you know, more capital is pretty
- 53:37straightforward, has existed for forever since money's existed.
- 53:41It's the notion that you need to go for home runs, that 9 out of
- 53:4410 bets failed. These are all concepts of a Fiat
- 53:47system. And that they, they can exist
- 53:49because you can do the, the the mental model of in a Bitcoin
- 53:54world. Well, what, what sane person
- 53:58would give up their capital to know that 90% of it is going to
- 54:01be evaporated? And like, what same person would
- 54:03get out of bed if they hadn't? They knew that a 90% chance they
- 54:05would fail. It doesn't make any sense.
- 54:08But we fund these concepts when they're theoretical and that we
- 54:11can go for the home runs because the money's broken.
- 54:13So, yeah, this, I hadn't fully looked at this, but this is kind
- 54:15of a common thread and really the understanding that if you're
- 54:19going to build a better firm and that last into to the future and
- 54:23the perpetuity. Ideally it said you have to
- 54:25start with the right foundation and then bet that the rest of
- 54:28the market is going to naturally come this way.
- 54:30Because that's the, one of the most exciting things from an
- 54:32institutional perspective is when people start to just wake
- 54:35up and realize, well, why am I doing any of this?
- 54:38Why don't I just hold this money that has a venture like return,
- 54:41but has the safety of bonds? And, and then that's the first
- 54:44step. And that's what on ramp and
- 54:45other portfolio companies solve for.
- 54:47But then over time, as you get there, as the price appreciates
- 54:50and the return profile starts to diminish.
- 54:52And also as you start to think about diversification,
- 54:55specifically from an institutional or even individual
- 54:58that wants to invest their Bitcoin will, their natural
- 55:01progression is will are you going to give me more Bitcoin
- 55:03than I gave you, which is a very rational thing to to say and do.
- 55:08100%, yeah. That, that's, that's a piece
- 55:11that most of the sort of traditional market is still
- 55:14missing. It's like, why would I, why
- 55:17would I want to receive more dollars 10 years from now?
- 55:19You have no anchor to know what those dollars are going to be
- 55:23worth 10 years from now. And so it's, it's completely
- 55:27irrational to to lock up capital for that amount of time with the
- 55:32hope of, you know, outperforming the S&P effectively in dollar
- 55:35terms, nominal terms. So Brian was referencing, you
- 55:39know, we're coming up on an hour, but one thing we did want
- 55:40to call out was the launch. This will be released on
- 55:43Tuesday, today's Monday honor and for everyone.
- 55:47We're really excited about this on the honor and side because
- 55:51ultimately one of the concepts we just talked about around
- 55:54understanding Bitcoin as your unit of account and savings
- 55:56vehicle is that still a far reaching for a vast majority of
- 56:01individuals because ultimately they don't know how to credibly
- 56:03custody it, which is impedes the ability to really get material
- 56:07exposure. And so we've been called, you
- 56:10know, on ramp the Rolls Royce of custody.
- 56:12We work with institutions, endowments, pub Cos, but a lot
- 56:16of individuals don't feel that they can work with us, whether
- 56:19it's because of our marketing needs to improve or the cost
- 56:21structure. So honoring for everyone
- 56:24includes an IRA account, individual self onboarding.
- 56:27We still do white glove onboarding, but then really a
- 56:30flat fee structure which has been asked for by a lot of
- 56:33individuals. One thing that we're going to do
- 56:35to upgrade, you know, this year is final settlement doing more
- 56:39kind of just engagement with the audience.
- 56:41One thing is if you sign up, if you want to check out on ramp,
- 56:44you can actually get 50% off your first month using FS.
- 56:47So if you go through get set up, you'll get 50%.
- 56:50If you've been meaning to try on ramp and you felt whether all
- 56:53those things that we talked about, you needed an IRA account
- 56:55to be included, the fee structure or you just didn't
- 56:59know if we worked with you as an individual.
- 57:01So we're super pumped to have that out.
- 57:04Brian, do you have any thoughts on honoring for everyone?
- 57:07Oh yeah. This is this is going to be a
- 57:10big, big deal for us heading into this new year.
- 57:13I think historically there's been a perception that on ramp
- 57:17only works with super high net worth folks or institutional
- 57:20allocators. And while we do service those
- 57:23those cohorts as well, we wanted to re emphasize the individual
- 57:27because frankly, that makes up the core of of our existing
- 57:31client base today is individuals, many of whom who
- 57:34have been holding Bitcoin for a long time, predominantly in some
- 57:38form of self custody. And they realize that a certain
- 57:41point when that portion of your net worth becomes so material
- 57:46that the burden of, of self custody and, and whether it's
- 57:50the physical or digital attack risks or even just thinking
- 57:53about long term planning like inheritance and estate planning.
- 57:57It it you don't have to be on an island effectively.
- 58:00You can use on ramp and also be confident and know that you
- 58:05know, you're not ceding unilateral control to anyone
- 58:08particular custodian, which has been basically the the pitfall
- 58:12and why a lot of folks have been in self custody for years is
- 58:14because they know it's not prudent to just keep coins on an
- 58:18exchange and you know, an omnibus pool where you don't
- 58:20actually have clear visibility or transparency into your
- 58:24Bitcoin. So, you know, the way on ramp
- 58:25works is you have a segregated multi sig vault where 3
- 58:30institutions are, are coordinating on your behalf.
- 58:32You're sort of quarterbacking the quorum.
- 58:34And it's really a, a fantastic solution for individuals of all
- 58:37kind. Whether you're new to the space
- 58:39and don't want to have to go down the path of, of learning
- 58:41self custody or you've been in for a while and you recognize
- 58:45the, the value prop of, of what we've built and how it can be
- 58:48accretive to your existing set of the, you know, none of this
- 58:50is meant to fully replace self custody.
- 58:53We, we believe in self custody and think it's critically
- 58:56important really to the network. The ability to hold your own
- 59:00keys is, is massively important. But you know, we think MIC and,
- 59:04and what on ramp provides can be in a creative element of someone
- 59:08set up and just being able to know that a certain amount of
- 59:13your Bitcoin wealth is going to be passed on to your your spouse
- 59:16or your kids, for example, with a proper inheritance plan, with
- 59:19legal titling, you can set up all that stuff easily in apps.
- 59:22So this is a big deal for us. But anything else on that, Mike?
- 59:27Yeah, I think we covered it. Super excited.
- 59:30As mentioned, you can use FS if you want to get 50% off your
- 59:33first month to try it out. And then like we talked about,
- 59:36we're just going to do a lot more with the audience as it
- 59:39relates to special incentives, swag, you'll be able to meet us
- 59:43in market. And then, yeah, I don't know if
- 59:47I want to leave it to Nick and Liam to leave.
- 59:50The one thing I'll share with the audience is we're constantly
- 59:53looking to improve the segments and what we're looking at.
- 59:55We've had no shortage of real high quality inbound from
- 59:59company buildings who would encourage anybody that's
- 1:00:01thinking about opportunities. We'd love to chat with them.
- 1:00:04And then also just in the YouTube comments, if you have
- 1:00:07any other thoughts around segments, opportunities, things
- 1:00:09we should be focusing on. We're always looking for
- 1:00:11feedback. So please, it's always nice to
- 1:00:14to hear from the audience, but Nick and Liam, anything before
- 1:00:17we wrap. No, I'd just say, yeah, please
- 1:00:22check out the white paper if you haven't seen it yet.
- 1:00:26It's a, it's really phenomenal work.
- 1:00:28And would would also please reach out and give us comments
- 1:00:32on the white paper too, in addition to just the segments in
- 1:00:35general. But then yeah, lastly, we're
- 1:00:37going to be trying to do a lot more with, you know, building
- 1:00:40the bridge across not just, you know, Bitcoin and and tried by
- 1:00:44on the early riders side. But yeah, with all the portfolio
- 1:00:46companies too, like on ramp for everybody kind of bridging all
- 1:00:50the principles of self custody such as proof of reserves built
- 1:00:54in no single point of failure and and the experience that
- 1:00:57everybody is used to at traditional financial U.S. banks
- 1:01:03and fintechs. So yeah, excited for for grade
- 1:01:072026 and can't wait to get after it neck anything else?
- 1:01:11Yeah. No, I think you, I think you hit
- 1:01:12the nail on the head. I think all I would say is is
- 1:01:14obviously super excited to be a part of the team.
- 1:01:16I think 2026 is going to be a big year.
- 1:01:20And you know, I think, I think we're pretty well positioned to
- 1:01:22to take advantage of that. So I think I would leave you
- 1:01:25with that. Awesome.
- 1:01:27Thanks guys there. You go.
- 1:01:32Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:01:35If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:01:37episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:01:39app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:01:41today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:01:44Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Rat Media is
- 1:01:47for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:01:49nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:01:53Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:01:55to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact
- 1:01:59to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 1:02:01Advisors.