Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Top 10 Tips for Drafting Enforceable Employment Arbitration Agreements
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:08Top 10 Tips for Drafting Enforceable Employment
- 0:11Arbitration Agreements. I'm Alla Policastro.
- 0:14I am the Director of Education and Professional
- 0:16Development at Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:19And today, I am delighted to introduce our speakers,
- 0:22Tyler Patko and Kathy Nguyen. Tyler has been
- 0:26representing employers in labor and employment
- 0:29law matters for 36 years. As both a trusted advisor
- 0:33and litigator, he has handled a variety of labor
- 0:36and employment challenges, including claims of
- 0:39wrongful termination, discrimination, retaliation,
- 0:43sexual harassment, defamation, wage and hour
- 0:45violations, unpaid commissions, collective and
- 0:49class actions, and unfair label practice charges.
- 0:53Tyler also represents employers in litigation
- 0:55involving unfair competition, misappropriation
- 0:59of trade secrets, restrictive covenants, and
- 1:02employee mobility issues. He also has extensive
- 1:05experience representing employers in traditional
- 1:07union management labor relation matters, including
- 1:10union organizing campaigns, strikes, and collective
- 1:13bargaining negotiations. Kathy represents employers
- 1:17in all aspects of labor and employment law in
- 1:20U .S. and federal and state courts before administrative
- 1:23agencies and in arbitration. Kathy has experience
- 1:26in wage and hour, class and Paga representative
- 1:29actions as well as collective. actions under
- 1:32the Fair Labor Standards Act. She also litigates
- 1:36claims involving workplace discrimination, harassment,
- 1:39retaliation, failure to provide reasonable accommodations,
- 1:42and other causes of action arising under state
- 1:45and federal laws. She also represents clients
- 1:47in background checks litigation under the Fair
- 1:50Credit Reporting Act. Kathy's clients span all
- 1:53industries with emphasis on technology, manufacturing,
- 1:56and transportation companies. In addition to
- 1:59her litigation practice, Kathy advises clients
- 2:01on California's complex employment laws. She
- 2:05regularly helps employers review and revise their
- 2:07employment policies and procedures, including
- 2:10policies on wage and hour issues, employee background
- 2:13checks, and paid sick leave. Kathy also provides
- 2:16employment law compliance training to management
- 2:18and executives. We can't wait to hear what both
- 2:21of of these amazing speakers have to share with
- 2:23us today. So I'm going to turn it over to them.
- 2:27Thank you very much. And thank you, BHBA. Sorry
- 2:33for my voice. First of all, I was at the spring
- 2:36training this weekend and my voice hasn't recovered
- 2:40yet. So we're very happy to be here. Happy St.
- 2:45Patty's Day to everyone. I'm going to ask my
- 2:47colleague Kathy to carry me a little bit here.
- 2:50just with my voice going, but I'll try to speak
- 2:53up a little bit. So you can go to the next slide.
- 2:58We have a relatively ambitious agenda here today,
- 3:03and we welcome questions at any time or at the
- 3:07end. I think there's a chat feature where you
- 3:10can put those questions in. So just to be clear,
- 3:13this discussion today is not about the pros and
- 3:18cons of arbitration. And that's really a separate
- 3:21webinar. I think we could probably spend two
- 3:24hours on that. But just briefly, and you all
- 3:27probably know this, but just to be clear, arbitration
- 3:32does have its downsides. You have limited appeal
- 3:35rights, number one. The arbitration result is
- 3:39generally final and binding. You can appeal it
- 3:43to the Court of Appeal or the trial court even
- 3:46to vacate it, but the grounds again are limited.
- 3:49It also has limited discovery and arbitration.
- 3:53You generally are not entitled to a dispositive
- 3:55motion, an MSJ. So there are some downside risk.
- 4:02In addition, if an arbitrator makes an error
- 4:04of law, That, surprisingly, is not enough to
- 4:07overturn an arbitration award. It's the ideas.
- 4:11The parties have entered in and negotiated an
- 4:14alternative method to resolve disputes. And with
- 4:17that, they're giving up some rights. So I will
- 4:22leave it at that for now. But I will just say
- 4:25that arbitration is rough justice. And be careful
- 4:28what you wish for. I think for larger employers
- 4:31with a class action waiver, there's reasons for
- 4:36arbitration. But again, it's not a be all end
- 4:40all. It's not that you have to go to arbitration.
- 4:44Today, we're going to focus on once your client
- 4:49or you as an employer decide, yes, we want to
- 4:53go to arbitration, we prefer an arbitrator. We
- 4:58prefer taking our chances with an arbitrator
- 5:00versus a jury. So we're focusing today on enforceable
- 5:05drafting tips. And, you know, the law over the
- 5:10years has supported arbitration, both federal
- 5:14and California law are supposedly pro arbitration.
- 5:19But some of this, you know, the changes in the
- 5:22law, especially I blame it on the courts. And
- 5:26since we're here for St. Patty's Day, I call
- 5:30it shenanigans. by the courts. We have a tug
- 5:33of war between the federal courts, including
- 5:36the Ninth Circuit and the Supreme Court, U .S.
- 5:39Supreme Court, and the California Courts, Courts
- 5:41of Appeal, and the California Supreme Court.
- 5:44And you've heard these cases before, Armandara's
- 5:48California Supreme Court, which announced like
- 5:50minimum standards of fairness for statutory claims.
- 5:55And then since then, we've had a discovered bank
- 5:57case. which was overruled by the Supreme Court
- 6:00in Concepcion. And most recently, we had the
- 6:04Viking River Cruises, also a SCOTUS case, which
- 6:10embraced the Federal Arbitration Act and found
- 6:14that it preempted contrary state laws. So we're
- 6:18going to not get into the law so much on what's
- 6:24left after Concepcion and Viking River. That's
- 6:28also probably another seminar, but focus on doing
- 6:32it right. If you're going to do an arbitration
- 6:33agreement, how can you do it right? What are
- 6:37the best odds that it will be enforced? Just
- 6:40to share a little war story, we all love war
- 6:44stories. The genesis of this program in our article,
- 6:48which is included in the materials, is Cathy
- 6:52and I and a lot of our colleagues. often got
- 6:55embroiled in what I call satellite litigation
- 6:58over whether the agreement is even enforceable
- 7:01in the first place. And I had a case a long time
- 7:05ago. It was actually a 2014 case called TRI versus
- 7:14Lucky Chances. Lucky Chances, well, the citation
- 7:18for that is 226 Calab 4th, 231. It's a 2014 First
- 7:26District Court of Appeal opinion. And in that
- 7:30case, the plaintiff who was disabled filed a
- 7:36wrongful termination, disability discrimination,
- 7:39failure to accommodate claim, pretty standard
- 7:42stuff in California. I believe she filed her
- 7:45lawsuit in 2012. And the trial court, it was
- 7:50San Mateo, denied our motion to compel arbitration,
- 7:53even though we were correct. Some, especially
- 7:56state court judges, don't like arbitration. And
- 8:00you're already fighting an uphill fight in front
- 8:03of some judges in terms of enforcing arbitration
- 8:07agreements. So in the Terry case, the trial judge
- 8:12found that we didn't attach the arbitration rules
- 8:15to our agreement. There were some other elements
- 8:19of arguable which we'll talk about sometime a
- 8:24little bit later here. So we took an appeal,
- 8:28the Court of Appeal reversed the decision, and
- 8:31it was really based on the delegation provision,
- 8:34which is tip number one, have an express delegation
- 8:38to the Arbitrator provision because that entire
- 8:42order got reversed. The problem is when we went
- 8:46back to arbitration, I think in 2016, so some
- 8:50four years after the plaintiff filed her lawsuit.
- 8:55When we went to the hearing and she couldn't
- 8:58speak, you know, absolutely could not say a word.
- 9:01So again, be careful what you wish for because
- 9:04we won the, I guess we won the battle, but we
- 9:07still had to deal with the war, the end of the
- 9:09case. And as the whole, the purpose of this is
- 9:12to avoid all of that satellite litigation, or
- 9:15at least to make it less likely that you're going
- 9:18to have the satellite. litigation. On the on
- 9:24the part prior slide, I just indicated some of
- 9:27these tips are common sense, you know, it's based
- 9:30on fairness. And some of them, some of the tips
- 9:33that you see it there, common sense and fairness,
- 9:36there are a few traps for the unwary employer
- 9:38will point those out. Those are not so obvious.
- 9:42But if you don't get it right, it can doom your
- 9:44arbitration agreement from the outset. And and
- 9:48we do have a template California Arbitration
- 9:51Agreement. Kathy and I are still debating what
- 9:54to include in that. We don't like and don't recommend
- 9:58boilerplate for any employment agreements. So
- 10:01it's with some trepidation and reservation that
- 10:04we're going to send you our template, but it
- 10:07does have all the bells and whistles, some options
- 10:09for employers. But just bear in mind, and we'll
- 10:13include a disclaimer, the law in this area, it
- 10:17seems to change almost weekly. We'll get a new
- 10:20decision on a federal court or state court, court
- 10:23of appeal. And then, you know, in some cases
- 10:26we have to go back to the drawing board or we
- 10:28have to update the employment agreement. So that's
- 10:31a large disclaimer, you know, lawyers like disclaimers.
- 10:35It's not a one size fits all. And regardless
- 10:39of whether you use our template or not, you should
- 10:41still run it by your local employment council
- 10:44just because of the pace. to which these changes
- 10:49occur. The other thing about just drafting agreements,
- 10:54a lot of it is risk tolerance. There are some
- 10:57provisions that if you're going to be really
- 10:59conservative, you just delete them. We're not
- 11:02going to take a chance. There are other provisions.
- 11:05I'm thinking about the employer wants injunctive
- 11:08relief. A court might say that's not mutual.
- 11:11That's a claim the employer is more likely to
- 11:14make. for a TRO or in charge of relief trade
- 11:17secret dispute, for example, but not an employee.
- 11:21So it's about risk tolerance and how much risk
- 11:24your client wants to take in fashioning the arbitration
- 11:28agreement. So next slide. So without further
- 11:34ado, these are our top 10 list or top 10 tips.
- 11:41And just to explain what I mean, The use of a
- 11:46clear and unmistakable delegation clause, that
- 11:49I classify as a trap. You have to use magic language
- 11:53for it. So I call it a trap. Use a standalone
- 11:57agreement with a verifiable signature. In other
- 12:02words, don't bury it in an employee handbook.
- 12:04That I classify as obvious common sense. Number
- 12:10three. Make it clear and understandable. Use
- 12:12plain English. That is obvious and based on fairness.
- 12:17Number three, make it clear and understandable.
- 12:22Another obvious tip. Arbitrator neutrality. That
- 12:26should be obvious as well. Number five, I classify
- 12:31as a trap. because you can select the arbitration
- 12:35rules. You can even select provider rules like
- 12:39we'll talk about AAA, American Arbitration Association
- 12:43and JAMS, the most commonly used, but you can
- 12:47fashion your own. If you do that, you just have
- 12:50to make sure you get it right. It's a hidden
- 12:54trap. Six, I classify as a trap. It's kind of
- 12:59a reverse trap. The tip is by including an opt
- 13:03out period. So the employee is presented with
- 13:07a mandatory arbitration agreement. They have
- 13:0930 days to opt out of the arbitration program.
- 13:13And we all know most employees will not opt out.
- 13:18They may ask some questions, but giving that
- 13:22opt out period eliminates one element of unconscionability,
- 13:27which Kathy is going to talk about. That's procedural
- 13:29unconscionability. Most employment arbitration
- 13:33agreements that I've seen still do not have number
- 13:36six. So that's a big one for today. Number seven,
- 13:40I classify as obvious. You can't tilt the playing
- 13:44field. So this is really we're having a trial.
- 13:48like we would in court, it's just an alternative
- 13:51forum. So you can't shorten statute limitations,
- 13:55limit remedies, impose undue cost on an employee.
- 13:59All of those factors, you know, tilting the playing
- 14:02field will affect and potentially invalidate
- 14:07your arbitration agreement. Number eight, I classify
- 14:12as another trap, enforceable waivers. I know
- 14:15we're going to talk a little bit about the Private
- 14:18Attorney General Act, Everybody's Bain. It's
- 14:21been reformed, I heard, in 2024, but the reforms
- 14:25didn't take. I haven't seen any reforms yet.
- 14:28So we're still dealing with Paga claims and whether
- 14:31the individual claim can be compelled to arbitration
- 14:35under one of these agreements, even if the representative
- 14:38claim stays in court. Number nine is another
- 14:42obvious tip. And that is, as we said, the law
- 14:46changes constantly. So it's common sense to keep
- 14:50your agreement current, review it periodically,
- 14:53maybe even calendar reminders, you know, every
- 14:57couple of months to make sure there's nothing
- 14:59new that requires an update to your agreement.
- 15:02And 10 is obvious, but it's worth saying, and
- 15:06that's implement sensible protocols. and regular
- 15:09employee training. In employment law, I haven't
- 15:12done it for 36 years, but who's counting? Employee
- 15:15training is really, really important. It's often
- 15:19not emphasized enough how important that is.
- 15:22That's everything from what is our program? How
- 15:26is it explained to the employees? What disclosures
- 15:31are made to the employees? You may have an employment
- 15:34agreement that's presented, but then a separate
- 15:37policy around the arbitration program that could
- 15:42even include FAQs for the employees. So those
- 15:46are all important protocols and training managers
- 15:52in HR, when they get questions about the arbitration
- 15:55agreement, at least have them send them to a
- 15:58designated person who understands the arbitration
- 16:00program and can answer questions. So by my count,
- 16:07six out of the 10 tips that we have here are
- 16:10obvious. So they're already in your minds, they're
- 16:13common sense. So we are going to go over them
- 16:16just to, you know, not to beat a dead horse,
- 16:21but just make sure they're in your minds going
- 16:24forward. And a lot of this is for HR and compliance.
- 16:29So next slide. So I thought I would start. This
- 16:36is the most recent California Supreme Court decision
- 16:39on arbitration. Ramirez versus Charter Communications
- 16:42decided in July of 2024. And this is a good illustration
- 16:48of drafting errors, how drafting errors can doom
- 16:51an arbitration agreement. In this case, you know,
- 16:55it obviously went up to the Court of Appeal,
- 16:57then to the Supreme Court. Supreme Court... found
- 17:00that several provisions in the employer's arbitration
- 17:03agreement were unconscionable. And it's the obvious
- 17:07things that things that are frequently targets.
- 17:10The agreement unfairly limited discovery. It
- 17:13shortened the statute of limitations for certain
- 17:15claims. Remember, especially for statutory claims,
- 17:20wage hour, discrimination, harassment, retaliation.
- 17:25Those are now subject to longer. statute limitations.
- 17:31Excuse me for for wage hour claims you're looking
- 17:34generally at three years liability created by
- 17:36statute or four years if there's a companion
- 17:40unfair competition claim under business and professions
- 17:44code section 17 200. Lacking mutuality I use
- 17:49the example hey this has an exception the employer
- 17:52can go to court for injunctive relief Or maybe
- 17:55the agreement says both parties could go to court
- 17:58for an injunctive relief. But the courts have
- 18:00said, wait a minute, that's not something that
- 18:04an employee is going to go to court for. That's
- 18:05an employer benefit. And as a result, the agreement
- 18:10lacks mutuality. So in the most recent case,
- 18:15Ramirez, the Supreme Court remanded the case
- 18:18back to the trial court. to make these findings
- 18:23and decide whether to sever some of these unconscionable
- 18:28provisions and enforce the remainder of the agreement.
- 18:33And Justice Corrigan wrote for the court. You
- 18:35can see the quotation here. And I wish there
- 18:38was more guidance than this, but you have to
- 18:39look at the, quote, totality of the circumstances.
- 18:43And importantly, a court can't just rely on one
- 18:46or two provisions and say, OK, I'm throwing it
- 18:50out. It's unconscionable. It's not enforceable.
- 18:54But I would submit you don't want to be in that
- 18:56position where you're defending multiple provisions
- 18:59in your arbitration agreement as opposed to one
- 19:03maybe that can be severed. The one thing I might
- 19:06add based on the Charter Communications case
- 19:11is a tip 11, which is also obvious, but to include
- 19:16a severance agreement in your arbitration agreement,
- 19:19allowing an arbitrator or a court to sever any
- 19:23unconscionable provisions. Any provisions that
- 19:26go too far can be severed and the rest of the
- 19:29arbitration agreement can be enforced in court.
- 19:34The case also points out The primary challenge
- 19:38that we get to arbitration agreements, even today,
- 19:42is unconscionability. And there's a procedural
- 19:45unconscionability, which we'll talk about, and
- 19:49substantive unconscionability. You have to have
- 19:51both to have an unreforcible agreement, although
- 19:55they don't have to be present in equal measure
- 19:57in the agreement. So with that, I think we'll
- 20:03go on to the first tip. So delegation clause,
- 20:11what is it? So if you read, you go back and you
- 20:15look at the Terry versus Lucky Chance's case.
- 20:20Fortunately, we had a really good delegation
- 20:22clause in that case. And the court of appeal
- 20:26relied on that in reversing the trial court finding
- 20:32and said. The delegation provision itself was
- 20:36not unconscionable. It didn't have any elements
- 20:39of unfairness. And the typical delegation clause
- 20:43says that all disputes, claims, or controversies
- 20:47arising out of or relating to this agreement,
- 20:51including the interpretation, validity, enforceability,
- 20:56or scope of this agreement, or any part thereof,
- 21:00including whether a particular claim is subject
- 21:02to arbitration, and any claim that all or part
- 21:06of this agreement is void or avoidable, shall
- 21:09be determined exclusively by a single neutral
- 21:13arbitrator, and importantly, not by a court.
- 21:16Not by a court. So you need to include that in
- 21:20every arbitration agreement. It's rule number
- 21:23one. A recent example is the Jack versus Ring
- 21:26case we have cited here, where the court found
- 21:30it was ambiguous. It wasn't clear and mistakeable,
- 21:34because one provision delegated to the arbitrator
- 21:38the validity of the agreement, while another
- 21:41provision suggested a court could find the contract
- 21:44unenforceable. So it's kind of a mixed message
- 21:47there. So it has to be clear. It has to be unmistakable.
- 21:54Terry is a good example. There's other cases.
- 21:57Some of them are cited in our article. I know
- 21:59one was called Malone, which has examples of
- 22:02clear and unmistakable delegation clauses. And
- 22:06then you'll get a result like we got in Terry,
- 22:09where the court of appeals said, we have no jurisdiction.
- 22:13We can't even weigh in on unconscionability of
- 22:16the remainder of the arbitration agreement. Because
- 22:19of the delegation clause, it goes to the arbitrator.
- 22:27And by the way, you can use the Jams or AAA rules.
- 22:32They have sample delegation clauses that have
- 22:35been blessed by the courts. So that's another
- 22:37source if you want to look at a sample delegation
- 22:40clause. If you read Teary, it's in page one of
- 22:44the agreement that has the delegation clause.
- 22:53is pretty obvious to using plain language, specifically
- 22:58referencing the arbitration agreement. Again,
- 22:59this is in a standalone agreement, not in a handbook
- 23:04or a larger employment contract. Sometimes we
- 23:08see the employment agreement included in a proprietary
- 23:12information and invention assignment agreement
- 23:14or a larger employment agreement. And that's
- 23:18okay, not preferable, not ideal. It's better
- 23:21to have a standalone agreement. For sure. Next,
- 23:27turn it over to Kathy. Good afternoon. So I'm
- 23:32going to cover a few of the drafting tips that
- 23:34come up when these agreements are actually challenged
- 23:36in litigation, especially issues around electronic
- 23:40signatures and how the agreement is presented
- 23:42to employees. As Tyler mentioned, use a standalone
- 23:49agreement with a verifiable signature. And one
- 23:52of the biggest enforcement problems that we see
- 23:54in arbitration cases is proof that the employee
- 23:57actually agreed to arbitrate. Courts have rejected
- 24:01arbitration agreements when the employer cannot
- 24:04clearly show assent. Courts have emphasized that
- 24:09arbitration provisions should not be buried in
- 24:12employee handbooks or acknowledgment forms, as
- 24:15Tyler mentioned. And one of those examples is
- 24:17in the Mendoza case where the Court of Appeal
- 24:21refused to enforce an arbitration clause that
- 24:23was embedded in a handbook and was only supported
- 24:27by a generic handbook acknowledgment. In practice
- 24:31today, that often means electronic signatures,
- 24:34which are perfectly valid, but only if the employer
- 24:38can prove who actually signed it. In a case that
- 24:42I litigated a couple years ago in Montez versus
- 24:45Motel 6, venue in Santa Barbara Superior Court,
- 24:49the plaintiff in that case, he claimed that he
- 24:52never agreed to arbitration. But the court granted
- 24:55our motion to compel because we were able to
- 24:57show exactly how the employee electronically
- 25:00accepted the agreement through Workday. And in
- 25:03that case, I think what made the difference was
- 25:05the audit trail and the security features of
- 25:08the system that we were able to produce to the
- 25:11court. As part of our production, the evidence
- 25:15showed that the employee, he accessed Workday
- 25:18using a unique username and password. And then
- 25:23the arbitration agreement appeared in the employee's
- 25:25workday inbox as an action item that he needed
- 25:28to complete. We also showed that the employee
- 25:33could open the agreement and review the full
- 25:35PDF. And as he was doing this, the system recorded
- 25:40timestamps, session ID, and login credentials.
- 25:44And the agreement could also only be accepted
- 25:47while he was logged in using his specific employee
- 25:51account. So this kind of evidence satisfies the
- 25:55authentication requirements discussed in cases
- 25:58like Espejel versus Southern California Permanente
- 26:01Group. The court looked for, in that case, the
- 26:04court looked for proof that the electronic signature
- 26:07was actually the act of the employee. So I think
- 26:12from a practical standpoint, there are several
- 26:15implementation steps that could strengthen enforceability
- 26:19when we're dealing with electronic signatures.
- 26:22And nowadays with technology, most of these arbitration
- 26:25agreements are presented to employees through
- 26:27some kind of electronic platform like Workday.
- 26:32Just on that third bullet point there, Kathy,
- 26:35you know, this is common, you know, employees,
- 26:38employers like flexibility, right? So we see
- 26:43these all the time in handbooks, in policies.
- 26:46This is informational, informational, not contractual.
- 26:51The employer can change it any time, and they
- 26:54are sold in absolute discretion. It does not
- 26:57create a contract of employment. All of that
- 27:01runs counter to getting an agreement to arbitrate.
- 27:05It's inconsistent with a contract. Thanks, Tyler.
- 27:14So just some tips. I think if the arbitration
- 27:17agreement is delivered through an electronic
- 27:19platform, such as Workday or another HR system,
- 27:23best practices, present the agreement in a separate
- 27:27window or pop -up, and display the full agreement,
- 27:31not just a hyperlink. Provide the agreement in
- 27:35English and the employees primary language such
- 27:39as Spanish. I think we will discuss that a little
- 27:41bit further during this presentation. 1 of the
- 27:46key things that really helped us. be able to
- 27:48enforce the arbitration agreement in the case
- 27:51I litigated was required the employee to affirmatively
- 27:54type their name as an electronic signature rather
- 27:58than simply clicking. I agree. I know a lot of
- 28:01pop -up windows. We have a little box that they
- 28:04could just check. But here in our case, the employee
- 28:07actually had to type out his full name. Also,
- 28:12I think one of the important things to do is
- 28:14include language right above the signature line,
- 28:17confirming that the employee understands that
- 28:19they are signing a binding arbitration agreement.
- 28:23So that language disclaimer right above the signature
- 28:26line helps provide a print or download option
- 28:31where the employee can download or print out
- 28:34the entire agreement. And afterwards, even after
- 28:39signing, ensure that employees can access their
- 28:42signed copy later in whatever HR platform the
- 28:46employer is using. So I think these tips demonstrate
- 28:52that there's clear assent on the employee's part
- 28:56that they are assenting to an arbitration agreement.
- 29:00And also, by doing these steps, I think it creates
- 29:03an evidentiary record that you can use later
- 29:06if the agreement is being challenged in court.
- 29:10Because the reality is that, you know, these
- 29:12arbitration agreements are often tested years
- 29:15later in litigation. So if you can't reconstruct
- 29:18the signing process, I think enforcement just
- 29:21becomes much harder. Next slide, please. So arbitration
- 29:31agreements should be written in understandable
- 29:33language. Another recurring problem that we see
- 29:36is clarity and accessibility. So when California
- 29:40courts examine arbitration agreements, they look
- 29:44closely for procedural unconscionability, which
- 29:47focuses on whether employee had a meaningful
- 29:50opportunity to understand what they're signing.
- 29:53So the agreement should be written in plain language.
- 29:57We would avoid dense legal jargon, excessive
- 30:01cross references or provisions that obscure the
- 30:04key point. And the key point being that the employee
- 30:07is agreeing to resolve certain disputes through
- 30:10arbitration instead of court. As I mentioned,
- 30:14language accessibility is critical. There's cases
- 30:18you'll see here where the court found procedural
- 30:21unconscionability where the arbitration agreement
- 30:24was presented only for instance, in English to
- 30:28employees with limited English proficiency. And
- 30:33even in the Ramos versus Westlake Services case,
- 30:36the Spanish version of an employment agreement
- 30:38actually omitted the arbitration provision. So
- 30:43even though it was translated in Spanish, certain
- 30:47parts of it were omitted and the court treated
- 30:50that as fraud in the execution. In the Juarez
- 30:56case, also inaccurate translation, the court
- 30:59found undermined enforcement. So the key here
- 31:03is that translation must be accurate and consistent.
- 31:08And I think if an employer provides the agreement
- 31:10in Spanish, for example, the Spanish version
- 31:13must contain the same exact arbitration provision
- 31:17as the English version. And from a practical
- 31:21standpoint, this also ties back to like the electronic
- 31:23presentation of agreements. The agreement is
- 31:27provided electronically. The employer should
- 31:29consider displaying both the English and Spanish
- 31:33versions and having a function that allows the
- 31:36employees to kind of toggle between the languages,
- 31:39because some may have limited proficiency, but
- 31:42they may have limited English language skills.
- 31:45Where they can make the comparison, are the English
- 31:47and Spanish versions identical? just ensuring
- 31:53that the agreement is formatted clearly with
- 31:56headings and readable fonts. These steps help
- 32:00demonstrate that the employer is making a genuine
- 32:03effort to ensure that the employees understood
- 32:06the agreement that they were signing. And that
- 32:09reduces the risk of a court later finding that
- 32:11there was procedural unfairness. I'll pass it
- 32:17back to Tyler for the next slide. Thanks, Kathy.
- 32:23So this is another obvious one, ensuring arbitrator
- 32:28neutrality. So in the old days, a lot of companies,
- 32:35I shouldn't say a lot, but someone have a designated
- 32:38arbitrator or somebody that's not necessarily
- 32:42on the company's payroll, but a constant referral
- 32:45for arbitration. That's problematic under the
- 32:49law. That's Armanderas. At a minimum, the arbitrator
- 32:53should be neutral, and the employee should have
- 32:57some meaningful participation in the selection
- 33:01process. Even if you get a slate of proposed
- 33:05arbitrators from JAMS or AAA, I know working
- 33:10with them, they'll send you a list of 10. You
- 33:13can rank them, and then there's an ability to
- 33:15strike certain arbitrators, but it has to be
- 33:18mutual. So the employer and the employee have
- 33:22equal say in the selection of the arbitrator.
- 33:26Even with employee participation, we still get
- 33:31arguments, although not as much as in the old
- 33:33days, the repeat player effect. Hey, this arbitrator
- 33:37is not going to be fair to the employee because
- 33:41they're being retained by the company many, many
- 33:44times over. So the repeat player effect naturally
- 33:48leads to bias against the employee. So Jams and
- 33:53AAA, the other providers, I know there's a lot
- 33:56more recent signature resolution, ADR services.
- 34:03I'm sure I'm missing a few. Judicate West is
- 34:07another one. They're striving for fairness as
- 34:10well in the process. They don't want their name
- 34:14in a court opinion saying their process was not
- 34:17fair. Excuse me, the arbitrator selection process
- 34:21was not fair. So just on this arbitration selection,
- 34:27the safest, you know, the easiest way is to incorporate
- 34:31the JAMS or AAA or another provider's selection
- 34:35process so that it kind of removes it from the
- 34:38employer and you have the neutral that's administrating
- 34:42the process and making sure that it's fair and
- 34:45there's adequate participation by both sides.
- 34:51The way it works, those of you who have done
- 34:54arbitration know this, but you can indicate the
- 34:58jams or AAA when an arbitration is filed. The
- 35:02expertise that you'd like to see in an arbitrator,
- 35:05there's no guarantees and you probably get many,
- 35:09many different opinions. on the quality of the
- 35:11arbitrators at the different providers. I've
- 35:15used both AAA and JAMS. JAMS tends to be a little
- 35:19more expensive, just to be honest, and the arbitrators
- 35:23are slightly better quality. If you ask for an
- 35:27employment lawyer, you generally get them on
- 35:29your list. AAA, you might get them on your list,
- 35:34but they might be in New Jersey or Florida, as
- 35:37opposed to California. So just a word to the
- 35:41wise of a selection of which arbitration provider
- 35:44to use. Next slide. So this is another tip to
- 35:57specify the applicable law and the procedural
- 36:01rules. That is, as we say here, a recurring source
- 36:05of litigation. elect to have the Federal Arbitration
- 36:10Act apply. If for some reason it doesn't apply,
- 36:13there's no interstate commerce, the California
- 36:17Arbitration Act can apply. There are some differences
- 36:20between the two. Most notably, you know, I just
- 36:24discovered this week, the California version
- 36:27allows the parties to expand the standard of
- 36:30review and the cases so far under the Federal
- 36:36Arbitration Act don't allow that flexibility.
- 36:40It's the same old, you know, it's got to be manifest
- 36:42injustice, corruption, fraud, you know, and the
- 36:46failure to disclose by the arbitrator. It's a
- 36:48very, very high bar. And again, conversely, under
- 36:53the CAA, you can even select an appeal within
- 36:59arbitration and jams It's not used frequently.
- 37:06I'm not sure why, but they have a rule J, rule
- 37:09J in jams that's called appeals. And it essentially
- 37:13provides for a right of appeal from an arbitration
- 37:16award. They would go to a three judge panel or
- 37:19three arbitrator panel, and they would sit as
- 37:22a court of appeal over the arbitrator's decision.
- 37:27So it's still an arbitration, but you have the
- 37:29same rights you would have if you were to appeal
- 37:32from a bench trial judgment. in a superior court.
- 37:36So it's something that's different under California
- 37:39law. The other thing I would note here is that,
- 37:46especially the employment lawyers who are on
- 37:48the meeting, California in 2017 passed a law,
- 37:54California Labor Code Section 925, and that allows
- 37:59an employee to void a non -California venue or
- 38:04choice of law, even in an arbitration agreement.
- 38:07If the employee goes to court, they can get an
- 38:10injunction, a declaratory relief that's void,
- 38:14and they get their attorney's fees. So there's
- 38:16a risk in including non -California venue, non
- 38:20-California law in your arbitration agreements.
- 38:24So just a word to the wise there. Labor Code
- 38:27Section 925. It applies to contracts signed on
- 38:32or after January 1, 2017. So for a while there,
- 38:37we had an excuse, hey, it was signed before 2017.
- 38:41That's, what is that? Eight years later now,
- 38:44so you can't really rely on that anymore. New
- 38:47contracts, you can't have New York law or distant
- 38:52venue for the arbitration. That 925, by the way,
- 38:57it applies in both litigation and arbitration.
- 39:00So employment contracts can be voided with non
- 39:03California choice of law or venue for an employee
- 39:07who primarily lives and works in California.
- 39:11That's the standard. Next one. So as I mentioned,
- 39:21the arbitration can... specify which law should
- 39:26apply or both. The CAA could be a fallback if
- 39:30for any reason the FAA doesn't apply. If instead
- 39:34you want an appeal right you're going to want
- 39:37to go with the CAA which allows for a modified
- 39:41standard review by a three arbitrator panel within
- 39:45JAMS. It's JAMS rule J, rule J and JAMS and I'll
- 39:52just read a portion of it. This was actually
- 39:56just revised February 1, 2025. It's called the
- 40:00JAMS Optional Appeal Procedures. I think a lot
- 40:05of employers don't think of it because they think
- 40:07it might apply to construction arbitration or
- 40:11commercial arbitration, but it's not limited.
- 40:17And subdivision H, or sorry, J, says the appellate
- 40:22panel, again, the three arbitrator panel will
- 40:25apply the same standard of review that the first
- 40:29level appellate court in the jurisdiction would
- 40:32apply to an appeal from the trial court decision.
- 40:37So in other words, it's just like you had a bench
- 40:40trial and you get a full relief in the court
- 40:46of appeal. It doesn't make. It doesn't make it
- 40:49more likely you're going to win your appeal.
- 40:50You just have more to argue about, more things
- 40:53to bring up with a broader standard of review.
- 40:57And again, you want to identify the procedural
- 41:00rules. Hindsight is 20 -20. I didn't draft the
- 41:04theory, lucky chances, arbitration agreement.
- 41:07But knowing now, or knowing now what I know,
- 41:12I would have attached the rules, not just, they
- 41:15included a website to JAMS, and it's better to
- 41:19just attach the rules to the arbitration agreement.
- 41:22We use the website because even JAMS and AAA
- 41:26are always updating the rules. So what you attach
- 41:29in 2026 might not apply in 2030, but I would
- 41:34do belt and suspenders. Here's the current version
- 41:37attached as exhibit one. And here's a website
- 41:40to the Jams rules or AAA, Judicate West, Signature
- 41:45Resolution, ADR services. I'm sure I'm missing
- 41:51a few. And the last bullet point there is if
- 41:54you learn nothing from this program, you will
- 41:57learn bespoke, bespoke, selected by the parties.
- 42:02It comes from the 17th century. and civil row
- 42:07where a customer bespoke or spoke for a specific
- 42:11bolt of fabric. So that's what it is. The parties
- 42:15select the rules. Those can be negotiated. I
- 42:18mean, Kathy and I are negotiating right now on
- 42:21one. And you have flexibility. It's a matter
- 42:24of contract and consent. So those can be tailored
- 42:28to the parties within reason. Back to Kathy.
- 42:42So one of the most common defenses to enforcing
- 42:45arbitration agreements is unconscionability,
- 42:48which we previously touched on a little bit.
- 42:50In California, unconscionability has two components.
- 42:54There's procedural unconscionability, which looks
- 42:57at oppression or surprise in how the agreement
- 43:00was actually presented to an employee. Then there's
- 43:03the substantive unconscionability, which looks
- 43:06at whether the terms are overly one -sided. Even
- 43:10when you have terms that are fair, though, courts
- 43:13can still find procedural problems if the employee
- 43:16was not given a meaningful opportunity to review
- 43:19the agreement. For example, in the Carlson versus
- 43:25Holm team Pest defense case, the court found
- 43:27that there was procedural unconscionability where
- 43:30the agreement was presented as a non -negotiable
- 43:34Take it or leave it and the applicant risk losing
- 43:37unemployment benefits if she refused to sign.
- 43:41So it's really important to provide time to review
- 43:44the agreement. And that helps address that concern.
- 43:49I think best practices providing the agreement
- 43:51before the employee must sign it. And allowing
- 43:55employees to review it outside of the onboarding
- 43:59session. A lot of times with new hires, they
- 44:02come in for like a one hour session to meet with
- 44:05HR and they're signing a lot of paperwork. And
- 44:07the arbitration agreement is just embedded in
- 44:10that stack of paperwork that they're asked to
- 44:13sign. So giving the employees an opportunity.
- 44:16to review the arbitration agreement, and signing
- 44:20it on its own helps address that concern. And
- 44:24also encouraging these employees to ask questions
- 44:28or seek legal advice. I think that's really important.
- 44:32In the Montes case that I litigated that I mentioned,
- 44:36the court actually looked at how long the employee,
- 44:39how many days the employee had to review the
- 44:42arbitration agreement before accepting it. And
- 44:46because of the audit trails that we produced,
- 44:48it showed that the employee actually had 19 days
- 44:51to review the arbitration agreement before he
- 44:54actually signed the acceptance on workday. And
- 44:57then the audit trail also showed that he went
- 44:59in. and Red opened the pop -up windows multiple
- 45:04times throughout this 19 -day period prior to
- 45:06signing it. So I think that was really helpful
- 45:09for supporting enforceability in our case. Also,
- 45:16in that case, the system allowed the employee
- 45:21to actually print out a copy of the agreement
- 45:26and take it home with him if he needed to. And
- 45:30specifically for this case, there was a contact
- 45:33person, an HR person that the employee could
- 45:36reach out to with a phone number if the employee
- 45:40wanted to discuss the agreement or had any questions.
- 45:44So these kind of procedures help demonstrate
- 45:46that the employer did not rush. or like pressure
- 45:49the employee into signing and that the employee
- 45:52had like a real meaningful opportunity to review
- 45:56and understand the agreement that they were signing.
- 46:00Next slide please. Just one point quickly on
- 46:04the on the so courts courts call this a contract
- 46:09of adhesion. That's the that's the really the
- 46:12procedural unconscionability argument and I mentioned
- 46:15the the most recent California Supreme Court
- 46:18case from July of 2025. There is actually another
- 46:26case this year, February 2026, a case called
- 46:32Fuentes versus Empire Nissan. And in that case,
- 46:43the font, the print, and the arbitration agreement.
- 46:47The court said, well, the typeface in the agreement
- 46:50was not only strikingly minute, but also blurry,
- 46:56rendering it unreadable, unreadable. And the
- 47:02trial court said it was unenforceable. It was
- 47:05both procedurally and substantively unconscionable.
- 47:08The court of appeal reversed the trial court.
- 47:11and said that Fuentes, the plaintiff, had failed
- 47:14to show both procedural and substantive. The
- 47:20illegible font, the court said, that went to
- 47:23procedural, but not substantive. And on appeal
- 47:26to the Supreme Court, the court found that the
- 47:30tiny and unreadable print is a problem of procedural
- 47:34and constrability. and it should not be double
- 47:39counted as substantive unconscionability, but
- 47:43emphasize the unfair bargaining power between
- 47:48the parties. The courts in this, we see this
- 47:51a lot in arbitration decisions, very paternalistic,
- 47:55very protective of employees and any attempt
- 47:58by employers to force something or coerce them,
- 48:02shorten the time to review it. you know, it's
- 48:05a condition of employment. So courts are going
- 48:08to be skeptical and small print, the court in
- 48:12Fuentes also remanded the case, but I would say
- 48:17when they can't read the agreement, it's dead
- 48:19on arrival, you're going to lose. So that's the
- 48:24one case to look at as well. Fuentes versus Empire
- 48:28-Nissan, February 19, 2026. But going back to
- 48:37what Tyler briefly touched on was the opt out
- 48:40provision. I think that's another feature that
- 48:42can significantly strengthen enforceability with
- 48:46arbitration agreements, because an opt out clause,
- 48:50you know, allows the employee to decline arbitration
- 48:52within like, you know, a specified period. For
- 48:55example, I think 30 days after receiving the
- 48:58agreement, that's pretty common. And courts favorably
- 49:02view opt out provisions because they undermine
- 49:05arguments that the agreement was purely a take
- 49:08it or leave it agreement for the employee. And
- 49:12if employees truly do have the option to opt
- 49:15out without retaliation, I think the agreement
- 49:17just appears less oppressive and less procedurally
- 49:22unconscionable. you know, for to have the opt
- 49:27out option, it must be genuine. I think employers
- 49:30to show this, I think employers should have that,
- 49:34you know, it has to be clearly explained that
- 49:37there is an opt out provision and that the process
- 49:40is simple to use and employees are not discouraged
- 49:44or pressured from opting out. And one of the
- 49:48most important things I think is documenting
- 49:49this process. You know, having documentation
- 49:54to show that there was an opt -out provision
- 49:56if it was, you know, taken by the employee. And
- 50:02make it simple. Like, you know, make it that
- 50:04the employee, if they want to opt out, they can
- 50:06just send an email or submit a form through HR
- 50:10or just mail some type of written notice. Because
- 50:14the key point we really want to show is that
- 50:16the employee has, you know, real choice. And
- 50:19when courts see that the employee had the ability
- 50:22to opt out, and then many employees chose not
- 50:26to, I think it's just much more likely to view
- 50:29the arbitration agreement as fair and voluntary.
- 50:37Next slide, please. I think I'll pass that back
- 50:45to Tyler. Thanks, Kathy. I was just answering
- 50:50a question here. The case that I mentioned earlier
- 50:53is called Puente's versus Empire -Nissan. That's
- 50:58the most recent California Supreme Court decision.
- 51:03But keep those questions coming. I had to find
- 51:06the Q &A bar there. So this is another obvious
- 51:11one. We're deciding the same dispute in a different
- 51:16forum. really dead on arrival, excessive discovery
- 51:22restrictions. I will say arbitration is designed
- 51:26to be more streamlined. Generally, you get one
- 51:30deposition per side, limited written discovery.
- 51:35But if the arbitrator unnecessarily restricts
- 51:38it, or if the rules don't allow for broad discovery,
- 51:43that could be problematic. Fee shifting is a
- 51:46common one. So the employee I think, what is
- 51:49it now, Kathy, what are they paying? 480 bucks
- 51:52as a first initial appearance fee in court. So
- 51:55they can't be charged more than that to go to
- 51:58Jams or AAA or any other provider. They can't
- 52:03be liable for arbitration costs unless it's allowed
- 52:08under the substantive law. And that's something
- 52:11that you want to address in your arbitration
- 52:13agreement. as well, whether the arbitrator has
- 52:16the power to award sanctions, for example, or
- 52:20fee shifting, if the law allows for it. But another
- 52:23one we still see frequently, not so much from
- 52:27California -based employers, but employers on
- 52:29the East Coast and the Midwest and the South,
- 52:33shortened statute of limitations, not helpful.
- 52:36Limitations on remedies and damages, also not
- 52:40helpful. leads to a finding of substantive unconscionability.
- 52:46So again, even if you give them 30 days, talk
- 52:49to a lawyer, take your time, you can opt out,
- 52:53and it's all done correctly. If you have these
- 52:57provisions in there, you'll still get a challenge
- 53:00or could get a challenge to enforceability on
- 53:03substantive unconscionability grounds. Another
- 53:08thing we constantly foresee is limiting remedies.
- 53:12It's so tempting as an employer to say, okay,
- 53:15we design this program as an alternative. Let's
- 53:20just tilt the scales a little bit. So you can't
- 53:22get punitive damages. You can't get consequential
- 53:25damages, whatever that means. Not allowed. You're
- 53:30restricting remedies that an employee might get
- 53:32in court. So if the FIHA, Fair Employment and
- 53:37Housing Act, if the Wage Out Orders, the Labor
- 53:40Code allows for employees to recover their attorney's
- 53:44fees that they win, that's the law. You can't
- 53:47alter that. Nor can you say in an arbitration
- 53:50agreement, we'll just override the labor code
- 53:53and say, if the employer wins, it gets its fees.
- 53:59If it's not allowed under the law, that would
- 54:01be unconscionable, substantively unconscionable.
- 54:05We see those a lot. And it's like the charter
- 54:08case I mentioned at the outset. Cover Supreme
- 54:12Court, where the court did find several provisions
- 54:15were unconscionable. Next slide. So I'm gonna
- 54:28ask Kathy to weigh in here as well, but there's
- 54:31been a lot of back and forth about class action
- 54:33waivers and class and collective action waivers.
- 54:38We see a lot of Paga claims. And I would say
- 54:43that currently, most trial courts, when you file
- 54:48a motion to compel arbitration of the individual
- 54:50PACA claim, they will stay the litigation, the
- 54:53representative litigation. Because if an arbitrator
- 54:56finds that the plaintiff, the main plaintiff,
- 54:59was not an aggrieved employee, they don't have
- 55:02standing to go back to court and litigate the
- 55:05representative action. So most but not all trial
- 55:08courts are respecting arbitration and forcing
- 55:13the individual named plaintiff rep to go to arbitration
- 55:18first and stay in the litigation. That's the
- 55:21last bullet point there. And you see the Paga
- 55:25statute, which is really a a problem, I think,
- 55:30for a lot of employers, especially when they
- 55:33use it strategically. What I've seen recently
- 55:36is the plaintiff will say, hey, wait a minute,
- 55:39I'm disclaiming any individual recovery. I only
- 55:42want to bring a representative action. So forget
- 55:45about that arbitration agreement. I'm going straight
- 55:48to court. It seems like a ploy, right? But so
- 55:52far, at least what I saw last night, The California
- 55:56Courts of Appeal are split on whether that's
- 55:58permissible or not. So stay tuned on that front.
- 56:02Whether an employee could eschew the individual
- 56:06action or individual right to relief and just
- 56:11only pursue in the representative capacity court.
- 56:15Kathy, do you want to? Yeah, say any words about
- 56:18that. Yeah. I mean, it's true that we've come
- 56:20across most courts respecting arbitration and
- 56:24compelling plaintiff to arbitrate their individual
- 56:29claims. And usually, generally, that is a better
- 56:32route to take, because sometimes in arbitration,
- 56:35we can prove that the plaintiff was not an, quote
- 56:38unquote, aggrieved employee. And therefore, she
- 56:40or he would lack standing to come back into the
- 56:43state court action. and be the representative.
- 56:47Some courts, however, have refused to state the
- 56:52state court action pending arbitration. We've
- 56:55had a couple of those decisions in the last couple
- 56:57of years. But generally, for the most part, I
- 57:00think courts are willing to stay the representative
- 57:02action pending the arbitration results of the
- 57:07individual's claim. Next slide. So this is the
- 57:19tip of enforceable waivers. So if you do want
- 57:25a class action waiver, be clear in your arbitration
- 57:28agreement that you want that. That is allowed
- 57:32under the FAA, the Federal Arbitration Act. It's
- 57:36a matter of consent. So if it's silent, a court
- 57:40will not imply a mass arbitration or a class
- 57:43arbitration. But don't take chances. I would
- 57:47just include your class action, class collective
- 57:51action waiver. You can't wave a pocket claim.
- 57:55That's the Epic Center's case, cases since then,
- 58:00because it's brought. as the people of the state
- 58:03of California, you're a private attorney general,
- 58:06you're acting on behalf of the state. The state
- 58:09is not a party to the agreement, so the Paga
- 58:12representative claim at least cannot be compelled
- 58:15to arbitration even after Viking River cruises.
- 58:20But you definitely want to include that if you
- 58:22are going to have an arbitration agreement, the
- 58:24class section waiver. Next one. So the last two
- 58:33are really obvious things. It's a good reminder.
- 58:37The law changes constantly. They also, as the
- 58:41last bullet point says there, it shows good faith
- 58:43and helps with enforceability. We didn't just
- 58:46send them an agreement, sign and return it. And
- 58:51by the way, it's still okay to have paper wet
- 58:54signatures. Many years ago, that's all we had.
- 58:59You just have to be more careful about record
- 59:02keeping and making sure you're tracking the signatures.
- 59:05But all of this goes to show the court, hey,
- 59:08we're trying to be fair. We're training the employees.
- 59:12We're providing updates. Hey, we created this
- 59:14FAQ so they could read it on their own. It's
- 59:18not legalese. They could take it to their lawyer,
- 59:20review it. So all of that helps on overall. Fairness
- 59:25and enforceability. Same thing with the last
- 59:29tip. Number 10. And that is training, you know,
- 59:36especially HR. It's some of it is obvious, some
- 59:40of it is not, and the more guidance you can provide
- 59:44to HR to managers. And also with employees, you
- 59:50know, I know some employers have a robust arbitration
- 59:53agreement. or arbitration program, and they will
- 59:57hold two three hour sessions to go over the program,
- 1:00:01answer questions. There might be a follow up
- 1:00:04meeting, additional training sessions. All of
- 1:00:08that is positive. You can't do enough training.
- 1:00:10You cannot do enough training. So that's my last
- 1:00:16or last of the 10 tips. I see we're at our witching
- 1:00:19hour and we left a couple of minutes for questions.
- 1:00:24I was going back to the Q &A here. Let me find
- 1:00:27it. So I don't see new questions. One question
- 1:00:42from Melissa Hearns is, although the opt -out
- 1:00:46provision is favorable, can employers require
- 1:00:48arbitration as a condition of employment? The
- 1:00:52answer is yes, and continued employment can be
- 1:00:57adequate consideration for the arbitration agreement.
- 1:01:01But this is a good question. What happens if
- 1:01:04the employee says, no, I don't want to agree
- 1:01:07to arbitration? Then what do you do? Kathy, I'm
- 1:01:11going to throw that question to you. Part of
- 1:01:22this process of requiring, I think the Ninth
- 1:01:26Circuit Court of Appeals tried to rule. They
- 1:01:30actually held that the FAA, which is pro arbitration,
- 1:01:36says that you can require that as a condition
- 1:01:38of employment. And I think going back to the
- 1:01:41tips, too, is that we basically showed to the
- 1:01:43court that it was presented in a fair uh, consumable,
- 1:01:49you know, manner with the, um, you know, everything
- 1:01:52was clearly explained to them and that the terms
- 1:01:55were fair. And I think if we prove all of those
- 1:01:58steps that we had just, you know, talked about,
- 1:02:00I think really, you know, um, is in our favor
- 1:02:05for the employer to really require the employee,
- 1:02:08um, to sign the agreement so long as, you know,
- 1:02:11it's procedurally and substantively consumable.
- 1:02:14So back to the question or the hypothetical.
- 1:02:17Purely hypothetical question. If at the end of
- 1:02:20the 30 days, the employee says, hey, I talked
- 1:02:22to my lawyer and I'm not willing to sign up for
- 1:02:25arbitration. You know, if it is a condition of
- 1:02:28employment, it means you don't want to work here.
- 1:02:31I mean, that's that's really the practical effect.
- 1:02:34We're not they're not challenging the arbitration
- 1:02:37agreement in court because they refuse to sign
- 1:02:40it. But the trade off is they don't get employment.
- 1:02:43It is a condition of employment and that's lawful.
- 1:02:46That's a lawful condition. The opt out is just
- 1:02:49in case it's challenged. You have a defense and
- 1:02:53it eliminates complete well. I don't want to
- 1:02:56be too too categorically, but it takes out of
- 1:02:58the arsenal. The procedural unconscionability
- 1:03:01argument. If you can show they had 30 days to
- 1:03:05opt out or to ask questions about the agreement.
- 1:03:13So with that, we're just a little bit, the follow
- 1:03:19-up question, is the employee deemed to have
- 1:03:22resigned in that instance? I would do both in
- 1:03:25suspenders. I would confirm based on your failure
- 1:03:30to sign the agreement, which is a mandatory condition
- 1:03:33of employment, the company is not willing to
- 1:03:38employ you. Hopefully by that point, you haven't
- 1:03:42already made them, maybe you've made them a conditional
- 1:03:45offer. You revoke the offer, rescind the offer.
- 1:03:50The unwillingness to sign the agreement means
- 1:03:52that the employment ends. With that, you know,
- 1:03:58thank you everybody for staying on. Sorry about
- 1:04:00my my voice. I blame it on spring training and
- 1:04:05happy things Saint Patty's Day. Thanks Kathy
- 1:04:07and send us any questions you might have and
- 1:04:11we also are going to for those who are interested,
- 1:04:14let us know. Will send you our template with
- 1:04:17all the bells and whistles as of today. It's
- 1:04:20good today only. This concludes today's presentation.
- 1:04:26Thank you so much Tyler and Cathy for an excellent
- 1:04:29presentation and thank you so much to our audience.
- 1:04:31Have a great day everybody.