Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin vs the Teutonic Knights: The Forgotten Order
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've done a lot of episodes on Saladin — Hattin, Acre, Tyre, the Assassins, the Hospitallers. But there's one group that fought him that we haven't really touched: the Teutonic Knights. Luna: The German ones, right? I always think of them in the Baltic, not the Holy Land. Lucas: Exactly. They're famous for their later campaigns in Prussia and Lithuania, but they actually started in Acre during the Third Crusade. And Saladin had direct dealings with them. It's a fascinating, overlooked chapter. Lucas: The order was founded in 1190, during the Siege of Acre. A group of German crusaders from Bremen and Lübeck set up a field hospital outside the city walls. They used a sail as a tent. It was humble — but it filled a real need. The German crusaders didn't have their own hospital, unlike the Hospitallers or Templars. Luna: So it started as a medical charity, like the Hospitallers? Lucas: Exactly. Duke Frederick of Swabia — son of Emperor Frederick Barbarossa, who had drowned in Anatolia — endorsed them. And Pope Celestine III approved the order in 1191, giving them the Rule of St. John. But they quickly militarized, like so many crusader charities. Lucas: Now, Saladin's siege of Acre lasted from 1189 to 1191. The city was surrounded by his forces, but the crusaders held a narrow strip of coast. The Teutonic hospital was right in that strip, under constant bombardment. Baha ad-Din ibn Shaddad, Saladin's biographer, mentions German ships arriving with reinforcements. He calls them 'al-Alman' — the Germans. Luna: Did Saladin ever directly engage with the Teutonic Knights? Lucas: Yes, and there's a curious story. After Acre fell to the crusaders in July 1191, the Teutonic Order moved into the city. They established their headquarters there. But then, in the aftermath, Saladin's forces captured some Teutonic knights. According to Imad ad-Din al-Isfahani, Saladin actually released them without ransom at one point — a gesture of chivalry. But it's also possible he saw them as less threatening than the Templars or Hospitallers. Lucas: The order's first grand master, Heinrich Walpot, died in 1198 and was succeeded by Otto von Kerpen. They started building castles like Montfort — which we'll get to in another episode. But their real growth came under Hermann von Salza, who became grand master in 1210. He was a brilliant diplomat, and he cultivated ties with both the papacy and the Holy Roman Emperor Frederick II. Luna: So their big moment was still to come. Lucas: Exactly. Under von Salza, they shifted focus to the Baltic, where they carved out a state. But in the 1190s, they were just one of several military orders in the Holy Land, and Saladin seems to have dealt with them pragmatically. Lucas: One more detail: after the Battle of Arsuf in 1191, where Richard the Lionheart defeated Saladin, the Teutonic Knights played a supporting role. They helped guard the crusader march south. But our sources — Baha ad-Din, Imad ad-Din, and the 'Itinerarium Regis Ricardi' — rarely single them out. They were overshadowed by the Templars and Hospitallers. Luna: It makes sense. The Germans were a minority among the crusaders. Lucas: Right. But their presence mattered. Saladin's advisors, like al-Qadi al-Fadil, kept records of all enemy forces. The Teutonic Knights were noted, but not feared. It's a reminder that even within the crusader camp, there were layers of hierarchy and reputation. Lucas: If today's deep dive into the Teutonic Knights was useful to you, the way these episodes stay ad-free is simple: listener support. You can buy me a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It genuinely keeps this going. Luna: Yeah, it's a small gesture that makes a big difference. Lucas: Absolutely. So back to the Teutonic Knights — their real legacy in the Holy Land is as a bridge between the crusader kingdoms and the emerging German empire. And their interactions with Saladin show how even a powerful leader like him had to navigate a diverse array of enemies. Luna: What happened to the Teutonic Knights in the Holy Land after Saladin's death? Lucas: They stayed. They built Montfort Castle in 1220, which became their headquarters. But after the fall of Acre in 1291, they moved their base to Venice, and eventually to Prussia. Their time in the East was relatively short, but formative. Lucas: There's also a fascinating detail about the order's name. They were officially called the 'Order of the German House of St. Mary in Jerusalem'. Their hospital was dedicated to the Virgin Mary. And they carried a white mantle with a black cross — simple, unlike the Templars' red cross. Luna: So their identity was tied to Jerusalem, even though they barely held it. Lucas: Exactly. That name — 'in Jerusalem' — was aspirational. They held a few properties in the city after 1229, when Frederick II negotiated its return. But by then, Saladin was long gone. Lucas: One last point: the Teutonic Knights are a great lens to understand how the crusades were not just a French or English enterprise. German participation was significant, and Saladin had to account for it. His intelligence network, run by al-Qadi al-Fadil, tracked all the European factions. The Germans were one piece of a complex puzzle. Luna: It really shows how international the crusades were. Lucas: Exactly. So next time we'll look at another overlooked group — the Syrian Christians who served in Saladin's administration. But for now, I think we've given the Teutonic Knights their due. Luna: Absolutely. Thanks for this deep dive.