Latest / MUBI Podcast / In Andrea Arnold’s COW, audiences find themselves
Transcript
- 0:00[Sting of strings][Andrea Arnold] When I'm making a film, we would, now and again, go and watch edits on the big screen.
- 0:10because then you understand a bit more about what the images are doing.
- 0:13I think, I can't remember who said, a filmmaker said,"A look in the eye can start a war." So that's the kind of thing you need to be aware of is that sometimes those huge images convey way more than you realize.
- 0:26So you do need to check on the big screen.
- 0:28[Rico Gagliano] You don't always mean to start a war.
- 0:30[Andrea] Yeah! Yes...
- 0:32Actually I mean, to start loads of wars, really, to be honest. But...
- 0:36it's all about starting wars in my book.
- 0:41[Rico] That is UK filmmaker Andrea Arnold.
- 0:44And yeah, if you've seen her movies, you know they and her characters...
- 0:48don't shy from a fight.
- 0:50In 2005, she won an Oscar for Wasp, a short about a destitute single mom trying to raise kids and have a love life.
- 0:56[Woman 1] Look, Bullet-head's in there.
- 0:59If she sees you, she'll fucking turn us and you'll get taken away from me.
- 1:02Do you understand?
- 1:03[Rico] Her epic American honey was the story of a teenage girl who escapes abuse to sell magazines across late stage capitalism America.
- 1:10[Woman 2] I don't need you to fight my battles.
- 1:12[Man 1] I'm not fighting, actually I was doing a service, if you think about it.
- 1:14[Woman 2] Yeah, you were.
- 1:14[Man 1] Yeah.
- 1:17For you. You need me.
- 1:18[Woman 2] I can do this shit by myself, I don't need you.
- 1:21[Rico] That won the Jury Prize at Cannes.
- 1:22And her new movie is about the struggles of a very different female hero: A dairy cow.
- 1:35I'm Rico Galliano, and after a long hiatus, it is so great to welcome you back to the MUBI podcast.
- 1:41MUBI is the best place to stream beautiful, hand-picked cinema.
- 1:44On this show we tell you great stories about beautiful cinema.
- 1:47We are hard at work on season two of the show.
- 1:49Today, though the first of a few special episodes to tide you over, you're going to hear my interview with Andrea Arnold.
- 1:55Her amazing new documentary is called Cow.
- 1:58It's coming exclusively to MUBI in many countries, and it focuses on, yes, a dairy cow named Luma.
- 2:04Starting with the birth of one of her calves and following her through years of her life.
- 2:09There is no voiceover.
- 2:10You only get glimpses of humans and snatches of what they say.
- 2:14And for me, it is pure, immersive cinema.
- 2:18The other week, I got the chance to speak with her about it.
- 2:25Andrea Arnold, I'm honored to have you.
- 2:27[Andrea] Ok.
- 2:28[Rico] You've said that you wanted to make a film about an animal for a long time. Why?
- 2:32[Andrea] I guess this film has been with me for a really long time in terms of kind of, coming from a deep place, I think.
- 2:40And I think it's to do with my relationship with nature, which has been a sort of fairly intense one since I was a kid.
- 2:47And I did some research some years ago about farm animals for a completely different project.
- 2:52And from then on, I kind of used to think about them a lot.
- 2:55and this sort of notion as to whether they were sentient or not.
- 2:59So I guess Cow is a sort of endeavor to watch another, you know, another non-human consciousness and to look for its' sentience.
- 3:10[Rico] It works, I absolutely found its' sentience and I'm not alone, I think, and remarking that I found myself very moved by watching this cow, surprisingly quickly, within just a few minutes of the movie, I found myself just deeply relating.
- 3:24And I'd like to know how you came to choose what those opening minutes would be so that I would be put in that position.
- 3:30[Andrea] I mean, I when we started the film, I always had this idea we would go from consciousness to unconsciousness, so we would...
- 3:39When I first thought of the idea, I actually wanted to see a whole life.
- 3:43And then that became kind of not possible because cows live for 15 years and nobody was going to give me money to film a cow for 15 years.
- 3:51So I had to find another way, and so I decided I would film a cow and a calf so that I could start with birth.
- 3:59Starting with a birth is a very strong way to start.
- 4:02[Rico] Why do you think that is? I mean, it feels right to me.
- 4:05[Andrea] I guess the dairy cows existence is all around them giving birth Without giving birth.
- 4:10There is no milk.
- 4:13So their whole existence is dependent on them giving birth.
- 4:17So for me, it was always very clear that it had to start with the birth.
- 4:20Also, it's the beginning of life, so it's very powerful in all kinds of ways.
- 4:24But for the dairy cow, they, without giving birth, they have no existence because if they don't give birth, don't give milk, they're sent to the slaughterhouse.
- 4:31So getting pregnant, giving birth, giving milk it's...
- 4:35they had lived this maternal existence for all of their lives.
- 4:39And as soon as that stops, then they are sent to the slaughterhouse.
- 4:42So it's very much part of what a dairy cows life is.
- 4:45[Rico] It does make me think because you shot this for many years, right?
- 4:47How many years did you shoot?
- 4:49[Andrea] Well, we shot for four years, but the actual idea I had the idea and got the funding for about nine years ago.
- 4:54[Rico] It sounds like you had some idea of the map of the story, such as it is.
- 5:00How much of that panned out?
- 5:02How much did you know going in you were going to get, and how much that was sort of winged?
- 5:07[Andrea] Well, I think with any documentary and you start something I know, I didn't really know what was going to be revealed.
- 5:13I had the notion that if we followed her around that we would get to know her, and that would be interesting.
- 5:19But I didn't know what her future would be, and I didn't know, you know, details of kind of the industry and the things that went on.
- 5:26I mean, I understood some of it, but not obviously seeing it in detail like I did.
- 5:30So I think I went in with a very open mind and heart to see what happened.
- 5:36[Rico] What was the most surprising thing that happened that you just absolutely didn't expect?
- 5:39[Andrea] Um...
- 5:41I guess the thing I didn't expect...
- 5:43Or the thing that I found fascinating was that by the end of the filming, I think Luma...
- 5:50they say, I was reading a book the other day that said that when animals look at humans, they look warily.
- 5:57I mean, maybe not your dog, but you know, other animals, farm animals, wild animals.
- 6:01They will view humans warily.
- 6:04And by the time we finished filming with Luma, I feel like we were seeing something different in her look to us, like the way she was looking at us.
- 6:14I felt that she felt seen by us.
- 6:17Things change not so much in a relationship, but just how she felt about being seen.
- 6:22It was like she sort of felt the look, and I found that fascinating because I wondered what that actually meant.
- 6:30And I wondered, did that mean...
- 6:32Did she feel her existence more because she felt seen?
- 6:36I wonder what that actually meant for her.
- 6:38[Rico] Obviously, that's clearly the case for humans.
- 6:40If you pay attention to me.
- 6:42I pay attention to you.
- 6:44[Andrea] There's more than that, really, because we sort of pay attention to each other.
- 6:47But do we really hear?
- 6:49And do we really see is very interesting.
- 6:51Like, she's taught me a lesson in that way.
- 6:54So I try very hard now when I'm with people to really be with them, be in that moment and to hear what they're saying.
- 7:04[Rico] You seriously got that from this experience, from with this cow?
- 7:07[Andrea] I think probably not entirely, but more so. I'm more aware of it.
- 7:12And I'm... And it's like my dog, for example.
- 7:15I look at my dog really differently since I made the film with Luma.
- 7:19I look at her eyes and I wonder how she's feeling, and can I see if she's looking upset or like... When I tune in with her and I sort of look at her, I sort of now feel I can see sort of minutiae of things.
- 7:32I look at her more closely.
- 7:34I mean, you know, I don't remember to do this all the time with everybody and everything, but I think it's interesting to explore.
- 7:40[Rico] This actually brings to mind a shot that's very early in the film.
- 7:43where you linger on the shot of Luma the cow from some distance away, and she's just staring right into the camera and you stare back at her.
- 7:53Are you kind of like trying to put us in that mindset for a minute?
- 7:57Just look at this.
- 7:57Look at this being.
- 7:59[Andrea] That particular moment was very striking to me because she just had her calf, and she gets taken out of the pen with the calf.
- 8:08[Man 2] Stop! [Shushing][Whistling] [Cow mooing][Andrea] She's been separated from the calf, and you don't, you don't know.
- 8:17I don't think she knows whether she's going to see the calf or not again.
- 8:20[Shuffling] And she's in a different pen, and she just looks she just looked at us, and she mooed...
- 8:28[Cow mooing] for a really long time.
- 8:32[Cow mooing] And it was very striking for me, I don't know quite what she's doing or thinking.
- 8:46[Cow mooing] But it felt like she was definitely expressing herself.
- 8:51And I was very, I was very moved by her in that moment.
- 8:55So that's why I included it.
- 8:56[Rico] Yeah, she mooed. That moo feels to me almost like, you can't tell if it's rage...
- 9:01[Agitated moo] or "Help me", but it is this moment where it's like you're almost asking us right away to, like, start trying to figure it out.
- 9:10[Andrea] I mean, I didn't. I was just trying to show you all the moments that I kind of thought were important or striking, or...
- 9:15I mean, we can't get inside her head.
- 9:19And I never tried to get inside her head.
- 9:21All I did was try to show you her reaction to her world and for you to make up your own mind about what you think she might be feeling or thinking.
- 9:29And I think that's very distinctly one of those moments where you have all sorts of ideas about what she might be feeling.
- 9:35[Rico] To that point, you've mentioned several things, you know, this cow that's basically raised to give birth.
- 9:42You've talked about a cow that's raised to give milk.
- 9:45A cow that's got her baby taken away from her.
- 9:48It was very easy for me to sort of impose feminist readings onto this.
- 9:53And I'm wondering, less for you to confirm or deny that,
- 9:59but more to ask you: Is there a universality of reaction that you're getting? From a movie that has no narration and has no dialogue?
- 10:05but more to ask you: Are there still universal things that everybody gets out of this?
- 10:08but more to ask you: [Andrea] I get, I get a series of reactions from people and they vary.
- 10:13but more to ask you: But there are some universal things.
- 10:16but more to ask you: one is the feminine side it, mothers and children.
- 10:20but more to ask you: That's definitely... I hear that about, people respond in a way that they think about their relationship with their mothers or their lack of relationship with mothers.
- 10:28but more to ask you: I've had people say that it makes them think of...
- 10:31but more to ask you: An American friend said it made her think of how her body, like in America, it's becoming, her body's becoming not her own.
- 10:39but more to ask you: I've had people talk about a sort of incarceration.
- 10:43but more to ask you: Lack of freedom. Loneliness.
- 10:46but more to ask you: [Rico] Is there, are there any reactions that surprise you that you didn't necessarily see in the film until someone brought it up?
- 10:51but more to ask you: [Andrea] I've had some reactions, I think.
- 10:52but more to ask you: I think what happens is because there is no narration and because there's room for mulling over things as you're watching, people find their own things within it.
- 11:08but more to ask you: And that's happened a lot.
- 11:09but more to ask you: So there have been some kind of slightly off to the side sort of reactions as well, but I think that's more to do with the people than it is to do with the film.
- 11:17but more to ask you: [Rico] Can you think of any of those that were kind of unusual.
- 11:19but more to ask you: [Andrea] You know what, they're so personal to the people I would feel bad about relaying them because they would probably recognize themselves, and I wouldn't want to do that.
- 11:27but more to ask you: [Rico] Fair enough. And I guess really, the details don't matter because your point is made, right?
- 11:31but more to ask you: People watch this cow and they recognize themselves.
- 11:34but more to ask you: [Andrea] Oh, yeah, yeah.
- 11:37but more to ask you: [Rico] Yeah, I saw Cow like I think a lot of advance viewers did.
- 11:41but more to ask you: I got a digital screener copy.
- 11:42but more to ask you: I ended up watching it on my laptop, which is smaller than a legal pad.
- 11:46but more to ask you: [Andrea] Right.
- 11:47but more to ask you: [Rico] And it was still obviously a pretty emotional experience.
- 11:51but more to ask you: But I was thinking about the impact it must have on a big screen because it really does plunge you into a world.
- 11:57but more to ask you: When did you first see it in a theater?
- 11:59but more to ask you: [Andrea] I didn't see the finished thing on the big screen until it was at Cannes.
- 12:03but more to ask you: That was my first like audience big screen experience.
- 12:06but more to ask you: [Rico] So what was that like?
- 12:08but more to ask you: I mean, I've been to that theater in Cannes, and it's huge, first of all, and the screen is gigantic.
- 12:11but more to ask you: The sound is amazing.
- 12:13but more to ask you: [Andrea] Yeah.
- 12:14but more to ask you: [Rico] What was the experience like for you?
- 12:15but more to ask you: [Andrea] It was intense. I mean, it's an intense experience watching your work.
- 12:19but more to ask you: It's like you unzip yourself and put your soul on the screen for everyone to see.
- 12:22but more to ask you: It's a very intense experience to share something that is very personal to...
- 12:28but more to ask you: I don't know how many people are in that cinema, but a lot.
- 12:30but more to ask you: I mean, I got a bit too much in my head watching it. I didn't...
- 12:34but more to ask you: I don't think I've really watched it properly because it was too big an experience.
- 12:38but more to ask you: I think I was sitting next to the producer and she could feel me squirming.
- 12:42but more to ask you: And I mean, you want to leave, really, actually, you want to get out.
- 12:46but more to ask you: I wanted to get out at the end.
- 12:48but more to ask you: [Rico] Why is that?
- 12:49but more to ask you: [Andrea] I mean, I know, I knew that I did my utmost to make that film with, you know, as much love as I could manage.
- 12:57but more to ask you: So I'd feel like I did the making of it as best I could.
- 13:01but more to ask you: So at some point once you've done that, you're handing it over.
- 13:06but more to ask you: You are kind of, you know, you're letting go in a way.
- 13:09but more to ask you: And so that kind of experience is about letting go.
- 13:12but more to ask you: And that's quite a hard thing to do.
- 13:15but more to ask you: [String motif][Rico] Andrea Arnold.
- 13:24but more to ask you: Cow just got a best documentary nomination for this year's BAFTA Awards.
- 13:28but more to ask you: The movie is out now in select UK cinemas.
- 13:30but more to ask you: Starting February 11 in many countries, it will stream exclusively on MUBI.
- 13:35but more to ask you: where you'll also find a series of her shorts, including her Oscar winning Wasp.
- 13:39but more to ask you: Check the show notes of this episode for details of where you can watch.
- 13:44but more to ask you: And that is our special episode of the MUBI podcast this week.
- 13:47but more to ask you: There are more to come.
- 13:49but more to ask you: Leading up to April when we'll drop our full season two, which, by the way, will feature great stories about experiences that were only possible in movie theaters.
- 13:58but more to ask you: You know, like watching your own movie on the big screen at Cannes.
- 14:01but more to ask you: You can follow us wherever you get your podcasts or you might miss it.
- 14:04but more to ask you: And then what kind of movie buff can you call yourself, really?
- 14:06but more to ask you: While you're at it, please leave us a five star review wherever you listen.
- 14:10but more to ask you: It helps others find and love us.
- 14:12but more to ask you: We would love to hear your questions, comments or what you think of Cow once you see it.
- 14:16but more to ask you: Email us at podcast@mubi.com This episode was hosted, written and cut by me Rico Gagliano.
- 14:22but more to ask you: Martin Austwick composed our opening theme.
- 14:25but more to ask you: Yuri Suzuki composed our outro music.
- 14:27but more to ask you: Thanks this time to David Harper, and Julia Nowicka, the show's executive produced by me, along with Jon Barrenechea, Efe Cakarel, Daniel Kasman, and Michael Tacca for MUBI.
- 14:36but more to ask you: Thanks for listening! Be safe! Watch movies.
- 14:40but more to ask you: [String motif plays out]