Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / The Cartesian Method Applied to Electric Mobility
Transcript
- 0:10You know, usually when you walk into a car dealership, the vibe
- 0:12is it's entirely engineered around emotion.
- 0:16Oh. Absolutely.
- 0:17It's a complete sensory overload right from the minute you step
- 0:20onto the lot. Right, exactly.
- 0:21I mean, the salesperson wants you to smell the stitched
- 0:23leather. They want you to feel the
- 0:24vibration of the engine through the steering wheel.
- 0:28They almost always start talking about the soul of the car.
- 0:31It's all explicitly designed to bypass your logical brain an,
- 0:34you know, go straight for your pulse.
- 0:36Yeah, the automotive industry has sent over a century
- 0:39erfecting that they sell an identity rather than just, well,
- 0:43a mode of transportation. But imagine replacing that
- 0:46typical emotionally susceptible customer with someone completely
- 0:50immune to all of it. Someone who just ignores the
- 0:53aggressive styling, refuses to acknowledge the famous badge,
- 0:57and instead just demands empirical mathematical proof
- 1:00that the vehicle's propulsion system is the most efficient use
- 1:03of geometric space. Which is a hilarious image.
- 1:06And that buyer is Renee Descartes.
- 1:08Right, the 17th century father of modern philosophy.
- 1:12And today, for our deep dive, we're taking him and forcing him
- 1:16to buy a 21st century car. It sounds absurd, but it turns
- 1:20out to be a phenomenal lens for looking at modern
- 1:22transportation. We are pulling from some really
- 1:25insightful articles today, specifically Cartesio Gemini and
- 1:29Cartesio Perplexity, which explore this exact hypothetical
- 1:33scenario. And the mission here is to
- 1:34figure out, based strictly on his principles of logic and
- 1:37mathematics, what kind of vehicle Descartes would actually
- 1:40drive off the lot today. Because, I mean, since Dcard
- 1:43practically invented analytic geometry, he wouldn't look at a
- 1:46car as a vehicle, right? He'd look at it as a rolling
- 1:49physics equation. So to really understand his
- 1:51choice, we first have to look at the mechanical world the way he
- 1:54did. His philosophy of mechanism is
- 1:56central here. Yeah, Mechanism.
- 1:58He viewed the physical world not as a place of mystery, but as
- 2:02this giant, intricate clockwork. Everything is regulated by
- 2:06strict mathematical laws. Which forces an immediate kind
- 2:09of brutal confrontation with the internal combustion engine.
- 2:12Oh. Big time.
- 2:13Because if the universe is an elegant, calculable clock, a gas
- 2:17engine is an incredibly brute force way to generate motion.
- 2:20It really is. Think about the sheer physics of
- 2:23it. An internal combustion engine is
- 2:25basically a metal box where we create thousands of tiny,
- 2:28violent explosions every single minute.
- 2:31Just to force Pistons up and down.
- 2:32Right. To have extreme heat, massive
- 2:35amounts of friction, and a complex sequence of
- 2:38thermodynamics simply to turn a drive shaft.
- 2:41I mean, it feels like controlled chaos.
- 2:42And that chaos is deeply offensive to Cartesian
- 2:45sensibilities. For Descartes, the physical
- 2:48world is defined by what he called res extensa matter
- 2:51extending through space. So he wanted to understand
- 2:54motion through pure geometry. Exactly.
- 2:57And the internal combustion engine relies on the messy
- 3:00physical violence of burning fossil fuels.
- 3:03You're dealing with all these unpredictable variables like
- 3:05fuel quality, air density, mechanical wear.
- 3:07I see. The logic.
- 3:08But wait, I have to push back a little.
- 3:10If Descartes wants absolute verifiable truth, wouldn't a
- 3:13purely mechanical analog car like a 1960s combustion engine,
- 3:18where you can physically see the carburetor in the gears?
- 3:21Wouldn't that be easier to physically verify than a modern
- 3:23electric vehicle wrapped in closed source code?
- 3:26I mean, that is a very fair push back, but it misinterprets what
- 3:29kind of simplicity Descartes actually valued.
- 3:33Well, he was looking for mechanical transparency, where
- 3:35you can just see the parts moving.
- 3:37He was looking for mathematical elegance.
- 3:40When you contrast a combustion engine with an electric motor
- 3:42through his lens, the internal combustion engine is a system
- 3:46fighting against itself. Right, because of the waste.
- 3:49Exactly. It requires radiators to dump,
- 3:51wasted heat, energy, oil to prevent the metal parts from
- 3:55destroying each other, heavy exhaust systems to manage the
- 3:58toxic byproducts of the explosions.
- 4:00Whereas an electric motor operates on fundamentally
- 4:03different physical principles. Precisely, and EV relies on
- 4:08electromagnetism. You have a stator creating a
- 4:10rotating magnetic field that just pulls the rotor along with
- 4:13it. With very few moving parts.
- 4:15Right. And no explosions.
- 4:17The power delivery is entirely linear.
- 4:19Instead of relying on controlled explosions, you're relying on
- 4:22the invisible, mathematically perfect forces of magnetic
- 4:25attraction and repulsion. So it's less about being able to
- 4:28see the gears turning and more about the underlying physics
- 4:31behaving like a pure frictionless equation.
- 4:34Yes. Exactly.
- 4:35You could compare the internal combustion engine to like a
- 4:39chaotic kitchen during a dinner rush.
- 4:41Pots clanging, things boiling over, massive energy wasted just
- 4:45to get a plate out, while the electric motor is like a
- 4:48magnetic pendulum. Pure frictionless geometric
- 4:52momentum. That analogy captures his
- 4:55preference perfectly. For Descartes, the electric
- 4:58vehicle represents the ultimate victory of what he called
- 5:01geometric reason. Because it replaces
- 5:03thermodynamic chaos with calculable physics.
- 5:06Yes, it's a system of electrons moving through circuits in
- 5:08highly predictable ways. To him, an EV isn't just an
- 5:12environmentally greener choice, it's the only philosophically
- 5:15rational choice for generating motion.
- 5:18But recognizing the physical perfection of the electric motor
- 5:21is really only half the battle. To actually use the car daily,
- 5:24Descartes has to interface with the vehicle's software, its
- 5:27battery, and its dashboard. And historically, he refused to
- 5:30trust any information that wasn't mathematically absolute.
- 5:34Which brings us to methodic doubt.
- 5:36Methodic doubt. That's arguably his most famous
- 5:39contribution to human thought, right?
- 5:41It is. It's the practice of
- 5:43systematically rejecting any belief or pieces information
- 5:47that can possibly be doubted. If there's even a fraction of a
- 5:51percent of uncertainty, you throw it out.
- 5:53You only build your knowledge on things that are clear and
- 5:55distinct. Applying that to a modern EV
- 5:58seems like a rescue for a massive panic attack.
- 6:01I mean, anyone who drives an electric car knows the battery
- 6:04free range indicator is highly subjective.
- 6:06Oh yeah, the EV community literally calls it the guess O
- 6:09meter. Right.
- 6:10The number fluctuates based on, you know, whether you have the
- 6:12heater on, if you're driving up a hill, or even just what the
- 6:15ambient temperature is outside. He would suffer from the most
- 6:18intense philosophical range anxiety imaginable.
- 6:22He would completely reject the dashboards estimate because it
- 6:25relies on probabilistic algorithms.
- 6:27Because a heuristic prediction of human driving behavior is the
- 6:31exact opposite of clear and distinct knowledge.
- 6:34Exactly. So he would probably ignore the
- 6:37screen entirely. He'd demand the raw empirical
- 6:40data. He'd want the real time kWh
- 6:43usage per mile, the battery degradation curves ambient
- 6:47temperature. I can just picture him sitting
- 6:49in his driveway calculating the exact aerodynamic drag of the
- 6:53vehicle against the current wind speed before he even shifted
- 6:56into drive. He really would mathematically
- 6:58calculate his own range every single trip.
- 7:01But while he would distrust the predictive dashboard, our
- 7:04sources point out that he'd be absolutely enamored with the
- 7:06systems that manage the energy behind the scenes.
- 7:09You mean like the vert charging schedules?
- 7:11Yes. When an EV communicates with the
- 7:13electrical grid, calculates when electricity is most abundant and
- 7:17cheapest, and schedules its own charging cycle, that is
- 7:20profoundly rational. Sometimes even precondition the
- 7:23battery temperature for optimal efficiency before you unplug.
- 7:26Right, it is order imposed on a massive, chaotic physical grid.
- 7:30It turns a volatile system into a predictable function.
- 7:34Still, I do have to wonder about the human element here, because
- 7:37driving isn't purely A mathematical exercise of getting
- 7:40from point A to point B for most people.
- 7:42Well, no, not for most people. People buy certain EVs for the
- 7:45instant torque, you know, the aggressive acceleration that
- 7:48pins you to the seat. Does Descartes factor in the
- 7:51physical sensation of driving or the aesthetic pleasure of a nice
- 7:55interior? He dismisses it entirely, and
- 7:57this connects directly to his concept of dualism.
- 8:01Descartes drew an absolute impenetrable line between the
- 8:04mind risk ajatans and physical matter as extensa.
- 8:08The classic mind body split a. Very severe split.
- 8:11For him, the mind is the realm of pure rational thought and
- 8:14truth. The body, on the other hand, is
- 8:16just plumbing, mechanics and sensory input.
- 8:19And he famously argued that our senses frequently deceive us.
- 8:22So human emotions, the thrill of speed, the comfort of plush
- 8:25leather, they're all just. Messy bodily illusions.
- 8:28They have zero bearing on rational truth.
- 8:30The desire to signal status through a luxury badge is
- 8:33completely irrelevant to him. So his criteria are strictly
- 8:36confined to aerodynamic efficiency, maintenance costs,
- 8:40charging infrastructure and documented environmental data.
- 8:44It's a very cold, utilitarian approach to mobility.
- 8:47It is cold, but it leads to a truly fascinating conclusion
- 8:51when you factor in his views on consciousness.
- 8:54Descartes had a rather controversial belief that non
- 8:56human animals were essentially soulless automatons.
- 8:59Right, because they lacked the ability to reason.
- 9:02Exactly. He categorized them as highly
- 9:04complex biological machines acting purely on mechanical
- 9:07instinct without any internal conscious experience.
- 9:10OK, if he views complex, seemingly intelligent actions as
- 9:14something that can be executed purely by mechanical programming
- 9:17without a soul, then I mean it seems obvious where this leads.
- 9:21His ideal car wouldn't need a human driver at all.
- 9:23He'd be obsessed testing over autonomous driving technology.
- 9:26You. Would consider autonomous
- 9:27driving the absolute pinnacle of human achievement?
- 9:30Think about how a system like Waymo or Tesla's Full Self
- 9:33Driving actually works. It uses liar radar and cameras
- 9:38to map the chaotic physical world into a massive 3
- 9:41dimensional point cloud. It literally plots the real
- 9:44world onto a Cartesian coordinate system.
- 9:46The very mathematical system he invented, an autonomous vehicle,
- 9:50maps reality into XY and Z coordinates, calculates vectors,
- 9:55predicts trajectories, and executes motion based entirely
- 9:58on geometry. So to him, software calculating
- 10:01a parallel parking maneuver is the supreme proof of reason
- 10:04applied to matter. Precisely, he would probably
- 10:07argue that the car should drive itself at all times.
- 10:11From his perspective, the vehicles computer relies on
- 10:13deductive geometric logic, whereas a human driver relies on
- 10:17flawed sensory input, emotional reactions and fatigue.
- 10:20The human is the chaotic variable in the system.
- 10:23Yes, the autonomous EV is the perfect soulless automaton he
- 10:26theorized about four centuries ago.
- 10:29It is purely mechanical, governed entirely by logic, and
- 10:32capable of navigating the world without consciousness.
- 10:34OK, so taking all these incredibly strict philosophical
- 10:37boundaries, the demand for mathematical efficiency,
- 10:39transparent energy data, total rejection of emotional branding,
- 10:42and this deep appreciation for algorithms, we finally arrive at
- 10:45the dealership. The ultimate question.
- 10:47Yeah, what are the actual keys Descartes is walking away with
- 10:50today? Well, our sources suggest that
- 10:52rationality in the automotive market can actually be optimized
- 10:56in two different directions, depending on which variable you
- 10:58prioritize. This leaves Descartes with two
- 11:01distinct but equally logical approaches.
- 11:04OK, let's explore approach #1. Approach 1 optimizes for the
- 11:08absolute pinnacle of mathematical engineering.
- 11:10If his goal is to see universal math applied to physical reality
- 11:14to its maximum potential, minimizing physical resistance
- 11:17at all costs, he might choose something like a Lucid Air or a
- 11:21Tesla Model S Plaid. Wait hold on, those are 6 figure
- 11:24luxury vehicles we just established.
- 11:26He doesn't care about status, aesthetics, or plush leather.
- 11:29Why would he spend that much capital on a luxury sedan?
- 11:32Because he wouldn't be buying them for the luxury, he'd be
- 11:34buying them for the physics. The Lucid Air specifically, is
- 11:38renowned for its obsessive engineering focus.
- 11:40It's aerodynamic drag coefficient is incredibly low,
- 11:45meaning it slices through the physical air with minimal energy
- 11:48waste, and the engineers have miniaturized the electric motors
- 11:51to an absurd degree, maximizing the thermal efficiency of the
- 11:54battery pack. Oh, so he's looking completely
- 11:57past the premium price tag and drooling over the thermal
- 12:00management system. He just sees the high price as
- 12:03the cost of acquiring the ultimate clockwork universe on
- 12:06four wheels. Yes, it represents the absolute
- 12:09current limit of human ability to reduce physical friction
- 12:12through advanced geometry. But if he values a verifiable
- 12:16simplicity over cutting edge complexity, he takes approach
- 12:19to. Which I assume minimizes the
- 12:21variables. If approach one is maximizing
- 12:24engineering potential, approach 2 is minimizing systemic waste
- 12:26and maximizing predictability. Exactly the concept.
- 12:29If the primary goal of reason is to minimize complexity and keep
- 12:32every single variable completely verifiable, he might go for
- 12:36something drastically more pragmatic.
- 12:38The sources suggest a Tesla Model 3 or, if we look at the
- 12:41European market, a highly compact EV like the Renault Zoe,
- 12:44the BMW I3 or even the Dacia Spring.
- 12:47A Dacia spring, I mean for anyone unfamiliar, that is one
- 12:50of the most bare bones inexpensive electric vehicles
- 12:53you can possibly buy. It is the definition of a basic
- 12:57commuter appliance. It really is.
- 12:58It doesn't accelerate quickly, it has zero advanced luxury
- 13:02features, it literally just moves a physical body from point
- 13:06A to point B. Which is precisely what makes it
- 13:08a Cartesian masterpiece. It represents minimizing
- 13:12complexity, minimizing financial cost, and keeping performance
- 13:16entirely transparent. There are no illusions with a
- 13:19Dacia spring. It doesn't pretend to have a
- 13:21soul. Exactly.
- 13:22It is a mathematically sound, highly efficient appliance.
- 13:25This dichotomy is brilliant. You have a 17th century genius,
- 13:29one of the greatest minds in human history, and if you drop
- 13:32him into a modern car market, he faces the exact same dilemma as
- 13:35any spreadsheet loving buyer today.
- 13:38He is agonizing over whether to pay a premium for the ultimate
- 13:41spec sheet or by the most budget friendly, pragmatic commuter car
- 13:44simply because the math makes sense.
- 13:46He'd be awake at 3:00 in the morning on Internet forums
- 13:49comparing the kWh per mile efficiency of the Lucid Air
- 13:53against the total cost of ownership at the Dacious Spring.
- 13:55We've literally taken a philosopher who changed human
- 13:58history and reduced him to an EV forum moderator arguing about
- 14:02drag coefficients. It's hilarious, but stepping
- 14:06back, it really highlights how far we've actually come in
- 14:09realizing his vision of the world.
- 14:12The internal combustion engine was a brilliant but chaotic
- 14:15compromise with nature. We basically wrestled with fire
- 14:18to create motion. And the electric vehicle,
- 14:21especially an autonomous 1, is the realization of a 400 year
- 14:24old philosophical prophecy. We finally built the perfect
- 14:27machine he was dreaming of. Our sources tie this together
- 14:30beautifully. If you were alive today,
- 14:33surveying our grid connected geometrically calculating
- 14:36electric cars, his defining motto wouldn't just be the
- 14:38historic Cudito Ergo Sum. I think therefore I am right.
- 14:42His new conclusion would be Cobito Ego Grito Electrico.
- 14:46I think therefore I drive electric.
- 14:48I think therefore I drive electric.
- 14:51That is amazing. It strips away all the marketing
- 14:53noise, the heritage, the nostalgia, and forces you to
- 14:57look at the machine purely as a mathematical solution to the
- 15:00problem of distance. It is the physical manifestation
- 15:03of logic. Which brings us perfectly to the
- 15:05end of our intellectual joyride today, and I want to leave you
- 15:08listening right now with a final provocative thought to chew on.
- 15:12The practical application of all this.
- 15:14Exactly next time you make a big purchase, it could be a car, a
- 15:17smartphone, or even a major appliance.
- 15:20Apply a little Cartesian methodic doubt.
- 15:23Ask yourself, are you buying it for the chaotic emotion of the
- 15:27brand? Are you paying a premium for a
- 15:29feeling, a badge, or an aesthetic that intentionally
- 15:33bypasses your logic? Right.
- 15:35If you strip away the marketing narrative and demand empirical
- 15:38data, what is the most mathematically elegant rational
- 15:41choice? You might find that the
- 15:43verifiable truth of what you actually need is very different
- 15:45from the store you've been sold. Doubt everything until the data
- 15:49proves it clearly and distinctly.
- 15:51It is an incredibly powerful filter for navigating a world
- 15:55built on advertising. It really is Well, I want to
- 15:58explicitly thank you for sharing your time and joining us on this
- 16:01deep dive today. We know you have endless options
- 16:03for what to listen to and we always appreciate you choosing
- 16:06to explore these bizarre and brilliant intersections of
- 16:10history and technology with us. It's.
- 16:12Been a fantastic exploration. And lastly, for everyone
- 16:15celebrating, we want to wish you a very Happy Easter Monday or
- 16:18Buena Pasqueta. We sincerely hope your holiday
- 16:21is filled with good data, exceptionally clear thoughts,
- 16:23and absolutely zero messy combustion engine chaos.
- 16:27Go enjoy the day and we'll catch you on the next deep dive.
- 16:30Remember, keep thinking, because therefore you are.