Latest / Journey to the Fringe / A house without DD Homes
Transcript
- 0:00From the unexplained to the mundane, come join us on a journey to the fringe.
- 0:12Hello and welcome to Journey to the Fringe.
- 0:15Now I'm going to level with you guys.
- 0:17I had to research and write the script all in the same week that the Elden Ring DLC
- 0:22came out, so I haven't been outside in a long time.
- 0:25We are your hosts, Taylor and Chelsea.
- 0:27Here today, Chelsea, I need to tell you the thought process to how I came to this episode.
- 0:32Before I tell you, I can tell you the episode, it's about Daniel Humes.
- 0:35Okay, I don't know who that is.
- 0:37I had a great idea for an episode.
- 0:39Famous people who believed in psychics or had psychic friends that they relied on.
- 0:45I ended up getting 20 pages on one guy, so we had to do him.
- 0:49And that is Daniel Humes.
- 0:50There might be an episode sometime in the future about celebrity psychics, but at this time,
- 0:56it is just Daniel Humes that we're going to be talking about.
- 0:59Hold on, do I know this?
- 1:01You might know him.
- 1:02I might switch also between calling him Daniel Humes and Daniel Holmes because it's spelt
- 1:07H-O-M-E, but it's pronounced Humes.
- 1:10No, I've never seen this guy in my life.
- 1:12Well, prepare for a ride.
- 1:14He is a very interesting character.
- 1:16He has a real interesting family dynamic that we're just going to get right into from the
- 1:21start.
- 1:22It's the like long Jim Morrison hair, right?
- 1:24Yeah, for some of the pictures.
- 1:26Oh, there's one of someone levitating.
- 1:27Yeah, we're going to get to that.
- 1:29Daniel Humes' mother is Elizabeth Betsy Hume.
- 1:33She is a seer born in Scotland, as were many of her predecessors.
- 1:36Apparently, it's a family trait that they are just seers in Scotland here.
- 1:40And apparently in the family, the gift of second sight, as they called it, was often
- 1:44seen as a curse as it foretold instances of tragedy and death.
- 1:47Humes' father, William Hume, was the illegitimate son of Alexander, the 10th Earl of Hume.
- 1:53And William was described as a bitter, morose, and unhappy man who drank and was often aggressive
- 1:59towards his wife.
- 2:00Hold on, I have an important question.
- 2:02Why are we pronouncing this Hume?
- 2:04That's how it's pronounced.
- 2:05It says who?
- 2:06The Scottish.
- 2:07Oh, the Scottish.
- 2:08Of course they're pronouncing that it's not home.
- 2:11Okay.
- 2:12Yeah, I know.
- 2:13Now, Elizabeth and William end up having eight kids, six sons, two daughters.
- 2:17The eldest, John, later worked in the Ballerno mill and eventually managed a paper mill
- 2:22in Philadelphia.
- 2:23I don't know why this is important for the story, but apparently it is.
- 2:27Mary drowned in a stream at the age of 12 in 1846, and Adam died at sea at the age of
- 2:3217 while en route to Greenland, which Hume says he saw in a vision reportedly confirmed
- 2:38five months later.
- 2:40Not written down anywhere, just something that he said when he was a kid.
- 2:42Quite the family dynamics going on, but this is the weird part.
- 2:46Daniel Hume was Elizabeth's third child and was born March 20th, 1833.
- 2:52The one year old Hume was deemed a delicate child having quote, a nervous temperament
- 2:58and quote, and was passed to Elizabeth's childless sister, Mary Cook.
- 3:04She lived with her husband in the coastal town of Portobello outside of Edinburgh.
- 3:08According to Hume, his cradle rocked by itself at the Cook's house and he had visions of
- 3:12a cousin's death who lived in Linlithgau to the west of Edinburgh.
- 3:16Hume's a nervous temperament so they gave him to the childless aunt.
- 3:19As you do I guess back in the day, but not so much anymore.
- 3:23Oh we don't?
- 3:24I don't think so.
- 3:25Maybe we still do.
- 3:26I don't know, I didn't have eight kids.
- 3:28At some point between 1838 and 1841, this family that has adopted Daniel immigrated
- 3:34to the US, sailing in the cheapest class of steerage as they could not afford a cabin.
- 3:39After landing in New York, the Cook's, which is the family's last name, traveled to Greenville
- 3:43near Norwich, Connecticut.
- 3:45Hume attended school in Greenville where he was known as Scotchy.
- 3:49I wonder why they named him that by the other students.
- 3:52Is that funny or mean?
- 3:54I think it's mean.
- 3:55Like it's the 1830s so I think that's the only thing they know is meanness.
- 3:59Oh sure.
- 4:00And dysentery.
- 4:01No it's funny and mean as well as dysentery.
- 4:03And maybe a little bit infectious.
- 4:05Yeah.
- 4:06At this time Daniel makes a friend named Edwin.
- 4:09Apparently these two like to read the Bible together.
- 4:11You know the fun stuff going on in the day.
- 4:14They made a pact.
- 4:16Daniel's leaving town like they're moving and they make this pact and this isn't a
- 4:20normal one like hey we'll meet up when we're 18.
- 4:23No it's if one of us dies we have to try to contact the other after we die.
- 4:29As you do.
- 4:30Why haven't I made a pact like that yet?
- 4:31I don't know.
- 4:32You do it with someone.
- 4:33Maybe I'll do it this weekend.
- 4:34Hume moves to Troy, New York which is about 155 miles away from Greenville and Hume lost
- 4:39contact with Edwin until one night when Hume saw a brightly lit version of him standing
- 4:44at the foot of the bed which gave Hume the feeling that his friend was dead.
- 4:48Edwin made three circles in the air before disappearing and a few days later a letter
- 4:52arrived stating that Edwin had died of malignant dysentery and yes I did know that she was
- 4:57coming so I made sure that we talked about it earlier.
- 5:00Three days before Hume's mission.
- 5:01Percent of the letter.
- 5:02I would assume family.
- 5:03I don't know.
- 5:04Do they have a list in case someone dies of dysentery?
- 5:07You gotta write a letter to you to tell them?
- 5:10Don't you have your dysentery death list for people?
- 5:14Do you keep it at or do you keep it on behalf of someone else?
- 5:17Oh no, your parents can't keep it definitely because they're more apt to die of dysentery
- 5:23before the war ends.
- 5:24Okay and this is my favorite part.
- 5:26This just shows how ridiculous this family is.
- 5:29Few years later Hume and his aunt returned to Greenville and Elizabeth, Hume, emigrated
- 5:34from Scotland to the US with the surviving members of the family to live in Waterford,
- 5:39Connecticut which was 12 miles away from Cook's house.
- 5:42Hume and his mother's reunion however was short lived as Elizabeth foretold that she's
- 5:46going to die in 1850.
- 5:48So Hume said he saw his mother in a vision saying Dan 12 o'clock which was the time
- 5:53of her death.
- 5:54So she shows up she's like yeah I'm dying I'm gonna die foretold just how it goes.
- 5:58And kind of around this time when they move into this house apparently there's reports
- 6:02of wrappings and knocking similar to those that occur in the Fox sister story two years
- 6:09earlier.
- 6:10You never hear of wrappings anymore?
- 6:11No you don't.
- 6:12Pretty much never.
- 6:14Ministers were called to the Cook's house, a Baptist, a Congregationalist, and even a
- 6:18Westleyan minister who all believed that Hume was possessed by the devil although Hume believed
- 6:23it was a gift from God.
- 6:25According to Hume the knocking did not stop and a table started to move by itself even
- 6:29though Hume's aunt put a Bible on it and then placed her full body weight on it.
- 6:34And the noises did not stop and were attracting the unwanted attention of Cook's neighbor
- 6:38so Hume was told to leave the house.
- 6:40It happens a lot during this time period.
- 6:43He got kicked out because the house was possessed.
- 6:46That happened with the few of them actually.
- 6:49It happened with that one in Nova Scotia too.
- 6:51They kicked her out because she was possessed.
- 6:53Man what a time.
- 6:55I know to be alive.
- 6:57Here's this Daniel Hume character.
- 6:59He's 18 years old and he's staying with a friend in Willamantic, Connecticut and later
- 7:03Lebanon.
- 7:04I don't love Connecticut.
- 7:06The place that has way too many silent letters.
- 7:09And by that I mean I think one.
- 7:11Way too many.
- 7:12Way too many.
- 7:13From here he decides he's going to hold his own seances.
- 7:15So he has his first one in March of 1851 which was reported in a Hartford newspaper
- 7:20managed by W.R. Hayden who wrote that the table moved without anyone touching it and
- 7:24kept moving when Hayden physically tried to stop it.
- 7:28After the newspaper report Hume became well known in New England and traveling around
- 7:32healing the sick and communicating with the dead although he wrote that he was not prepared
- 7:37for his sudden change in his life because of his supposed shyness.
- 7:40I actually found what appears to be an affidavit of people who saw one of his seances.
- 7:46So I'm going to read it for you.
- 7:48Please do.
- 7:49The undersigned bear testimony to the occurrence of the following facts which we separately
- 7:54witnessed at the house of Rufus Elmer in Springfield.
- 7:581.
- 7:59The table was moved in every possible direction and with great force when we could not perceive
- 8:04any cause of motion.
- 8:052.
- 8:06It's the table was forced against each one of us so powerfully as to move us from our
- 8:09positions together with the chair we occupied in all several feet.
- 8:133.
- 8:14Mr. Wells and Mr. Edwards took hold of the table in such a manner as to exert their
- 8:17strength to the best advantage but found the invisible power exercised in an opposite
- 8:22direction to be quite equal to their utmost efforts.
- 8:254.
- 8:26In two instances at least while the hands of all the members of the circle were placed
- 8:30on top of the table and while no visible powers was employed to raise the table or otherwise
- 8:35move it from its position it was seen to rise clear of the floor and to float in the atmosphere
- 8:40for several seconds as if sustained by some denser medium of an air.
- 8:445.
- 8:45Mr. Wells seated himself on the table which was rocked for some time with great violence
- 8:50and at length.
- 8:51The table poised itself on the two legs and remained in this position for some 30 seconds
- 8:55when no other person was in contact with it.
- 8:576.
- 8:58Three persons, Mr. Wells, Mr. Edwards assumed positions on the table at the same time and
- 9:03while thus seated the table was moved in various directions.
- 9:06How many more points can they make on this table?
- 9:09They're all saying the same thing.
- 9:13Yeah.
- 9:14Essentially.
- 9:157.
- 9:16Occasionally we were made conscious of occurrences of a powerful shock which produced a vibratory
- 9:20motion of the floor of the apartment in which we were seated.
- 9:23It seemed like the motion occasioned by distant thunder or the firing of ordinances far away,
- 9:28causing the table, chairs, and other inanimate objects and all of us to tremble in such a
- 9:33manner that the effects were both seen and felt.
- 9:358.
- 9:36In the whole exhibition which was far more diversified than the foregoing specifications
- 9:40would indicate, we were constrained to admit that there was an almost constant manifestation
- 9:47of some intelligence which seemed at least to be independent of the circle.
- 9:519.
- 9:52In conclusion we may observe that Mr. D.D.
- 9:55Hume frequently urged us to hold his hands and feet during these occurrences.
- 10:00The room was well lighted, the lamp was frequently placed on and under the table, and every possible
- 10:05opportunity was afforded us for the closest inspection if we admit this one emphatic declaration.
- 10:11We know that we were not imposed upon nor deceived.
- 10:14It is signed by a W.M. Bryant, B.K. Bliss, W.M. Edwards, David A. Wells.
- 10:28So we're talking about seances then, okay.
- 10:30Cause I wasn't sure if you meant seances or being so impressed with something that you
- 10:34and your friends need to go get a lawyer right after David's read a sign about it.
- 10:40You know what never occurred to me before, I should start writing them more often.
- 10:46Have you ever done that?
- 10:47No, nor have I been to a seance.
- 10:49So you think it's only applicable for seance type purposes?
- 10:53It almost feels like it's a marketing gimmick, does it not?
- 10:56Now that you say that, yes.
- 10:57I thought it was just someone being blown away.
- 11:00Maybe they're a lawyer.
- 11:02Maybe they deal with affidavits every day so they just like, that's what they're like
- 11:06doing, or to work the next day they're like, I'm just going to do one up for myself.
- 11:11I should make note here that Hume does not have a law degree so he did not write this
- 11:14affidavit for them.
- 11:15You're impressed by that, right?
- 11:17Here sign this affidavit.
- 11:18Yeah, but the writer probably writes a lot of affidavits in his life.
- 11:22I would say, I would venture to say that he is probably a chronic affidavit writer.
- 11:30He's putting on these seances.
- 11:32He's impressing people so much they're going to the lawyers, but apparently Hume never
- 11:35actually charges people to go to his seances.
- 11:38There's no payment there.
- 11:40I've seen it explained, it felt like he was an employee to people and then he was using
- 11:44his powers incorrectly if he was seeking payment, but he also accepts gifts and donations.
- 11:49I don't really see a difference.
- 11:52He apparently did, I don't.
- 11:54Well, I will say because I have my Reiki training, you are supposed to, oh never mind, you can
- 12:02take payment for Reiki.
- 12:03Oh good.
- 12:04You're supposed to have an exchange of something, whether it be money or dinner or something
- 12:10like that for Reiki.
- 12:11I was thinking about it wrong.
- 12:13Okay.
- 12:14He felt that he was on, quote, a mission to demonstrate immortality and, quote, and
- 12:18wished to interact with his clients as one gentleman to another rather than as an employee.
- 12:23I don't think he quite understands what the word employee means, but maybe it meant something
- 12:28different in the 1850s.
- 12:30In 1852.
- 12:31So where does he make his money?
- 12:32He gets gifts and donations.
- 12:34That's how he lives.
- 12:36Fancy people really like him as he kind of probably could have guessed from how I came
- 12:40to find this guy.
- 12:42Okay.
- 12:43In 1852, Hume was a guest at the house of Rufus Elmer.
- 12:47That's the story we just told.
- 12:48We can skip that one.
- 12:50All convinced of Hume's credibility and wrote to Springfield Republican newspaper stating
- 12:54that the room was well lit, full inspection.
- 12:56It was also reported that one of Hume's demonstrations had five men of heavy build and Chelsea, I
- 13:02just, is going to tell you a real difference between nowadays and the 1850s.
- 13:07Five men of heavy build with a combined weight of 850 pounds sat on the table, but it's
- 13:12still moved.
- 13:13So each of those men weighed on average 170 pounds.
- 13:16Okay.
- 13:17Well, that would make it more difficult to stop it.
- 13:20Yeah.
- 13:21But heavy built men are 170 pounds in the 1850s.
- 13:24Is 1850 supposed to make a difference to me?
- 13:27Well, I just feel like a heavy built man is far more than 170 pounds.
- 13:31Oh, no, that's true.
- 13:33Yep.
- 13:34No, you're right.
- 13:35So you could make that number probably with three people in a random audience now.
- 13:38Oh, yeah, that's true.
- 13:39Okay.
- 13:40Now I get what you're getting at.
- 13:41Yeah.
- 13:42Okay.
- 13:43They are like quite obese by 1850s.
- 13:46They're heavy gentlemen.
- 13:50Hume was investigated by numerous people such as Professor Robert Hare and John W. Edmonds,
- 13:55a trial court judge.
- 13:56Maybe he was right in affidavits.
- 13:58Who knows?
- 13:59They were skeptical, but later said they believed Hume was not fraudulent.
- 14:03Hume's did write a book later in life.
- 14:04It was called Incidents in My Life.
- 14:06And he claims that in August of 1852 in South Manchester, Connecticut at the house of a
- 14:11Ward Cheney, a successful silk manufacturer of the day, he was reportedly seen to levitate
- 14:16twice and then rise up to the ceiling with louder wrappings and knockings than ever before.
- 14:22More aggressive table movements and the sound of a ship at sea in the storm, although persons
- 14:27present said that the room was badly lit so as to see the spirit lights.
- 14:31Hume then moved to an apartment in New York at Bryant Park on 42nd Street and his most
- 14:36verbal critic in New York was a man by the name of William Makepeace Thackeray, the author
- 14:41of Vanity Fair.
- 14:43Thackeray dismissed Hume's abilities as dire humbug and dreary and foolish superstitions.
- 14:48I should say those are both direct quotes.
- 14:50Although Thackeray had been impressed when he saw a table turning.
- 14:53Hume thought that Thackeray was quote the most skeptical inquirer he had ever met and
- 14:58quote and as Thackeray made his thoughts public, Hume faced public skepticism and further scrutiny.
- 15:04In 1853 he resided at the Theological Institute as he wanted to take a course in medicine.
- 15:09And Dr. Hall funded Hume's studies and offered to pay Hume $5 a day for his seances but Hume's
- 15:16refused due to that whole opinion he has on betting paid for seances.
- 15:21His idea was to fund his work with a legitimate salary by practicing medicine but he became
- 15:26ill in 1854.
- 15:28You know as they said earlier, he had that disposition which made him have to be given
- 15:33to his aunt.
- 15:34And it turns out he gets diagnosed with tuberculosis or consumption as it's also called.
- 15:39Do you know what the doctors recommend for him?
- 15:41Bloodletting.
- 15:42Not a bad guess for how the conversations have gone today.
- 15:45But move to Europe.
- 15:49Like a super weird diagnosis.
- 15:51Yeah, why?
- 15:52What was the reasoning?
- 15:53Does it say?
- 15:54I don't know.
- 15:55All I know is from here he sets off in March of 1855 and moves to Europe.
- 15:59Now up to this point I should let you know these are all the things that people say that
- 16:03he's done in his seances.
- 16:04The raps and knocking sounds, object levitation and movements including complete levitation
- 16:08of pianos and tables.
- 16:11Tables tilted or moved sharply.
- 16:13Alteration in the weight of objects.
- 16:15I don't understand that one but it does come up and we're going to talk about that
- 16:18one later on.
- 16:19So it can make things heavier or lighter.
- 16:21The appearance of lights or luminous phenomenon.
- 16:24The appearance of partially or fully materialized forms.
- 16:27Touches, poles, pinches and other tactile phenomena occurring while the hands of all
- 16:32present were visible above the table.
- 16:34Auditory phenomena.
- 16:35Odors produced at the absence of any visible object.
- 16:38Earthquake effects.
- 16:39The shaking.
- 16:40This is a weird one.
- 16:41Hands.
- 16:42Supple, solid, mobile and warm of different sizes, shapes and colors.
- 16:46While the hands were animated and solid to the touch, they would often end at or near
- 16:50the wrist and eventually dissolve or melt.
- 16:53Sometimes the hands were said to be disfigured exactly as the hands of a deceased ostensible
- 16:57communicator had been.
- 16:59And he would play musical instruments, either totally not touching them or while handling
- 17:04them while they were unable to actually be played.
- 17:06Was he good?
- 17:07I didn't think.
- 17:08It didn't come up.
- 17:09It was too bad.
- 17:10He would handle hot coals, elongations in which the medium grew from several inches
- 17:15to more than a foot and levitation.
- 17:17So that's the kind of stuff that we're talking about in his seance is they sound like a good
- 17:20time.
- 17:21Absolutely.
- 17:22And I'm sad that I can't go to one, I think.
- 17:24Well, you just wait and see what happens at the end of this.
- 17:27Okay, I'm excited for that.
- 17:30Hume's when he moves there, I don't understand why it seems weird that it was included in
- 17:35the Wikipedia article, but I'm just going to keep it here anyways, because it is his
- 17:38full name.
- 17:39He stretches his name out from Daniel Hume to Daniel Dungless Hume.
- 17:43Like, I thought it was Douglas for a long time, but no, it's Douglas.
- 17:47Is this the elongation that they were talking about?
- 17:50Yeah, it's like I elongated my name to D.
- 17:53And you'll see D.D. Hume written a lot when you're referring to him.
- 17:57And everyone's like, oh my God, he didn't like people are creating fucking like Afed
- 18:02Davids or like he elongated.
- 18:04And they are really impressed by very simple legalese back in the day.
- 18:09You better go get a lawyer to confirm our astoundingness.
- 18:14When he gets to London, Hume found a believer in spiritualism, William Cox, who owned a
- 18:18large hotel.
- 18:19He gets to stay with him for free.
- 18:22There's also another guy that lives there named Robert Owen.
- 18:24He's an 83 year old social reformer.
- 18:26I don't know what that meant, but it was included.
- 18:29It was also staying at the hotel and introduced Hume to many of his friends in London society.
- 18:33So he gets connected quick.
- 18:35He's not living a bad life for someone who's not charging anything for him.
- 18:39I know.
- 18:40He's doing quite well for himself.
- 18:42Very.
- 18:43So at the time, Hume was described as a tall and thin with blue eyes and auburn hair,
- 18:47fastidiously dressed, but seriously ill with consumption.
- 18:50Nevertheless, he had held sittings for notable people in full daylight, moving objects that
- 18:55were some distance away.
- 18:56Some early guests at Hume's sittings included the scientist Sir David Brewster, who remained
- 19:01unconvinced that he was doing anything fancy.
- 19:04The novelists are Edward Bulwer-Lytton and Thomas Adolphus Trollope and the Sweden-Borgen
- 19:11James John Garth Wilkinson.
- 19:13I don't know any of those names.
- 19:15No, neither do I.
- 19:16Not one ring a bell.
- 19:18As well as Brewster, fellow scientists Michael Faraday and Thomas Huxley were prominent contemporary
- 19:23critics of Hume's claims, and it was the poet Robert Browning, however, who proved
- 19:27to be one of Hume's most adamant critics.
- 19:30After tending a seance of Hume's, Browning wrote in a letter to The Times that quote,
- 19:34the whole display of hands, spirit, utterances, etc. was a cheat and imposter.
- 19:41Browning gave his unflattering impression of Hume in the poem Sludge the Medium, like
- 19:45he specifically wrote a poem putting him in bad light.
- 19:49And his wife, Elizabeth Barrett Browning, was convinced that the phenomena she witnesses
- 19:53were genuine and loved Hume's.
- 20:04There was dysentery.
- 20:05I really like the fact that he moved to America, got consumption, and then got told to go back.
- 20:10And it will save him.
- 20:12He does live for a while after, so that's good.
- 20:14Yeah, I mean, you're up for it as far as I'm concerned.
- 20:18So Hume's fame continued to grow, fueled by his ostensible feat of levitation.
- 20:23There's a band by the name of William Crooks.
- 20:25He claimed Hume could levitate five to seven feet above the floor and wrote, we all saw
- 20:30him rise from the ground slowly to a height of about six inches, remain there for about
- 20:3410 seconds and then slowly descend.
- 20:37William Crooks is going to come up later because there's some fun stuff with him.
- 20:41In the following years, Hume traveled across continental Europe and always as a guest of
- 20:46wealthy patrons.
- 20:48In Paris, he was summoned to the Thulieres.
- 20:53My French is pretty terrible.
- 20:56To perform a seance for Napoleon the Third.
- 21:00So the shittier one.
- 21:02But there is a behind the bastard's episode on him.
- 21:04Is it good Napoleon?
- 21:05The Napoleon the first one was at least fairly famous.
- 21:10Napoleon the Third is very different.
- 21:11Oh, I think I only know the bad one.
- 21:13Okay.
- 21:14I performed for Queen Sophia of the Netherlands who wrote, I saw him four times.
- 21:18I felt a hand tipping my finger.
- 21:21I saw a heavy golden bell moving alone from one person to another.
- 21:24I saw my handkerchief move alone and returned to me with a knot.
- 21:28He himself is pale, sickly, rather handsome young man, but without a look or anything
- 21:33which would either fascinate or frighten you.
- 21:35It is wonderful.
- 21:36I am so glad I have seen it.
- 21:38It wasn't fancy enough though for her to go see her lawyer.
- 21:40I was just going to say, was this written on an affidavit or are we taking her word
- 21:45for it then?
- 21:46Yeah, so that's how it is.
- 21:50Well known liar.
- 21:52In 1866, Mrs. Jane Lyon or Leon, I don't know, a wealthy widow.
- 21:57I love this story.
- 21:59She adopts him and gives him 60,000 pounds because she wants to see.
- 22:05He's in his mid 30s at this point.
- 22:07Okay.
- 22:08I'm looking for people to ask that he adopted me and adopted me.
- 22:11And yeah, moms are just the thing that get you get lent out to.
- 22:15If it is his mind.
- 22:16So it's because she wants him to introduce her into high society.
- 22:20She found that this didn't do anything for her.
- 22:22So she changes her mind and brought a lawsuit for the return of her money from him on the
- 22:27grounds that he had been obtained by spiritual influence.
- 22:32And I need to find this lawsuit because she ends up winning.
- 22:35The money was returned.
- 22:36Wow.
- 22:37That's incredible.
- 22:38And certainly Hume's high society acquaintances thought that he behaved like a complete gentleman
- 22:42throughout the ordeal and he did not lose a single important friend.
- 22:45Also, it should be noted though that generally if he lost the case and generally you don't
- 22:52immediately sue, you just ask for the money back.
- 22:55And then after some time, you have to go to a lawsuit.
- 22:58So he didn't just return the money.
- 22:59I mean, maybe that's what was so gentlemanly.
- 23:02There's no affidavit about this.
- 23:03They're lying, obviously.
- 23:05Yeah.
- 23:06So the first person I ended up finding this guy through, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, the creator
- 23:11of Sherlock Holmes, he was a big fan of Hume's.
- 23:14He stated that Hume's was an unusual seer in that he had four different types of mediumships,
- 23:20direct voice, the ability to let spirits audibly speak, transpeaker, the ability to let spirits
- 23:25speak through oneself, a clairvoyant ability to see the things that are out of view, and
- 23:30physical medium moving objects at a distance.
- 23:33So he was a big fan of all that.
- 23:34Now of course, like the biggest thing, this guy is known as like the levitating guy.
- 23:39So his biggest one happened in 1860.
- 23:41Yeah, I have a picture here of him levitating.
- 23:43A young Lord Adair, who his name will come up later, was fascinated by Hume's and began
- 23:49documenting the seances that he held.
- 23:51The following year, Hume was said to have levitated out of a third story window of one
- 23:57room and back in through the window of the adjoining room in front of three witnesses.
- 24:02Adair, Captain Wynn, and Lord Lindsay.
- 24:05Lord Adair stated that Hume, quote, swung out and in, and quote, of a window in a horizontal
- 24:11position.
- 24:12It should be noted, everybody remembers the story completely differently of these three
- 24:16people who saw it.
- 24:19The incident took place at number five Buckingham Gate Kensington says Adair at Ashley Place,
- 24:25Westminster says Adair at Victoria Street, Westminster says Lindsay.
- 24:29Adair was a ledge four inches wide below the window says Adair, a ledge one and a half
- 24:34inches wide says Lindsay and no footholds at all says Lindsay at a different time.
- 24:39Adair at different times said the balconies were seven feet apart and that there were
- 24:43no balconies at all.
- 24:45The windows were eight feet from the street, Lindsay, 70 feet, Lindsay, 80 feet, Hume on
- 24:51the third floor, Adair on the first floor, Adair.
- 24:54It was dark, Adair, there was a bright moonlight, Lindsay.
- 24:58Hume was asleep in one room and the witnesses went into the next adair.
- 25:02Hume left the witnesses in one room and went himself into the next adair.
- 25:07So I don't know how great that story is.
- 25:11That is like the most insane I've ever heard like eyewitness accounts.
- 25:16Yeah.
- 25:17It's just they've constantly changed the story over the years and like nobody, it's
- 25:23hard to really tell what happened from it.
- 25:25Well, no, not just based on that.
- 25:27Yeah.
- 25:28Trevor H. Hall, who researched the case in detail, established that the levitation likely
- 25:33took place at Ashley Place in Westminster, which is one of the places they said it could
- 25:37have happened at, at a height of 35 feet and suggested rather than levitating, Hume had
- 25:42stepped across a gap of four feet between two iron balconies.
- 25:45So that doesn't seem unreasonable.
- 25:47That's the width of a sheep squat shoulders right there.
- 25:51Yeah.
- 25:52You could step over that.
- 25:53Yeah.
- 25:54Okay.
- 25:55Now this part.
- 25:56So he's made a name for himself.
- 25:57There's this guy named William Crooks.
- 25:59He's a very well known scientist of his day and he wants to study to see if the paranormal
- 26:05is real.
- 26:06So he's going to conduct experiments on Hume and there's kind of two that we're going
- 26:11to be talking about that he's done.
- 26:13He does during this time.
- 26:14Crooks tested Hume's apparent ability to alter an object's weight.
- 26:18It consisted of a mahogany board 36 by 9.5 by one inch onto whose ends had been screwed
- 26:24mahogany strips 1.5 inches wide, one of these feet rested on a firm table and the other
- 26:29was supported by a spring balance hanging on a sturdy tripod.
- 26:32This apparatus was rigged so that the mahogany board lay horizontally between the table and
- 26:36the tripod.
- 26:37As in the case of the accordion, Hume had never seen the device.
- 26:41I'm sorry and the accordion is going to come up later.
- 26:43I thought it was the other way around.
- 26:45Apparently it's not.
- 26:46Hume sat at the table where one end of the board rested and placed his finger tips lightly
- 26:51on that end of the board.
- 26:52Crooks and Huggins sat on either side of the board.
- 26:55Almost immediately the board and spring balance began to oscillate up and down.
- 27:00Hume then placed a nearby handbell and matchbox on one end of the board, one under each hand
- 27:05and in order to demonstrate he said that he was not producing the downward pressure.
- 27:09The oscillation of the spring balance became more pronounced and Huggins who was watching
- 27:14the index saw it descend to 6.5 pounds and later to 9 pounds.
- 27:18The normal weight of the board as registered by the balance had been 3.5 pounds prior to
- 27:22the experiment.
- 27:23I just don't know what about that you'd be like, ooh spooky like paranormal.
- 27:28Wow.
- 27:29Yeah.
- 27:30He's just added six pounds to it somehow.
- 27:33I don't know how I would still be like, wow, that's so uninteresting.
- 27:37Like made it idiot.
- 27:38Yeah.
- 27:39Well, and if he was alive today, he would clearly be making his name in diet fortunes.
- 27:43True.
- 27:44Like that's probably about it though.
- 27:45Yeah.
- 27:46I don't know what he's just going to pay for it.
- 27:48Oh yeah, influencers do that still.
- 27:50Yeah.
- 27:51No more, no affidavits though.
- 27:53No affidavits.
- 27:54Crooks was particularly impressed by Hume's accordion phenomenon.
- 27:57So this is the other thing.
- 27:59He could play music through instruments that he was just touching, not playing them, touching
- 28:03them.
- 28:04So he's like, I'm going to see how he does this.
- 28:05So you guys have a, you can do that with the piano.
- 28:09Just touch the piano.
- 28:10Touch it and it plays music.
- 28:12Oh play it.
- 28:13But this is a hundred years before that automatic piano that we have.
- 28:16You're just going to give away your fucking secrets.
- 28:19Yeah.
- 28:20Yeah.
- 28:21Wow.
- 28:22I don't know if I can get behind that.
- 28:23This is really, I find this super suspicious.
- 28:27Hume's customary procedure for like playing these instruments was to hold the accordion
- 28:31at the end away from the keys, just under a table.
- 28:35So it had to be under a table for him to play it this way.
- 28:38With his other hand supporting him resting on top of the table.
- 28:41His explanation for this was that the power was greatest under table.
- 28:47They let him do this.
- 28:48So basically they set him up.
- 28:49They're going to explain it, but they set it up with the accordion under the table where
- 28:53he can't reach the keys to play it.
- 28:55Crooks ends up like sitting right beside him with a foot on his foot so he can't move his
- 28:59foot.
- 29:00And that's how he's like, he's not doing anything with his foot or his hand.
- 29:03We can see it and he can't reach in.
- 29:05It's so nice of him though to sit there with him.
- 29:08Yeah.
- 29:09With your foot on his foot.
- 29:10Yeah.
- 29:11So this is a new accordion for the occasion and Hume saw it for the first time when the
- 29:14experiment began.
- 29:15Crooks went to Hume's apartment and watched him change clothes and that enabled him to
- 29:20determine that Hume hadn't concealed some device that would allow him to manipulate the accordion
- 29:24circuitously.
- 29:25Oh, he watched him.
- 29:26That's nice.
- 29:27And then Crooks then brought Hume's to his house where he had prepared a wooden cage wound
- 29:33with insulated copper wire and netted together with string.
- 29:36The cage fit under Crooks's table and the accordion was placed inside it.
- 29:41There was enough space between the cage and the table for Hume to reach in and hold the
- 29:45accordion at the end away from the keys, but there wasn't enough space for Hume to reach
- 29:49in further and touch or manipulate the keys.
- 29:52Furthermore, Hume couldn't operate the accordion with his feet because the cage rested on the
- 29:56floor besides Hume had boots on and there were observers who were keeping an eye on him.
- 30:00So Crooks describes it this way, the cage begins being drawn from under the table so
- 30:05as to just allow the accordion to be pushed with its keys downwards.
- 30:09It was pushed back as close as Mr. Hume's arms would permit, but without hiding his
- 30:13hands from those next to him, very soon the accordion was seen by those on each side to
- 30:19be waving around in a somewhat curious manner.
- 30:22Then sound came from it, and finally several notes were played in succession.
- 30:26While this was going on, my assistant went under the table and reported that the accordion
- 30:31was expanding and contracting at the same time, and it was seen that the hand of Mr.
- 30:36Hume by which it was held was quite still.
- 30:39His other hand resting on the table.
- 30:42So those are the experiments that Crooks designs and uses on Hume, and he concludes that this
- 30:48guy is totally legit and paranormal stuff's real.
- 30:51Chelsea, I need it to be known now.
- 30:54There's three people he's done experiments on that he fully believes at this point,
- 30:58legit in their paranormal powers.
- 31:00Hume, Florence Cook, and Kate Fox.
- 31:03It isn't Hume himself?
- 31:05Crooks is doing the investigations, and he's concluding this.
- 31:08He's found three mediums he fully believes are real.
- 31:11Okay, I thought he found three people that fully believed that what he was doing was...
- 31:15No, he did experiments on these three individuals and concluded that they were all real.
- 31:19Well, the Fox sisters.
- 31:20Yes.
- 31:21Okay, that took me a long time to process.
- 31:23I apologize.
- 31:24Yes.
- 31:25Yeah, so, yeah.
- 31:26So Fox sisters legit according to this.
- 31:28Yeah, okay.
- 31:29You haven't listened to our Fox sister episodes, go listen, they are not legit.
- 31:33They even admit it.
- 31:34Yeah, okay.
- 31:35They're not up to speed on that point of the Fox sisters.
- 31:37So he wrote this paper in 1874 and concluded that the phenomenons produced by all three
- 31:42of these mediums were genuine.
- 31:44That's pretty much the life I wanted to talk about and his notoriety where it comes from.
- 31:49Very interesting things.
- 31:50It doesn't end the same way the Fox sisters do and that they come out and say like, that
- 31:53this is real.
- 31:54He never comes out and says that.
- 31:56He's never actually had like a full public issue come out where it's like, yeah, this
- 32:01guy's a fraud.
- 32:02Is it?
- 32:03It never happens.
- 32:04Yeah.
- 32:05What?
- 32:06There's more to this story.
- 32:07It should be noted though that while the statements that Hume was never caught in a fraud has
- 32:12been made many times, it's not that true.
- 32:14It's simply that Hume was never publicly exposed for his frauds.
- 32:18Privately he was caught in fraud several times and in addition, there are natural explanations
- 32:22for a lot of things that he has says that he did.
- 32:24Interesting.
- 32:25Joseph McCabe wrote regarding the alleged levitation.
- 32:28No one professes to have seen Hume carried from window to window.
- 32:32This is that one window thing that was talked about.
- 32:34I think it's already been fairly well debunked at that point, but Hume told the three men
- 32:39who were present that he was going to be wafted and he thus set up a state of very nervous
- 32:44expectations.
- 32:45Both Lord Crawford and Lord Adair say that they were warned and then Lord Crawford says
- 32:50that he saw the shadow on the wall of Hume entering the room horizontally and as the
- 32:54moon by whose light he professes to have seen the shadow was at most only three days old.
- 33:00His testimony is absolutely worthless.
- 33:02Lord Adair claims only that he saw Hume in the dark standing upright outside our window.
- 33:08In the dark it was almost moonless December night.
- 33:11One could not as a matter of fact say very possibly whether Hume was outside or inside
- 33:15but in any case he acknowledges that there was a 19 inch window sill outside the window
- 33:20and Hume could stand on it.
- 33:22I think that was fairly obvious from the story though.
- 33:25Yeah.
- 33:26Arthur Conan Doyle even says at points that there were many cases on record of Hume levitating
- 33:31but skeptics assert the alleged levitations occurred in darkened conditions susceptible
- 33:35to trickery and pretty much all of his seances are done in very dark lighting so if you're
- 33:41going to be doing trickery it's a lot easier to get it done.
- 33:43Yeah.
- 33:44Now those fancy magicians that are in Vegas like do levitation.
- 33:48Yeah they do it all the time.
- 33:49It's easy to do.
- 33:50Yeah levitation that is.
- 33:52Yes.
- 33:53At a seance in the house of the solicitor John S. Nathan Reimer in Ealing in July of 1855
- 33:59a sitter observed that quote a spirit hand unquote was in fact a false limb attached
- 34:05to the end of Hume's arm.
- 34:06Yeah what's up with those spirit hands.
- 34:08Yeah I don't know.
- 34:09Merrifield also claimed to have observed Hume uses foot in the seance room so there are
- 34:15allegations nothing was ever proven and then our friend Robert Browning who hated this
- 34:21guy attended the seance on July 23 1855 in 1895 after the death of Robert and Elizabeth
- 34:28the journalist Frederick Greenwood alleged that Browning had told him that during seances
- 34:32he had taken hold of a luminous object that appeared above the edge of the table which
- 34:36turned out to be Hume's naked foot.
- 34:39You.
- 34:40You imagine.
- 34:41I know.
- 34:42Later Browning's son Robert in a letter to the London Times December 5 1902 also referred
- 34:47to the incident saying that Browning had caught hold of Hume's foot under the table.
- 34:51The allegation was repeated by Harry Houdini and later writers.
- 34:56But detailed descriptions of the seance written soon afterwards by Robert and Elizabeth make
- 35:00no mention of any such incident and Browning's account states that although he was promised
- 35:05that he would be allowed to hold a spirit hand the promise was never kept.
- 35:10Those men these guys in these spirit hands.
- 35:12Yeah.
- 35:13You can't say I've ever heard of that before but there was like all types of spirit hands.
- 35:17They're just all over the place.
- 35:19But this guy's known for levitation which is the funny thing.
- 35:21Spirit hands.
- 35:22In the society of psychical research there was a letter by Dr. Barthes a physician in
- 35:29the court of Empress Eugenie.
- 35:30He wrote this home more thin shoes easy to take off and draw on and also cut socks that
- 35:36left the toes free at the appropriate moments he takes off one of his shoes and with this
- 35:41foot pulls a dress here and a dress there and rings a bell knocks one way and another
- 35:46and things done quickly puts his shoes back on again.
- 35:49Hume positioned himself between the Empress and Napoleon III one of the seance sitters
- 35:54known as General Fleury also suspected that Hume was utilizing trickery and asked to leave
- 35:58but returned unobserved to watch from another door behind Hume.
- 36:02He saw Hume slip his foot from his shoe and touch the arm of the Empress who believed
- 36:07it to be one of her dead children.
- 36:09The observer stepped forward and revealed the fraud and Hume was conducted out of the
- 36:14country quote the order was to keep the incident secret end quote.
- 36:17The allegations described by Dr. Barthes and General Fleury are second hand and have
- 36:21caused disputes between psychical researchers and skeptics.
- 36:24They've came up before I can't remember where though.
- 36:27Yeah I can't either.
- 36:28I assume for that time it's probably it wouldn't be Edelure and Warren it's probably something
- 36:33like Blavatsky or something.
- 36:35That would make sense because that's right around the right time.
- 36:38And then let's just talk a bit about William Crook's investigation.
- 36:42He says that it was all done and controlled and secured in his laboratory.
- 36:47That's method of foot control that we talked about that was super important.
- 36:51Yeah.
- 36:52Wasn't great because he used the exact same foot control on a Yusapia Paladino who was
- 36:58able to get around it as she just slipped her foot out of the shoe because it was a
- 37:02thick shoe and he didn't know what it is.
- 37:05How did it stay put?
- 37:07I can't imagine if someone's foot is on mine no matter the thickness of shoe getting it
- 37:13off.
- 37:14Yeah I know but she got around it.
- 37:17It wouldn't be unreasonable to think other people would have done it as well.
- 37:20Well yeah I guess if your crew is depending on it I just can't imagine myself.
- 37:23And in addition Crook's motive method and conclusion with regards to Florence Cook were
- 37:27called into question both at the time and subsequently casting doubt on his conclusion
- 37:31with Humes and that's one of the three mediums that he confirmed in 1874 were real.
- 37:36In a series of experiments in London at the House of Crooks in February of 1875 the medium
- 37:41Anna Eva Fay managed to fool Crook into believing she had genuine psychic powers and Fay later
- 37:47confessed to her fraud and revealed the tricks she had used.
- 37:50Same with the Fox sisters.
- 37:51And same with the Fox sisters.
- 37:52No good track.
- 37:53I feel like this happens again and again with these spiritualists at this time that they
- 37:58find someone that conducts research on them and they're like oh it's totally real because
- 38:03they just want to believe in it.
- 38:04And this guy absolutely has the believability behind him and he ends up being like very
- 38:08well known scientist in his day.
- 38:10So fabulous mustache.
- 38:12Fabulous mustache.
- 38:13This is named Cook.
- 38:14Crooks.
- 38:15C-R-O-O-K-E-S.
- 38:16Oh yeah.
- 38:17Oh yeah.
- 38:18Wow.
- 38:19This is incredible.
- 38:20They don't make mustaches like that anymore.
- 38:21They do not.
- 38:22No.
- 38:23That is someone that takes some pride in their mustache.
- 38:26Yeah.
- 38:27So in 1871 Belford Stewart in an article in Nature noted that the experiments that Crooks
- 38:31had conducted were not conducted in broad daylight before a large unbiased audience and the
- 38:36results were inconclusive.
- 38:37Stewart suspected the phenomena observed were subjective rather than objective occurring
- 38:42in the imaginations of those present rather than the outward physical world.
- 38:46In the same year JP Earwaker wrote a science review that heavily criticized Crooks experiments
- 38:52for their poor design including they were pseudoscientific and according to Earwaker
- 38:57for in truth they are the very opposite of scientific even to call them unscientific
- 39:01is not strong enough.
- 39:02Plumsy and futile are much nearer the truth.
- 39:05Some people brought into question the actual weight of the wood he used in that mahogany
- 39:09doesn't weight what he says it does which is weird and it should also be noted Crooks
- 39:15was a huge believer in psychic powers before he started doing these experiments.
- 39:19It just said that.
- 39:20So he might have just fallen into his own bias.
- 39:22He just wants to know he just wants to confirm it.
- 39:25Yeah.
- 39:26I mean that's obvious just given that two of them came out as for sure frauds themselves.
- 39:31They're like yep we're frauds.
- 39:32It's probably like probably just don't just say that just like let other people say that
- 39:37don't just don't they were like I'm a fraud.
- 39:39Is that just totally discredits my work?
- 39:42Perry Houdini wrote this about crooks there is not the slightest doubt in my mind that
- 39:46this brainy man was hoodwinked and that his confidence was betrayed by the so-called mediums
- 39:51that he tested his powers of observation were blinded and his reasoning faculties so blunted
- 39:55by his prejudice in favor of anything psychic or a cult that he could not or would not resist
- 40:01the influence.
- 40:02One of the experiments is making something heavier.
- 40:04That's just not possible.
- 40:06Spiritualism is very spooky.
- 40:08It wouldn't be impressed if someone made something heavier.
- 40:11I wouldn't.
- 40:12I do want to end off too with the accordion.
- 40:13A skeptic by the name of James Randy stated that Humes was caught cheating on a few occasions
- 40:18but the episodes were never made public and that the accordion feat you know where he
- 40:22made an accordion play without touching it he thinks it was a one-octave mouth organ
- 40:27which is basically a really small harmonica that Hume concealed under his large mustache.
- 40:31Randy writes that one octave mouth organs were found in Hume's belongings after his
- 40:35death and according to Randy around 1960 William Lindsay Gresham told Randy that these mouth
- 40:40organs in Hume's collection at the Society of Psychical Research.
- 40:44Oh man, I mean that's as good as being found a fraud.
- 40:47Yeah, I can't confirm that's true though this guy's just saying it's there so I don't
- 40:51know for sure.
- 40:52And also a really weird turn that I got near the end of when I was doing this research.
- 40:57For some reason his name triggers a wiki for LGBTQIA.
- 41:01I don't know why like he has his own LGBTQ Wikipedia page and I was really confused what
- 41:08was going on with that.
- 41:10It turns out that Lord Adair that guy who saw him levitate, he wrote a diary and apparently
- 41:16there's it's titled the experiences in spiritualism with DD Homes.
- 41:20He says in it that he slept in the same bed with him and many of the diary entries contain
- 41:25erotic homosexual overtones between Adair and Hume.
- 41:29So for them.
- 41:30Yeah.
- 41:31And lastly Hume retired due to ill health and tuberculosis from which he had suffered
- 41:36for much of his life.
- 41:37He dies on June 21st 1886 at the age of 53 and was buried in the Russian cemetery of
- 41:42Saint Germain-en-Laye in Paris.
- 41:45So that's the story.
- 41:46Actually I wasn't disappointed by this guy.
- 41:48It's an interesting one.
- 41:50Yeah, I was a little disappointed that we didn't find out in the end that he was an
- 41:54asshole.
- 41:55He was Scottish so I didn't think I had to state it.
- 41:58Also, anybody who forces people that enjoyed their show to sign affidavits, they're assholes.
- 42:04They are.
- 42:05Or lawyers and he's not a lawyer.
- 42:07Maybe.
- 42:08No, he wasn't both.
- 42:09No, he was just an asshole.
- 42:10He was only one of those at a time.
- 42:11Yeah, that was good and I never even, I think he did come up before though.
- 42:15Yeah, he's right around this time like just after the Fox sisters but before Houdini shows
- 42:20up on the scene to like counteract them all.
- 42:22This was the time that that was what you did.
- 42:25It was like the popular influencer type thing to do, I think.
- 42:29Yeah, it was the movie theater.
- 42:31It was the mall of its time.
- 42:32Yeah, the movie theater, the arcade.
- 42:35It was the YouTube of its era.
- 42:36But yeah, that's Daniel Dungless Humes.
- 42:39Chelsea, anything you want to know more?
- 42:42I don't think so.
- 42:43I think that was it.
- 42:44I quite enjoyed that.
- 42:45I was like a good spiritualist.
- 42:46This one probably he was alright.
- 42:48He was okay.
- 42:49Really into hands and feet and floating.
- 42:52As we all are.
- 42:53At least he didn't have a here list tail.
- 42:55Yeah, and with that, I have been Taylor, here with Chelsea.
- 42:59We are Journey to the Fringe.
- 43:01Thank you all for listening and we'll see you next week.
- 43:03Bye.
- 43:04Thank you for listening to Journey to the Fringe.
- 43:07If you have liked what you have listened to, please like, share, subscribe, or follow
- 43:13depending on what venue you are listening to us through.
- 43:17Also please, if possible, leave a five star review as that really helps us in the algorithms.
- 43:23Should you wish to interact with us, please check us out on your social media of choice.
- 43:28I bet you we are there.
- 43:30And if you really want to communicate with us and give us ideas for new episodes or tell
- 43:34us that we're wrong and terrible, either way, please send us an email at journeytothefringe.com.
- 43:41For now, I'll see you in the next episode.