Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Career Reference From a Former Colleague
Transcript
- Lucas: So you're updating your resume, you find a great job listing, and then you hit the reference section. And you realize — your former boss from your last role? You haven't spoken in three years, and frankly, you're not even sure they remember you. Luna: That is such a common panic moment. And it's not just for people early in their careers either. I've seen senior folks freeze up on this. Lucas: Right. Today we're talking about how to ask for a career reference from a former colleague — when your old boss isn't an option, or when you just don't have that recent manager relationship to lean on. Luna: And I think the key word there is 'colleague' — not just anyone who shared your cubicle. You want someone who can speak to specific work you did together. Lucas: Exactly. Let's ground this in a real scenario. A listener named Priya wrote in. She's a marketing manager who spent four years at a mid-sized agency. Two years ago, her agency was acquired by a larger holding company. Her old boss — the creative director who hired her — left during the transition. She has no current contact for him. She's now applying for a senior brand manager role, and the application asks for three professional references. She has her current boss, but she needs at least two more. Luna: And that's where the fear sets in. She doesn't want to seem like she's scrambling, but she also doesn't want to ask someone who'll give a generic, forgettable recommendation. Lucas: Priya's situation is perfect for this discussion because she has a few good options among former peers. The question is: how does she choose the right one, and how does she ask without it being awkward? Luna: So where do you start? Her LinkedIn network probably has dozens of people from that agency. Lucas: First step: narrow the list. You don't want your 'work bestie' who you got lunch with every day but never actually collaborated on a project. You want someone who observed your work product firsthand. For Priya, that might be a senior copywriter she partnered with on three major campaigns, or the analytics manager who saw her improve conversion rates on a big account. Luna: So it's about specific, measurable contributions. Not just 'she's nice to work with' — which, okay, that's nice, but it's not a reference. Lucas: Exactly. Let's say Priya identifies two strong candidates: a former peer, Sarah, who was the lead designer on a campaign that won an industry award, and a former direct report, Marcus, who she mentored for two years. Both can speak to different strengths. Sarah saw her creative strategy and client management. Marcus can speak to her leadership and development skills. Luna: I like the direct report angle. A lot of people overlook that because they think references should be from superiors, but a former report who's now in a senior role themselves can be incredibly credible. Lucas: Absolutely. And it shows confidence. Now, the ask. Priya hasn't talked to Sarah in over a year. So she should not just send a LinkedIn request with 'Can you be a reference?' out of the blue. That's like proposing on a first date. Luna: Right. You have to rebuild the bridge first. What's the right way to start that reconnection? Lucas: Send a warm, low-pressure message referencing a specific shared experience. Something like: 'Hey Sarah, I was just thinking about our work on the Acme campaign last year — that was such a fun project. Hope you're doing well! Would love to catch up when you have a moment.' No ask yet. Just a touchpoint. Luna: And then after that exchange, you can follow up with the request. But what if they don't reply? Do you send a second message? Lucas: You can send one polite follow-up about a week later. If they still don't respond, move on. That's a signal they're either too busy or not comfortable. Don't take it personally. Luna: And when you do make the formal ask, I think a lot of people make the mistake of apologizing too much. 'Sorry to bother you, I know you're busy, I hate to ask...' It undermines your confidence. Lucas: Yes. Instead, lead with respect and clarity. Say: 'I'm applying for a senior brand manager role, and I'd be honored if you'd serve as a professional reference. I valued our collaboration on the Acme campaign and thought you could speak to my strategic and creative contributions. If you're comfortable, I'll send you the job description and my resume so you have context.' That's it. Luna: And always give them an out. 'No pressure at all — I completely understand if you're not in a position to do so.' That makes it easy for them to decline gracefully, and it preserves the relationship. Lucas: Exactly. Now, let's talk about what happens when they say yes. You want to make it easy for them. Prepare a brief document that lists the key projects you worked on together, your specific role, and any quantifiable results. Also include a few bullet points about the kind of role you're targeting and the skills you'd like them to highlight. Luna: That's so smart because then they're not scrambling to remember details. And it also ensures they highlight what you need for this particular job, not just generic praise. Lucas: Right. And one more thing: if you're asking a former colleague who is now at a different company, make sure they're comfortable using their personal email or LinkedIn — not their current work email, which could get flagged by their employer's IT. People have lost freelance gigs over that. Luna: Good point. So we've covered who to ask, how to reconnect, and how to make the ask. But there's another scenario: what if you don't have a strong former colleague you've worked with closely? Like if you were a solo contributor in a siloed role. Lucas: That's harder, but not impossible. Look for cross-functional partners — someone from another department you collaborated with on a project. Even a client can serve as a reference if they're willing. Just be upfront that they're a client reference, not a colleague. Employers usually separate those categories anyway. Luna: And if all else fails, there's always the alumni network. A former classmate who's now in a senior role and knows your work ethic from a group project — that's better than nothing, but use it as a last resort. Lucas: I'd actually put that below a volunteer board member or a former intern you mentored. But point taken. The core idea is: think broadly about who has seen you deliver results. Luna: Before we wrap up, I want to circle back to something you said earlier about giving the reference an out. That's really about respect. And I think that's the thread through all of this — you're asking someone to invest time and reputation in you. So you want to make it as easy and dignified as possible for them. Lucas: Exactly. And you know, if we've helped you think through a tricky career move or a tough conversation like this one, we hope you'll consider supporting the show. It's what keeps Office Hours ad-free and focused entirely on your questions. You can do that at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, every bit helps us keep bringing you practical, no-fluff advice. And we're grateful for every listener who chips in. Lucas: Alright, back to Priya's situation. Once she's identified her two references and they've agreed, the next step is to brief them properly. Send them the job description, your updated resume, and a short note on what you'd like them to emphasize. For Sarah, that might be your strategic thinking and client relationship skills. For Marcus, your mentorship and ability to develop talent. Luna: And do you recommend following up after the reference check? Like, letting them know if you got the job? Lucas: Absolutely. Always close the loop. Send a thank-you note regardless of the outcome. If you got the job, they'll be happy for you. If you didn't, they'll appreciate knowing their effort wasn't wasted. And it keeps the door open for future requests. Luna: That's a good habit. I think a lot of people forget that part. Lucas: One more tip: if you're using a former colleague who is now at a competitor, be careful. Some companies have policies against providing references for former employees who go to a direct competitor. Ask them privately if that's a concern before you list them. Luna: Great point. So to sum up for Priya and anyone in a similar spot: pick a colleague who saw your work, rebuild the connection with a warm message, make the ask clearly and respectfully, equip them with context, and follow up. That's the playbook. Lucas: And don't be afraid to ask. Most people genuinely want to help a former colleague succeed — especially if you were a good teammate. The worst they can say is no, and that's fine. Luna: I think that's the takeaway. Thanks for writing in, Priya. And if you have a career question you'd like us to tackle, send it in. We read every one. Lucas: We'll be back next time with another real-world career dilemma. Until then, keep the conversations going.