Latest / Film And Whiskey / One Battle After Another (2025) / Green River Wheated Full Proof Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00In 2025, director Paul Thomas Anderson and star Leonardo
- 0:04DiCaprio gave the world an explosively dark comedy that
- 0:08struggles to balance drama with absurdism.
- 0:12Oh, in 2026 we try a whiskey that might have us asking for
- 0:17one bottle after another. I I like that, Bob.
- 0:24That's good. Thanks so much.
- 0:25Thank you. The film is 1 battle after
- 0:28another. The whiskey is Green River
- 0:31weeded foolproof bourbon. And we'll review them both.
- 0:35This is the Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 0:57Welcome to the Film and Whiskey podcast, where each week we
- 1:00review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 1:03I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad Gee.
- 1:06Brad, do you look like you're you're still waking up here,
- 1:09man. It's 12:00.
- 1:10What are we doing? It's.
- 1:11It sure is. It's just itch on my eye, Bob.
- 1:15That's all right, it's all right.
- 1:16You know, we're rolling, we're going live, and we're doing
- 1:19something different today. Folks.
- 1:20Welcome into film and Whiskey. By the way, if this is your
- 1:23first time joining us, we typically don't talk about
- 1:26movies as recent as Paul Thomas Anderson's 2025 film 1 Battle
- 1:31After Another. We're usually looking at classic
- 1:34movies from bygone eras and reviewing those.
- 1:37However, this season of the podcast, we've gone back and
- 1:40we've reviewed every movie we did way back in season #1 with
- 1:44the exception of two films, because we had already revisited
- 1:47both of those films already, and we figured that a third time
- 1:51might not be the charm to talk about Goodfellas and whatever
- 1:54the other one was, Brad. So we said, hey, we're going to
- 1:57have two open spots at the end of the season.
- 1:59It's going to be right around Oscar time.
- 2:01What if we take the two leading contenders for Best Picture and
- 2:05talk about those movies instead? And so this week we're talking
- 2:09about 1 battle after another, which is by all accounts the
- 2:12front runner for Best Picture. But next week we're talking
- 2:15about Ryan Coogler's record-breaking nominated film
- 2:19Sinners, which is by far the biggest contender with One
- 2:23Battle after Another. So stick around for these two
- 2:25weeks because we're talking about movies that are very, very
- 2:28fresh, that haven't really had time to marinate not just with
- 2:32us, but within the culture. Brad, I think you know, for the
- 2:35most part in the past we've tried to stick to about a five
- 2:38year gap between the movie's release and the time we've
- 2:41talked about it and other have been exceptions for Cruise
- 2:44misses. I know we've done Oppenheimer
- 2:46and the Holdovers and past lives, but for the most part we
- 2:51try to put a little bit of distance between US and the film
- 2:54chronologically. Yeah, yeah.
- 2:56And and it works because we have a chance to let it sit.
- 2:59It sits in the cultural consciousness.
- 3:01And then, you know, we just come in swing right in there and and
- 3:04give our to be honest with you, Bob, the best opinion you'll
- 3:08ever find on any movie. So.
- 3:11Well, you know, they say the way to get the most clicks on your
- 3:14website and downloads on your podcast is to wait five years
- 3:17after the movie's released. You know, because culture
- 3:21doesn't like to know what a current movie is like.
- 3:23They want to know what that movie from 5 years ago.
- 3:25It's right, Brad, and that's why we're so successful, folks.
- 3:28That's the key, the recipe to our success.
- 3:30The the key would because there's that like 25 year
- 3:34nostalgia window that like seems like every fifth year you're
- 3:38jumping 25 years back. And that's like the thing they
- 3:41make ATV show about. So we really should be focused
- 3:44right now on like that early 2000s, which we kind of did.
- 3:48We recently released a 25th anniversary episode about Lord
- 3:52of the Rings. So do you want your nostalgia
- 3:54fix? Go back and listen to that.
- 3:56Go listen to the Lord of the Rings.
- 3:58I do like the kind of five year rule, Brad, because it allows us
- 4:01to get like some things just out of the way really quickly.
- 4:04So like when we did Green book, especially for this revisit,
- 4:07it's like, look, everyone acknowledges this movie
- 4:10shouldn't have won best picture. Do we need to throw the baby out
- 4:13with the bathwater? And I feel I feel like it
- 4:15allowed us to deal with the movie on its own terms and to
- 4:18grapple with the kind of like, you know, Cinderella esque
- 4:22racial tension in that movie where it's like, is this really
- 4:26how racism gets solved or is this a Hollywood thing?
- 4:28And because we didn't have to have the conversation about the
- 4:31best picture of it all, it actually allowed us to
- 4:33appreciate things about the movie and to be a little more
- 4:36honest about its flaws, which we're going to try to have to do
- 4:39that today with one battle after another.
- 4:41A movie that has not yet allowed the public to come all the way
- 4:46back around on it. Like this movie.
- 4:48When it was released in late 2025, it was, I think, the best
- 4:53reviewed movie by most metrics of this decade so far.
- 4:57The hype train was absolutely off the charts for this movie.
- 5:01I went and saw it in the theater.
- 5:03I'll very quickly tell you that I was not on this movie's
- 5:06wavelength the first time I saw it and I am, I feel very alone
- 5:09and very on an island about that because like I said, universal
- 5:13acclaim for this movie. So of course I have to be the
- 5:16contrarian and I never like being the guy that's like this
- 5:20movie sucks because if someone enjoys something like good for
- 5:23you. I wish I enjoyed this movie
- 5:25more. I go see this movie at like a
- 5:2710:30 PM showing. I get out of the theater at like
- 5:301:00 in the morning. I'm driving home on this Country
- 5:33Rd. and there is a dead deer in the middle of this road that,
- 5:37like, the construction on the road has narrowed it down to one
- 5:40lane. I'm going around a curve and
- 5:41there's a deer and I have no choice but to run over this
- 5:45small deer that's already dead in the middle of the road.
- 5:47It screwed up my whole, the whole bottom part of my car.
- 5:50And then, you know, within a month, I have to get a new car.
- 5:53So I blame this movie not just for being a let down for me, but
- 5:56for having, but for totalling my car, essentially.
- 5:59Brad. Yeah.
- 6:00So I mean, if that's not coming. No, I come into this rewatch
- 6:04with this movie's got to prove a lot to me, to improve in my
- 6:08estimation, 'cause now Paul Thomas Anderson owes me a
- 6:11vehicle. Yeah.
- 6:12That, that's how I I take it to be.
- 6:14I think, I think legally as well that, yeah.
- 6:17I believe the law's on my side in this one.
- 6:19That feels like an Old Testament, like if your bull
- 6:23gores your neighbors and you owe him restitution.
- 6:27I think Paul Thomas Anderson owes you restitution, Bob.
- 6:30I agree with that. All right, Brad, you have just
- 6:33seen this movie for the first time.
- 6:35Now I know that there will be a lot of folks out there that are
- 6:37going to be a little bit myth that you did not go see this in
- 6:39the cinema but you saw it on the small screen.
- 6:42I will say gorgeous cinematography in this movie.
- 6:45And I think that one good sign of a well shot movie is that it
- 6:50does translate to a smaller screen, whether you're watching
- 6:53it on ATV at home or you probably watched it, you know,
- 6:56on your computer monitor. Brad, it's it's big enough,
- 6:59right? At least it's not a phone.
- 7:00It's TV sized. And I think that the movie in
- 7:03terms of the way it's shot, the compositions, the sound design,
- 7:07that all translated to this viewing where I streamed it as
- 7:10well. So I think points in the
- 7:13transferability column for this movie.
- 7:16But we want to hear Brad. We're all waiting with bated
- 7:18breath what you thought of this movie, and in order to do that,
- 7:22we have to explain what the movie's about, and that means
- 7:25it's time for our first segment of the day, which we call Brad
- 7:28explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 7:30movie plots with only 60 seconds taken on the clock, so let's go
- 7:34ahead and do your take with this little segment that we call,
- 7:37Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 7:40show where Brad breaks down the plot of the movie that he has
- 7:43just seen, often for the first time.
- 7:45I believe this is the first time this season we've been able to
- 7:48actually say this is a first time watch for Brad G.
- 7:52It absolutely is a first time watch.
- 7:54It's kind of nice to be back to a new movie.
- 7:57I like, I've deeply enjoyed going back to season 1 movies.
- 8:01It's been an absolute blast. I was kind of excited I, you
- 8:04know, popped onto HBO Max and was like, all right, let's do
- 8:08this. We're watching a new movie.
- 8:11You know, I do feel like it has been kind of a crutch for you
- 8:13this season that you already knew what all these movies were
- 8:15about. It really improved the quality
- 8:18of, Brad explains. But the chaos factor has gone
- 8:21way down and I missed the chaotic, Brad explains.
- 8:24Trust me when I say this is going to be a chaotic, Brad
- 8:27explains. All right, Brad, I'm actually
- 8:30really eager to hear your thoughts on this movie because
- 8:32there's a lot of directions we can go.
- 8:34Usually you tip your hand a little bit with how you or what
- 8:37you decide to include in your summary of the film, so you have
- 8:4060 seconds on the clock. This summary is just going to be
- 8:43me reading off names from the movie just as you jungle
- 8:48Pussycat perfidia Beverly Hills. Folks, here's the thing, Brad
- 8:53explains. It's going to be full of
- 8:55spoilers. It always is.
- 8:56So if you don't want this movie spoiled for you, it is now
- 8:59streaming. You can rent it across a number
- 9:01of platforms or it's streaming, you know, for free on HBO Max.
- 9:05Please go watch this movie. It's likely going to win Best
- 9:07Picture 2 1/2 hours. It's a long movie.
- 9:10Come back and join us for the rest of the episode.
- 9:13But Brad, the task before you is to spoil this movie in 60
- 9:16seconds or less and go. One Battle After Another is a
- 9:21film that follows the members of a revolutionary group called the
- 9:26French 75 who make it their goal to attack ICE customs and
- 9:33enforcement officers and free and allow immigrants to come in
- 9:37seemingly from Mexico into the US.
- 9:40The 1st 45 minutes of the film follows them on a revolutionary
- 9:45mission where the main character Perfidia Beverly Hills comes in
- 9:49contact with a Colonel Lockjaw of the military forces.
- 9:55They have a weird sexual encounter and he gets her
- 9:57pregnant. Fast forward 16 years later, she
- 10:02has been put away and escapes from from confinement.
- 10:08What's witness protection? Because she sold out her crew
- 10:12and she's gone. You never see her again.
- 10:14The rest of the film follows Leonardo DiCaprio who thinks
- 10:17that he is the father of Perfidious child who is 16 years
- 10:20old and named Willa. She is captured by Stephen
- 10:25Lockjaw because he is trying to make his way into a racist white
- 10:29people club and trying to erase the reality that this was his
- 10:34mixed race daughter and chaos ensues.
- 10:38Leonardo DiCaprio is wildly hilarious and I think, I think
- 10:44that's it. I think that's it.
- 10:46That's a good start. Brad is that is that, is that a
- 10:49good start? Listen, I will commend you first
- 10:51of all. Because that was that was pretty
- 10:53good. That was pretty good and it was
- 10:56a very neutral and and what I'm most interested to hear from you
- 10:59today, because Brad, you are the resident, you know, right wing
- 11:03Alex Jones, loving conspiracy theorist, worshipper of the
- 11:08rights on this podcast, right, That that's a good explanation
- 11:11of of where you are. That is me to a tee.
- 11:14I don't have any thoughts on my own.
- 11:16I only follow what, Alex Jones and Nick Fuentes and all that.
- 11:23I'm just like. And I, I am a straight up
- 11:27communist who worships at the altar of people like, you know,
- 11:31Rachel Maddow, let's just say, you know, so that and Carl Marx
- 11:35and Carl, well, I mean, of course that goes without saying.
- 11:39So you are a little bit more right leaning than I am.
- 11:41And right before we pressed record, you said like, I think
- 11:44this might be the most left wing movie we've ever done on the
- 11:47podcast, which is saying something because there's a lot
- 11:49of them and we've done quite a few of them on the podcast as.
- 11:52Well, you tell me a movie that's more overtly left wing.
- 11:57Well, see, here's The thing is that, and I think that like,
- 12:00this is a good jumping off point because I want to talk about
- 12:03like what we think the movie's trying to do because our ability
- 12:07to articulate that I think will also tip our hand as to whether
- 12:12we think the movie works or not. So this movie is based on a
- 12:15novel called Vineland by Thomas Pynchon.
- 12:18And Thomas Pynchon is a very lauded novelist who likes to
- 12:22write, you know, semi absurd, humorous novels.
- 12:27And this is the second time Paul Thomas Anderson has adapted
- 12:31Pynchon for the the screen, the first time being his movie
- 12:34Inherent Vice, which is probably his most divisive movie.
- 12:38And a lot of people would say it's his worst movie.
- 12:40I find it to be his worst movie. It really rambles.
- 12:42It's also 2 1/2 hours long. But you get kind of similar
- 12:46things where like there is a level of like slapstick humor,
- 12:50like Joaquin Phoenix is high all the time and kind of like doing
- 12:53pratfalls. Same thing you get with Leonardo
- 12:55DiCaprio here. I think that movie is pitched a
- 12:58little bit more absurd than this one is.
- 13:01But you have all those kind of classic traits of like absurdist
- 13:04names like Lockjaw and Toe Jam and things like that.
- 13:07That's also in Inherent Vice. What I really want to try to get
- 13:12to the bottom of here, Brad, is that I don't think you or I has
- 13:15ever actually read a pension novel.
- 13:17So we're here only experiencing that through the lens of Paul
- 13:21Thomas Anderson. And the novel Vineland is set in
- 13:25a different time period. I think it's set in the 1970s.
- 13:27So he modernizes it, adapts it to what he sees going on in the
- 13:31country today and kind of makes it his own thing, but tries to
- 13:35carry over some of that satirical absurdist humor as
- 13:39well. Do you think that that is, have
- 13:42I captured what we think he's trying to do with this movie?
- 13:45I would say so. It seems it seems like he's
- 13:49trying to capture the cultural moment in a way that uses
- 13:55absurdity to call out the ridiculousness of what he sees
- 14:00to be negative things going on in our culture.
- 14:04Is that fair? Yeah, I think so.
- 14:07And I, you know, this time around, I really did notice that
- 14:10while the majority of the absurdism is directed towards
- 14:14these kind of like hard right figures and or, you know,
- 14:18military structures, there definitely is also this sense of
- 14:22like, OK, if if Dicaprio's character Bob is Paul Thomas
- 14:27Anderson's muse in this movie, then there also is that sort of
- 14:31like, what the hell are the kids doing?
- 14:33I don't understand these kids. Is that a he or a she or a they?
- 14:37And then also like, you know, the new revolutionaries that are
- 14:40coming up underneath DiCaprio. He's like, at one point he's
- 14:42talking to the guy on the phone and he hangs up and he's just
- 14:45like you liberal prick. And he hangs the phone up.
- 14:48So there's also this sense of like, I have a deep hatred for
- 14:51what the left has become as well.
- 14:53And I find that really fascinating.
- 14:56Now, again, there's a million directions we can go in.
- 14:58Brad, I think I want to start with just the simple question of
- 15:02whatever the tone of the movie that you think Paul Thomas
- 15:06Anderson is going for, how like what percentage did it actually
- 15:11succeed at that? I found myself really struggling
- 15:19with the 1st 45 minutes of this movie 'cause it's played dead
- 15:23serious like. But besides the fact that these
- 15:26characters have ridiculous names, which somewhat makes
- 15:29sense, like you can tell that these are pseudonyms.
- 15:32They're not their real names, they're revolutionaries.
- 15:35Have that have taken on these personas?
- 15:38Go ahead. Can you set the stage for like
- 15:40what is the 1st 45 minutes? Yeah.
- 15:43So the first 45 minutes I struggled a little bit because
- 15:46they make it seem like it's set in the 1970s, but then they're
- 15:50also using smartphones and so it is a little bit confusing.
- 15:55It seems like it's set in 2008 to 2010 area where we have some
- 16:01early smartphones but there's still a lot of more just more
- 16:05analog nature to life and the whole 1st 45 minutes is the
- 16:11French 75 revolutionaries waging war on capitalist America.
- 16:18They are freeing immigrants that are being held by American
- 16:23forces. They capture that.
- 16:27I mean, the key scene is when she captures Stephen Lockjaw,
- 16:30the Colonel, and like forces him into like sexual humiliation and
- 16:35he likes it. And then I, this was something,
- 16:39this is something that I struggled with throughout the
- 16:42movie is that there's no subtlety to this movie.
- 16:45This is like the the least subtle movie I've ever seen.
- 16:49And the first note I took on Lack of subtlety is like Stephen
- 16:53Lockjaw, like walks Sean Penn, played by Sean Penn.
- 16:56He walks funny and it almost looks like he has a stick up his
- 16:58butt because he likes a stick up his butt.
- 17:02He sure does. He sure does.
- 17:05But that's the first 45 minutes, and it all ends poorly.
- 17:09When a bank robbery goes wrong, Perfidia gets captured.
- 17:12She sells out her revolutionary friends, she becomes a rat.
- 17:17And then as soon as she's set up with her witness protection, she
- 17:19pieces out. It disappears to South America,
- 17:23I think. Yeah, we don't know.
- 17:25Where is? Is that what you're looking for?
- 17:27Yeah, yeah. And I think that's helpful
- 17:29because there is such a big time jump in the movie.
- 17:32One thing that I struggled with is throughout the movie, they
- 17:35really play around with the timelines.
- 17:38And because like the timelines are just happening across a
- 17:40couple days in the back half of the movie, it's not that big of
- 17:43a deal. But there will be like, there's
- 17:45this one moment late in the movie where Dicaprio's character
- 17:50gets arrested, He gets tased and arrested.
- 17:52And then they cut away to what's happening with his daughter, who
- 17:55is being taken to like a safe haven.
- 17:58And you kind of stay with her for a day or two.
- 18:01And then they cut back to DiCaprio getting put in the
- 18:03cruiser a couple nights before that.
- 18:05So you're, you're kind of constantly aware of the fact
- 18:08that like we're jumping around in time as it suits the story.
- 18:12Where I struggle with. Where I struggle with that is
- 18:15that in the prologue towards the end where like Sean Penn's
- 18:18character has like fallen madly in love with Perfidia 'cause he
- 18:23just attracted to her like raw whatever sex appeal.
- 18:27He drives his truck over to her house and he gets out of the
- 18:29truck and it's like a very modern truck, like it's a 2020
- 18:34truck. And then they show her escaping
- 18:37and she puts on AT shirt and the font on it.
- 18:40I can't remember. It was something that was
- 18:41popular a couple years ago that said like such and such club.
- 18:44It was a thing from like 2022. So I don't understand if they're
- 18:48just like not paying attention to the details of these scenes
- 18:51or if we're supposed to understand that she's been in
- 18:53witness protection for years and years and is just now escaping.
- 18:57I like there are things that seem a little bit sloppy and
- 19:02unexplained for a movie. To your point, that just does
- 19:06not concern itself with being subtle in any other area.
- 19:09Yeah, it what, what's it called? You have like a person on set
- 19:13that makes sure of like continuum.
- 19:15Is that the word? Yeah, yeah.
- 19:17Like continuity, Yeah. Continuity, thank you.
- 19:20That like, I know that that is like with a scene to make sure
- 19:23the person's seated the right way when you reshoot the next
- 19:26take, but like it feels like they needed somebody like that
- 19:30to be like, hey, this doesn't make sense for 2008.
- 19:33Like 'cause I had the same thought and I, and that's what
- 19:36felt so confusing about the 16 year time jump that I was like,
- 19:41wait, I thought this was like 30 or 40 years ago, but maybe it
- 19:44wasn't because she had a smartphone and I guess that
- 19:47would put him in this time period.
- 19:49But there was just stuff that and it's, it's little things
- 19:52like that that, you know, a lot of people would be like, well,
- 19:55why do you care? It's you know, it's just
- 19:56artistic and he's doing his thing.
- 19:57It's like within the world of the movie.
- 20:00I do want there to be some logic to it.
- 20:05That is such that I don't have to worry about it, that I, the
- 20:07viewer, don't have to be taken out of the experience to go,
- 20:10wait a second. I thought this was set in this
- 20:13year, but now they're in that year and and it just takes you
- 20:16out of the movie a little bit. Yeah, so like returning to the
- 20:20bigger question, 'cause, you know, I said, like, what
- 20:22percentage does the tone that we're going for work?
- 20:25And the first thing you said was like, I struggle with that first
- 20:28part of the movie. So that tells me that something
- 20:30about the second part of the movie must have worked a little
- 20:32bit better for you. Yeah, I think once you do the
- 20:35time jump and you have pothead Leo who doesn't remember all of
- 20:39his revolutionary stuff from there on out, I think the movie
- 20:43works like gangbusters. And I actually think that the
- 20:47movie works better if you completely cut out that first 45
- 20:51minutes. I think you just, you just add
- 20:54like like a 5 minute Leo telling his daughter his version that he
- 21:02wants her to believe of what happened.
- 21:05And it's like a pothead flashback.
- 21:07You kind of see things but you kind of don't.
- 21:10And it's 5 minutes And then throughout the rest of the movie
- 21:14you are finding out with Willa, his daughter, the truth of what
- 21:18happened back then. I think that makes for a way
- 21:21more fascinating movie about a young daughter trying to figure
- 21:25out her past, her inheritance, who she is and how she can
- 21:29connect with her father over this.
- 21:31It makes the revelation of Lockjaw as her.
- 21:34As her dad way. Different I, I, that's, that was
- 21:38my big take away. Just the structure of the film.
- 21:41I think you cut out those first 45 minutes and a, you get a much
- 21:45cleaner film. It's not 2 hours and 40 minutes
- 21:48long. And B, it gives you way more of
- 21:53a perspective from Willa and it makes her much more of the main
- 21:56character than Leo. And I think that that would
- 21:58actually work better. And I know better than Paul
- 22:01Thomas Anderson so well. Of course, I mean, you guys have
- 22:05won the same number of best director Oscars, so hey, you're
- 22:09on equal footing. Bro that was wow the dude PTA
- 22:15fanboys are going to be coming after you.
- 22:18I mean, not if he wins this year.
- 22:19It's in fact he hasn't won yet. You know, what are you gonna do
- 22:23now? I will say I've been thinking a
- 22:25lot about this too, because the movie really wants to be on some
- 22:28level this kind of like semi absurd, semi satirical, funny,
- 22:34dark comedy. And I actually think that this
- 22:36time around, now, I saw this in the theater, dead silent.
- 22:39Like, I just don't think anybody in the theater was on this
- 22:42movie's wavelength. Watching it at home a second
- 22:44time and knowing what, like, what he's trying for, I think
- 22:48was much more successful. I laughed a lot during this
- 22:50movie, and I thought most of the comedy was really well done.
- 22:54It also is very successful at like, raising dramatic stakes
- 23:00and crafting, like very tense sequences of like robberies and
- 23:05terrorism. And, you know, the chase scene
- 23:07at the end of the movie, there's no jokes happening in that
- 23:10stretch of the movie. Like, it really is just a a
- 23:12really good action scene. It's the melding of those two
- 23:16together or the lack of melding and the sort of juxtaposition
- 23:20from scene to scene, from moment to moment of like, here's a guy
- 23:24who's a buffoon and now he has to be a concerned dad.
- 23:27And we're taking him very seriously in his role as
- 23:29concerned dad, not as buffoon. And sometimes it just doesn't
- 23:33quite land those beats to me. And I've been thinking a lot
- 23:37about like, what's the overall theme?
- 23:39What what are we actually going for here because of that first
- 23:423545 minutes. And I do think that Paul Thomas
- 23:46Anderson is really making this movie as a 50 something dad with
- 23:50children who are about the age of Willa.
- 23:52And it's it's definitely a commentary on getting older.
- 23:55It's a commentary on being a parent and not understanding the
- 23:58world that your kids are coming up in and, and feeling helpless
- 24:01and like you don't have control over that world anymore.
- 24:04I think that all reads really, really well.
- 24:07And so if you look at it through that lens, the first part of the
- 24:10movie, I think it's about how like when you're 25 years old,
- 24:15everything you're doing is very serious to you.
- 24:19Like we are changing the world and like what we're doing is
- 24:22revolutionary. And then when you're 50 years
- 24:25old, maybe that maybe you still think that about your 25 year
- 24:28old self. Maybe you've changed in how you
- 24:30look at your 25 year old self, but there's a self-awareness in
- 24:34the character in PTA by putting this into the character of Bob
- 24:38that like I'm kind of a loser now.
- 24:41Like Bob just sits around and gets high and gets drunk and he
- 24:45has like no meaning or purpose to his life.
- 24:48He doesn't engage with society in any way.
- 24:50And it's kind of a question of like, what happens when you lose
- 24:55your purpose as a middle-aged person And that and through that
- 24:58lens, I think the movie is mostly successful even when it
- 25:03doesn't navigate the tone properly.
- 25:07And I think like, this is kind of jumping to my end point where
- 25:12I landed with this movie. I think that that right there is
- 25:15why this movie is a failure. I think he had such an
- 25:20incredible chance to show that the core of this movie is a man
- 25:27who finds his purpose in being a parent, in passing on his wisdom
- 25:32to a new generation and being active in his role in society so
- 25:37that he can show his daughter like, you know what?
- 25:39There is something of value that we can add to this society and
- 25:43it doesn't have to involve us enacting violence upon the
- 25:48world. And you see that at the end when
- 25:51he when he finally finds her and she comes out from behind the
- 25:55sign and they're on the highway together and he holds her.
- 25:58It's this beautiful moment of like, this is the important
- 26:02thing. It's not all the destruction and
- 26:05mayhem and chaos that the French 75 are causing upon the world or
- 26:10these racist old white men are causing upon the world.
- 26:13It's the beauty of a familial relationship.
- 26:17And then he goes straight into, he's back on the couch.
- 26:21He's a pothead loser that just smokes and drinks and can't
- 26:24figure out how to take a selfie. And she's the American girl who
- 26:29is fighting the revolution and continuing on what her mother
- 26:33did for her. And I was, I literally just sat
- 26:35back and was like, you just ruined your entire movie.
- 26:40Like absolutely ruined the entire movie for me because he
- 26:43had a chance to point towards something larger than the 1
- 26:49battle after another narrative. He had a chance to point to
- 26:52something eternal and instead he pointed back to like, Nope, you
- 26:55just need to be in the moment and fight the battle that you
- 26:58see in front of you and it's never going to end as a battle.
- 27:02And and it just was such a negative bull kind of ending to
- 27:07the movie that I was like, oh man.
- 27:11Like I I thought he could nail it.
- 27:12I thought he was going to land the plane and then it just.
- 27:15That's interesting. Yeah.
- 27:17I mean, I actually, I think that the the ending is kind of like
- 27:21for Paul Thomas Anderson. It's a very cheesy kind of
- 27:23ending, right. And even that needle drop of
- 27:24American Girl, I'm like, really. Like this is the most obvious
- 27:27thing. Like I said, it's not subtle, no
- 27:29subtlety. But then if you listen to what's
- 27:32happening in that final scene, you know, something comes over
- 27:34the ham radio and it's like something happened and there's
- 27:38going to be a protest. And they don't say like, we're
- 27:41gonna go blow up a bank like Perfidia did, you know?
- 27:44And I think so, like, they do adapt and, and I think Leo has
- 27:47realized that like that revolution and even Perfidia
- 27:51says like, we failed at changing the world through what we did.
- 27:54Leo's just on the couch now. He's like, I'm done with this
- 27:56revolution stuff. And his daughter's like, I
- 28:00actually want to fight what I perceive to be the battle of
- 28:03society right now, and I'm gonna do that.
- 28:05It seems to be through nonviolent means.
- 28:08So I never had a problem with that in particular.
- 28:10But I think that we're pointing at something here, which is
- 28:14like, how is this movie actually handling current events?
- 28:18And it's hard to talk about it without linking it to another
- 28:21film that came out last year called Eddington, which we
- 28:24talked really briefly about on this podcast.
- 28:26Eddington is a movie by Ari Astor who makes horror movies
- 28:30for the most part. And it gets even more kind of
- 28:33absurdist in how it views current events in the United
- 28:37States and slightly less funny and like less funny on the
- 28:41surface, I think. But they both are are trying to
- 28:45portray current events through this black comedy absurdist
- 28:49lens. I think because whether you're
- 28:52on the right side of the aisle or the left side of the aisle in
- 28:542026, I think we can all kind of agree that over the last 10-15
- 28:58years, America has kind of just become a cartoon.
- 29:01And it's really hard to talk about like, what is going on
- 29:05without trying to portray it in the most absurd light because
- 29:10reality now seems more absurd than it did 20 years ago.
- 29:14The problem is like, I don't know if I can blame the movies
- 29:17themselves or just like where we are as a society, but you almost
- 29:21need a more normal society and a more absurd movie because
- 29:26they're still too close together in terms of the tone for me to
- 29:30take it seriously as a satire. You know what I mean?
- 29:34Like, you and I were texting about Doctor Strangelove the
- 29:37other day. And I think that like when I
- 29:39think about a movie that is making satire of current events,
- 29:43I think about Doctor Strangelove where it's it's about nuclear
- 29:47weapons, but it's taking place in this alternate America.
- 29:52And yes, you do see like the archetypes of the the George C
- 29:55Scott character who's like. What's his name?
- 29:58Macho meathead guy. And then you've got like the ex
- 30:01Nazi Kissinger guy in the like. There's definitely parallels,
- 30:05but it's so much more absurd and the names are even more absurd
- 30:09than the pension names where the president's name is Merkin
- 30:12Muffley. Like it's just because you get
- 30:14it, the president's a pussy. Brad, do you understand the
- 30:16reference Like? That's what we're saying here.
- 30:19And I feel like this movie is like just one tick less
- 30:25satirical and I wish that it was either not satirical at all or
- 30:30just slightly more satirical because the tone wobbles a
- 30:34little bit. Yeah, it, it does.
- 30:38And I, I would say for me, when the world starts to feel really
- 30:43absurd, I think it's because as a society, we've lost touch with
- 30:48what we believe collectively about like the eternal truths of
- 30:52the world that we as a society, even with all of our different
- 30:56viewpoints, are working with the same set of like rules and
- 31:01truths and stories that we're telling about the world.
- 31:05And so when the world becomes really absurd, I think it's
- 31:07because you have people who believe very deeply different
- 31:11things about the purpose of humanity are living together in
- 31:15close quarters, not that America is close quarters.
- 31:20And so I think a movie like this just plays into that even more
- 31:24where it's just like, yeah, life is absurd and you just have to
- 31:28fight the battle in front of you.
- 31:30And it's going to be just one battle after another.
- 31:32And and like he gives, he gives away.
- 31:36The end Reality of that is like, Willa is going to be a 50 year
- 31:40old someday laying on the couch smoking pot, going, ah, man, we
- 31:46didn't accomplish the revolution that we thought we would.
- 31:49And that like, there's this weird obsession with young
- 31:52people in the movie of like, well, we old people screwed up
- 31:55and we're just going to smoke pot now.
- 31:57And Perfidia has given up on her dream of revolution.
- 32:00And we're just going to let the young people do it.
- 32:02And we're going to kind of like weirdly worship the young people
- 32:05and be like, yeah, these young people, they're going to figure
- 32:07it out. And I just, I just very deeply
- 32:12feel like that's a bad vision of the world.
- 32:16That's not a healthy vision of the world to me.
- 32:18The healthy vision is Leo at the end of the movie, realizes the
- 32:23cost of his decades of pot smoking, beer drinking,
- 32:30abdication of responsibility. And he goes, you know what?
- 32:34I'm going to take responsibility for my life.
- 32:35I'm going to take responsibility for my daughter's life while
- 32:37she's still in my home. And we're going to do something
- 32:41productive in the world. And instead he just continues to
- 32:45abdicate his responsibility because life is absurd.
- 32:49And we're just going to let the children figure it out.
- 32:51And that to me just. Yeah, no, I mean, I I do think
- 32:56it's funny because like I have like very major issues with this
- 32:59movie. This is just not one of them.
- 33:00And I think that like I just take a different read on the
- 33:02end, which is like. The funny The funny thing is,
- 33:05Bob, I actually really like this movie other than the first 45
- 33:09minutes. The movie itself within the
- 33:13world it sets up, I think, I think it's a really good movie.
- 33:17It's really funny at different points and he gets his point
- 33:20across really effectively. I think that's why I started all
- 33:23this by saying this is kind of my end point of like, at the end
- 33:27of the day, I just deeply disagree with the vision of how
- 33:32we as humans ought to live that Paul Thomas Anderson lands on.
- 33:36I think he gets there really effectively and I I think it's a
- 33:39really funny movie. Yeah, I agree.
- 33:42And and, you know, just to put a pin in this particular
- 33:45conversation, I just view the end more as like an
- 33:48acknowledgement that that life is that goes in these kind of
- 33:51cycles and there's seasons to life.
- 33:53And I, I actually was very encouraged by the fact that I
- 33:56think the argument he's making is like, hey, guess what, old
- 33:59people who missed your chance to do real change in the world.
- 34:03We actually do at some point have to acknowledge that it's
- 34:06time for us to recede into the background and that the world
- 34:09that we're leaving to our kids at some point has to be turned
- 34:11over to those kids. And it's like, it's
- 34:13acknowledgement of like, the kids are going to be our rights.
- 34:16She has a good head on her shoulders.
- 34:18You can't control what happens in the world.
- 34:20And I don't know. And especially juxtaposing that
- 34:24against like, the guys in the Christmas club or whatever it's
- 34:26called, where it's like they're all between 50 and 95 years old.
- 34:30And it's like these old men trying to control the world.
- 34:34I don't think that we should all abdicate responsibility and
- 34:37smoke pot instead. But I do think it's it.
- 34:40It makes a point that like even its dumbest, most buffoonish
- 34:44character understand something that like, these powerful guys
- 34:48don't understand. Do you know what I mean?
- 34:50I I know what you're saying. I just deeply disagree.
- 34:53Like it'd be what? It'd be one thing if Leonardo
- 34:56DiCaprio was 90 years old and he's like, all right, let's let
- 34:59the kids handle it. He's like 50, 45 in this movie.
- 35:04He's 42 according to the lie he told to the people at the jail,
- 35:10which I don't know, maybe he gave them the correct age.
- 35:12But then at the end of the movie when they flash back to the
- 35:15three of them in bed together when the when Will is an infant
- 35:19and you see all of Leo's like neck rolls that a man that's
- 35:22clearly 50 years old has, but he's playing 26.
- 35:25It's like, oh, I don't usually add like I don't advocate for
- 35:29CGI that often, but like, let's clean up that jowl situation a
- 35:32little bit. PTA.
- 35:33Totally. I, I think what I'm trying to
- 35:36say is that I hope we don't give up on our ability to enact
- 35:41change in the world when we're 42 or 50 or however old he is in
- 35:46the movie. I personally prefer a vision of
- 35:50the world where people who are middle-aged and older and
- 35:56younger all work together to make the world a better place.
- 36:00And the older people share their wisdom with the younger people.
- 36:04And sometimes they say, yeah, like, I love your passion for
- 36:07the world. Maybe let's slow down a little
- 36:08bit and think about the consequences of our actions and
- 36:12think about the fact that if you get caught doing this thing and
- 36:15you get thrown into prison, like it will change your life in a
- 36:19very negative way. And how do we work within the
- 36:23system to enact change in a healthy way that isn't violent
- 36:28and and broken? And I just, like I said, it's
- 36:32the vision of the movie that I'm like, I'm out the the world is,
- 36:37the world is not run by racist people who are out to get you.
- 36:41And because they're out to get you, you have a right to
- 36:44violently defend yourself. Like that is something I just
- 36:48deeply disagree with. I think that's actually a really
- 36:50dangerous way to view the world. So.
- 36:53Do you think that that that's actually what PTA thinks is
- 36:56happening or are we just using metaphors for like the struggle
- 37:01that young people have and parents have?
- 37:04So that's, so that's the other big frustration I have with the
- 37:08movie philosophically, is that when you are making a movie that
- 37:13like very clearly is about real life modern events, like even
- 37:18set 16 years ago, like for better or for worse, there were
- 37:24not revolutionaries in 2008 who really cared deeply about
- 37:28immigrant rights. Like there's some, but that
- 37:30wasn't the big thing we were worried about in 2008.
- 37:33The big thing we were worried about in 2008 was The Big Short,
- 37:36right? So very clearly, even in the
- 37:40past, he is making it about what's going on here.
- 37:43In 20252026. When you are doing a movie that
- 37:47is very clearly about real world events and you also make it a
- 37:52dark comedy and a satire, I feel like you are hindering your
- 37:59ability to make any statements about what's going on.
- 38:03Because the whole time you have to ask the question like, well,
- 38:05is the way he makes fun of comrade Josh for needing a safe
- 38:11space, like is he being serious about that?
- 38:13Is he actually, is that an actual message he's trying to
- 38:16make? Or is it just a joke?
- 38:18Are the, are the racist old white men, the, the, the
- 38:21Christmas nightclub are like, are they serious?
- 38:24Is he actually saying that there's a cabal of evil white
- 38:28men ruling the world? Or is it, oh, it's just another
- 38:30joke? And I feel like that's a, that's
- 38:32a cop out on Paul Thomas Anderson's part to be like, you
- 38:37know, if somebody approaches him and is like, like, do you
- 38:39actually think that the world is run by racist old white men?
- 38:42He can just be like, no, of course I don't.
- 38:44It was a comedy. And, and, and it just by making
- 38:48it a comedy, he kind of takes away any punch from his own
- 38:52viewpoint. And I I wish that he just made
- 38:54it a straight drama. I'm wondering though, like,
- 38:56can't you say that to some extent about every satire?
- 38:59So like take Doctor Strangelove where you have, you know, like
- 39:02the the inciting incident of Doctor Strangelove is this
- 39:05general loses it. And because of the way the
- 39:09military is set up and the lack of fail safes in the nuclear
- 39:13arsenal system, the dominoes fall in a very specific way.
- 39:17And it happens, you know, comedically, right.
- 39:20But like, I do think they're getting at something in the the
- 39:23character of the crazed Colonel or general or whatever his name
- 39:26is. That's like, I think we're, you
- 39:29know, we're a little aggressive as a military in 1964.
- 39:33And we're going to pitch that up a little bit so that people will
- 39:36recognize the absurdity here, but also reapply that back to
- 39:40what we see in everyday life. That's satire.
- 39:43Yeah. I'm kind of wondering, are we at
- 39:45a point now as a country where we're like, beyond the efficacy
- 39:51of satire? Like, does satire just not work
- 39:54on us anymore because we are so aligned with our political
- 39:59identities that anytime anyone tries to do something satirical
- 40:03about either party, we only see what we want to see and we take
- 40:07offense to the things we want to take offense to instead of
- 40:11engaging the satire on its own rights and asking like.
- 40:16What is like, does this actually get at something wrong with our
- 40:19society that needs fixed? Like I just wonder if we skip
- 40:22the the self reflective part sometimes and go right to like
- 40:29it needs to be more balanced. It needs to attack the left and
- 40:31the right or, or whatever it might be.
- 40:33And I think, you know, to your point, this happens on both
- 40:35sides now. Like, you know, the identity
- 40:38politics is a real thing and I think it's killed our ability to
- 40:41be self reflective. And I, I think what I would say
- 40:46about satire losing its efficacy and power in our current
- 40:52culture, I would say that it's lost its power because we are
- 40:56such a cynical society. I think satire works a lot
- 40:59better when you have really sincere people who believe in
- 41:03the world that they live in, and then you satirize something that
- 41:07might not be great about the world they live in.
- 41:09And because we are sincere about the world we live in, we can
- 41:13recognize a satire go. He's obviously making a
- 41:16statement about how ridiculous this is.
- 41:20But when we look at our own world, it's like, OK, maybe
- 41:22there is a point being made because we're so cynical.
- 41:26We've already thought of the points they're trying to make
- 41:29about the other side. Usually before he ever made the
- 41:33satire. And we were.
- 41:35Already defending them too. And we were already defending
- 41:37them. And so it's like, yeah, like the
- 41:39satire doesn't hit home because I've already thought bad things
- 41:44about the other side or, or not thought bad things, put bad
- 41:47intentions behind the other side.
- 41:50And I have to say, like when Paul Thomas Anderson makes this
- 41:54movie, he does make fun of the left and the right, but he makes
- 41:58fun of the left by going, you need a safe space.
- 42:02You're such a, you're such a snowflake.
- 42:05And he makes fun of the right by saying they are racist evil
- 42:11cabal of monsters that are trying to control the society
- 42:16through racist means. Those don't feel like even
- 42:20satire to me. Like if you were if you had to
- 42:23be called a snowflake or racist monster Bob, which one would you
- 42:28prefer to be satirized into? I I get it, man.
- 42:31I also do think that, like, you know, satire usually attacks
- 42:35whoever's in power in the moment right now because PTA probably
- 42:40aligns more with the left. Like would he be making this
- 42:43movie in an Obama era? Probably not because he you're
- 42:46right about there is identity politics there.
- 42:48I guess the question then is, like for my left-leaning
- 42:51friends, like, will you accept a satirical comedy about the left
- 42:58more at face value than you see right wing people taking movies
- 43:03like 1 Battle After Another or Eddington?
- 43:06And I think that, like, that's a challenge to the left, right.
- 43:09Like, you have to allow people to speak what they've perceived
- 43:13to be truth to power, whether that's through, you know,
- 43:16lampooning them or taking things really seriously.
- 43:19And Brad, I think it's about time for us to get to our break.
- 43:22So let me just say like 1 Battle After Another, a very funny
- 43:26movie that I think we need to talk about more as a movie when
- 43:29we return. I'm glad we got the big picture
- 43:31conversation out of the way because I just want to talk
- 43:33about like Leo and Benicio Del Toro and Sean Penn when we come
- 43:37back from break. But before we get there, let's
- 43:40try this Green River. We did foolproof.
- 43:43What do you say? I noticed, Bob, that you only
- 43:45talked about men and that, you know those three people you
- 43:48named like what is there? Is there something there we
- 43:51don't like? The women When?
- 43:52You can tell me what time it is. You can call me back, Brad.
- 43:58Let's let's drink that whiskey, Bob.
- 44:05All right, so today we're checking out Green River
- 44:08Foolproof Weeded Bourbon. Now we have had many a whiskey
- 44:12from Green River in the past couple years.
- 44:15We have a good friend that works down there, Aaron Harris, their
- 44:17master distiller, and their latest offering is this Green
- 44:20River Foolproof Weeded Bourbon. Now, they've done their regular
- 44:25bourbon as a foolproof before, but then the weeded bourbon won
- 44:29best overall whiskey at the New York Spirits competition this
- 44:32year. And so they said, well, hey,
- 44:34it's time for us to expand this product line as well.
- 44:37So now we're getting a weeded foolproof.
- 44:40I'll give some quick stats on it, Brad, and then I want your
- 44:42thoughts. It says that this is going to be
- 44:44a variable batch proof ranging from one O 9 to 116.
- 44:50So this initial batch is at one O 9.3 proof or 54.65 ABV and it
- 44:57ranges between 5:00 and seven years.
- 44:59In terms of the distillate we're getting here, 71% corn, no 70%
- 45:04corn, 21% wheat, 9% malted barley in the mash bill and MSRP
- 45:10on this, Brad, you're going to love this 14999.
- 45:15Dude, I, I mean, I will say, unfortunately we've hit a point
- 45:19where 50 bucks for like mid, mid level, mid tier whiskey is like,
- 45:26yeah, no, that's 50 bucks Now. It makes my, my miserly heart
- 45:30sad, but honestly, it's a, it's honestly a good price.
- 45:33I I'm I'm being mostly facetious.
- 45:38Now I I will say the the best thing we've tried by far from
- 45:41Green River is their foolproof of their regular bourbon.
- 45:44So I'm really looking forward to this one because I've kind of
- 45:46gone back and forth on their weeded mash bill before.
- 45:49It seems like it's a hit among other people with all the awards
- 45:51it's winning, but I'm excited to dive into this one.
- 45:54Brad, Now, I know you've already tried it.
- 45:56I have not. So I'm going to be sipping it
- 45:58live and you're at least doing it for show here.
- 46:00So why don't you give us your notes on the nose here, Brad?
- 46:03I mean it, it might be a good indication of how I feel about
- 46:05it if I poured myself another DRAM.
- 46:08That's true. I will say on the nose, this has
- 46:11a really potent cherry syrup bomb It, it has a lot of cherry
- 46:16on it. The vanilla is there.
- 46:18There's a little bit of brown sugar.
- 46:21I feel like I got like a little bit of a woody cinnamon, like
- 46:24maybe a cedar vibe going on. It's a really pleasant nose.
- 46:29The cherry is like tipping on the edge.
- 46:32Like I said, cherry syrup. It's tipping on the edge of
- 46:36cherry cough syrup for me. So I like, I'm holding off a
- 46:39little bit. It's a 7.5.
- 46:41I I really like the nose a lot. I'm just curious to see where it
- 46:44goes. Yeah, I think I'm going to land
- 46:46at a 7 out of 10 here, Brad. And that that might even be a
- 46:49little bit lower than I want to go, but it's a gut reaction.
- 46:53I had this poured and sitting here for about 5 minutes, I
- 46:55raised it to my nose and it was this very like syrupy Maple
- 47:00brown sugar and cherry. And then I kind of just swished
- 47:04it around in my glass and agitated it a little bit.
- 47:06And I got some notes that are like just slightly concerning
- 47:09here. Like it's, it's not, it doesn't
- 47:12smell like it's going to be really viscous.
- 47:14It has like a sort of thinner, more aggressive, more alcohol
- 47:16forward nose. And then it has this note
- 47:19underneath that that's characteristic of like younger
- 47:22whiskey, like 2 year whiskey. It just the little bit of
- 47:25grassiness and like a, a lack of maturity in the grains here.
- 47:29So even though it's five to seven years, I'm kind of prep
- 47:33preparing myself for a little bit of harshness on the palate
- 47:35here. So I'm going to get ahead of
- 47:37that by giving it just a 7 on the nose.
- 47:39I think on the palate, I, I know that the brand's not Hostess,
- 47:42but, you know, like the little fruit pies in the box.
- 47:45Oh, yeah. In like the Hostess section of
- 47:48the gas station. This reminds me of a cherry pie,
- 47:51like one of those really cheap cherry pies that's sugary and
- 47:55delicious and like immediately clogs the arteries.
- 48:00The taste really reminds me of that.
- 48:01There's a lot of vanilla on the palate and the graininess that
- 48:05you were talking about Bob comes through in like a very
- 48:08unflavored cream of wheat cereal, like hot cereal that
- 48:13it's it's got this creaminess, this wheatiness that isn't bad.
- 48:18It's not uplifting it to a super high height.
- 48:21I do like this a lot. I think it's a really pleasure,
- 48:24full, interesting whiskey that doesn't have a lot of richness
- 48:29or depth around it. So I am.
- 48:30I'm gonna stick it a 7.5 for the palate.
- 48:34Yeah, I'm a little surprised at how kind of herbal and bitter
- 48:38this stays on the palate and it kind of spreads out across my
- 48:41mid palate and right on the edge of my tongue.
- 48:44I get like this really bitter note.
- 48:46And I took two sips just to make sure you do get acclimated to
- 48:49it. And there does become like a
- 48:51little bit of fattiness to it that I didn't think would be
- 48:54there. But overall, I do think it's a
- 48:56thinner, more aggressive mouthfeel than I would like it
- 48:59to be. It's not as it's not as fruity
- 49:02and it's not as sweet as some other weeded bourbons that it's
- 49:05now going to be competing against in the market.
- 49:08A much darker cherry note, a much more bitter herbal note
- 49:12here. Like you said, I think it's well
- 49:14made, but I think I'm just going to give it a 7 out of 10 again,
- 49:19Brad. I think the finish is where I
- 49:22fall to a 7 out of 10. The finish is weirdly short,
- 49:27like for a one O 9 proof whiskey I expected to have a little more
- 49:31staying power. It's a little bit short.
- 49:34The weak rain really comes through now.
- 49:37The cherry flavor does sit with you for a little bit.
- 49:40So it's still it's a weeded whiskey through and through.
- 49:43I'll give it a 7 out of 10 on the finish.
- 49:45Just not enough there to push it over the finish line.
- 49:49Yeah, I think this is really where the barrel char becomes
- 49:52prominent. But then also it has notes of
- 49:54like a toasted barrel as well. That sort of bitter oak that we
- 49:57get on toasted finishes a lot. Again, like if this is your
- 50:01wheelhouse, if you like a a sort of tannic, unsweet black tea
- 50:07note on your bourbon, and this is like right up your alley.
- 50:12I don't know if I would peg this immediately as a weeded bourbon
- 50:14if you put it in front of me, Brad.
- 50:16Aside from that kind of dark cherry note, it doesn't have
- 50:19that characteristic sweetness to it that we typically associate
- 50:22with weeded bourbons. And it it's not especially soft
- 50:25on the palate either. So like if you had told me this
- 50:27was a high rye bourbon that had notes of cherry in it, I'd
- 50:31probably believe you. Again, I think it's well made,
- 50:34but I also think I'm probably just going to be at A7 across
- 50:37the board on this whiskey. Yeah, So balance wise, I'll give
- 50:41it a 7.5. I think that despite the fact
- 50:45that I'm like a tiny bit let down, I think I was hoping for a
- 50:47little more. I I think this is a well
- 50:49balanced whiskey. They give you the flavor profile
- 50:52you're looking for and there's there's no surprises for me.
- 50:56So 7.5 on balance. Yeah, I'll do the same.
- 50:59I'll come up to a 7.5. I do think this is like a three
- 51:01out of four-star kind of a whiskey and that takes us into
- 51:04value where I'm trying to balance much like Paul Thomas
- 51:08Anderson, the actual quality of the whiskey or like my enjoyment
- 51:14of the whiskey versus like is it fairly priced?
- 51:16Regardless of what I think, and I think it is fairly priced,
- 51:19$50.00 for a foolproof bourbon is like very much in line with
- 51:24the market and probably a little better than the market.
- 51:26I do not like this as much as the regular foolproof and and
- 51:30kind of by a considerable margin.
- 51:32So I'm going to give it a 7.5 on value again to kind of indicate
- 51:37that three out of four stars like it's it's worthwhile.
- 51:40It's just not for me. That's so funny, Bob.
- 51:43So I gave almost everything a higher score than you, and yet
- 51:47I'm going to give it a 6.5 on value.
- 51:49Oh wow. Like I, I think this is a good
- 51:51whiskey. I think $50.00 is a decent price
- 51:54point. I just think that there's other
- 51:56really good options at this price point that kind of push
- 52:00the value down for me a little bit.
- 52:02So I'm, I'm at a 6.5 on value. I am coming out to a total of 36
- 52:08out of 50. I am also coming out to a total
- 52:12of 36 out of 50, so we're at a 72 out of 100.
- 52:16I love how we balance each other on this podcast.
- 52:18Man, this is perfect, Bob. This is just over that line.
- 52:22Typically around 35 is where we'll start giving like a soft
- 52:25recommend. The closer you get to 40, it's a
- 52:27pretty solid recommendation. And then over 40 is just a darn
- 52:30good whiskey. This is solid, and I think it's
- 52:33boosted, at least for me, by the fact that it's not $80.00,
- 52:36right? $50.00 is a fair price to charge
- 52:39for this. If you are in the liquor store
- 52:42and you see the weeded foolproof next to the regular foolproof,
- 52:46take the regular foolproof all day.
- 52:47That's one of the best values in the world of bourbon and I think
- 52:51they could charge way more than they are at that $50 price
- 52:54point. This one's like, I'm glad I
- 52:57tried it, it's just not for me. Yeah, I I think I'm with you.
- 53:00The regular foolproof Green River is one of the best
- 53:03bourbons on the market right now.
- 53:05Go get yourself a bottle. If you really like weeded
- 53:08whiskies, like go give this a try.
- 53:10It's 50 bucks. You could maybe find a pour of
- 53:12it at the bar for like 8 bucks. It it would be worth a try.
- 53:16I think this is a recommend from me, but definitely the regular
- 53:21foolproof bourbon is where it's at.
- 53:24Now, Brad, while we're talking about alcohol, I do have to
- 53:26bring up a a, a major part of this film, which is the French
- 53:2970 fives, yes, which are named after one of Bob Book's most
- 53:34favoritest cocktails in the whole world.
- 53:37You've you've had a French 70 fives.
- 53:39I have not dude. So listen, New Year's Eve is one
- 53:43of the few times that my wife and I will will do anything
- 53:46alcohol related together, especially around our children.
- 53:48But we'll get a nice bubbly, right?
- 53:50So if 75, you essentially make like a gin sour.
- 53:55So it's like an ounce of gin, lemon juice and simple syrup and
- 54:00you top it off with sparkling wine of some sort.
- 54:03So it's like a champagne cocktail and you get just a
- 54:05little bit of that like herbaceousness and bitters from
- 54:09the gin. And when I tell you like my, my
- 54:13family all went to bed around 1:00 in the morning and I had
- 54:16half a bottle of Prosecco left and I was like, I'm going to
- 54:18make 6 French 70 fives right now and just sit here and watch,
- 54:22watch movies. It is phenomenal.
- 54:25So folks, if you're not feeling the Green River or the whiskey
- 54:27this week, I would highly recommend trying out a couple
- 54:30French 70 fives. They're a really fun drink.
- 54:33Yeah, have at it, man. What say you though, Bob?
- 54:36Are you ready to go back to battle?
- 54:39Let's do it man. Let's get back into talking
- 54:41about 1 battle after another. All right, everybody, That was
- 54:50Green River weeded bourbon. Foolproof.
- 54:53A whiskey that just didn't quite make the grade for us.
- 54:58Is that fair to say? Almost made the grade like.
- 55:02It's like it's. Like over that mark, but it's
- 55:04like a very soft recommendation for me.
- 55:06Although we probably shouldn't start this old battle back again
- 55:11regarding Bob's idiotic take on the grading system, we will
- 55:15leave that battle in the past and we will move back into the
- 55:19weekly battle that is 2 facts and a falsehood, Brad.
- 55:24Is going to try to stump your ball.
- 55:27To. Our right and what is wrong?
- 55:322 facts and a falsehood. 2 facts and a falsehood is the part of
- 55:35the show where Brad presents me with three items as.
- 55:39Fact. About the making of this movie,
- 55:41one of which is a complete lie and I have to figure out which
- 55:44one that is. Now Brad I, I started keeping
- 55:48tally on this season. I have not caught myself back
- 55:50up. I promise I will have a final
- 55:52record before our movie Sinners next week so we could see where
- 55:56I'm sitting. I have a feeling I'm below 500
- 55:59on the season. You.
- 56:00You've done a really good job on this.
- 56:02I appreciate that. I think that you are at like
- 56:0911:50 wins if I had to follow my gut.
- 56:13Yikes. That's that's kind of rough.
- 56:15I will say while we're talking about games, you know, we
- 56:17participated again this season in a thing called the Movies
- 56:20Fantasy League with Vulture Magazine.
- 56:23And when I go to their leaderboard each week and I
- 56:25click through to the podcasters division, of which there are
- 56:29probably like 100 to 200 people in there, your boy is sitting at
- 56:333rd place among the podcasters right now.
- 56:36I would say. Primarily because I chose I
- 56:39chose 1 battle after another as part of my team, so I'm doing
- 56:42pretty well man. Bob, I'm not going to lie within
- 56:46our podcast division, which is just you and me and some fans of
- 56:49the Film with Whiskey podcast, guess who's in second place,
- 56:52Bob? That's right.
- 56:54And. Overall, you're in like 30
- 56:56thousandth place. That is not true.
- 56:58Every week I check it I'm like 5800 out of I think it's like
- 57:0335,000 people signed up. So I'm just saying compared to
- 57:08years past in this league, I am knocking it out of the park.
- 57:13Do you know what I chose as my my username for this season?
- 57:16What's that? One barrel after another I boom,
- 57:20I get it. I see what you did.
- 57:21Somebody had already taken 1 bottle after another.
- 57:24I was like, oh that. Dude, that was all.
- 57:27Right, dude, let's get into our two I'm.
- 57:28Going to go all for the day. I'm going to go all perfidia
- 57:31Beverly Hills on your ass. All right, fact number one.
- 57:40There are a number of allusions to parts of the novel Vineland
- 57:45that were not adapted. Early in the film, we see Willa
- 57:48playing in the field outside her trailer park home with a dog
- 57:51while Bob notices a helicopter flying high above them, which is
- 57:54a gag that alludes to the climactic events of the book
- 57:57that are otherwise excised from this from the film adaptation.
- 58:03Fact #2 The exterior of the mansion where the Christmas
- 58:07Adventurers Club meets was the home of Ronald Reagan in
- 58:12Sacramento when he was the governor of California.
- 58:14Fact #3 Paul Thomas Anderson named Perfidia Beverly Hills in
- 58:19part after an aunt he remembered from growing up in the San
- 58:23Fernando Valley. The aunt was a quote fiery
- 58:26smoker who lived in Beverly Hills.
- 58:29I have no idea, man. This is a good one, Brad,
- 58:33because I don't know which falsehood is fueled by your
- 58:37vengeful hate for the left. I kind of feel like I love the
- 58:44Ronald Reagan fact because like, I don't care what side of the
- 58:50political aisle you're on. Like, that's kind of funny that
- 58:52they would make that, you know what I mean?
- 58:54But I also feel like, you know, that I would think that's funny,
- 58:57and that's why you would totally make that up.
- 58:58I like making up good facts. I don't know if Perfidia Beverly
- 59:03Hills is a made-up character though, or if or if she was part
- 59:07of Vineland. I'm going to go ahead and assume
- 59:08number one is true because as I've said, I have not read
- 59:11Vineland so I have no idea. So if you got me there, you got
- 59:14me there. But you also haven't read it, so
- 59:16you know. I love I love the the Internet
- 59:20world of like. I don't know if this is true or
- 59:23not. I have no experience with it, so
- 59:24I'll assume that it's true. Well, it's more like the only
- 59:29ones that I even have an inkling about.
- 59:31I want to put my chips on those. And if I lose that way, I'm I'm.
- 59:35I feel better doing that than like you tricked me on a book I
- 59:38haven't read that doesn't feel totally, I'm gonna say #2 is
- 59:42false, but I have no idea, Brad. Bob, this was not fueled by my
- 59:50far right ridiculous hatred of the left.
- 59:55It was. It was.
- 59:57That was that was the truth. That is some that was real.
- 1:00:01Was it really? Yes, that's funny, dude.
- 1:00:06When I saw it, I was like, A, that's kind of funny, but B,
- 1:00:09that feels really disrespectful to a former president.
- 1:00:13Like it's it's cool to disrespect presidents who are
- 1:00:15sitting or like just out. But like, you know, I'm not
- 1:00:19going to make fun of Jimmy Carter.
- 1:00:20Like, come on. That's true.
- 1:00:24That's true. I Bob, I am with you if if you
- 1:00:28are a person of left lefter leaning orientation, I am sure
- 1:00:33that that's one of the funniest jokes that you could funniest
- 1:00:37like behind the scenes little that's like wow, exactly I'm
- 1:00:42like I I recognize the humor and I'm also like that feels really
- 1:00:47wildly insulting. Wait, So what was the falsehood?
- 1:00:51The falsehood was fact #3 that he named Perfidia after his
- 1:00:54aunt. Was Perfidia a character in the
- 1:00:56book? I don't know.
- 1:00:59I do know that he was indeed from San Fernando Valley.
- 1:01:04Yeah, I do. That is true.
- 1:01:06That is true. So that's, see, I knew I was
- 1:01:08like if I just put one little thing in there.
- 1:01:13OK, listen, I want to start our conversation after taking my L
- 1:01:16here about Paul Thomas Anderson, the bastard who owes me a new
- 1:01:20car and I I have been reckoning for a long time with a couple
- 1:01:26different things. Number one is my up and down
- 1:01:30relationship with his films because I think that he has made
- 1:01:34some true masterpieces and some of the best films of the
- 1:01:38century. And I also think that his miss
- 1:01:41rate is a lot higher than people admit that it is like he
- 1:01:45definitely takes swings. He definitely has a tone in
- 1:01:49mind. And especially with his comedies
- 1:01:52like you, you look at a movie like Punch Drunk Love with Adam
- 1:01:55Sandler, that is a movie that I have just never vibed with.
- 1:01:57I cannot get on that movie's wavelength.
- 1:02:00It's an hour and a half long and it it feels like it's three
- 1:02:03hours long to me. And then you have a movie like
- 1:02:06Inherent Vice, which is a more absurdist comedy, which falls
- 1:02:10kind of in the camp with this one, and I think much less
- 1:02:14successfully. So you could make the argument
- 1:02:16that Licorice Pizza is a comedy. I don't even think I would say
- 1:02:19that I think Licorice Pizza is just like a hangout movie that
- 1:02:23funny and dramatic stuff happens in.
- 1:02:26But he's a guy that's like he has really spanned the
- 1:02:29transcendently great to very good to like.
- 1:02:33This did not work at all for me range.
- 1:02:37And that leads me into the second thing I struggle with
- 1:02:40with him, which is that I think he's become kind of lionized and
- 1:02:44and in a lot of ways the patron St. of the modern film bro,
- 1:02:49where he's achieved like Kubrick territory.
- 1:02:52So like he starts out in the late 90s and he's making
- 1:02:55independent films. He he bursts on the scene with
- 1:02:58this movie called Hard 8, gets a little bit of funding and makes
- 1:03:01Boogie Nights. And Boogie Nights is like, it's
- 1:03:03controversial because it's about porn, but it's also like it's
- 1:03:06just Goodfellas set in the porn world and it's it's it's
- 1:03:10Scorsese RIP off. Then he makes Magnolia, which is
- 1:03:13this big messy magnum opus and he takes a couple years off.
- 1:03:17He comes back with Punch Drunk Love, which is really divisive.
- 1:03:20Then he's like, I'm out for a little while.
- 1:03:22I have overexposed myself. I've been, he's on, he's doing a
- 1:03:25ton of cocaine and he was like spouting off his mouth and he
- 1:03:28had a God complex. When you say overexposed, you
- 1:03:31mean like I? Mean, maybe, I don't know, takes
- 1:03:35five years off and comes back with there will be blood.
- 1:03:37And it's like, is this the greatest movie I've ever made?
- 1:03:40I don't know. Paul Thomas Anderson immediately
- 1:03:42jumped from like talented guy with a God complex to like
- 1:03:46actual movie God in people's eyes now.
- 1:03:49And he's been atop that pedestal since then.
- 1:03:52And when you get atop that pedestal like a Kubrick, you can
- 1:03:55explore your own idiosyncrasies and get a pass for them.
- 1:04:00And I think that that happens a lot with PTA and it happens in
- 1:04:03this film bro culture we have now where it's like, it's it's
- 1:04:08cool to like be in the Criterion Collection and it's cool to know
- 1:04:13about aspect ratios and IMAX and things like this.
- 1:04:16And so PTA is like this patron St. that is like idolized in the
- 1:04:22movie bro culture now. And it just bothers me when we
- 1:04:26have film makers who have achieved a status where they
- 1:04:29they seem to be beyond not just reproach, but any criticism
- 1:04:34because I think that this is a flawed, messy movie.
- 1:04:37That is, I'm still positive on In the Balance, but it's hard to
- 1:04:43talk about people like PTA when it feels like you're fighting an
- 1:04:47uphill battle just to offer any criticisms of his films.
- 1:04:52Yeah, absolutely. The the reality is a lot of
- 1:04:57times when people die is when the opinion on their work is
- 1:05:01more cemented and you know, it's, it's still a little bit
- 1:05:04wet. You still have some people who
- 1:05:06vary, but it feels like that's when we lionize people.
- 1:05:10And for that to happen when somebody's still alive and not
- 1:05:13just still alive, but still actively making films, it feels
- 1:05:17like you're not allowed to engage in healthy discourse
- 1:05:21around their work in a way that you can around all these other
- 1:05:26directors that that are making movies.
- 1:05:29And so I I'm kind of with you, Bob.
- 1:05:31Now I will say I have seen there will be blood licorice pizza 1
- 1:05:37battle after another. So like my exposure to PTA is,
- 1:05:41is very limited. You know, three of his, what, 10
- 1:05:45films? I, I would be very curious to
- 1:05:47see the master at that. There's something about his
- 1:05:50exploration of Colts in that movie that I'm like, I don't
- 1:05:53know, I'm curious to see his take on that.
- 1:05:57I, I did see a lot of licorice pizza in this movie.
- 1:06:01There are like hangout moments when Willa is in the bathroom,
- 1:06:06just the way he shot those girls in the bathroom.
- 1:06:08I was like, oh, we're back at Licorice Pizza, like, like right
- 1:06:12back to it. But then he also the at the end
- 1:06:16of the film when he is filming the car chase, it felt very
- 1:06:21deeply like a 1960s Hitchcockian.
- 1:06:26Like filming the chase from one person's point of view, then
- 1:06:29another person's point of view. The camera like rising up and
- 1:06:33down with the road felt like a bullet type of movie.
- 1:06:37There was so much about this movie that I'm like, I think he
- 1:06:40did a really good job for me. To get to your point about being
- 1:06:45able to critique PTAI think the script is what's messy and the
- 1:06:50script is what kind of keeps us back.
- 1:06:53I think PTA as a mover of the camera, as a creator of action
- 1:06:58scenes, I, I think he's a really great director in a lot of those
- 1:07:02ways, and you see that on display here.
- 1:07:06I mean, I think one of the one of the criticisms I gave of
- 1:07:09There Will Be Blood, which I don't know if we've talked in
- 1:07:12the last year. Last year Regal showed a whole
- 1:07:15bunch of classic movies for like a month straight.
- 1:07:18Man, I went and saw There Will Be Blood in the theater for the
- 1:07:20first time since 2007 and I was like, OK, never mind.
- 1:07:23Like all my criticisms, pretty much gone.
- 1:07:25Gone. I do feel like as a writer, he
- 1:07:28he often writes himself into a corner with his endings.
- 1:07:32And so even There Will Be Blood, it has that sort of explosive
- 1:07:36ending and that final punchline of like, I'm finished and then
- 1:07:40it just goes to credits. I still think that's the weakest
- 1:07:42part of the movie for me. It's, it's satisfying, but it
- 1:07:46could have been more satisfying. And I feel like that with one
- 1:07:49battle after another where it's like you have achieved such a
- 1:07:53status that no one ever needs to do a second pass of your work
- 1:07:56and you're allowed to just make. It's like Tarantino.
- 1:07:58Like I feel like Tarantino's last couple films have been, for
- 1:08:01me, a step down from some of his best work.
- 1:08:04And it's because it's like there's no one there.
- 1:08:06Like Sally Menke, his former editor, has died.
- 1:08:09So the movies are getting longer and like, there's no one there
- 1:08:12to kind of rein that in. And I think that you have to
- 1:08:15surround yourself as a film maker with people who are
- 1:08:17willing to give you like, really honest feedback and rein you in
- 1:08:21when you need to be reined in. Now how that it reminds?
- 1:08:24Movie. Go ahead, go ahead.
- 1:08:26It reminds me of our conversation about David Fincher
- 1:08:28and Aaron Sorkinson in The Social Network.
- 1:08:31That, like Sorkinson, needs a director that, like, keeps his
- 1:08:35writing at Bay. Yeah, dude.
- 1:08:39And I'm really concerned about Aaron Sorkin's next movie, the
- 1:08:42Social Network sequel that he's working on.
- 1:08:44I don't know how that's going to turn out, but we we shall see.
- 1:08:48But getting back to this movie, I, I'm wondering, Brad, you
- 1:08:52know, you've seen three PTA movies and they are in three
- 1:08:55very different kind of buckets of types of movies he makes,
- 1:08:59which if there's one thing you can say about him, it's like, at
- 1:09:01least he doesn't limit himself to making one genre of movie.
- 1:09:05Sure. But.
- 1:09:06What are the things that you now notice about you know, in in
- 1:09:10both the pros and the cons column of him as a filmmaker?
- 1:09:13I think, I think his cinematography is incredible.
- 1:09:16Like he just has a very obvious real talent of working with his
- 1:09:22cinematographer to photograph reality in a very compelling
- 1:09:27way. Even even like small shots when
- 1:09:30they're at the 1776 compound and you see the bounty hunter, which
- 1:09:37sorry, back to the skirts being bad.
- 1:09:39Like this bounty hunter is like, I don't kill kids, but I'll take
- 1:09:43kids to somebody who I know will kill them, but then I'll feel
- 1:09:46bad about it and go back and get killed for her.
- 1:09:51And you're like, huh, How like how does this make any sense?
- 1:09:55Anyways, They're like, there's a few shots in that where you have
- 1:09:59the 1776 guy sitting and you see the dude walking from behind and
- 1:10:03he just walks up and takes the keys.
- 1:10:05It's the camera's still, it's just sitting there, but it
- 1:10:09captures the human experience so incredibly well.
- 1:10:13So I, I think as a cinematographer, when I think
- 1:10:16about There Will Be Blood and when I, I was going to say
- 1:10:22Daniel Day Lewis, what's his character's name?
- 1:10:25Daniel Plainview. Daniel.
- 1:10:27Yeah. That's how I was.
- 1:10:27Like Daniel. Daniel Plainview.
- 1:10:29When Daniel's Plainview's grief erupts with the fiery inferno of
- 1:10:36the oil furnace, and like you feel, that sense of this grief
- 1:10:40is a sweeping, massive Vista of pain and suffering.
- 1:10:45What does he do with the camera? He gives you one of the best
- 1:10:48camera movements, from the spouting fire to following him
- 1:10:53to Daniel Plainview screaming. And it's this incredible use of
- 1:10:56the camera that captures the feeling of grief that Daniel
- 1:10:59Plainview is feeling. Like.
- 1:11:02He does an incredible job. He does it in licorice pizza
- 1:11:05with the playfulness of the interactions between the the
- 1:11:10main 2 characters of that movie, like the flirtatiousness of
- 1:11:13young teenagers, young 20 somethings.
- 1:11:15He captures that with the way he slowly moves the camera behind
- 1:11:19them as as they're standing in line to get their pictures
- 1:11:22taken. And the young boy is like
- 1:11:24following her. Like it's like, Hey, if I if I
- 1:11:26was in high school, would you date me?
- 1:11:28And like there's a playfulness to the camera movement that I'm
- 1:11:31like, I he just is so good with the camera.
- 1:11:35I wish he was better at writing in one battle after another.
- 1:11:39I out of Do you think that's fair?
- 1:11:42Absolutely. I mean, I think any criticism of
- 1:11:44any movie is fair with you sharing it as well as you just
- 1:11:47did. And I think that's a good
- 1:11:48jumping off point to talk not just about the characters but
- 1:11:51about the actors here we're, you know, an hour plus into this
- 1:11:54episode. We haven't talked about Leonardo
- 1:11:56DiCaprio, Oscar nominee. We haven't talked about Sean
- 1:11:59Penn, Oscar nominee. We have not talked about Benicio
- 1:12:02Del Toro, Oscar nominee for this movie.
- 1:12:05And you know, you you said I talked about just the men, but
- 1:12:08Chase Infinity, who plays Willa. This is for all intents and
- 1:12:12purposes, her first big movie. I think she's phenomenal in this
- 1:12:15movie and she does not get a nomination.
- 1:12:18Teyana Taylor does get nominated for her role as Perfidia, which
- 1:12:22is kind of shocking to me because I think Regina Hall is
- 1:12:26better in this movie than she is.
- 1:12:29But we know we've got a good collection of folks that we can
- 1:12:31talk about. Brad, where do you want to start
- 1:12:34with our main actors here? I I do think starting with Leo
- 1:12:40makes the most sense. He takes up the most screen
- 1:12:42time. I I found I really liked Leo in
- 1:12:46this movie. I you know, as much as like I
- 1:12:50said, I don't like the character as written.
- 1:12:52I love how Leo plays him because he does bring that pained sense
- 1:12:59of regret over his past that like you need Leo to play that
- 1:13:05depth. Cause clearly we know that Leo
- 1:13:08can play a tortured individual but because he's playing a
- 1:13:12character that's been a pothead for 30 years, the moments of his
- 1:13:17like forgetting the code of what time is it is hilarious and the
- 1:13:23way he plays it so serious. His anger is so sincere it it
- 1:13:28just works like gangbusters. And the moments where he gets
- 1:13:33the most angry and the most emotional are around his
- 1:13:37daughter and the love he clearly has for his daughter.
- 1:13:40And that's why Leo works for me in this role.
- 1:13:43He does just such an incredible job of showcasing like I've
- 1:13:48screwed up a lot in life. I am not going to screw my
- 1:13:51daughter up, I'm not going to screw our relationship up, and I
- 1:13:53will fight to get it back, as buffoonish as I am as I try to
- 1:13:57fight to get it back. It is interesting to see the
- 1:14:01sort of phases of the types of characters Leo plays throughout
- 1:14:05his career. And we've spent a lot of time on
- 1:14:07this podcast focused on that sort of like mid 2000s departed
- 1:14:12era Blood diamond departed up through the mid 20 teens of the
- 1:14:18Revenant where he was playing like exclusively deeply tortured
- 1:14:23souls who cry a lot. Like that was like his thing.
- 1:14:27And he takes a couple years off after making the Revenant and he
- 1:14:29comes back and now he's like, I want to play dumb asses.
- 1:14:32Like I want to play people who are like losers and dumb.
- 1:14:36Like that's who I am now. And so he does, you know, don't
- 1:14:42look up a couple years ago, which is probably his lowest
- 1:14:45rated movie of this era. He plays a really intelligent
- 1:14:49person in that movie, but he's a person who's like on the outside
- 1:14:52of the power structure. And so he's kind of bumbling.
- 1:14:55You know, he's in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood playing Rick
- 1:14:57Dalton, who is like this guy who is a has been and kind of
- 1:15:01pathetic. And then, you know, you have him
- 1:15:04in in a movie like Killers of the Flower Moon with Scorsese,
- 1:15:08where he's playing like a genuinely dimwitted person who
- 1:15:11gets suckered into doing horrific things and pays the
- 1:15:14price for it. And then in this movie, once
- 1:15:16again, he is like the dimmest bulb in this movie.
- 1:15:20He's a genuinely good dude but like watching him try to process
- 1:15:24things happen while stressed out and high, it's a really funny
- 1:15:29performance and I don't think Leo gets enough credit for how
- 1:15:32funny he can be. He gets nominated for best actor
- 1:15:35for this film on 1st watch. I was like, this seems like a
- 1:15:39kind of a minor Leo performance to get an Academy Award
- 1:15:43nomination. But watching it back I'm with
- 1:15:45you man. I think that it's like it's not
- 1:15:48subtle. Like, nothing about this movie
- 1:15:49is subtle, but the work DiCaprio is doing, I think when you watch
- 1:15:55it with the intention of like, is this an Oscar worthy
- 1:15:58performance? It absolutely.
- 1:15:59Is it like he's giving this his all?
- 1:16:02And it's a really, really good kind of, you know, addition to
- 1:16:06all the great roles he's done over the years.
- 1:16:09And, and I I'll go back to my, my gripe with the movie.
- 1:16:12I think if you end the movie with him hugging Willa on the
- 1:16:16road, Chef's kiss, like Oscar is in the bag.
- 1:16:21He has it because he provides the emotional core of the movie,
- 1:16:26which to me, the core message of this movie that I take away is
- 1:16:32the pursuit of family is a pursuit that transcends all
- 1:16:37political bounds. Like, regardless of what he
- 1:16:40believed in the past, he has recognized I'm going to protect
- 1:16:43my daughter. And I, I think that's where
- 1:16:46Leo's performance just like leaps up into Oscar territory is
- 1:16:51when you see him embracing Chase Infinity and just, oh man, it's
- 1:16:55such a great moment. Let's talk about Chase Infinity
- 1:16:59just for a moment because, you know, she's she's not getting
- 1:17:01the Oscar recognition. But like to be able to be in
- 1:17:04scenes with Leonardo DiCaprio and Sean Penn and Regina Hall,
- 1:17:09you know, for a couple minutes and hold your own against all
- 1:17:12these really, really great actors as a newcomer.
- 1:17:16And to be able to play like the stress of the situation of being
- 1:17:19kidnapped and the complete like melting into Leo's arms at the
- 1:17:24end of this movie. Like, I'm kind of blown away by
- 1:17:27the talent that she is. And I'm excited to see where
- 1:17:30she's going to go after this. Absolutely like.
- 1:17:34The. Transition within scenes of when
- 1:17:37people see her and she has this shield up and she has her walls
- 1:17:41up to when she's actually alone and is curled up in a ball and
- 1:17:46crying silently on the bed. I I think she was lights out in
- 1:17:52this movie. I really, really loved her
- 1:17:54performance when, when Sean Penn is chewing scenery and like
- 1:17:57flexing his biceps and, and just being this big douche of a guy
- 1:18:03and she's just got this like, calm, powerful anger.
- 1:18:07She nails it. She is absolutely incredible.
- 1:18:11I I am curious where you're at on Sean Penn, though, because I
- 1:18:14don't know if we're going to land in the same place on him.
- 1:18:17No. And just to spoil things a
- 1:18:18little bit, you texted me like, I think this is the worst
- 1:18:21performance of all time, which is really funny because I think
- 1:18:23he's doing exactly what he was asked to do and exactly what a a
- 1:18:27guy named Colonel Stephen Lockjaw is supposed to do.
- 1:18:31Yep. It is interesting to me because
- 1:18:35he's gotten the recognition of nominations throughout award
- 1:18:39season. I think when this movie came
- 1:18:41out, actor, supporting actor, when this movie came out,
- 1:18:45everybody was like Sean Penn Oscar, Write it down like it's
- 1:18:48just gonna happen. And what we've actually found to
- 1:18:50be true is that they're nominating both Sean Penn and
- 1:18:53Benicio Del Toro. And in a couple instances,
- 1:18:56Benicio has won a few supporting awards throughout awards season,
- 1:19:01you know, just from critics groups and things like that.
- 1:19:03But it's funny because Benicio's giving a completely different
- 1:19:06kind of performance and it's a much more like thankless role.
- 1:19:09Like it's a it's fun to hang out with the sensei, but like he's
- 1:19:14not the thing that's top of mind.
- 1:19:15Then it kind of reminds me of like when Leo did Django
- 1:19:20Unchained and he was like the big bad villain, but he doesn't
- 1:19:24get the Oscar recognition Christoph Waltz does.
- 1:19:27And and when you know, Jack Nicholson does The departed, he
- 1:19:30doesn't even get nominated for the departed, but Mark Wahlberg
- 1:19:33does. So it's just kind of like, it's
- 1:19:35one of those things to me where Sean Penn seems to have the more
- 1:19:39Oscari, big scene chewing performance here, but they're
- 1:19:44actually like, there's more love going towards Benicio Del Toro
- 1:19:48in this movie. Yeah, I say all that good to
- 1:19:50say, I I like Sean Penn a lot, but it seems like people are
- 1:19:54kind of coming around to the idea of like, we don't really
- 1:19:56have to give this guy an Oscar just 'cause he's playing like
- 1:19:59the big bad in a big movie, you know?
- 1:20:01Right. And I I think my frustration
- 1:20:04with Sean Penn probably is just more about his character is
- 1:20:07written. We talked earlier about the
- 1:20:10absurdism of the movie. He is the height of that and it
- 1:20:14clashes with the style and of the other characters of the
- 1:20:19movie. It just it's so heightened and
- 1:20:22so Doctor Strangelove levels of absurd that I I kind of just was
- 1:20:28like, I can't take this seriously.
- 1:20:31And you know, PTA and his writing fell, fell prey to the
- 1:20:37like, cynical Marvel humor of having Willa say to him like,
- 1:20:45why is your shirt so tight? I love that dude.
- 1:20:48And then there's. Like the long, the long pause or
- 1:20:51that he's like, I'm not gay if that's what you're.
- 1:20:54I thought that was hilarious. Of all the comedy in this movie,
- 1:21:01that one fell completely flat for me.
- 1:21:03I'm like, really interesting, OK, Just the worst writing.
- 1:21:08I There's something about writing in the snarky.
- 1:21:14Sarcastic youth Marvel humor that I just find it is the least
- 1:21:20funny thing I've ever. Well, I think the only reason it
- 1:21:22actually worked for me though is because right before that he's
- 1:21:25like, you should put more make up on like, you know, like he's
- 1:21:28like feeding into her insecurities.
- 1:21:30And then she's just like, why is your shirt so tight?
- 1:21:32And then he just immediately gets defensive.
- 1:21:35I'm with you, though. I do think that there are, like,
- 1:21:37there are definite misses. But yeah, I asked you the
- 1:21:42question earlier of like, how often does the tone of this
- 1:21:44movie actually land? And if you'd asked me four
- 1:21:47months ago, I'd have been like 50% of the time.
- 1:21:50Like, I think I gave this movie A6 when I walked out of the
- 1:21:52theater. I've come around a lot more on
- 1:21:55it. And I think that it's like 70 to
- 1:21:5780% of the time the jokes work, which if you're writing a
- 1:22:01comedy, like if we're talking about Anchorman, I think like
- 1:22:0480% of the jokes work in Anchorman.
- 1:22:06And that's an all time classic comedy, you know what I mean?
- 1:22:09Like. 80% of the jokes work every time.
- 1:22:12Every time. Yeah, I did write down a couple
- 1:22:16a couple lines that really made me laugh and moments that made
- 1:22:20me laugh. And like, when, when they have
- 1:22:23all of the old white guys get together for the Christmas club
- 1:22:26or whatever and they're explaining the situation to the
- 1:22:29the assassin that they're gonna send out.
- 1:22:31And they say, like, you know, they conducted a raid on the
- 1:22:34chicken lickin frozen farm. And the guy goes, oh, no, I love
- 1:22:39their Nuggets. It's just the line of like, I
- 1:22:43love their Nuggets Made me laugh so hard.
- 1:22:46And there's just little moments like that, like when when
- 1:22:49DiCaprio is on the phone with with Comrade Josh and just
- 1:22:53losing his absolute shit. I wrote down every line there
- 1:22:56'cause it made me laugh so hard and, and Comrade Josh is like,
- 1:23:01you're violating my safety. These are noise triggers.
- 1:23:04And Dicaprio's like fucking noise triggers.
- 1:23:07He's like, what is your, what's your name?
- 1:23:09I want to know your name. He's like, my name is Comrade
- 1:23:12Josh. And he goes, all right, well,
- 1:23:13first of all, you need to get a better name.
- 1:23:15Comrade Josh is a fucking horrible name for a
- 1:23:17revolutionary. Says the guy who his name not
- 1:23:24This is confusing because you're Bob, please be honest.
- 1:23:26But I love when I because I'm pretty sure he answers that by
- 1:23:30going all right, Bob. It's just this perfect, like,
- 1:23:35yeah, Comrade Bob, all that much better.
- 1:23:37It's so much better. And then there's like the moment
- 1:23:41of like they cut back to DiCaprio and they've put him on
- 1:23:44hold with the the revolutionary hotline and there's like hold
- 1:23:48music on the phone. There's just so many good
- 1:23:52moments of comedy. I can't hate on this movie too
- 1:23:54much because like it, it really does work.
- 1:23:58Yeah, there's there's even moments of like almost like a
- 1:24:00Wes Anderson aesthetic When it when Willa is at this nunnery of
- 1:24:08like revolutionary nuns and it just cuts to her perfectly
- 1:24:12framed in the center of the frame, like big wide stands
- 1:24:15holding a machine gun, just blasting off the same way that
- 1:24:19you saw her mother doing when she was pregnant with her.
- 1:24:22But like this specific scene, it's bright and vibrant and
- 1:24:26there's colors and she and it's she's perfectly centered in the
- 1:24:29frame and somebody else is talking off screen about her.
- 1:24:33And it just felt like this Wes Anderson comedic.
- 1:24:37Like I just, I loved the little moments like that throughout the
- 1:24:41movie. Yeah, we we should talk really
- 1:24:44quickly about Benicio Del Toro, who was in a Wes Anderson film
- 1:24:48just this year, The Phoenician Scheme.
- 1:24:50He had the lead role in that movie and that is one of my
- 1:24:52favorite movies of the year. I felt like it was really slept
- 1:24:55on. I wish Benicio was nominated for
- 1:24:57that for best actor instead of for this movie.
- 1:25:00Not that he's not great in this movie, but I just felt like he
- 1:25:03was even better in the Wes Anderson film.
- 1:25:06I I am partial to Sensei though, like I really like what he's
- 1:25:09doing in this movie. It's cool to watch him be an
- 1:25:12ally to DiCaprio and just to be like the the coolest cucumber.
- 1:25:17He gets that great last line of I had a few small beers and then
- 1:25:20they just cut away and you never see him again.
- 1:25:22Like it's it's a cool character for sure.
- 1:25:25And the way he's like dancing as the cops are like having him put
- 1:25:29on his cops. I think once again, I think
- 1:25:32Benicio Del Toro's character highlights the struggle for me
- 1:25:35though of like, at first you see him and, and he's Willa's like
- 1:25:40sensei and trainer and he's helping Bob out, but he's also
- 1:25:44like organizing this like resistance to ice.
- 1:25:48And he's very serious. And so I, I was struggling.
- 1:25:51I'm like, is it, is he supposed to be funny or serious or like
- 1:25:55say something about the world? What are we doing here?
- 1:25:59And then at the end of all things, he's just a very
- 1:26:01unserious, funny character that's like, you know, in the
- 1:26:05eyes in in the eyes of the film, he's doing the right thing.
- 1:26:09But he's just kind of chill and has a few beers and it's funny.
- 1:26:12And like once I landed on oh, he's an unserious character, I
- 1:26:18was able to enjoy his performance and and I he's very
- 1:26:22funny. The way he like puts his first
- 1:26:24up as the carpet, like rolls over him as he's leaving.
- 1:26:28It's just like, it's really funny and it's a great.
- 1:26:31Performance. Yeah, I think that every
- 1:26:34character in the movie is an unserious character, except for,
- 1:26:37I guess you could say, except for the female characters like
- 1:26:40Perfidia is, is portrayed as like this incredibly flawed
- 1:26:44person. And one of the things I do love
- 1:26:45about the movie is like the for a, for an unsubtle movie, like
- 1:26:50she makes horrible selfish choices, but nobody in the movie
- 1:26:55has to be like she's a horrible selfish, like they call her a
- 1:26:58rat 'cause she literally ratted on them.
- 1:26:59But like, you understand as an audience member that she is both
- 1:27:04afraid of being tied down. She's afraid of being a mom.
- 1:27:08She's afraid of losing attention.
- 1:27:09She craves attention and she like gets off on danger.
- 1:27:13And like, this is not a, this is not setting yourself up for
- 1:27:16success as a mother. So she abandons her kid and she
- 1:27:18just she does, and I think that like portraying it so frankly is
- 1:27:24is perhaps the most adult thing this movie does.
- 1:27:26Like sure, and in letting you actually understand, like I
- 1:27:30don't like Perfidia because she did this, but I understand her
- 1:27:33motivations, even if they are selfish.
- 1:27:36So when you see a character like Chase Infinity Willa in the
- 1:27:39movie, she's like one of the only serious people because
- 1:27:42she's still like she's looking around her at all these absurd
- 1:27:46characters and trying to figure out like, how do I make my way
- 1:27:49in a world filled with absurd people?
- 1:27:52And you kind of get that with Regina Hall because at some
- 1:27:55point someone tells her you're the only one that takes this
- 1:27:58seriously anymore. Like one of the nuns even says
- 1:28:00like, I don't like doing this revolution thing anymore.
- 1:28:03You're way more involved in this than we are.
- 1:28:05So I I do think there's something to the idea that,
- 1:28:07like, the world is filled with absurd people and only a couple
- 1:28:12of us are actually serious about this.
- 1:28:15And that kind of feeds into the comedy of it, but it also kind
- 1:28:18of feeds into this disconnect you and I both feel with the
- 1:28:22tone of the movie. Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:28:25And I, I think the the disconnect for me also comes
- 1:28:28down. I'm curious how you feel about
- 1:28:30this. It's interesting to me that the
- 1:28:33most emotionally powerful part of this film is when father and
- 1:28:38daughter are reunited. It's not when the villain of the
- 1:28:43movie is defeated. Like, it feels like there should
- 1:28:47be this sense of like, like, like we got in Locklear is dead.
- 1:28:53They're free from his influence. And yet, like his death kind of
- 1:28:57feels anticlimactic and just kind of like, OK, he's dead now.
- 1:29:05And I, I just, I don't know, to me, once again, the everything
- 1:29:09that happens after Willa and Bob are reunited feels like it just
- 1:29:15kind of cuts the legs out of the movie because we've already had
- 1:29:20our emotional climax. The whole thrust of the movie
- 1:29:23has been completed. And then there's all this add on
- 1:29:25stuff that makes you go, oh, maybe the movie wasn't about
- 1:29:29what I thought it was about. And it's it's maybe it's about
- 1:29:34defeating Lock Lockjaw. But when I see him defeated, I'm
- 1:29:38just kind of like, OK, that happened, I guess.
- 1:29:42He was ultimately just a cog in a machine, too.
- 1:29:44Yeah. And I think that if you wanted
- 1:29:47to take a much more negative view on PTA as a film maker,
- 1:29:51then you could say that he's kind of aping other film makers
- 1:29:56and and he's kind of derivative. I don't think this about him,
- 1:29:59but like you could very clearly map Boogie Nights is a Scorsese
- 1:30:03movie. Magnolia has always been
- 1:30:06considered like a Robert Altman type movie.
- 1:30:08I think you could say that Licorice Pizza being a hangout
- 1:30:11movie is very Altman, but it's also very like French New Wave.
- 1:30:15You could say that There will be blood and the Master are very
- 1:30:17Kubricky. And I think when you look at
- 1:30:20this movie, this is him and his most like Coen brothers, both in
- 1:30:24trying to capture the dark comedy and the sort of like
- 1:30:28randomness and futility of life. And there is a ton of No Country
- 1:30:32for Old Men in the way this movie is shot and set up.
- 1:30:36You know, this whole idea of like sending an assassin after
- 1:30:40the main bad guy who just ends up getting killed really quickly
- 1:30:43too, like Woody Harrelson did in No Country for Old Men.
- 1:30:47I I do think there's a ton of Cohen in this movie.
- 1:30:51I don't know if he is as successful at balancing tones as
- 1:30:54the Coens are, but I do think that there's something to the
- 1:30:58way that it's like, well, you know, this, we thought this was
- 1:31:02our big bad. And now he's been dispatched as
- 1:31:04quickly as anybody else in this movie.
- 1:31:06Kind of like when Josh Brolin gets killed in No Country and it
- 1:31:11happens off screen and you you fade back in and he's just dead
- 1:31:14and you're like, what the hell. Like, I I wanted the payoff of
- 1:31:17seeing that happen. So yeah, I mean, I think it's
- 1:31:20purposeful, but it's also a thing that you could pinpoint as
- 1:31:23a potential weakness of the movie.
- 1:31:25Yeah. And I, I think, I mean, Bob, I
- 1:31:28think this is kind of wrapping us up to the point where we need
- 1:31:31to finish out with our last two segments of the day, the first
- 1:31:34of which being let's make it a double.
- 1:31:37We're near the end of the episode, so thanks listening to
- 1:31:40the film and Whiskey show. Let's have another film with
- 1:31:43this one, even if it's struggling.
- 1:31:44It's the final segment of the day.
- 1:31:46Now let's make it a double. Let's Make It a Double is the
- 1:31:49part of the show where we pick a movie to pair up with this one
- 1:31:52to make the perfect double feature.
- 1:31:54Brad, since you brought it up, I'm going to assume you have a
- 1:31:57good one on deck here for us. So I'll let you go first with
- 1:31:59Let's Make It a Double. Yeah, I, I think that if you
- 1:32:03look at this film as a man and his daughter trying to reclaim
- 1:32:09some semblance of life after a period of war, after a period of
- 1:32:15revolution of, you know, Bob living this violent life.
- 1:32:19I'm actually, this is like probably a, a stretch.
- 1:32:23I'm going to pair this with the best years of our lives from
- 1:32:261946. I, I think that there is that
- 1:32:30sense of how do we make sense of our lives after this very big
- 1:32:35traumatic event that we participated in?
- 1:32:39And how do we, how do we reconcile with our parts and our
- 1:32:43roles in that war, in that struggle?
- 1:32:46I think that there's actually a lot of similarities there.
- 1:32:48And I think I would rather watch 1 battle after another and then
- 1:32:52the best of your years of our lives and end in this kind of
- 1:32:55better, more optimistic place. Nice.
- 1:32:59Yeah. I, I think there's a couple
- 1:33:01directions I could go with this. The first of which is if you
- 1:33:03just want to keep it to 2025, there's another movie that came
- 1:33:06out this year called Marty Supreme, which is shot in this
- 1:33:10kind of hectic tension building. This guy is screwing up his life
- 1:33:15with every choice he's making. And you make reckless choices as
- 1:33:17a young person, and then you kind of learn how to figure it
- 1:33:20out when you see the eyes of your baby for the first time.
- 1:33:24And like, it's very much a movie about fatherhood.
- 1:33:26Marty Supreme would be a really good movie to pair this with.
- 1:33:29I think I'm going to stick on the Coen brothers thing.
- 1:33:33You know, there's definitely no country for old men in this.
- 1:33:35There's definitely some Fargo in this movie as well.
- 1:33:38I think I'm going to pair it with one of my favorite Coen
- 1:33:41Brothers movies which is called Burn After Reading, which is a
- 1:33:44great 90 minute movie that is all about like CIA intrigue and
- 1:33:49a bunch of really stupid people who get trapped in having
- 1:33:53documents they shouldn't. A bunch of people get killed and
- 1:33:56the end of the movie is very much just like, what did we even
- 1:33:59learn here? I don't know.
- 1:34:01And then that's the end of the movie.
- 1:34:02And it feels like very much akin to 1 battle after another.
- 1:34:06I think it does the comedy just a little bit better.
- 1:34:09So I'd highly recommend pairing this up with Burn after reading
- 1:34:14Brad. We have made it.
- 1:34:16We're an hour and a half in. We should probably give this
- 1:34:18movie some final scores here. I'm a lot higher than I was the
- 1:34:22first time I saw this. I don't think it's a perfect
- 1:34:24movie. I don't think that it's like, I
- 1:34:27don't think it even approaches There Will Be Blood in terms of
- 1:34:30Paul Thomas Anderson's best films.
- 1:34:32If it wins Best Picture, I won't be mad about it.
- 1:34:37I just don't think that this was a particularly strong year for
- 1:34:39film, and I'm going to reflect that in the fact that I'm giving
- 1:34:43this movie an 8 out of 10. OK.
- 1:34:46I think I just as a movie, I think that this is I'm with you.
- 1:34:51It's like an 8 out of 10. Like the cinematography is
- 1:34:54really great. The scripts kind of average.
- 1:34:58The action scenes are really well done.
- 1:35:00That there's a lot to like about this movie.
- 1:35:03I think for me, and you tell me if I'm wrong about it feels like
- 1:35:07there is a political statement being made here.
- 1:35:12Like, am I crazy? OK.
- 1:35:14No, not at all. OK, so I for me, the vision of
- 1:35:19the world, of the human experience that he is promoting,
- 1:35:24I just disagree with like on a deep fundamental level.
- 1:35:28So for me that's like it's like a one out of 10 on the message
- 1:35:33it is bringing to the world. Like I just, I very deeply
- 1:35:36disagree with it. And so I, I think I'll land at
- 1:35:40like a 6.5. Like I think this is a really
- 1:35:43well made movie. I just think that the the
- 1:35:47message that the world is run by these dark, evil, racist people
- 1:35:53and they are trying to ruin and destroy people's lives.
- 1:35:57And that therefore makes violence OK.
- 1:36:02It makes it OK to enact violence and chaos on the world.
- 1:36:05I just, I can't get down with that man.
- 1:36:07It really is. And antithetical to how I view
- 1:36:11the human experience. So I I'm, I'm, I'm kind of in
- 1:36:17the middle where I recognize that this is a really well made
- 1:36:19movie. It's funny.
- 1:36:20There's a lot to like about it. I just found myself a little
- 1:36:24sour at the end. I hope that you feel like you've
- 1:36:27been able to express your dissenting opinion today.
- 1:36:30And I've kind of, I've also tried not to argue with it
- 1:36:33because a, like the movie kind of does the arguing.
- 1:36:36You know, I don't agree with the idea of like, we should
- 1:36:39violently overthrow things. But I do think that, like, the
- 1:36:43course of human history kind of says that there are powerful
- 1:36:47people and people who are not in power.
- 1:36:48And like, change comes through people protesting.
- 1:36:52Now, my issues with the movie are not of the political ilk at
- 1:36:56all. It's more just like, does the
- 1:36:58tone of this movie work or not? And I think for the most part it
- 1:37:01does. And I think you and I can find
- 1:37:03common ground in the fact that, like, what the movie does as a
- 1:37:06movie, for the most part works pretty well.
- 1:37:09Yeah. So totally, I'm coming out to an
- 1:37:128 out of 10. Brad's coming out to a 6.5,
- 1:37:15which puts us at an average of a 7.25 on this.
- 1:37:19So next week when we return with the movie Sinners, we're going
- 1:37:22to be holding it up against this 7.25 and seeing which of these
- 1:37:25two movies actually deserves to win the Oscar for Best Picture
- 1:37:29this year because of. Our vote that matters.
- 1:37:32That's right, now you can let us know what you thought of 1
- 1:37:35Battle After Another by getting in touch with us on any of our
- 1:37:38social media accounts, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, TikTok or
- 1:37:43YouTube at film. Whiskey.
- 1:37:46Or if you want to join the conversation, you can find a
- 1:37:48link to our Discord server at the end of every single one of
- 1:37:51our show notes. All right, we'll be back next
- 1:37:53week talking about sinners, but until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 1:37:57I'm Brad G. And we'll see you next time.