Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP256: The Future of Your Ecommerce Returns Strategy - Understanding The Pivot To Paid Returns & Fair Usage
Transcript
- 0:02You're listening to the Insidecommerce podcast, hosted
- 0:05by experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 0:08Insidecommerce is your fast tracked additional knowledge
- 0:10featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 0:13industry thought leads and the C-Suite of key tech companies to
- 0:16explore the latest in digital strategy, customer experience
- 0:18and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 0:21really mean and get practical advice based on experience to
- 0:24help fine tune your ECOM strategy and tech stack.
- 0:27Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 0:30like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 0:32We hope you enjoy the latest episode.
- 0:35Today's episode is sponsored by Centre and Greber.
- 0:37More about them later. We are focusing on return
- 0:40strategy, process and technology.
- 0:42And you might be thinking, oh, why?
- 0:44Why? Another discussion about
- 0:45returns, but this is important because we're looking at the
- 0:49context of why returns are how they are and how return
- 0:53strategies evolving and where the market's going.
- 0:55I think this is really one because there is a bit of a, a
- 0:57seismic change at the moment and retailers start to change their
- 1:01behaviour. They've had big retailers
- 1:03recently like lights of ASOS coming out and announcing to see
- 1:06that they can start charging for returns and various, you know,
- 1:11reactions from customers. So the market's changing, the
- 1:15technology's evolving and we want to talk about what this
- 1:18means for e-commerce and retail specifically.
- 1:22So just a little bit of a context that I guess is what
- 1:25where we've got to is that that major retailers shaped customer
- 1:30perceptions. And for a long time, big
- 1:32retailers like Amazon have had, yeah, extended returns options
- 1:38like 30 day policy, more than 14 day statutory rights.
- 1:41You've had major brands like Zappos who launched from ground
- 1:48up of 365 all year round free returns.
- 1:52So a lot of big retailers have established an expectation
- 1:55returns should be free, which is translated into a customer
- 1:58belief that they should be offered free returns.
- 2:01So good intentions, but misguided because returns is a
- 2:04cost and returns is seen as a policy by a lot of businesses.
- 2:09So policies are seen as costs, not as as services and not as
- 2:15potential ways of improving like the overall customer experience.
- 2:18So historically, people have seen the need to mimic free
- 2:22returns, but at the same point treating it internally as a
- 2:25policy. And that's lead to not always
- 2:26optimal solutions for the customer, which when you then
- 2:30drop the news that you're going to start charging for returns,
- 2:33can often lead to frustration. So what we're going to try and
- 2:36unpick is, is policy versus service where the market's
- 2:40headed. And also what were the
- 2:41implications of this, this current evolution of returns?
- 2:45Paul, do you want to build on that?
- 2:47Yeah. So I think, I think returns is
- 2:49an interesting point. I think the biggest thing that I
- 2:52would say and the biggest thing that I've noticed over the years
- 2:55is for the average brand return like optimizing the returns
- 3:00experience. And also, you know, attacking
- 3:04the returns problem is actually really complicated because
- 3:07you've got multiple departments, multiple technologies involved,
- 3:12multiple vendors. And I think a lot of our clients
- 3:15that are smaller have really struggled to even understand the
- 3:18impact of returns on the business and on their kind of
- 3:21Net margin. I think when you're working with
- 3:23larger businesses, they're probably slightly more aware.
- 3:27And I think ASOS quite famously did a lot of analysis a few
- 3:31years ago and understood because essentially their model was like
- 3:35based on cost per new customer, blah, blah, ultimately become
- 3:40profitable. But then they realized that the
- 3:42return rate and the number of people doing multiple returns
- 3:47and essentially they were losing money on X percent of new
- 3:50customers. And that was a big part of their
- 3:53like, transformation project. And they've invested a lot in
- 3:55understanding that. But I still think even achieving
- 3:59that, like understanding the cost to the business of returns,
- 4:03both new and return. And I think it's still really
- 4:05challenging. There's been a few vendors have
- 4:08tried to achieve it. But yeah, overall, I think, you
- 4:11know, is still a really challenging area.
- 4:13I think people look the front and side is quite simple and you
- 4:17know, presenting different options and providing like
- 4:20better RMA flows. I think that side is pretty
- 4:22simple and a lot of vendors do that really well.
- 4:26But you know actually then handling the back end side of
- 4:30that editing orders, you know, preventing certain situations
- 4:35from happening etcetera is then a bit more complicated.
- 4:40Yeah. And then I think the other thing
- 4:41that we talked about briefly before this is, I see a lot of
- 4:45people said, right, we started charging for returns and there's
- 4:48no impact. But I think the real impact of
- 4:51charging for returns isn't on the 1st purchase or even the
- 4:54next purchase. It's the purchase after that
- 4:57because essentially a customer completes a purchase, pay is to
- 5:01return it and then they're less likely to return again.
- 5:04But that is quite hard to measure and it would take a long
- 5:07time to measure. So, yeah, I think that's kind of
- 5:10why returns is challenging when you look at it at the level that
- 5:14you've certainly looked at it based on the notes that we've
- 5:17got here and just because it is a lot more complicated than
- 5:20people make out. Greb and create digital flagship
- 5:24stores for iconic brands of today and tomorrow.
- 5:27We are the number one Centra agency in the world with more
- 5:30than 50 Centra implementations to date.
- 5:33We are also e-commerce design specialists, platform and tech
- 5:36partner agnostic. Try our new e-commerce design
- 5:39subscription, visit greben.com. Yeah, and I think for me there,
- 5:44there is a a pivot moment here of stopping seeing returns as a
- 5:49policy and a compliance department and seeing it as a
- 5:52customer service because that totally changes the thinking,
- 5:54the outlook in the same way that that delivery evolved to be in a
- 5:57service like how can we make life easier?
- 5:59How can we remove friction from the customer journey.
- 6:03And this is where I think the leading retailers are have
- 6:07started to move, others are following and and this is about,
- 6:11OK, well, what what how do we make life easier?
- 6:14As you talk about the front end bit there, you know, there are
- 6:16simple things that you can do, initiate returns online, offer
- 6:21people like pre printed returns labels, have a Courier.
- 6:23So there are things that you can set up and do, but the next bit
- 6:27is going to be about to side in who is eligible and when, under
- 6:31what criteria, how you communicate this, at what point
- 6:35it's fair to charge people when it's not?
- 6:38And how do you actually ensure that the quality of the return
- 6:41service is, is good enough that people when they're paying for
- 6:45it, perceive that they're actually paying for a service
- 6:47and they're not being penalised. And I, I think that's key thing
- 6:51is because I don't believe that for a lot of the people who are
- 6:54obviously going to start charging outside of the, the,
- 6:57the major brands that this has been thought through in terms of
- 7:01the customer experience piece yet.
- 7:03Completely agree. And I think the other thing is
- 7:05when you do charge and you kind of alluded to it there, I think
- 7:09communicating like why as well. And like some because like some
- 7:13of our clients, if you know, like had like a sustainability
- 7:17angle within it and stuff like that.
- 7:19And I think you're obviously going to have different reasons.
- 7:22And in 99% of cases it's going to be marginal.
- 7:25I think if you communicate like the why and communicate it well,
- 7:30I think it, like you said, has less of an impact.
- 7:33The one thing I would say as well, which I, I not sure we
- 7:37actually touch on here, but when, whenever we've had you
- 7:41mentioned about it being a friction point, but whenever
- 7:43we've had clients do really deep analysis of like MPs feedback,
- 7:48like return, like true MPs returns is always a major like
- 7:55feedback area. So I think if you've got
- 7:58someone, if you're hiring like, you know, a head of customer
- 8:01experience with very few brands have like really experienced
- 8:05like that person with deep experience in this area, I think
- 8:09they would be going straight to returns and looking at how they
- 8:12could improve the experience for a customer like new and
- 8:15returning. But yeah.
- 8:18Yeah. I, I think that's a really
- 8:19interesting point actually, because delivering shipping is
- 8:22all is typically seen from an acquisition lens.
- 8:25And therefore it gets more attention because it's very easy
- 8:28to get excited about acquiring new customers because that's
- 8:31direct revenue and, and isn't that great and we'll monetize
- 8:34them as well in, in, in the retention strategies.
- 8:36But returns is then the loss of some of those.
- 8:39And if your returns is in manage you, as you said, because
- 8:42reporting is often quite fragmented in return space, you
- 8:46could be understating that loss and therefore your true cost of
- 8:48acquisition is actually significantly higher when you
- 8:50factor in returns. And This is why it's really
- 8:52nuanced and I think it should. I think it'd be worth us
- 8:56pointing out some of the issues created by a poorly managed
- 8:58return strategy because some think are obvious, but they're
- 9:01worth emphasizing and others are less obvious and people don't
- 9:05think necessarily have such a strong handle on.
- 9:07But let's start going through those because there are some key
- 9:11business impacts not understanding the data.
- 9:15Yeah. So I think the first one and I
- 9:17will add that as always, you've done almost all of the work in
- 9:21the background in terms of like this show notes for this.
- 9:24But the first one is the cost to the business of returns, a cost
- 9:27of additional postage, cost of processing the items, refunds to
- 9:33customers. So they would be like the the
- 9:36line items against the business. Centra is the only commerce
- 9:39platform built exclusively for fashion brands.
- 9:41Over 300 fashion brands run on Centra, including icons like
- 9:44Paul Smith, Jeff Ave. and Nudie Jeans.
- 9:46Centra solves business logic challenges for fashion brands.
- 9:48I know other platform and they are on a mission to help you
- 9:50scale up rapidly globally across all online and offline channels.
- 9:54Take your fashion brand global faster, further stronger today.
- 9:58Yeah and the one I I don't think's talked about enough,
- 10:01certainly when I when I talk to businesses about like returns as
- 10:04part of that wider whether it's systemic or whether it's it's
- 10:07about the end to end user journey pieces, the fraud
- 10:13techniques that are taken to minimize fraud.
- 10:16So fraud is often couched in terms of payment processing,
- 10:20right. You know, we have fraud controls
- 10:21and our Stripe in Shopify payments or we've got Signify,
- 10:25but returns fraud exists. And I, I read something from the
- 10:29National Retail Federation in the US where apparently fraud
- 10:31last year was 11% of transactions E com that's that's
- 10:36big. And in some verticals it's way
- 10:38harder than higher than others. So basically, if, if, if policy
- 10:43isn't monitored and guardrails are in place to prevent
- 10:45exploitation, you find bad actors, test it, find it worked
- 10:50and then we'll just accelerate that.
- 10:52So a good example would be empty boxing where somebody orders and
- 10:59they check they've they check how quickly like a refund is is
- 11:04placed. Some businesses refund
- 11:05instantly. You then send it back, they
- 11:08empty box it and they send a box of no goods in checking whether
- 11:13the supply chain is accurate enough for the item to get back
- 11:16to be properly receipted, to be scanned, to be assessed, to be
- 11:19quality controlled and and that flow have come back.
- 11:22And when they find that this doesn't happen, then they just
- 11:25start accelerating and placing more orders and taking advance.
- 11:27So that's one example where actually it's not just about
- 11:31being able to to process a return, it's about being able to
- 11:34make sure that the return is of the is a genuine.
- 11:37Yeah, I, I actually was speaking to someone recently about this
- 11:41and I had no idea how big that was.
- 11:43And also people saying items are broken and like that being a
- 11:47level of fraud. And then the other one, which
- 11:49again, we could do an episode on this to be honest, if we got the
- 11:52right guest. The other one I had no idea was
- 11:55so big. And I think it's like the
- 11:57fastest growing area of fraud is people choosing the right option
- 12:01when they're not in and then basically saying the delivery
- 12:04never arrived, which apparently is happening more and more and
- 12:09having a big impact. And the other one that I was
- 12:12going to add to this as well, in terms of the cost of business, I
- 12:14think one of the biggest ones that I see come up because
- 12:17obviously the biggest side of our business is tight, but it
- 12:20comes up pretty regularly is when you either have a sudden
- 12:25increase in returns or you know, periods where you have a lot
- 12:28more returns and you've got a model for acquiring customers in
- 12:32terms of, you know, making sure that it's profitable across
- 12:36different levels of the catalogue, across different
- 12:38types of customers, different products, etcetera.
- 12:41And then you're not factoring in for a potential increase in
- 12:45returns or just the return rate generally.
- 12:48So I think that's often and there's been some high profile
- 12:52cases where people have basically thought that they're
- 12:56acquiring customers profitably, but then when they come to, and
- 12:59we've just talked by a little bit.
- 13:01So when they factor in the impact of returns, actually it's
- 13:04not profitable basically. Yeah, definitely.
- 13:10And this is about data visibility isn't and about
- 13:12tracking the true impact of returns and this often isn't
- 13:16done. And coming with that, I guess
- 13:18that fraud bun that you, you kind of just built on the one of
- 13:20the areas that always surprises me that isn't exploited more is
- 13:24so many delivery companies, whether it's Amazon Prime
- 13:27deliveries or it's DPDS, if there's not a response on the
- 13:31door, will leave it by like the front door and they'll take a
- 13:35picture to go, we have delivered it.
- 13:37So yeah, you can obviously invest in delivery services that
- 13:43will not do that. They insist on a physical
- 13:45connection, but they typically cost more.
- 13:48And it's just people are trying to shave pence off of all costs
- 13:52in their in their business because at scale, that's a mass
- 13:54amount of money. But Christ, is it easy to nick
- 13:57something off someone's doorstep if they're out all day and the
- 14:00F, it's easy to exploit and claim, no, it's gone.
- 14:03How do you validate that it wasn't stolen and this is where
- 14:05the data's needed? Because if you're able to to, if
- 14:09you've got the data intelligence that says, OK, this return
- 14:11reason is items stolen. And we've seen this X times in
- 14:16the last X weeks or months from one particular customer.
- 14:20The ability to then block on that account from ordering.
- 14:24You've got to have these automated processes, but you
- 14:26can't have it without the data intelligence.
- 14:30Yeah, exactly. Yeah, Yeah, I think I've
- 14:32actually thought about that. Like I said, I had that
- 14:35conversation and Brand was telling me how much more common
- 14:39it's getting. And yeah, I do agree.
- 14:41I think that's I, I think it's just an area that's very easy to
- 14:45exploit. Yes, it is.
- 14:48There is. I mean, this is a reality.
- 14:50All the while there are processes, there'll be people
- 14:52out there trying to find loopholes to exploit them.
- 14:54That's the way it goes. And, and when a weakness is
- 14:57found, then people do it at scale.
- 15:02Then one, one other point about Datapoint actually about the
- 15:07faulty items and making sure there's a robust process when
- 15:11items have come back that they're actually properly
- 15:13audited to know that it was faulty and the customer hasn't
- 15:16just said it was faulty to get it returned is most, most
- 15:20businesses do and should have rebates negotiated with
- 15:23suppliers for a certain percentage write off knowing
- 15:27that a certain percentage will always be faulty.
- 15:29And that means that rebate's built into the commercials and
- 15:31you don't have to go through a discussion point with your
- 15:33supplier to get that money back. But you might find your rebate's
- 15:37undercut if the fault rate's higher than the rebate allows or
- 15:40you're losing money. So you need to basically be
- 15:43ensuring your trackless data and renegotiating constantly with
- 15:46suppliers and also pushing back if one supplier and you might
- 15:50have different suppliers for the same product as well.
- 15:52If one supplier's fault rent's far higher, then maybe you've
- 15:55got supplier issue that's contributing to your returns
- 15:58rate that you should be tackling head on.
- 16:01What else in terms of like the the commercial issues and why
- 16:04this needs to be taken more seriously?
- 16:06So another point that you've put here that we've already touched
- 16:09on a little bit, it's just that impact on repeat purchase.
- 16:12And yeah, I do think again, when I have worked with more mature
- 16:16businesses where they've had someone that's really analyzing
- 16:19the date or in fact doing or like the impact of a bad returns
- 16:23experience, it does impact the lifetime value that customer or
- 16:27the likelihood of them repeat purchasing.
- 16:30So I think that to me that and then the margin impact of those,
- 16:35you know, points from the first point I think are the biggest
- 16:38one. Yeah, exactly.
- 16:39And also if you have just a generic returns policy, which is
- 16:44a lot, a lot of simple ones are you send it back to us, we give
- 16:48you a refund after we've got the item back.
- 16:50That's the most basic level for E com.
- 16:52We don't have system sophistication or the teams to
- 16:54manage it. The problem with that is some of
- 16:56your margins, some of your margins on a product are social,
- 17:00especially when you're in high discount land.
- 17:03The returning doesn't always make sense.
- 17:05And you've seen more and more brands, especially those with
- 17:08sustainability at their heart who are trying to reduce like
- 17:11the carbon footprint. This process of saying, well
- 17:14actually it is better that you keep this item, you can give it
- 17:18away, can you just take it to a recycling centre?
- 17:21It's more environmentally ethical and also better cost
- 17:25around rather than you ranging a Courier send them back to us, us
- 17:28for receipts in a warehouse, us then taking it somewhere else to
- 17:30dispose. So you've also got to think
- 17:32about the use cases for when you should and shouldn't be getting
- 17:36items returns back to you. Next big question.
- 17:41Why don't you go first on this? Because I think this is an area
- 17:43where there isn't a clear definition and and retailers are
- 17:46really trying to find the balancing point is what does
- 17:48fair usage mean in, in the context of this is where it's
- 17:51going to right fair usage. You can get free returns or the,
- 17:55you know, access to our, our standard return service if it's
- 17:59fair usage. But if it's not fair usage, then
- 18:01we start to charge. Yeah.
- 18:03So I think and again I think ASOS were quite was it ASOS?
- 18:06I think it was ASOS there and they were working with, I
- 18:10believe as I said are based in Sweden for this project.
- 18:13They did a piece where they essentially just analyzed a lot
- 18:17more of this at customer level. And essentially the fair usage
- 18:22policy, I think was like free returns for their first return.
- 18:26And then basically you would get more like you'd get more of an
- 18:33allowance essentially as you purchase more without returning.
- 18:38And then essentially our customer level, it was like,
- 18:41yeah, you then had a policy. And I guess that's probably
- 18:46where it will go over time. And I think, you know, AI will
- 18:49help to do that. I think the vendors continuing
- 18:52to improve around the data side would definitely help with that.
- 18:55And but I guess that's the Holy Grail where you offer a free
- 18:59return in one scenario, but as a customer then you know, becomes
- 19:03an A repeat offender or becomes less profitable or have an
- 19:07impact on margin, you then start to charge for returns.
- 19:11And I think ASOS was it ASOS that started blocking customers
- 19:14as well. I think they've been banning
- 19:16customers based on returns. Yeah, And actually it originated
- 19:20out of the US some of the big development stores out there
- 19:22started was some of the most high profile ones a couple of
- 19:25years back to start doing it. That's when it started to we got
- 19:28the winds across the the ocean to us about there and the
- 19:32initial reaction, Oh, we shouldn't be doing that.
- 19:34Fundamentally, when you pull this back to returns as a
- 19:36service, it's not a right, it, it's a, it's a statutory right
- 19:39from a, you have the right to return a, a, a faulty or unused
- 19:43product, but you don't have the right to just order loads of
- 19:45stuff and return whatever you want and not have to bear any
- 19:48responsibility. It's crazy.
- 19:51So yeah, I, I think that I think reposition it as a service
- 19:54changes perspective. When you look at it as a cost, a
- 19:56cost line to the business will impact, it has a profitability.
- 20:00You have to have fair usage. And I, I'm, I'm actually really
- 20:04behind this. I, I don't, I don't have a, as a
- 20:06consumer, I do not have an issue with it.
- 20:08A person is having to take effort to pick and pack
- 20:11something, send it to me. That's why I pay shipping.
- 20:14If I don't want it now, somebody's got to take the
- 20:17effort to get that back. And if I don't want to pay for a
- 20:19Courier, if I refuse to go, oh, you don't want to order a
- 20:22Courier and pay for a Courier, why should I expect somebody
- 20:25else to do that for me free of charge?
- 20:28Especially if I've ordered 5 items because I wasn't sure
- 20:31which one I must want. But I think you're right.
- 20:34I mean, if it really it's got to come down to how do you make it?
- 20:39How do you make a service that that is transparent to the
- 20:41consumer and isn't punishing them unfairly?
- 20:44And that's what fair usage has got to mean is you're not
- 20:46punished for returning, but you understand the implications of a
- 20:50return depending on the reason for you returning that item.
- 20:54I think to your point, you've already made a couple of times
- 20:57as well, so one around the wardrobe in concert where you
- 21:00order multiple sizes, multiple colours and then return the ones
- 21:03you don't like. And also how you approach the
- 21:06low margin point. I think there's no
- 21:10one-size-fits-all solution here. I think that's probably the big
- 21:14message. I think so your wardrobe in
- 21:16point point reminded me of how some of our clients have used
- 21:20Harper and you know, they're selling items that are, you
- 21:23know, 1000 LB A&V. Encouraging someone in in London
- 21:28in particular to use Harper essentially gives them certain
- 21:33benefits around the experience, benefits from a data perspective
- 21:36and then also means that that service agent and then take back
- 21:40the other sizes. And it's essentially addressing
- 21:43this on some level. And I guess it's like in the
- 21:46luxury segment, there probably will be different options of how
- 21:51you could maybe address this with more of an in person
- 21:54component. But when you're dealing with
- 21:57more volume, then yeah, you probably need a completely
- 22:00different policy basically. Yeah, exactly.
- 22:03And the policy's got to be nuanced, doesn't it?
- 22:06Because you've got you've got brands like Nudie Jeans and they
- 22:09Poly who have free returns in store.
- 22:12So if you're a, if you're a a stores and online retail, this
- 22:18makes perfect sense if you've got a good store base.
- 22:20Now, if you're a read, if you're ADC brand that's got two stores,
- 22:24one in London, one in Manchester, they're offering
- 22:26free returns in store, you know, appeals to a very, very limited
- 22:31metropolitan base, unfortunately.
- 22:34So if you've got decent store coverage, that's actually really
- 22:37good because then you can say, hey, look, we give you a free
- 22:39return, but if you want to send it to us and don't want to come
- 22:42to store, then there is a charge for that unless it's damaged.
- 22:45So I think you're right, it's not one-size-fits-all.
- 22:47It's got to be nuanced, but I think the key message here is
- 22:50it's got to be thought through in terms of how it lands to the
- 22:53customer. Like that that return in stall
- 22:57point as well. So Doc Martens just rolled this
- 23:00out recently. I think obviously there it can
- 23:03be complex from like an operation perspective at like
- 23:06the big scale. But almost all of the multi
- 23:10channel brands we've worked with have found that getting a
- 23:12customer into store is high value and they're more like to
- 23:15buy something else. And like you say as well all the
- 23:18way through this, I'll have a better experience.
- 23:21So I think yeah, I completely agree.
- 23:22I think that's a really good strategy.
- 23:24It's just that you'll probably only ever get a small proportion
- 23:27of customers doing it. But it is a really good point.
- 23:31Yeah, exactly. In the I, I think there, well,
- 23:34it's kind of this blends in nicely to the next point we want
- 23:37to discuss, which is like the key techniques to reduce the
- 23:40impact returns and improve or reduce the cost impact I think
- 23:44as well. So how can you minimize the
- 23:46damage because you'll always have returns.
- 23:48There will always be cost. You will not be able to offset
- 23:52all of the cost through income. I think accepting that and build
- 23:55back into your overall profit and loss stuff is really
- 23:59important. But the free returns in stores
- 24:01is 1 mitigation. I really like the way the brands
- 24:04like Nudi offer free repairs because one of the big things is
- 24:08you've got an item, you know that if it's it's got a warranty
- 24:11period and that warranty period varies from product to product
- 24:15and brand to brand. But if something happens and
- 24:17that product is substandard and it tears, for example, and I had
- 24:21this with a North Face jacket and I looked at it and North
- 24:24Face do do repairs. Repairs out of warranty are
- 24:28quite expensive, but newly offer free repairs for life.
- 24:31Now what a great way that is. And again, you've got to bring
- 24:33it in, you've got to take it to repair store and they're not
- 24:36everywhere, but I think that's a really good thing.
- 24:38What services can you provide around it where you can actually
- 24:41keep and maintain a product longer so that it's not sent
- 24:45back, where you don't have to refund it and the customer then
- 24:48perceives a probably greater value and it only suits certain
- 24:50products. What else are you?
- 24:52You obviously speak to a lot of different brands around
- 24:54supplies. What are you seeing?
- 24:56Like where are people focused? What are people really trying to
- 24:58do? And where are you advising a
- 24:59focus to help reduce earns demand?
- 25:03Yeah. So I'll answer in a second.
- 25:04I think your point on returns as well.
- 25:06Sorry, repairs, I think the really interesting one because
- 25:10the overhead of that now is so much lower than it would have
- 25:12been three years ago. There's so many third parties
- 25:15that will essentially own this for you.
- 25:18You partner with them and they will come and collect the
- 25:21product, etcetera. They will do the repair, they
- 25:23will return it. And essentially you just educate
- 25:26them and give them the information, etcetera.
- 25:29And the cost is relatively low. And again, going back to that
- 25:33experience point that it's such a positive experience if you've
- 25:36got an item that might have, yeah, I guess, need repair
- 25:40either straight away and you might take the hit or further
- 25:42down the line. And even if you charge the
- 25:44customer, it's such a good experience.
- 25:47I think we were going to do an episode with Sojo at one point,
- 25:49which we should revisit. So they're the one that a lot of
- 25:51our clients use. But there's so many vendors out
- 25:54on this space and the overhead is so much lower.
- 25:59I guess the biggest thing for our clients is just trying to
- 26:01prevent the return and that's the I and like there's obviously
- 26:05I would say that. And then also using vendors,
- 26:08you've mentioned swap a few times in here who have obviously
- 26:10been a podcast in the past, Loopers and I've won our clients
- 26:14use various others. But I guess that front end
- 26:18experience around the return and in trying to incentivize
- 26:22exchanges and all that would be one.
- 26:25But by far the biggest one would be trying to prevent a return in
- 26:28the 1st place. And that's just trying to
- 26:30basically surface as much information around size.
- 26:33And that again, given that we're the only thing I would add that
- 26:37I should always caveat is that we're almost, well, we're very,
- 26:40very fashion focused. And in that vertical majority of
- 26:45the returns are going to be size and fit.
- 26:47And so just trying to surface as much information around the
- 26:50measurements, trying to surface as much information from real
- 26:53customers around their size, as much kind of imagery content,
- 27:00Yeah, and just add as much context in those areas.
- 27:03So I'd say that's probably the bit that we're most involved in
- 27:06personally. Yeah, and we did a podcast last
- 27:11week, which is around 14 examples of brands who are doing
- 27:14standard E com features just a bit better.
- 27:16Yeah. And one of the ones I liked that
- 27:18you bought out was around better use of of product reviews.
- 27:22So not just did you like it, how much would you rate it?
- 27:26And give us a few words, but actually very specific elements
- 27:29of gym shop doing it as one example.
- 27:30There are others as well where it's how did this fit, you know,
- 27:34was this was, was it the right length?
- 27:37So getting very specific facets of the product fed back at that
- 27:42product level to be able to then do an assessment of whether
- 27:44there are specific fit issues with particular garments,
- 27:47particular suppliers, etcetera. I think anything where the data
- 27:51granularity gets deeper is better because you get more
- 27:53intelligence. The other one that I think is
- 27:57really smart is where, where instead of like free returns is,
- 28:03yeah, you're just going to get it being able to say to people,
- 28:07right, if you just want to send back and get a refund, there's a
- 28:10charge for the return. However, if you're willing to
- 28:13excha to transfer that product to store credit, we'll also we
- 28:18won't charge you for that return because then say you've got a 60
- 28:21LB pair of jeans, instead of having to now refund that item,
- 28:24but they pay 395% back to you, they're not paying.
- 28:29They keep you get the item back and it's in good condition.
- 28:34It can go on for resale and that £60 goes into store credit,
- 28:38which means that they will you reuse it on another order and
- 28:40you keep them. Hopefully you keep them happier,
- 28:43but you take them within a purchase journey and that should
- 28:47give you a great chance to turn it into future orders and get
- 28:49get the lifetime value up to then recoup the cost of that
- 28:53return. The the other, the next level of
- 28:56that that you see a bit in the fast fashion space is rather
- 28:59than offer you the £60 value because of the margin here and
- 29:04you know the operational here people, they'll actually offer
- 29:07you like 120 a 130% the value to further incentivize the store
- 29:13credit or exchange rate. Yeah, yeah, it's interesting.
- 29:18I, I know I've worked the few businesses where from policy
- 29:21level they've evolved customer service 5 frameworks to offer
- 29:26store credit for it turns out the policy window.
- 29:28So where they've got quite a loyal customer base, they don't
- 29:30want to piss them off, but they don't want to have this endless
- 29:34like Zappos has three, you know, 365 all year round.
- 29:38You're out of your 30 day window.
- 29:40Fine, we'll accept the return, but it's going into store credit
- 29:43rather than a refund. And once it's been communicated
- 29:47as to why that's happening and the reason for the need to do
- 29:49it, actually it's landed pretty well with customers because it's
- 29:52communicated clearly and the customer understands that
- 29:54they're not being punished and that that money is there for
- 29:56them to to reuse. Yeah, makes sense.
- 30:01Let's talk about the key point then, because you, you raised
- 30:05this when we were planning this episode about the link between
- 30:07return service and loyalty and where this is going.
- 30:09And that free return still fundamentally has a place, but
- 30:12it's judicious use of it. So do you want to talk me
- 30:15through where, where, where are you seeing this?
- 30:17What is the between returns and what?
- 30:19Yeah. So I think there's big trend at
- 30:20the moment, both loyalty and just data collection in general.
- 30:25There's a big trend around people being willing to offer
- 30:28free shipping, free returns in exchange for either.
- 30:34They'll offer it to loyal customers, which I think makes
- 30:36perfect sense in terms of creating like tangible value and
- 30:39experience value for being a loyal customer and then trying
- 30:43to continue to push the value of that customer.
- 30:46I think that makes perfect sense.
- 30:47But I would say also some people like Jay Lindbergh and lots of
- 30:52other brands, Solomon, who else, Basically if you build an
- 30:57account and as part of that account you provide certain data
- 31:00points that they can then push into their CDP and use for
- 31:03personalization and CRM etcetera, you will get free
- 31:08shipping and returns. And quite a few of our clients
- 31:10have started doing this or are in the process of doing this at
- 31:13the moment. And to be fair, it does kind of
- 31:16make sense. So I think obviously it's a
- 31:19massive incentive to actually hand over the data or build an
- 31:22account that you might not even really do, you know, feel like
- 31:25you're doing too much, but it's just a nicer way to do it as
- 31:29well. But yeah, the other point was
- 31:31building into your loyalty program and and there's some
- 31:34customers that have gone beyond as well.
- 31:36So like they'll come and collect the item for free and Hugo Boss
- 31:41off that receipt less returns, which I really like.
- 31:43So if you're a certain tier of their loyalty program, you don't
- 31:46need it receipt, you can just return at any point.
- 31:49And there's various other examples of that where it's been
- 31:53pushed a bit harder. But I mean, realistically with,
- 31:56I guess loyalty, like you said, the star, it's like you're
- 31:59trying to find those points of friction and turn them into like
- 32:03really great experiences. And it's just another reason to
- 32:08stay loyal to a brand. Yeah.
- 32:11I think the key point here is is that customers need to be
- 32:14profitable because if customers aren't profitable, a business
- 32:16goes out business and it can't then, you know, provide that
- 32:20service anymore And making people educating people that
- 32:23understand that, but rewarding them for the the more they
- 32:26contribute to your business. It's just absolutely no brainer,
- 32:29isn't it? Don't punish people for not
- 32:31spending much and not being a frequent customer, but don't
- 32:35reward them for that as well. Then in the next point, before
- 32:42we come to the roundup of where's this headed?
- 32:43What's the future it turns is is the where what's happening in
- 32:47the tech space. So a few things that I that I've
- 32:49definitely been noticing in terms of where people are
- 32:51focused and where my clients effort is evolving from the
- 32:55basic of hey, we've got an online form you can fill out and
- 32:58send it to us. And then somebody who will get
- 32:59in contact is using the the you know, model generation of live
- 33:05chat AI bots to pre program flows for return.
- 33:09So Rattenboer, for example, do this using certainly where
- 33:13you've got a a standard like pails.
- 33:15It's like, what do you want to do?
- 33:16You can do, you can have your standard chat that you have I
- 33:18want to initiate return, check all the status pre programmed
- 33:21flows, which then enable you to log in or to put in your order
- 33:25number that gets validated. Then you can send a return
- 33:28request, add the return information that is pushed
- 33:31through a particular process flow.
- 33:33Where that ends up is obviously where you want it to could be in
- 33:36a customer service queue. It could be to specific
- 33:38individual, but I think I think things like that help the
- 33:42customer experience bit. And what we're trying to do, we
- 33:44said is like the move towards reducing friction, seeing this
- 33:47as a service. And by doing that, you're,
- 33:49you're providing better tooling and more people are getting used
- 33:53to this as an easy interaction. And then the second bit build on
- 33:56top of that, I'm actually working with the customer list
- 33:58at the moment is whether it's a request formal line or whether
- 34:02it's through an AI bot or whatever that mechanism is that
- 34:05you have a process that automatically pushes that into
- 34:07customer service ticketing solutions.
- 34:09So it automatically generates ticket with the tag of return,
- 34:13which enables that to be flow to specific customer service reps
- 34:16who are responsible for handling returns.
- 34:19I mean, if people in B2B, if you've got assigned specific
- 34:22accounts and obviously it can put it into your workload as
- 34:25well. But this improves visibility and
- 34:27speed of response because it will take tickets rather than
- 34:29somebody having to go and pick up like an inbox message, then
- 34:31go and create a customer ticket. 1 brand I work with in food
- 34:37space good saw a 50% reduction in their inbound ticket
- 34:42inquiries for like returns information simply by adding
- 34:47that AI live chat thing. So it can have a fundamental
- 34:53impact on on like team efficiency and help people focus
- 34:56on value add. So that's what I'm seeing in the
- 34:59tech and automation. What what have you noticed as
- 35:02well? Recent trends and developments?
- 35:04I think I think you've covered most of it, to be honest.
- 35:06I think the bit that I was going to say is I think it's going to
- 35:09be super interesting to see where this is in two years.
- 35:12One, from an AI perspective and you know, how much more
- 35:15intelligence I'll be behind this and how much like data sharing
- 35:18that could exist with some of the vendors.
- 35:21And two, how much consolidation we'll see because you're talking
- 35:25here about integration with live chat and chat bots and stuff
- 35:29like that. And it'd be interesting.
- 35:31I mean, if you look at a business like gorgeous, I guess
- 35:33the their own in more and more of that customer service piece
- 35:37and more areas around it. Like does it make sense to them
- 35:40to also offer returns and build that into the flow entirely?
- 35:46Yeah. So I think it'll be, I think
- 35:48it'll be interesting to see and equally, you know, someone like
- 35:51Luke as well, like they're a really, you know, big scale,
- 35:55just covenantly cover and returns exchanges some other CX
- 35:59bits like yeah, it'll just be interesting to see where all of
- 36:01this goes. And, and I think the bit that's
- 36:04still missing for me is the data on the impact of returns at
- 36:08different level. And again, I think AI could
- 36:11definitely solve that, but it's just yeah, where that sits
- 36:16within different vendors and the different parts of the stack.
- 36:20Yeah, agreed. And and I know a lot of
- 36:23businesses where they have a very manual process in the
- 36:25warehouse. So and that's where the data
- 36:27points fall down. So items come back in, they're
- 36:30not scanned, there isn't an automatic notification and it's
- 36:34fed back through via the WMS into whatever back office
- 36:38system, which is then connected to E com.
- 36:40So at an E com account level, you typically see the the refund
- 36:46because the refund's often processed in the the payment
- 36:50gateway that's connected to the E com store.
- 36:52So at least you see that the customer account level and you
- 36:54see that in your admin back end, but you don't see the return
- 36:56status and therefore you have gaps in in knowledge and data.
- 37:00So yeah, I agree the data bit's critical.
- 37:02So we're not going to talk about today about the the specialist
- 37:06dedicated RMA platforms license like swap, Nava, loop, etcetera,
- 37:11simply because I mean that we have covered it previously,
- 37:15although probably about a year or so ago and there's a lot of
- 37:19deep functionality there. We wouldn't be doing it justice
- 37:21if we tried to talk about how those systems are used.
- 37:25But I think let's, let's let's close this off, which is a
- 37:29summary of where this is heading.
- 37:31So do you want to do your what? What are your points in terms of
- 37:34strategically where is returns headed in ECO?
- 37:37Yes, I think I just kind of touched on it there a little
- 37:39bit. I think in terms of data across
- 37:41the whole piece. The other thing that I would
- 37:44say, I think this will all be and has already all been
- 37:47accelerated and will continue to be accelerated as a result of
- 37:51more a higher proportion of brands using the same
- 37:54technologies. So be that the third party
- 37:58returns vendors that we've just talked about, be that Shopify
- 38:01obviously the same ERP solutions etcetera, I think and also you
- 38:07know things like unify and returns reasons.
- 38:09And I just think the data is just getting much cleaner and
- 38:12easier to work with. So I think that will make a lot
- 38:16of this stuff easier and there'll be a lot more room for
- 38:20automation and intelligence. Yeah, agreed.
- 38:25And and my, my key points and take away just started this
- 38:29episode with is, is you should be seeing returns as a service,
- 38:33not a policy. Yes, you've got to have a policy
- 38:35in place and it's got to be compliant, but fundamentally
- 38:39this is about the customer experience.
- 38:40And if you don't understand the impact on the customer and the
- 38:44friction that's being created and try and remove that, then
- 38:47fundamentally returns is always going to be seen as a hassle and
- 38:50it's going to cause you problems and headaches that won't go away
- 38:53unless you flip that thing in. Paid is the new 3.
- 38:57That's my pithy headline grabber.
- 39:02But that doesn't mean that everyone should pay all the
- 39:04time. You have to decide what are the
- 39:07rules for when people pay them or they're not, but you also
- 39:10have to give your customer service team that flexibility to
- 39:13respond and waive for that if there is an, you know, born
- 39:17customer or, or if there's a use case where actually do you know
- 39:20what the the grief that it caused by not actually being
- 39:22flexible is, is, you know, is not sustainable.
- 39:28And then I think the other thing is, is just when you are
- 39:31charging to make life easier for the customer, and one good
- 39:35example of this is don't make them pay for it upfront.
- 39:38The the ideal way is that it's deducted from the cost of the
- 39:41refund. That's one part of a policy of
- 39:44send it back, we'll refund, but we'll take the return fee out.
- 39:47You don't have to pay any extra. Don't worry.
- 39:49There are little things that can make this more palatable base.
- 39:53Yeah, agreed on that one for sure.
- 39:55And then, yeah, I think the other one for mine is just, it
- 40:00comes back to yours as well. It's like, yeah, offering free
- 40:03returns to the right customers rather than people that, you
- 40:09know, have, you know, had high return rates in the past or even
- 40:13new customers. So trying to think of a reason
- 40:17to justify taking the hit I guess on the return.
- 40:20Yeah. And the, the other one that we
- 40:22talked about, but I'm not sure how this will play out is where,
- 40:26where the larger retailers have like a delivery subscription
- 40:29service where you pay 10 pounds, £20 a year to get free delivery
- 40:34standard deliveries. Expanding that to now do a, a
- 40:39additional one where, OK, you take this tier and you get free
- 40:42delivery and returns wrapped up and you pay US money.
- 40:45And, and therefore we know that that's probably going to cover
- 40:48some of the, the hit to our margin.
- 40:51But I think that's, that's an area that needs a lot more, lot
- 40:54more model. And as you say, the data often
- 40:55isn't there for people to do this.
- 40:59Cool. Well, that brings us to the end.
- 41:01I'm sure me and Paul could talk about this for a lot longer, as
- 41:03you can probably tell. So an area we both feel quite
- 41:06passionately about because it's critical to to ECOM success,
- 41:09margin and customer happiness. Let's know what you think.
- 41:13Anything in this you disagree with, anything you think we've
- 41:15missed? What what have you learned?
- 41:17What works for you? What does good returns look?
- 41:19And what tech do you use to help provide the right service to
- 41:22customers? We always love hearing back from
- 41:24everyone else. Hope you found it useful.
- 41:26Until next week everyone, you're listening to the Inside Commerce
- 41:30podcast. Hosted by experienced
- 41:32consultants James Gert and Paul Rogers, Inside Commerce is your
- 41:35fast track to digital knowledge, featuring interviews with
- 41:38leading e-commerce retailers, industry thought leads and the
- 41:41C-Suite, key tech companies to explore the latest digital
- 41:44strategy, customer experience and tech.
- 41:46Discover what the latest trends really mean and get practical
- 41:49advice based on the experience to help fine tune your
- 41:51e-commerce strategy and tech stack.
- 41:53Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 41:56like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 41:58We hope you enjoy the latest episode.