Latest / 21andsensory Podcast / Episode 86: Special Guest, Professor Janet Harbord ('Autism Plays Itself' Video Essay)
Transcript
- 0:00Hi everyone, welcome back to the 21 and Sensory podcast with me,
- 0:04Emily. Today I have special guest
- 0:07Professor Janet Harper on the show.
- 0:10Janet is a professor of film studies at Queen Mary,
- 0:13University of London. Recently she has worked as a
- 0:17Principal investigator alongside Stephen Eastwood on a six year
- 0:21Welcome Trust funded project called Autism Through Cinema.
- 0:26Autism Through Cinema was a collaborative investigation into
- 0:29the relationships between neurodivergent thinking and
- 0:32cinematic creation. Through the formation of a
- 0:36collective of autistic film makers, a reimagining of medical
- 0:40films and an exploratory podcast, the project sought out
- 0:44the rich interactions of autistic experiences with the
- 0:47moving image. Janet is on today's episode to
- 0:51chat about her work directing a video essay called Autism Plays
- 0:55Itself, where she asks how films made in clinical settings have
- 1:00contributed to how autism has been medically imagined and
- 1:03defined across the past 70 years.
- 1:07Janet takes one such clinical film and works in collaboration
- 1:11with autistic respondents. Really excited to chat to Janet
- 1:14about her work and yeah, would you like to say hello?
- 1:17Hi. Hi.
- 1:18It's an absolute pleasure to be here and to be discussing the
- 1:21film with you. Thank you.
- 1:23I really appreciate that. Trying to find a time to both
- 1:28record, but we managed it and yeah, I'm really excited to chat
- 1:31to you about it. I have very kindly been given
- 1:35access to the film, so I have watched it.
- 1:39I did make notes, so maybe you could give us a bit of kind of
- 1:44background as to how this kind of video essay came about, and
- 1:49then maybe we could talk more about kind of directing it.
- 1:51Yeah, sure. So the project was thinking
- 1:55about the relationship between autism and cinema, not so much
- 1:59in terms of the content of things like Rayman for example,
- 2:04which have become real fixed stereotypes, but in terms of how
- 2:08cinema in lots of different ways has has shaped our experience of
- 2:13autism and particularly around the affinities of of the form of
- 2:19films. So how does film work in terms
- 2:21of close-ups, editing, repetitions, patterns?
- 2:25So those sorts of things were our focus rather than character
- 2:28driven narratives. And my particular angle on this
- 2:31was looking at the history of medical films.
- 2:34And I was working with the historian Bonnie Evans, who has
- 2:37written a fabulous book about the history of autism called
- 2:41called The Metamorphosis of Autism.
- 2:44And she had identified a film from 1957 as the first mention
- 2:50of autism in a clinical setting in a clinical film.
- 2:54And so we did a lot more work around archives and we didn't
- 2:57find anything earlier than that. So that film became incredibly
- 3:00important. It's a 30 minute film.
- 3:04It's a silent film shot at the Maudsky Hospital in South
- 3:08London. It shot in the children's unit,
- 3:12which was quite a small new unit in the 1950s, where the purpose
- 3:19was to observe children, to try and sort of hone different
- 3:24diagnostic categories, classifications.
- 3:28And the way in which they were doing that we can see in the
- 3:31film is to isolate certain what they would cause symptoms and
- 3:37record those and create intertitle cards with the
- 3:42medical explanation that came before and after the short clip.
- 3:46So the original film is 30 minutes long, as I say, and 1/3
- 3:51of that is sort of medical explanations of what we're
- 3:55seeing the the children's behaviour in medical
- 3:57interpretations. And it's a really difficult film
- 4:01to watch. And, and Bonnie and I were both
- 4:03presenting at conferences with showing extracts from films.
- 4:07And people were saying to us, you know, actually it's, it's,
- 4:10it's, it's a bit traumatic watching these children.
- 4:12They look so unhappy. And we also were doing some
- 4:17workshops with Project Artworks in Hastings.
- 4:20Project Artworks is an arts organization working with people
- 4:25with complex needs. And the workshops we did there,
- 4:30we invited autistic people to come in and view a selection of
- 4:34film extracts. And we had a range of things
- 4:37like Buster Keaton. We had some quite, you know,
- 4:40some quite cool entertainment films to sort of entice people.
- 4:43And interspersed between that, we had kind of these pretty
- 4:46awful medical films. And what we noticed is that
- 4:49people just avoided them. You know, no, no one wanted to
- 4:51go near them. There was no recognition from
- 4:56the autistic people who we were there with that, that these
- 4:59children had anything in common with them.
- 5:01So really we spent, you know, a year or two getting nowhere with
- 5:04this. And I was almost sort of
- 5:06abandoning the idea that there was anything worth saying about
- 5:10medical film other than quite, quite a dry academic way to
- 5:14quite a small academic audience. And then I worked on a podcast
- 5:20with a group of autistic people and we developed that during
- 5:24COVID. We became quite close.
- 5:28We had an audience who were writing into us and saying, oh,
- 5:31you know, this is this reminds me of this film.
- 5:34I'd really love to come on your podcast and talk about it.
- 5:36And so we did as we sort of built this audience around
- 5:39autism through cinema and I began to kind of test out some
- 5:44ideas with those people. And I was thinking, actually, I
- 5:46wonder now that I have established relationships with,
- 5:49with people, I wonder what they would, you know, whether they'd
- 5:52be prepared to, to have a look at this film and, and see if
- 5:55they can interpret what the children are doing, see if they
- 5:58can speculate, free associate, whether they have any
- 6:01identification with these children.
- 6:05And so that's what happened. And of course we had to do risk
- 6:08assessments first. You know, the last thing I
- 6:11wanted to do was was traumatise people.
- 6:14But all three participants decided not to see the film in
- 6:18advance. So I gave them a kind of, you
- 6:20know, a bunch of trigger warning type descriptions of some of the
- 6:24things that are in the film. And I recorded with each of them
- 6:30individually in a studio in Soho last summer.
- 6:34And that was the first time they'd seen it.
- 6:36And that was the first time they'd seen it.
- 6:38Yeah. So Ash, look.
- 6:40Yeah, it was. And it's it felt, it felt quite
- 6:45intense sitting, sitting next to people where they're watching
- 6:50these images of these children. I had removed.
- 6:53I should say that actually, I've removed the medical intertitle
- 6:55cards. So there was no medical
- 6:57descriptions, just the extracts, short extracts of children in
- 7:02the children's unit. So the the you see the children
- 7:05doing things like playing with sand, being offered sweets,
- 7:10being given milk and then things being taken away from them, sort
- 7:14of slight provocations. And then also just recordings of
- 7:20children who are ticking in various ways and stimming.
- 7:25So a range of different sort of quite disjointed sorts of
- 7:29behaviours and scenarios that that we get to see.
- 7:34Yeah. So that's, that's, that's the
- 7:36background to what we did. Do you want me to kind of carry
- 7:41on describing how we how we worked in the studio?
- 7:44I think it, yeah, it'd be interesting to know kind of how
- 7:48from kind of start to finish, how long did you spend on this
- 7:51kind of, you know, crafting this video essay from the very start
- 7:54as well. That would be interesting to
- 7:55know. Sure.
- 7:57So, well, I had the idea for it several years ago as it sort of
- 8:01generally evolved through the project, but we actually made
- 8:05the film in quite a short amount of time.
- 8:07So we recorded in May and June last year.
- 8:10So I, I worked with each participant separately and we
- 8:16were in the studio for about three or four hours, taking lots
- 8:22of breaks, having a, a, a breakout space with the studio,
- 8:28trying to take it quite, you know, quite, quite carefully,
- 8:31quite easily with each of them. And I think, I think in some
- 8:35moments it was quite, quite hard for them to watch some of the
- 8:39images in the films. And some of the responses were
- 8:42quite emphatic, quite, you know, sort of speaking back to, to the
- 8:46film, like, you know, don't do that to that child, that, that
- 8:49sort of sense. But also quite a lot of witty,
- 8:53insightful comments about, about the people who are making the
- 8:57film or the, the, the nurses that you see in the backgrounds,
- 9:01kind of shady figures. And but more than anything, a
- 9:06really, really high level of identification with the
- 9:10liveliness and sort of life force of these children and
- 9:15descriptions and interpretations of what the children are doing
- 9:18and thinking and seeing that just opened it up for me as
- 9:22someone who isn't autistic. Just the film just blossomed
- 9:26into this completely different thing where I could see the
- 9:30children as individuals for the first time and outside of this
- 9:34institutional framework. Yeah.
- 9:39So it was a it was a really sort of moving experience.
- 9:42I think it was, it was, it was it was incredibly rewarding.
- 9:50And also it was it just flowed, which was quite extraordinary.
- 9:54Each of the participants had a very different take.
- 9:58Ashley Lloydon, who is a graphic designer, artist, he had a very
- 10:04sort of engaged response to the film, thinking about his own
- 10:08children and thinking about how diagnosis takes place and how
- 10:14diagnostic categories overlook the cleverness that is there in
- 10:17children's behaviour. So he was very good at
- 10:19identifying, in fact, how, you know, how smart the children
- 10:23were and how this was not being picked up on in in the hospital
- 10:28at all, but being ticked off as some sort of pathology of Sophie
- 10:33Broadgate, who's a film maker. And she was very interested in
- 10:39the rhythms and sort of physical movements and repetitions that
- 10:46the children were involved in all of the time.
- 10:49And her take is that all autistic people are are dancers
- 10:53have a relationship to rhythm and and dance sort of naturally.
- 10:57And towards the end of this film, there is a sequence of a
- 11:00girl out in the garden and it's quite beautiful.
- 11:02And Sophie's glossing of that is, really brings it to life
- 11:06that this, this girl is sort of communing with the different
- 11:09shrubs and flowers and rocks that we see.
- 11:12And it's very rhythmic. It's it, you know, it's, it's,
- 11:15it is like contemporary dance, as she says.
- 11:18And then the third participant was Ethan Lyon.
- 11:21And Ethan had been a student at Queen Mary.
- 11:24So I've known Ethan since about 2013 and Ethan to take was, I
- 11:29think more critical of the three of them into of, of, of the
- 11:32hospital context, but very, very powerful his in his
- 11:39interpretation of what the children wanted.
- 11:41And it also evoked a lot of memories for him in terms of,
- 11:46you know, his own diagnosis and his own enjoyment in childhood
- 11:50of lining up toys and things like this.
- 11:51So yeah, that's, that's that was the experience of, of being in
- 11:56the studio with each of them. I had Alex Widderson recording
- 12:01the sound, who is a new Divergent animator, so he was in
- 12:06the room too. It was just the three of us each
- 12:08time. And I had a lot of material to,
- 12:11you know, get down to about 1520 minutes of these three
- 12:16interviews. So I went away thinking, oh,
- 12:18this is yeah, this is going to be terrible.
- 12:19This is going to take me a year just to to create a paper edit.
- 12:24But in fact, it didn't it it, it was very intuitive.
- 12:27They each had something very different to offer.
- 12:30And it was really just a question of, of going for that
- 12:33through, going through the material and picking out the
- 12:36differences. And it, it seemed to me then at
- 12:38that point that I wasn't making a film about interpretations of
- 12:42the past only. I was also making a film about
- 12:45each of them. So that that that became, you
- 12:48know, very significant. And I hadn't really understood
- 12:51that before, before we went to the studio, that in fact this
- 12:54was as much about those three people in the present as it is
- 12:58about those children. That was a really, that was
- 13:02really fascinating to kind of hear you break it down more
- 13:05because kind of like you say, like I've just seen the kind of
- 13:0918 minutes and, you know, not realising that it was kind of,
- 13:14you know, put to them on the day to kind of talk over this.
- 13:17And yeah, you kind of think that if you're spending three to four
- 13:20hours with someone that that would be hard to cut down.
- 13:23But from from my kind of point of view, like exactly as you
- 13:30said, they were all had such different kind of reactions, but
- 13:34also like pushback as well as to what was the, you know, what
- 13:38they were watching. And I think also a lot of
- 13:43listeners might not appreciate that the kind of editing and the
- 13:49sound design and all these like little things that that add to
- 13:53this kind of, I don't know, it's, it's uncomfy to watch.
- 13:58It gets more comfortable because you're like, oh, actually, you
- 14:01know, they are kind of being themselves.
- 14:03And I think, I can't remember who said it, but someone said
- 14:07there's just something about the freeness of being autistic that
- 14:10frightens people. Yes.
- 14:12That's. And that was just that hit me.
- 14:14Yeah. Yeah, absolutely.
- 14:16That's, that's Ash towards the beginning when we see one boy
- 14:21who has quite, quite exaggerated stimming movements or rocking
- 14:28movements and he rocks as he moves forward across the room.
- 14:33And I that's, I mean, that's one of the more difficult images in
- 14:37the film's film. And I think that his, his take
- 14:40on that, you know, that it, that it frightens people that, but
- 14:44it's a kind of freeness in, in being and moving as a beautiful
- 14:49way of, of putting it. And I think it was important
- 14:51that that came quite early in the film.
- 14:54I mean, one, one of the things you're talking about the, the
- 14:57editing and how how to put this together.
- 15:00And one of the issues that we had quite early on, I, I worked
- 15:04with Sasha Litvin Saver, who's a fabulous film maker and she's a
- 15:08colleague of mine at Queen Mary. And we had extensive
- 15:12conversations about how we might edit it beforehand.
- 15:14And I was saying to her, the problem that I think we're going
- 15:18to have is that I'm going to have three lots of commentary on
- 15:23one short sequence. So the sequences are only about
- 15:2710, possibly 12 seconds long, at the most, about 20 seconds long.
- 15:32And that's really not very long to have someone narrate it,
- 15:36someone make a comment over it. So how are we going to cope with
- 15:40having really long comments and a really short sequence?
- 15:43I mean, either you need to cut to black and hear the voice
- 15:47without the image or, or what else, or, or we slow it down.
- 15:52And so we, we tried slow motion with it.
- 15:55And slow motion is not something that I'm a fan of.
- 15:58I find whenever you slow, whenever you get slow motion in
- 16:01TV or film, it tends to suggest, here's a really profound epic
- 16:06moment. You know, it's, it's used very
- 16:08well by a filmmaker like Wonka Y who has these, you know, this
- 16:12beautiful big soundtrack. And we see someone very
- 16:15melancholic in slow motion walking through a street in Hong
- 16:19Kong looking hard, heartbroken. And it's this, this great
- 16:22pathos. But it it, it, it's sort of
- 16:25problematic in a situation like this where, you know, it's just
- 16:27so loaded in terms of making something look profound and sort
- 16:31of asking the audience to have this kind of this, this
- 16:35connection to it where they're they're it just felt a bit
- 16:38manipulative. So that was just not going to
- 16:41happen right from the beginning. Like, no, slow motion won't
- 16:44work. So thinking more about the edit,
- 16:47we began to think about the editing as a form of stimming.
- 16:50And could we use editing on loops just like stimming is a
- 16:55form of looping. And going with, you know, Sophie
- 16:58Broadgate's sense of, of the children needing feedback, you
- 17:02know, she talks about this a lot in their bodies, what they're
- 17:04doing when they're rocking from foot to foot or, you know, hand
- 17:08flapping, They are actually getting feedback from the world
- 17:13in a, in a particular way, making the air move, feeling the
- 17:16ground beneath their feet. And so we started to think about
- 17:19editing as, as something as enhancing or amplifying what the
- 17:22children were doing. And that's really what, what the
- 17:25film does. And I, I, I mean, I hope that
- 17:28that works for people. It certainly works for me.
- 17:30I think that it invites a sort of liveliness in, in our
- 17:35responses, our bodily responses to to the children's movements
- 17:41in in the film. And I found myself, I mean, one
- 17:44last comment on that. I found myself at night after I
- 17:47watched this footage, You know, like, like you do when you're
- 17:49looking at edits and you're working with material you go
- 17:51over and every I, I just found myself beginning to mimic what
- 17:56some of the children were doing. And there's particularly one
- 17:58girl in the film whose movement, whose expression and movement I
- 18:03absolutely love. It's the girl who uses her skirt
- 18:06as a as a tool, as as Ash puts it.
- 18:10Though you probably remember this bit too.
- 18:11She's the door's in the middle of the film.
- 18:13She's a little, quite a small blonde child sits cross legged
- 18:17on the floor, puts toys in her skirt.
- 18:21And she has this sort of like, almost like a hiccup.
- 18:23She's but she's not hiccuping. She's sort of, her body sort of
- 18:26lifts up and her eyes move up at the same moment and her
- 18:30expression is just so joyful and cheeky.
- 18:33And then she moves off and, and, and off screen carrying these,
- 18:38these toys in her skirt. And I just found myself just
- 18:41wanting to, to do that movement, rehearse that movement myself.
- 18:45So there's something about the editing and the repetition that
- 18:48that sort of was, you know, infectious.
- 18:52It sort of moved, it moved me into a space of, of feeling the
- 18:56rhythms of, of what the children 70 years ago were doing.
- 18:59And that seemed pretty fantastic.
- 19:01Yeah, definitely. And the way you're saying that
- 19:03the editing is kind of reflective of stimming, like
- 19:07I've definitely got that through the kind of like rhythm of the
- 19:11kind of sound design on top of, you know, how it was edited, but
- 19:14also just kind of through the looping.
- 19:18I felt like each time the kind of loop, you know, reset almost
- 19:23and went back to the start it I'd almost kind of noticed
- 19:27another thing that the like, like I don't know, focus on the
- 19:31feet this time or like focus on their facial expression like it
- 19:34gave you more opportunity to watch, I think.
- 19:37Right. Yes, yes.
- 19:39In a good way. Yeah, yeah, that's, that's,
- 19:41that's interesting that you could, you could see more each
- 19:43time you go back to. It.
- 19:44Yeah. And I found myself also, I think
- 19:47there was one point where where someone said like, whoa, whoa,
- 19:51like wait, let's go back kind of thing, like that expression that
- 19:55one of the children was doing. And I found after I'd watched it
- 19:59kind of through, I went back to that bit because I was like, I
- 20:02wonder if I can see what he sees in it kind of thing.
- 20:05So I found myself going back over it just to see kind of what
- 20:10I could see a second time sort of thing.
- 20:12So I thought that was quite interesting because I feel like.
- 20:15And I wouldn't necessarily kind of do that with a video
- 20:19normally. So I was trying to see what
- 20:22their what the kind of participants saw.
- 20:25Yes, yes. And I, I think that that's,
- 20:27that's one of the sequences from the film that was powerful for
- 20:31all of us of a boy sitting on a nurse's lap looking directly
- 20:35into camera. And he has one of the most
- 20:39sustained looks into the camera, which of course, in most film
- 20:45making is taboo. You know, the one thing actors
- 20:47are not meant to do or even a documentary film, they're meant
- 20:51to be talking to someone, not not into the camera.
- 20:55So it, it, it's a sort of, it creates a strange moment, but
- 20:59it's a moment in which it, it looks as though the child might
- 21:05be understanding that, that, that he is being recorded and
- 21:13the, the. Yeah, but the, the camera is
- 21:15doing something that is not just a toy.
- 21:20I think that's kind of what I get from that sequence.
- 21:24And I think that's when Ethan has that lovely line of it's the
- 21:28face of someone who's just understood something.
- 21:31Yeah. Always like recognising that
- 21:33flicker come across someone's face and that was the bit I went
- 21:36back to. I was like, can I see that?
- 21:38Yes, yeah. Yeah, and also what you said
- 21:41about the girl with the the like lovely long skirt.
- 21:45I love just how I don't know how I don't know her thought her
- 21:50thought pattern was like, you know, I can use this as a tool
- 21:53to to help me kind of thing. And like you say, that kind of
- 21:57rocking action of getting up and away is quite kind of it's kind
- 22:02of therapeutic to watch, I guess, in that she was kind of,
- 22:06you know, kind of full of joy and like happy to get get going
- 22:11with everything in her skirt. Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
- 22:14And it's, I mean, it's quite, when you think about the context
- 22:17of these children being in this institutional setting, you know,
- 22:23they're not just behaving as they would do at home.
- 22:26They're going to be in a place of discomfort, bewilderment, no
- 22:31matter, you know, who, who they were before they arrived there.
- 22:35And so I think it's very difficult for for anyone to look
- 22:38resilient or, or joyful. And yet some of these children
- 22:41do, which is incredibly sort of touching, moving these these
- 22:47children have that sense of resilience about them.
- 22:52I did, I mean, another thing just to say about the, the
- 22:55making of the film and the the sort of planning of it.
- 22:58So first of all, I was thinking that I would like to try and
- 23:02trace whether any of these people were alive.
- 23:05There's a chance that the that some of them could have been or
- 23:08tracked down some of their relatives.
- 23:10And it would have been amazing to meet them as, you know, older
- 23:15adults and, and get them to reflect on their time at the
- 23:18Maudesley. But, but it but no records have
- 23:21been kept. So all of the children were,
- 23:24were anonymous as far as the research and the archive were
- 23:27concerned. So that would have been a
- 23:30completely different film. And, and for a while that
- 23:33stymied me. And I was thinking, oh, OK, I'm
- 23:35not, I'm not going to be able to, to make a film, an essay
- 23:38film about this. It'll only be an academic
- 23:41interpretation. But but then, you know, it's
- 23:44impossible to work it from the from the present moment.
- 23:46Instead with yeah, with people who were meeting the film for
- 23:52the first time and and without knowing any of the history of
- 23:55the children. And did you kind of find out
- 23:58more about kind of what the children once they were kind of
- 24:03there, were they kind of like impatient and kept there until
- 24:06they became adults? Like what was the kind of, I
- 24:10don't know, the almost sort of history where they kind of
- 24:13inpatient for life sort of thing Or do you think like how did it,
- 24:18how did it work? Yeah, sure.
- 24:20I mean, I think the 50s were it was, it was a significant decade
- 24:26for diagnosis and and for autism in particular.
- 24:31Of course, you know, Asperger and Canna had in 1944 staked
- 24:38their claims from written studies, case histories of, of
- 24:43children in in the States and in Vienna.
- 24:46And this hadn't really sort of rooted anywhere particularly.
- 24:50So autism wasn't a kind of concrete diagnostic category.
- 24:55But during the 50s there was this sort of sifting of
- 24:57behaviours and autism was under the umbrella of psychosis
- 25:01broadly. So they were trying to narrow
- 25:02this this down and the Mawsley was try also trying to establish
- 25:06itself as a research hospital and be taken seriously.
- 25:11And so this film was made by a a a British doctor called
- 25:16psychiatrist called James Irwin Anthony, who went to the States
- 25:20quite quickly after after this. But at this time he was
- 25:24conducting research in these quite new units of studying
- 25:28children for for the study of children.
- 25:31And they weren't kept in, so they weren't institutionalised.
- 25:34This was a decade in which, you know, institutions were being
- 25:37shut down and people were being sort of encouraged to live
- 25:44within communities. And you see in the 60s a sort of
- 25:46push towards filming children in community settings and, you
- 25:53know, different sorts of day centres and, and educational
- 25:56settings and films become public information film around sort of
- 26:01trying to educate people around diversity of various sorts.
- 26:05But during the 50s it's there's a sort of in between where there
- 26:08are these, these research centres where children go for
- 26:11the day. They probably would have been
- 26:13attending for several weeks. Their parents are involved in
- 26:19the diagnosis in in one part of the film, you see some parents
- 26:24coming in. You can't tell what they're
- 26:26saying because of course it's a silent film and there aren't any
- 26:28inter titles covering that. But you, you know, you do see a,
- 26:34a family around one of the, the, the children.
- 26:39So it's not kind of it's, it's not a terrible sense of
- 26:42incarceration for these children.
- 26:44They're not, they're not there for life or anything like that.
- 26:47But they're sort of children who, for whom there is no
- 26:50context that that makes sense for them.
- 26:54And so they're here. People are sort of puzzling.
- 26:57People are putting quite heavy labels on their behaviour.
- 27:02And that's about where where we are in 1957.
- 27:05And the film was made in order to to compare notes with other
- 27:10psychiatrists on a global scale. So and when Anthony takes this
- 27:14to a conference in Switzerland, a conference that Kanner is AT
- 27:20and many other hundreds of psychiatrists there to discuss
- 27:25their research on diagnostic categories, not all around
- 27:29children, but but children are are quite an important focus for
- 27:34psychiatric research during that decade.
- 27:37I think that's really, that's really helpful because it kind
- 27:39of gives a bit of context because like me just watching
- 27:42it, I didn't have that kind of background.
- 27:44I was like, oh, you know, are these are these children like
- 27:47being kept kind of thing. But seeing it from the kind of
- 27:50research perspective like that, that makes like much more sense.
- 27:56But it's, it was so interesting to me how how much was kind of
- 28:01like pushed on the children, but also taken away from the
- 28:04children. Like, just like every other
- 28:08clip. It was like, oh, you need, you
- 28:10need this or you, you can't have that.
- 28:13Like, did you, did you feel like you were seeing that quite a
- 28:16lot? Yes, I did.
- 28:18I I think there were real enticements and provocations,
- 28:22some of which completely failed, you know, children refusing
- 28:26sweets and so forth. Although the refusal of sweets
- 28:28is interpreted in the film as a sort of, you know, part of a
- 28:32pathology and a non engagement with the adults who who are
- 28:37offering. Yeah, it's, I mean, one of the
- 28:42comments that doesn't get into the film was was Ash saying, you
- 28:46know, there's so many sweets are offered to children in the
- 28:48course of the of, of this film that he says, you know, it's
- 28:51like it's sponsored by by the sugar industry, Tate and Lyle's
- 28:56sponsoring of the Moseley Hospital.
- 28:58I mean, it is quite incredible. And there's that sort of
- 29:01fascination with, you know, childhood acceptable behaviours
- 29:06around children from earlier times, you know, that it was
- 29:10just, it was just fine. It was seen as desirable that
- 29:12you'd, you'd entice children with sweets to come and play in
- 29:15the sand or you'd, you know, you'd give them a milk bottle
- 29:18and then take that milk bottle away to see what happened.
- 29:21You know, sort of strange things where you think now you know,
- 29:27well, is that OK? Why would you do that?
- 29:32But there's so, so there's something quite, you know, I
- 29:34don't, I don't know what to say about it, but exactly.
- 29:37But I, I guess I'm trying to trying to think about the way
- 29:40in, in which it captures that particular moment of the 50s,
- 29:45that post war moment where sweets are around, you know,
- 29:48children are, are there's mass education, children are getting
- 29:52milk at school, they're being offered milk here.
- 29:55But there's also a sense of children being quite passive and
- 30:01having, having to, to respond to the authority of, of, of adults.
- 30:06That's what I get in the film. Yeah, definitely.
- 30:09I think it's just considering it was an 18 like minute film,
- 30:14there's so much like packed in there I feel to like then unpack
- 30:17afterwards. And I think like a bit like you
- 30:20saying like you were going over certain bits in your head
- 30:22afterwards. Like I feel like since watching
- 30:25it, like I just have found myself thinking about it more
- 30:30and trying to like unpick certain bits, which I think is
- 30:34really interesting. And I can definitely kind of, I
- 30:39don't know, just relate to how, I don't know, just the the
- 30:44freedom that they feel when they're just left to it and
- 30:50allowed to be themselves, kind of like a kind of autistic
- 30:54unmasking sort of thing. Yes, yes, quite right that.
- 30:58I mean, there, there are definitely moments in the film
- 31:00like that too, aren't there? Where you, you, you do see the
- 31:03children behaving in a way where it seems as though they're quite
- 31:06uninhibited. And it's, it's interesting what
- 31:09the, the different bits of the film stay with you.
- 31:12I think it's, it's, you know, for me working on it, having
- 31:16seen this film so many times, different bits stay with me in
- 31:21different, in different moments. So it's a bit like you say, you
- 31:23know, going back over and over footage, you see something, see
- 31:27something new and it sort of gets under your skin in in
- 31:30different ways. Yeah, definitely.
- 31:33And I think also like I know I've mentioned the sound design
- 31:36as well as the editing, but I'd be interested to know because it
- 31:40was kind of this underlying sort of like track behind.
- 31:45Like obviously the voices were the main kind of focus sound
- 31:50wise. But are you able to explain the
- 31:52kind of thinking behind the sort of background sort of track?
- 31:55It was very kind of like bloops. I don't know how to digital
- 32:01bloops is is what comes to my mind.
- 32:04Yeah, yes, well, the sound designer is Tom Fisher, who does
- 32:09a lot of work documenting natural sounds.
- 32:14So he works a lot in landscapes where there's water and Oh yeah,
- 32:22all, all sorts of nature sounds that you, you know, you wouldn't
- 32:25think that something would make a sound and like, you know, the,
- 32:28the kind of the sound of someone walking across Lycan, for
- 32:32example, or something like that. So he has a whole range of a
- 32:38sort of archive of sounds that he's collected and he's creates
- 32:44things with them and they, you know, that's, that's how he
- 32:47works. And so we had a conversation
- 32:50where I gave him some some sort of markers in in the film
- 32:57landscape of things that I liked.
- 32:59And one of those things was a film called Scrapbook by a
- 33:02Canadian film maker, Mike Hulbum.
- 33:05It's a film that's online if if people wanted to find it.
- 33:09And it's a film where he uses the footage that an avantgarde
- 33:16film maker shot in a children's home in in the States in the
- 33:22late 60s. And Hubong makes a film
- 33:26similarly with archive footage, but, but, and he has one of the
- 33:30original children going back and, and responding to herself
- 33:34on film. And he uses these sorts of quite
- 33:37abstract sounds that seem to be tonal.
- 33:40You know what, what's the note here?
- 33:42What's the tone? What's the feel of this, of this
- 33:44image? You know, the, the, the child
- 33:46looks quite lost in themselves. So you might strike a
- 33:49particular. So, so that I liked that a lot,
- 33:51but I also liked the way in which Hulbum works with found
- 33:56sound. You know, he uses a lot of
- 33:58sampling of, of different sounds and, and moves it together.
- 34:02So Tom and I ended up working with those ideas and sometimes
- 34:07with me giving him some words. So for example, one of the words
- 34:12that was useful for him was the word transmission.
- 34:16And what I meant by that was I wanted something in the sound
- 34:21design to to feel as though it's coming from a long time ago.
- 34:28So there's, you have the voices in the contemporary, but I
- 34:30wanted the soundtrack to feel as though there's also a
- 34:33communication from from the past, from the 1950s without
- 34:38using sounds from the 1950s. So he found a lot of sounds that
- 34:42were, you know, sort of like old referencing old technologies or
- 34:48what sound, what sound does when it's distorted and comes through
- 34:53different channels of transmission.
- 34:56So that that's yeah, that's one example of, of, of how we how we
- 35:00worked. And he, you know, he also drew
- 35:05on a lot of his own sort of riffs and repetitions of things
- 35:12that he liked from from the natural world, which also seemed
- 35:16to fit rather strangely with the institutional setting in which
- 35:21we see the children. So maybe there's something that
- 35:24is kind of referencing a world outside of the institution in
- 35:29the sound design. Yeah.
- 35:31I, I don't know, you know, what other people think of that.
- 35:35Yeah, I definitely think it, it kind of pairs really well with
- 35:40the visuals because I don't know, you kind of it, I don't
- 35:45know, it kind of follows a sort of kind of rhythm I feel.
- 35:50And yeah, it's kind of at one point I was like, oh, it's quite
- 35:55kind of random. But then it seems to kind of
- 35:58like fit what's happening on screen.
- 36:00And it was just, I don't know, the whole sensory experience of
- 36:03like, what of watching. I think it added another like,
- 36:06layer. I don't know if that makes
- 36:07sense. Yeah.
- 36:08Yeah, it makes absolute sense. And I think the film can appear
- 36:10so stark. And I think, I think what you're
- 36:12saying is, is, you know, it's a fabulous way of explaining the
- 36:17feel of the film, that there's something that is more layered
- 36:20in in there with the voices and the sound design.
- 36:22Also, I know that the film has been accepted as part of a Film
- 36:28Festival. Are you able to tell us a little
- 36:29bit more about the background behind that?
- 36:32Yes, sure. So the film was finished in
- 36:36October 2023. We had a small amount of money
- 36:41for for a bit of publicity and producer, but it's very
- 36:45difficult to get short films into festivals.
- 36:48I imagined that this film might just, you know, go onto our
- 36:51project website. But in fact it got into the
- 36:54number of festivals. It got into quite a big festival
- 36:57in Toronto, Toronto Hot Docs. And on a Friday night in May, I,
- 37:05my phone just wouldn't stop ringing and, and I haven't
- 37:08picked up my emails because I was working on something else at
- 37:10the time. And it turned out that the film
- 37:12had won a big award at this, at this festival of best
- 37:17international short documentary film.
- 37:20So that was just stunning. Yes.
- 37:22And, you know, immediately I was emailing Ash and and Ethan and
- 37:27Sophie and having to put together an acceptance speech.
- 37:31None of us were there, but, you know, emailing that to Toronto
- 37:35for them to read out that night. So that was really wonderful.
- 37:38And then it also got into Krakow Film Festival and it also has
- 37:46got into the Edinburgh Film Festival.
- 37:48So it's screening there on Monday.
- 37:52And I'm not sure when this podcast is going out.
- 37:54So it's it will be screening on Monday the 19th of August or
- 37:58have screened Edinburgh and Ash, Sophie, Ethan and I are all
- 38:04going to be there. It's the first time we're going
- 38:05to be watching the film together and in, Yeah, probably in a, in,
- 38:12you know, in a, in a festival context.
- 38:14And we're also doing the Q&A there.
- 38:17And Ash has designed some fabulous T-shirts for a sort of
- 38:20wear with an image of the of the little boy who looks into the
- 38:25camera. Oh, OK.
- 38:27So that's going to be really exciting and fun.
- 38:29And also the film has a different life.
- 38:33Quite curiously, it's going to be on Josie Long's show on Radio
- 38:394. Her, her, her programme
- 38:41Shortcuts, or it will have been by the time this is broadcast.
- 38:46And it's a, a show where they use a radio show where they use
- 38:51sound that's already in existence and they frame it in a
- 38:54particular way. So the theme of, of this episode
- 38:58is, is in colour. And it's, the idea is that the
- 39:03respondents bring to life this film from a long time ago that's
- 39:07black and white and sort of give it colour and, and life.
- 39:12And so that, so, you know, it's radio.
- 39:13How strange that the film's going to be part of a radio,
- 39:17your radio thing. But it is.
- 39:19And there's going to be an AI voice that's describing some of
- 39:23the sequences. And then you hear Ash, Ethan and
- 39:25Sophie commenting on these sequences.
- 39:29So I'm intrigued as to what that's going to sound like.
- 39:34But that's that's also fantastic.
- 39:36So the film has this life of its own that that I'd never imagined
- 39:40for it. And it's, you know, it's, it's
- 39:43been an an absolute delight and fabulous for all of us because
- 39:49it means we we get to to keep talking and, and thinking about
- 39:53the film and, and, and celebrating those children from
- 39:59from that long time ago, as well as, as as making something now.
- 40:04Yeah. And also kind of reframing that
- 40:07into, you know, continued conversations about, you know,
- 40:11what it was like then and what it should be like now kind of
- 40:13thing like. Yeah, I think that's, you know,
- 40:16it's really interesting how you've kind of turned it a bit,
- 40:22but also like really fascinating about the the radio show.
- 40:26And I'll try and I'll try and link that if it does kind of
- 40:30come out and I have have the link to it, sure.
- 40:35But I guess people will fill fill in the visuals kind of
- 40:39thing when when they hear potentially.
- 40:42Yes, yeah. I mean, I, I mean, I think it's,
- 40:45it's testament to how powerful the responses were that, that
- 40:52they're so evocative that listening to their descriptions
- 40:54is, is is enough to, to make a radio programme from.
- 40:58So I mean, it's, you know, all credit to Sophie's and Ash.
- 41:03You know, they were, their interpretations have just been
- 41:06fantastic. Yeah, I, I really enjoyed, I
- 41:10don't know, just sometimes that there was such a range of kind
- 41:14of blunt and witty and like just, there was just such a
- 41:19range of emotion in what they were saying about what was going
- 41:22on. That was really interesting.
- 41:24And, you know, at the start it's like, oh, this is a bit
- 41:27uncomfortable to watch. But then the way that they're
- 41:29reframing it, like, you know, this, this girl is having a
- 41:34great time in the garden. Like if she's left to it and
- 41:37just just let her be. Yes.
- 41:40So. Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
- 41:45I think it's also, it's also an interesting film for things like
- 41:50social policy, which is perhaps a bit of a dry subject to to
- 41:54bring up in this discussion. But it just, you know, there are
- 41:58those debates about what should happen to films like this.
- 42:02They appear online in some contexts that are, you know,
- 42:07just like freak films. There's a whole category, if
- 42:10you, if you Google for long enough, of sort of freakish
- 42:14medical clinical films, no context about how they were
- 42:18made, who these children or adults are.
- 42:22And you know that it's, it's kind of an argument to for, for
- 42:27it to be taken down and no one to see these films.
- 42:29And I think that a lot of archives are very aware of that.
- 42:33And so they tend to monitor who has access to these films and
- 42:36ask them what they're going to do with them.
- 42:38But of course, that also limits who's who's going to get to see
- 42:41them. And it's often people like me,
- 42:43academics who, you know, have have quite an easy access
- 42:48because of my training. So there's there's not a middle
- 42:53ground. And I think there was something
- 42:54about making this film that made me think about how this film
- 42:58might be a model for how we work with archive films that maybe
- 43:06archive films. I mean archive medical films
- 43:08that are difficult to watch. You know, rather than just say,
- 43:11right, we don't want to watch them because they're too
- 43:13difficult. That seems to repress that
- 43:16silence, that history. But on on the other hand, you
- 43:20know, if they're just out in the public domain, they have no
- 43:23context. That seems problematic too.
- 43:25But to revisit them and to have commentary that is coming from
- 43:30the position of the people in the film seems a really
- 43:34interesting thing to to take forward into into other archive
- 43:39film work. Yeah, definitely.
- 43:41And I think it's really important to know where we've
- 43:44come from to be able to do better now.
- 43:47Like as long as there is that context and kind of
- 43:51understanding, Yeah, I think it's really important to kind of
- 43:56learn from the past and do better.
- 43:58But also just to show that these children are just, they're just
- 44:05stemming. Like just just let them kind of
- 44:09exist and you don't, you don't need to analyse them down to the
- 44:14very core. No, absolutely.
- 44:18And, you know, an academic interpretation of that film,
- 44:22it's much, much drier. And I have written about the
- 44:25film and it's nowhere near as as good or as lively as, as the
- 44:30interpretations that are in Autism Plays Itself.
- 44:34So, yeah, it just, I think, I think the the sheer force of
- 44:38identification that came from each of those respondents of
- 44:42like, you know, yes, I know those children.
- 44:43You know, they're my people. They're I understand what
- 44:46they're doing, what they want. I understand their frustrations.
- 44:51It's just very straightforward and yeah, that that you you get
- 44:57the the, the humour as well as the frustration and pain in in
- 45:03the film. So I think really, really quite
- 45:06lovely and enlivening. I keep using that word, but it's
- 45:11sort of sort of animating the film animates me.
- 45:14It sort of goes back to the past and come bounces back to the
- 45:17present I think. And do you know if the film will
- 45:20be kind of available sort of publicly at any point to watch?
- 45:25Yeah, yes, absolutely it will be.
- 45:28We don't have a date for that yet because it's still whilst
- 45:33it's doing the festival circuits.
- 45:34You have to keep it sort of, you know, people will know out of
- 45:38the public domain. It may, it may be in the London
- 45:41Film Festival. It's definitely showing at
- 45:43Folkestone Documentary Festival in October and it will probably
- 45:49have a a few more screenings and then it'll be on our project
- 45:53website, I would think towards the end of this year, certainly
- 45:56by the beginning of 2025. OK, no problem.
- 46:00What I'll do is I will when it comes out, I will update the
- 46:03show notes so that people can go and watch it when it does come
- 46:07out because I feel like having, you know, obviously, you know,
- 46:11talked to you. I think people are going to want
- 46:13to, you know, see the visuals and.
- 46:16Yeah, yeah, yeah, sure. There's also a link to a trader,
- 46:19actually, I'll give you that sort of.
- 46:20Oh yeah, that's absolutely good. Some taste of it.
- 46:23That would be good. And I know we were going to kind
- 46:27of touch upon your autism kind of through cinema project and
- 46:32maybe just, I don't know if you could just kind of give us sort
- 46:36of overview as to kind of being a principal investigator on it
- 46:41and what that involved. Yes.
- 46:44So being a principal investigator was a mixed bag,
- 46:51particularly working on a project like this that that was
- 46:56planned around a lot of collaboration.
- 46:58But then of course the pandemic arrived.
- 47:01But like we've all limitations, there are creative ways it
- 47:05forces you to be creative around that.
- 47:07And, and having a podcast was, was one of the things that
- 47:11worked really well for us and building a building a community
- 47:15remotely and online. And I think it enabled us to
- 47:18reach autistic audiences internationally.
- 47:22You know, we had listeners in Australia and far afield from
- 47:26that, which is great. So we got all sorts of feedback
- 47:29for the project and input in a way that we hadn't if we just
- 47:33conducted workshops in London and Hastings.
- 47:36So that so that was great. But to to answer your question
- 47:38of what the the project was really, as I was saying at the
- 47:43beginning, thinking about a relationship between these two
- 47:48terms, autism and cinema. And, you know, you say that to
- 47:52people and people come up with with sort of classic films.
- 47:58It might be Temple Grandin, might be Rain Man, it might be
- 48:01something more contemporary, like the terrible music I see.
- 48:06So, yeah, all those sort of fictional representations that
- 48:12engage you in in a world in which it's as though the
- 48:17character is is real and you sort of forget about the film
- 48:21form, about how it's been shot and staged and constructed and
- 48:25edited. And we were coming from the
- 48:28other direction, which was really to think about our way
- 48:31into it was was thinking about how lots of things that are said
- 48:36about cinema are very similar to the things that are said about
- 48:40an autistic apprehension of the world.
- 48:43So for example, cinema in its earlier days, it was very much
- 48:51lauded for its way of photographing the world and
- 48:55showing us things we didn't already see.
- 48:58So like the the the wind moving the leaves in the trees, the way
- 49:03in which it showed us patterns. So, for example, a camera from a
- 49:07high position documenting crowds, filming crowds moving
- 49:11through a city, we begin to see patterns of of behaviour.
- 49:16And I think that that's that's something that that resonates
- 49:20with an autistic apprehension of the world, you know, because
- 49:22sort of the way in which autistic focus can be like a
- 49:27close up, you know, it can kind of latch onto something and
- 49:30really want to investigate or immerse in that.
- 49:32It very interested in sensory ways of being involved with the
- 49:37world and very attached to patterns and rhythms.
- 49:42So we we were thinking about, well, you know, there's a lot,
- 49:47there's a lot of interesting overlap.
- 49:48I wonder, I wonder how we can explore that.
- 49:51So Stephen Eastwood, my collaborator, explored that with
- 49:56a collective that was formed during the course of the
- 49:59project, the Newer cultures collective who made a film with
- 50:04him called Swimming Pool that's in also in festivals at the
- 50:07moment. A a feature length kind of
- 50:12experimental fictional documentary form.
- 50:16Hard, hard to know how to how to describe it.
- 50:19It has a protagonist, but it's also a sequence of scenes
- 50:24written by the different members of the collective that are
- 50:26threaded together. So that that's doing incredibly
- 50:31well. And we'll have a cinema release
- 50:33at the end of the year. So that was One Direction, sort
- 50:37of experimental cinema and collaboration.
- 50:40And then for my direction, I've been writing about autism and
- 50:45I've written a book called Autism and the Empathy Epidemic,
- 50:50which is really trying to reverse the idea that that
- 50:54autism is is an issue for society broadly because autistic
- 51:00people aren't empathetic. And really turning it around
- 51:03through Damian Milton's version of of autism and empathy, which
- 51:07is, you know, there's a double empathy problem, that autistic
- 51:10people are on the receiving end of those kinds of slurs and
- 51:19pathologisations when in fact their engagements of the world
- 51:22are just not recognised. So yeah, that's really what the
- 51:28project's been about. It sort of engages with with
- 51:31these new theorisations and explorations of autism as a
- 51:38particular sensory form, the sorts of things that's coming
- 51:42through the work of Anna Stenning, for example, in the
- 51:45UK, an autistic life writing that's very much about nature
- 51:52and reinvents that that that genre of nature writing from
- 51:57something that's that was just kind of considered romantic into
- 52:01something that's very vibrant. And yeah, really, really
- 52:06resonates with an autistic apprehension and also with
- 52:12scholarship in the UK. Like Remy Yergo, who is quite a
- 52:18prolific writer on autism and rhetoric.
- 52:25Remy is an autistic scholar who advocates very much for for
- 52:32autistic scholarship. And they came and keynoted our
- 52:37conference a year and a half ago at Queen Mary.
- 52:39So that that was pretty fabulous.
- 52:43Yeah. So I think that does that give
- 52:45you a broad enough project. Also, it's really fascinating to
- 52:49me that you've you've also been involved as a podcaster and, you
- 52:55know, kind of had that sort of side of things and just having
- 53:00that kind of audience as well. I think.
- 53:02Yeah, it's always interesting to hear from other people that have
- 53:05done it. Yes, yeah, absolutely.
- 53:09I mean, I think it was, it was a thing right when COVID happened.
- 53:13How are people going to speak to each other?
- 53:15How are we going to do this? And, and podcasting took off,
- 53:19but it was also it for me, it was a really new way of working.
- 53:25And it's, it's informed the way that I teach now.
- 53:27And it, it taught me how to think with people.
- 53:31You know, it was, it was like moving in a swarm.
- 53:35You, you begin to discuss a film that someone has suggested we'd
- 53:38all watched it, someone would introduce it.
- 53:40And then, you know, you listen to two or three people talking
- 53:43about it. You say something and you know,
- 53:45it begins to go in One Direction.
- 53:47And then, and then everyone moves in a slightly different
- 53:49direction. And, and I really enjoyed that.
- 53:52And it seemed like a, a very productive way of working that
- 53:56is, that is not at all individualistic.
- 54:01And so I, you know, I, I like that and I'm, I would like to do
- 54:04more work like that at the interface of not just different
- 54:08disciplines just, but also with different forms of
- 54:11collaboration. I mean, I think it's important.
- 54:16I think disability studies, critical autism studies
- 54:20absolutely need scholars that are disabled and autistic, but I
- 54:24think it's also important that those subjects don't become
- 54:28siloed. You know, they don't become
- 54:30those communities speaking just to themselves, but but but that
- 54:35those there, there is so much for the from those disciplines
- 54:39that we need to take up more broadly and academia and of
- 54:44course, more broadly and culturally and socially that
- 54:47it's important that collaborations move across those
- 54:50boundaries as well. Yeah, definitely.
- 54:52And I'd be keen to understand, are you kind of, you know what
- 54:57the kind of future holds for you and your research?
- 55:00Like will you still kind of be focusing on kind of autism or do
- 55:04you think like is that kind of where your kind of interests lie
- 55:09or are you kind of moving kind of on how how does it work in
- 55:13terms of what you do to research?
- 55:16Yeah, good question. I don't know the answer for that
- 55:20to that right right now, but some of my thoughts are I am
- 55:27very much still interested in, in autism and its relationship
- 55:31to cinema and the history of autism and cinema, how they
- 55:34overlap in medical films. And there's they're a sequence
- 55:37of Dutch films actually from the 60s where there's a study of
- 55:42twins and they're much longer films with sound.
- 55:45They don't seem to have been written about at all, but they
- 55:49they're very beautiful. This is there's a sort of study
- 55:52of this one doctor's relationship with one of the
- 55:54twins who's autistic. And it's a very, it's like it
- 55:58will be writing and working with an object that is good, you
- 56:01know, looking back as like, oh, what a beautiful film.
- 56:04So how do you work about with something that in fact you think
- 56:06is quite lovely and its origin? So that's a question for me
- 56:10about what what I can do with that.
- 56:13I'm also interested in the overlap between queer histories
- 56:19and autism. I think there's a lot of shared
- 56:24history around things like conversion therapy, for example,
- 56:28and outside Alinas. And as someone who's who's
- 56:31identified as queer for all of my life, I'm sort of keen to to
- 56:37explore some of that medical history too.
- 56:41It sounds like it must be really hard to to almost like switch
- 56:45off work wise because you it sounds like you're someone that
- 56:49kind of thinks as they're just kind of existing about
- 56:53potential, kind of like films and different kind of crossovers
- 56:57of things. So it must be.
- 56:59It must be quite hard trying to switch off as as an academic.
- 57:05Well, yeah, that's true. It's it is.
- 57:09But you've you've always got another, another narrative going
- 57:12on. But you're thinking like, you
- 57:13know, OK, what can I do with this?
- 57:14I think it can be frustrating for people around me sometimes
- 57:18who are not in the world of academia.
- 57:20So yeah, yeah, some limitations for sure.
- 57:25But it's also incredibly enjoyable, you know, puzzling
- 57:29these things. Well, thank you so much for
- 57:32spending an hour, I can't believe it's been an hour
- 57:36talking about autism plays itself and also autism through
- 57:41cinema. And yeah, I will try and link as
- 57:44much as I physically can in the show notes and keep the show
- 57:47notes updated as to when the actual film goes kind of live.
- 57:53But I will definitely put the trailer link in the show notes.
- 57:57Yeah, that's amazing. Well, thank you for a really
- 57:59lovely interview.