Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #No.52🎙️. Public Inquiry -Phantom Feasibility Study Week 4 Day 1
Transcript
- 0:04Would someone explain to me how are you supposed to stay with a
- 0:07process to arrive at a correct decision when you believe the
- 0:11process itself to be fatally flawed?
- 0:14When I came home from the public inquiry this evening feeling
- 0:18tired and a bit dejected, I decided to take myself out for a
- 0:21walk on the nearby mountain. Yes, one of the beloved Sperrins
- 0:25under threat from mining. There was exploratory drilling done
- 0:28here, less than half a mile away, in the beautiful
- 0:31Glenhordial . However, that's not what I want to speak about today.
- 0:36To get back to my walk. It was a stunning evening, soft, golden
- 0:40light, the birds choir in full song, new life and possibility
- 0:45everywhere, the grass never seemed as green or the
- 0:49dandelions as Golden, and the sky for once, clear of clouds
- 0:53and blue. Oh so blue
- 0:56was also a cold evening
- 0:58with a soft breeze, and it felt good to walk, walk hard, to
- 1:02clear my head of the nonsense of the day and to return me to my
- 1:06why.
- 1:08In 20 years, I'll be 87 in 20 years, my granddaughter will be
- 1:1224 then when she looks at me in the eye and asks me, did you
- 1:17really do everything you could possibly do to leave the earth a
- 1:21fit place for all the generations coming behind you. I
- 1:24want to be able to answer with a resounding yes.
- 1:28Why I do this spend endless hours sitting through a
- 1:31meaningless process listening to what I believe could only be
- 1:34described as creative storytelling on the part of the
- 1:36applicant and their various representatives.
- 1:40Why am I there to witness us third parties engaging in
- 1:43meaningless argument and counter argument, all built on candy
- 1:46floss.
- 1:48That's why I watched the orchestration of this dance by
- 1:51well paid actors and nonsensical duet destined to be in the
- 1:54stranglehold of each other company for months to come.
- 1:59That's why I believe I'm witnessing the erosion of
- 2:01democracy at an institutional level. I look around the room,
- 2:05and I know my heart and soul that these are fellow human
- 2:08beings with their own loves and lives, their own hearts and
- 2:12souls, and I ask myself, how can they allow themselves to be
- 2:16party to this farce? How can they go home in the evening and
- 2:19say to themselves, today, I did a valuable day's work. I
- 2:22contributed to making the world a better place. Okay, so that's
- 2:27my rant. Here's what happened.
- 2:30Sometime over the weekend, savers burns came to the
- 2:33collective conclusion that the bulk of the questions in the
- 2:37socio economic section could be addressed with a single
- 2:40statement, which was duly delivered by Mary Brawley, most
- 2:44of it, but not all, as the commission was unwilling to hear
- 2:47us out to the end,
- 2:50this is the Save Our sperm statement,
- 2:54Commissioner. In light of developments over the last few
- 2:57days of the inquiries, it appears that these public
- 3:01inquiries will run significantly longer than anticipated
- 3:07to expedite proceedings. We wish to highlight information gaps in
- 3:10the Delray and gold planning applications that make it
- 3:13impossible for save our sparse to engage in a meaningful manner
- 3:17in this process.
- 3:19We intend to rely on this statement henceforth and
- 3:22interject in proceedings by exception going forward.
- 3:29Number one, our reading of the applicant's economic argument is
- 3:33hindered by a lack of succinct information. We submit that its
- 3:37extensive use of pences and variously dated addenda creates
- 3:42confusion, and the information provided by the applicant over
- 3:46these last three days has not alleviated this
- 3:50number two,
- 3:53clear and material deficiencies have been repeatedly identified
- 3:56in the provision of essential, specific and accurate,
- 4:00quantitative data by the applicant.
- 4:04The data presented in this application is based upon a
- 4:07phantom feasibility study.
- 4:11In section 3.6 of the guide to application document of November
- 4:152017
- 4:17the applicant states that JDS mining completed a feasibility
- 4:22study
- 4:25in late 2016
- 4:27which was published in early 2017
- 4:31however, this JDS 2016 stroke 17 report that provides the
- 4:37baseline data contained in this 2017 application has been
- 4:42superseded by del radians own 22nd of June, 2018
- 4:48technical report prepared by SRK consulting that renders all
- 4:54previous reports obsolete and no longer valid or current on at
- 4:58least 26
- 5:00Instances,
- 5:02the 2018
- 5:03SRK technical report stated that updated economics for the
- 5:08cournald gold deposit will be announced in the upcoming
- 5:12feasibility study expected later this year, additionally by
- 5:17letter dated sixth of December, 2018
- 5:20Noel Lavery, Permanent Secretary of DFE, informed Graham Walker
- 5:24of DFI that it is anticipated that an updated feasibility
- 5:29study scheduled for release by the end of 2018
- 5:33will outline potential impact.
- 5:36However, this 2018 feasibility study has not been produced, and
- 5:41we highlight again, the applicants continued reliance
- 5:44upon obsolete, invalid and outdated, pre 2018 information
- 5:50before this commission.
- 5:52Over the past few days, we've heard some conflating a
- 5:56feasibility study with terms such as economic benefits or
- 6:00impacts in referencing TR, five and RR, one, four, we believe
- 6:07that any attempt to reduce the macro level cost benefit
- 6:10analysis that underpins an independent feasibility study to
- 6:14such an addendum is wholly unacceptable and somewhat
- 6:18disingenuous. The issue of the feasibility study is of outmost
- 6:24material importance to the public inquiry.
- 6:27It is integral to to the due diligence expected by the public
- 6:32of the government departments assessing an application of this
- 6:35magnitude and must be subjected to robust scrutiny by this
- 6:39commission.
- 6:42Additionally, the prejudicial impact of the absence of a
- 6:46feasibility study cannot be ignored. We believe that public
- 6:50opinion has been prejudiced since June 2018
- 6:54in that Ernst Young's socio economic impact review of the
- 6:58cournald gold project fails to reference the 2018
- 7:03SRK Technical Report, instead referencing a different 2017
- 7:09Sok statement of environmental impacts.
- 7:13Delraydian references this report in its marketing
- 7:16materials as a significant and a timely stimulus for the Northern
- 7:21Ireland economy, such a report by a big four consultancy
- 7:26company does influence public opinion, but interestingly, does
- 7:31not reference the
- 7:332018
- 7:35SRK Technology Report. Again, we submit that in the absence of
- 7:40complete and reliable baseline data you and we the public
- 7:44cannot properly or lawfully assess the likely economic
- 7:49viability of this application.
- 7:52Furthermore,
- 7:54we have raised concerns regarding the non usage of
- 7:57standard mining industry standards and the analysis of
- 8:01data presented by the applicant. Instead, the applicant has
- 8:05relied upon a bespoke economic model to which neither the
- 8:09public nor the commissioners have had access.
- 8:13To date information and input details regarding the bespoke
- 8:18economic model used by the applicant have not been
- 8:21provided.
- 8:25The psychometric properties of that measurement model that
- 8:28assure the user of its reliability and validity have
- 8:32also not been provided. This absence of complete information
- 8:37is procedurally unfair and prevents you, the commissioners
- 8:40and us, the public, from properly assessing the
- 8:43information provided by the applicant.
- 8:46We submit that in the absence of same no weight can properly be
- 8:51attached to the entire application.
- 8:55Having listened to the evidence on behalf of delrayne over the
- 8:58last few days.
- 9:00SOS raises concerns that information now being provided
- 9:04on behalf of the applicant may be considered an attempt to
- 9:07update in real time the application already before the
- 9:11commissioners. For example, we have recently heard proposals
- 9:15resale of concentrate at the gates to brokers, or possible
- 9:19onward transportation to smelters, none of which has been
- 9:23verified.
- 9:25In summary, we believe that the continued Reliance by the
- 9:29applicant upon obsolete reports that are no longer valid or
- 9:33current makes it impossible for the public and commissioners to
- 9:37make a serious economic appraisal of this application.
- 9:40We submit that all further discussions of the remaining
- 9:44topics within this section have been so severely compromised by
- 9:48the applicant's inadequate data, uncertain measurement model,
- 9:52misleading marketing materials, coupled with dfis failure to
- 9:56recognise that this complex application lies outside.
- 10:00Outside the skill set and expertise of its own officers,
- 10:06we believe it will be a matter of gross negligence to assert
- 10:09any socio economic claims about GVA public revenues multipliers,
- 10:15etc, based upon ever fluctuating and unclear information provided
- 10:21by the applicant regarding issues that are fundamental to
- 10:23their operational cost basis and the subsequent economic impact
- 10:28or benefits claimed.
- 10:30Significant issues have been identified regarding the lack of
- 10:34clarity of the costs associated with the makeup of the
- 10:37concentrate it intends to sell
- 10:40the lifespan of the mine, and especially the dry stack stroke
- 10:44mine waste facility, maximise maximisation,
- 10:48the cut off grade of gold ore being applied. The location of
- 10:52the cyanide processing plant, the strength of cyanide, what
- 10:56chemicals are used in the processing,
- 10:59the tariffs applicable when the concentrate is exported,
- 11:04the number and location of exploratory tunnels that are
- 11:07applied for and
- 11:09whether the concentrate will be sold at the mine gate to a
- 11:12broker, and if so, the details thereof and the future impact
- 11:18of any labour saving devices such as AI or the mechanisation
- 11:24of manual labour,
- 11:27we submit that given the clear gaps in baseline data already
- 11:31identified to date, plus lack of supporting evidence in the
- 11:35application, the public, let alone the commission, cannot
- 11:39lawfully and properly assess this application and its
- 11:43impacts, and we submit that the application before the pack is
- 11:47not fit for robust public scrutiny and should not have
- 11:51been played placed before the PAC by the dfi.
- 11:56Regrettably, from the evidence heard over the last few days, we
- 11:59also believe that the DFI are not equipped to process this
- 12:03application, to make any independent assessment of this
- 12:06application, or to assess the adequacy or otherwise of the
- 12:10information it has received from the applicant.
- 12:14We are of the view that its progression before the
- 12:17commission risks undermining the integrity of this process,
- 12:22we invite the commission to consider all of our submissions
- 12:25at this stage, as we believe that the application presently
- 12:28before it is fundamentally flawed and not fit for scrutiny.
- 12:33We should rely on this statement from time to time and propose to
- 12:37speak in Proceedings only by exception, to expedite
- 12:41proceedings and in an effort to protect the public purse from
- 12:45further unnecessary expenditure. Fair play to you and thank you.
- 12:51If you've taken the time to listen this far,
- 12:54you might well understand that there isn't a whole lot more
- 12:58that we can say, and all we can be is present in the public
- 13:03inquiry,
- 13:05witnessing this tragic comedy.
- 13:09Who knows what the outcome will be. By the way, plenty more
- 13:13happened today. But as these podcasts about the public
- 13:17inquiry are designed to be pretty brief, I'm going to leave
- 13:21it here for now.
- 13:23If you're curious about what else happened, it will be up on
- 13:26the don't minus website within 48 hours. See you tomorrow. You.