Latest / Politics with Paul / Redistricting Part 1: What Goes Into Making New Districts? | Politics with Paul #96
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:05political science and civics.
- 0:07I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:09Today's the first of a two parter on redistricting, and today is specifically about
- 0:15what goes into making new districts for elections.
- 0:20The current redistricting wars between the Democratic and Republican parties is shaping up
- 0:25to be one of, if not the most influential factors on how the twenty twenty six elections
- 0:30and beyond turn out.
- 0:33American elections already struggle with competitiveness.
- 0:37A large majority of contests for congress are very predictable as to which party will win,
- 0:44and the same goes for a lot of state level races like governor and state legislature.
- 0:50Now despite my usual reluctance to put forth my own opinions, I have said before many times
- 0:55that I think it's quite obvious that none of these recent attempts at redistricting have
- 1:00altruistic motives despite partisan justifications from both sides.
- 1:05Most of it is obvious attempts at gerrymandering.
- 1:10But let's put feelings aside for a moment.
- 1:13With neither party backing down, it's led many people to ask how we can ensure fair elections
- 1:20in America for the future, or better yet, is it even possible to do that?
- 1:25And there's a lot to cover on this subject, so it's going to be split into two episodes.
- 1:29And before we get to the actual possibility of whether or not we can ensure fair elections, it
- 1:37makes most sense to set the stage by talking about the history of gerrymandering and
- 1:42redistricting, how redistricting happens in the states, the criteria for making new districts
- 1:49and what lessons the past holds for today.
- 1:52And then the next episode, we'll talk about proposals for fixing the redistricting process
- 1:57and whether we can ensure fair districts and elections.
- 2:01So first, let's get into the brief history of redistricting in congress because if you really
- 2:08want to, you can make a
- 2:09whole episode about this on its own.
- 2:12Because as bitter and awful as the redistricting wars going on are right now,
- 2:19Attempts to unfairly sway congress's elections before they even happen are not a new thing.
- 2:25In fact, it's basically been there since the ratification of the US constitution back in
- 2:321789.
- 2:33And Lee Drutman, who's a a lecturer and a commentator and author, he's been talking a lot
- 2:41about these current redistricting wars, and he has a really good Substack article about the
- 2:47brief history of redistricting.
- 2:50And some of this content comes from that and some of it comes from other places.
- 2:57But back in 1789, this kind of stuff was already happening because the US constitution
- 3:03left house states elect representatives to the states.
- 3:08Though Congress could overrule them, it didn't really, but it was part of the tenth
- 3:12amendment's powers delegated to the states because the tenth amendment says any powers not
- 3:17expressly given to the US constitution belong to the states.
- 3:21And so in some ways, it was kind of a free for all for all the states to dictate how to redraw
- 3:28their districts because they also redraw the congressional districts.
- 3:32It is not the federal government that does that.
- 3:34It is the state governments that do that.
- 3:37So federalists and Democratic Republicans alike tried plenty of different methods to screw each
- 3:43other out of seats and sometimes went back and forth between them.
- 3:46They engaged in the very first instances, at least in this country's history, of cracking
- 3:52and packing, which are two common ways to try to gerrymander or at least try to unfairly
- 3:59redistrict for elections.
- 4:02Cracking being you split up opposing electorates across enough elections so that
- 4:08their power is diminished and they can't really compete in any of these elections or at least
- 4:15try to diffuse them enough so that their power is limited.
- 4:18Or you pack them all into one or a handful of districts.
- 4:22So, yeah, you guarantee that they're going to win those districts, but the vast majority of
- 4:27districts still are yours for the taking.
- 4:31And so there are all sorts of ways that both parties try to do that in their respective
- 4:36strongholds.
- 4:37And sometimes they went back and forth between at large districts, which encompassed the whole
- 4:42state.
- 4:43And this is just for Congress, by the way.
- 4:45State legislatures, that just gets into a whole other can of worms.
- 4:49But at large states, they encompass the whole state.
- 4:54So everybody on the in that state votes on those districts.
- 4:58Then they've also got they also tried districted elections.
- 5:02So they instead of everybody in the state voting on that district, you can only vote on
- 5:06that district if you live in that district's boundaries.
- 5:10They tried mixes of at large and districted elections, so some of the states, if the state
- 5:19had multiple seats, some of them might have been at large and then some of them might have
- 5:23been districted.
- 5:24And then they also tried at large districts, but you needed to reside in specific districts.
- 5:29So if there was there might have
- 5:32been three districts overall or three at large seats, but they technically all had their own
- 5:38districts that each at large member needed to reside in, but the whole state could still vote
- 5:42for them.
- 5:43The very first instance of a gerrymander can be seen in Virginia's fifth congressional district
- 5:49back then.
- 5:51And that was when Patrick Henry, an anti federalist, tried to basically rig the election
- 5:56against James Madison by trying to fit a whole bunch of anti federalist sympathizers who would
- 6:04later become the Democratic Republican Party into that district to try to take down James
- 6:09Madison.
- 6:09Although James Madison still won anyway against another fellow future president James Monroe.
- 6:15So it still worked out for both of those guys anyways.
- 6:19But he had to get creative and try to appeal to people across party lines.
- 6:24So sometimes, gerrymandering leads to people getting creative.
- 6:28But the term gerrymandering didn't actually get coined until about 1812 when Massachusetts
- 6:34governor Elbridge Gerry tried to secure his party seats by signing off on a snaking state
- 6:42senate district.
- 6:43Now how you pronounce this name?
- 6:45Some people call it Gary.
- 6:46Some people call
- 6:47it Jerry.
- 6:47I think gerrymandering sounds more reasonable, sounds better, but whatever the
- 6:53case may be, the the term wasn't coined until about 1812.
- 6:59And then so from about 1842 to 1896, the single member district became the primary method of
- 7:07redistricting because the Whig party who eventually filled the vacuum left by the
- 7:12dissolution of the Federalist party, they came into power and they mandated single member
- 7:19districts for congress nationwide through the 1842 apportionment act to try to preserve the
- 7:26districts that they had swept back in the eighteen forty elections.
- 7:30And it was the only time in American history that the US house actually shrunk, except
- 7:34technically the civil war because when South seceded, technically, the US house became
- 7:40smaller.
- 7:42But despite the Whigs attempts to try to preserve their power, it didn't work because
- 7:46they would still lose the House and some Democratic states already refused to comply
- 7:53with this order to move to single member districts in the US house until they started to
- 8:00realize it actually might help them protect them in the eighteen forty six midterms.
- 8:05So they eventually then decided, you know what?
- 8:07Single member districts aren't so bad.
- 8:09Single member districts, in case you don't know, are basically or not basically, they are
- 8:13each district has one person as opposed to multi member districts where they can have a
- 8:19single district can have two, three, or more people representing it.
- 8:24And so in the '18 is leading up to the civil war, boundaries boundaries were redrawn
- 8:31repeatedly, but it became even more pronounced in the Reconstruction era following the civil
- 8:38war up through 1896 and especially past the Reconstruction era.
- 8:44So right at the end of the eighteen seventies through 1896.
- 8:48And that nearly two decade period was probably the most similar to today's redistricting wars.
- 8:54And from 1896 up until about the nineteen sixties, you saw solid regional blocks
- 9:01solidified as Democrats took back their stronghold, their stranglehold on the South,
- 9:07and Republicans dominated in the North.
- 9:091896 was the election of William McKinley, a Republican against Democrat William Jennings
- 9:15Bryan.
- 9:16And this election is actually very notable for many reasons, but one of the most notable
- 9:21reasons is that much of today's urban and rural divide can be traced back to that election
- 9:29where a lot of the more urban industrial factions and voters supported William McKinley,
- 9:37while more rural voters away from the cities supported William Jennings Bryan.
- 9:45And so because of the firm hold that Democrats and Republicans had in the respective regions
- 9:50of the country, they often didn't feel the need to redraw their congressional maps.
- 9:55Why bother?
- 9:56The other party's not competing.
- 9:57So Democrats in the South don't have to worry about Republicans, and Republicans in the North
- 10:02don't have to worry about Democrats, generally speaking.
- 10:05But then in the nineteen sixties, things changed considerably because for one, you saw
- 10:12the passage of the Voting Rights Act, which led to dramatically increasing black voter
- 10:18registration participation.
- 10:20And you also saw the beginning of the, what is often called the great sorting out that led to
- 10:25many longtime Democratic strongholds becoming increasingly Republican, and a lot of the
- 10:32historical Republican area areas becoming increasingly Democratic.
- 10:37And then in 1967, Congress passed the Uniform Congressional District Act, which reaffirmed
- 10:43that 1842 apportionment act that the Whigs had passed, which required single member districts.
- 10:50It also codified equal population requirements, meaning districts had to be relatively equal in
- 10:56population, and it also prevented Southern states from trying to switch back to at large
- 11:01blocks in an attempt to try to dilute black representation.
- 11:07And then after the 1990 census, the Justice Department used the 1982 amendments to the
- 11:13Voting Rights Act to push states to create new majority minority districts.
- 11:18Majority minority meaning a district is predominantly racial minorities.
- 11:23And this led to a surge in majority black districts and black members in Congress, but it
- 11:29also basically guaranteed that surrounding districts would be whiter and more Republican.
- 11:35And then you saw the nineteen ninety four midterms saw Republicans take back the US House
- 11:41for the first time in four decades, and the great sorting out started to sort of reach its
- 11:47culmination with the South.
- 11:51You really started to see them becoming more republican and more in the North starting to
- 11:55become more democrat, and especially with democrats increasingly moving into cities and
- 12:01suburbs, and then Republicans were increasingly moving into rural areas and exurbs.
- 12:07And you saw these as there was this sorting out, you saw more and more competitive
- 12:14elections.
- 12:15But after 1994, those genuinely competitive districts started shrinking in frequency as
- 12:22well as split ticket voting.
- 12:24And you can still see some of it today where these genuinely competitive districts are
- 12:29becoming fewer and fewer and split ticket voting is becoming even less common than it was
- 12:38before.
- 12:40And so that leads us into today.
- 12:42How do states redistrict for federal, state and local level?
- 12:47Because states are required to redraw their lines every ten years following the census, you
- 12:52get a decade.
- 12:53And there are three basic ways that states redistrict legislative boundaries at the
- 12:59federal and state level.
- 13:01It can be led by the state legislature, it can be led by a commission, or it can be led
- 13:08jointly by state legislature and a commission.
- 13:12And how one state redistricts its federal boundaries, that is to say for the US House
- 13:17because the US Senate covers entire states, so you don't actually redistrict those, But how
- 13:23one state redistricts its federal boundaries isn't always the same as how it does it for the
- 13:29state legislature.
- 13:30So you might have one state that uses the state legislature predominantly to redraw its state
- 13:37legislature, but then a commission for the congress.
- 13:41And there's also the fact that in some cases, a state's population is too small to have more
- 13:46than one US house representative like Wyoming, for example.
- 13:50So only 44 states have to worry about how to redistrict congressional districts because
- 13:55there's only one there.
- 13:58In the case of congressional redistricting, 33 states have their state legislature lead in
- 14:06drawing the new district boundaries.
- 14:08Nine states use a commission, and then two states use that hybrid of both a state
- 14:13legislature and a commission.
- 14:15And then for state legislative redistricting, 34 states use the state legislature to draw the
- 14:22new boundaries, 14 states do that with a commission, and then two states do that with a
- 14:27hybrid of both state legislature and commission.
- 14:31Now local level redistricting is where it gets very tricky and very murky, and this is talking
- 14:37about things like city councils and county commissions.
- 14:41So there's even more variation in how local level redistricting is done compared to the
- 14:47federal and state level because there are 90,000 local governments in The US.
- 14:53I think it's 90,837 or something like that, but there's over 90,000 of those.
- 14:59So there's a lot of different ways it happens.
- 15:02And all local redistricting must at least follow equal population rules and comply with
- 15:08the Voting Rights Act, though with the recent ruling in the Louisiana versus Calais case,
- 15:13that may change that somewhat.
- 15:15And also local areas are subject to some extent to state laws, and that depends on how much
- 15:21home rule is granted to those local areas.
- 15:24So in some states, they might give certain localities more power in how they redraw their
- 15:31city district lines or their county district lines compared to other states where they might
- 15:37say specifically, You have to do it this way.
- 15:40Typically they redistrict as of the census just like federal and state lines do, but they may
- 15:46not do so if they confirm that their populations are relatively unchanged and still
- 15:51have relatively equal population in the district.
- 15:54So a lot of cities might not or towns, they might not change all that much in their
- 16:00demographic makeup.
- 16:01They might have basically the same amount of population as they did the last time.
- 16:08But a lot of cities have been growing considerably, so they will have to redistrict.
- 16:13And how they exactly redistrict is a bunch of different ways that it can be.
- 16:18Some may use commissions, some may hire consultants to do it for them, some may have
- 16:24the local legislative body draw instead, or there might be a completely different way.
- 16:29Again, some states give their localities more leeway into how those local legislative
- 16:37boundaries are drawn than in other states.
- 16:40So it can be a whole bunch of different ways that it happens.
- 16:44But all that being said, there are certain criteria that generally have to be followed
- 16:50when it comes to redistricting.
- 16:53Though how important they have to be in the process varies depending on federal, state, and
- 17:00local laws.
- 17:01Because again, the US constitution had very few stipulations for how to redraw congress.
- 17:10It was mostly just that they have to reapportion based on population.
- 17:14So, you know, the bigger the state is, the more US house reps they have, generally speaking.
- 17:22But how those actual districts are redrawn, mostly up to the states.
- 17:27And then state constitutions can vary considerably on how to redistrict state and
- 17:33local governments because, again, most of those powers belong to them because of the tenth
- 17:37amendment.
- 17:39But there are a handful or so of relevant factors that you typically see regardless of
- 17:47what state you're talking about.
- 17:49And the most common criteria that you see are that districts have to have an equal
- 17:55population, they have to have racial minority representation or have to have it to some
- 18:01consideration, they have to be contiguous, They have to respect existing political boundaries
- 18:07like cities and counties.
- 18:10They have to be compact.
- 18:12They have to preserve communities of interest, and there has to be some consideration for
- 18:18undue partisanship or to prevent undue partisanship.
- 18:21Those are
- 18:22the seven main criteria that you see, but not every state has to follow each one of those
- 18:30things.
- 18:31And even when
- 18:33they do follow each one of those things, what their definitions are or how important they
- 18:37have to be depends on the state.
- 18:39And looking up some of the statistics about which states consider which factors, There's a
- 18:44bit of a discrepancy in how many states use each criterion between the Congressional
- 18:48Research Service and All About Redistricting, and All About Redistricting is hosted by the
- 18:53Loyola Law School of Loyola Marymount University.
- 18:58But since all about redistricting gives numbers of states using these criteria for congress and
- 19:03state legislatures, I went with their numbers whenever possible.
- 19:09But generally speaking, there's not a whole
- 19:11lot of difference between those two sources.
- 19:14So first, equal population.
- 19:17And this can look a little
- 19:18bit different for the US house and state and local districts, but generally speaking, your
- 19:24districts have to be relatively equal.
- 19:27It's almost impossible to make them exactly equal, but they have to be pretty close to
- 19:34being equal, and there are some
- 19:36mathematical calculations for that depending on the state.
- 19:39For the US House, reapportionment, not redistricting, decides how to reallocate the
- 19:45four thirty five seats in the US House across the states based on their populations.
- 19:51But after you get to
- 19:52that point, once those seats are reapportioned, now to get to
- 19:56the actual redistricting, calculations are based on the total number of people in each
- 20:02state, not the number of voters or eligible voters that are in that state.
- 20:07So even children and babies and people who are not eligible to vote but are still adults, They
- 20:15are all counted, and states must make a good faith effort to draw districts with about the
- 20:21same number of people in each district, and so it has to be consistent and relatively small of
- 20:28a spread.
- 20:28And if you do that, it's likely going to be found to be constitutional, at least on the
- 20:34equal population grounds.
- 20:36Now for state and local districts, when it comes to equal population, there's more
- 20:41flexibility than the federal level, but they still must be quote unquote substantially
- 20:45equal.
- 20:46Legal rulings have mostly stated that it's probably not constitutional if the largest
- 20:53state legislative district and the smallest state legislative district are more than 10%
- 21:00apart, unless there's a very compelling reason for that.
- 21:04And also a smaller disparity can also be struck down if it's not justified.
- 21:09And some states are more strict legally on population equality limits than other states
- 21:17might be, especially Colorado, Missouri, and Iowa.
- 21:21But who is counted can be a bit murkier because the Supreme Court has not been definitive on
- 21:28this when it comes to the state legislatures and local legislative bodies.
- 21:33Now for the US House, yes, everybody in the
- 21:37population is counted.
- 21:39But at the state
- 21:40and local level, some pundits and states and politicians have suggested using voting age
- 21:47population, so anybody that's 18 or older or citizen voting age population, so anybody who's
- 21:5318 or older and is also a citizen of United States, or they've considered using registered
- 21:59voters rather than total population.
- 22:03So whenever it comes to the state level, it tends to get murkier and murkier because
- 22:07there's 50 different states.
- 22:10The second criterion that is predominantly considered when it comes to redistricting is
- 22:17racial minority representation.
- 22:20For the most part, their legal protections include preventing lines being drawn that
- 22:26deliberately set out to harm voters based on race, particularly black voters, and where
- 22:31discrimination currently or has historically played a significant role.
- 22:36So you look at electoral patterns to decide whether minorities have proportionate electoral
- 22:42power.
- 22:43Now the recent ruling in Louisiana versus Calais has changed some things in that regard
- 22:48because now there can no longer be a district drawn specifically to have a majority minority
- 22:53district, that is to say predominantly voters of color.
- 22:56The idea there being and this is not necessarily obviously, it's not entirely agreed
- 23:01upon.
- 23:02But the idea behind these districts is that if you have one or two of these districts where
- 23:08there are majority minority districts, you can guarantee that there's gonna be some black
- 23:13representation in Congress as opposed to if you spread them out, it becomes less and less
- 23:20likely because historically blacks have been underrepresented in Congress.
- 23:26Now, this ruling by Louisiana versus Calais is typically hailed by conservatives as not
- 23:31deliberately benefiting any race by specifically drawing districts to favor them,
- 23:36and it's also typically lamented by liberals because there are likely to be fewer people of
- 23:40color elected to congress and state legislatures now.
- 23:44There's also the consideration that black voters predominantly vote Democratic, so that
- 23:49also sways some people's opinions based on whether or not they're Republican or Democrat.
- 23:55The third criterion that is most often considered when you redistrict is contiguity.
- 24:04And contiguity means the entirety of the district must be physically connected.
- 24:08Like when you talk about the contiguous United States, you talk about the main 48.
- 24:13Alaska and Hawaii are separated from The US, so they are not considered contiguous.
- 24:20And it's for a lot of states, it's a similar case for their districts, whether it's
- 24:25congressional or state legislative.
- 24:2745 states require at least one chamber's state legislative districts to be contiguous.
- 24:34So they might require for a state house, they might require for a state senate, and then of
- 24:38course some states will require
- 24:40it for both chambers.
- 24:41Now in practice,
- 24:44the contiguous stipulations don't always work out or they're at least given some legal
- 24:52exceptions, like how some districts may be split by bodies of water in coastal states like
- 24:58Florida or North Carolina.
- 25:01They could be in these cases, they could be considered contiguous if a common means of
- 25:06transport connects the sections.
- 25:09So if there is like a ferry that typically goes between the two sides, that can be considered
- 25:15contiguous.
- 25:16Or if there's an island section and a mainland section, if the island section is closest to
- 25:22that mainland section, that part of the island will be considered part of that district that
- 25:29the mainland area is as long as they're pretty close together.
- 25:31And there's also another exception that is somewhat common that you see where a city may
- 25:40have a noncontiguous portion away from the rest of the city.
- 25:45And so in an attempt to preserve that city's representation the way it is in the state
- 25:53legislature, they may have all of that city incorporated within one legislative district.
- 25:58So those
- 25:59are the two common exceptions you see when it comes to contiguity.
- 26:04Common criterion number four for redistricting is the preservation of political boundaries
- 26:12that already exist.
- 26:13So things like counties and cities and towns and ward lines.
- 26:17The idea is to try to not split these up across state legislative districts as much as you can.
- 26:24So try to, whenever possible, keep the entire county within the same state legislative
- 26:30district.
- 26:31Now, obviously, it doesn't always work out like that because of population issues, for example,
- 26:37or population considerations.
- 26:40But in any case, 34 states require state legislative districts to show some accounting
- 26:46for political boundaries, and then 15 states do it for congressional districts.
- 26:51And because congressional districts are inherently bigger than those state legislative
- 26:54districts, sometimes the considerations are a little bit different.
- 26:59And usually, state law simply just says to keep the political boundaries, quote, to the extent
- 27:06practicable, end quote.
- 27:08So it's sometimes very vague as to what they stipulate when it comes to political
- 27:14boundaries, kind of like how it's vague for some of these other stipulations.
- 27:20And so this can be complicated for cities or towns that spill over county lines.
- 27:25So if county or, you know, I'm trying to think of a specific city, you know how Kansas City
- 27:32is,
- 27:32I mean, it's split over state lines.
- 27:34But if you were to take the situation of Kansas City and apply
- 27:40it to another city that's instead of overstate boundaries, it's over county boundaries.
- 27:46It's split up between two counties.
- 27:48That legislative district may instead just keep that entire city within the legislative
- 27:55district, even though it goes across multiple counties.
- 28:00And if counties or cities have to be split to comply with other redistricting requirements,
- 28:06like equal population, most state law does not specify if the number of splits must be
- 28:11minimized.
- 28:12So it doesn't say specifically if if you're going to have to split these counties or cities
- 28:18across multiple legislative districts, you can only do it two times.
- 28:21You can only do it three times.
- 28:23A lot of times it doesn't have that.
- 28:25It just simply says to keep the
- 28:28political boundaries to the extent practicable.
- 28:31The fifth
- 28:32major criterion that you typically see for redistricting is compactness.
- 28:38So if you look how many states split counties and state legislative districts, you will
- 28:44notice that sometimes areas are relatively squared off or at least they don't spread out
- 28:49incredibly far.
- 28:50They don't have tendrils going out everywhere.
- 28:53If you watched my episode with Stephanie Houghton, it was actually my random question of
- 28:57the day with her.
- 28:58We talked about the most pleasing looking county boundaries and we looked at a lot of the
- 29:03states, especially in the Midwest, a lot of them look very much squared off, whereas other
- 29:09states outside of the Midwest, a lot of them do not do that.
- 29:12So people in the districts
- 29:15live relatively close to each other when it comes to compact legislative districts.
- 29:21And 32 states require compact state legislative districts, while 17 states require compactness
- 29:27for congressional districts.
- 29:30But what compactness means is often vague.
- 29:33Few states actually precisely define it.
- 29:36Scholars have actually proposed over 30 different measures for it.
- 29:40And these generally fall into three categories.
- 29:42You have contorted boundaries.
- 29:44So the idea is smoother boundaries means it's more compact.
- 29:48So if it's very squared or rectangled, it's probably gonna look more compact.
- 29:55But if it's got a lot of squiggles and and many different sides, it's probably not gonna be
- 30:01considered compact.
- 30:03Then there's also level of dispersion.
- 30:05So districts that only spread out a little from a central core are considered more compact.
- 30:12And then the third basic category that you have to see is the consideration of housing
- 30:16patterns.
- 30:17So if district tendrils spread out based on whether the area is sparsely or densely
- 30:23populated.
- 30:23And this is more meaningful in dense areas because if they're more densely populated, it
- 30:28is easier to make districts more compact based on housing patterns.
- 30:33Whereas, there are a lot more spread out like in rural areas, becomes a lot more difficult to
- 30:38make them compact.
- 30:39So the consideration of district tendrils and spreading out all over the place isn't as big
- 30:45of a deal because it's going to happen when the place is sparsely populated.
- 30:51The sixth major criterion for redistricting is the preservation of communities of interest.
- 30:58And these are groups of people with a common interest, usually one that legislation might
- 31:04benefit.
- 31:05And so such interest can be incredibly varied.
- 31:08It might be a very social one.
- 31:09It might be a cultural one, historical, racial, ethnic, partisan, economic.
- 31:15Take your pick.
- 31:16It could be a whole bunch of different kinds of interests that are considered here.
- 31:22And sometimes these interests will be naturally preserved by following other criteria such as
- 31:28compactness or observing political subdivisions.
- 31:33And 15 states consider keeping communities of interest whole for state legislative districts
- 31:38and 11 states do so for congressional districts.
- 31:43The last major criterion for redistricting that a lot of states use is the consideration of
- 31:51partisan outcomes.
- 31:53So how much is a map designed to favor either Republicans or Democrats?
- 31:58Now the US constitution has had few, if any, practical limits in this regard, especially
- 32:04because at that point, the founding fathers weren't necessarily thinking about political
- 32:09parties even if they, as we talked about a couple episodes ago, even if
- 32:14they fairly quickly took to political parties once they were forming.
- 32:19At the
- 32:19time of the US constitution, they weren't necessarily thinking about those.
- 32:22So the US constitution said nothing about parties.
- 32:26And the Supreme Court of the United States has been ambivalent about this issue too.
- 32:32On one hand, it said that excessive partisanship in the process is
- 32:37unconstitutional, but it's also said that federal courts cannot hear claims of undue
- 32:42partisanship because of an inability to decide when there is too much partisanship.
- 32:48So basically, they say they cannot be the arbiters of when there is too much
- 32:55partisanship.
- 32:55It can become a political question that's then if they rule one way or another, it might also
- 33:01look like they're favoring one party or another.
- 33:04So they've kind of and those two rulings weren't around the same exact time, but the
- 33:11Supreme Court has had has kind of hemmed and hawed a little bit about what to do about
- 33:17partisan gerrymandering.
- 33:20State laws, however, have often taken to restricting undue partisanship.
- 33:2519 states do this for state legislative districts and 17 of them do it for Congress,
- 33:31though how exactly they do that differs.
- 33:33They might explicitly encourage competitive districts or they might prohibit discouraging
- 33:39of competition.
- 33:40Now how enforceable those are, we'll have to see, especially with states, both Republican
- 33:46and Democrat, clearly trying to partisanly draw favorable maps for their own respective party
- 33:54and power.
- 33:56But there are some states that at least say that you cannot draw maps that lead to undue
- 34:06partisanship.
- 34:08And those are the main criteria.
- 34:10Those are the most common criteria that you see in states.
- 34:13But there are some other ones that you might see as well.
- 34:16Things like nesting.
- 34:18So nesting refers to when district boundaries of state senate districts roughly or completely
- 34:24encompass the same boundaries as two to three state house districts.
- 34:28Washington, for example, their state senate districts are basically the exact same
- 34:35boundaries as I believe they have two house districts within each state senate district.
- 34:42And there are several states that do that or at least come close to doing that.
- 34:47In fact, 18 states ask for nesting whenever it is possible.
- 34:51Though in a few cases, it's it's more of a rough preference rather than a mandate.
- 34:57So it's like, we'd really like you to nest these districts if you can, but we're not gonna
- 35:02make you do it.
- 35:02It's basically what the state law says in a lot of those places.
- 35:05There's also relatively few, but there are some states that use multi member districts for at
- 35:11least one of their state legislative chambers, so their districts elect more than one person
- 35:17to represent them.
- 35:18And nine states use this for their state houses and two use it for their state senates, and
- 35:23Vermont is the only state that does it for both chambers.
- 35:28And then you lastly have what are called flotereal districts, which means that a
- 35:33district wholly or partially overlaps other districts in the same chamber, as opposed to
- 35:40where you talk about nesting where state senate lines overlap a couple of state house
- 35:47districts.
- 35:48This is actually saying in floterial districts that maybe two state house districts can sort
- 35:54of overlap each other.
- 35:55And that's meant to preserve political boundaries while also limiting significant
- 35:59population disparities, especially if it's a city that is particularly large in that state
- 36:07compared to the rest And Florida, Mississippi, and New Hampshire in particular expressly
- 36:13permit flotereal districts.
- 36:16So when we take the past and apply it to today, what do we learn?
- 36:23What are the lessons of the past for today's redistricting wars?
- 36:28Well, for one thing, highly partisan redistricting has been around for a long time,
- 36:33and the process of making new districts has never ever been 100% fair across the board.
- 36:39Now there might be some places where they actually legitimately did try to be fair, but
- 36:44for every state, that's never been the case.
- 36:47But there have been eras where it has been fairer than others.
- 36:52And before these recent attempts by the two major parties to redistrict, it still wasn't
- 36:58completely fair because you have sometimes seen maps half where they have had to be redrawn
- 37:05after being struck down by courts.
- 37:07Florida, it happened back in, I believe it
- 37:10was 2014, 2016.
- 37:12North Carolina has had it.
- 37:14Arizona has had issues before.
- 37:17I'm
- 37:19and I don't know if I could say every single state has had an issue with it before, but
- 37:23probably more common than
- 37:24you think before today's recent stint of redistricting.
- 37:32But
- 37:33these past couple years have arguably been the most bold faced and widespread attempts to
- 37:38unfairly district in some time.
- 37:41Still though, even though we've had all these issues with redistricting in the past, we've
- 37:47still been able to overcome these obstacles and the makeup of political bodies has still
- 37:52managed to change over time because another lesson we can take is that gerrymandering has
- 37:58still had notable instances where it completely backfired.
- 38:01We talked about Patrick Henry and anti federalist who tried to screw James Madison out
- 38:08of an election, and it did not work out.
- 38:10James Madison won that election.
- 38:12The Whigs in 1842 trying to force single member districts to preserve their gains, that didn't
- 38:18work.
- 38:19There's a lot of instances in state governments where the ruling party tried to find every way
- 38:28to preserve its power, and it did not work.
- 38:31In my state, Florida, for example, the state legislature once had a group that was dubbed
- 38:36the Park Chop Gang, which was a group of Northern Democratic legislators who tried to
- 38:43basically fix, maybe not quite fix elections, but they tried to gerrymander districts so that
- 38:52they could constantly get reelected and keep their not just democratic power, but their
- 38:57power specifically for their specific faction of democrats.
- 39:01And now and now that was a while ago.
- 39:05That was back in, like, the sixties and maybe into the seventies.
- 39:09Now Florida's one of the most republican state legislatures there is, but that's a case where
- 39:15a party has completely changed despite one party completely dominating it.
- 39:20Or how Democrats used to rule the South and Republicans used to rule
- 39:26the North.
- 39:26And despite their attempts to hold on to power, even though at some points they were so
- 39:33dominant, they didn't really have
- 39:34to worry about redistricting.
- 39:35They actually went for long spurts of time during that first half of the twentieth century
- 39:41where sometimes they didn't even bother to redistrict because they didn't need to.
- 39:46At least they didn't need to to to keep their power.
- 39:50But, eventually, those strongholds went to the wayside and they kind of traded places as to
- 39:56where their strength was.
- 39:59So as much as gerrymandering has tried to basically rig elections, it hasn't always
- 40:04worked the way it was expected to, meaning voters can still affect some change.
- 40:08They can still tell their legislators that these things are not okay, that they want
- 40:15something new.
- 40:16And redistricting methods have also changed a lot over time.
- 40:21Even if they've swung back and forth between different methods like early on where it was at
- 40:26large to districted to a mix of at large and districted to at large, but you have to live in
- 40:31a specific district and going back and forth between all those different kinds of
- 40:36districting methods.
- 40:39So change is possible, but is it time for something wholly new?
- 40:44Could something wholly new happen like perhaps proportional representation,
- 40:49which we'll talk about in the next episode?
- 40:52Will
- 40:52enough people get tired of the redistricting wars from both parties that it spurs widespread
- 40:58grassroots change in redistricting methods?
- 41:01Perhaps many more states adopt independent commissions instead of having their state
- 41:06legislatures run the show.
- 41:10Obviously, time will tell on that, but that'll also take a lot of other people, a lot of
- 41:17normally partisan people saying that they've had enough of their own party's partisanship
- 41:22and being willing to fight for something better, fight for something more fair.
- 41:28All things said, despite all of these attempts to try to, if not outright rig elections to at
- 41:35least unfairly sway elections, history shows that we don't have to just accept that this is
- 41:41the
- 41:41way things are from now on, that things can change and sometimes you have
- 41:47to incentivize the powers that be, regardless of whether they're Republican or Democrat, to
- 41:54actually affect that change.
- 41:56Sometimes it has to be the people themselves that affect that change.
- 41:59But all these historical bullet points that I demonstrated and all of these different ways
- 42:07that states handle how they redistrict, it shows that we can make things better, that we
- 42:14can actually make elections more fair, but we have to demand it.
- 42:20We have to make it happen because clearly politicians are not going to do it of their own
- 42:26accord.
- 42:27It's gonna have to be us that make them do it, which is going to be a core part of the next
- 42:32episode where I talk about whether we can ensure fair districts in elections and what we
- 42:39have to consider when we talk about a fair district because what somebody else thinks is a
- 42:45fair district, we might not think is fair, or we might think something is fair and somebody
- 42:49else doesn't.
- 42:50Some attempts to gerrymander elections are pretty obvious, but some aren't.
- 42:56And we're gonna talk about what a lot of those considerations we need to think about are in
- 43:02regards to that.
- 43:03But that is gonna do it for today's episode of the politics with Paul podcast.
- 43:07As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 43:09Please like, comment, share, subscribe on YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts.
- 43:14My links in the show notes, my LinkedIn, I post on very frequently, my medium.com profile, my
- 43:19Facebook page, my website, email, my five day educational email course about how we can more
- 43:26effectively mitigate toxicity and polarization in American politics, and my book on Amazon.
- 43:33And that's gonna wrap things up here.
- 43:35So as always, thank you
- 43:37so much for listening and we'll see you next time.