Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 2025 House Market Exposed ⚠️
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the deep dive. We're here to cut through the
- 0:03noise, you know, and really get to the heart of what's
- 0:05happening. Forget this idea of a single
- 0:07National Housing market. Frankly, it's a myth.
- 0:10And today we're going to show you why we're diving deep into
- 0:14the US residential real estate scene as it stands mid 2025.
- 0:18The situation we're calling the Great Market stagnation.
- 0:22Our mission today to unpack the Aradoxes, understand the forces
- 0:26at play, and really reveal the dramatically different realities
- 0:30unfolding across the country. And this is all based on a whole
- 0:33stack of fresh data and recent analysis.
- 0:36That's right, because while those national headlines might
- 0:38seem, well, relatively calm on the surface, underneath the US
- 0:42housing market has really fractured into completely
- 0:45distinct realities. And understanding this, it isn't
- 0:47just for investors or, you know, real estate pros.
- 0:49It's actually crucial for anyone looking to buy, sell, or just
- 0:53get a handle on one of the biggest economic forces shaping
- 0:55our lives right now. OK, so we've set the stage.
- 0:58Great stagnation. But what does that actually look
- 1:00like? Let's zoom into the national
- 1:02data first. What you find is this core
- 1:04paradox, right? You've got inventory slowly
- 1:06climbing. Prices are, well, stubbornly
- 1:09high, yet sales activity is incredibly low.
- 1:11Historic lows. Even analysts are calling it a
- 1:14low velocity equilibrium. Sounds technical maybe, but for
- 1:17us it just means the markets kind of stuck in neutral, a real
- 1:20gridlock. Yeah.
- 1:21And if we look at the national key performance indicators, the
- 1:23KP is the main stats for mid 2025.
- 1:27The picture is really one of minimal change.
- 1:29Stagnation is the right word. The median home price
- 1:31nationally, it's plateaued, hovering just over say $440,000,
- 1:36maybe $443,500 as of July. For single family homes
- 1:39specifically, we're talking around $462,000 back in May.
- 1:44And that's miniscule year over year growth.
- 1:45We're talking maybe .5% to 1.2%. It's a crawl compared to recent
- 1:50years. And interestingly, see new
- 1:51construction, median prices are actually lower around 400 and
- 1:54$800. That kind of shows you builders
- 1:56are trying to move that inventory.
- 1:58OK. So price is basically
- 1:59flatlining. What about the actual activity?
- 2:02Are homes even, you know, changing hands at these prices?
- 2:05That's where it gets really stark.
- 2:06Sales volume is probably the most striking indicator of this
- 2:09frozen state. Existing home sales are tracking
- 2:12at roughly 4.01 million units annually.
- 2:16Annually. And what does that mean in
- 2:17context? Well, to put that in context for
- 2:19you, that's near a 30 year low. 30 years.
- 2:22Wow. Yeah, imagine a highway where
- 2:24traffic has just completely ground to a halt.
- 2:26That's kind of the picture. New home sales, they're also
- 2:29down about 6.6% year over year, down to 627,000 units.
- 2:34It's just a market that isn't moving much.
- 2:36And inventory, because I mean, if sales are that low, you'd
- 2:39think homes would just be piling up, right?
- 2:41If they are to a degree, active listings are up quite a bit,
- 2:45about 25% year over year. As of July 2025, that pushes the
- 2:50total to over 1.1 million homes. That is a post pandemic high.
- 2:54However, and this is important, it's still about 13% below the
- 2:57typical pre pandemic levels we saw from say 2017 to 2019.
- 3:01So yes, inventory is rising, but we're not exactly flooded with
- 3:04homes. Compared to historical norms,
- 3:05the trend is definitely upward though.
- 3:07OK, now this next metric. I know this one can be tricky.
- 3:09Months of supply for existing homes.
- 3:11It's currently sitting at 4.6 months and historically isn't
- 3:14like 5 or 6 months considered balanced?
- 3:16That's right. So on paper, 4.6 months sounds
- 3:21almost healthy, but you've called this a mathematical
- 3:23artifact. What's really going on there?
- 3:25Yeah, that's a really, really important distinction to make
- 3:27that 4.6 months. It is a mathematical artifact
- 3:30and it's quite misleading if you take it at face value.
- 3:33It's a ratio, right? You divide the total number of
- 3:35homes for Sale by the monthly sales rate.
- 3:38What we have right now is historically low inventory and
- 3:42exceptionally low sales volume. Both numbers are low.
- 3:45So when you divide 1 low number by another low number, the ratio
- 3:49appears balanced. But it's not because the market
- 3:52is healthy. It's because two unhealthy
- 3:54metrics are kind of cancelling each other out in the math.
- 3:58A truly healthy market would have both higher inventory and
- 4:01much higher transaction volume. What we're seeing is gridlock.
- 4:04Pure gridlock, not a healthy rebalancing.
- 4:07It's like saying traffic is flowing perfectly because there
- 4:09are only two cars in the entire highway.
- 4:11It doesn't mean the system is working well.
- 4:13That makes perfect sense. So the numbers look one way but
- 4:15the reality on the ground is totally different.
- 4:17Critical point, but is anything getting made maybe a little
- 4:21easier for buyers? What about affordability?
- 4:24Well, the affordability crisis definitely persists.
- 4:26I mean, a typical mortgage payment is still nearly $1000
- 4:30per month higher than it was before the pandemic. $1000.
- 4:33Yeah, that's a huge barrier for so many potential buyers.
- 4:36There is a slight positive, maybe a sliver of hope.
- 4:39Wage growth running around 3.9% year over year is now
- 4:43technically outpacing home price growth, which is under 2%.
- 4:47So purchasing power is slowly starting to maybe catch up a
- 4:50tiny bit, but it's a very, very gradual process, like taking
- 4:54baby steps up a really steep hill.
- 4:56OK, so buyers are barely gaining ground.
- 4:58Prices aren't really falling. This gridlock, this slow burn,
- 5:02it has to be driven by some powerful underlying economic
- 5:04forces, right? Let's pull back a bit and look
- 5:07at the big picture. What's causing this freeze?
- 5:09The single the most dominant factor without question is the
- 5:12mortgage rate impasse. Average 30 year fixed rates have
- 5:15just been stubbornly high. They've been hovering generally
- 5:17between say 6.6% and 7.0%. Late August 2025 they were
- 5:23around 6.58%. And critically, the forecasts.
- 5:27They offer very little hope for a return to the 5% range anytime
- 5:30soon, and many analysts believe that's the level needed to
- 5:33really unfreeze the market. So yeah, high rates are
- 5:35suppressing demand, sure, but they're also anchoring
- 5:38homeowners in place. Right.
- 5:39And what about the broader economy, inflation, jobs?
- 5:42How are those factoring in well? Inflation has been moderating,
- 5:44which is good news generally. The CPI, the consumer price
- 5:47index, was at 2.7% year over year in July.
- 5:51That cooling allowed the Federal Reserve to, you know, pause its
- 5:53rate hikes. And that's helped stabilize
- 5:55mortgage rates, even if they're stable at a high level.
- 5:57On the employment side, though, the labor market is clearly
- 6:00slowing down. Unemployment ticked up to 4.2%
- 6:03in July. Job growth has been minimal.
- 6:06Now, the slowdown is kind of a double edged sword for housing.
- 6:09It prevents a total collapse in demand, you know, from mass
- 6:12layoffs. But it also means there's less
- 6:14new income fueling the kind of intense buying sprees we saw
- 6:18before. It's a key reason things are
- 6:20just idling, and consumer confidence, as you might guess,
- 6:24remains pretty low. A lot of buyers are just waiting
- 6:27on the sidelines for more clarity.
- 6:29It really is a head scratcher though, isn't it?
- 6:31If sales are near 30 year lows and affordability is, well,
- 6:35terrible, why haven't we seen a big price crash nationwide?
- 6:39What's propping things up? Yeah, what's really fascinating
- 6:41here, and counterintuitive maybe, is what economists call
- 6:44the wealth effect. Think about it.
- 6:47The last decade created substantial home equity for
- 6:49existing homeowners. Millions of people are sitting
- 6:52on a lot of value. This means there's very little
- 6:54distressed selling happening. People aren't being forced to
- 6:56sell at a loss like they were back in, say, 2008.
- 6:59OK. That makes sense.
- 7:00Plus, you have robust equity markets.
- 7:03The stock market's done relatively well, providing
- 7:05capital for more affluent buyers.
- 7:07They can make larger down payments, or they can buy down
- 7:09their mortgage rates, paying points upfront to get a lower
- 7:12rate. This financial strength among
- 7:14existing owners, combined with the smaller pool of wealthy
- 7:18buyers who can still transact, creates a really powerful floor
- 7:22under national prices. It prevents those widespread
- 7:25declines you might otherwise expect.
- 7:27But it leads to this bifurcated market, those without
- 7:31significant assets largely priced out.
- 7:34Activity is sustained, but only by those with wealth.
- 7:37Wow, it's almost like golden handcuffs for existing
- 7:40homeowners. Great for their balance sheets
- 7:42but terrible for market fluidity and really tough for anyone
- 7:46trying to get in. Exactly.
- 7:47It locks things up. So it's not just a slow market,
- 7:49it's fundamentally unequal in how it's playing out.
- 7:52But OK, wealth can't conjure up new homes out of thin air.
- 7:55That brings us to the other critical piece, supply.
- 7:58And this is where things get really divergent, right?
- 8:01Absolutely. The supply side is where the
- 8:03regional stories really split apart.
- 8:06The single biggest constraint, and this is a national thing, is
- 8:09the lock in effect we touched on with mortgage rates.
- 8:12Analysis from places like JP Morgan shows that over 80%,
- 8:16eight, 0% of existing mortgage holders have rates that are 1%
- 8:20or more below current market rates. 80% yeah, many are locked
- 8:24into rates between say 2.5% and 4%.
- 8:28Think about that. If you have a 3% mortgage, why
- 8:30on earth would you sell your home, give that up, only to buy
- 8:33another one and take on a 7% mortgage?
- 8:36Your monthly payment would explode.
- 8:37Right. It's a massive financial
- 8:39disincentive. Huge.
- 8:40It's like a giant game of musical chairs, but everyone
- 8:42loves their current chair and the new chairs are incredibly
- 8:44expensive so nobody wants to get up and the music slows down.
- 8:47It's effectively frozen a massive portion of the existing
- 8:51housing stock. So that lock in is basically
- 8:53starving the market of resale homes everywhere.
- 8:56Precisely. That's the story for existing
- 8:58homes. But then you look at new
- 9:00construction and it's a completely different picture,
- 9:02especially regionally. New home supply is actually
- 9:05quite plentiful, particularly in the Sunbelt, the South and the
- 9:08West. Nationally, there were around
- 9:11481,000 new homes listed for sale recently.
- 9:15That's the highest level since way back in 2007.
- 9:18And a big chunk of those 385,000 are speculative homes, meaning
- 9:23they were built without a buyer already lined up.
- 9:25That's the highest spec inventory since 2008.
- 9:28Wow. So a flood of new homes in
- 9:29certain areas. Exactly.
- 9:31Mostly in regions where construction boomed after the
- 9:34pandemic. But even there, we're now seeing
- 9:36builders putting on the brakes because of the high interest
- 9:38rates impacting their borrowing costs and buyer demand.
- 9:40We've seen a sharp fall in multifamily starts, for example.
- 9:43OK. So let's connect the dots and
- 9:45you have this universal lock in squeezing the resale market
- 9:48every. Yeah.
- 9:49But then you have this surge of new construction mainly in the
- 9:51Sunbelt. How do these two different
- 9:54supply stories create that nation divided you mentioned
- 9:56earlier? It really comes down to a
- 9:58concept called market elasticity, or, you know,
- 10:01flexibility. The universal lock in effect
- 10:03creates scarcity in the resale market everywhere, no escaping
- 10:07that. But the key differentiator
- 10:10between regions is their ability to add new supply.
- 10:13The Sunbelt, generally speaking, has more available land and
- 10:16often more permissive zoning laws.
- 10:19It acted as an elastic market. It could stretch and respond to
- 10:23the pandemic demand surge with a massive wave of new buildings.
- 10:26So it could build its way out of the initial scarcity.
- 10:28Right. That created the boom.
- 10:30But now, as demand cools and that new supply hits the market,
- 10:33it's leading to oversupply and price corrections.
- 10:37The Sunbelt has the flexibility to both boom and correct because
- 10:40it can build. The Northeast, and parts of the
- 10:42Midwest, too, are fundamentally different.
- 10:44They're inelastic markets. They have geographical
- 10:47constraints, much less open land, established development
- 10:50patterns, and often very restrictive zoning that makes
- 10:52adding new supply incredibly difficult and slow.
- 10:55Rigid markets. It's exactly rigid with very
- 10:59little new construction possible.
- 11:01These areas are fully exposed to that lock in effect on the
- 11:03resale side piled on top of pre-existing chronic undersupply
- 11:08issues. So what happens?
- 11:10Higher costs, persistent scarcity, and continued price
- 11:13appreciation. Even when affordability is
- 11:15terrible, they just can't build enough to relieve the pressure.
- 11:18This is where it gets really specific for you, the listener.
- 11:21We need to break down the US into these distinct housing
- 11:25market narratives because where you live truly matters most
- 11:28right now. Yeah, we can essentially
- 11:30categorize the country into three main stories.
- 11:32First, you have the resilient Northeast and Midwest lands of
- 11:36scarcity. These regions are actually
- 11:38showing the strongest price growth currently.
- 11:40The Northeast, for instance, saw a pretty robust 4.1% year over
- 11:43year increase in price per square foot in July 2025.
- 11:47Price per square foot. That's interesting.
- 11:49Why that metric? It's crucial there because with
- 11:51so little land and new building, every square foot is at a
- 11:54premium and that value is still climbing significantly.
- 11:58The Midwest also saw respectable growth, around 1.3%.
- 12:02What's driving this critically low inventory?
- 12:06Active listings are down, I mean a staggering 51% in the
- 12:09Northeast compared to pre pandemic levels, down 40% in the
- 12:13Midwest. Half the inventory gone in the
- 12:14Northeast. Basically yes compared to normal
- 12:17and homes are selling fast. 13 days faster in the northeast
- 12:21than the pre pandemic average, 8 days faster in the Midwest.
- 12:24You see states like Connecticut, Rhode Island, New Jersey posting
- 12:27strong year over year price gains because supply is just
- 12:30incredibly tight. Even smaller markets like
- 12:32Johnstown, PA, saw huge increases.
- 12:35It's not just a big city thing. That's really surprising growth,
- 12:38especially in regions people don't always think of as housing
- 12:40hotspots. It really underscores that
- 12:42scarcity factor. It's all about scarcity.
- 12:44Limited land, restrictive zoning.
- 12:47New supply just cannot keep up, even with demand being somewhat
- 12:50muted by rates. OK, so that's story #1 what's
- 12:53story #2? Story #2 is the Sunbelt
- 12:55correction from boom to balance. This is where things have
- 12:59shifted most dramatically. These markets, mainly in the
- 13:02South, are now facing the most significant cooling.
- 13:06Many areas have shifted to a buyer's market.
- 13:08Median list prices are down slightly year over year in the
- 13:11South, overall, maybe .6%. Homes are sitting on the market
- 13:15longer, about 8 days longer on average.
- 13:17Price cuts are widespread. Florida as a prime example.
- 13:20It hit 15 year highs in active listings recently.
- 13:23Just a ton of inventory building up.
- 13:24And what's driving that reversal?
- 13:26It's that combination we talked about, the massive surge in new
- 13:29construction supply finally hitting the market, coupled with
- 13:32the cooling of that intense pandemic era migration to these
- 13:35areas. You look at Austin, TX, kind of
- 13:37the poster child. List prices down almost 5% year
- 13:40over year, homesteading for 65 days.
- 13:42Further declines are forecast there.
- 13:43Miami is seeing similar trends. List prices down time on market,
- 13:47way up. Louisiana's even forecast to say
- 13:49significant price drops in cities like Huma and Lake
- 13:51Charles, Texas, overall added 91% more inventory than it had
- 13:55back in 2019. Wow, a complete flip from being
- 13:59red hot just a couple of years back.
- 14:02So the Sunbelt party is definitely cooling down.
- 14:05What about the West? The West is story #3 the cooling
- 14:08WA mixed picture. It's also seeing a slowdown.
- 14:11Median list prices down slightly year over year, maybe .8% time
- 14:15on market, up 10 days. Overall inventory there is now
- 14:18actually about 9% above pre pandemic levels.
- 14:21A lot of this is correction from those really unsustainable
- 14:23pandemic booms in the Mountain West states, Colorado, Utah,
- 14:26Nevada, Washington state. Those got overheated high cost
- 14:29California markets. They're still competitive
- 14:31fundamentally because of long term supply constraints, but
- 14:34even they are seeing a slowdown because of rates and just sure
- 14:36affordability exhaustion. So even California's feeling it,
- 14:39how does that play out? It's complex there.
- 14:42You take San Jose. The median sale price is still
- 14:44incredibly high, like $1.5 million, and technically up year
- 14:48over year, but broader indices like Zillow's show an underlying
- 14:51decline of about 1.1%. In San Francisco, similar story,
- 14:55median sale price $1.4 million, up slightly year over year, but
- 14:59you see a clear split. Single family homes are holding
- 15:02up better while the condo market is weaker.
- 15:04Oakland stands out as maybe the weakest major metro in the state
- 15:07right now. Redfin reported median prices
- 15:09down over 12% year over year there recently as Zillow showed
- 15:12nearly 10% down. So definitely cooling, but with
- 15:15variations. What's really striking, though,
- 15:16is that even within a state like Texas, which is seeing this
- 15:19broad correction you mentioned, there can be outliers defying
- 15:22the trend, like McKinney. Yeah, McKinney, TX is a perfect
- 15:25example of how local dynamics can buck the regional trend.
- 15:29Wallet Hub actually ranked it as a top real estate market for
- 15:322025, but its strength isn't coming from scarcity like in the
- 15:36Northeast. It's coming from really strong
- 15:39growth fundamentals, incredible job growth, something like 21%
- 15:42annually, and a robust pipeline of new building that's actually
- 15:46matching that strong demand. It just proves you absolutely
- 15:49cannot paint the entire country or even an entire state with a
- 15:52single brush. You have to get local.
- 15:54Absolutely. So taking that point further,
- 15:57let's connect this to the bigger picture.
- 15:59What are the longer term trends shaping real estate beyond just
- 16:03this immediate stagnation in 2025?
- 16:05Well, demographics are always huge.
- 16:07One interesting thing recently is immigration policy changes
- 16:10led to a noticeable decline in the US foreign born population
- 16:13in the first half of 2025, maybe over 1,000,000 fewer people.
- 16:17Short term that could reduce demand, especially for rental
- 16:20housing. But the flip side is critical.
- 16:22Immigrants make up roughly 30% of the construction labor force.
- 16:26Yeah. So a sustained reduction there
- 16:28could actually worsen the housing shortages in the long
- 16:31run, especially in those undersupplied markets, and
- 16:34potentially drive up building costs even more than there's
- 16:37remote work. That continues to fuel demand
- 16:39for larger homes, maybe in more affordable suburban or even
- 16:42exurban areas. People want space.
- 16:45However, we're also seeing some corporate return to office
- 16:48mandates and that seems to be stabilizing demand in some prime
- 16:52urban locations again. So it looks like we're heading
- 16:55towards more of a hybrid future for housing Demand patterns and
- 16:59policy, especially at the local level, remains a massive factor.
- 17:01Restrictive zoning is still a major barrier in those inelastic
- 17:05markets, basically perpetuating the affordability crisis in
- 17:08places like the Northeast and parts of California.
- 17:10OK, so weaving all this together, what does it mean for
- 17:13you, the listener, whether you're thinking about buying,
- 17:16selling, maybe investing, or just trying to understand your
- 17:19own community's market? Well, for anyone navigating this
- 17:22market, the current environment really demands A nuanced
- 17:25strategy. It's not simple for investors,
- 17:28for example, that Sunbelt correction we discussed that
- 17:31could present strategic buying opportunities in places like
- 17:34Austin, Phoenix, parts of Florida.
- 17:36If you have a longer term view, you might acquire assets at a
- 17:39discount now, betting on strong underlying fundamentals like job
- 17:44and population growth to eventually absorb that excess
- 17:47inventory. Conversely, you probably need to
- 17:50navigate the Northeast with caution.
- 17:52It's likely less about finding deals for rapid appreciation
- 17:56right now and more about long term wealth preservation and
- 17:58maybe stable rental income precisely because of those high
- 18:02barriers to entry and the persistent scarcity.
- 18:04So different place for different regions.
- 18:06Exactly. And it's crucial to monitor the
- 18:08new construction pipeline very closely.
- 18:10That sharp drop in multifamily starts we saw happening in 2025,
- 18:15that's often a leading indicator.
- 18:16It suggests a potential shortage of new rental units coming
- 18:19online in the next, say, 24 to 36 months.
- 18:22That could create future opportunities, especially for
- 18:24rental property investors. And it's not just about where,
- 18:28but what type of property to. Absolutely critical.
- 18:30You have to differentiate by property type.
- 18:32Broad market analysis just isn't enough anymore.
- 18:35We mentioned San Francisco single family homes behaving
- 18:38very differently from condos in places like New Jersey.
- 18:41Reports suggest townhouses and condos might be becoming more
- 18:44buyer friendly, while single family homes remain firmly in a
- 18:47seller's market due to that extreme scarcity.
- 18:50You really need a granular approach.
- 18:52Get single family homes versus condos versus townhouses, and do
- 18:56it within specific submarkets, not just the metro area as a
- 18:59whole. That's essential for making
- 19:01informed decisions. Wow.
- 19:04It is incredibly clear that the US housing market today isn't
- 19:07one thing. It's truly a collection of
- 19:09distinct micro markets, each playing out its own story.
- 19:12This great market stagnation isn't just about slow sales.
- 19:15Nationally really is a tale of two, maybe even three different
- 19:18countries operating side by side within one border.
- 19:21Precisely. And I think the key take away
- 19:22for you listening is that this national price stability, this
- 19:26plateau we see in the headlines, it's actually masking deep
- 19:29dysfunction and frankly inequality.
- 19:32It's creating totally opposite outcomes depending on where you
- 19:34live and your financial situation.
- 19:36Understanding these granular local realities is absolutely
- 19:40crucial now. You just can't rely on those
- 19:41broad national trends anymore. So maybe to leave you with a
- 19:45final thought to chew on, given the unprecedented power of this
- 19:49lock in effect holding homeowners in place and this
- 19:52stark regional divergent, we've mapped out, what long term
- 19:56societal shifts might this great market stagnation permanently
- 19:59imprint on how and where we live?
- 20:02Things far beyond just the month to month home prices.
- 20:04We've unpacked the present reality, this gridlock, this
- 20:07division, but the future, it's still being built or perhaps in
- 20:10some places not being built much at all.
- 20:12And that really depends on where you happen to be standing.