Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 323. Turn Up the Heat: Make Conflict More Constructive
Transcript
- 0:00Matt Abrahams: Adding warmth to heat can actually help your conflicts.
- 0:05My name's Matt Abrahams, and I teach Strategic Communication at
- 0:08Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:10Welcome to Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:19Today I'm looking forward to once again speaking with Priya Parker.
- 0:21Priya is best known for her work, The Art of Gathering:
- 0:24How We Meet and Why It Matters.
- 0:27She's an expert facilitator and strategic advisor.
- 0:30She's worked with many organizations and individuals worldwide to
- 0:33reimagine how we come together in both personal and professional settings.
- 0:37Her latest book is The Art of Fighting: The Transformative Power of Conflict.
- 0:42Priya, thank you so much for joining me again.
- 0:44Our audience really enjoyed our previous conversation in episode 174.
- 0:49Thanks for being back.
- 0:50Priya Parker: Thank you so much for having me.
- 0:52Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 0:53Uh, shall we get started?
- 0:54Priya Parker: Let's do it.
- 0:55Matt Abrahams: All right.
- 0:56Uh, when you were last with us, you introduced the concept of heat in
- 0:59communication and relationships, and I know you've talked about healthy
- 1:04heat as a transformative tool.
- 1:06Can you help share what you mean by healthy heat?
- 1:10Priya Parker: In so many workplaces and groups and friendships, when conflict
- 1:16arises, we tend to oscillate between two places, what I call unhealthy
- 1:23peace, which is conflict avoidance, pretending everything's fine, nothing
- 1:27to see here, folks, and unhealthy conflict, domination, escalation, abuse.
- 1:34And as a conflict resolution facilitator, I know that there's actually a third
- 1:40place, which is a very important place to be, which is what I call healthy heat.
- 1:44And healthy heat is the ability to hold friction or tension well between people
- 1:49with care long enough for something to be generative or clarifying.
- 1:54Matt Abrahams: So help me understand, what are some of the ways of generating healthy
- 1:59heat without burning down the house?
- 2:01And you use a great example in your book, The Art of Fighting,
- 2:05that really hit home for me.
- 2:06You talk about, uh, pineapple and ham pizza, which is a perpetual
- 2:10debate my wife and I had.
- 2:12How do you generate healthy heat in those moments?
- 2:14And, and you mentioned banter, which is something that really fascinates me.
- 2:19Priya Parker: I think of banter as the elixir of pro-social conflict.
- 2:26Part of our, our fear of approaching conflict, and I have it as
- 2:29well, is that we are afraid that it's gonna burn the house down.
- 2:33And part of what I began to see in teams, in restaurants, in organizations and
- 2:39clubs that were able to have relevant conversations that scared the people
- 2:45in them, but were helpful to their performance and breakthrough, was that
- 2:49they added warmth to heat, and they began to see that there are so many
- 2:56different ways to actually approach conversations and, and have actually
- 3:01energy and debate and controversy that also injects fun, and humor, and energy.
- 3:09One of the things I began to see in multiple different workplaces was that
- 3:13when people normalized or were invited into banter, like literally bantering
- 3:18with each other, whether it was part of the culture or whether they actually
- 3:20designed for it, low stakes arguing helped them prepare for high stakes arguing.
- 3:30And I was in a room in a tech company that was bringing together their
- 3:34leadership, uh, across a global organization, across a lot of departments.
- 3:39They knew that they were at a crossroads as a company.
- 3:40They needed to really have serious conversations in which the conversations
- 3:44themselves, the arguments, the debates, would affect the outcome of the
- 3:49direction they wanted to go as a company.
- 3:50So, they needed, like so many teams, to be able to actually have good conversation.
- 3:55Any time they'd sort of approach a more difficult or, or high-stakes conversation,
- 3:59people would kind of lean out.
- 4:01And so, uh, on the first day, 500 people in this ballroom, and the
- 4:06vice president of the company came out on stage and said, "You know,
- 4:12I don't really want to start in a heavy place today, but
- 4:15we got a lot of work to do.
- 4:17And so, we're gonna start with five really important but controversial
- 4:21conversations." And he said, "So, the first one I want to really put to you
- 4:25all as leaders of this firm are, is," and he put up a slide behind him, and
- 4:30it said, "Pineapple on pizza, yes or no?" People were like, "What the heck?"
- 4:36And then he said, "Okay, turn to three people around you and debate for
- 4:4115 minutes." People started turning to each other and started debating.
- 4:45And in the group that I was in, somebody was like, "Yum, it's amazing.
- 4:48Salty and sweet." And someone else was like, "This is disgusting."
- 4:51And someone else was like, "Well, I'm Italian, and this is offensive
- 4:53to my tradition," you know?
- 4:54But all of a sudden, people started laughing and chatting,
- 4:58and the room changed.
- 4:59And then he came back and he said, "Okay, let's hear it out." And then he began
- 5:03to go from the small group to the large group where people started yelling out
- 5:06pros and cons for pineapple on pizza.
- 5:08And this group of people, who let alone didn't know each other, had the social
- 5:13permission to argue about something that didn't matter, but that they felt
- 5:17strongly about, was actually injecting warmth into the room to help them practice
- 5:24actually disagreeing with one another.
- 5:26And immediately, it basically gives people humor, banter, and social
- 5:32permission to actually be, I don't want to use the word antagonistic, but
- 5:35actually turn to each other and have a different form of interaction that's
- 5:39related to controversy, but infuses fun.
- 5:43And those are two elements, two ingredients in communication and in
- 5:47an interpersonal, uh, interaction that often doesn't go together.
- 5:52But when it does, it begins to help you approach the heat to realize, oh,
- 5:56there's so many ways we can do this.
- 5:59Matt Abrahams: I really like this idea of adding warmth to heat, which plays on
- 6:04lots of words, but really taps into some foundational principles in communication
- 6:09by bringing connection and levity, and in service of practicing, how we're
- 6:14going to interact with each other.
- 6:16So it's a way of warming up and practicing and showing respect in
- 6:22something that doesn't really matter that can be really close to people.
- 6:26If you listen to Think Fast, Talk Smart, you know I believe communication
- 6:29is something we can all get better at, and getting better takes more
- 6:33than simply learning new ideas.
- 6:35It takes practice.
- 6:36That's why I love teaching Communication Essentials for Work and Life
- 6:40through Stanford Continuing Studies.
- 6:42We explore the communication challenges that show up in everyday life, how
- 6:47to be more persuasive, tell better stories, strengthen your presence,
- 6:51navigate difficult conversations, and connect with others more effectively.
- 6:55Along the way, you'll hear from expert guest speakers, learn
- 6:58practical techniques, and most importantly, have opportunities
- 7:02to put those ideas into practice.
- 7:04My goal is simple, to help you become a more confident, clear, and effective
- 7:09communicator at work and in your life.
- 7:12If that sounds like something you'd like to work on, I'd love to have you join me.
- 7:16Learn more and sign up at continuingstudies.stanford.edu/tfts.
- 7:25That's continuingstudies.stanford.edu/tfts.
- 7:29I'd like to move to right in the moment when conflict is generating.
- 7:35Uh, there's a difference between identifying a dispute
- 7:39and actually addressing it.
- 7:41Uh, when we're caught in a, in a spontaneous moment where a
- 7:44disagreement just flares up, what's the best way to address that?
- 7:48Is there a conversational framework for naming it honestly without immediately
- 7:53triggering the person and getting into a, a full-on conflict right away?
- 7:58Priya Parker: One of the things I did with The Art of Fighting was I began to
- 8:01look at places that actually fight well.
- 8:04One of the types of teams I looked at were restaurants, in part because
- 8:09restaurants have inbuilt 110 micro conflicts every night of service.
- 8:15And I looked at this restaurant called Canlis.
- 8:18Part of what they do as a team is they assume that there will be
- 8:25disagreement between and conflict between every employee at some point
- 8:30or another, and they find ways to ritualize it, to normalize it, and to
- 8:37be able to have a place to diagnose what's happening, and then also have a
- 8:42second moment to go and deal with it.
- 8:44If the team is sort of snapping at each other while preparing the evening's
- 8:47meals or cleaning up after close and, and someone can hear something's, you
- 8:51know, starting to really bubble between two employees, you may actually hear
- 8:55one of the owners or the chef or any leader of the organization yell on
- 8:58the floor, "Take it to the hooch!" And the staff involved in the exchange, as
- 9:04irritated as they might be, drop what they're doing and file into a secret
- 9:09room they built in the restaurant for these purposes, specifically created to
- 9:13relieve tension in the heat of battle.
- 9:15And you sneak downstairs in this funny little room in the basement of
- 9:19the basement, and it's time to talk.
- 9:20How do you decide what to do in the heat of the moment?
- 9:23Really, teams and organizations that are, have group intelligence are starting
- 9:31to find ways to normalize, ritualize, and give both tools and places and
- 9:37skills for, for people to be able to actually have the argument and not rely
- 9:45so deeply on the, you know, on putting it on the weight of the individual.
- 9:48In fact, one of the things I actually have it with me.
- 9:50Canlis has come out with an employee manual.
- 9:53It's the first time I've ever seen an employee manual that doesn't
- 9:56look at if conflict arises, you have to go to HR, right?
- 9:59Or if conflict arises, you have to go to alternative dispute resolution.
- 10:03They actually have conflict as one of the core ways their team builds trust.
- 10:08They have a three-page manual on what to actually do in the moment, and the first
- 10:12thing they say is, "Assume the best in others and look for their true north."
- 10:19Matt Abrahams: Wow.
- 10:20That's so powerful to, to build it into the way you do business.
- 10:25I appreciate the idea of normalizing it, that conflict is natural and normal,
- 10:29and when you bring people together who are good at what they do and
- 10:31passionate, conflict is going to arise.
- 10:34The ritualizing part I'm, I'm curious about.
- 10:37I can see a leader saying, "Hey, we, we support conflict that's healthy,
- 10:40that's respectful." What are some other very specific actionable tools
- 10:44to help ritualize it so it becomes part of what we do in our daily lives?
- 10:50Priya Parker: I mean, the first is, uh, talking about conflict, shifting
- 10:54our mental model of, of conflict as something that's dysfunctional
- 10:59to something that's functional, meaning that it serves a purpose.
- 11:03And that it's not, not all conflict is good.
- 11:06Some conflict can be toxic, some conflict can be deeply unhealthy.
- 11:10But first is normalizing and saying there are certain conversations that we
- 11:13actually have to have in which there's going to be disagreement, there's
- 11:17going to be passion, in part because these questions affect us, right?
- 11:22Conflict heat is relevance.
- 11:24And so where and how do we begin to hold these conversations with care?
- 11:27I worked with a tech team, um, a few years ago where they, they realized that every
- 11:33time at their weekly leadership meeting, every time a really kind of thorny issue
- 11:37would come up that really was related to kind of who they were as a company and
- 11:44the core direction they were gonna go, either they'd run out of time or it'd be
- 11:48so scary, someone would inevitably sort of turn it into a logistical conversation.
- 11:53Like, it's a communication move, like, "Oh, well, we don't have time to do that,"
- 11:56or, "Well, actually we shouldn't even talk about that 'cause we don't have the
- 11:59bandwidth to actually implement that."
- 12:00The leader of the organization, the CEO, came to me and basically said, "We, these
- 12:05are the conversations we deeply need to have, but it feels actually scary
- 12:08to have them in our regular leadership meeting. Can you help us design a
- 12:11meeting?" So we came up with a solution, uh, to create a new type of meeting
- 12:17specifically for these larger, thornier questions, and we called it a grapple.
- 12:22And the company's leader sent out a document describing the
- 12:25purpose of the new meeting.
- 12:27The purpose was, our job as a leadership team is to discuss, debate,
- 12:32and quote, "grapple" with large strategic issues that are critical
- 12:36to us achieving our ambitious goals.
- 12:39And then they listed three factors that would trigger a grapple.
- 12:42One, a high level of uncertainty in the outcome.
- 12:47Two, a broad range of opinions among the leadership team on
- 12:51how we should handle the issue.
- 12:53And three, a significant level of risk to our long-term success.
- 12:59What this team was doing was they were raising the group intelligence
- 13:03level of all of the leaders to begin to listen differently, to say, "What
- 13:07are the conversations that rise to a grapple?" And then they laid out four
- 13:12principles that would guide them through these hot-topic discussions and, and
- 13:16outlined it in an internal document with me, which I have permission to share.
- 13:19So one, we create an inclusive way of grappling so that diverse viewpoints
- 13:24are heard, understood, and considered.
- 13:28We create a space for synchronous discussion and debate.
- 13:33We make a call on the issue at hand and commit as a team within a given timeframe.
- 13:38And we live into the decision with new behaviors that we practice and
- 13:42hold each other accountable to.
- 13:45And so they did two things here, which having the intelligence to,
- 13:48it's almost like an early warning system, to know what are the triggers
- 13:51for the type of conversation that requires a different type of meeting.
- 13:55And then the second, what are the principles of the infrastructure of
- 13:57that meeting to make it a success?
- 13:59Matt Abrahams: So much value in that response.
- 14:02The first and foremost, the idea that heat is all about relevance, and that
- 14:06you can set up almost a early detection system, train people to, to look for it.
- 14:12I like the, the three criteria you used, uh, uncertainty, uh,
- 14:17broad base of different opinions, and there's some kind of threat.
- 14:21So as you're listening, as you're engaged in the conversation, you're,
- 14:24you're searching out signals of those.
- 14:27And if they, if they exist, then in essence you say it's time to, to grapple.
- 14:31And a grapple, uh, has really specific steps to it, uh, and people
- 14:38commit to that, uh, to those steps.
- 14:41So in essence, you're giving people a framework through which to have that
- 14:44discussion, and you're naming it.
- 14:47One thing that I found really interesting in your book as you're
- 14:50talking about conflict is that you say conflict can be a sign that
- 14:56the group should evolve or disband.
- 14:58So it's actually a signal for movement.
- 15:01How can we use the friction of a fight to diagnose whether a team or community
- 15:05needs to evolve or it simply has run its course and we should disband?
- 15:09What are we looking for there?
- 15:11Priya Parker: I structured The Art of Fighting into the natural
- 15:16cycle groups go through when they have an existential fight.
- 15:21And so the types of fights I'm really interested in, in part 'cause I'm a
- 15:25facilitator and these are the fights that I'm brought in to, uh, to help
- 15:29groups hold, aren't all types of fights.
- 15:32They're not fights for dominance.
- 15:34They're not fights for extremely bad behavior.
- 15:37They're not fights for what temperature the AC should be on in the building.
- 15:41They're a specific type of fight, which is what I call an existential fight,
- 15:45which is when a majority of a group has to ask or grapple with the question,
- 15:49"Well, who are we? And how do we do this? How do we do things around here?"
- 15:53Right?
- 15:54What kind of church are we?
- 15:55What kind of football team are we?
- 15:57The other thing is groups can't actually form or, or evolve without a fight.
- 16:01So often a group starts because of a need, or a company starts because
- 16:05of a need in the marketplace, or a need in the, in the public.
- 16:08But for groups to actually evolve, fights trigger the
- 16:13conversations we've been avoiding.
- 16:16And part of what happens when a group has to face a certain conversation is
- 16:23all of the questions that often lay below the surface come to a head, and this
- 16:28often happens at moments of gatherings.
- 16:31Gatherings so often that are the forcing mechanisms to have the
- 16:35fights that make us decide aloud who we are and who we're gonna be.
- 16:41Matt Abrahams: And it is, at some point, a decision that you have to
- 16:44make if we wanna continue being or not.
- 16:47The point that evolution in groups, in teams, is predicated on tension,
- 16:54on fighting, on, on challenge, is one that's really, uh, insightful.
- 16:59Because as a leader, as a manager, as a participant in a group or a team,
- 17:03rather than avoiding it, I should be seeking it out, or at least trying
- 17:08to figure out where those tension points are to help the group grow.
- 17:11Priya Parker: Or to, yeah, or to be curious about it.
- 17:13And so part of the invitation to have how to become an artful fighter is to
- 17:18start noticing when are the conversations happening that are more likely gonna
- 17:22trigger existential conflict, and how to get both curious about it and good at it.
- 17:29Matt Abrahams: And you mentioned earlier that notion of we don't want just
- 17:32logistics to, to bowl over potential rich conversation around conflict.
- 17:40If someone listening or watching right now wants to initiate a conflict
- 17:45that they've been avoiding, what might be the best opening sentence
- 17:49or way to get that conversation going that will lead to hopefully
- 17:53good heat and productive outcomes?
- 17:55Priya Parker: I first would go through a checklist in oneself, which is, uh, what
- 18:00is my purpose in having this conversation?
- 18:03What is my intention?
- 18:04Do I think that by saying something I'm able to alter a situation?
- 18:09Could I meaningfully engage without saying something, right?
- 18:15So some of these are diagnostic tools to get better at understanding when
- 18:19to face something and when not to.
- 18:20Chapter three of The Art of Fighting is actually when not to face.
- 18:24And so a huge part of what I'm saying is not just, you know, dive into
- 18:29all conflict everywhere, always.
- 18:30Like, I'm not saying necessarily fight more, I'm saying fight better.
- 18:34And so the first is to diagnose what is the conversation I want to have?
- 18:38How do I increase the likelihood that it goes well?
- 18:40Part of what the skill is in one's own self is figuring out what is the
- 18:45need and then how do you find the right languaging, because 90% of the
- 18:49success of a fight or a gathering happens before anyone has entered.
- 18:53And so part of what you're trying to do in that situation is making sure that
- 18:56you're setting yourself up or setting other people up to have the right fight.
- 19:00Matt Abrahams: The correction you gave me of, don't go into it thinking
- 19:04I'm going to have a conflict.
- 19:05Think it's a conversation.
- 19:07And then understand what it is you're hoping to get out of it and what you need.
- 19:11And I really like the idea of how you frame it and what you do in
- 19:16advance sets you up for success.
- 19:18Many of us are so fixated on the actual event, we don't think about
- 19:22what we can do in advance to help ourselves get ready, and your Art
- 19:25of Gathering was a masterclass for me in thinking that through.
- 19:30Let's take a quick break for a word from our sponsor, Strawberry.me.
- 19:34The real value of coaching is what it helps you see and what
- 19:37it helps you do differently.
- 19:39I have been coached and I have coached others, and for me, the value is
- 19:43clarity, seeing what you're doing well, where you're getting in your own
- 19:47way, and what you can do differently.
- 19:49And if you're watching this, I'm guessing you're someone
- 19:51who wants to keep improving.
- 19:54That might mean communicating with more confidence, becoming a
- 19:56stronger leader, or getting clearer about your next career move.
- 20:00Strawberry.me is like therapy for your career.
- 20:04They match you with a coach who fits your goals and gives
- 20:07you practical, personalized guidance you can actually use.
- 20:11It's all designed to make coaching more financially accessible.
- 20:14And because it's online, you can use it from anywhere in the world.
- 20:18Visit strawberry.me/smart to get 50% off of your session, and make
- 20:23sure you tell them Matt sent you.
- 20:25Well, Priya, I knew this was gonna be great because we've had previous
- 20:28conversations, and your work is so meaningful and helpful to, to everyone.
- 20:33I'd like to end, as we always do, with three questions.
- 20:35One I'm going to make up just for you, and the other two you
- 20:38had a chance to answer before.
- 20:39I'm gonna see if they're, they're a little different now that you've spent
- 20:41some time thinking about conflict and, and healthy heat in a different way.
- 20:45Um, you up for that?
- 20:47Priya Parker: I'm up for it.
- 20:48Matt Abrahams: All right, first question.
- 20:50In The Art of Gathering, you talked about the container of a meeting
- 20:53or event and how important the physical and virtual space can be in
- 20:57influencing how communication unfolds.
- 21:01When it comes to fighting, talk to me about the importance of virtual
- 21:05communication and how we can leverage it.
- 21:08Priya Parker: The physical environment deeply affects the
- 21:10room and the Zoom and the conflict.
- 21:14And so a couple of, of tips on virtual life is, first of all, sometimes Zoom
- 21:20actually really helps conversations because Zoom is an inherent equalizer
- 21:26if you know how to use it well.
- 21:27I work with a multigenerational family that could never, one of the, one of the
- 21:32blockages to their, to their fight was that they couldn't agree on where to meet.
- 21:36Who's hosting?
- 21:36Who's paying?
- 21:37How much is an airplane?
- 21:38What does it actually mean to gather in that spot?
- 21:40And so our breakthrough actually happened because all four siblings could
- 21:44Zoom in from their own home, right?
- 21:47And so don't assume all Zooms are bad.
- 21:51Think about the tools that you have and how do you create an
- 21:54ecosystem that allows you to get the conversations that you want given the,
- 21:58given the infrastructure you have.
- 22:00Matt Abrahams: So really thinking through how the virtual can,
- 22:03can be a benefit can help.
- 22:05Question number two, who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 22:10Priya Parker: I deeply admire Mayor Zohran Mamdani.
- 22:15I think he's an extraordinary communicator, both from,
- 22:19um, his embodiment, his physicality as a communicator.
- 22:22He, uh, he wants to be where he is, which I think is actually
- 22:29a really powerful force.
- 22:30You know, when sometimes you see people communicating and they may
- 22:32be saying the perfect speech, but actually you can tell, like, they're
- 22:35not, their heart isn't really in it.
- 22:37Um, I think he's a very embodied leader.
- 22:39Um, and, and I think he's a brilliant communicator in terms of being able
- 22:43to actually talk about issues across communities that are high-wire acts and
- 22:49always come from what his values are and inviting people into a world in which
- 22:55everyone gets to experience those values.
- 22:57Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 22:58So I like this idea of being an embodied communicator.
- 23:01Be there and, and help others see that you really want to be there.
- 23:06Final question, what are the first three ingredients that go into a
- 23:10successful communication recipe?
- 23:13Priya Parker: Clarity of purpose, clarity of audience,
- 23:19and specificity.
- 23:21Matt Abrahams: Clarity of purpose and audience makes a lot of sense.
- 23:24You've talked a lot about that both in your book, The Art of Gathering and The
- 23:28Art of Fighting, and then making sure that you, you have a, a clear outcome in mind.
- 23:34Thank you, Priya.
- 23:35I knew from our last meeting that this was going to be a great conversation.
- 23:39Thank you for helping us to hold heat and really see the value that conversations
- 23:45that involve conflict can have in our organizations and in our lives.
- 23:49Priya Parker: Thank you so much for having me.
- 23:51Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of Think
- 23:54Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 23:56To learn more from Priya Parker, check out episode 174.
- 23:58It was great again learning from Priya.
- 23:59The one
- 24:02thing I'm taking away that really stood out to me was that you can add warmth,
- 24:07connection, levity to your conversations that will help you be better at
- 24:13solving the more tangled and difficult conversations and conflict that we have.
- 24:18This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 24:24Our music is from Floyd Wonder, with special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 24:28Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 24:31Be sure to check out fastersmarter.io for deep-dive videos, English language
- 24:36learning content, and our newsletter.