Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Secondary Offerings to Raise Capital
Transcript
- Lucas: So this is episode 100 — and I wanted to mark it by drilling into a topic that every newly public company will eventually face, but almost nobody talks about unless they're in the room. I'm talking about secondary offerings. Luna: Not the IPO itself — the second time they go back to the public markets to sell more shares? Lucas: Exactly. And it's almost always a moment of tension. You've got early investors who've been holding for six, seven, ten years, and they want liquidity. You've got the company itself, which might need capital to build a factory or make an acquisition. And then you've got the public market, which often interprets 'more shares for sale' as a negative signal. Luna: Right — dilution. More shares outstanding means each existing share represents a smaller piece of the company. Lucas: And the stock usually drops 3 to 5 percent on the announcement, sometimes more. But not always. It depends on how the offering is structured, who's selling, and what the money is for. Let's look at two recent examples from this year. Luna: I'm guessing one is Rivian. I saw they did a big secondary back in March. Lucas: Yeah — Rivian announced a 1.5 billion dollar secondary on March 11th. The stock was trading around 18 dollars and change. The offering was a mix: the company sold about 750 million worth of new shares to fund production expansion, and existing shareholders — mostly venture capital firms — sold the other half. The stock dropped about 6 percent that day. Luna: Ouch. But was it really the dilution, or was it the signal that insiders were cashing out while the stock was already down like 80 percent from its IPO? Lucas: That's the million-dollar question. The market tends to view insider selling — especially at low prices — as a lack of confidence. But in Rivian's case, the company itself also needed cash. They burned through 1.8 billion in free cash flow last year. The secondary was less optional and more necessary. Luna: So the market punished them for necessity, not confidence. That feels harsh. Lucas: It does, but contrast it with Airbnb's secondary in April. They did a 650 million dollar offering — all from existing shareholders, none for the company. The stock barely budged. Down maybe 1.5 percent and recovered within a week. Luna: Why the difference? Because Airbnb is profitable? Or because the sellers were early employees who'd been locked up for years? Lucas: Both. Airbnb is generating positive free cash flow — they don't need the money. So when the company says 'this is purely a liquidity event for early shareholders,' the market takes it in stride. The key variable is whether the secondary is dilutive to earnings per share. If the company is raising capital that it will deploy at a high return, the dilution can be accretive over time. If it's just selling shares to stay alive, that's a different story. Luna: And a couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these going — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, if you've gotten something out of them. Lucas: Yeah, it really does make a difference. People often ask how we keep the show ad-free — it's because a small number of listeners chip in a few bucks a month. Buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. If that's not your thing, no pressure. We're glad you're here. Luna: Alright, back to secondaries. One structural detail I think listeners would find useful: how do companies price these offerings relative to the market price? Lucas: Great question. Typically, the offering price is set at a discount to the last closing price — usually 3 to 5 percent. That discount is the incentive for institutional buyers to step in. But the size of the discount can signal demand. A small discount — say 2 percent — suggests strong demand. A wide discount — 7 or 8 percent — suggests the underwriters had to work to find buyers. Luna: And the underwriters are the same investment banks that ran the IPO? Lucas: Usually, yes. Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, JPMorgan — they'll syndicate the secondary just like the IPO. And they earn fees again, typically 2 to 3 percent of the offering size. So for a 1.5 billion dollar deal, that's 30 to 45 million dollars in fees. It's a lucrative business. Luna: Which is why banks love taking companies public — it's not just the IPO fees, it's the steady stream of follow-on offerings. Lucas: Exactly. And there's a pattern. Many companies do a secondary within 12 to 18 months of the IPO. Often right after the lockup period expires. That's the trap door for early investors. They've been locked up for 180 days, and the moment they're free, they sell. Luna: Which is why we saw that wave of secondaries in 2022 and 2023 from the 2020-2021 IPO class. Companies like Bumble, Didi, Robinhood — all did secondaries within a year. Lucas: Right. And the best time to do a secondary, from the company's perspective, is when the stock is at a high. But insiders often can't sell because of blackout periods around earnings. So you see a cluster of secondaries in the window between earnings releases — February-March, May-June, August-September, November-December. Luna: So it's a dance between insider lockups, earnings blackouts, and market conditions. One wrong step and you spook the market. Lucas: Right. And there's another variant that's worth mentioning: the 'registered direct offering.' Instead of an underwritten public offering, the company sells shares directly to a few institutional investors at a negotiated price. It's faster, cheaper, and more private — but it usually comes with a bigger discount because the buyer demands compensation for the lack of liquidity. Luna: And less price discovery, right? There's no book-building process. Lucas: Exactly. So the company trades certainty of execution for a worse price. It's a tool for when you need capital quickly and can't wait for a full roadshow. Luna: What about the shareholders who don't sell? Are they just stuck with dilution? Lucas: Short-term, yes. But if the capital is deployed well — say, to acquire a competitor at a compelling valuation — the dilution can be offset by the accretion from the acquisition. There's a whole framework called accretion/dilution analysis that investment bankers use to model this. If the deal adds more to earnings per share than the dilution subtracts, it's accretive. If not, it's dilutive. Luna: And that's the ultimate test. The market will reward accretive secondaries and punish dilutive ones. Lucas: In theory. But in practice, the market often overreacts to any secondary announcement, especially in the first few days. A study by the Journal of Finance found that, on average, secondary offerings underperform the market by about 2 percent in the first month. But then they recover over the next year as the capital gets put to work. Luna: So the initial dip might be a buying opportunity for long-term investors who trust the company's capital allocation. Lucas: That's the contrarian take. But you have to do the work — understand why the offering exists, who's selling, and what the proceeds will fund. It's not a blanket signal. Luna: Speaking of signals — there's one that's almost always negative: when a secondary is announced alongside a disappointing earnings report. That double whammy can be brutal. Lucas: Yeah, that's a common trap. The company wants to raise capital because they need it, but the market sees the earnings miss and the dilution together and punishes the stock severely. We saw that with Peloton in early 2022 — they announced a secondary right after a bad quarter, and the stock dropped 20 percent in a day. Luna: Right. And Peloton never really recovered. Lucas: So the lesson for companies is: if you need a secondary, try to do it when the story is strong. If you can't, at least wait until the earnings dust settles. And for investors, the lesson is to read the terms carefully. Is the company selling, or are insiders selling? What was the discount? How big is the offering relative to market cap? All of that matters. Luna: I also think it's worth mentioning that not all secondaries are created equal. There's a difference between a 'follow-on offering' — which is a traditional underwritten deal — and an 'at the market offering,' where the company slowly dribbles shares into the market over time. Lucas: Good point. The at the market offering, or ATM, is much less disruptive. The company appoints a broker to sell shares at prevailing market prices, up to a certain limit. The stock doesn't gap down because there's no big block trade. But ATMs are typically used by companies that need smaller amounts of capital — 50 to 200 million — and want to avoid the fixed costs of a full secondary. Luna: And they're transparent — the company discloses the ATM program in advance, but not the exact timing of sales. Lucas: Right. So it's a gentler way to raise capital. But it can also drag on for months, creating a persistent overhang on the stock. The market never knows when the company will sell next. Luna: So as a listener, if you own shares of a company that announces an ATM, should you be worried? Lucas: Not necessarily. It depends on the company's cash needs and valuation. A high-growth, cash-burning company using an ATM to fund operations is a red flag. A profitable company using an ATM to opportunistically raise capital for an acquisition is fine. Again, context is everything. Luna: Alright — so secondaries, follow-ons, registered directs, ATMs. That's a lot of vocabulary for one episode. What's the one takeaway you'd want a newly public company's CFO to hear? Lucas: Plan your secondaries like you plan your earnings calls. Have a clear narrative for why you're raising capital, and execute when your stock is strong. And if you can't, at least be prepared for the market's reaction. Because the market will ask — 'why now?' and if you don't have a good answer, the stock will pay the price. Luna: And for investors — keep an eye on the S-1 filings. The registration statement for a secondary tells you exactly who's selling and how much. It's public information, and it's full of signals. Lucas: For episode 100, I think that's a solid place to land. Next time, we'll look at how companies use stock buybacks in conjunction with secondaries — it's a more common pairing than you'd think. Luna: Looking forward to it.