Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Bloomberg Analyst: Everyone Says Bitcoin Is Dead — Here's Why They're Wrong
Transcript
- 0:00What is this like the eighth time Bitcoin has like had a
- 0:02serious drawdown. So I'm a big fan of patterns.
- 0:06This is what Bitcoin does. I have been lately acquitting it
- 0:09to Rocky. You know, I I live in Philly,
- 0:11but doesn't matter. I grew up watching Rocky movies.
- 0:14Every single movie he gets beat down and he comes back and wins
- 0:18and there's how many Rocky movies they've been like 8.
- 0:21It's a very interesting metaphor.
- 0:22So if you go to see Rocky 9, do you think, you know, do you
- 0:26think he's going to die halfway through the movie and it's over?
- 0:29I know he's going to get beat up somehow and then in the third
- 0:32act, he'll come back and he'll win.
- 0:34So I don't see any reason based on the other 8 Rocky movies why
- 0:39you won't have a comeback here. It's just what happens.
- 0:41It's just horrible when it happens.
- 0:43Doesn't feel right. You know, if you can't handle
- 0:46that volatility and you don't want to pay that price, you
- 0:49should be in bonds or something. If Bitcoin is like that on
- 0:51steroids, the price you pay is this.
- 0:54This is the the cost of admission.
- 0:56The more it hurts and the more the more you have to stare into
- 1:02the void and contemplate the whole thing and think, is this
- 1:06it? That's why you know, people who
- 1:09who have done that multiple times and hung in there have
- 1:12been so greatly rewarded. The cost is very high.
- 1:15Obviously, when I say cost, I just mean that the mental
- 1:18ability to sort of have another part of your brain say this
- 1:21isn't happening. Just because this to chart goes
- 1:24down and it's red doesn't mean it's dead.
- 1:26In fact, it could even be healthy.
- 1:27You have to play these tricks with yourself to hang in there,
- 1:30and you got to really believe in it too, and I think that's why
- 1:33those people have been greatly rewarded.
- 1:35What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 1:39going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous extra
- 1:43ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1974198792972000 and
- 1:52whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 1:55over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 1:58I say when. We sell, I say, when we sell.
- 2:07We are back. Welcome, Eric Beltranes.
- 2:10It's nice to have you back on the last trade.
- 2:13Good to see you. Thanks for making some time.
- 2:14What's going on? Not too much.
- 2:18I was just telling you before you went on, I got to write some
- 2:21evals for my team. That's like an annual thing.
- 2:25And then I got a couple research notes to get to.
- 2:29So not nothing too much, just trying to stay out of trouble.
- 2:35Good. Aren't we all?
- 2:37Well, look, you're our favorite boomer of the podcast.
- 2:39I say that in jest. I know you're not a boomer, of
- 2:41course, but we're excited to have you back on the show.
- 2:45And I think there's a great place to start is for anyone
- 2:48who's not familiar with your background.
- 2:49We, we got into it in the last episode, but Eric to me and and
- 2:53your counterpart James at Bloomberg as well are really the
- 2:56Bitcoin ETF guys. I mean, in terms of the best
- 2:59analysis, the best insights on flows over the past almost three
- 3:03years now it's been the two of you.
- 3:05And so Eric, I'd be curious. The first question for you is
- 3:09you really kind of grew in popularity as your analysis
- 3:12picked up in 2023, at least it was my perception when BlackRock
- 3:16first filed for a Bitcoin ETF, Bitcoin just traded around
- 3:2025,000 at that time. And then the ETFs actually went
- 3:24live and you had a lot of analysis between that date in
- 3:27June and January of 2024 when the ETFs went live and we were
- 3:31trading around 50,000, right? And so we've seen a major move
- 3:35to the upside from 24 almost three years ago now to 126.
- 3:40And now things are falling through the floor.
- 3:42We're trading at 67 sentiment. I know you're, you're partially
- 3:47on Bitcoin Twitter, you're in trad 5, but you're also in tune
- 3:50with what's going on in the Bitcoin space, of course.
- 3:52And look, this is a, it's an ugly chart, right?
- 3:54I think we're down about 20% in just the past week alone.
- 3:57But I'd be curious from your vantage point having really
- 4:00started to follow the asset class more closely with the
- 4:02filings of the ETFs. Just kind of like, could you
- 4:05summarize the journey that we've been on so far and, and
- 4:07contextualize this and move away from just kind of the short term
- 4:10noise that we're seeing here in the past, past past few weeks?
- 4:15Yeah, sure. So my take on it is this is not
- 4:20fun. Sell offs never are.
- 4:22And I think it's, you know, now that it like it's getting below
- 4:2570s in the 60s, you know, you get to an area that gets a
- 4:29little panicky for sure. But what is this like the eighth
- 4:33time Bitcoin has like had a serious draw down.
- 4:36In fact, it might not even be serious yet, right?
- 4:38We're talking, let's say over 50% would be like a big one has
- 4:42like 8 of them. So I'm a big fan of patterns.
- 4:45This is what Bitcoin does. You know, I have been lately
- 4:49equating it to Rocky. You know, I, I live in Philly,
- 4:51but doesn't matter. I grew up watching Rocky movies.
- 4:54It every single movie he gets beat down and he comes back and
- 4:59wins. And there's how many Rocky
- 5:02movies they've been like 8. It's a very interesting
- 5:04metaphor. So if you go to see Rocky 9, do
- 5:08you think, you know, do you think he's going to die halfway
- 5:11through the movie and it's over? No, he's going to get beat up
- 5:13somehow and then in the third act he'll come back and he'll
- 5:16win. So I don't see any reason based
- 5:21on the other 8 Rocky movies why you won't have a comeback here.
- 5:26It's just what happens. It's just horrible when it
- 5:30happens. Doesn't feel right it and
- 5:34there's questions on like why would it go down when all the
- 5:36narratives feel pretty good? But my take on that is I, my
- 5:40thesis is what happened was there were so many good
- 5:43narratives after FTX, the ETFs came in and just like
- 5:47legitimized it in a way, brought in a lot of the retail, I mean
- 5:51the advisor world, then Trump winning.
- 5:54It was like a bunch of narratives quickly priced in.
- 5:58And so this year, last year, 2025, all the narratives
- 6:02actually played out and they all happened and the pricing had
- 6:09already been priced in. I mean, 450% in two years.
- 6:13So in 2023 and 2024, you're up 450% in two years.
- 6:17That's insane. If you could borrow some of that
- 6:22like 2023 and 2024 up, I don't know, 100% each year, you would
- 6:26have had plenty for 2025 and this year to still be up a ton.
- 6:30So if you could have like it's like you got a gigantic sundae,
- 6:34too much ice cream. I wish I could just put some in
- 6:36the next two years. That's sort of I think what
- 6:39happened. It got way too ahead of itself.
- 6:44That's that's number one. Number two, I think there was a
- 6:47silent IPO. I think some of the Ogs who were
- 6:49in it a long time saw, you know, let me there's now new
- 6:52liquidity, let me take some profits from my long term
- 6:55investment. They earned it.
- 6:57Honestly, they really went through a lot.
- 6:59And so I think those two things are a play.
- 7:01I think sometimes Bitcoin always looks for the next narrative and
- 7:04it's like, well, what is the next narrative?
- 7:07But I really don't think there needs to be a next narrative.
- 7:11I feel like the debasement happens.
- 7:14It's going to happen. It's happening more that you
- 7:17know, you're that is the fundamental case still seems
- 7:21pretty solid. The network has not been hacked.
- 7:24I don't really see anything too wrong, except it's just that
- 7:27corrections are hard. You know, they don't feel good.
- 7:30That's that's my take on it, but I don't know.
- 7:32I mean, like I said, I I would just never this happens with
- 7:35stocks too. When stocks go down, I'm like,
- 7:38well, they have 100% their, their track record of coming
- 7:41back from a sell off to hit all time high is perfect.
- 7:45Literally like in stocks case it's like 1000 times, let alone
- 7:498. And I'm like, why would I not?
- 7:52Why would I worry that? I mean, I mean, I, unless the
- 7:55pattern's going to break forever and, and the 1001 time is going
- 7:59to be the one where it doesn't happen again.
- 8:02So I, I don't really know if there's too much else to take
- 8:05away here. If you're a long term investor,
- 8:07if you're a trader, maybe you go in and out, you know, you're
- 8:10trying to look for spots. I get that.
- 8:12But for long term I don't not totally sure what has changed.
- 8:16Yeah, makes a lot of sense. And you're on fire with the
- 8:19analogies. I don't know if you know Eric,
- 8:21but I'm also in the Philadelphia area as well and grew up in this
- 8:23area, so Rocky is near and dear to my.
- 8:26Heart that hits home for you, I'm sure.
- 8:27It sure does. And you know, it's, it's a great
- 8:31point. I've been thinking more about
- 8:32this just because I came from the traditional finance world.
- 8:36My father-in-law is a financial advisor.
- 8:39It was kind of a path that I saw myself on back in high school or
- 8:42college. I wanted to do wealth management
- 8:44and I did a little bit of that. But that point aside, what would
- 8:48you do if you, what would your advisor say if you were to call
- 8:50them up and you're panicking about the S&P being down 1520%,
- 8:55right? They're going to tell you, stay
- 8:57the course, sit on your hands. You don't sell, you don't let
- 9:00the fear get to you. And Bitcoin, I think it's even
- 9:02more challenging, right, because the volatility is even more
- 9:05pronounced to the downside, but also to the upside.
- 9:09To your point as well, how explosive 2024 was 2023 and 25.
- 9:13So it's all great points. It's good takeaways.
- 9:16And to your point as well, there's really nothing that has
- 9:18changed. I think the narratives have
- 9:21gotten quite negative sentiments, quite poor.
- 9:23And I don't know if you would agree with this, but a lot of it
- 9:27has to do with expectations as well, right?
- 9:29So the sentiment was awful in 2022, but that was after so many
- 9:33firms kicked the can and that was after FTX blew up and
- 9:36Bitcoin crashed through the previous all time high of
- 9:3819,000. But people were kind of already
- 9:40expecting that we were already in a bear market.
- 9:42We had already corrected 6070%. And I think the difference this
- 9:45time is that we had such high expectations.
- 9:49Well, I don't, I won't speak for the entire group of of investors
- 9:52in the space, but a lot of people had incredibly high
- 9:54expectations of 2025. Many people are disappointed
- 9:59about 126 is an all time high. And then there was the
- 10:03expectation that, well, maybe cycles don't repeat at all,
- 10:06right? So 2026 we're just going to be
- 10:07at back off to the races. But here we are trading in the
- 10:1160s and it just doesn't feel good, right.
- 10:13And so there's a bad component as well, just expectations are
- 10:16are misaligned. Yeah, I mean, there's a phrase I
- 10:22like. It came from this.
- 10:25Obviously he's a friend, but he's a colleague.
- 10:26Morgan Housel wrote a book called Psychology of Money.
- 10:28It's very good. And he talked about volatility
- 10:31is the take the price that you pay for the returns of stocks.
- 10:36You know, if you can't handle that volatility and you don't
- 10:40want to pay that price, you should be in bonds or something.
- 10:43Bitcoin is like that on steroids.
- 10:45The price you pay is this, this is the the cost of admission.
- 10:49The more it hurts and the more the more you have to stare into
- 10:56the void and contemplate the whole thing and think, is this
- 11:00it? That's why you know, people who
- 11:03who could have done that multiple times and hung in there
- 11:06have been so greatly rewarded, right?
- 11:08The cost is very high. You know, obviously when I say
- 11:13cost, I just mean that the, the mental, the mental ability to
- 11:19sort of have another part of your brain say this isn't
- 11:21happening. Like my just because this the
- 11:24chart goes down and it's red doesn't mean it's dead.
- 11:28In fact, it could even be healthy.
- 11:29Like you have to play these tricks with yourself to hang in
- 11:32there. And you got to really believe in
- 11:33it too. And I think that's why those
- 11:36people have been greatly rewarded.
- 11:37If you look at Bitcoin investors who have been in it since 15
- 11:40years or even 10 years ago, they have beat every other investor
- 11:45by a magnitude of whatever 10 or something.
- 11:49And this is the price they paid, you know, because it's brutal.
- 11:53It's like you popping depression medication or something where
- 11:56you're like, not that it cures depression, but it literally
- 11:59depresses you. Like, it's almost like taking
- 12:02some a pill that just makes you depressed and contemplate your
- 12:05whole existence with stocks that never gets that bad because you
- 12:09can hang on cash flows a little bit.
- 12:11You can go, well, yeah, this sucks, Maybe I should sell.
- 12:14But you're like, well, it's not like IBM is going to stop making
- 12:17compute. And you start to think like,
- 12:19it's not that bad. So that's like a, you know, it's
- 12:21easier with stocks in my opinion, although it gets scary
- 12:23there too. Like a 2008 can get scary.
- 12:25But this is like a whole nother level.
- 12:28That's why anybody who has made it through has has my respect
- 12:32and deserves to cash out a little.
- 12:33That's why this island IPO doesn't bother me.
- 12:37You know, it makes, seems natural to me.
- 12:39What does make me a little nervous, and this is something
- 12:42you, you probably better take to me on is if you're an OG and
- 12:46you're really into the concept and and it's not just a Ponzi
- 12:49scheme for you and you really do believe that it's a place to
- 12:52store value against the declining currency.
- 12:55Why, why would you pull all out? Like I, I don't know what, why
- 12:59not keep a 70% in Bitcoin no matter what's going on if you're
- 13:03a long term believer? So I do sometimes wonder if some
- 13:06of these OG's either because they think, well, trad Fi's
- 13:09involved now it's not cool anymore, or they just want a ton
- 13:14of money. I don't know.
- 13:15I just wonder like if you got in early for the concept that it's
- 13:20hard money that the government can't dilute, that is completely
- 13:24intact. So why would you not stay at
- 13:26least a majority of your holdings?
- 13:28I don't know if you have any thoughts on that.
- 13:30Yeah, I'll let Brian chime in too.
- 13:32But one thing that this is something I have been thinking
- 13:36about as well, Eric. And I think it's a challenging.
- 13:38First of all, it's challenging to understand out of the cohort
- 13:41of people, let's say the whales of the past decade plus that
- 13:45have been selling, it's hard to say are they selling what
- 13:49percentage of them are selling a full position versus selling
- 13:52part of the position. I have spoken to some people who
- 13:55say that that are that are not happy in terms of the capture
- 14:00that they perceive of of Wall Street traditional finance of
- 14:03Bitcoin. And some people genuinely feel
- 14:05like Bitcoin no longer is aligned with the original vision
- 14:10that Satoshi had. And so I think some people are
- 14:13ideological driven and may have resulted in fully liquidating.
- 14:18But I would love to see some more concrete numbers in terms
- 14:21of what is full liquidation of the sellers versus partial
- 14:24liquidation. And then in terms of the IPO
- 14:27moment, you spoke to a lot of the the aspects to it.
- 14:29I think one other aspect that maybe is often underlooked is
- 14:33the fact that, yeah, there is the psychological number of 100K
- 14:37and big milestone to head and cash out some of the position.
- 14:40I think what some people miss as well is the fact that you
- 14:43couldn't really cash out a sizable position of Bitcoin in
- 14:47previous presidential administrations.
- 14:50You ran the risk of having those dollars frozen in your account,
- 14:54even the previous Trump administration, right?
- 14:55Trump has really changed his tune in terms of Bitcoin and
- 14:58crypto. And so I think there was also
- 15:00that aspect of, look, we can't sell.
- 15:03I mean, we definitely can't sell into onshore bank accounts.
- 15:05There's no way to liquidate billions of dollars of Bitcoin a
- 15:08year or two ago. But now that's changed.
- 15:11And so I don't know, Brian, if you have other thoughts as well
- 15:14just in terms of some of these points, but it's something I
- 15:17think it, you know, it's worth asking Eric and it's a little
- 15:19bit challenging to parse out fully.
- 15:21Yeah, I mean, I, I agree with all that.
- 15:23I think there's, there's different components to it.
- 15:25But I think what makes this most recent sort of drawdown or, or
- 15:30chop downwards particularly painful for folks is that you've
- 15:35watched gold and precious metals run aggressively over the past
- 15:38year. And and you had the debasement
- 15:40trade become more mainstream, be less of a niche, you know, crazy
- 15:44conspiracy, you know, theory type mental model.
- 15:48And it really it it did become much more legitimate in terms of
- 15:53like, yeah, this is happening, the dollar is being debased.
- 15:56You need to protect yourself with outside money, hard assets.
- 16:00And Bitcoin hasn't sort of kept up with that narrative
- 16:04necessarily. Now.
- 16:05I think there's a few sort of, you know, possible reasons for
- 16:09that. One, I think there's a lot of
- 16:11people that still anchor to the, you know, the historical four
- 16:14year cycles. And I think there was a lot of
- 16:16front running last year of that dynamic.
- 16:18And so, you know, if you think about that four year cycle, you
- 16:22know, last year was supposed to be a green year and I think
- 16:24people got ahead of thinking that 26 would be a a down year.
- 16:29And so they just front ran that trade.
- 16:30And and I think that's part of what we saw.
- 16:34But, you know, I think there is, to your point, Jackson, there's
- 16:36certainly, you know, a lot of people who've been in Bitcoin
- 16:39for a long time who are ideologically driven around
- 16:43seeing what has happened with ETFs, with banks getting into
- 16:46the game. And, and that just rubs them the
- 16:48wrong way. And I think that's, I think
- 16:50that's reasonable. But at the same time, at least
- 16:52from my vantage, and maybe I'm somewhat biased because I came
- 16:56from the trad fire world, you know, spent a decade in, in
- 16:58private banking, But I always kind of like thought like that
- 17:01would be the path. Like if Bitcoin's going to be
- 17:05digital money for the future, you know, an Internet native
- 17:07currency, there's going to be adoption from people you don't
- 17:10like institutions that on their face may seem adversarial to the
- 17:15asset or the original ethos of the asset.
- 17:18But to me, that was kind of always going to be the path.
- 17:20And so I think it's reasonable for early folks to, you know,
- 17:25not like that aspect of, of sort of where adoption is headed, but
- 17:28I just think that that was always going to be a reality of,
- 17:31of the situation. You know, if, if, if bitcoin's
- 17:34going to grow from A1 to $2 trillion asset to a 10 to $20
- 17:39trillion asset, you're going to need those other rungs of
- 17:41capital to be involved, right? Like, I don't think just pure
- 17:45retail speculators get us to those numbers that ultimately
- 17:50really compete with gold. I think you need other rungs of
- 17:53of institutions and allocators to come in.
- 17:59Yeah, I mean, that seems to be pretty.
- 18:02I mean, I think there there was even there's a couple of the old
- 18:05founding father types who wrote that.
- 18:08I mean, I so it doesn't seem that weird.
- 18:09I so I'm not, I don't really get the ethos thing plus nothing
- 18:14about in a weird way, you know, I mean the FTX and there's been
- 18:22a couple exchanges that were hacked.
- 18:24FTX is probably the best example, really high profile.
- 18:29I if you say, well, that wasn't bitcoins problem, that was just
- 18:33a bad intermediary, then you could then come to the
- 18:36conclusion that, well, we need better intermediaries.
- 18:38Well, that's where Triadfy is filling this void.
- 18:41If FTX hadn't messed up so much, I it would be harder, I think
- 18:44to, for and if they had lower fees to out of the ETFs probably
- 18:48wouldn't have been as big of a hit.
- 18:50So I think all this time, whether you're getting your
- 18:54Bitcoin through an ETF or a crypto native exchange, I guess
- 18:59you'd call it, it's just intermediaries.
- 19:03The actual base asset is exactly the same, hasn't changed at all.
- 19:08This did nothing. So that's why I, I really think
- 19:11it it, it doesn't take too much mental work to get through that.
- 19:15But yeah, I sometimes equated somebody had said, it's like
- 19:18your parents joining Facebook. You know, there is just
- 19:21generally a this is back in my day when I'm not a boomer again.
- 19:25By the way, I always say, I say done have some respect.
- 19:31I'm Gen. X.
- 19:31We fought the Boomers before you were even born.
- 19:35We were fighting the Boomers before cell phones.
- 19:37OK, Yeah. We were like have some respect.
- 19:41No, it's true though, because my my father is a boomer.
- 19:45Boomers had young kids. So Gen.
- 19:46X is like only 20 years after the Boomer.
- 19:48So anyway, but we were first anyway, we that's just sometimes
- 19:54the boomers, I think really pissed off the millennials the
- 19:56most. I don't know.
- 19:57There's there's those two generations are like, I think
- 19:59they're alike and they just they're like opposite ends of a
- 20:02anyway. But anyway, enough on that.
- 20:05The idea of these intermediaries being just a little more
- 20:09trustworthy is good and it's cheaper and it's just easier to
- 20:13access. The Jack Dorsey thing about
- 20:16like, well, it has to be a currency that that's one where
- 20:18it's it is a more interesting question.
- 20:21But maybe you need it to be something people are familiar
- 20:24with as an investment, because if you all if you want, Ibid and
- 20:27then you go to the store and you see it takes Bitcoin, you just
- 20:29all of a sudden you're you're way more curious than you would
- 20:31have otherwise been. So I just think it's fine the IT
- 20:35being a global currency, I'll just think it needs to be a
- 20:38little more easy to use on the phones because someone compared
- 20:42it to fantasy football in order if you play that, but a total
- 20:46moron can use fantasy football app on Yahoo.
- 20:49It's really easy and I was there when it was more complicated,
- 20:51but it's gotten like really easy.
- 20:53Just boom, boom, boom and you're done.
- 20:55Bitcoin needs to get fantasy football level easy, I think,
- 21:00and it will then potentially be a a currency as well.
- 21:03I just don't know if it's there yet.
- 21:05I tried to get Bitcoin myself in a wallet and all this stuff and
- 21:08it just got a lot of friction. It's it takes time.
- 21:11All right, it's 2026 and. We have a new year ahead of us.
- 21:15That means it's a great time. It is an opportunity to take
- 21:19inventory, think about your Bitcoin custody, your
- 21:22inheritance plan, your broader ownership structure, and your
- 21:26goals. If you're looking for more Peace
- 21:28of Mind this year, get in touch with us here at On Ramp.
- 21:31We're working with individuals all over the world, people
- 21:34who've been in Bitcoin for a decade, people who got in for
- 21:37the first time last year. We're working with individuals
- 21:40who use self custody and have done so for a number of years or
- 21:43even over a decade. And.
- 21:45Likewise, we're working with people who never felt
- 21:47comfortable with self custody and have Bitcoin on an exchange.
- 21:50Either way, get in touch with us here at Onramp.
- 21:52We have a private client type approach to our relationships.
- 21:58You have a dedicated account manager always human support.
- 22:01Multi. Institution custody with
- 22:03inheritance included, an IRA account included as well at no
- 22:06additional cost. Access to Bitcoin back loans,
- 22:09insurances included, trading capabilities as well.
- 22:14And for a limited time, if you use the code TLT you'll get 50%
- 22:18off your first month with on ramp.
- 22:21Now I will say. It may be worth having a
- 22:23conversation so when you speak with me or speak with someone
- 22:26and book that consultation on our homepage, you can just
- 22:28mention you heard of us through the last trade, mentioned TLT,
- 22:32and we'll still take care of that if you sign up.
- 22:34So hope you enjoy the rest of the episode.
- 22:36Thanks for being here. Your point, Eric, I mean, I
- 22:38think what people miss in this industry is if we would agree,
- 22:42the three of us and then more broadly, people who participate
- 22:46in the Bitcoin industry, asset class, money, whatever you want
- 22:49to think of it as if we would agree that it's early, then that
- 22:52also means that the infrastructure is early, right?
- 22:54I mean, we wouldn't expect that everything that will exist in
- 22:58its final state, what exists 15 years after the white paper and
- 23:02Bitcoin subsequently goes live, right?
- 23:04So that's ultimately a big part of our business and we don't
- 23:08need to get into the details there.
- 23:09But one of the biggest challenges, Eric, you spoke to
- 23:12directly, I mean, it's really hard for most people to go to an
- 23:15exchange, buy Bitcoin, send it to a wallet that they fully
- 23:19control. I mean, it's a non starter for
- 23:22most people, right? So that was the great innovation
- 23:24of ETFs was the access. It made it a click of the button
- 23:29and made it fantasy football easy for most people to just
- 23:32participate in at least the price appreciation of Bitcoin
- 23:37from a brokerage account from a retirement account.
- 23:41Yeah, the the other, the other thing I, I wanted to mention
- 23:44just on in terms of like, I think there's a, there's a
- 23:47tendency with all assets, but particularly with Bitcoin for
- 23:51people to look at price action and then try to ascribe the
- 23:55reason for it. And you know, that's, it's
- 23:57obviously multivariate, could be a lot of different things, most
- 24:00simply sort of, you know, somewhat cliche, but like
- 24:04there's more sellers than buyers right now.
- 24:05That's why the price is going down.
- 24:07But I think, and Eric, I'm curious to get your thoughts on
- 24:10this just over the past two weeks, sort of this violent
- 24:14downwards pressure. I think I've seen some people
- 24:17try to attribute it to Trump's pick for the new Fed chair,
- 24:21Kevin Warsh, who's historically been looked at as a bit of a
- 24:24hawk, even though it's likely that he's probably going to
- 24:28listen to Trump and cut rates if and when he he does become the
- 24:30chair. I'm curious to get your thoughts
- 24:33on that just from sort of the Fed environment, the broader
- 24:36macro picture, liquidity, do you attribute any of this to to
- 24:40that? Yeah, sure, a little bit because
- 24:43he does have some past comments and what not where you sounded
- 24:46hawkish. But on the flip side, there is
- 24:50some that some people were relieved that looks like the Fed
- 24:54chair will have a little bit of his own mind.
- 24:56You know, that way it's not just a pushover and a yes man for
- 25:00Trump, you know what I mean? So there was a lot to unpack
- 25:03from that, but it did sound like maybe, OK, this guy might not be
- 25:07as like rate cutting. And so the market had to reprice
- 25:09a little. I still think that you've,
- 25:14you've seen Trump's other picks in the second term.
- 25:17They've been a lot more like people very agreeable with him
- 25:21and not people who like already work in government who were
- 25:24recommended to him. And therefore, I think given
- 25:27that I'm a fan of patterns, given that pattern, I, I just
- 25:30have to think Kevin, I mean, worse will be pretty much doing
- 25:35what he wants. I mean, I, you know, like I
- 25:37said, I don't study this every day, but the pattern would tell
- 25:39you he'd pick somebody who would like fulfill his wishes, which
- 25:42is lower rates. So I, I try not to
- 25:45overcomplicate it. You know, you can really start
- 25:48getting midwit here and going. And I think the market does that
- 25:52sometimes and analysts certainly do it and the expert class does
- 25:55it all the time. But I think if you're like
- 25:57either the dumb, dumb or the Jedi, you have the same thought,
- 26:00which is Trump wouldn't pick somebody who wasn't going to cut
- 26:02rates it pretty much immediately and be, you know, pretty very
- 26:07accommodative. So, you know, I don't I don't
- 26:11know if anything's really changed there.
- 26:14And after Doge where, you know, Elon and Elon is the most
- 26:19creative, richest person, right? And there's a tailwind of an
- 26:23election. They created doge and it just
- 26:24didn't really couldn't that was like a good shot at like curbing
- 26:28debt and debasement. And if so, if he can't work in
- 26:33this administration, I mean, maybe the next administration's
- 26:37like ammt fancy. I mean like, so I just think
- 26:40like the bigger issue is worse. Not, you know, it's just
- 26:44probably going to be the same old thing.
- 26:47You know, if you look at the money supply, it's I think it's
- 26:51gone up 10 trillion in like 7 or 8 years.
- 26:54I mean, it's that's a lot. And I think ultimately from the
- 26:58signs I've gotten based on moving instead of leaning into
- 27:02doge, you know, Trump kind of moved away with it with the big
- 27:04beautiful bill. That's where when him, him and
- 27:06Elon got into a fight, that was one sign that like, he's
- 27:11probably going to be a little more traditional.
- 27:13He's not going to be the, the debt guy who's going to like,
- 27:16you know, balance the budget like Clinton did back in the
- 27:1990s. And so I, I think it just seems
- 27:21like what's really a priority is just making sure the economy is
- 27:24nice and juiced and everything's like, you know, the, the best it
- 27:29can be. And that does seem to involve
- 27:30involve the basement and lower rates.
- 27:32So I just don't, I've always been like thinking that the
- 27:36Trump put has always been real, whether he talks a big game or
- 27:38not, at the end of the day, he likes talking about how the
- 27:41market's up, like talking about how the economy is good.
- 27:44He's not going to like let the economy suck for like a year and
- 27:46not do anything, you know, and just seems like at the end of
- 27:50the day, that's still totally intact.
- 27:53So I think in the short term though, maybe a little repricing
- 27:57of a slightly less dovish Fed chair.
- 27:59But again, this is, I'm not, don't do this every day, but as
- 28:02a just a general observer of the markets through ETFs, that's my
- 28:06general take on it. And I will say that when we look
- 28:08at ETF flows, the the general Vanguard investor has not
- 28:13changed at all. They have just completely
- 28:15allocated business as usual. Sometimes this stuff is involved
- 28:19in our little bubble of finance and the day-to-day it's a lot of
- 28:23times the sell offs are simply algos.
- 28:24It's not even real humans. It's just computers trading
- 28:27against each other until there's like a 20% draw down the last
- 28:30over like 12 months. I just wouldn't give too much
- 28:34worry about it. Bitcoin obviously is it's a
- 28:37bigger draw down, but it also went up way more than it
- 28:40probably normally would have. I mean that that's, that's a, I
- 28:45don't know what standard deviation event that was, but
- 28:47would you say 20,000 to 120 in two years is like almost too
- 28:51fast. It's like too many GS or
- 28:53whatever you got to be like, and it's weird that people forget
- 28:57that happened. They'll be like, Oh my God,
- 28:59Bitcoin. It like it was supposed to go up
- 29:01and like, OK, you know, if gold is the debasement trade this
- 29:04year, well then if gold was only up 10% when Bitcoin was up to
- 29:08100% in 2024, does that mean gold failed that year?
- 29:13It's just the narratives drawn from like a year of information
- 29:16are so dumb. And that's what really bothers
- 29:19me. I'm like, OK, everybody just got
- 29:22like this short term reference point and they make these long
- 29:25term inferences. It makes no sense.
- 29:28There's just a lot of noise. Different assets are mean
- 29:30reverting at different times. You know, if you go back five
- 29:35years, you know, silver and gold are frankly catching up to
- 29:40Bitcoin. If you're talking about a
- 29:41debasement trade, see you know, and you zoom out further than it
- 29:45just blows everything away. So I don't know I, I don't
- 29:48really I, I know I went from the Fed to that, but it was it is
- 29:52related to a degree only because I think the, the the stock sell
- 29:56off is very small. The Bitcoin went a little
- 29:58bigger. I think some due to worse, but I
- 30:00just think those other bigger things are at play more than
- 30:04that. I, you know, if anything though,
- 30:07I think one thing that's a true, maybe concerned is, is these
- 30:11true Ogs who got into it for like something that the
- 30:14government can't control it. I think it's, it is important to
- 30:18keep the base, you know, I think those people, you want them
- 30:20around talking about this and being as excited as they were.
- 30:24So I think that is one thing to look for.
- 30:27But I would say that in the regular traditional finance
- 30:30world, if BlackRock is saying it's an asset class and Fidelity
- 30:34saying it's an asset class, Vanguard's not letting it trade.
- 30:38It's an asset class. I mean, it's fully accepted.
- 30:41But I I would say that it would be better if the OGS came along
- 30:47for the ride. Yeah, makes sense, Eric.
- 30:52I wish I could call them up for you and and we could let them
- 30:54know hey, stick around with us for a little bit longer, why
- 30:57don't you? Yeah, but you know what I'm
- 31:00using. Co GS I'm I, you know, it's a
- 31:02very, very general term. Right.
- 31:06Yeah. I do think that there is a kind
- 31:07of a lot of like the middle of the curve type of discourse on X
- 31:11in particular and going back to there's a lot that we could
- 31:15react to going back to the first component just around the Fed
- 31:18chair wash and just it just kind of the realities, right.
- 31:22I mean the fiscal reality is that the basement needs to
- 31:25continue. There is no balancing the budget
- 31:28like you mentioned. And so while this is the short
- 31:31term noise about, oh, is he more hawkish?
- 31:33Is he more dovish? What's going to happen?
- 31:35Well, we know what happens over the next 5 or 10 years, right?
- 31:38I mean, it's, it's kind of an obvious trend line that is not
- 31:41going to change because it it structurally cannot.
- 31:44And then we love the boomers. Let's talk about the boomers for
- 31:46a second. Well, the boomers don't want the
- 31:48stock market to go down because they have $150 trillion of
- 31:52wealth. I know that's not all the stock
- 31:53market, but collectively they have a shit ton of shit ton of
- 31:57wealth and there's a lot of political interest to keep
- 32:01kicking the can down the road. And we want the market to go
- 32:04higher. Trump wants it to go higher.
- 32:06It doesn't matter. Everyone wants it to go higher
- 32:08because that is signaling to people that we have a strong
- 32:11economy. You know, things have never been
- 32:13better, but the reality is it's just interest.
- 32:16It's just self-interest where most people are going to have
- 32:20most of their wealth stored in equities and real estate.
- 32:22And now you even see this with the real estate market too,
- 32:24right? You have Trump talking about how
- 32:26well, we don't want more. We don't want house prices to go
- 32:28down because that's bad for the people who own homes.
- 32:31Well, it's what about the people who want to own a home, right?
- 32:33So you have this dichotomy of the people who have have amassed
- 32:36all the wealth and they don't want that wealth to be destroyed
- 32:40or at least depreciate. And then the people who want to
- 32:43build wealth are looking, OK, well, how do I do that?
- 32:45Right? Because everything's at all time
- 32:47highs and it's only going higher over the long term.
- 32:51Yeah. I mean, the stock market is
- 32:54basically America's retirement bank at this point.
- 32:57And they got this new plan where they're going to, every baby's
- 33:01going to have $1000 assigned to them invested in an index fund,
- 33:05probably S&P 500. So like the 50% of people who
- 33:08weren't investors are about to be invested for the most part.
- 33:11So we're locked in there, I think.
- 33:15And the net interest on the budget is now I want to say 14%
- 33:21of the budget. That's a big number.
- 33:23And at some point, like you think if they're like, this is
- 33:27where I, when I really dove into Bitcoin and I'd always been
- 33:30interested in the national debt. What really struck me as a very
- 33:35powerful thesis for Bitcoin is this idea that the government
- 33:43rarely, if ever makes hard choices.
- 33:47You know, because they wouldn't even get elected for the first.
- 33:50Like they it's not even their fault.
- 33:53The politicians are they have to not get elected, right.
- 33:57And would you ever get elected saying I'm going to cut a bunch
- 33:59of Medicare and try to balance the budget?
- 34:01Probably not. And so there's this cycle that
- 34:03seems unstoppable. And so if you have an asset that
- 34:08can be a hedge against that. I just, that's where I think it
- 34:12in other words, because I will say, I will see people being
- 34:15like, well, Bitcoin, what even is it has no cash flow.
- 34:18And I think in order to really understand that, you have to
- 34:21understand that other part first.
- 34:24You have to understand the situation that the government is
- 34:27with the and how the money works and that kind of thing.
- 34:29Once you lock into that, Bitcoin does make a lot more logical
- 34:32sense. So that seems to be completely
- 34:35intact. I don't that has not changed at
- 34:37all. So given that hasn't changed and
- 34:41the ETFs have made it very accessible, accessible and the
- 34:45fact that it has these sell offs routinely, there is there is a
- 34:50case he made is like everything's completely normal
- 34:54even if it feels bad. Right.
- 34:59Yeah. You know, I would love to get
- 35:01your thoughts more on the the new investor class of Bitcoin.
- 35:04And and before we jump into that, I do want to react to the
- 35:07fact that you're totally right. I mean, you have to understand
- 35:11the problem to understand why Bitcoin is interesting and why
- 35:14it's a potential solution, right?
- 35:16I mean, if you don't understand the problem to begin with, then
- 35:20Bitcoin doesn't make any sense. Why would scarcity make sense?
- 35:23Why would the halving make sense?
- 35:25Why would sound money in general make sense if you don't
- 35:28understand the context of the debt that the the debasement,
- 35:31right? Like these are just
- 35:32prerequisites and in many cases for investing as well.
- 35:35Like I would make the case that you know, most, most of the
- 35:38Vanguard ETF investors probably don't understand it that deeply,
- 35:42but they recognize it enough to the fact where I don't want to
- 35:44be sitting in dollars. I don't want to be fully
- 35:47allocated to bonds because I need to be participating in the
- 35:51market because I need my money to grow, right?
- 35:53There's this perception I need my money to grow and I need it
- 35:55to work for me. So I think people are
- 35:57directionally and have been for a while, directionally
- 36:00identifying the problem, which is dollar devalues.
- 36:03But now it's just to your point, devaluing even quicker.
- 36:06But you need to understand all of that for Bitcoin to make any
- 36:09sense at all. Yeah, totally.
- 36:12So yeah, I mean gold has the same case to be made.
- 36:17So then then you then you have to sing out what's better to do
- 36:21it. I think they both can work, but
- 36:23that's the first. If you don't do that, then you
- 36:26end up in this. It's just Beanie Babies
- 36:29situation. But I also think I'm just
- 36:33understanding the just the fact that a bunch of people who don't
- 36:37know each other and may not even like each other can like run
- 36:39this network is is pretty interesting technology and
- 36:43incentive system. So when you actually open it up
- 36:46and look at that and the fact that like its user run money,
- 36:50that's also really interesting. That seems to have some value
- 36:53too. And that's why the the more you
- 36:56learn about it, the more you tend to respect it and give it
- 36:59like some you, you, you can't blow it off hardly, you know
- 37:04what I mean? So I think a lot of times in a
- 37:06sell off like this, the people who are like the haters or some
- 37:10people in the media who haven't done that deep of a of a deep
- 37:12dive into it, they're excited to dump on it and it that that's
- 37:16what makes it feel worse. They're like trying to egg it on
- 37:19to go down. And so then you get this just
- 37:21nasty build up of sentiment, even though nothing has changed
- 37:27in a way. So anyway, but.
- 37:30In the white paper too, right, you mentioned the fact that it
- 37:33is peer-to-peer people. You don't forget that there's a
- 37:37reason to own Bitcoin outside of just the debasement story and
- 37:41outside of it appreciating. And, you know, that was clear
- 37:45talking about the problem and then the solution.
- 37:46That was clear from the very start.
- 37:48That was in the white paper and that was in the genesis block
- 37:50talking about chancellor on the brink of of bailout.
- 37:53And so this is definitely a core part of Bitcoin.
- 37:57But yeah, we don't need to, you know, I don't need to go on any
- 38:00longer about that. I would be curious to hear more
- 38:02about your thoughts on just the new investor class of Bitcoin
- 38:06ETF investors. You did point out a couple of
- 38:08data points. I can pull them up real quick
- 38:10that I thought were interesting. And the general gist for people
- 38:13who are not going to be watching here on, on YouTube, the general
- 38:18gist that we're going to be referring to is Eric put out
- 38:20some tweets just about Bitcoin ETF inflows despite the, the
- 38:26price crashing. This was 2 days ago.
- 38:28So I'm, I'm sure maybe it looks a little bit different today as
- 38:30we continue to crash. But the, the biggest point that
- 38:33stuck out to me was the fact that only about 6% of the assets
- 38:37in Bitcoin ETFs have actually left.
- 38:39And so about you mentioned, Eric, about 94% are hanging
- 38:42tough. And this is despite the major
- 38:45correction that we're currently experiencing, despite being down
- 38:4845% from the all time high. So I'd be curious like what are
- 38:51you seeing out there in your space as it relates to just the
- 38:54investor psychology and why do you think the ETF investors are
- 38:57holding on so strong? Yeah #1 ETF investors are the
- 39:01smart money. This is not GameStop dum dum
- 39:04retail ETF investors. If you found the ETF, you're
- 39:08smart because no brokers are incentivized to sell them to
- 39:11you. There's no middle.
- 39:13Like there's no payouts. Some other products, people get
- 39:17paid for you to be in them. And sometimes they're not that
- 39:19good. ETFs are something where you
- 39:22have to find them and they're they're a good business to clean
- 39:25business. And so people who find them tend
- 39:27to know things about behavior. They tend to have relationships
- 39:31with wholesalers. So like you take like a
- 39:33wholesaler from Fidelity talking to an advisor who loves, you
- 39:36know, advisors love ETFs. They've probably explained to
- 39:39them they didn't say like, hey, Tom Brady's in a commercial
- 39:41FOMO, have fun staying poor. They're not talking like that.
- 39:44They're like, look, this is A and they just like we said, this
- 39:48is an asset that's a good hedge for the basement.
- 39:51It's volatile, maybe 2% allocation.
- 39:54So the person goes in going OK, maybe I'll do a 545 year
- 39:58commitment to this asset and. It's only 2% and you know, right
- 40:03now stocks have still been really good last year.
- 40:05I mean, they're down a little bit in now, but they've had nine
- 40:07straight months up. So like this investor who's got
- 40:11like this problem with Bitcoin, it's only a 1% problem right now
- 40:14or 2%. So they're like, well, it was
- 40:17meant to be hot sauce. I knew it going in.
- 40:19I think more of the bad vibes are coming from people who were
- 40:22A50 or percent or over. Like these are the crypto people
- 40:26where they're like, oh, shit, I was banking my whole life on
- 40:28this. That's where it gets more scary,
- 40:30I think, than your average boomer investor, where this is
- 40:33just like a little something, you know, it's like a call
- 40:36option on just in case these maniacs are right.
- 40:40Or I do believe in the basement. I want a little something there.
- 40:43Some of these boomers also bought gold.
- 40:44I mean, I don't think they're like, they're not as usually
- 40:47exclusive. So I think that's a big reason
- 40:50that they're hanging in there. But you know, you go down
- 40:54another 30 percent, 40%, yeah, you'll they'll start to peel off
- 40:58a little. But there's been cases.
- 41:00I've studied ETFs all the time. SPY lived throughthe.com bubble.
- 41:07It lived through 2008, saw some months of outflows, but
- 41:10generally held up fine in those stock sell offs.
- 41:14Also, the QS was launched in 1999.
- 41:17That's the NASDAQ 100. So it launched a year before a
- 41:20vicious 2001 sell off. And today it's like the fourth
- 41:25biggest ETF. Gold launched 22 years ago.
- 41:29It went up immediately, probably for like 4 years.
- 41:31Then it had a real nasty sell off around let's say 2011 or
- 41:34something where it went down 40% in six months.
- 41:38And it actually saw I think something like 7 billion of
- 41:41outflows, which with the time was about 32% of all the assets.
- 41:45So a lot of people left. Again, you got to, you know, I
- 41:49think gold's more of a trader tool.
- 41:50But either way, since then, gold's taken in like $30 billion
- 41:55like you. The good news is the ETFs are
- 41:58there. They're pretty liquid.
- 42:00They're established. They're this just happens like
- 42:03things go up, things go down. When it's up, usually see a
- 42:06little more inflows. When it's down, you sometimes
- 42:08see some outflows. But I've never really seen an
- 42:12ETF where the core just got up and left, whether it's stocks,
- 42:17even ARC, which remember ARC was like ARC Mania, They still
- 42:20retain well over half of their investor base.
- 42:24Even if it went and it went down 80%, I mean that that drawdown
- 42:27was really nasty. So I just think the way ETFs
- 42:30design people design their portfolios with a cheap Vanguard
- 42:32core, it gives them more intestinal fortitude for the hot
- 42:35sauce. So I think that's what you're
- 42:37seeing here. And again, Matt Hogan pointed
- 42:40out also that the people who would buy Bitcoin in the first
- 42:42year or two of the ETFs were the most convicted because there is
- 42:46a still little reputational risk for like real, real big gigantic
- 42:51conservative advisor shops. Those people might eventually
- 42:53get in. But like the people who got in
- 42:55the first year or two were a little more like predisposed to
- 43:00thinking Bitcoin is valuable, but one of the ETF to do it.
- 43:03So you throw all those things together.
- 43:05That explains why I think they're holding holding up
- 43:09better than maybe this is also why I've told crypto people when
- 43:13I'm on their podcasts, you should buy some stocks and
- 43:17bonds. Like it's nice to have
- 43:18diversification because it can help you stomach the bad times
- 43:23better. And that's why advisors make
- 43:25diversified portfolios because I know people get crazy, but then
- 43:29the but it's so it's interesting.
- 43:32How so? I think your nerves right now
- 43:35are kind of correlated to how much Bitcoin is in your
- 43:38portfolio. Yeah, maybe the human or or
- 43:43monkey brains were not equipped to be all in on Bitcoin and
- 43:46watch it go down 80% a few times.
- 43:49But yeah, I, I, it makes sense, right?
- 43:52If you're, if you just have a small position, then you stomach
- 43:56it. You see where we end up in the
- 43:58next couple of years here. But it is tough.
- 44:01I mean, it's tough being all in and it's tough watching it go
- 44:03down 40 or 50% since October. And I'll speak from first hand
- 44:08experience, but it's, I don't know what else I'd be doing,
- 44:11Eric. So I'm here, I'm committed to it
- 44:13and to the point of this conversation.
- 44:18Yeah, we're here for the long haul, I and I, I can see your
- 44:20point too. Like diversification.
- 44:23I don't know the exact numbers of my personal net worth
- 44:25percentage wise, but it's like overwhelming majority Bitcoin.
- 44:28But I still have stuff that I just like, didn't bother to sell
- 44:31and convert into Bitcoin. So I still have some equity
- 44:33exposure. I still have some precious metal
- 44:35exposure. I don't own a house, I don't
- 44:37have any real estate exposure. But like, yeah, I mean, I'm well
- 44:41over allocated to Bitcoin, but I could also still appreciate the
- 44:44fact that, well, at least not all of my net worth has gone
- 44:47down 40 to 50% in the past six months.
- 44:50And I'm, I think that in general, we're just seeing more
- 44:53of a maturity in this group of investors, right?
- 44:57Like the people who got into Bitcoin a decade ago, mostly
- 45:00younger guys, probably not married, not children.
- 45:04And like as you get older, you kind of recognize that maybe
- 45:07it's not the best idea. It'll be 100% in something that
- 45:11can go down so quickly and such to a large degree if you have
- 45:14obligations besides yourself, right?
- 45:16Like you got to mean you got to manage the cash flow to the cash
- 45:19flow is important. If you have great cash flow that
- 45:21maybe you do weather the storm, maybe you take the 80% on the
- 45:23chin because you have that conviction.
- 45:25But for most people, it doesn't make a lot of sense.
- 45:28And I think people are starting to recognize that.
- 45:30And I don't think that's a bad thing.
- 45:31I mean, it doesn't mean that the thesis is dead as we spoke to,
- 45:34but yeah, just kind of a general maturity that's happening right
- 45:38now, at least from my vantage point.
- 45:41Yeah, one thing. Yeah.
- 45:43Go ahead, I. Was just going to say just on
- 45:45it's so fascinating. The investor psychology, the, OR
- 45:48the monkey brains, as as you termed it, Jackson, Like I, I
- 45:51tweeted this morning and I, I just put out some quotes like I
- 45:55come from a value investing background and it's, it's,
- 45:58there's some very prescient learnings from, from that style
- 46:02of thinking. So I had Howard Marks quote, a
- 46:05hugely profitable investment that doesn't begin with
- 46:07discomfort is usually an oxymoron.
- 46:10And then from John Templeton, the time of maximum pessimism is
- 46:14the best time to buy. And then from Baron Rothschild,
- 46:17buy when there's blood in the streets, even if the blood is
- 46:20your own. And it's like, it's easy to
- 46:21think these things, but to actually execute them in
- 46:24practice is the hard part and where the monkey brain can take
- 46:29over. Yeah.
- 46:30But just coming from that world, like that's where I always try
- 46:33to remind myself when this this type of stuff happens is like, I
- 46:36have AI have a multi decade thesis on this thing.
- 46:38I should be excited that the price is is giving me the
- 46:40opportunity to add exposure. Yeah, the volatility and these
- 46:46bad feelings is the cost of the returns.
- 46:50So if you are in Treasuries, you don't have to feel this hardly
- 46:54ever, but you only get 4% a year.
- 46:58So you have to pick your lane. You know, how much potential
- 47:02depression and like existential crisis do you want, you know,
- 47:09forget the expense ratio. That is a cost, the technical
- 47:12cost, but the figurative cost is this.
- 47:14And it does exist with stocks. Stock investors go through the
- 47:17same thing, just not quite as extreme, but their returns
- 47:20aren't as extreme. So there's, I don't know, that's
- 47:22just the way I look at it. But you know, I think time will
- 47:27tell where this goes. The other thing is I think
- 47:31Bitcoiners are perpetually online and so they're able that
- 47:37it's hard for them sometimes to zoom out.
- 47:40I think some people who are in Vanguard, they forget they're
- 47:42even investors for like 6 months a year.
- 47:44They're just doing shit and they're like, I'm in a good
- 47:46fund, I don't need to worry about it.
- 47:49And then but the crypto people are on like 18 hours a day on
- 47:53Twitter looking at every intraday chart and like freaking
- 47:55themselves out. So that energy spreads and it's
- 47:59crazy. Yeah.
- 48:00So I mean, there is a touch grass element here.
- 48:04Yeah. But because this sell off was
- 48:08also interesting. There's that phrase, you know,
- 48:09the only thing we have the fear is fear itself.
- 48:12There were really wasn't any narrative change except that
- 48:17maybe profit taking because 10-10 I whatever that quirk was.
- 48:22I don't know if you can blame the whole thing on that, but
- 48:25it's like fear just starts to spread out of nowhere and it was
- 48:29just fear. I I didn't there wasn't really
- 48:31any driving factor. But I suppose the FOMO also
- 48:37spreads to where you get extra returns just for no narrative
- 48:41either. So I think that's why Bitcoin so
- 48:44volatile. It's got packed with FOMO on the
- 48:46way up and then fear on the way down.
- 48:48And that's on top of and that can cloud the fundamental case
- 48:52of like normal annualized return of say 40 to 50% a year.
- 48:58Yeah, and, and people will chase performance too, right?
- 49:00I mean, you see something going up and that's that is part of
- 49:03the FOMO that is part of investor psychology.
- 49:05And so it's working the same way to the downside.
- 49:08And look, I'll tell the audience right now I'm doing this for
- 49:11you. If I wasn't doing this podcast,
- 49:13then I wouldn't be checking the price so much and I wouldn't be
- 49:16chronically online. It's your it's your fault that I
- 49:19have to do this. But it's it's a great otherwise
- 49:22I like. I you quoted Buffett and the
- 49:25blood in the streets and all that.
- 49:26We we've talked about the team, like when someone starts quoting
- 49:30like Psalms from the Bible like that, that's when it's the
- 49:33bottom is probably close. Yep.
- 49:35And then and then the Mike Tyson quote that's in there.
- 49:39Everybody has a plan until they get punched in the face.
- 49:42These are the things you typically see around the bottom.
- 49:44But we'll see if that plays out. But yeah, sometimes we'll see
- 49:47Bible quotes somewhere, like, all right, it's got to be close
- 49:49to over. One thing you you mentioned
- 49:531010, the sort of flash crash in the broader crypto space.
- 49:58I do think there is something to that in the sense that obviously
- 50:01Bitcoin is still very correlated with the broader crypto index or
- 50:04you know, complex. And I think a, a broader
- 50:08narrative that we're seeing play out in the crypto space is like
- 50:13these native tokens aren't being ascribed the value that the
- 50:16crypto people thought it they were going to be.
- 50:18You have Stripe just building their own blockchain.
- 50:21You have these banks wanting to do more private style
- 50:24blockchains and not necessarily building on Ethereum or, or
- 50:28ascribing value to the native token.
- 50:30And so I do think that's part of it.
- 50:31And I think Bitcoin is obviously wrapped up in that sort of
- 50:34broader contagion of a lot of these other tokens that people
- 50:38are recognizing. Like there isn't necessarily the
- 50:41need to own the native token. You can just build your own
- 50:43blockchain and accomplish a lot of the things that you want to
- 50:45do with stablecoins or real world assets, you know,
- 50:48tokenizing the world, all those things.
- 50:50And so I, I do think there's a broader shift in the sort of X
- 50:53Bitcoin crypto land of, of a recognition that a lot of the
- 50:57things that people thought about these, all these native tokens
- 51:00maybe isn't going to amount to much.
- 51:02And so that I think that's part of it too is like there's still,
- 51:05you know, these tokens that have multi, you know, 10s of
- 51:08billions, hundreds of billions of dollars of market cap that
- 51:11there's a lot of room for those things to fall And and Bitcoin
- 51:13obviously gets caught up in that.
- 51:16Yeah, no doubt. Seems to be like stocks do the
- 51:20same thing. There's high beta stocks which
- 51:23go up, you know, betas market. So high beta means it goes up
- 51:26more and up and it goes down more and down.
- 51:28That's to me seems like the tokens, the tokenization story
- 51:32I've always thought was a little overblown, but it wasn't a lie.
- 51:35It's I feel like a lot of the blockchain technology is going
- 51:39to get absorbed by traditional finance.
- 51:40Like in the end, trad Phi is too big and too powerful and I think
- 51:44like they will utilize like seems like a ether platform and
- 51:48Solana for things. And so that's just seems really
- 51:50good. The other thing about the crypto
- 51:53space that is that it makes me maybe not totally excited is
- 51:57that they're competing with each other, which means that there's
- 51:59just like this can be this brutal fee war and anytime you
- 52:02have like a fee war in tech or finance, it can really that the
- 52:06revenues are tough. You know, I see it in ETFs all
- 52:09the time. Bitcoin, meanwhile, is sort of
- 52:12has the the this whole lane to itself as the store of value
- 52:17anti debasement thing. And it's also the first one and
- 52:21it's got this like kind of special Halo, almost religious
- 52:24thing connected to it. So I've always thought Bitcoin
- 52:27is like this special gold like thing that was almost like a
- 52:29miracle the way it can again be run by a bunch of users who
- 52:33don't even know each other. And then on the other side, you
- 52:36have these tokens that took one part of it and are now competing
- 52:40like small cap tech stocks in the 90s.
- 52:42Who Will Win, who will lose? You know, there's going to be
- 52:45like some, you know, that's why I think a basket approach is
- 52:49probably best for those. And then you pick So I, I, I, my
- 52:53personal feeling is a lot of people say pick the Bitcoin you
- 52:57want. How much debasement are you
- 52:58worried about? So you do Bitcoin with that
- 53:00percentage and then how much do you want to link on to this
- 53:03trend of like blockchain? And would you call that, you
- 53:09know, the basically making the bowels of Wall Street much more
- 53:17instantaneous, you know, and how much?
- 53:20Cheaper databases ultimately. Yeah, exactly.
- 53:22And it's boring, You know, it's actually more boring, like
- 53:25plumbing work. And so that's where you just buy
- 53:28a basket and like, let the market figured out because who
- 53:31the hell can track all this stuff all the time?
- 53:33And a lot of the coins that were like the popular ones 10 years
- 53:36ago, like we looked at the top ten list 10 years ago, I think
- 53:39three are on the list still. So just reminds me of the tech
- 53:44stocks in the 80s and 90s. So anyway, that's that's
- 53:47generally what we see with the tokenization stuff.
- 53:50But I'll, I sometimes, you know, battle with people on that.
- 53:53I think they think like the whole thing is going tokenized.
- 53:56And I will see what we'll see how this plays out.
- 53:58But you've got some good fans in Larry Fink.
- 54:01He's always talking about it Fidelity, so that though their
- 54:05opinions matter a lot, people if they say it, it's almost like
- 54:08gospel, like you know what I mean?
- 54:10If Larry Fink says bitcoins and asset class it, you know, it
- 54:13kind of is because a lot had to happen for him to utter those
- 54:18words. It's not just him saying it.
- 54:19It's the culmination of everything that happened that he
- 54:21says it and says the final stamp like OK, this is fine.
- 54:25So tokenization is kind of getting that stamped too.
- 54:27I just don't know how how much it absorbs Trad 5 versus the
- 54:32vice versa. In case you missed it earlier,
- 54:34we are offering a limited time opportunity to sign up.
- 54:39Use code TLT for 50% off your first month with on ramp.
- 54:44I just want to reiterate, stakes are high and this is an
- 54:48important decision to think through.
- 54:50So I would fully expect that you'd want to have a
- 54:53conversation with someone on our team to speak with Cam, myself,
- 54:57Michael. Go to our.
- 54:58Homepage book A consultation. You can speak with us for 15
- 55:01minutes. Thirty minutes no obligation
- 55:04beyond that you can just ask us questions learn about the
- 55:06solution and I just want to make sure that as you as a listener,
- 55:10whether it's for you your friends or family, I just want
- 55:14to make sure you have Peace of Mind and you feel good about
- 55:16this year ahead of us as it relates to Bitcoin ownership,
- 55:19custody and inheritance. So again limited time offer 50%
- 55:23off your first month use code TLT.
- 55:25You can just mention that during the consultation or if you do
- 55:28end up just going direct to sign up, mention that code on the on
- 55:31the website and you'll be all set.
- 55:33So thanks for being here and hope you enjoy the rest of the
- 55:35episode. Yeah, You know, Eric, we traded
- 55:38the the Ogs. We the OGS left us, but it meant
- 55:41that Larry Fink could join us. He, you know, now he's the the
- 55:45talking head for Bitcoin, for better or for worse.
- 55:48But yeah, I don't know about where the tokenization stuff
- 55:51goes, Eric. I'd be, I'd be curious real
- 55:53quick because I know you got to run.
- 55:54You have a lot of stuff on your plate outside of Bitcoin, so I'm
- 55:58just curious what what else is exciting in your world in the
- 56:01ETF space. I saw you tweet out something
- 56:03the other day, it might have been earlier this week about
- 56:08Vanguard overtaking or soon to overtake BlackRock.
- 56:11BlackRock in the ETF space. I'm just curious like what else
- 56:14is exciting to you? I know the world doesn't revolve
- 56:16around Bitcoin for everyone, So what else you paying attention
- 56:19to? You know, the Vanguard fighting
- 56:23BlackRock is like, it's like tracking Godzilla versus King
- 56:26Kong. Like they've been fighting for
- 56:28years and you know, it's like, and everybody else fights over
- 56:32the crumbs that falls out of their mouths.
- 56:33So there's always like smaller for us fighting over like, no,
- 56:36those two firms take in 2/3 of all the money that crazy.
- 56:41And so then you've got 298 firms fighting over the other one
- 56:44third of the money. So it's so BlackRock and
- 56:47Vanguard, we take them for granted, but they are just so
- 56:49giant ginormous. And Vanguard now takes in, I
- 56:53don't know, 1.5 billion a day. Isn't that crazy?
- 56:58As somebody who's like in like that world, like that just seems
- 57:01like bizarre. But we so we always track that
- 57:04because it's just so big. But it can be boring.
- 57:07I'd say an exciting thing we're tracking is everybody wants to
- 57:09get ahead now of these potential Unicorn IPOs.
- 57:12SpaceX might make IPOs cool again.
- 57:16You've also got Neurolink and XAI, which is joining SpaceX.
- 57:19And then you've got Open AI and Tropic.
- 57:21Then there's a bunch of these, like drone delivery services,
- 57:24all kinds of really cool companies that are in private
- 57:26world. And a lot of investors want
- 57:29access because they feel like small caps aren't where those
- 57:31stocks can be had because large caps are great.
- 57:34But they're like adults, right? People want to get some exposure
- 57:37to the toddlers and the teenagers of the stock world.
- 57:40And privates are now where those are happening.
- 57:43And so we're all ETFs which technically have to hold liquid.
- 57:47Things are starting to put privates in their portfolio in
- 57:50like smaller doses, but it's actually getting bigger and
- 57:52bigger ETF like to push the envelope.
- 57:54So there's going to be this interesting tension between
- 57:58something not that liquid being put into the liquid wrapper and
- 58:02ETFs. The demand is there.
- 58:04Anytime someone adds a little private, they all this all the
- 58:07sudden see inflows. So there's a clear instant
- 58:09response from the marketplace that they want privates in the
- 58:12ETF wrapper, but it's not technically the correct wrapper.
- 58:15The interval fund is the correct wrapper, but no one wants it
- 58:17there. There's just no assets like the
- 58:20you, you have funds that have a lot of privates and not a lot of
- 58:23investors. It's a my metaphor is you make
- 58:27like a great album, but you're only put it on compact disc.
- 58:31You would sell a lot less even if it's the greatest album,
- 58:34right? You put that thing on Spotify,
- 58:36you, you know, you get mill 10s more millions people.
- 58:38So can you put, you know, how much privates can you get on the
- 58:44Spotify, if you will? That's been a huge theme for me
- 58:47this year. And SpaceX could be the biggest
- 58:49IPO. It might IPO with the size of
- 58:52Walmart, you know, so this is Major League stuff.
- 58:56And so getting exposure to that ahead of the actual public is
- 58:59going to be an interesting thing given ETFs traditionally have
- 59:03only owned public stocks. So the race to like push the
- 59:08envelope and like jockey for position reminds me of crypto 4
- 59:13years ago where the issuers would like tweak prospectuses
- 59:15and I'll do futures, I'll do this.
- 59:18Everyone was trying to get out first to bend the rules, not get
- 59:21caught by the and not get their hands slapped by the SEC.
- 59:24Very similar dynamic taking place here in privates.
- 59:28Interesting. Yeah, I remember, I remember a
- 59:32few years ago back when I was in traditional finance still, we
- 59:35had some interval funds on platform and I just can't
- 59:37remember if there was ever really any serious interest in
- 59:40them. There was plenty of interest and
- 59:41other type of alternatives, but not the interval fund so much.
- 59:44And just how does that end up working out then Eric in terms
- 59:48of having having those private assets held in, in exchange
- 59:53traded vehicles, like what are the, I know you got to jump
- 59:56soon, but like what are the friction points there?
- 59:58How does that actually work out mechanically?
- 1:00:00It's complicated, so I'll just give you an example Ron B, which
- 1:00:04is the Ron Barons ETF. He has he put 22% of the fund
- 1:00:09into SpaceX. So SpaceX was the largest
- 1:00:11holding. Now people started buying into
- 1:00:13the fund because they're like oh, SpaceX and so they took in
- 1:00:17it assets grew by 40%. So the SpaceX percent drops
- 1:00:22because it doesn't go out and buy more SpaceX like it would a
- 1:00:25stock. It takes cash for that position
- 1:00:28and then just it ends up putting that cash into more of the
- 1:00:32public name. So the more assets that grow,
- 1:00:35the IT gets diluted unless they go buy more.
- 1:00:37But it's hard to buy more because it's by appointment kind
- 1:00:40of stuff. However, SpaceX is the most
- 1:00:43liquid of the privates easily by far.
- 1:00:46So there are places that he can buy them.
- 1:00:48And also Ron B probably has Elon on speed dial.
- 1:00:51He probably, and his mutual fund has some SpaceX.
- 1:00:53So certain firms might have in a better position to be feeding
- 1:00:58certain stocks into their ETFs. We had Kathy Wood on who has an
- 1:01:02interval fund, which all with all these privates and she's
- 1:01:04obviously close to Elon or at least friendly with him.
- 1:01:08And she said that she asked some of the private companies, can I
- 1:01:11put you in my ETF? And they didn't want to be put
- 1:01:13in there. And so there are some other
- 1:01:15artificial, there's some barriers in that regard too.
- 1:01:18So it it isn't that's the problem is how do you but I
- 1:01:24would say that let's say your ETF has 20% space XI buy it and
- 1:01:28the SpaceX gets twindled down because more and more assets
- 1:01:30come in. OK, fine, I'm still got SpaceX
- 1:01:32exposure. It's not the craziest thing.
- 1:01:34And if it does trade it a little bit of a discount or premium to
- 1:01:37NAV because market makers are unable to like arbitrate.
- 1:01:40I mean, they're unable to make a market cleanly because they
- 1:01:43don't know where SpaceX is trading.
- 1:01:44So they they widen their bid ask and where they'll buy it and
- 1:01:48orbit at. So you have a price that's maybe
- 1:01:51a little lower than the NAV and we call it the arbitrage band.
- 1:01:55So the less liquid some stuff in an ETF, the more the arbitrage
- 1:01:58band stretches, obviously. And that would be called the
- 1:02:01premium discount. I don't want to get wonky here,
- 1:02:03but most people are fine with that.
- 1:02:04They're like, I don't really care if there's a premium
- 1:02:06discount. I trust the ETF price.
- 1:02:07It's usually like based on competition and like the market
- 1:02:10makers are very good. So I think for the most part
- 1:02:14ETFs can handle it. I think the bigger issue is at
- 1:02:19how much should they handle? You know, should it be 50% of a
- 1:02:23fund? Like where's the limit?
- 1:02:25And then the other one is like, well, how do you market it?
- 1:02:28Because you don't want to go out and market it and say, hey,
- 1:02:30we're the SpaceX ETF. And then everybody comes in and
- 1:02:33they get the the exposure gets diluted.
- 1:02:35There's some non truth in advertising there.
- 1:02:39Then the other thing is, you know, this whole idea of like
- 1:02:42private equity firms wanting to democratize private, there's a
- 1:02:44little bit of a red flag there because why do you want to
- 1:02:47democratize something if it's so great?
- 1:02:49You know, I've never totally trusted that and I think that's
- 1:02:53one thing to watch. But personally, as an investor,
- 1:02:56when I look at some of the privates in Arcs Venture Fund,
- 1:03:00I'm like, you know, I would be kind of cool to be invested in
- 1:03:02the idea. I just saw a video on neural
- 1:03:04Link where the guy's brain can play a video game just thinking
- 1:03:07about it. And I'm like, Oh my God, like,
- 1:03:09that's why you invest. You invest to get your hooks
- 1:03:13into something like that early. And right now you can in an ETF.
- 1:03:16And so that's pretty legitimate. Like, so that's, that's going to
- 1:03:22be really fascinating. And I don't know what the, the,
- 1:03:27the, the rule is. You can only have 15% of your
- 1:03:30ETF in illiquid stuff. So Ron B actually just denoted
- 1:03:36SpaceX as less liquid, not illiquid.
- 1:03:39So he's making that call. And I guess there is a potential
- 1:03:42he can get sued maybe if somebody doesn't agree, but it's
- 1:03:45up to him to make that call. So we're trying to think, OK,
- 1:03:46what else is less liquid Anyway, this is the semantics that are
- 1:03:51involved. And I know if I know the ETF
- 1:03:52industry, they are going to push the envelope.
- 1:03:55We'll see where it goes. So I would just say if you're an
- 1:03:58investor out there and you're thinking about doing it, you
- 1:04:00know, just just know that where you buy it, that percentage
- 1:04:05could go down if the assets and the fund go up.
- 1:04:07That's the main thing you should know.
- 1:04:08Other than that, it's not a ton, it's not a ton of worry.
- 1:04:12I don't think about it. But you know, I honestly, I'd
- 1:04:16never said this because I'm a big fan of ETFs, but an interval
- 1:04:19interval fund with like 80% privates and like 30 of them is
- 1:04:24probably a better move, right? Arcs interval fund is up 56% in
- 1:04:31a year. It's beating the queues.
- 1:04:33Nothing beats the queues and like nobody cares.
- 1:04:36It's crazy. It's so weird.
- 1:04:39It's I think mutual funds, I think it gets tied in with
- 1:04:42mutual funds and I think mutual funds over 50 years have just
- 1:04:45done a disservice. They didn't lower fees,
- 1:04:46underperformed. And a lot of people just feel
- 1:04:49like they don't trust the mutual fund wrapper and like they just
- 1:04:52are repelled by it. And in this case, it's like
- 1:04:55actually the better deal, but like it's got to get over this
- 1:04:57reputation it has. Whereas the ETF has like a Halo
- 1:05:00over it's like I don't care what's in a ETFSI trust so that
- 1:05:04that's what's going on. It's really it hits it so many
- 1:05:06things. That's what crypto did too.
- 1:05:08So I love topics that like have like 3 or 4 subplots at the same
- 1:05:12time. Thanks for walking us through
- 1:05:15that. Yeah, so that's that is
- 1:05:17interesting. And then we'll let you go
- 1:05:18because we're over an hour at this point.
- 1:05:19But it's interesting the fact that so these products exist
- 1:05:23because people want exposure to private market investments, but
- 1:05:27at the same time if you invest in them, then you're diluting
- 1:05:30your ownership of said private market investment.
- 1:05:32So that's that is an interesting dynamic.
- 1:05:34And you're getting, you know, in Ron BS case, 80% is regular
- 1:05:38public stocks which you probably own in your index fund already.
- 1:05:40So there's a redundancy. Whereas if you bought an
- 1:05:43interval fund with almost like all privates, that's completely
- 1:05:47separate exposure and adds to your portfolio like everything
- 1:05:51says just by the interval fund, but like people like, oh, it's
- 1:05:54got five letter ticker, I'm not interested.
- 1:05:55It's like, OK, you know, it isn't that weird.
- 1:06:00Yeah, yeah, it is weird. Yeah, anyway.
- 1:06:04Well, cool Eric. So where do you want people to
- 1:06:07find you online? For those that are chronically
- 1:06:10online, they spend 18 of 24 hours a day on X.
- 1:06:14You're probably already following Eric on X, but what's
- 1:06:16your handle there again? At Eric Balchunas so that's
- 1:06:22probably the best place because I I also tweet like other things
- 1:06:25I'm doing there, but I have a podcast called trillions, which
- 1:06:28you can get on Spotify and I have ATV show called ETFIQ,
- 1:06:32which is on Bloomberg TV. But if you Google ETFIQ, you can
- 1:06:35go watch all kinds of back episodes and we interview all
- 1:06:38kinds of people. We actually just had Kathy Wood
- 1:06:40on our last show talking about her interval fund and you know,
- 1:06:43this dynamic that we just went over.
- 1:06:44So that's that's those are some ways to find me and look out for
- 1:06:49a wee. James and I wrote a book called
- 1:06:51Both Sides of the Coin about our experience with the ETFs and
- 1:06:56crypto and basically the risks. You know, we try to just lay out
- 1:07:00the risks and rewards potentially of this space and
- 1:07:03that comes out in like October. But it we handed it in.
- 1:07:07I mean, we're not editing it now, but yeah, we finished it.
- 1:07:09Congrats, Congrats. So ways, all right, I'll go
- 1:07:11ahead and flight, you know, put it out there.
- 1:07:15So you already know, Eric, that I'll be reaching out to you to
- 1:07:17have both you and James on the podcast after.
- 1:07:20The yeah, I would love it. Yeah, I just want so much.
- 1:07:23Will we have to edit it based on what happened this year?
- 1:07:27Yeah, we all we, we show charge, you know, we, we went over
- 1:07:30everything but there. I will probably have to add a
- 1:07:32little bit about this year at some point.
- 1:07:34Hopefully it's good. Stay away.
- 1:07:36Time will tell. It also could, I mean, who
- 1:07:38knows, it could just go right back.
- 1:07:40I mean, who knows anyway, But thanks for having me.
- 1:07:43I'll see you next time. It was a pleasure all.
- 1:07:46Right. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:07:48week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:07:50valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:07:53rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:07:55All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:07:57notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:08:00reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 1:08:02entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:08:05investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:08:08your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:08:11Visit onrampbitcoin.com. Contact Schedule a consultation
- 1:08:15with one of our private client advisors.