Latest / The Line Podcast / The Line Podcast: Canadians secretly love Mark Carney BECAUSE he yells
Transcript
- 0:00hey guys it's the line podcast mark carney yells oh no also we
- 0:06check in with our
- 0:07jewish friends they're pissed an update from alberta jen's
- 0:11pissed it's the line
- 0:12podcast all right jen elder millennial to elder millennial go
- 0:29ricky martin
- 0:31Livin' La Vida Moca That's his really famous one He had the
- 0:36other one that was just
- 0:37she bangs And I read in the Toronto Star this quote about Mark
- 0:42Carney that simply
- 0:43SPEAKER_01: said he yells And I've had she bangs in my head
- 0:49the rest of the week i've been listening to it on my music
- 0:52account and my wife's
- 0:53looking at me like i've gone insane and she's like is this like
- 0:56a midlife crisis
- 0:57like are we like listening to all the songs we listen to in
- 1:00grade 11 i can't rule
- 1:01SPEAKER_01: out a midlife crisis but no so jen mark carney he yells
- 1:10Althea Raj Toronto Star a feature with the Liberal Caucus
- 1:14talking about some
- 1:15dissent there it's funny Jen you and I are sometimes you know
- 1:20we're not life
- 1:21partners but we're work partners and we're not life soulmates
- 1:23but sometimes we're
- 1:24work soulmates because I'm reading this article and I had like
- 1:28one thought running
- 1:29SPEAKER_01: through my mind and my phone goes doo-doo
- 1:32and I look at it and it is Jen verbalizing my like she was like
- 1:37narrating my inner
- 1:38monologue would you like to tell Jen the listeners the audience
- 1:43what was your
- 1:43reaction to he yells good yeah it's like I don't I don't think
- 1:51that many of these
- 1:52sweet sweet sugar cookies in the liberal caucus have fully
- 1:55comprehended what's
- 1:56SPEAKER_00: happening here and that is
- 2:00he yelling at you was part of the value proposition you you
- 2:05gone done run the
- 2:06government run the country into the ground for 10 years it's
- 2:10time for you to be
- 2:11punished and the fact that you're going to be punished by a man
- 2:14who is like the
- 2:15living physical avatar of liberal self-conception only makes it
- 2:19all the more
- 2:20beautiful like this is why we actually hired Mark Carney and
- 2:24part of the reason why
- 2:25SPEAKER_00: his personal approval rating is going up because he yells
- 2:29It's because he's mean to you Are you not in the same
- 2:34conservative sort of group
- 2:35chats that I am where every single time one of these stories
- 2:38comes out that's like
- 2:39Mark Carney is demanding people get back into the office Mark
- 2:42Carney is demanding
- 2:43British English Mark Carney is tasering people Mark Carney is
- 2:48demanding that you
- 2:48show up not wearing sweatpants like every sort of red Tory
- 2:52conservative I know is
- 2:53SPEAKER_00: going
- 3:02every single policy of the last 10 years that he quietly undoes
- 3:07and then forces the
- 3:08SPEAKER_00: liberal caucus to stand behind and clap we're like good
- 3:13X more oh oh does he yell at you tell me more tell me more in
- 3:18very vivid detail
- 3:19give give me like lay the scene for me it's extremely I think
- 3:24he speaks to
- 3:25something that is deeply sadistic and nasty in the Canadian
- 3:28character that lives in
- 3:30the shadow self behind all of our apparent politeness and
- 3:34niceness there's a
- 3:36there's a mirror image or kind of like matter anti-matter thing
- 3:39going on where like
- 3:41I've spent like 15 months trying to explain to my conservative
- 3:44friends that you had
- 3:44the best ever result you've ever had in terms of like getting
- 3:47out the vote and raw
- 3:50SPEAKER_01: number of votes.
- 3:51You exceeded the threshold normally required to get a majority
- 3:54and you still
- 3:55SPEAKER_01: fucking lost because you suck.
- 3:57and i think the liberals have a mirror image of that going on
- 4:01which is they won now
- 4:03they have their bare majority and i think they're taking in
- 4:06that a measure of
- 4:08vindication and almost like oh we couldn't have been that bad
- 4:12but no you were
- 4:14you know the liberal party was saved in 2025 by a combination
- 4:19of a genuinely smart
- 4:22tactical campaign and Pierre Polyev being incapable of pivoting
- 4:28and having a staff
- 4:28around him that couldn't force him to and you know there's that
- 4:33old expression
- 4:33you've probably heard that you were born on third but you think
- 4:37you hit a triple
- 4:38and i think the liberals here like have some version of that
- 4:41going on where they
- 4:44were spared just over a year ago what would have probably have
- 4:48been a really
- 4:48affirming positive emotionally helpful development of getting
- 4:55their asses kicked in
- 4:56public but they were spared that and now mark carney's job is
- 5:00to do it in private
- 5:02SPEAKER_01: and the only response these people have is to go leak it to the store
- 5:06but there's also something sort of deeply karmically
- 5:08appropriate about this too
- 5:10because you know to just be kicked out of power wouldn't have
- 5:14been an appropriate
- 5:15punishment there's something even better about the idea of like
- 5:18oh no you're still
- 5:19nominally in power but all of your hopes and dreams will be
- 5:22stripped away from you
- 5:23in real time and you're going to have to smile and nod like
- 5:27that that there's
- 5:28something almost better about that from just a judgmental point
- 5:32of view right um
- 5:33You have to order Stephen Gibault to go cut the ribbon out of a
- 5:36new coal mine.
- 5:37SPEAKER_00: Cry fucking harder, Stephen.
- 5:40SPEAKER_00: Look,
- 5:40I'm sorry if this really appeals to the part of my soul that's
- 5:43maybe not morally
- 5:44SPEAKER_00: good,
- 5:45SPEAKER_00: but we all contain multitudes.
- 5:49SPEAKER_00: Okay, but here's also where I would inject some nuance into this.
- 5:51SPEAKER_00: And I was like,
- 5:52SPEAKER_00: of course,
- 5:53there's a line between the Prime Minister yelling at you and a
- 5:56genuinely toxic
- 5:58SPEAKER_00: workplace environment.
- 6:00SPEAKER_00: We know that there are lots of political cultures that cross that line.
- 6:05SPEAKER_00: Political cultures are intended to be quite harsh and quite adversarial.
- 6:10We're expecting high performers to be able to tolerate a high
- 6:12degree of stress.
- 6:14SPEAKER_00: That's the norm in the standard, the system that we're in.
- 6:18and at the same time there's a point where that goes too far
- 6:21and it becomes
- 6:21counterproductive so like it's very hard for us from the
- 6:24outside to gauge whether
- 6:26or not we're just dealing with a high demand high performance
- 6:29boss who's unpleasant
- 6:31and a bit of an asshole but guess what sugar cookies that's
- 6:34life suck it up you
- 6:36grand for office and you're expecting to lead a G7 country
- 6:40you're going to need to
- 6:40be performing appropriately and if you show up and waste the
- 6:43boss time and act
- 6:44SPEAKER_00: stupid act basically like a
- 6:47SPEAKER_00: There's that
- 7:03SPEAKER_00: The Line theline
- 7:29is going to alienate their entire caucus so what where's the
- 7:32line between that um
- 7:35but i would say like the sorts of complaints that liberals have
- 7:38made in publicly
- 7:39unwisely like i think marco mendicino's complaints about his
- 7:42email load or you know
- 7:46why should i have to show up to work or you know i'm bitching
- 7:50about having to wear
- 7:51SPEAKER_00: proper clothes i don't have any sympathy for that i'm sorry
- 7:58none i'm glad he yells at you if you're a dumbass good i'm glad
- 8:02someone's doing it
- 8:04you know what this is like i've been saying for years jen it's
- 8:06been like a
- 8:07recurring theme on the podcast that i've been desperate for
- 8:10someone to release some
- 8:11wolves back into the canadian government ecosystem that's right
- 8:14and now we have a
- 8:15SPEAKER_00: boss that yells good i'll take it i'll take it i'll take that
- 8:20SPEAKER_01: to your point about toxic work environments.
- 8:22SPEAKER_01: Yeah, of course, you're right.
- 8:24SPEAKER_01: Of course.
- 8:24SPEAKER_01: Of course.
- 8:25The one thing I would mention,
- 8:26and I'm not saying this to excuse a toxic work environment.
- 8:30But a member of parliament is not like a normal employee who
- 8:33really does serve at
- 8:34SPEAKER_01: the pleasure of the boss,
- 8:36SPEAKER_01: right?
- 8:37A liberal member of parliament serves at the pleasure of the
- 8:40constituents.
- 8:41SPEAKER_01: They are elected to represent a community, not to serve Mark Carney.
- 8:45And if there's a toxic work environment,
- 8:47if it genuinely gets to a point where it's
- 8:51miserable and unpleasant you stand up in the house on a point
- 8:54of order or whatever
- 8:55the phrasing would be and you announce that you're leaving the
- 8:58liberal caucus
- 8:58because the boss is an asshole and you can't work for him and
- 9:01you're going to
- 9:01continue to represent your constituents and you have a little
- 9:04pride and dignity
- 9:05like MPs have vastly more ability to defend themselves than
- 9:10almost any other
- 9:12employer because they don't actually work for the prime
- 9:14minister and they they work
- 9:16SPEAKER_01: for the people and the prime minister can get that fact
- 9:20SPEAKER_01: You might lose the job eventually.
- 9:39SPEAKER_01: Mark Gurney can't fire you and replace you.
- 9:42SPEAKER_01: That's the voter's job.
- 9:43SPEAKER_01: You work for the people.
- 9:43This is not a normal workplace environment where people are
- 9:46subject to human
- 9:47SPEAKER_00: rights,
- 9:48SPEAKER_00: or sorry,
- 9:48SPEAKER_00: not human rights,
- 9:49SPEAKER_00: human resources departments in the same kind of way.
- 9:52SPEAKER_00: You're right.
- 9:53And the MPs who forget that are kind of just being chicken shit
- 9:58and displaying
- 9:58SPEAKER_00: their own weakness.
- 9:59I mean,
- 9:59I think that was so interesting about- And that's why we like
- 10:00it when you get yelled at.
- 10:02Well that's right but also this is this is one of the subtexts
- 10:05or one of the things
- 10:05that was brought up in Althea Raj's columns in the Toronto Star
- 10:08was that apparently
- 10:08there was a letter signed by I think 13 anonymous MPs chicken
- 10:12shit chicken shit put
- 10:15SPEAKER_00: your name to it um you're an MP this isn't this isn't a normal workplace
- 10:20environment that's just reality um the other thing too is none
- 10:23of the actual
- 10:25SPEAKER_00: anecdotes
- 10:27strike me as being over the line now that being said I'm sure I
- 10:30don't have the full
- 10:31suite of anecdotes but let's hear if he's truly going beyond
- 10:37mean high expectations
- 10:39boss in a high stress work environment and he's going over into
- 10:43toxic asshole
- 10:45Then I want to hear some actual examples because I've covered
- 10:49stories of leaders
- 10:50SPEAKER_00: who went toxic on their caucuses.
- 10:53SPEAKER_00: Alison Redford was was perhaps most notorious about this.
- 10:57SPEAKER_00: The actual stories that came out of this was not she yelled at me.
- 11:00The actual stories that were coming out of this was were
- 11:03absolutely over the top.
- 11:05SPEAKER_00: And I mean, I mean, there were even public.
- 11:07like throwing things being physically violent like engaging in
- 11:12workplace behavior
- 11:13that was beyond the pale like non-professional workplace
- 11:16behaviors would be putting
- 11:18it mildly right that's what a toxic sort of caucus workplace
- 11:22environment is and
- 11:22that's why also she didn't last very long she got spilled Mark
- 11:28Carney is a toxic
- 11:29boss you can spill him you have that power other than that and
- 11:34short of that
- 11:35It's not reasonable to expect the same kind of workplace
- 11:38standards that you're
- 11:39SPEAKER_00: going to get working at a McDonald's.
- 11:42SPEAKER_00: You've chosen government.
- 11:44SPEAKER_00: It's not going to be like H&R Block.
- 11:47You know,
- 11:47you're not going to be able to appeal to the HR department at
- 11:51Deloitte.
- 11:52Like,
- 11:54this is a different environment and you have the power to stand
- 11:56up for yourself.
- 11:57You have the power to walk away and you have the power to spill
- 11:59your boss.
- 12:00SPEAKER_01: I expect more from my local McDonald's.
- 12:03I'm going to need you to demonstrate some spying if you want to
- 12:07be taken seriously there.
- 12:09SPEAKER_00: Otherwise,
- 12:10every single time that we see a story about Mark Carney being
- 12:13mean to a liberal MP,
- 12:15SPEAKER_00: every single normal Canadian just goes,
- 12:19excellent.
- 12:21I think,
- 12:23look,
- 12:24millions and millions,
- 12:24over 8 million Canadians voted for Mark Carney.
- 12:27and over 8 million as well not quite as many but a huge number
- 12:31of Canadians voted
- 12:32for Pierre Polyev and something that Jen and I have talked
- 12:35about before and I think
- 12:37a public opinion polling backs this up is that Mark Carney has
- 12:43impressed some
- 12:44conservatives and it's funny like I feel almost like I'm
- 12:48describing this as like
- 12:50SPEAKER_01: I'm at a zoo exhibit because like I'm on the record
- 12:53SPEAKER_01: I think Carney,
- 12:55in terms of everything I know about his personal priorities and
- 12:57comportment,
- 12:58SPEAKER_01: I'm definitely a fan.
- 13:00SPEAKER_01: But I've been kind of peevish all along about going, where's the beef?
- 13:04SPEAKER_01: You've got to show me some progress here.
- 13:06None of what we're saying is an actual commentary on his record
- 13:09as someone on government.
- 13:13SPEAKER_01: And I think that's where a lot of conservatives start to like him.
- 13:17where disagree on the policies as i do be frustrated at a lack
- 13:22of some deliverables
- 13:23which i am uh we're going to talk in the second segment about
- 13:26some bad habits mark
- 13:28carney has kept from the predecessor his predecessor but
- 13:32overall i think this guy
- 13:35could keep winning majority governments if he just keeps
- 13:38angrily calling bullshit
- 13:40SPEAKER_01: on his own caucus
- 13:42Like I do think there's like this primal desire in this country
- 13:46to see Stephen
- 13:48Gibbo be sad and resign I think he actually could be Prime
- 13:52Minister forever if he
- 13:53starts showing up in Toronto and pointing out the garbage and
- 13:56getting angry about
- 13:57it like I think that they're the normies and I certainly you
- 14:00and I have got this
- 14:00perception is that behind this calm professional exterior is a
- 14:03man who's like a
- 14:04total fucking asshole and that's an energy that we like in this
- 14:08country Do you mean
- 14:10SPEAKER_01: carny?
- 14:14whistling asshole behind this this someone who's quite composed
- 14:17and controlled on
- 14:18the exterior and I think that there's something about that that
- 14:21is very Canadian I
- 14:22don't know like my impression of Carney isn't that he's an
- 14:25asshole it's actually
- 14:26kind of the opposite but I think what Carney is is a guy who's
- 14:30willing to point out
- 14:31failure and that might code to Canadians as asshole like
- 14:36compared to some other
- 14:37SPEAKER_01: politicians that you and I could both name but probably won't
- 14:41Carney seems to have like a clean personal life pleasant
- 14:44personal demeanor all
- 14:45these things but when he shows up at work and people are like
- 14:50complaining about
- 14:51bullshit and he calls him out and I think in Canadian speak
- 14:57that does get coded as
- 14:59SPEAKER_01: asshole what I find fascinating though to your point is the
- 15:06We are living in an era of unparalleled existential threat to
- 15:09our way of life and
- 15:10SPEAKER_01: our very sovereignty,
- 15:12SPEAKER_01: our existence as a nation Also,
- 15:16my boss yelled at me My boss yelled at me I think I'm
- 15:21interpreting that as he's
- 15:23expecting people who have accepted the burdens of office to
- 15:28behave at a level that
- 15:30SPEAKER_00: is indicative and in alignment with normal high performance
- 15:34and we're dealing with a caucus that overwhelmingly isn't isn't
- 15:37accustomed to those
- 15:38expectations that's that's what I think it is I think that you
- 15:43have a caucus of
- 15:43people who you know I mean I don't mean to be too shitty to the
- 15:46to the liberal
- 15:46caucuses I normally am like I do think it's a mixed bag as any
- 15:49caucus is going to
- 15:50be but you have a kind of a party culture and a caucus culture
- 15:57that has been very
- 15:59SPEAKER_00: wooly in its thinking and very soft and
- 16:03SPEAKER_00: and also unaccustomed to dissent,
- 16:05SPEAKER_00: unaccustomed to internal debate on issues at a really intense level.
- 16:10SPEAKER_00: And I think they think they're accustomed to that, but they're not.
- 16:14SPEAKER_00: And then all of a sudden,
- 16:15SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 16:16SPEAKER_00: this asshole comes rolling in is like,
- 16:18SPEAKER_00: no,
- 16:18SPEAKER_00: that's not good enough.
- 16:19SPEAKER_00: I'm holding you to a higher standard.
- 16:20SPEAKER_00: And if you don't perform, I'm going to yell at you.
- 16:22SPEAKER_00: Or I'm not even sure he's yelling.
- 16:24SPEAKER_00: I suspect he's just raising his voice and being harsh and direct.
- 16:28SPEAKER_00: And you've got, you know, a kind of
- 16:30for lack of a better term Canada is a bit of a culture of
- 16:32pandas being like oh he's
- 16:37not interested in my opinion there was a poll out this week I
- 16:41think it was legit
- 16:43where Carney's approval rating has hit or liberal approval
- 16:46rating has hit like 50%
- 16:48SPEAKER_01: I thought that was interesting but I think
- 16:53SPEAKER_01: I don't mean this as wordplay, Jen.
- 16:55SPEAKER_01: I mean this very sincerely.
- 16:56I do think right now I could see Canadians having approval for
- 17:00the government but not affection.
- 17:03So if you kind of look around at the state of things and go,
- 17:07well,
- 17:08the world's on fire.
- 17:09SPEAKER_01: Things suck.
- 17:09SPEAKER_01: The country's a bit of a mess.
- 17:10SPEAKER_01: The conservatives are delusional.
- 17:13SPEAKER_01: I guess we're going to go with the liberals.
- 17:17SPEAKER_01: But also you don't like them.
- 17:19SPEAKER_01: And you find them to be sanctimonious windbags,
- 17:21SPEAKER_01: or as I used to call them under the previous prime minister,
- 17:24SPEAKER_01: gormless weasels.
- 17:26SPEAKER_01: And you find out that these guys,
- 17:28you're kind of reluctantly feeling like you might kind of have
- 17:31to back in the
- 17:31SPEAKER_01: circumstances,
- 17:33SPEAKER_01: but the boss is chewing them out for their failures.
- 17:35SPEAKER_01: You kind of go, eh, you know what, I can live with that.
- 17:38I can I can live with that that's actually that that's that's
- 17:41maybe uh follows in
- 17:42my my uh Jen Gerson political maxim number one and that is on a
- 17:45long enough
- 17:46timeline every single person gets exactly what they deserve in
- 17:49politics I think I
- 17:54saw you tweet about this and you texted me this and I just
- 17:57thought it was brilliant
- 17:57the more he yells at his own like the more he yells and the
- 18:01more this gets leaked
- 18:02SPEAKER_01: the
- 18:04his popularity will go up if he scraps some idiotic program and
- 18:08makes the minister
- 18:09who spent 10 years under Trudeau explain why it was amazing go
- 18:13out and give the we
- 18:14are proud to stand up for Canadians by killing this thing I've
- 18:18invested 10 years of
- 18:19my life into and then two days later Althea reports that Mark
- 18:23Carney also chewed
- 18:24the guy out for being a moron he'll go up another three percent
- 18:28because I think
- 18:29SPEAKER_01: Canadians will go wow he's
- 18:32he's killing the stupid programs and yelling at the idiots who
- 18:35told us they were
- 18:36great ideas but wow sign me up for more prime minister for life
- 18:41here's my donation
- 18:44i can only imagine and i know it's not the most important point
- 18:49you imagine how
- 18:50SPEAKER_01: pure poly of feels
- 18:55Sorry Pierre I'm sorry but like in the same way that only Nixon
- 18:59could go to China
- 19:00only technocrat daddy could properly punish the liberal cock
- 19:07Perny sorry Polyev
- 19:10SPEAKER_01: snacking on an apple
- 19:12showing a measure of contempt for some random newspaper editor
- 19:17somewhere near a
- 19:17farm and it's like a national story and it's like a political
- 19:21thing that like has
- 19:22become to define the guy right like munching the apple is
- 19:25Paulyev's cliche now Mark
- 19:28Carney in the caucus room going you're a fucking idiot and
- 19:31you're a fucking idiot
- 19:32and you're a fucking idiot his approval just goes up and up and
- 19:35up and up so okay
- 19:39SPEAKER_00: sorry Pierre
- 19:40SPEAKER_00: Sorry, I feel for you.
- 19:42It's a very difficult strategic rhetoric environment for
- 19:45conservatives right now.
- 19:49SPEAKER_00: I buy that.
- 19:51SPEAKER_01: He yells.
- 19:52SPEAKER_00: But it's also...
- 19:54darkly hilarious and as I said speaks to something that is
- 19:57deeply nasty and
- 19:59sadistic about the Canadian soul that that this is where we're
- 20:03at look in the best
- 20:05way I'm not I'm not even dissing us I'm like this is actually
- 20:07what I like about
- 20:08Canadians is when their passive aggressive meanness comes out
- 20:12if we're going to be
- 20:13stuck with them as a majority government for the next three
- 20:16years the least we can
- 20:18SPEAKER_01: count on the least we can ask for is that they're all miserable
- 20:22I think that's reasonable that's a reasonable compromise that
- 20:25they shall find no
- 20:26joy they shall find no satisfaction it should be nothing but
- 20:30getting yelled at by
- 20:31someone who thinks you're a moron and does not hesitate to tell
- 20:35you that because
- 20:36you deserve it and the voters don't see a better option than
- 20:39you but they do not
- 20:41wish happiness upon you tell me tell me that that's not the
- 20:44karmically appropriate
- 20:45answer for all of Canadian woes right now it is it is
- 20:50everyone's getting something
- 20:51SPEAKER_01: better
- 20:52SPEAKER_00: Everyone's getting what they deserve And on that note,
- 20:54like and subscribe www.readtheline We'll be back to talk about
- 20:59the Jews In short
- 21:00SPEAKER_01: order He yells
- 21:04SPEAKER_01: This episode of The Line Podcast is brought to you by the Forest Products
- 21:09SPEAKER_01: Association of Canada.
- 21:10Canada's forest industry is a national economic anchor rooted
- 21:14in hundreds of
- 21:15SPEAKER_01: communities across the country.
- 21:17The Canadian Forest Sector Transformation Task Force was
- 21:20created to chart a path
- 21:21SPEAKER_01: toward a stronger,
- 21:23SPEAKER_01: more competitive,
- 21:23SPEAKER_01: and more resilient sector.
- 21:26SPEAKER_01: That means practical federal action on long-standing priorities,
- 21:30SPEAKER_01: stronger supply chains,
- 21:31SPEAKER_01: better productivity,
- 21:33SPEAKER_01: more homes,
- 21:34SPEAKER_01: and regional resilience.
- 21:36SPEAKER_01: Learn more at fpac.ca
- 21:42SPEAKER_00: So Matt,
- 21:42SPEAKER_00: I couldn't help but notice that there was a lot in the news this week,
- 21:46SPEAKER_00: especially coming from Ontario about the Jews and the Jews being unhappy,
- 21:51SPEAKER_00: particularly with a speech that Mark Gurney gave.
- 21:54SPEAKER_00: You have more contacts in that world, particularly in Ontario than I do.
- 21:59SPEAKER_00: Can you talk to me about what's going on there?
- 22:02SPEAKER_01: Well, I mean, we can talk about the news.
- 22:04SPEAKER_01: We can kind of recap it at a very basic level.
- 22:10The Prime Minister came to Toronto this week to give a speech
- 22:15at a synagogue in
- 22:16SPEAKER_01: Toronto where he took on the issue of anti-Semitism in Canada,
- 22:22which has been a real and growing concern since the October 7th
- 22:26attacks a couple of
- 22:26SPEAKER_01: years ago.
- 22:28this was uh sold in advance i'm not being cynical here i'm just
- 22:32saying like the
- 22:32word went out it's gonna be a big address we're gonna
- 22:34acknowledge you know that we
- 22:35haven't taken this seriously enough we're gonna we're gonna
- 22:38turn the corner we're
- 22:39gonna reassure the jewish community blah blah blah blah blah
- 22:42and um so that was the
- 22:44the signaling before and i'm actually sorry i'm looking off the
- 22:47camera right now
- 22:48SPEAKER_01: i'm just scrolling through
- 22:50SPEAKER_01: Yeah, here it is.
- 22:50SPEAKER_01: So I've been scrolling through the speech.
- 22:52SPEAKER_01: I'm going to read you a section of it in a minute.
- 22:55But I think while we're still kind of setting it up,
- 23:03the speech wasn't bad.
- 23:05SPEAKER_01: It's not like it said bad things,
- 23:08but I just think if you go out of your way to reassure a
- 23:12community that's under
- 23:15SPEAKER_01: siege or feels under siege,
- 23:18and you don't actually show up with anything meaningful and
- 23:22tangible they're not
- 23:23going to feel reassured and I want to read you part of the
- 23:25speech here because I
- 23:26know the Prime Minister and his advisors would say but we did
- 23:29announce things well
- 23:30here is part of the speech right so the Prime Minister shows up
- 23:33in Toronto he says
- 23:34to the Jewish community you guys have been unfairly attacked
- 23:37you do not feel like
- 23:38full citizens in this country your families your businesses
- 23:41your homes your
- 23:42SPEAKER_01: neighborhoods are being harassed and I quote
- 23:46SPEAKER_01: To that end,
- 23:47I am pleased to announce the launch and membership of Canada's
- 23:50new Ministerial
- 23:51SPEAKER_01: Advisory Council on Rights,
- 23:52Equality and Inclusion to be chaired by the Minister of
- 23:56Canadian Identity and
- 23:57SPEAKER_01: Culture,
- 23:57SPEAKER_01: Mark Miller Well,
- 24:03SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 24:05SPEAKER_00: an advisory council is not a bad place to start.
- 24:11SPEAKER_00: Is it?
- 24:15SPEAKER_01: In response to the Chinese invasion of BC,
- 24:18SPEAKER_01: I am convening the Canadian-Chinese Relations Committee.
- 24:23SPEAKER_01: Alright,
- 24:25SPEAKER_00: so here's the feedback that I was noticing here,
- 24:28SPEAKER_00: and I mean,
- 24:28SPEAKER_00: neither of us are Jewish,
- 24:29SPEAKER_00: neither of us are part of the Jewish community,
- 24:31but a lot of people in the Jewish community I saw seem to be
- 24:36unimpressed by the
- 24:37SPEAKER_00: fact that he wouldn't actually
- 24:39name the perpetrators of a lot of these attacks and the
- 24:43presumption here is like
- 24:44you're not willing to name the fact that it's the I mean
- 24:48quoting someone here
- 24:49saying anti-Zionist or the pro-Palestinian movement that is
- 24:54explicitly in support
- 24:55of parts of it are explicitly in support of Hamas like if
- 25:01you're going to give that
- 25:02SPEAKER_00: speech you need to at least name the people who are
- 25:06SPEAKER_00: You need to name the people who are doing the damage.
- 25:09We know who these people are,
- 25:10and it's not exclusively people of a certain ethnicity.
- 25:14SPEAKER_00: There are white people involved in this group too,
- 25:16but they all seem to be aligned with a kind of common
- 25:19anti-Zionist rhetoric or
- 25:23ideology that conflates Jews with people who are personally
- 25:29responsible for what's
- 25:30SPEAKER_00: happening in Israel with respect to Gaza.
- 25:33So I think thought saw that and that was very disappointing for
- 25:37a lot of people
- 25:38Yeah The Prime Minister To me the whole thing was close but no
- 25:47cigar because I
- 25:48think he did articulate correctly the Jewish Canadians feel
- 25:52attacked I think he
- 25:54articulated correctly that it's abhorrent I think he
- 25:56articulated correctly the
- 25:57SPEAKER_01: history of anti-Semitism including in this country
- 26:01but then starting around oh midnight on October 7th 2023 his
- 26:07memory got real vague
- 26:10and what has happened in this country since the October 7th
- 26:12attacks is that well
- 26:15first of all the attacks were openly celebrated by some in
- 26:18Canada and I've already
- 26:19written about that openly celebrated well before Israel had
- 26:23fired a single shot in
- 26:24SPEAKER_01: retaliation the attacks were being celebrated and embraced as resistance
- 26:30there was later on the targeting as the Prime Minister noted he
- 26:34had a whole list of
- 26:36horrible things that have happened to Jews in this country over
- 26:38the last few years
- 26:40but never directly linked it to the fact that Canadian Jews are
- 26:43being used as
- 26:44scapegoats no pun intended subbing in for Israelis which is
- 26:50inherently anti-Semitic
- 26:52and prejudicial and if we didn't have such friggin brain rot in
- 26:56this country we
- 26:57SPEAKER_01: would all know that
- 27:00you know all the same people who 25 years ago would have known
- 27:04in their hearts you
- 27:06don't take out 9-11 on your Muslim neighbor seem to have gotten
- 27:09real fuzzy on that
- 27:10concept sometime in the last couple years and there was just
- 27:15the prime minister
- 27:17said a lot of good stuff but there were just a few critical
- 27:20things and Ariella
- 27:21Kimmel in the line this week wrote a column about it you've got
- 27:24to take this thing
- 27:26SPEAKER_01: on directly you've got to say
- 27:28SPEAKER_01: The Line theline
- 27:51SPEAKER_01: is probably either a jerk or in some cases a criminal.
- 27:57SPEAKER_01: And a lot of what we've seen in this country has been criminal.
- 28:00SPEAKER_01: And you and I have spoken about this already,
- 28:03SPEAKER_01: where after the US consulate in Toronto took some gunfire,
- 28:06all of a sudden the Toronto police rediscovered the virtue of
- 28:08enforcing the law.
- 28:10and there have been a series of arrests in Toronto or the
- 28:13greater Toronto area
- 28:14because some of these people were in the suburbs of people who
- 28:17have been now
- 28:18charged not convicted so these are allegations but they've been
- 28:21charged with
- 28:21attacks either on Jews directly assaults on Jewish persons or
- 28:26attacks on Jewish
- 28:27property or is you know property in some way related to or
- 28:31affiliated with Jewish
- 28:33SPEAKER_01: institutions or Jewish religious and cultural sites Jewish businesses
- 28:38SPEAKER_01: And,
- 28:38SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 28:40only very recently in the last couple of months did the city of
- 28:43Toronto police
- 28:44SPEAKER_01: brass decide,
- 28:46SPEAKER_01: yeah,
- 28:46SPEAKER_01: you know what,
- 28:46SPEAKER_01: it's not okay to have huge throngs protesting in Jewish neighborhoods.
- 28:51SPEAKER_00: That had absolutely nothing to do with the Israeli government.
- 28:54That is a materially different thing than protesting the
- 28:56Israeli embassy,
- 28:57for example.
- 28:58SPEAKER_01: Or a company with strong defense ties to Israel, right?
- 29:01SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 29:03SPEAKER_00: I'm agreeing with everything you say,
- 29:06but I just want to make sure that there's lots and lots of
- 29:08clarity on what we're
- 29:09SPEAKER_00: saying here and what we're not saying.
- 29:11We're not saying that you have to be uncritical of Israeli
- 29:15policy in the Middle East.
- 29:17SPEAKER_00: We're not saying that you should be uncritical of Netanyahu.
- 29:20We're not saying that it's wrong to protest the way that Israel
- 29:24has responded in Gaza.
- 29:26reasonable people can have a wide range of views on all of
- 29:29those things and if you
- 29:30SPEAKER_00: are on the side that like for example the Israeli response to Gaza was
- 29:33disproportionate or heavy-handed or or or not appropriate to
- 29:38the crime okay by all
- 29:41means that's fine and also protest the Israeli embassy that is
- 29:44fine where we cross
- 29:46SPEAKER_00: the line here is where when we start to conflate anybody who holds
- 29:51pro-Zionist views as people who therefore have legitimate
- 29:56targets because the
- 29:57default of where that goes is essentially okay then you've just
- 30:00turned every
- 30:01civilian Jew into a legitimate target for your protest and
- 30:06we've seen that escalate
- 30:07SPEAKER_00: into justification for violence against ordinary Jews in Canada.
- 30:11SPEAKER_01: It has happened.
- 30:11SPEAKER_00: It has happened and it's continuing to happen.
- 30:14just this week a synagogue in Montreal there was an attempted
- 30:17arson there and I
- 30:19don't want to make light of this Jen because God knows it's not
- 30:21funny but like I
- 30:23had to have a sad laugh because someone just said gosh it's
- 30:26like the perpetrator I
- 30:27saw a tweet it was like wow did the perpetrator not even know
- 30:30that we have a new
- 30:31council on inclusion and you know one of the things I just find
- 30:35incredibly
- 30:35frustrating Jen you're entirely right what you said a minute
- 30:38ago about protesting
- 30:41SPEAKER_01: Israeli policy is fine
- 30:42SPEAKER_01: protesting in solidarity with the Palestinian people is fine.
- 30:45SPEAKER_01: There are legal ways to do this.
- 30:48And there are also illegal ways to threaten the Jewish
- 30:51community in this country.
- 30:53SPEAKER_01: And a lot of really,
- 30:54SPEAKER_01: really smart people have all of a sudden gotten real,
- 30:57SPEAKER_01: real fuzzy on how to do that.
- 30:59SPEAKER_01: And there's nothing that drives me nuts,
- 31:01SPEAKER_01: Jen,
- 31:01SPEAKER_01: more than people who are pretending to be stupider than they are.
- 31:05and people who don't want to take a side we were just talking
- 31:07about this last week
- 31:08in a very different context you and I were talking about last
- 31:10week about how a lot
- 31:12of conservatives in Alberta suddenly lost the heart for the
- 31:16fight when it meant
- 31:17they would have been fighting against other conservatives well
- 31:19this is a version of
- 31:20that where on the progressive or kind of center left center or
- 31:24further left of
- 31:25SPEAKER_01: Canadian politics a lot of people who know better
- 31:28A lot of people who aren't antisemites just all of a sudden
- 31:31lost their guts and
- 31:33they lost the nerve to call out the elements of the protest
- 31:37movement that were
- 31:39veering into antisemitism and were justifying violence against
- 31:44civilians and were
- 31:45at times engaging in threatening and destructive illegal
- 31:48conduct in Canada.
- 31:50SPEAKER_01: And I hold the most contempt of all
- 31:53for our police and judicial and political officials who just
- 31:59went gutless.
- 32:00And I honestly believe,
- 32:02Jen,
- 32:02a couple of arrests early for like minor crimes.
- 32:07SPEAKER_01: Nope, you stepped out of line on this protest.
- 32:09SPEAKER_01: We're arresting you.
- 32:10SPEAKER_01: A couple of arrests at the outset would have set the tone.
- 32:13SPEAKER_01: It would have said you are allowed to protest legally.
- 32:16SPEAKER_01: You are allowed to march for Gaza.
- 32:18SPEAKER_01: You are allowed to protest Israeli military overreach as you see it.
- 32:22but you were we're going to in this country we're going to have
- 32:25standards we're
- 32:27going to adhere to the law and we're not fucking around on this
- 32:31one and if you step
- 32:31out of line you're going to get arrested but for months and
- 32:35months and months and
- 32:36SPEAKER_01: months particularly in Toronto and Montreal
- 32:38our civic leadership and our police leadership were absolutely
- 32:41gutless and I've
- 32:42spoken to senior cops I've spoken to crowns I've spoken to
- 32:45politicians Jen it is
- 32:47the most disgusting Canadian cycle of blame deflection and
- 32:53responsibility avoidance
- 32:54SPEAKER_01: you've ever seen
- 32:55Cops are like hey we're ready to go in there but you know the
- 32:57the crown will just
- 32:58let him out crowns going we'll lay charges cops aren't making
- 33:01arrests politicians
- 33:03are going hey we can't direct the police we can't direct the
- 33:05courts it was just a
- 33:07SPEAKER_01: it was just like a stool with no legs
- 33:12it wasn't a two-legged stool it was a zero-legged stool and it
- 33:15was Canadian Jews
- 33:16who got hung out to dry the Prime Minister's speech is a
- 33:19recognition of that it's
- 33:20an attempt to set it right I think again rhetorically the tone
- 33:24was right I think
- 33:25morally the tone was right but you're going to go to a family
- 33:29that's been living in
- 33:30terror and their business has been vandalized their kids school
- 33:33has been targeted
- 33:34people in their community have been assaulted but don't worry
- 33:39Mark Miller said
- 33:41fresh off all of his recent successes is going to lead a new
- 33:45inclusion council and
- 33:47also the problem isn't an inclusion council the problem what we
- 33:50need is a standards
- 33:51council like the problem isn't lack of inclusion the problem is
- 33:56that we need to see
- 33:57political leadership set a boundary I mean this is I mean I
- 34:03don't know how many
- 34:03SPEAKER_00: times have we had this conversation I'm sick of having this conversation
- 34:07we don't say no in this country we don't say this not that we
- 34:13seem incapable of
- 34:14saying and I'm gonna we're gonna talk about Alberta it's the
- 34:17same goddamn problem
- 34:18but it's it's we seem impossible to for us to say we're going
- 34:22to set this priority
- 34:23and that means this one we're not gonna do it we have limited
- 34:28bandwidth we're gonna
- 34:28do this this and this but not this this and this it's it's just
- 34:32everyone has to be
- 34:33SPEAKER_00: placated everyone has to be brought on board everybody it's like
- 34:37look sometimes that's the right answer and sometimes the right
- 34:40answer is no no I'm
- 34:45gonna grab I'm looking at my phone again scintillating for the
- 34:49video viewers but
- 34:50I'm looking at my phone again we are two and a half years into
- 34:54a campaign of
- 34:55targeted harassment threatening and violence directed against
- 34:58Jewish Canadians and
- 35:00our response to it is a ministerial advisory council on rights
- 35:05equality and
- 35:06SPEAKER_01: inclusion
- 35:07jesus fuck anyway it's like even when even when saying we must
- 35:12respond to the hyper
- 35:14specific problem of threats of violence and violence against
- 35:20the jews we are
- 35:21SPEAKER_01: responding with the most pablum generic
- 35:27SPEAKER_01: The Line theline
- 35:53but again this is what was intended to reassure the Jewish
- 35:57people I know I know I
- 35:58said this is this is gosh my goodness am I noticing some
- 36:02patterns and habits across
- 36:03different different different fields this feels like one of the
- 36:08most Justin Trudeau
- 36:09things Mark Carney has done yeah well it's up there the thing I
- 36:14just want to say is
- 36:15you know I don't necessarily think that all culture comes from
- 36:18the top I think
- 36:19SPEAKER_00: culture is a is a is a
- 36:23a complicated dynamic between leadership and by the people who
- 36:27are taking cues from
- 36:29various forms of leadership both civic and political but yeah
- 36:36it's your job to set
- 36:37a tone as a leader it's your job to set a moral tone and it is
- 36:41your job as a leader
- 36:42part of your job is to say this but not that this is over the
- 36:47line there's a
- 36:48SPEAKER_00: boundary here and we're going to enforce the boundary and
- 36:53SPEAKER_00: We're really uncomfortable with that in this country.
- 36:56And I don't even blame Carney because I think that it's a
- 36:58broader cultural problem.
- 37:00But we do seem to have lost track of the idea that part of
- 37:03leadership isn't just
- 37:04SPEAKER_00: doing what your base wants.
- 37:07Part of leadership is going back to that base and saying this
- 37:10but not that.
- 37:11SPEAKER_00: No.
- 37:12SPEAKER_00: And...
- 37:14that that and persuading your base and just saying no I'm not
- 37:17my job isn't just to
- 37:18take is just not just not it's just not to pull everyone who
- 37:21votes for me and then
- 37:22take the mass amalgamation of that of that result and then give
- 37:26that people those
- 37:27people what they want because other if that were if that were
- 37:29all that leadership
- 37:30SPEAKER_00: entailed we could have an AI do it.
- 37:33If leadership was just doing a straw poll of the people most
- 37:40likely to vote for you
- 37:41SPEAKER_00: and then coming up with the common denominator of positions,
- 37:47SPEAKER_00: We could do this with chat GPT right now.
- 37:50SPEAKER_00: We don't need actual people to do that right now.
- 37:54Part of the job of a leadership is not just to respond to what
- 37:57their base responds,
- 37:58SPEAKER_00: but also what the rest of the country wants,
- 38:00but to also set a tone and set a persuasive tone for what's
- 38:04acceptable and what
- 38:04SPEAKER_00: isn't.
- 38:06SPEAKER_00: On that note,
- 38:06SPEAKER_00: Matt,
- 38:07I also want to ask you another question because I think you may
- 38:09have manifested
- 38:10something into reality or a reality may be manifesting itself
- 38:15as we speak.
- 38:16a couple of weeks ago at the line podcast you said something
- 38:20and it was very funny
- 38:22I remember very distinctly he was like she you said okay put a
- 38:25mark here Jen
- 38:25because I'm going to say something and I'm afraid that it's
- 38:29going to become reality
- 38:30so I'll say it and then you tell me if I should say it and then
- 38:33if you should I
- 38:34should say it then we'll keep it in the podcast and if I
- 38:37shouldn't say it then
- 38:38SPEAKER_00: we'll cut it from the podcast and you said
- 38:42Donald Trump should offer or what if Donald Trump offered
- 38:45Canadian Jews asylum?
- 38:48SPEAKER_00: Like,
- 38:49SPEAKER_00: what a potent and political statement that would make,
- 38:52SPEAKER_00: not only in support of Jews,
- 38:54but also a very effective way to condemn Canadian inaction on
- 38:59anti-Semitism.
- 39:00SPEAKER_00: It would be very embarrassing, I think, for Canada.
- 39:04and also would be an extremely effective statement in a country
- 39:07that only seems to
- 39:08be able to respond to accountability measures when those
- 39:10accountability measures
- 39:11SPEAKER_00: come from south of the border.
- 39:13SPEAKER_00: And the rumor is now circulating.
- 39:14SPEAKER_00: I don't know if it's true,
- 39:16SPEAKER_00: but we've got,
- 39:17SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 39:17SPEAKER_00: Gadsad and either high-profile Jews picking up stakes and saying,
- 39:20SPEAKER_00: screw it,
- 39:20SPEAKER_00: I'm not living here anymore.
- 39:21SPEAKER_00: This is too dangerous.
- 39:22And whether or not that's self-aggrandizing or not is another
- 39:25conversation,
- 39:26SPEAKER_00: but they're doing it.
- 39:27SPEAKER_00: There's high-profile Jews now leaving.
- 39:30There was also a doctor who issued an open letter,
- 39:32I think,
- 39:33in Montreal as well.
- 39:34One of the top surgeons in Montreal has announced he's leaving
- 39:38for a job in the United States.
- 39:40SPEAKER_01: And one of the factors,
- 39:41SPEAKER_01: not the only factor,
- 39:42but one of the factors in his decision was rampant
- 39:45anti-Semitism in Montreal.
- 39:46SPEAKER_00: And there are lots of reasons why people leave, so it's fine.
- 39:49But one of the rumors is that this is something that the Trump
- 39:54administration is
- 39:55SPEAKER_00: now seriously considering.
- 39:56SPEAKER_00: So you may have manifested this into reality by hook or by crook.
- 40:01SPEAKER_00: Or might be about to manifest this into reality by hook or by crook.
- 40:05SPEAKER_01: Now,
- 40:05SPEAKER_01: as I said,
- 40:05I think the Trump administration would be doing it for their
- 40:08own reasons and not
- 40:09SPEAKER_00: necessarily for the benefit of Jews.
- 40:10I think that this would be about a statement that is about
- 40:12embarrassing Canada,
- 40:14especially as we're heading into like these tumultuous trade
- 40:17negotiations.
- 40:18SPEAKER_00: So let's not be naive about anyone's intentions.
- 40:22But again,
- 40:23even if that's the case,
- 40:24you know,
- 40:25that's a knife that you left on the table.
- 40:28SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 40:28SPEAKER_01: and for what it's worth,
- 40:29SPEAKER_01: Jen,
- 40:29SPEAKER_01: I've heard the same rumors that Mr.
- 40:31SPEAKER_01: Trump or some administration official in the United States will announce.
- 40:36My understanding is it won't just be Canada but Canada will be
- 40:39included in
- 40:41countries where the Jewish citizens of those countries will be
- 40:44offered some kind of
- 40:45SPEAKER_01: political asylum or expedited immigration pathway into the United States.
- 40:50Canada's on that list and one of the related rumors I heard and
- 40:54it's a rumor and
- 40:54I'm stressing that I don't normally come here and spread rumors
- 40:57but the person I
- 40:58heard it from is a reasonably well connected person who would
- 41:02have knowledge of
- 41:03SPEAKER_01: this.
- 41:04SPEAKER_01: Kearney's speech was intended to get ahead of that.
- 41:08Or at the very least that was part of the pre-positioning of
- 41:12the government to the
- 41:14SPEAKER_01: possibility or expectation of
- 41:16that the united states will offer some kind of humanitarian
- 41:19protection to canadian
- 41:20jews and how how hilariously inadequate if that's the case
- 41:26there was an essay i
- 41:27responded to a few days ago not even an essay it was a long
- 41:30social media post on
- 41:31Substack uh by an american writer guy has like 100 followers but
- 41:36he wrote something
- 41:36beautiful and some algorithm put it up into my feed where he's
- 41:40talking about you
- 41:41know the concept of cargo culting the um pacific islanders
- 41:44during the second world
- 41:44SPEAKER_00: war yep
- 41:45Yeah so for readers basically during the second world war the
- 41:49United States had
- 41:51supply bases scattered around the Pacific and they had food and
- 41:55radios and medical
- 41:56officers and primitive islanders on these cults according to
- 42:00like to legend I don't
- 42:01know how true this is This is kind of folk legend at this point
- 42:04it's a question
- 42:05about how true any of this was but it's still a useful metaphor
- 42:07so let's take our
- 42:09SPEAKER_00: colonial privilege like self
- 42:13thing out of this noble savage vibes here yes but the the
- 42:18legend is that the
- 42:20islanders first worship the Americans as gods because they flew
- 42:26in from the sky and
- 42:27brought wondrous things but then when the Americans left the
- 42:31the islanders began
- 42:32kind of using the equipment they'd left behind and trying to
- 42:35think if we perform
- 42:36the rituals the the gods will come back with the stuff and we
- 42:41shall be blessed
- 42:41SPEAKER_01: again and
- 42:42and the essay on Substack was basically talking about how much
- 42:45of like American
- 42:46SPEAKER_01: political culture right now is people going through the rituals
- 42:50I thought it was such a wonderful point that I've made
- 42:54differently in the Canadian
- 42:55context of how many of our governments the convoy was the
- 42:58example I used they have
- 43:00a vague understanding of things they're supposed to be doing
- 43:03during a crisis but
- 43:05they only really know how to go through the motions so like
- 43:07reports are written and
- 43:09briefings are held and meetings convened but nothing actually
- 43:13happens but the
- 43:13people who are responsible are confused right they're like I
- 43:16don't understand I did
- 43:17SPEAKER_01: the things
- 43:18I had the meetings we had the briefings the reports are issued
- 43:22why are the problems
- 43:22not solving themselves and what worried me about the Carney
- 43:26speech in Toronto this
- 43:27SPEAKER_01: week is it felt like I said extremely Justin Trudeau
- 43:31We have a massive problem with anti-semitism so I shall go
- 43:34there and I shall say we
- 43:37have a massive problem with anti-semitism and I shall announce
- 43:41a new watered down
- 43:42generic accepts all comers panel on inclusion and the thing he
- 43:47did in the speech I
- 43:48SPEAKER_01: didn't read this part of the speech to you Jen but I had it in my notes
- 43:54Kearney fell into the habit the trap that we saw Justin Trudeau
- 43:58and so many other
- 43:59Canadian politicians fall into where instead of showing up and
- 44:02being like we got a
- 44:03real problem here and here's how we're going to fix it they
- 44:05show up and they read a
- 44:06list of the financial commitments they've made in recent years
- 44:10we've spent 70
- 44:11million dollars on this yeah inputs no outputs yeah we've I'm
- 44:15being judged by what
- 44:16by the amount by the money I put in or the effort I put in I'm
- 44:19not being judged by
- 44:20SPEAKER_00: the actual outcome
- 44:21so hey jews i'm so sorry for what's happening to you that's why
- 44:25our government
- 44:26three years ago committed 70 million dollars to whatever yeah
- 44:30wait you know hold
- 44:31for applause meanwhile nothing everything got worse yeah or at
- 44:37least failed to get
- 44:37better so look and oh sorry you finish oh it's just like okay
- 44:43yeah so look there's
- 44:44one there's one other thing that i i want to say is that
- 44:46whether or not this uh
- 44:47SPEAKER_00: asylum thing is is announced um
- 44:51SPEAKER_00: not trying to manifest any more unpleasant realities for Canada.
- 44:55I don't think that I've ever encountered in the last 10 years a
- 44:58country that has
- 45:00SPEAKER_00: actively scared away more actual talent than this country.
- 45:04Like we really can't afford to be losing some of our most
- 45:10talented and intelligent people.
- 45:13And it shocks me the degree to which,
- 45:15well,
- 45:16we have like a boomer class who's gone all elbows up
- 45:20It seems to me like our ruling class at the same time thinks
- 45:23that this was a
- 45:25SPEAKER_01: panacea to losing young talent and money.
- 45:30That a bunch of people in their 60s who felt like Donald Trump
- 45:34was pissing upon
- 45:36SPEAKER_00: their generational legacy being really,
- 45:39really angry was going to somehow fix the problems for people
- 45:44under the age of 40
- 45:45SPEAKER_00: in this country.
- 45:46SPEAKER_00: Again, I go back to this speech that
- 45:49Carney gave last year at the University of Ottawa where he
- 45:52asked young people to be
- 45:53ready to make sacrifices for their country he'll never give
- 45:56that speech to a boomer
- 45:58that'll never happen and boomers wouldn't understand it boomers
- 46:03wouldn't understand
- 46:04it right like like that's I mean I'm already buying Canadian
- 46:07made barbecue sauce
- 46:08yeah like what are you talking about drinking rye instead of
- 46:11bourbon I'm all in I'm
- 46:13SPEAKER_01: all in what's the problem I took my golf trip in Mexico
- 46:18instead of Arizona heroes heroes of the nation yeah um the best
- 46:25thing that we can
- 46:26do in response to American belligerence is to make a Canada
- 46:30that is highly
- 46:31functional competent effective smart if you'll forgive me one
- 46:36in which the prime
- 46:37SPEAKER_00: minister can yell um
- 46:42It's not more It creates an inclusion task force On inclusion
- 46:45Let me put it that
- 46:46way And I just The degree of callousness And indifference That
- 46:53our ruling class
- 46:54Regards talent Which is probably One of the scarcest resources
- 46:58We actually have in
- 46:59this country And always has been You know what I mean Like
- 47:01always has been
- 47:04I can't I can't I can't put my finger on it and you know I
- 47:08don't with respect to
- 47:10not wanting to fall into stereotypes and those sorts of gross
- 47:13places you know the
- 47:15Jews of Canada more than pull their goddamn weight I don't want
- 47:20I don't want to be
- 47:22losing 200,000 Jewish people from the country to America that's
- 47:27not that doesn't
- 47:28SPEAKER_01: lead to good things for us here two-thirds of my friends
- 47:33SPEAKER_00: go right there.
- 47:35SPEAKER_00: So yeah, I just I'll leave it there.
- 47:38I think we have some more to say that's kind of on a related
- 47:40note in Alberta,
- 47:42Alberta talk.
- 47:44SPEAKER_01: You're right.
- 47:45SPEAKER_01: We'll leave it here except for one final note.
- 47:46SPEAKER_01: And it's I'm it's a one sentence addition to what you're saying there.
- 47:50SPEAKER_01: And it relates to the joke I just made a minute ago.
- 47:52SPEAKER_01: I'm not even sure I'm joking.
- 47:53My gut feeling is if this offer does happen,
- 47:56I don't think it will be huge uptake.
- 47:59SPEAKER_01: People's
- 48:00lives are complicated right people stay where their kids are
- 48:02where their families
- 48:03are where their businesses are but i think for the elbows up
- 48:07crowd if you think the
- 48:08uptake to this would be zero and it would be limited to maple
- 48:11mega you are wrong
- 48:13the other thing i would just add to that as well is like look
- 48:15if the americans
- 48:16actually wanted to hurt us and the heart the worst thing that
- 48:19they could do like
- 48:20the absolute worst thing that they could do to hurt us
- 48:22psychologically and
- 48:23SPEAKER_00: economically it's not tariffs you
- 48:27create an expedited working visa for every canadian under 40
- 48:31with a university
- 48:32degree yeah and then you buy us at a discount in 20 years
- 48:37that's that's how we
- 48:38become the 51st state that's if you actually wanted to to to to
- 48:42damage us and use
- 48:43economic coercion to to to turn us into a vassal state you
- 48:49wouldn't be worrying
- 48:50about auto parts and and tariffs you would be taking our most
- 48:54limited and valuable
- 48:55SPEAKER_00: asset and that's that's talent
- 48:57Our Jews and our children Well I mean they already do it but I
- 49:02mean look the path
- 49:03to getting American visas is convoluted and it's hard and it's
- 49:07expensive and only
- 49:08certain people qualify and if you look at H-1B visas it's by no
- 49:12means assured it
- 49:13costs a lot of money like you can do it but it's they already
- 49:18take huge amounts of
- 49:19SPEAKER_00: our talent but it's a hard process you want to create a one click
- 49:28SPEAKER_00: Well they do now.
- 49:48SPEAKER_01: They might not have 90 seconds ago, but they do now.
- 49:51SPEAKER_01: Oops, sorry.
- 49:54SPEAKER_00: But you know what?
- 49:55SPEAKER_00: I'm sorry, but Canada, that's your challenge.
- 49:57So build a country that is offering such an incredible value
- 50:02proposition in terms
- 50:03SPEAKER_00: of a social safety net and political and social culture and offer so much
- 50:10SPEAKER_00: opportunity and social mobility for young Canadians and their kids.
- 50:16SPEAKER_00: that not enough of them would uproot their lives for an offer like that.
- 50:20SPEAKER_00: That's actually the challenge of the Canada that you need to build.
- 50:24SPEAKER_01: Or Mark Miller heads up the new Youth Economic Opportunities Task Force.
- 50:30SPEAKER_00: Perfect.
- 50:31SPEAKER_00: Great.
- 50:31SPEAKER_00: Problem solved.
- 50:32SPEAKER_01: Nailed it.
- 50:33SPEAKER_00: Nailed it.
- 50:34SPEAKER_00: www.readtheline.ca God help us.
- 50:40SPEAKER_01: This episode is also brought to you by BioCanRx.
- 50:45SPEAKER_01: Nearly half of all Canadians will face a cancer diagnosis in their lives,
- 50:49SPEAKER_01: and Canadian scientists are racing to build better treatments.
- 50:52But it's not just the science,
- 50:53it's the logistics of actually getting it to patients.
- 50:57SPEAKER_01: BioCanRx is a federally funded,
- 50:59not-for-profit research network that specializes in moving
- 51:02Canadian cancer
- 51:03SPEAKER_01: immunotherapy from the lab to clinical trials here at home.
- 51:07SPEAKER_01: Since 2015,
- 51:08SPEAKER_01: they've funded 16 trials and treated more than 400 patients,
- 51:12SPEAKER_01: all with Made in Canada technology.
- 51:14SPEAKER_01: So what is immunotherapy?
- 51:16Your immune system eliminates threats every day,
- 51:18including your own cells when they mutate.
- 51:21SPEAKER_01: But sometimes mutating cells are able to evade the immune system,
- 51:24SPEAKER_01: and that's usually when we call them cancer.
- 51:28Okay,
- 51:31so Matt,
- 51:40we want to finish off this podcast with a quick Alberta update.
- 51:43And I'm going to rely on you to start asking me questions
- 51:46because I'm so far down
- 51:47SPEAKER_00: the Alberta hole,
- 51:48SPEAKER_00: which from here on out,
- 51:49SPEAKER_00: podcast listeners,
- 51:50SPEAKER_00: I'm now going to call the a-hole.
- 51:52SPEAKER_01: The a-hole?
- 51:53SPEAKER_00: That I can no longer see daylight.
- 51:57SPEAKER_00: What do you need to know, Canada?
- 51:59SPEAKER_00: What can I tell you?
- 52:01SPEAKER_00: What update can I give you?
- 52:02Well,
- 52:03I mean,
- 52:03this is an unhelpfully vague question,
- 52:05but I'll try to bound this.
- 52:07SPEAKER_01: In two minutes or less, tell me what happened this week.
- 52:09SPEAKER_01: Like, what do I need to know since last week?
- 52:11SPEAKER_01: It obviously struck me that not a ton was happening.
- 52:14Like,
- 52:14the campaigns are campaigning,
- 52:16people are getting mobilized,
- 52:17events are being held.
- 52:18But in terms of actual difference-making news developments,
- 52:23I didn't see anything this week.
- 52:24SPEAKER_01: Does that sound about right?
- 52:26Yeah I mean the one thing I would say is we do have Daniel
- 52:29Smith and the UCP
- 52:30government committing to put forward like a full costed package
- 52:34for what it would
- 52:34really take to form your own country that they're claiming is
- 52:39going to be bounded
- 52:39in reality and basically they've come out and said to the
- 52:42separatists like this is
- 52:43not a six billion dollar project you would need to spend
- 52:46hundreds of billions of
- 52:47dollars to seriously run your own country and replicate the
- 52:52services that Canada
- 52:53SPEAKER_00: provides us.
- 52:55The problem of course and I mean I've discussed this before
- 52:58about the rhetorically
- 52:59symmetry that exists between the Federalist and the Separatist
- 53:01campaign is that you
- 53:03can have a credible source come out and be like yeah you're
- 53:05looking at 400 billion
- 53:06dollars as a startup cost and hundreds of extra billions of
- 53:09dollars over X period
- 53:10of time and you get two responses three responses to that the
- 53:13first one is no it
- 53:16wouldn't no it wouldn't or the second response you get is well
- 53:22that's just
- 53:23SPEAKER_00: fear-mongering
- 53:25SPEAKER_00: Or the third response you get,
- 53:26SPEAKER_00: which is a slightly more sophisticated response,
- 53:28SPEAKER_00: is,
- 53:29SPEAKER_00: well,
- 53:29SPEAKER_00: we'd recoup the value of that in regained equalization.
- 53:34SPEAKER_00: Right?
- 53:34SPEAKER_00: Which, again, no, you wouldn't.
- 53:37SPEAKER_00: You know, like, no, not necessarily.
- 53:40SPEAKER_00: Like, no, you wouldn't.
- 53:42Because you have no idea what the actual impact of the economic
- 53:45damage you'd be
- 53:46SPEAKER_00: doing to the quote-unquote independent nation would be.
- 53:50versus staying in Canada so like you're playing with like these
- 53:52weird economic
- 53:53counterfactuals so again I mean Sam Harris actually made this
- 53:57really excellent
- 53:58point when he was asked one time well why won't I debate
- 54:00conspiracy theorists and
- 54:02SPEAKER_00: his answer to it was because if you're coming at any kind of issue from a
- 54:08fact-based framework you have to work 10 times as hard to
- 54:12refute every fantasy
- 54:13SPEAKER_00: claim coming out of a conspiracy theorist
- 54:16SPEAKER_00: So conspiracy theorists are often,
- 54:17SPEAKER_00: by the way,
- 54:18SPEAKER_00: extremely hyper-well-informed on the issues that they're discussing,
- 54:23SPEAKER_00: which makes them come across as very credible,
- 54:25SPEAKER_00: but they're almost encyclopedic in their knowledge of their topic,
- 54:29but they don't know how to weight those topics appropriately or
- 54:33judge them or
- 54:34synthesize them in a way that allows them to come to a
- 54:37conclusion that is grounded
- 54:38SPEAKER_00: in consensus reality.
- 54:39So the end result is you have a fact-based person who's coming
- 54:42at this from an
- 54:45SPEAKER_00: educated position,
- 54:47SPEAKER_00: who spent maybe 10 years actually researching their subject matter.
- 54:50And then they come up and they face a conspiracy theorist and
- 54:52they get peppered
- 54:53SPEAKER_00: with these like fact,
- 54:54SPEAKER_00: fact,
- 54:54SPEAKER_00: fact,
- 54:54SPEAKER_00: fact,
- 54:54SPEAKER_00: fact,
- 54:55SPEAKER_00: fact,
- 54:56but with no weighting or appropriate judgment or assessment of
- 54:59those facts.
- 55:00So the fact-baked person is right off the bat totally
- 55:03overwhelmed and swamped like
- 55:04SPEAKER_00: a tsunami wave with like meaningless contextless facts.
- 55:08SPEAKER_01: Haven't you even read the 1974 report by NASA on atmospheric composition?
- 55:13Exactly and then the person whose fact base has to come back
- 55:18and be like no but
- 55:20that's not relevant to the point we're actually trying to make
- 55:22like that's not
- 55:22relevant to your truth claim and the end result is that there's
- 55:26just this constant
- 55:27informational asymmetry between a person who's grounded in fact
- 55:30and someone who can
- 55:32SPEAKER_00: just tsunami a person with either
- 55:36SPEAKER_00: meaningless or pointless facts or just making up shit all together.
- 55:40That's kind of the problem that we're dealing with the
- 55:42asymmetry between the
- 55:42SPEAKER_00: Federalist and the separatist side.
- 55:46SPEAKER_00: A Federalist can be like,
- 55:47SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 55:49SPEAKER_00: but if you want to set up your own country,
- 55:50SPEAKER_00: it's going to cost you X billion of dollars in military funding.
- 55:54SPEAKER_00: It's going to cost you X billion of dollars to set up your
- 55:57your consulate and your foreign service and it's going to cost
- 56:00you X billion of
- 56:01SPEAKER_00: dollars to do insurance programs or all of these sorts of things.
- 56:05These things aren't free and they're going to cost a really
- 56:09significant amount of
- 56:10SPEAKER_00: money and we're doing this on a much smaller tax base.
- 56:13A population of only 5 million people can only support so many
- 56:17of those services.
- 56:18That's before we get into the question of how you're going to
- 56:20get landlocked access.
- 56:21SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 56:22the trade negotiations are going to have to restart from
- 56:25scratch with both Canada
- 56:26SPEAKER_00: and the US don't guarantee you the same access that you have today.
- 56:30SPEAKER_00: So the size of your economy may not be the size that it is right now.
- 56:33Like we're playing in counterfactual spaces and the separatists
- 56:36can be like,
- 56:37no,
- 56:37it wouldn't.
- 56:40SPEAKER_00: The economy will be amazing.
- 56:41SPEAKER_01: This whole thing, Jen, is the onion.
- 56:43SPEAKER_00: Taxes will go in half.
- 56:45SPEAKER_01: This was 20 years ago, more than 20 years ago.
- 56:46SPEAKER_00: You don't have to pay anything to Quebec.
- 56:49in 2003 just before the Iraq invasion the onion ran a debate a
- 56:55point counterpoint
- 56:56and it was point invading Iraq will destabilize the entire
- 57:00Middle East embolden
- 57:01Iran and begin a generational cycle of chaos counterpoint no it
- 57:06won't that's yes
- 57:08SPEAKER_00: and that's and that's but as I said yes
- 57:10That puts the federal aside at this perpetual information
- 57:14disadvantage,
- 57:15right?
- 57:16SPEAKER_00: So how do we break through to that?
- 57:18And how do we get through to people's emotions in a way that is
- 57:22making them feel
- 57:22SPEAKER_00: heard and respected,
- 57:24SPEAKER_00: but at the same time as saying,
- 57:26SPEAKER_00: I get where you're coming from.
- 57:27SPEAKER_00: The problem isn't that I don't understand your feelings.
- 57:31The problem is that your solution to these problems is Kool-Aid
- 57:36spiked with cyanide.
- 57:37SPEAKER_00: Like,
- 57:39The situation is not like the status quo or some kind of utopic
- 57:48vision that fixes
- 57:49SPEAKER_00: all your problems.
- 57:51SPEAKER_00: The actual choices before us are like,
- 57:55SPEAKER_00: hey,
- 57:55we're going to have to continue to fight for our interests in a
- 57:59complicated
- 58:00SPEAKER_00: confederation and we're going to win some and we're going to lose some,
- 58:04SPEAKER_00: which is
- 58:05not necessarily emotionally satisfying but is reality or here's
- 58:11this fantasy that
- 58:13is actually just suicide and chaos and decline that's the
- 58:19dynamic that I think
- 58:21SPEAKER_00: rhetorically is a real challenge so look
- 58:25I think that the campaigns are just getting started I think
- 58:28also one of the major
- 58:29challenges that people who are in politics are struggling with
- 58:32in the current
- 58:32information space is that they're expecting there to be some
- 58:35kind of overarching
- 58:38federalist strategy committee that is deciding who's going to
- 58:42be taking what lane
- 58:43and who's going to be doing what messaging and who's going to
- 58:45be doing what and the
- 58:46SPEAKER_00: problem is no there won't
- 58:49SPEAKER_00: There is not going to be a federalist campaign strategy.
- 58:54SPEAKER_00: And the reason why that is,
- 58:55SPEAKER_00: is because the third party rules that exist in Canada,
- 58:58SPEAKER_00: in Alberta,
- 58:59SPEAKER_00: are chaos.
- 59:01SPEAKER_00: There can be no collusion between any two third party advertisers.
- 59:05so there literally can't be an overarching campaign strategist
- 59:11deciding how the
- 59:12federalists will marshal their forces there's going to be like
- 59:1520 different groups
- 59:17all trying to appeal to different target audiences according to
- 59:22what they think
- 59:22will work and there will be some like I think leaders so this
- 59:26vote to stay campaign
- 59:27which I'm involved in is going to be it's kind of
- 59:29conservative-ish coded but it's
- 59:31SPEAKER_00: pan-partisan
- 59:33And I think its job is going to be to try and create a
- 59:36permission structure for
- 59:38SPEAKER_00: Federalist Conservatives to feel like,
- 59:40SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 59:41SPEAKER_00: no,
- 59:41there is a rational sort of non-separatist response and a good
- 59:45reason to vote to
- 59:46SPEAKER_00: stay in Canada.
- 59:47SPEAKER_00: And very good reasons also to not leave Canada,
- 59:51SPEAKER_00: not vote to leave Canada,
- 59:53or there's very good reasons to not think that this will be a
- 59:56costless protest vote
- 59:58SPEAKER_00: that will,
- 59:58SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 59:59SPEAKER_00: stick it to Ottawa,
- 1:00:00SPEAKER_00: that this will do a lot more damage than it can possibly
- 1:00:03SPEAKER_00: the province.
- 1:00:05SPEAKER_00: There's a structure around that.
- 1:00:06SPEAKER_00: There's the Lead Not Leave campaign,
- 1:00:09SPEAKER_00: which I'm also involved in,
- 1:00:10SPEAKER_00: and that is not a third-party advertiser.
- 1:00:13SPEAKER_00: This is very much what I call lovingly, and lovingly, my nerd herd,
- 1:00:17These are people who are going to come up with policy proposals
- 1:00:20that will help
- 1:00:21SPEAKER_00: address some of Alberta's grievances in a really productive way.
- 1:00:24And it's modeled very much on the firewall letter of the early
- 1:00:272000s,
- 1:00:28right?
- 1:00:29Something that started to circulate around this year or this
- 1:00:32week was this article.
- 1:00:34SPEAKER_00: Dave Cornuier posted this article from 2003.
- 1:00:37where it was ralph klein going to his party at an agm and
- 1:00:40saying look i understand
- 1:00:42you're frustrated about the wheat board and i understand you're
- 1:00:44frustrated about
- 1:00:45the gun registry and i understand you're frustrated about the
- 1:00:47misrepresentation in
- 1:00:48the senate separatism solves none of these problems we're
- 1:00:51moving on and of course
- 1:00:5320 years later the wheat parts abolished the federal gun
- 1:00:55registry was abolished and
- 1:00:56you know i still think that the senate misrepresentation
- 1:00:59problem isn't really a
- 1:01:00problem um because i think that's kind of a nerd it's a nerd
- 1:01:03preoccupation
- 1:01:06But anyway the point being is that you know we have a track
- 1:01:08record of showing that
- 1:01:10over time if you put grievances on the table and provide
- 1:01:13productive ways forward
- 1:01:14and build coalitions and alliances within confederation and you
- 1:01:18know successfully
- 1:01:19win elections you can have those grievances seriously and
- 1:01:23meaningfully addressed
- 1:01:25you may not be able to have all of them perfectly addressed but
- 1:01:27you can make
- 1:01:27significant progress but no there's no there's no magic bullet
- 1:01:31there's not going to
- 1:01:31SPEAKER_00: be an instant solution but that's that's adult politics for you right
- 1:01:36um and then of course you've got a lot of progressive groups
- 1:01:38and and and you know i
- 1:01:40let the progressive groups do their thing i think their job is
- 1:01:42going to be really
- 1:01:42more about you know mobilizing their supporters and mobilizing
- 1:01:45the vote but yeah
- 1:01:46it's a very chaotic space it's much more american and in the
- 1:01:51way that um this is
- 1:01:52happening so in normally in a canadian context you have like
- 1:01:55campaign team versus
- 1:01:56campaign team choose your fighter this is a much more american
- 1:02:00style political
- 1:02:01SPEAKER_00: space now because it's it's
- 1:02:05SPEAKER_00: half dozen a dozen actors now all doing their own thing and not able to
- 1:02:10meaningfully coordinate with one another um so that's that's
- 1:02:15new that's new for a
- 1:02:16lot of a lot of Alberta political campaigners as well and that
- 1:02:20is Jen's two minute
- 1:02:21recap of this week's developments um sorry see I promise I told
- 1:02:28you I'm in the
- 1:02:29SPEAKER_00: a-hole I can't I can't see daylight anymore man I can't see I can't see
- 1:02:36I have two more specific questions um we neither of us has the
- 1:02:41time necessary to
- 1:02:42answer them both in 10 minutes each but some polling this week
- 1:02:46came out it was
- 1:02:46Ipsos our buddies there who uh showed that since the referendum
- 1:02:50was announced
- 1:02:51support for separatism has declined even when Ipsos was pulling
- 1:02:55on the specific
- 1:02:56referendum to have a referendum question the uh there was
- 1:03:00something like in the 20s
- 1:03:01SPEAKER_01: we're actually considering voting for this
- 1:03:05my up in the nosebleeds eating my popcorn looking at Alberta
- 1:03:10from afar like it's a
- 1:03:11sports game analysis has been so far the separatists have been
- 1:03:15better organized
- 1:03:16more animated bluntly more effective yeah they're winning the
- 1:03:19war I think so far
- 1:03:20yeah yeah and I think a lot of what Jen was just saying a
- 1:03:23minute ago is why I don't
- 1:03:25think it's that the separatists have suddenly gotten much
- 1:03:27better I think the
- 1:03:27SPEAKER_01: federal forces are disorganized and not led effectively
- 1:03:33Well and the point i'm trying to make here is like there's no
- 1:03:35way to lead the
- 1:03:36federalist which is effectively like there's there's there's no
- 1:03:39mechanism by which
- 1:03:39that can happen right why why could ipsos be capturing i don't
- 1:03:46know look i trust
- 1:03:47the ipsos guys there are buddies but you know weird polls
- 1:03:50happen those guys
- 1:03:51definitely they're great they're great polling firm i also
- 1:03:52don't read too much into
- 1:03:53SPEAKER_00: one single poll
- 1:03:55I need to see data over time in order to know what to have a
- 1:03:58sense of what's happening.
- 1:03:59And also I've seen other polls that suggest that the framing of
- 1:04:02the question has
- 1:04:03SPEAKER_00: actually increased the permission structure.
- 1:04:05It's increased the social permission structure for for a vote
- 1:04:08to leave vote.
- 1:04:08SPEAKER_00: And I've made this point before.
- 1:04:09SPEAKER_00: It's because if you can go into that,
- 1:04:11the ballot question isn't going to be should we stay or leave
- 1:04:14ballot question,
- 1:04:15SPEAKER_00: which is just to clarify for people who aren't aware.
- 1:04:18SPEAKER_00: There's the there's the physical question on the ballot.
- 1:04:21And then there's the question people have in their heads when
- 1:04:23they're writing what
- 1:04:24SPEAKER_00: they vote for,
- 1:04:24SPEAKER_00: okay?
- 1:04:25SPEAKER_00: The ballot question isn't the actual words on the ballot.
- 1:04:28The ballot question is what people are thinking when they
- 1:04:30choose to write that ballot.
- 1:04:31SPEAKER_00: So the way that this question is structured is,
- 1:04:34SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:04:36SPEAKER_00: basically,
- 1:04:36do you vote in favor of starting a process that will eventually
- 1:04:40lead to another
- 1:04:41SPEAKER_00: referendum?
- 1:04:42I think there's going to be the risk here is that a lot of
- 1:04:45people who would vote
- 1:04:46SPEAKER_00: against leaving Canada
- 1:04:47SPEAKER_00: are going to say, well, I'm not voting to leave Canada really.
- 1:04:51SPEAKER_00: The ballot question is whether or not I'm happy with the status quo.
- 1:04:54The ballot question is whether or not I want to send a message
- 1:04:58to Ottawa,
- 1:04:59right?
- 1:04:59SPEAKER_00: Like that's the ballot question.
- 1:05:01SPEAKER_00: And if that's the framework that they're going into,
- 1:05:04then I think we will have an artificially high result that
- 1:05:08suggests that there's
- 1:05:08SPEAKER_00: more support to leave the country than there actually is.
- 1:05:12SPEAKER_00: That is the fundamental risk.
- 1:05:13SPEAKER_00: Now, I don't know if that's the way it's actually going to go.
- 1:05:16But that's the risk and that's why it's so important especially
- 1:05:18for conservatives
- 1:05:19in this province a province that perceives itself as
- 1:05:22conservative to present a
- 1:05:24social permission structure that is different from that that's
- 1:05:27saying no no you can
- 1:05:28be conservative and still think that trying the knife to the
- 1:05:33throat strategy is
- 1:05:35really dangerous and more likely to cause damage to the
- 1:05:38province and the people in
- 1:05:39it than it can possibly gain than any concession can possibly
- 1:05:42gain as a result of
- 1:05:43SPEAKER_00: it.
- 1:05:44What I was wondering,
- 1:05:45Janet,
- 1:05:45I understand you're not going to have an answer to this.
- 1:05:48SPEAKER_01: Like this is a vibes question more than anything and time will tell.
- 1:05:51SPEAKER_01: But when I looked at the Ipsos results,
- 1:05:53SPEAKER_01: I was surprised because,
- 1:05:54SPEAKER_01: like I said,
- 1:05:55SPEAKER_01: I think the separatists have been more effective so far.
- 1:05:57SPEAKER_01: But I also thought to myself,
- 1:05:59you and I spent some time earlier in this podcast talking about
- 1:06:01the specific issue
- 1:06:02SPEAKER_01: that people in this country aren't good at saying no.
- 1:06:05and I wonder if a lot of people in Alberta are having a hard
- 1:06:08time saying no to
- 1:06:09their anti-Canadian friends but meanwhile they're thinking
- 1:06:13conservatively you know
- 1:06:14small c way they don't want to fuck up their jobs they don't
- 1:06:17want to fuck up their
- 1:06:18families they don't want to blow up the value of their
- 1:06:20businesses or their homes so
- 1:06:22they're oh yeah they're all oh yeah the the Easterners are
- 1:06:25milking the cow of the
- 1:06:27West yeah we're angry too but but they get a pollster on the
- 1:06:30phone hey do you plan
- 1:06:31SPEAKER_01: to leave no and I'm wondering if
- 1:06:37the notion of the silent majority is always a dangerous one but
- 1:06:41that's what I was
- 1:06:42wondering and I guess if we see other polls confirming it maybe
- 1:06:45there's some of
- 1:06:45that going on but also maybe the silent majority question is
- 1:06:49the flip no I know
- 1:06:51Right like maybe like 60% of Albertans are actually really
- 1:06:55totally willing to send
- 1:06:56a message to Ottawa but they're not going to confess that on a
- 1:06:58pollster to a
- 1:06:59SPEAKER_01: pollster.
- 1:07:00The other thing that I think that is also really interesting if
- 1:07:01you start looking
- 1:07:02at for example Brexit results and this is where you would
- 1:07:04probably need a data nerd
- 1:07:06SPEAKER_00: like my husband to talk to you a little bit about this.
- 1:07:08SPEAKER_01: We could find one.
- 1:07:10Yeah the I where would I find one of those in the basement um
- 1:07:12where he belongs in
- 1:07:14the windowless office downstairs where we keep him locked 12
- 1:07:17hours a day um
- 1:07:19managing the broken toys of his people um look uh if you look
- 1:07:24at the final results
- 1:07:25around Brexit it's that the polling got extremely volatile in
- 1:07:29the final like weeks
- 1:07:30and days of the vote so it went from being pretty steady pretty
- 1:07:33steady to go all
- 1:07:34over like totally different from one day to the next and that
- 1:07:36made that final vote
- 1:07:37SPEAKER_00: really really hard to predict um
- 1:07:40but what started to happen is as the volatility went up what my
- 1:07:44husband would call
- 1:07:44the social permission effect started to take effect so people
- 1:07:48who were like
- 1:07:49SPEAKER_00: I know that Brexit are the quote-unquote deplorables, but you know what?
- 1:07:54More people around me seem to be okay with thinking about
- 1:07:57voting for Brexit than I
- 1:07:59had previously thought because this poll result is showing
- 1:08:03really high support.
- 1:08:03So maybe my concerns about the EU are not as unique as I
- 1:08:08thought they were.
- 1:08:11SPEAKER_00: Once you start to see these sorts of really volatile polling results,
- 1:08:14SPEAKER_00: it can have a social permission effect on
- 1:08:17what were previously considered fairly fringe positions so
- 1:08:20that's another one of
- 1:08:20the risks that we have going into the what will eventually be
- 1:08:23the final days of of
- 1:08:25this particular vote like last question for you sorry yeah no
- 1:08:29no i will not i will
- 1:08:30not lean in on my husband's turf here on that that to that end
- 1:08:35i had texted you
- 1:08:35this a few days ago and you monster you did not respond so i'm
- 1:08:39bringing it up on
- 1:08:39SPEAKER_01: the podcast i shall have my answer
- 1:08:42immigration and not just immigration from outside of Canada but
- 1:08:46internal migration
- 1:08:47in Canada Alberta's been a net winner in recent years
- 1:08:50population has been growing
- 1:08:52and they're reframing that as a loss now but you know that's a
- 1:08:55little bit of
- 1:08:56revisionist history I know one of the truths in Canada and
- 1:09:04North America the
- 1:09:04western world generally is most population growth is in urban
- 1:09:08areas and the
- 1:09:10SPEAKER_01: countryside's been depopulating and
- 1:09:13And this is pretty much holding true almost everywhere,
- 1:09:16including in Alberta.
- 1:09:17SPEAKER_01: I spoke with you about a year, maybe a year and a half ago.
- 1:09:20I popped into Calgary for like a day because you and I had some
- 1:09:23meetings we had to do.
- 1:09:24And I noticed immediately just like a quick visual scan that
- 1:09:28Calgary was visibly
- 1:09:30SPEAKER_01: larger,
- 1:09:30SPEAKER_01: more crowded and also more diverse.
- 1:09:33what effect is that having on Alberta politics not even in
- 1:09:36terms of the referendum
- 1:09:37but just generally like what happens when you have increasingly
- 1:09:41moderate population
- 1:09:43centers in Calgary and Alberta surrounded by increasingly less
- 1:09:47populated and more
- 1:09:48conservative rural areas like that has got to be already
- 1:09:51skewing the politics
- 1:09:53Gerrymandering is what you're getting as a result of that so
- 1:09:57yeah there we could
- 1:09:58SPEAKER_00: get into that conversation at another day
- 1:10:02Yes,
- 1:10:03I do think that you have a sense of,
- 1:10:04look,
- 1:10:05separatism is concentrated in rural Alberta.
- 1:10:09SPEAKER_00: There's no question about that.
- 1:10:10SPEAKER_00: It is less popular in the cities than it is in rural Alberta.
- 1:10:13SPEAKER_00: Although that's not as hidebound as you would imagine.
- 1:10:18This is not like you leave Calgary city limits and all of a
- 1:10:22sudden you're in
- 1:10:23SPEAKER_00: independent Alberta territory.
- 1:10:25SPEAKER_00: I mean, rural populations themselves are complicated and diverse as well.
- 1:10:30SPEAKER_00: And it's not like you go into my neighborhood in suburban Calgary and,
- 1:10:34SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:10:35SPEAKER_00: people started putting up Alberta flags.
- 1:10:37SPEAKER_00: We all know what that means now.
- 1:10:41SPEAKER_00: So it's more porous than you might think.
- 1:10:43SPEAKER_00: But I do think that part of what's fueling this,
- 1:10:47SPEAKER_00: and maybe there's a part of Kippicoke analogy too,
- 1:10:50is a sense of threat or loss of way of life that had become
- 1:10:58entrenched in rural
- 1:10:58SPEAKER_00: Alberta
- 1:11:00SPEAKER_00: And this is a kind of counter reaction or backlash to that as well.
- 1:11:03SPEAKER_00: I think that that's probably a factor here as well.
- 1:11:06SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 1:11:06if your kids are moving to the city or they're moving to other
- 1:11:09parts of the
- 1:11:09SPEAKER_00: country,
- 1:11:10SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:11:10you're starting to see your small town you've grown up in
- 1:11:13depopulate or get
- 1:11:14SPEAKER_00: smaller,
- 1:11:15SPEAKER_00: the opportunities just aren't there anymore.
- 1:11:18SPEAKER_00: And then you're looking around the rest of the country and you're like,
- 1:11:20SPEAKER_00: well,
- 1:11:21SPEAKER_00: this place is getting real broke real fast.
- 1:11:26SPEAKER_00: You can see how the idea of retrenchment,
- 1:11:30SPEAKER_00: bring the walls down,
- 1:11:32SPEAKER_00: gain more control over my life,
- 1:11:34SPEAKER_00: bring autonomy back,
- 1:11:35SPEAKER_00: bring sovereignty back to my life.
- 1:11:37SPEAKER_00: It's a response to a feeling of loss of control.
- 1:11:40SPEAKER_00: I can understand that.
- 1:11:42SPEAKER_00: So I think it's a factor.
- 1:11:44Like you talked to your husband again about Brexit and you
- 1:11:46would hear a lot of that.
- 1:11:48Yeah.
- 1:11:49SPEAKER_00: People feel like they've lost control.
- 1:11:50SPEAKER_01: I think people feel like they've lost control of their lives.
- 1:11:53SPEAKER_00: I think that's part of it.
- 1:11:55SPEAKER_01: Sorry, I was talking over there.
- 1:11:57SPEAKER_01: What was that, Jen?
- 1:11:57I think some people,
- 1:11:59a lot of people are feeling like they've lost control over
- 1:12:01their lives.
- 1:12:02SPEAKER_00: And a lot of our politics is being dominated by that.
- 1:12:08SPEAKER_01: You are so depressingly right, I don't even want to think about it.
- 1:12:13SPEAKER_00: But it's not like as an urban cosmopolitan elite Calgarian.
- 1:12:18SPEAKER_00: It's not like I have any more control over my life, guys.
- 1:12:22SPEAKER_01: No, you know what, Jen?
- 1:12:23What it comes down to,
- 1:12:23honestly,
- 1:12:24the future at least looks somewhat recognizable to you.
- 1:12:27SPEAKER_00: Yeah, that's right.
- 1:12:28SPEAKER_00: I think that's right.
- 1:12:29I have some sense of agency and control over my life in a way
- 1:12:33that a lot of people
- 1:12:34in the provinces who have latched onto this is like the savior
- 1:12:38for their concerns.
- 1:12:40SPEAKER_00: I would not
- 1:13:11SPEAKER_00: But my duty is to tell you the truth.
- 1:13:12SPEAKER_00: And when I tell you that this isn't going to solve any of your problems,
- 1:13:17SPEAKER_00: eight years away from Brexit,
- 1:13:18SPEAKER_00: this only made everything worse for people.
- 1:13:21They got their feelings about their loss of control out through
- 1:13:24the ballot box.
- 1:13:25SPEAKER_00: And eight years later, everything is a little bit worse for them.
- 1:13:29What we're playing with here with separatism is much,
- 1:13:32much worse than Brexit,
- 1:13:34right?
- 1:13:35SPEAKER_00: You're courting a kind of hyper-polarized politics
- 1:13:40SPEAKER_00: that not only can't solve your problems and isn't productive,
- 1:13:43that will only make all of the problems that led you to this
- 1:13:46place of desperation
- 1:13:48SPEAKER_00: worse.
- 1:13:50SPEAKER_01: And I can only tell you that that's what I believe to be true.
- 1:13:53SPEAKER_00: And you can look at me and be like,
- 1:13:54SPEAKER_00: well,
- 1:13:55she's an elitist cosmopolitan Calgary bitch who's been
- 1:13:58colonized by the East.
- 1:14:00SPEAKER_00: And I'd be like, okay, that may be true.
- 1:14:02But i still believe that this is true and like i one of the
- 1:14:06reasons why i'm
- 1:14:06SPEAKER_00: fighting so hard against the the separatist stuff and why i think it's so
- 1:14:10pernicious is because i think it's going to hurt people like
- 1:14:14you and i think it's
- 1:14:16going to lead people good good people down a really dangerous
- 1:14:20path that will
- 1:14:21SPEAKER_00: eventually get them hurt and
- 1:14:25I do have the luxury of leaving I don't want to but I do have
- 1:14:29that luxury and a lot
- 1:14:30of people aren't going to have that luxury and that's why it's
- 1:14:34so important to be
- 1:14:35like I need I think you need to be told an honest thing by
- 1:14:38someone who has no
- 1:14:39material benefit in leading you down the garden path I'm sure
- 1:14:46they're going to be
- 1:14:46really grateful Well no they're going to hate me for it and I
- 1:14:49understand that
- 1:14:50they're going to hate me for it I understand they're going to
- 1:14:52be angry and they're
- 1:14:53SPEAKER_00: going to hate me for it but that doesn't change my duty
- 1:14:56anyone and Jen answer this in 10 seconds is anyone seriously
- 1:14:59talking about Calgary
- 1:15:00and Edmonton separating from the Republic of Alberta if it
- 1:15:03separates from Canada
- 1:15:04it's that's the hilarious thing is that I mean Howard Englund
- 1:15:06made this point he's
- 1:15:07like well look if a province is divisible once then it's
- 1:15:10divisible twice then it's
- 1:15:11divisible three times like are is the are the northern oil I
- 1:15:15mean I had this
- 1:15:15conversation back in Ottawa earlier this week with someone
- 1:15:18whose name I won't
- 1:15:19SPEAKER_00: mention because I don't want to put her in risk but
- 1:15:22is northern alberta the oil sands regions going to vote to
- 1:15:25separate are you so sure
- 1:15:26i honestly have no idea you well i know i don't think anybody
- 1:15:31does and what like
- 1:15:32what if northern alberta is like yeah i don't i don't what if
- 1:15:35the oil producing
- 1:15:36regions are like we're not we don't want this where does that
- 1:15:40leave southern
- 1:15:40alberta where does it leave calgary like it's so canada keeps
- 1:15:43the oil edmonton and
- 1:15:44SPEAKER_01: alberta okay sorry calgary edmonton and the oil hmm
- 1:15:49You want to start playing the divide and conquer game,
- 1:15:54that's where this could go,
- 1:15:55right?
- 1:15:56So where are all your economic assessments and all your rosy
- 1:16:00economic pictures if
- 1:16:01SPEAKER_00: you don't have the oil regions,
- 1:16:03SPEAKER_00: much less treaty lands?
- 1:16:05Plus all the federal assets in Alberta,
- 1:16:07which is probably about 10% of the land area.
- 1:16:09SPEAKER_00: Well,
- 1:16:10SPEAKER_00: and even if they bought the federal assets,
- 1:16:11SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 1:16:11SPEAKER_00: so now you're in debt,
- 1:16:12SPEAKER_00: now you're in hock.
- 1:16:13SPEAKER_00: I mean, like I said, you just start opening up
- 1:16:16We'll wrap it up now but i did send you something this week
- 1:16:20that i thought was
- 1:16:21SPEAKER_00: funny and uh quebec support for quebec separations dropping
- 1:16:36maybe maybe we're making it drop maybe like we're making
- 1:16:38separatism look so bad
- 1:16:40that they're like oh Quebecers are looking at that and going ah
- 1:16:45you know what
- 1:16:46actually maybe maybe not yeah god did did we look like that was
- 1:16:52that us yeah it was
- 1:16:55okay okay well okay okay things are weird but that's things are
- 1:17:01super weird um
- 1:17:02SPEAKER_01: Just a very quick programming note.
- 1:17:04SPEAKER_01: We're not running a dispatch this weekend.
- 1:17:06SPEAKER_01: We do have something special coming out tomorrow though.
- 1:17:08Tomorrow is a major anniversary and we have an article we'll be
- 1:17:11releasing tomorrow.
- 1:17:12SPEAKER_01: So we hope people look forward to that.
- 1:17:13SPEAKER_01: Other than that, Jen, I got nothing else.
- 1:17:15SPEAKER_01: Do you?
- 1:17:16SPEAKER_00: All right.
- 1:17:16SPEAKER_00: We got something really fun coming on Monday as well.
- 1:17:18SPEAKER_00: So,
- 1:17:19SPEAKER_00: oh,
- 1:17:19and I'm going to write a column about how I think that Mark
- 1:17:21Carney's meanness is
- 1:17:23SPEAKER_00: part of his appeal.
- 1:17:25And I say that without any kind of endorsement of anything he's
- 1:17:28done in government.
- 1:17:29SPEAKER_01: I might bake a pie that has nothing to do with the line or our audience,
- 1:17:34SPEAKER_01: but I'm just thinking for the weekend I might bake a pie.
- 1:17:37SPEAKER_00: There you go.
- 1:17:37SPEAKER_00: And that, no, we've already gone over long again.
- 1:17:39SPEAKER_00: So sorry about that.
- 1:17:39SPEAKER_00: And thanks for sticking with us.
- 1:17:41SPEAKER_00: www.readtheline.ca Like, and subscribe.