Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul Podcast #7 - How Do We Interpret the Constitution?
Transcript
- 0:00Time for another episode of the politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Reeder.
- 0:04Now last week, we talked about a potential 28th amendment to the constitution and what that
- 0:09would look like, so we're gonna stick with the constitution this week.
- 0:13So when a government official in the US is sworn in to take a new office or they are
- 0:19taking the same office for a new term, they take an oath in which they vow with some
- 0:24differences in how it's worded, to uphold and protect the US constitution.
- 0:29Same thing with the military, and it's not just federal level officials.
- 0:33The state and local level officials do it as well, with state officials also vowing to
- 0:39uphold these state constitutions.
- 0:41But we've seen time and time again that in these political battles and in various
- 0:47lawsuits, these various interpretations of constitutional law by political personalities
- 0:53like candidates, campaign officials, appointed officials, basically anybody involved with
- 0:59politics.
- 1:00So
- 1:01we all have these different concepts of what the constitution says and means, but we all
- 1:07swear to uphold it.
- 1:09So how exactly do we determine what the constitution says and what it means?
- 1:14How do we interpret it?
- 1:17Well, that has been a debate since the, really, since the beginning.
- 1:22We've had the debate over what are
- 1:24called enumerated versus implied powers ever since the early days, enumerated meaning that
- 1:33it's specifically, explicitly laid out in the constitution, and implied being that it's only
- 1:39inferred.
- 1:40Federalists often refer to implied powers, while democratic republicans who were born out
- 1:46of antifederalists who initially were in opposition to the US constitution because they
- 1:53still wanted to stick with the articles of confederation back then, they their focus was
- 1:59solely on enumerated powers.
- 2:01They thought that these implied powers would lead to a federal government being unchecked,
- 2:06whereas federalists, they saw it as these implied powers were needed to have a robust
- 2:11federal government that could respond to certain issues that
- 2:16maybe these enumerated powers would not always be able to address.
- 2:23Now as for how vague, for lack of
- 2:27a better term, this or the US constitution is, it's far less specific and wordy than a lot of
- 2:34these state constitutions are, really pretty much every one of them.
- 2:37State constitutions are a lot more specific in what they address, whereas the constitution is
- 2:42something like, I believe, 8,000, 9,000 words.
- 2:47It's far less specific and wordy than state constitutions are.
- 2:50Now some some parts are pretty clear and defined.
- 2:53Like, for example, the constitution clearly states that we get 2 senators per state, 2 US
- 3:00senators per state, and lifetime terms for supreme court judges.
- 3:05But there's also some of the more ambiguous pieces like what's called the necessary and
- 3:11proper clause for congress to make laws that are basically necessary and proper for the
- 3:16government to carry out function.
- 3:18What does that mean?
- 3:19That's one of those things that has been, debated for a long time, specifically to make
- 3:25all laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into execution the foregoing
- 3:30powers, etcetera, etcetera.
- 3:33Again, what that exactly means, that's that's been debated.
- 3:37And then there's somewhat vague clauses in the constitution where there's there's some level
- 3:43of definition, but what exactly falls under that purview is not always as clear.
- 3:50For example, the interstate commerce clause.
- 3:52So the federal government has the power to regulate interstate commerce, so commerce
- 3:59between one state and another.
- 4:02What falls under interstate commerce is a little a little bit unclear.
- 4:07It was, in fact, the subject of a major I'm drawing a blank on what the case was, but there
- 4:15was a major case, in the 19 thirties when FDR was president, one of his new deal acts.
- 4:22The argument was that it regulated interstate commerce, and the supreme court ruled it was
- 4:28not interstate commerce and drawing a blank on which case that was.
- 4:33But, anyways, interstate commerce is a lot
- 4:36of times, it's it's pretty well defined, but in other times, there might be a little bit of
- 4:41argument as to what is commerce between one state or another.
- 4:45And then, of course, congress can regulate trade between the US and their countries.
- 4:51Now another part of that enumerated versus implied powers debate back in the early days of
- 4:57the nation is we see it in the bill of rights.
- 5:01So federalists believe that the first ten amendments of the constitution, they were
- 5:07basically already part of the US constitution, while anti federalists who later became
- 5:12Democratic Republicans didn't see it that way.
- 5:15And as sort of a compromise, the bill of rights was ratified a couple of years after the US
- 5:19constitution.
- 5:20US constitution was fully ratified in 17/89.
- 5:23The bill of rights are officially added to the US constitution in 17/91.
- 5:30And then part of that bill of rights is the 9th 10th amendments, 9th amendment being rights not
- 5:37expressed in the constitution and reserved to the people.
- 5:40So just because it's not stated in the constitution does not mean that people do not
- 5:44get those rights.
- 5:45And then the 10th amendment is where powers not given to the federal government belong to the
- 5:50states, and those 2 are also subject of debate as to what rights are under the purview of the
- 5:599th Amendment, what powers are under the purview of
- 6:02the 10th Amendment.
- 6:04It's one of
- 6:04those many arguments and debates going on about what the constitution explicitly says and what
- 6:11it is implying or if it even infers anything in the first place.
- 6:17So there are 3 branches of government.
- 6:19There's the executive, there's the legislative, and the judicial.
- 6:22And the judicial branch is tasked with interpreting the constitution, but it was not
- 6:26always like that.
- 6:27It wasn't until the Marbury versus Madison case in 1803 where chief justice John Marshall
- 6:33established SCOTUS' power, supreme court being SCOTUS for short, the power of judicial review
- 6:40for the supreme court.
- 6:43Price's case, SCOTUS was not actually given the power to the authority to interpret the
- 6:49constitution.
- 6:50And another early issue was whether the bill of rights applied to state governments.
- 6:56Early on, the bill of rights was actually only considered to be applicable to the federal
- 7:00government.
- 7:00The responsibility of such rights against state governments were that was delegated to the
- 7:06states, and it was the state's responsibility to incorporate that in their own constitutions.
- 7:12But the impetus for this change on this front was really the ratification of the 14th
- 7:16amendment, specifically the due process clause.
- 7:20And from that, we get the it's called the incorporation doctrine.
- 7:23So due process clause imposes the bill of rights.
- 7:28Limitate the limitations from the bill of rights on the federal government, those same
- 7:32limitations are imposed on the state governments as well in terms of what rights
- 7:36people have.
- 7:38So now you go more to the present day, and you have several different labels for these
- 7:44philosophies on interpreting the constitution.
- 7:46People might not necessarily use these specific labels, but they're pretty common.
- 7:50Some people might use something similar.
- 7:52Like, typically, you get either originalism or you get living constitutionalism.
- 7:59And a bit of a of an oversimplified definition, but originalism, it tends to be, conservative
- 8:07judges tend to lean more to the originalism side, and it's more of a interpreting the
- 8:12constitution in the context of the framers' time.
- 8:16Now even that is not necessarily agreed upon by originalists.
- 8:19There are there's a subgroup called the textualists, which interpret the constitution
- 8:24based strictly on how it's written regardless of its intentions.
- 8:27For a lot of originalists, they look at it as, what is the intention of the founding fathers
- 8:34in term or or, excuse me, rather, the framers of the constitution, because not all the
- 8:39framers or not all the founding fathers were framers of the constitution.
- 8:42Some of the founding fathers, like Patrick Henry, were actually against the US
- 8:46constitution and, at least initially, wanted to stick with the articles of Confederation.
- 8:51Some originalists are textualists where they don't even consider what the framers'
- 8:57intentions may or may not have been.
- 8:59They specifically, strictly just how was it written.
- 9:03That's what we gotta go by.
- 9:06And on the flip side, you have the living constitutionalist.
- 9:09So those tend to be more liberal judges.
- 9:12And for them, the constitution's meaning changes with different eras of US history.
- 9:19Now when it comes to these political debates, you often hear the term judicial activism that
- 9:24tends to have negative connotations, really just used by one side of the aisle against the
- 9:29other to describe actions, that's for whatever reason, they think that it's outside of the
- 9:36bounds of what the court is allowed to do.
- 9:40So maybe the two sides have completely different interpretations of a constitutional
- 9:44provision or because SCOTUS overturned one of its previous rulings.
- 9:49And that's happened in 236 cases as of September 2024, 20 2 constitution dot congress
- 9:56dot gov.
- 9:57So you hear it a lot from conservatives against liberal rulings, but you've also heard it from
- 10:04liberals against conservative rulings.
- 10:06So with conservatives calling more liberal rulings judicial activist rulings, one example
- 10:13would be the Obergefell versus Hodges case from 2015, which which, ruled that same sex marriage
- 10:23is protected by the constitution.
- 10:26For a lot of conservatives, they said that the court applying the 14th amendment's equal
- 10:31protection clause to same sex marriage was judicial activism because the amendment had
- 10:35nothing to do with it.
- 10:37The intention of the 14th Amendment was not to be applied to same sex marriage, and at least
- 10:43in the conservative view, in the originalist view.
- 10:46And conservatives will also argue that it contradicts the 10th amendment because it
- 10:51infringes on the power of states to regulate same sex marriage.
- 10:55Again, that's just what conservatives are saying about liberals.
- 10:58For liberals who see certain conservative rulings as
- 11:05judicial activism, you saw it
- 11:08particularly with the Dobbs versus Jackson Women's Health Organization.
- 11:12That was the court case which reversed the Roe v Wade ruling.
- 11:17So Roe v Wade established the according to the ruling there, Roe v Wade in 1973 dictated that
- 11:25the that there was a constitutional right to abortion that was protected by the US
- 11:30constitution, but the Dobbs ruling that reversed it and said that abortion was not a
- 11:35constitutional right.
- 11:36So for liberal judges or people with a more liberal philosophy, a living constitutionalist
- 11:43philosophy, they saw that as judicial activism because these judges in their eyes, these
- 11:51judges went out of their way to overturn a precedent that had been set for the time almost
- 11:5750 years.
- 11:58And they would also argue that it goes the against the equal protection clause of the 14th
- 12:03amendment because that would allow states or because of the ability for states to ban
- 12:09abortion that is infringing upon the equal protection that women would get.
- 12:14Again, that's just what liberals would say against conservatives.
- 12:19Not saying one way or the other on either one of these cases, it's correct or not correct.
- 12:25It's just how a lot of them see it.
- 12:27But in the case of Roe v Wade, that's not the only major court case where SCOTUS has changed
- 12:31its interpretation of laws or reversed precedent before.
- 12:35Like I said before, there's at least 236 cases where that's happened.
- 12:39So besides that Roe v Wade ruling, one of the other really big instances was, in a way, it
- 12:44was kind of actually reversing precedent twice.
- 12:48So in the case of racial inequality, we had the Dredskin versus Sanford case in 1857, which, at
- 12:55the time, slavery was legal, and slaves were considered property and did not have
- 13:00citizenship, and they didn't have any of those rights that were afforded to free people.
- 13:07Then you get to Plessy versus Ferguson case in 18 96, which
- 13:12takes doesn't totally reverse it.
- 13:15They in the ruling, the idea, at least according to the judges, was that separate
- 13:21facilities, segregation was legal as long as these, facilities were equal, the whole
- 13:29separate but equal doctrine.
- 13:31Then Brown versus Board of Education in 18/54 completely overturns that and says, separation
- 13:37of facilities for blacks and whites is inherently unequal, and segregation
- 13:44is therefore unconstitutional.
- 13:46And then one more particularly big case was, with Chevron USA versus Natural Resources
- 13:53Defense Council in 1984.
- 13:55It was kind of overturned by 2 cases actually
- 13:58earlier this year in January 2024.
- 14:03Back then or prior to these 2024 rulings, there was what we had what we call the Chevron
- 14:09Deference, where federal courts deferred to
- 14:12a federal agency's interpretation of an ambiguous or unclear statute that congress
- 14:18delegated to that agency to administer.
- 14:21The Loper Bright Enterprises versus Raimondo case and the Relentless Incorporated versus
- 14:27Department of Commerce case.
- 14:29The rulings there overturned the Chevron deference.
- 14:33So you have a couple of those cases of originalism versus living constitutionalism
- 14:39there, butting heads.
- 14:40Now that's not
- 14:41to say that there aren't degrees of originalism and living constitutionalism, but if we're
- 14:46talking in general, the basic philosophies going against each other like that,
- 14:52originalism, more of the conservative,
- 14:57what was the intention of the framers back in their time, or even a step further, textualist
- 15:03saying just specifically what the constitution says.
- 15:07Living constitutionalists, the meaning of the constitution changes over time.
- 15:13So what would some of these originalists and living constitutionalists say about their
- 15:17particular viewpoints?
- 15:18Couple of the major arguments you would hear.
- 15:20So for originalists, this the idea is that it's reducing judges wanting to impose their
- 15:25personal values on the law.
- 15:27To them, they're saying, well, we just gotta say we gotta look at it and what the framers
- 15:31intended.
- 15:32We can't have judges or in their case in their eyes, judicial activists dictating what the
- 15:39constitution says.
- 15:41They would also say, if you don't even have a basic unchanging meaning of the constitution,
- 15:46What's the point of even having a constitution?
- 15:48There has to be some sort of foundational meaning to what the constitution says.
- 15:53And if they really wanna change the meaning of the constitution, then it should be left
- 15:58to the people to amend the constitution if that's what's needed.
- 16:05And we've seen the constitution amended 27 times over the course of over 230 years.
- 16:12Living constitutionalists, on the other hand, would say that you have to account for the
- 16:16changing times from the framers because they could not have predicted a lot of these issues
- 16:22that we have today, issues of today.
- 16:24A lot of them are much different than those of the framers' time.
- 16:28And the framers were an eclectic group with different viewpoints, and it's difficult if not
- 16:33impossible to fully determine what their intentions were.
- 16:38A lot of time, a lot of aspects of the constitution they didn't even agree on.
- 16:43It's really one giant compromise.
- 16:46And to them, originalism loses sight of the bigger picture, and it doesn't let judges
- 16:50prevent potential legal crises that come from inflexible interpretations of the constitution.
- 16:56So which one is right?
- 16:58Obviously, that's for you to decide, but that's just the basic idea between originalists and
- 17:05living constitutionalists.
- 17:06And then whenever you hear the term judicial activism, there's not really gonna be a whole
- 17:11lot of people that actually describe themselves as such, but that's usually more of a negative
- 17:18label that either originalists apply to judicial or excuse me.
- 17:23Originalists apply to living constitutionalists, and living
- 17:26constitutionalists may apply to originalists
- 17:28if they try to overturn precedence, such as with the Roe v Wade, case.
- 17:34So just something to think about whenever you hear the term judicial activism.
- 17:40But that does it for today's episode.
- 17:43Get a basic give you
- 17:44a basic sense of what these judicial philosophies are.
- 17:48And, really, it's it's been a been an argument, a debate ever since the constitution was
- 17:55ratified.
- 17:56So with that, we're gonna end off with the random question of the day.
- 18:02And today's random question is, do you subscribe to the shopping cart theory?
- 18:07So if you don't know what the shopping cart theory is, it's basically the idea of if you
- 18:12are at the grocery store or supermarket or any sort of market where you have a shopping cart
- 18:18and nobody is there around to criticize you, would you just leave your shopping cart where
- 18:25it is in a, like, in a parking space, for example, or would you actually walk over to
- 18:29place it in a shopping cart return?
- 18:32And I gotta tell you, I have never worked in retail or for, like, grocery stores or anything
- 18:38like that.
- 18:39And it drives me up a wall anytime I see somebody do that.
- 18:43It's just
- 18:45unbelievably lazy.
- 18:46Just return your cart to it it takes
- 18:49a lot for me to not say anything.
- 18:52And I actually one time had somebody who whistled to me, did not even say, hey.
- 18:57Can you take this, card back?
- 19:00And I've never worked in retail, and I wasn't even dressed like I was working there.
- 19:04And he just threw the or shoved the card towards me and said thank you after.
- 19:08It's like, you know, you could actually ask if if I could put it there.
- 19:11If you asked, I
- 19:12would've yeah.
- 19:12Sure.
- 19:13I would've done it.
- 19:14But, to assume that I
- 19:16was gonna do that, it's it's just one of those one of those things that's just exceedingly
- 19:21annoying.
- 19:22Just put the cart there.
- 19:24Just make the cart returner's job a little easier.
- 19:27You don't have to take
- 19:28it all the way back to the store.
- 19:30No.
- 19:31Put it in a shopping cart return.
- 19:34But I think constitutionalists and living originalists can agree on that at least,
- 19:41hopefully.
- 19:42But, anyways, that's gonna do it
- 19:43for this episode.
- 19:44Once again, as always, thank you so much for listening.
- 19:48Like, comment, subscribe, and share the video with with all your friends and your network.
- 19:53You can follow me on Facebook at Paul Raider, comma, author and speaker.
- 19:57My website, paulrader.org.
- 20:00My LinkedIn profile, which is simply just Paul Raider.
- 20:04My podcast, obviously, as well.
- 20:08And, I also have a book out.
- 20:10It's been out for a few years now called Why Independents Rarely Win Elections and How They
- 20:14Could Become More Competitive.
- 20:16Get that on Amazon at ebook and paperback format.
- 20:19But other than that, I think that does it for today.
- 20:22So hopefully, this shed a little bit of light on one of the many, many political debates of
- 20:28our time that really has been around since since the very beginning of this, country.
- 20:33So with that all said, until next time.
- 20:37Take care.