Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Underwritten IPOs Are Fading for Tech Companies
Transcript
- Lucas: So Palantir is up about one point three percent over the past five days, trading around one hundred thirty-seven bucks. Airbnb is down one and a half. Shopify basically flat. And I think the story behind those three tickers tells you everything about the state of tech IPOs in late May 2026. Luna: How so? Because they all went public in different ways — Palantir via direct listing, Airbnb via traditional IPO, Shopify was already public but had a secondary offering. They're like a museum of capital markets approaches. Lucas: Exactly. And the market is now basically telling us which model works. But before we get into that — if these conversations around capital markets and company-building are useful for what you're running or building, we keep this whole show ad-free thanks to listener support. You can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small thing that keeps us independent. Anyway — back to the data. Luna: Yeah, agreed. So let's talk about the big shift we're seeing. The ClickUp news this morning — mass layoffs — that's not directly an IPO story, but it's connected. Lucas: Right. ClickUp raised a ton of private capital at high valuations. Now they're cutting staff. That's the pattern we've seen from a lot of late-stage software companies that were planning IPOs in 2024 or 2025 and then pulled back. The public markets are not welcoming unprofitable growth stories the way they were in 2021. Luna: And ClickUp is a good example because they were a high-flying productivity software company. They had a big valuation, they were considered a candidate to go public. But the window closed. Lucas: It's not that the window closed entirely — it's that the underwriting model broke. The traditional IPO relies on investment banks pricing the deal, allocating shares to institutional clients, and then the stock pops on day one. That pop is basically money left on the table for the company. Direct listings like Palantir and Spotify eliminated that. Luna: But direct listings have their own challenges. You don't raise new capital, and there's no underwriter to stabilize the stock. For a company that needs cash, it's not an option. Lucas: That's true. And that's why we've seen the rise of the 'direct listing with a capital raise' — the SEC approved that in 2020. So companies can now sell new shares directly on the open market without an underwriter. It's still not as common, but it's growing. Luna: Let's look at the numbers. Palantir's stock is up over the past five days. Airbnb is down. Is that just noise, or does it reflect something about how the market views their capital market choices? Lucas: I think it's more than noise. Palantir's direct listing meant early investors and employees could sell immediately, and the price discovery was more organic. Airbnb's IPO was priced at sixty-eight dollars, it popped to one hundred forty-four on day one, and then it spent the next two years drifting. That initial pop was a signal that the banks underpriced the deal. Luna: Which is great for the banks' hedge fund clients who got the allocation, but bad for the company that left money on the table. Lucas: Exactly. And now companies are saying, why should we give that value to your clients? We can do it ourselves. The ClickUp news is interesting because they were reportedly considering a traditional IPO. But after seeing the aftermarket performance of companies like Instacart and Arm — which had modest pops and then struggled — they probably decided the juice isn't worth the squeeze. Luna: So what's the alternative for a company like ClickUp? Stay private longer? Sell to a larger company? Or do a SPAC? Lucas: SPACs had their moment in 2020 and 2021, but the regulatory scrutiny and the poor performance of many SPAC mergers has cooled that market significantly. I think we're going to see more companies using the secondary markets — like Forge or EquityZen — to let employees and early investors cash out without a full IPO. That's a quieter path, but it's growing. Luna: It's almost a private IPO. You get liquidity, but you don't have to deal with quarterly earnings calls and analyst scrutiny. Lucas: Right. And that's appealing for companies that are profitable but don't want to be public. But the trade-off is that your valuation is less transparent, and you don't have a public currency for acquisitions. So it's not a perfect solution. Luna: Let's bring it back to the data. You mentioned Shopify and Palantir and Airbnb. If you were advising a tech CEO today, what would you tell them about going public? Lucas: I'd say: if you can do a direct listing, do it. If you need to raise capital, consider a direct listing with a capital raise or a traditional IPO but negotiate hard on the price range. And if you're not ready for the scrutiny, stay private and use secondary markets. The one-size-fits-all underwritten IPO is becoming an artifact of a previous era. Luna: And that's a big structural change. For decades, the investment banks controlled the gateway to public markets. Now that gateway is being dismantled. Lucas: Yeah. And the data backs it up. In 2021, about fifteen percent of tech IPOs were direct listings. By 2025, that number was closer to thirty percent. And I expect it to keep rising. The banks are losing their grip. Luna: What about the role of retail investors? In a direct listing, retail can participate from day one. In a traditional IPO, they're usually locked out until the stock starts trading. Lucas: That's a key point. Retail investors have been increasingly vocal about wanting equal access. And companies are listening. When you see a stock like Reddit — which went public via traditional IPO but allocated a portion to its users — that's a hybrid model. I think we'll see more of that. Luna: So the future of tech IPOs is fragmented. No single model dominates. Lucas: Exactly. And that's healthy. Companies should have options. The market is evolving to fit the needs of companies, not the other way around. And that's a good thing for innovation. Luna: Alright, so to wrap up: ClickUp's layoffs are a symptom of a broader trend. The traditional IPO is on life support. Direct listings and secondary markets are the new normal. And retail investors are getting a seat at the table. Lucas: Yeah. And one number to keep an eye on: the percentage of tech IPOs that are direct listings. If it crosses fifty percent in the next couple of years, that's a definitive shift. We'll be watching.