Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / Does Christmas End at the Manger or Is It Just the Beginning?
Transcript
- 0:01Coming up on the Together for Good podcast.
- 0:03Christmas isn't even over yet, but I want to talk about how
- 0:06Christmas continues. Do I have your attention yet?
- 0:11Can't wait. Here we go.
- 0:12Welcome to the Together for Good podcast, a podcast created by
- 0:16Bethany Lutheran Church in Cherry Hills Village, Co and
- 0:19hosted by me, Pastor Nate Pricinger and Together for Good.
- 0:23Our goal is to provide practical, engaging content that
- 0:27supports you without expectations.
- 0:29Whether you're feeling disconnected from traditional
- 0:32religion or simply exploring what faith means in your life,
- 0:35we are here to walk alongside you.
- 0:38No matter where you are on your journey of faith, we're glad
- 0:41you're here. Welcome to Together for good.
- 0:44OK, here's my thesis statement. The Manger wasn't an ending, it
- 0:49was the beginning of a movement. How do you like that?
- 0:54We're not even at Christmas yet, but we're looking ahead and
- 0:57we're preparing our hearts and our minds for this great
- 1:00holiday. But we need to talk about the
- 1:02theological implications of what's happening on Christmas.
- 1:06Let's start there. There's a fancy word called the
- 1:09incarnation. Incarnate, become flesh in
- 1:14fleshed. This is what we're celebrating,
- 1:16is God becoming a human being in the person of Jesus.
- 1:21It's a really bold claim to think that we're saying that the
- 1:26divine, eternal, infinite God took on finitude and temporality
- 1:33and a human body. But that's what Christmas is all
- 1:37about, Charlie Brown. It's not about presents or any
- 1:41of that. It's about presents and in the
- 1:45sense of God with us. I know that's really clever and
- 1:48funny. You can laugh about this as
- 1:50you're listening or spit out your coffee has some of you do
- 1:53while you listen to the podcast. But what I want to really think
- 1:57about is this idea of the incarnation and why it's so
- 2:00significant, because it because it really does matter for
- 2:04everything else that follows within Christianity.
- 2:07If God has become a human being, then that means that the divine
- 2:11infinite, eternal creator of the universe has come up against and
- 2:17is encountering real human life, means that Jesus knows what
- 2:23you're going through. Maybe not exactly the situation,
- 2:27but the emotions that accompany whatever difficulty you're
- 2:31facing. Jesus has experienced those two.
- 2:35And so even those strange, awful emotions of of grief or feeling
- 2:40betrayed or feeling abandoned or feeling as if God is absent, all
- 2:46real emotions that Jesus has during his lifetime according to
- 2:49Scripture. So all of those emotions now
- 2:52somehow are a part of the reality of God.
- 2:56God has taken all of those emotions into God's self by
- 3:00living through them as Jesus, the Incarnate Word, made flesh.
- 3:07It's kind of hard to wrap your mind around, but you start to
- 3:09hopefully see the significance of these claims and just what
- 3:14they mean for us as we muddle through this difficult, ordinary
- 3:17human life. I really think that all of this
- 3:20is so much of why I'm still able to call myself a Christian.
- 3:24It's just because it is so personal, it's so real.
- 3:27It's so connected with the really hard moments of life.
- 3:32Often it is those really hard moments that lead people to
- 3:35abandon the faith. And I understand that when when
- 3:39things are really hard, it feels as if God has nothing to do with
- 3:43the terrible moment you find yourself in.
- 3:46Only the incarnation says no, no, no, that that's exactly the
- 3:49point. God comes into those messy,
- 3:53muddy, strange situations. The the Christmas story itself
- 3:58in Luke chapter 2 is filled with these details that really seem
- 4:03to hammer home that God shows up, that Jesus is born into the
- 4:09really difficult circumstances. As you head to church on
- 4:14Christmas Eve, hopefully, and you hear that story again this
- 4:18year, Luke chapter 2, I want you to notice how it starts.
- 4:22It starts by mentioning Caesar Augustus and Quirinius, the
- 4:26governor of Syria, these big important rulers.
- 4:31But that's not where God shows up.
- 4:34Then, after naming these incredibly prominent figures at
- 4:37that time, it shifts to talking about Joseph, who is from
- 4:41Nazareth in Galilee, which, if you don't know, was a totally
- 4:44backwater town other side of the tracks.
- 4:47Nothing special or important or good ever coming from that type
- 4:51of space. But it shifts over there.
- 4:54And then it talks about how Joseph is engaged to Mary and
- 4:57she's about to have a child. And what they obviously are
- 5:00leaving out is that the two of them aren't married.
- 5:02And at that time, that would have been a big deal to be
- 5:06having a child when you are not wed yet.
- 5:10And from there, it gets even worse.
- 5:12Then it says that they are going to their hometown, Joseph's
- 5:14hometown, to be registered. They're going back to Bethlehem
- 5:17because that's where Joseph is from, only they can't find
- 5:20anywhere to stay. And this is really significant
- 5:24because if that was his hometown, that means Joseph
- 5:27should have had family there. And it underscores the fact of
- 5:30how upsetting it would have been to people at that time that
- 5:35Joseph and Mary were about to have a child, but they weren't
- 5:38married yet. And so maybe likely no one from
- 5:43Joseph's family was willing to take them in.
- 5:46Even though he was traveling back to his hometown where he
- 5:48should have had dozens of places to stay and open and available
- 5:52to him, no one wanted anything to do with them because of the
- 5:56shameful circumstances that society said Mary and Joseph
- 6:01were in. And so as you know, Mary and
- 6:06Joseph end up in a stable Outback.
- 6:09It's the only place they could find in Joseph's hometown, the
- 6:12only place that would take them in.
- 6:14And that's where Jesus is born amongst the animals in a feeding
- 6:19through. What a strange way for God to
- 6:24enter the world, and yet how significant, how symbolic that
- 6:29this is, how God shows up into the messy circumstances, into a
- 6:37space that goes completely against the current ideas of
- 6:43those days about what is permissible and what is good and
- 6:46what is worthy to be welcomed into your home.
- 6:49It's really fascinating to see where God chooses to enter in.
- 6:55And so this is what we call the incarnation.
- 6:58And this is a reminder that God continues to enter into all of
- 7:02those messy places that we find ourselves in, that God knows
- 7:06what we're going through from an emotional standpoint.
- 7:11God has lived and experienced the, the breath of human of the
- 7:16human condition. But shifting here we talk about
- 7:21the incarnation and I wanted to set it up to really help us
- 7:24understand the significance of this theological idea.
- 7:28And, and really it's the grounding of the Christmas
- 7:30celebration. It's what we're about.
- 7:32What an incredible promise that God has given to us that God
- 7:36will show up in the mess. And of course, the rest of
- 7:39Jesus's life will contain countless examples of the same
- 7:44theme of Jesus in his ministry showing up in the messy
- 7:49situations, being with the lepers and the hungry ones and
- 7:54the prostitutes and the tax collectors and all those people
- 7:57who society says should have nothing to do with religious
- 8:01life. Jesus says like, no, no, no.
- 8:03This is where religious life begins.
- 8:05This is where religious life needs to be focused and entering
- 8:08in. We need to care for one another.
- 8:11That's constantly what Jesus is trying to show us.
- 8:14And even his crucifixion and resurrection also point to that
- 8:18reality that Jesus is willing to take on the very worst that
- 8:23humanity has to offer, so that we might know that even death is
- 8:30a place that God has encountered.
- 8:33Even death is a place that God is willing to go for our sake
- 8:36and that when we face our own deaths or when we face the loss
- 8:40of a loved one, we know that that is a space that is not God
- 8:45forsaken. It is already been brought back
- 8:47into the reality of God. That's what the death and
- 8:50resurrection is telling us. But what I think about now,
- 8:54though, all of the significance of the incarnation and the
- 8:57movement that Jesus was starting, it doesn't end with
- 9:02his ascension back to heaven after he's resurrected.
- 9:06It's not as if the incarnation is just something we remember
- 9:10that happened that one time on Christmas Day in Bethlehem.
- 9:15And now we just are crossing our fingers that maybe someday Jesus
- 9:19will return. No, no, no.
- 9:21The whole idea of Jesus's ministry, the end of the early
- 9:26Christian Church that followed and and was a reaction to
- 9:29Jesus's ministry is that this incarnation continues.
- 9:35You see, in the early Christian Church, they called themselves
- 9:40the body of Christ. You've heard that term before.
- 9:44You've heard the church being spoken about as the body of
- 9:47Christ. It's this nice throwaway phrase
- 9:49that church people like to say, but it's so much more
- 9:52significant than that. Christ was a physical body.
- 9:57God became Incarnate, but the work of Christ continues through
- 10:06the gathered community of Christians.
- 10:09The body of Christ is still present in the world.
- 10:12The incarnation is still happening through the efforts of
- 10:19you and I, through the thing, the ways that we care and show
- 10:23up and continue the ministry of Jesus in our own little corner
- 10:26of the world. There's a Catholic theologian,
- 10:29Karl Ronner, and he says that God self communicates through
- 10:34ordinary human life. God self communicates through
- 10:40ordinary human life. It's this idea that the
- 10:45incarnation is continuing that that it's continuing through the
- 10:50ministry of the church. I experienced this a lot as a
- 10:56pastor because I understand that by the nature of my position,
- 11:01when I step into a room or a situation, sometimes it has
- 11:06added significance for people. Oh my gosh, the pastor came to
- 11:10visit. And I think it's that reaction
- 11:13that some folks have when I, when I visit them in their home
- 11:16or in their hospital room, that, that that really helps us
- 11:19understand how the incarnation continues.
- 11:22I'm not saying this to say that I'm extra special.
- 11:24I'll get to that in a second. I mean, we could do a whole
- 11:27podcast about all of my failings, but what I'm really
- 11:31talking about is that people feel because it's the pastor,
- 11:36that somehow God is more present now and they feel a greater
- 11:41sense of peace because the pastor, the the representative
- 11:44of the church came to visit. But here's the thing, the
- 11:48Lutheran Church believes in something called the priesthood
- 11:51of all believers. And we really try to emphasize
- 11:55that. And I in in the way I lead, try
- 11:57to just show up as a normal person with a lot of failings
- 12:00and flaws and weird interests. But I just try and be myself
- 12:05because there's nothing special about me other than the fact
- 12:10that this is what I've chosen as my vocation.
- 12:14But everyone can show up as the presence of Christ.
- 12:17Yeah, maybe people will feel a little differently because
- 12:20pastor has this type of grandiose feeling to it.
- 12:25To some people, to others, it's the exact opposite.
- 12:29And that's a good thing. But but more to the point, like
- 12:32when we show up and we pray with other people, when we show up to
- 12:38care for other people, and this is all that I really do when I
- 12:41stop by a hospital room, that, that, that matters.
- 12:45That's the incarnation continuing.
- 12:48And the way that sometimes someone feels about the pastor
- 12:51coming for a visit. Yeah, it can be the same when
- 12:55you show up to pray to, to bring the presence of God, to bring a
- 13:01reminder of the presence of God. That's a better way to say it, a
- 13:05reminder of the presence of God in to this difficult moment.
- 13:12God self communicates through ordinary human life, ordinary
- 13:19human interaction. Through all of this, the
- 13:22incarnation continues. But what about, you might say,
- 13:27those times when God feels absent?
- 13:29What about those moments when it just seems like God is so far
- 13:34off? Peter Rollins, I've talked about
- 13:36him before. I really like his stuff.
- 13:38He's an Irish philosopher and he talks about the absence of God
- 13:45then being this space that this void where community steps in,
- 13:52in the very similar Carl Reunner way, the community of faith, the
- 13:58community that shows up to suffer alongside one another.
- 14:03In some way. This becomes the presence of
- 14:07God. The body of Christ is still
- 14:10there even if God feels absent. And in fact, the way that
- 14:14Rollins talks about it is that the absence and the shared
- 14:19experience of absence or the shared experience of grief and
- 14:23loss, when we as a community of faith bring that together and
- 14:27admit to vulnerably, yes, this is hard for me, yes, I'm
- 14:31suffering, yes, I'm grieving. When more than one person does
- 14:35that, when we share that experience together, that is the
- 14:40body of Christ that is somehow in some way God's presence.
- 14:47The way he talks about it is as it's as the negation of a
- 14:50negation. You remember math like double
- 14:52negatives, 2 negatives make a positive.
- 14:55If you multiply 2 negative numbers, it becomes a positive
- 14:58number. It's that idea, except that when
- 15:02I admit the ways that I felt God at God's absence, and then you
- 15:06and compassion also admit the way you've felt God's absence,
- 15:10somehow in this negation of the negation, God is mysteriously
- 15:16present again through the shared connection and the shared
- 15:20community. Yeah, I know, cool stuff.
- 15:25This just blows my mind. It's so powerful and helpful and
- 15:29reassuring, and it's been how the church has been talking
- 15:32about this for thousands of years.
- 15:34The body of Christ, the shared experience together as people of
- 15:39faith somehow significantly continues God's presence in this
- 15:45world, in and among us. And I felt this in my own
- 15:51personal life. I remember I went to camp 1
- 15:53summer as a junior in high school, and I had the best
- 15:57experience ever. It was still to this day, one of
- 15:59the very best weeks of my entire life.
- 16:02It was so meaningful. It was so faith forming, so
- 16:05powerful in so many different ways.
- 16:07And so the next summer I went back to camp and I unfairly
- 16:11assumed that it would be just as dramatic and great the next time
- 16:16around. And it wasn't.
- 16:19It was, it was fine, it wasn't bad, but it was just pretty
- 16:22mediocre in a lot of ways. And I definitely didn't feel
- 16:26God's presence anywhere near as strongly as I had the summer
- 16:29before. And so on the last night of
- 16:33camp, there was this worship service.
- 16:35And for so many people, it was clearly incredibly powerful.
- 16:38It, it, it, it has some real movement to it.
- 16:41And it ended with everyone kind of sitting out on the lake, this
- 16:46campus on the lake, looking out at the lake.
- 16:48And there's this beautiful sunset.
- 16:50And you know, I'm looking around, there's, there's people
- 16:52crying. And it's clear that this has
- 16:54been so powerful and important to so many folks that are there
- 16:58except me. And I'm just kind of mad and I'm
- 17:01not feeling great. And like, what the like, why
- 17:03would God, where are you? God, why are you not showing up
- 17:07in the way that you had before? And then this kid from my cabin
- 17:14who had gotten to know, I wouldn't say we were close
- 17:16friends, but he just walked over, man.
- 17:20He sat down next to me and he put his arm around me.
- 17:24And just to kind of comfort me, he could tell somehow that I was
- 17:30going through something serious and significant.
- 17:33And so he just reached out with compassion in that moment and he
- 17:37didn't say anything. He just sat with me there in my
- 17:41frustration. But notice this is exactly what
- 17:45I'm talking about. I was experienced this, this
- 17:48absence, this lack of God. And then God found a way to show
- 17:52up through my cabin mate right there in that moment.
- 17:58What a strange way for God to work.
- 18:03And yet this is how God has been working.
- 18:07This is how the Incarnation is continuing through you and
- 18:12through me and through the loving, compassionate, humble
- 18:15actions that we take. Now, before I close this all
- 18:19out, I need to make sure that we understand that it.
- 18:25I'm not trying to say it's all up to us now.
- 18:28It always starts with what God does for us.
- 18:31It can never be about what we have to do, and I try and make
- 18:35that so clear in all of my preaching and in all of my
- 18:38teaching and in all of my podcasts.
- 18:40It is never about what we do in order to be good enough for God.
- 18:43It's never about our efforts to then make God's God present by
- 18:48our own will and force and sheer grit.
- 18:52If that was the case, the only thing that would happen is
- 18:55despair because eventually we wouldn't be able to hold it all
- 18:58together anymore. Eventually there would come
- 19:00something where we couldn't by our own efforts, make God
- 19:04present. And so that is never the way
- 19:08that things work. Instead, it's always about what
- 19:10God does for us first. And, and so the way we show up
- 19:15for other people, the way we would continue the incarnation
- 19:19and, and we live as the body of Christ today is by first and
- 19:23foremost, always grounding ourselves in this Christmas
- 19:28story, in the promises of our faith, in the reality of what
- 19:33God through Jesus has already done for us.
- 19:38That's what came first. That's why we revisit the story
- 19:42again and again, is so we can put down deeper roots into that
- 19:47story, into that promise. And then we're transformed by
- 19:52the reality of what God has done.
- 19:56God left eternity, Infinity. God limited God's self by
- 20:02becoming a human being for our sake.
- 20:07What an incredible sacrifice. It's impossible to even wrap our
- 20:12minds around because we exist in this temporal space.
- 20:17But that's what God does. And then we think about the
- 20:21crucifixion, the resurrection. All of Jesus ministry, the ways
- 20:26he was constantly showing us how to show up for others, and we
- 20:31know that Jesus will find ways to break into our life.
- 20:34The body of Christ will reach out in care, in support, in
- 20:39compassion. And so in response to all of
- 20:45that grace that we experience, we then reach out to others as
- 20:51the body of Christ. This is how the incarnation
- 20:55continues. This is how you make Christmas
- 20:58last all year. I hope that was valuable and
- 21:04interesting. I think it's really neat to peel
- 21:07back the layers and, and put this all together.
- 21:09We pray Thy Kingdom come, thy will be done.
- 21:12And it is happening. God's Kingdom is continuing to
- 21:15break in and, and, and it started with Jesus and it
- 21:18continues through you and I as we continue that Jesus movement.
- 21:24It's not about our efforts or our will, but it's about
- 21:27responding to the grace that was shown to us with similar acts of
- 21:32grace towards those who are in need around us.
- 21:35I'm reminded of the famous The Light Shines in the Darkness
- 21:38quote, and I think that that's really the culmination of it.
- 21:42All of every little action we take is like a small candle in a
- 21:48vastly dark space. And so at first it doesn't seem
- 21:52like it could possibly be enough.
- 21:54But those little candles make such a big difference amidst the
- 21:59darkness of this world. So keep showing up for each
- 22:03other. Keep lighting that candle and
- 22:07becoming the body of Christ for those in need around you.
- 22:11And also live knowing that the body of Christ is constantly
- 22:15reaching out to you through the ordinary actions of your friends
- 22:19and your family. Start to see those as God
- 22:23moments, as God tapping you on the shoulder.
- 22:27These moments of grace that we experience, these moments of
- 22:30compassion, they're not just absent from the reality of God.
- 22:34No, no, no, they are very much God showing up in your life
- 22:37again and again and again. I hope this was interesting,
- 22:42helpful, a new way to think about Christmas.
- 22:45Please share it with family and friends.
- 22:47The other piece too, is, if you think about it, if you're able
- 22:50to leave a review of the podcast and a rating that helps other
- 22:54people find it. We really want to try and spread
- 22:56this message, the things that we're sharing and have going on
- 22:59here at Bethany with a lot of other people.
- 23:01So anyway you can help support getting the word out there from
- 23:03this podcast. We'd really appreciate it.
- 23:06Thanks for listening and as always, stay in peace.
- 23:09Thank you for listening to the Together for Good podcast.
- 23:12If you'd like more resources for your walk of faith, please visit
- 23:15our website, Bethany Denver org, or download our mobile app by
- 23:21searching Bethany Connect in your phone's App Store.