Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Lululemon‘s Q2 Earnings Exposed: Margin Tricks and Stock Crash
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine a beloved premium brand, right?
- 0:03Like for years it was the absolute darling of Wall Street.
- 0:06Oh yeah, a company that seemingly could just do no
- 0:09wrong. Exactly.
- 0:10You look at the stock chart and it's soaring over $510 a share.
- 0:15And then gravity hits hard, very hard.
- 0:18You watch that same stock just plummet, slicing all the way
- 0:23down to, you know, the 100 to $120.00 range.
- 0:26And when you see a collapse like that, you really have to ask
- 0:29yourself, is this a falling knife that's just going to keep
- 0:31cutting anyone who tries to catch it?
- 0:33Right. Or is it the deep value
- 0:35opportunity of a lifetime? Exactly so.
- 0:37Today's deep dive focuses on Lululemon Athletica, ticker
- 0:40symbol Lulu. It's just a textbook
- 0:43psychological stress test for investors right now.
- 0:46I mean, looking at that kind of place action, your immediate
- 0:48instinct is either, you know, sheer panic or irrational greed.
- 0:52Oh, totally. But to figure out what's
- 0:53actually happening underneath the stock ticker, you have to
- 0:56separate the markets emotional reaction from the fundamental
- 0:59business reality. Which is our exact mission
- 1:02today. We are looking under the hood of
- 1:04Lululemoners financial statements, kind of peeling back
- 1:07the accounting maneuvers and figuring out if the underlying
- 1:11business is permanently broken or just heavily discounted.
- 1:15And we have a lot of data to back this up.
- 1:17We do. We're pulling from a massive
- 1:19stack of sources today, including a 39 metric
- 1:22comprehensive financial research report and AQ 2 fiscal 2026 deep
- 1:27value valuation analysis. We are going to tear into these
- 1:31numbers. It's going.
- 1:31To get interesting. Really interesting, but before
- 1:34we get into the weeds, if you're following along and want to
- 1:37build your own investment thesis, I want to share some
- 1:39essential tools to access more advanced researches, follow
- 1:43Guru's latest movement and leverage our latest Deep Values
- 1:46agents. Welcome to download Deep Values
- 1:48APP from App Store. Definitely worth checking out.
- 1:50Yeah, and to track stock market temperature.
- 1:52Welcome to download iOS app Buffett indicator from Apple App
- 1:56Store or Bubble Watch from Google Play.
- 1:59Links are in the description. Perfect.
- 2:01And you know, before we start really dissecting these
- 2:04financials, we do need to establish, establish the ground
- 2:06rules for how we're looking at this data.
- 2:08So disclaimer, all analysis is based on publicly available
- 2:11sources and may be subject to revisions or differing
- 2:14interpretations. All contents from this channel
- 2:17is for research and entertainment purposes only and
- 2:20does not constitute any investment or financial advice
- 2:22or service. Conduct your own due diligence
- 2:25before making investment financial decisions.
- 2:27Awesome. So let's start with their most
- 2:29recent report card, right? We're looking at the Q2 fiscal
- 2:342026 earnings, right? Covering the 13 weeks ended
- 2:37August to 2026, Yeah. And the most striking thing
- 2:41about these numbers is just the sheer geographic divergent.
- 2:44Like it feels like we're evaluating 2 completely
- 2:47different businesses operating under the same logo.
- 2:49It really does. I mean, the regional split is
- 2:51incredibly stark right now. First, you have the Americas.
- 2:54Which is their bread and butter. Exactly.
- 2:56This is their mature core market.
- 2:58Historically, it makes up about 71% of their total revenue, but
- 3:02in this quarter, the Americas segment saw an 8% revenue
- 3:07contraction. Wow.
- 3:10Yeah, but the metric that truly measures the pulse of a retail
- 3:13brand is comparable store sales. Right, same store sales.
- 3:16It measures revenue from stores that have been open for at least
- 3:19a year, and in the Americas that effect dropped by 12%.
- 3:24A 12% drop in same store sales for a brand that literally used
- 3:28to have people lining up around the block.
- 3:30It's a severe warning sign. It's crazy, but then I looked at
- 3:33their international segment, specifically mainland China, and
- 3:36it's like a completely inverted reality over there.
- 3:39Oh, it's booming. Yeah.
- 3:40Revenue in Mainland China is up 16% year to date, and
- 3:44historically it's been growing at roughly 29%.
- 3:48And they are actively feeding that demand too.
- 3:50They open 41 new international stores over the trailing 12
- 3:54months. So you essentially have a
- 3:56saturated shrinking footprint in North America paired with this
- 3:59massive hyper growth engine in China.
- 4:01Exactly. And the challenge for anyone
- 4:04analyzing this business is that the North American struggles
- 4:07are, you know, starting to bleed into the overall profitability,
- 4:11even though the headline numbers kind of attempt to hide it.
- 4:14They definitely try to hide it. I noticed that when digging into
- 4:17their gross profit margin for Q2, at first glance it came in
- 4:22at 60.5%. Which sounds fantastic.
- 4:25Right. I mean, in the retail sector,
- 4:27anything over a 60% gross margin usually means you were just
- 4:30printing money. But reading through the
- 4:33research, I realized that number is a complete illusion It.
- 4:36Really is. It's like, it's like an
- 4:38Instagram filter on a financial statement.
- 4:40Or you know, a restaurant claiming they have their most
- 4:43profitable month ever selling burgers, but if you look at the
- 4:46books you realize they just found a bag of cash in the alley
- 4:49behind the kitchen. That is a brilliant way to put
- 4:52it. Right, it's a one time windfall,
- 4:54not an improvement in how they actually sell burgers.
- 4:56And for Lululemon, that bag of cash was a 134.5 million dollar
- 5:02customs tariff refund. Wait, 134 million?
- 5:06Just hand it back to them. Under the International
- 5:09Emergency Economic Powers Act, or IEPA.
- 5:13That analogy of yours captures the accounting mechanism
- 5:15perfectly, by the way. So how does that even work on
- 5:18the balance sheet? Well, to understand it you have
- 5:21to look at how tariffs are initially recorded.
- 5:24So when Lululemon imports garments, the government tariffs
- 5:28they pay are booked as a cost of acquiring inventory.
- 5:32Right. OK, that makes sense.
- 5:33So when the government issues this massive refund check for
- 5:35those plast tariffs, Lululemon credits that money directly
- 5:38against their current cost of goods sold.
- 5:41So it makes their costs look way lower for this specific quarter.
- 5:45Exactly that single non recurring accounting event
- 5:49artificially inflated their reported gross margin by 560
- 5:53basis points. Geez.
- 5:55Meaning they artificially bumped their margin up by over 5 1/2
- 5:58percentage points. Exactly.
- 5:59And that one time trick added roughly $0.86 to their diluted
- 6:03earnings per share. Wow.
- 6:05So if we take away that windfall, what does the real
- 6:08margin look like? The real underlying gross margin
- 6:11actually fell by 360 basis points, dropping all the way
- 6:15down to 54.9%. That is a huge drop.
- 6:18It's a significant deterioration, yeah.
- 6:21And the core margin is dropping so fast because of operating
- 6:25leverage working in reverse. What do you mean by reverse?
- 6:27Well. When your sales drop 12% in the
- 6:30Americas, your fixed costs don't just magically shrink.
- 6:34You still have to pay the rent on your massive distribution
- 6:36centers. You still have those high end
- 6:39retail store leases? Right.
- 6:40The rent doesn't go down just because you sold fewer leggings.
- 6:43Exactly. So those fixed overhead costs
- 6:46consume a much larger percentage of your shrinking revenue.
- 6:49On top of that, the research points to elevated inbound
- 6:53supply chain expenses because of some recent changes in shipping
- 6:56exemptions. Which just compresses the margin
- 6:58even further precisely. But from what I read, the
- 7:01biggest drag on that margin is that they are basically being
- 7:04forced into higher promotional discounting in the US just to
- 7:08clear out inventory. Yeah, the discount racks are
- 7:10getting full. And this doesn't happen in a
- 7:12vacuum, right? Like a premium brand like
- 7:15Lululemon doesn't suddenly have to put its gear on sale unless
- 7:19there is a massive failure in product execution.
- 7:22And the product missteps over fiscal 2024 and 2025 have been
- 7:26severe. I mean, Lululemon built its
- 7:28reputation on these highly coveted core franchises like the
- 7:32Aligned leggings and the Wonder Train gear.
- 7:34Yeah, people love those. They do, but customers expect
- 7:37fresh seasonal color updates to keep them coming back to buy
- 7:40more. But recently, the company just
- 7:43failed to introduce those seasonal updates.
- 7:45They simply rolled out the same legacy colors year after year.
- 7:48And the research highlights an even more baffling error, which
- 7:52is that they completely botched their inventory allocation on
- 7:55sizing. Oh.
- 7:56This was a disaster. They literally ran out of the
- 7:58smaller sizes, specifically sizes zero to four, across their
- 8:02entire retail footprint. I was trying to figure out how a
- 8:04multibillion dollar apparel company lets that happen.
- 8:07It's a massive oversight. Often this comes down to broken
- 8:10forecasting algorithms, or sometimes it's supply chain
- 8:13bottlenecks where the factories prioritize large bulk orders
- 8:16over highly fragmented sizing. Whatever the mechanical cause
- 8:20is, the result is basically retail malpractice.
- 8:23Your core demographic walks in willing to drop $118 on leggings
- 8:28and you don't even have their size.
- 8:30It's a quick way to lose loyalty.
- 8:32When you frustrate your best customers with inventory stock
- 8:35outs, you are effectively paying for them to try your
- 8:38competitors. And the competitive landscape is
- 8:42vastly different today than it was even five years ago.
- 8:46Brands like Aloe Yoga and Vori have built incredible momentum.
- 8:50But really, have they're everywhere.
- 8:51They are actively capturing the younger demographic through
- 8:55aggressive community building and way fresher seasonal drops.
- 8:59They're basically capitalizing on every unforced error
- 9:02Lululemon makes. And these aren't just like floor
- 9:04level mistakes either. They originate directly in the
- 9:07boardroom. The corporate drama right now is
- 9:09intense. It's getting messy.
- 9:11Seriously. Former CEO Calvin McDonald, who
- 9:13previously oversaw the company's massive revenue expansion to
- 9:17over $10 billion. He stepped down in January of
- 9:202026 and then the company's founder Chip Wilson, who still
- 9:25owns over 8% of the outstanding shares, has been ruthlessly
- 9:29public in his criticism of the management team.
- 9:32The philosophical division there is really at the heart of this
- 9:34whole transition. Wilson has repeatedly criticized
- 9:37the board for chasing what he calls commoditized lifestyle
- 9:41apparel. Meaning they're making generic
- 9:43stuff instead of specialized gear.
- 9:45Exactly. His argument is that the company
- 9:47abandoned its focus on hyper technical, innovative athletic
- 9:51wear just to chase mass market trends.
- 9:53He thinks they're diluting the brand's unique value
- 9:55proposition. And he actually forced
- 9:57structural changes because of it.
- 9:59His disagreements led to a formal cooperation agreement
- 10:01that expanded the board of directors.
- 10:03So right now the company is in this weird holding pattern run
- 10:07by interim Co CEO's Megan Frank and Andre Mastrini while they
- 10:10wait for incoming CEO Heidi O'Neill to officially take the
- 10:13reins on September 8th. And this instability has
- 10:16absolutely infuriated the ownership base.
- 10:19At the June shareholder meeting, 27 million votes were cast
- 10:23against executive say on pay. 27,000,000 That is a staggering
- 10:28metric. It really is.
- 10:30For context, a say on pay vote is just a mechanism where
- 10:33shareholders vote to approve or reject the compensation packages
- 10:37given to top executives. Usually these votes are a polite
- 10:40rubber stamp. Everyone just folks.
- 10:42Yes, and moves on. Right.
- 10:44So seeing 27 million votes cast against it.
- 10:47It means the institutional shareholders are furious.
- 10:49They are sick of paying premium salaries for declining
- 10:52performance. Yeah, and the shareholders also
- 10:54threw their weight behind a proposal to declassify the
- 10:57board. Which is another huge shift.
- 10:59Yeah, they are moving away from staggered multi year terms where
- 11:03directors are basically protected from being voted out
- 11:06all at once to holding annual elections for all directions.
- 11:09The shareholders want the ability to hold leadership
- 11:12accountable every single year. They want shorter leashes.
- 11:14Exactly. So looking at all this right,
- 11:18the missing sizes, the plunging margins, the boardroom brawls, I
- 11:23keep coming back to a physical analogy.
- 11:25What's that? Is Lululemon suffering from a
- 11:27temporary pulled hamstring, meaning you know they missed
- 11:31some color trends the old CEO left, but they just need some
- 11:35ice and physical therapy to get back on the track?
- 11:37Or is this a permanent structural loss of athletic
- 11:40dominance? That's the $1,000,000.
- 11:42Question, right? Is incoming CEO Heidi O'Neill
- 11:45walking into a fixable inventory glitch or a fundamentally eroded
- 11:50brand Moat? Well, the data strongly suggests
- 11:52this is a high quality franchise undergoing a severe operational
- 11:55stress test, not a fundamentally broken business.
- 11:58OK, so more of a pulled hamstring.
- 12:00Definitely. I mean, they still maintain a
- 12:02highly active global customer base of over 34 million people.
- 12:06They still hold proprietary trade secrets regarding their
- 12:08fabric finishes and garment construction, which competitors
- 12:12really struggle to perfectly replicate.
- 12:14Yeah, their fabrics are famously hard to copy.
- 12:16Exactly. And crucially, they still
- 12:18control their own distribution. 91% of their volume goes
- 12:23directly through their own retail stores and digital
- 12:25storefronts. Which means they don't have to
- 12:27share profits with department stores, right?
- 12:30It means they bypass wholesale markdowns and retain a direct
- 12:33relationship with their customer.
- 12:35So the pulled hamstring analogy fits perfectly.
- 12:38The underlying muscle of the business is still incredibly
- 12:41strong, but the coordination at the leadership level just
- 12:45failed. OK, so if the brand has merely
- 12:47stumbled, the ultimate question for a deep value investor is
- 12:51whether the market has overreacted and priced in the
- 12:54apocalypse. And the market tends to do that.
- 12:56It does, so I want to look at the deep value assessment
- 12:59starting with the balance sheet because it is remarkably clean.
- 13:02Lululemon carries essentially 0 funded debt.
- 13:05Which is huge in this interest rate environment.
- 13:08Totally. They aren't borrowing from banks
- 13:10at high interest rates just to keep the lights on.
- 13:13They are sitting on nearly $1.4 billion in cash and cash
- 13:17equivalents, and historically they boast a 34% average return
- 13:22on equity over the last decade. That is an unbelievable number.
- 13:26Just to break that down for you, a 34% Roe means that for every
- 13:31dollar of shareholder equity invested in the business, they
- 13:35were generating 34 cents of pure profit year after year.
- 13:39That level of capital efficiency is exceedingly rare in retail.
- 13:43But because the broader market is hyper focused on that 12%
- 13:47drop in America's sales, the stock price has just collapsed,
- 13:51right? And at the 100 to $120.00 range,
- 13:54their trailing price to earnings or PE ratio has compressed all
- 13:59the way down to between 8.2 and 9.8 times earnings.
- 14:03And just to illustrate how extreme that compression is,
- 14:06Lululemon's 10 year historical average PE is 41.2.
- 14:11Yeah, investors used to happily pay $41.00 for every $1.00 of
- 14:14earnings because they believed in the infinite growth story.
- 14:17Now you can buy that same dollar of earnings for under $10.
- 14:21Which brings us to the mechanics of the discounted cash flow or
- 14:24DC DF models presented in the research.
- 14:26Yes, let's talk about the DCF. So ADCF model is basically a
- 14:29foundational valuation tool. It estimates the current
- 14:33intrinsic value of an investment based on all the future cash
- 14:36flows the business is expected to produce discounted back to
- 14:40today's dollars. Usually when analysts build ADCF
- 14:43for a growth stock like Lululemon, they plug in these
- 14:46really aggressive assumptions like 15 or 20% annual growth for
- 14:51the next decade. But this research ran a no
- 14:54growth model, which is fascinating.
- 14:56It really is. This scenario assumes
- 14:58Lululemon's free cash flow remains completely flat. 0
- 15:02Perpetual growth. It assumes the company never
- 15:05grows at the profits again for the rest of eternity.
- 15:07A. True worst case scenario.
- 15:09Yeah. And even in this flatlining,
- 15:11totally pessimistic scenario, the model calculates the
- 15:14intrinsic value of the company at roughly $133.71 to $145.43
- 15:21per share. And the implication there is
- 15:23profound. I mean at roughly $120.00 a
- 15:26share, you are buying the business at a steep discount to
- 15:29its absolute zero growth intrinsic value.
- 15:32Right, you are paying a price that is assumes permanent
- 15:34stagnation. Exactly.
- 15:36If the incoming CEO Heidi O'Neill can simply stop the
- 15:39bleeding in the Americas and just continue to ride those
- 15:42massive demographic tailwinds in China, the upside asymmetry
- 15:46becomes highly attractive. You don't need the company to
- 15:49conquer the world anymore. You literally just need them to
- 15:51stabilize. You just need them to finish the
- 15:53race without tripping again. And you know, the people who
- 15:56manage billions of dollars for a living are definitely noticing
- 15:59this math. Oh, they are.
- 16:00Swarming. The research highlights several
- 16:02super investors stepping in to buy the dip.
- 16:04Michael Bury, Scion Asset Management You know the guy
- 16:07famous for the Big Short? He recently bought 100,000
- 16:10shares of Lululemon. That is a massive position for.
- 16:13Him it is. That single purchase makes up
- 16:1632% of his 13 F equity portfolio.
- 16:20Now the technical caveat here is that 13 F filings only show what
- 16:23a fund holds at the very end of 1/4.
- 16:25So we don't know his exact execution price or if he has
- 16:28traded around the position since.
- 16:30But allocating 1/3 of a public portfolio to 1 stock?
- 16:35That is a massive signal of conviction.
- 16:38And he is in good company. Classic value investing
- 16:41stalwarts like Francois Rochon of Giverty Capital and the firm
- 16:45Tweety Brown Company are either holding or initiating new
- 16:49positions. Wow, yeah, these firms don't
- 16:52chase momentum. They look at the unlevered
- 16:53balance sheet, those recurring direct to consumer cash flows
- 16:57and that sub 10 PE ratio and they see a classic
- 17:00mathematically sound value setup.
- 17:02However, there is a distinct risk that we have to acknowledge
- 17:05here. This is only a bargain if that
- 17:0712% drop in the Americas isn't a permanent structural decline.
- 17:11Right, because as if it is. That is the literal definition
- 17:14of a value trap. If consumers have permanently
- 17:17moved on to Vori and Aloyoga, and Lululemon is forced to
- 17:20permanently lower its pricing tiers to compete, then the
- 17:24historical cash flows will permanently shrink.
- 17:26Meaning the profit margins will reset to a lower baseline.
- 17:29Exactly. And if that happens, the stock
- 17:31isn't cheap. You are just buying an asset
- 17:34that is decaying faster than the stock price is falling.
- 17:37Ouch. And management's historical
- 17:39capital allocation doesn't inspire total confidence either.
- 17:42The research points out their share buyback history, which is
- 17:45pretty rough. Between fiscal 2021 and 2024,
- 17:49management spent $3.76 billion repurchasing shares at average
- 17:55prices above $330 a share. Yikes.
- 17:58Yeah, they were basically incinerating capital by buying
- 18:01their own stock at the absolute top of the market.
- 18:04It was a highly inefficient use of shareholder capital, to put
- 18:07it mildly. However, to their credit, they
- 18:09have shown vastly improved discipline recently.
- 18:12Oh, really? Yeah, In the first half of
- 18:15fiscal 2026, they deployed $695,000,000 to buy back nearly
- 18:205 million shares at an average price of $141.00.
- 18:24Well, that's. Way better.
- 18:25And in Q2 specifically, they were buying at $122.
- 18:29Retiring shares at APE of 10 is vastly more accretive to long
- 18:33term shareholders than buying at APE of 40.
- 18:35And by accretive, we basically mean it actually increases the
- 18:39underlying value of the remaining shares because they
- 18:42are buying up earnings power very cheaply rather than
- 18:45destroying capital by overpaying.
- 18:47Spot on. So kind of synthesizing all of
- 18:50this for you, the listener, analyzing a complex business
- 18:53really requires looking past the shiny headlines.
- 18:56When you see a 60% gross margin, you have to read the footnotes
- 19:00to find the hidden government tariff refund that's actually
- 19:03propping it up. And when you see a stock price
- 19:05collapse, you have to look past the panic to see the boardroom
- 19:08drama and the missing sizes on the retail floor causing the
- 19:11pain. Lululemon is currently a high
- 19:13quality franchise undergoing a severe stress test.
- 19:17It has an incredible balance sheet, it prints cash, and it is
- 19:20finally trading at a deep value price.
- 19:22But the new management absolutely has to stop the
- 19:24bleeding in North America. It's a fascinating transition to
- 19:27watch. I mean we are essentially
- 19:28watching a momentum growth story attempt to pivot into a turn
- 19:32around value play. Yeah, it's a huge shift in
- 19:35identity. It is the underlying assets, the
- 19:38brand equity, the supply chain infrastructure, the cash hoard,
- 19:42they are stellar. But the operational execution
- 19:45has undeniably faltered, which brings up a broader question
- 19:49about the nature of premium retail.
- 19:51And it's something I want to leave you to Mull over on your
- 19:53own. OK, let's hear it.
- 19:54This entire situation perfectly illustrates the classic
- 19:57innovator's dilemma. Lululemon built its empire on
- 20:01premium, hyper technical performance wear.
- 20:04They engineered the absolute best yoga pants in the world.
- 20:08And they charged a massive premium for that exclusivity.
- 20:10Because it was worth it to the core customer.
- 20:12Right. But as they expanded to appease
- 20:14Wall Street's relentless demand for infinite double digit growth
- 20:18year after year, they pushed far outside of their niche.
- 20:21They moved into casual lifestyle wear button down shirts and
- 20:24men's running shoes. Trying to be a lifestyle brand,
- 20:27not just a yoga brand. Exactly.
- 20:29So you have to ask, did they dilute the very exclusivity that
- 20:33allowed them to charge $118 for a pair of leggings in the first
- 20:37place? Growth eventually becomes the
- 20:39enemy of exclusivity. When a luxury niche brand tries
- 20:42to become everything to everyone, does it inevitably
- 20:45become nothing to anyone? That is the structural question
- 20:47the new CEO has to answer.